Shear-response of the spectrin dimer-tetramer equilibrium in the red blood cell membrane

The red cell membrane derives its elasticity and resistance to mechanical stresses from the membrane skeleton, a network composed of spectrin tetramers. These are formed by the head-to-head association of pairs of heterodimers attached at their ends to junctional complexes of several proteins. Here we examine the dynamics of the spectrin dimer-dimer association in the intact membrane. We show that univalent fragments of spectrin, containing the dimer self-association site, will bind to spectrin on the membrane and thereby disrupt the continuity of the protein network. This results in impairment of the mechanical stability of the membrane. When, moreover, the cells are subjected to a continuous low level of shear, even at room temperature, the incorporation of the fragments and the consequent destabilization of the membrane are greatly accentuated. It follows that a modest shearing force, well below that experienced by the red cell in the circulation, is sufficient to sever dimer-dimer links in the network. Our results imply 1) that the membrane accommodates the enormous distortions imposed on it during the passage of the cell through the microvasculature by means of local dissociation of spectrin tetramers to dimers, 2) that the network in situ is in a dynamic state and undergoes a "breathing" action of tetramer dissociation and re-formation.     

Influence of the membrane undercoat on filipin perturbation of the red blood cell membrane

Filipin, a polyene antibiotic, interacts with beta-hydroxy sterols such as cholesterol in most cell membranes, forming bumps and pits that are visible by electron microscopy of freeze-fracture replicas. The markedly reduced perturbability of the red blood cell (RBC) membrane, compared to other cells, has been attributed to the constraining influence of the red cell membrane skeleton, the undercoat composed of spectrin, actin, and protein 4.1. To test the influence of the membrane skeleton on filipin-induced perturbation of the RBC membrane, we studied the interaction of filipin with red cells that were inherently devoid of spectrin and RBC in which spectrin had been crosslinked or denatured. These spectrin-deficient, crosslinked, and denatured cells have a fivefold increase in the number of filipin-induced perturbations as compared to control cells, despite equivalent membrane cholesterol content. These findings confirm that the spectrin-based membrane skeleton strongly influences the organization of the membrane so as to limit perturbation by filipin:cholesterol interaction and that for membranes in which the cholesterol content is known, filipin is a useful probe for testing the avidity of spectrin-based cytoskeletal attachment.     

Stress-free state of the red blood cell membrane and the deformation of its skeleton

The response of a red blood cell (RBC) to deformation depends on its membrane, a composite of a lipid bilayer and a skeleton, which is a closed, twodimensional network of spectrin tetramers as its bonds. The deformation of the skeleton and its lateral redistribution are studied in terms of the RBC resting state for a fixed geometry of the RBC, partially aspirated into a micropipette. The geometry of the RBC skeleton in its initial state is taken to be either two concentric circles, a references biconcave shape or a sphere. It is assumed that in its initial state the skeleton is distributed laterally in a homogeneous manner with its bonds either unstressed, presenting its stress-free state, or prestressed. The lateral distribution was calculated using a variational calculation. It was assumed that the spectrin tetramer bonds exhibit a linear elasticity. The results showed a significant effect of the initial skeleton geometry on its lateral distribution in the deformed state. The proposed model is used to analyze the measurements of skeleton extension ratios by the method of applying two modes of RBC micropipette aspiration.     

Calculation of a Gap restoration in the membrane skeleton of the red blood cell: possible role for myosin II in local repair

Human red blood cells contain all of the elements involved in the formation of nonmuscle actomyosin II complexes (V. M. Fowler. 1986. J. Cell. Biochem. 31:1-9; 1996. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 8:86-96). No clear function has yet been attributed to these complexes. Using a mathematical model for the structure of the red blood cell spectrin skeleton (M. J. Saxton. 1992. J. Theor. Biol. 155:517-536), we have explored a possible role for myosin II bipolar minifilaments in the restoration of the membrane skeleton, which may be locally damaged by major mechanical or chemical stress. We propose that the establishment of stable links between distant antiparallel actin protofilaments after a local myosin II activation may initiate the repair of the disrupted area. We show that it is possible to define conditions in which the calculated number of myosin II minifilaments bound to actin protofilaments is consistent with the estimated number of myosin II minifilaments present in the red blood cells. A clear restoration effect can be observed when more than 50% of the spectrin polymers of a defined area are disrupted. It corresponds to a significant increase in the spectrin density in the protein free region of the membrane. This may be involved in a more complex repair process of the red blood cell membrane, which includes the vesiculation of the bilayer and the compaction of the disassembled spectrin network.     

Spectrin properties and the elasticity of the red blood cell membrane skeleton

Two models of spectrin elasticity are developed and compared to experimental measurements of the red blood cell (RBC) membrane shear modulus through the use of an elastic finite element model of the RBC membrane skeleton. The two molecular models of spectrin are: (i) An entropic spring model of spectrin as a flexible chain. This is a model proposed by several previous authors. (ii) An elastic model of a helical coiled-coil which expands by increasing helical pitch. In previous papers, we have computed the relationship between the stiffness of a single spectrin molecule (K) and the shear modulus of a network (μ), and have shown that this behavior is strongly dependent upon network topology. For realistic network models of the RBC membrane skeleton, we equate μ to micropipette measurements of RBCs and predict K for spectrin that is consistent with the coiled-coil molecular model. The value of spectrin stiffness derived from the entropic molecular model would need to be at least 30 times greater to match the experimental results. Thus, the conclusion of this study is that a helical coiled-coil model for spectrin is more realistic than a purely entropic model.     

Native ultrastructure of the red cell cytoskeleton by cryo-electron tomography

Erythrocytes possess a spectrin-based cytoskeleton that provides elasticity and mechanical stability necessary to survive the shear forces within the microvasculature. The architecture of this membrane skeleton and the nature of its intermolecular contacts determine the mechanical properties of the skeleton and confer the characteristic biconcave shape of red cells. We have used cryo-electron tomography to evaluate the three-dimensional topology in intact, unexpanded membrane skeletons from mouse erythrocytes frozen in physiological buffer. The tomograms reveal a complex network of spectrin filaments converging at actin-based nodes and a gradual decrease in both the density and the thickness of the network from the center to the edge of the cell. The average contour length of spectrin filaments connecting junctional complexes is 46 ± 15 nm, indicating that the spectrin heterotetramer in the native membrane skeleton is a fraction of its fully extended length (∼190 nm). Higher-order oligomers of spectrin were prevalent, with hexamers and octamers seen between virtually every junctional complex in the network. Based on comparisons with expanded skeletons, we propose that the oligomeric state of spectrin is in a dynamic equilibrium that facilitates remodeling of the network as the cell changes shape in response to shear stress.     

The lens membrane skeleton contains structures preferentially enriched in spectrin-actin or tropomodulin-actin complexes

The spectrin-based membrane skeleton plays an important role in determining the distributions and densities of receptors, ion channels, and pumps, thus influencing cell shape and deformability, cell polarity, and adhesion. In the paradigmatic human erythrocyte, short tropomodulin-capped actin filaments are cross-linked by spectrin into a hexagonal network, yet the extent to which this type of actin filament organization is utilized in the membrane skeletons of nonerythroid cells is not known. Here, we show that associations of tropomodulin and spectrin with actin in bovine lens fiber cells are distinct from that of the erythrocyte and imply a very different molecular organization. Mechanical disruption of the lens fiber cell membrane skeleton releases tropomodulin and actin-containing oligomeric complexes that can be isolated by gel filtration column chromatography, sucrose gradient centrifugation and immunoadsorption. These tropomodulin-actin complexes do not contain spectrin. Instead, spectrin is associated with actin in different complexes that do not contain tropomodulin. Immunofluorescence staining of isolated fiber cells further demonstrates that tropomodulin does not precisely colocalize with spectrin along the lateral membranes of lens fiber cells. Taken together, our data suggest that tropomodulin-capped actin filaments and spectrin-cross-linked actin filaments are assembled in distinct structures in the lens fiber cell membrane skeleton, indicating that it is organized quite differently from that of the erythrocyte membrane skeleton.     

Membrane skeleton-bilayer interaction is not the major determinant of membrane phospholipid asymmetry in human erythrocytes

Transbilayer phospholipid distribution, membrane skeleton dissociation/association, and spectrin structure have been analysed in human erythrocytes after subjecting them to heating at 50 degrees C for 15 min. The membrane skeleton dissociation/association was determined by measuring the Tris-induced dissociation of Triton-insoluble membrane skeletons (Triton shells), the spectrin-actin extractability under low ionic conditions, and the binding of spectrin-actin with normal erythrocyte membrane inside-out vesicles (IOVs). The spectrin structure was ascertained by measuring the spectrin dimer-to-tetramer ratio as well as the spectrin tryptophan fluorescence. Both the Tris-induced Triton shell dissociation and the spectrin-actin extractability under low ionic conditions were considerably reduced by the heat treatment. Also, the binding of heated erythrocyte spectrin-actin to IOVs was significantly smaller than that observed with the normal cell spectrin-actin. Further, the quantity of spectrin dimers was appreciably increased in heat-treated erythrocytes as compared to the normal cells. This change in the spectrin dimer-to-tetramer ratio was accompanied by marked changes in the spectrin tryptophan fluorescence. In spite of these heat-induced alterations in structure and bilayer interactions of the membrane skeleton, the inside-outside glycerophospholipid distribution remained virtually unaffected in the heat-treated cells, as judged by employing bee venom and pancreatic phospholipase A2, fluorescamine and Merocyanine 540 as the external membrane probes. These results strongly indicate that membrane bilayer-skeleton interaction is not the major factor in determining the transbilayer phospholipid asymmetry in human erythrocyte membrane.     

Influence of network topology on the elasticity of the red blood cell membrane skeleton.

A finite-element network model is used to investigate the influence of the topology of the red blood cell membrane skeleton on its macroscopic mechanical properties. Network topology is characterized by the number of spectrin oligomers per actin junction (phi a) and the number of spectrin dimers per self-association junction (phi s). If it is assumed that all associated spectrin is in tetrameric form, with six tetramers per actin junction (i.e., phi a = 6.0 and phi s = 2.0), then the topology of the skeleton may be modeled by a random Delaunay triangular network. Recent images of the RBC membrane skeleton suggest that the values for these topological parameters are in the range of 4.2 < phi a < 5.5 and 2.1 < phi s < 2.3. Model networks that simulate these realistic topologies exhibit values of the shear modulus that vary by more than an order of magnitude relative to triangular networks. This indicates that networks with relatively sparse nontriangular topologies may be needed to model the RBC membrane skeleton accurately. The model is also used to simulate skeletal alterations associated with hereditary spherocytosis and Southeast Asian ovalocytosis.     

Ultracentrifugal analysis of the junction complexes of the red cell membrane cytoskeletal network: application to hereditary spherocytosis and metabolically depleted cells

A method has been developed for the assessment of the number of spectrin dimer units associated with each actin protofilament junction, in the membrane cytoskeletal network (i.e. the degree of branching) of the red cell. Ghosts are first exposed to elevated temperature at low ionic strength to dissociate some 65% of the spectrin tetramers (that link the network junctions) into dimers, without causing their release from the actin filaments. Non-ionic detergent is then added to solubilize the membrane itself with its intrinsic proteins, so as to liberate the cytoskeletal material, and the mixture is immediately examined in the analytical ultracentrifuge. The predominant components observed are isolated junctions (20 S), free spectrin dimers and the residual undissociated cytoskeletal material, with very minor components, probably corresponding to multiple junctions, linked by spectrin tetramers. The junction boundary is homogeneous within the accuracy of measurement and is taken to correspond to a complex containing six spectrin dimers, known to predominate in situ. About 17% of the total network is liberated in this form and 12% as free spectrin dimers. In hereditary spherocytosis both the size of the junction complex (as reflected by its sedimentation coefficient) and the proportion of the complex and of free spectrin liberated are indistinguishable from normal values. We conclude that the reported deficit of spectrin in hereditary spherocytosis is not reflected by a lower degree of branching of the network, and, if the membrane area is not correspondingly reduced, this must mean that the junctions are more widely spaced and the spectrin tetramers therefore more extended. In metabolically depleted cells, in which the cytoskeletal proteins are known to be extensively dephosphorylated, there is no change in the sedimentation pattern and thus no detectable loss of spectrin from the junctions or weakening in the cohesion of the cytoskeletal network.     

A model of spectrin as a concertina in the erythrocyte membrane skeleton

To maintain its distinctive biconcave shape, the erythrocyte has a skeleton composed largely of the protein spectrin, which associates closely and exclusively with the cell membrane. Although the membrane skeleton forms through specific protein-protein interactions of defined stoichiometry, it has a flexible structure and organization due to the unusual molecular properties of spectrin. Here we describe these properties and propose a model to account for the extensibility of spectrin and for its organization in the skeleton.     

Spectrin, human erythrocyte shapes, and mechanochemical properties.

Physical studies of human erythrocyte spectrin indicate that isolated spectrin dimers and tetramers in solution are worm-like coils with a persistence length of approximately 20 nm. This finding, the known polyelectrolytic nature of spectrin, and other structural information about spectrin and the membrane skeleton molecular organization have lead us to the hypothesis that the human erythrocyte membrane skeleton constitutes a two-dimensional ionic gel (swollen ionic elastomer). This concept is incorporated in what we refer to as the protein gel-lipid bilayer membrane model. The model accounts quantitatively for red elastic shear modulus and the maximum elastic extension ratio reported for the human erythrocytes membrane. Gel theory further predicts that depending on the environmental conditions, the membrane skeleton modulus of area compression may be small or large relative to the membrane elastic shear modulus. Our analyses show that the ratio between these two parameters affects both the geometry and the stability of the favored cell shapes and that the higher the membrane skeleton compressibility the smaller the values of the gel tension needed to induce cell shape transformations. The main virtue of the protein gel-lipid bilayer membrane model is that it offers a novel theoretical and molecular basis for the various mechanical properties of the membrane skeleton such as the membrane skeleton modulus of area compression and osmotic tension, and the effects of these properties on local membrane skeleton density, cell shape, and shape transformations.     

Spectrin: a structural mediator between diverse plasma membrane proteins and the cytoplasm

The spectrin skeleton of non-erythroid cells is likely to interact with a variety of integral membrane proteins and participate both in stable linkages as well as dynamic structures capable of rapid disassembly and assembly. The basis for diversity of roles for spectrin includes multiple, functionally distinct isoforms of spectrin, ankyrin and other associated proteins, regulation of protein interactions through phosphorylation and calcium/calmodulin, as well as differential expression of accessory proteins that determine the organization and localization of spectrin in cells. Spectrin is highly conserved from Drosophila to man and is likely to be involved in fundamental aspects of membrane structure requiring long range order and organization. Spectrin is a candidate to interact with many integral membrane proteins in roles basic to metazoan cells which must associate into tissues. Organization of cells into tissues requires loss of cell motility, formation of specialized membrane domains and assembly of cell junctions, which are all activities potentially involving spectrin. Future challenges lie in devising direct experiments to evaluate the functions of spectrin in cells and tissues.     

Immunodetection of spectrin-like proteins in yeasts

Spectrin, a component of the membrane skeleton in erythrocytes and other animal cells, has also been identified in plant and fungal cells. However, its postulated role, i.e., the maintenance of shape and elasticity of the plasma membrane, is probably not exerted in walled cells. To study spectrin in these cells, we chose yeasts because of a high morphological variability of their life cycle. The localization of spectrin in the cells and protoplasts of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Schizosaccharomyces japonicus var. versatilis was detected by immunoblotting, indirect immunofluorescence, and immunogold electron microscopy techniques with the use of anti-chicken and anti-human erythrocyte spectrin antibodies. A protein band of 220-240 kDa and some bands of lower relative mass were detected in cell and protoplast extracts of both yeast strains. Spectrin-like proteins were revealed by fluorescence microscopy at cell surfaces and in vacuolar membranes. Immunogold-labelling showed spectrin-like proteins in the plasma membrane, endoplasmic reticulum, vacuoles, nuclei, vesicles, mitochondria, and cell walls. The topology of spectrin was not affected by actin depolymerization with Latrunculin B nor was it changed in either act1-1 or cdc42 mutants, under restrictive conditions. Under osmotic stress, both spectrin and actin were delocalized and appeared in the form of large clusters in the cytoplasm. It is concluded that a protein cross-reacting with spectrin antibodies is present in fission and budding yeasts. Generally, it is located in the proximity of the plasma membrane and other intracellular membranes, probably as a part of the membrane skeleton. No evidence of its relationship to either actin or growth zones of the cell can be provided.     

Visualization of the hexagonal lattice in the erythrocyte membrane skeleton

The isolated membrane skeleton of human erythrocytes was studied by high resolution negative staining electron microscopy. When the skeletal meshwork is spread onto a thin carbon film, clear images of a primarily hexagonal lattice of junctional F-actin complexes crosslinked by spectrin filaments are obtained. The regularly ordered network extends over the entire membrane skeleton. Some of the junctional complexes are arranged in the form of pentagons and septagons, approximately 3 and 8%, respectively. At least five forms of spectrin crosslinks are detected in the spread skeleton including a single spectrin tetramer linking two junctional complexes, three-armed Y-shaped spectrin molecules linking three junctional complexes, three-armed spectrin molecules connecting two junctional complexes with two arms bound to one complex and the third arm bound to the adjacent complex, double spectrin filaments linking two junctional complexes, and four-armed spectrin molecules linking two junctional complexes. Of these, the crosslinks of single spectrin tetramers and three-armed molecules are the most abundant and represent 84 and 11% of the total crosslinks, respectively. These observations are compatible with the presence of spectrin tetramers and oligomers in the erythrocyte membrane skeleton. Globular structures (9-12 nm in diameter) are attached to the majority of the spectrin tetramers or higher order oligomer-like molecules, approximately 80 nm from the distal ends of the spectrin tetramers. These globular structures are ankyrinor ankyrin/band 3-containing complexes, since they are absent when ankyrin and residual band 3 are extracted from the skeleton under hypertonic conditions.     

Protein 4.1N is required for the formation of the lateral membrane domain in human bronchial epithelial cells

The membrane skeleton forms a scaffold on the cytoplasmic side of the plasma membrane. The erythrocyte membrane represents an archetype of such structural organization. It has been documented that a similar membrane skeleton also exits in the Golgi complex. It has been previously shown that βII spectrin and ankyrin G are localized at the lateral membrane of human bronchial epithelial cells. Here we show that protein 4.1N is also located at the lateral membrane where it associates E-cadherin, β-catenin and βII spectrin. Importantly, depletion of 4.1N by RNAi in human bronchial epithelial cells resulted in decreased height of lateral membrane, which was reversed following re-expression of mouse 4.1N. Furthermore, although the initial phase of lateral membrane biogenesis proceeded normally in 4.1N-depleted cells, the final height of the lateral membrane of 4.1N-depleted cells was shorter compared to that of control cells. Our findings together with previous findings imply that 4.1N, βII spectrin and ankyrin G are structural components of the lateral membrane skeleton and that this skeleton plays an essential role in the assembly of a fully functional lateral membrane.     

A beta-spectrin isoform from Drosophila (beta H) is similar in size to vertebrate dystrophin

Spectrins are a major component of the membrane skeleton in many cell types where they are thought to contribute to cell form and membrane organization. Diversity among spectrin isoforms, especially their beta subunits, is associated with diversity in cell shape and membrane architecture. Here we describe a spectrin isoform from Drosophila that consists of a conventional alpha spectrin subunit complexed with a novel high molecular weight beta subunit (430 kD) that we term beta H. The native alpha beta H molecule binds actin filaments with high affinity and has a typical spectrin morphology except that it is longer than most other spectrin isoforms and includes two knoblike structures that are attributed to a unique domain of the beta H subunit. Beta H is encoded by a different gene than the previously described Drosophila beta-spectrin subunit but shows sequence similarity to beta-spectrin as well as vertebrate dystrophin, a component of the membrane skeleton in muscle. By size and sequence similarity, dystrophin is more similar to this newly described beta-spectrin isoform (beta H) than to other members of the spectrin gene family such as alpha-spectrin and alpha- actinin.     

Influence of calmodulin on the human red cell membrane skeleton

The calcium receptor calmodulin interacts with components of the human red cell membrane skeleton as well as with the membrane. Under physiological salt conditions, calmodulin has a calcium-dependent affinity for spectrin, one of the major components of the membrane skeleton. It is apparent from our results that calmodulin inhibits the ability of erythrocyte spectrin (when preincubated with filamentous actin) to create nucleation centers and thereby to seed actin polymerization. The gelation of filamentous actin induced by spectrin tetramers is also inhibited by calmodulin. The inhibition is calcium dependent and decreases with increasing pH, similar to the binding of calmodulin to spectrin. Direct binding studies using aqueous two-phase partition indicate that calmodulin interferes with the binding of actin to spectrin. Even in the presence of protein 4.1, which is believed to stabilize the ternary complex, calmodulin has an inhibitory effect. Since calmodulin also inhibits the corresponding activities of brain spectrin (fodrin), it appears likely that calmodulin may modulate the organization of cytoskeletons containing actin and spectrin or spectrin analogues.     

Role of membrane-associated cytoskeleton in maintenance of membrane structure

Various structural components of biological membranes are asymmetrically localized in the two surfaces of the membrane bilayer. This asymmetry is absolute for membrane (glyco) proteins, but only a partial asymmetry has been observed for membrane phospholipids. In the red cell membrane, choline-phospholipids are localized mainly in the outer monolayer whereas aminophospholipids are distributed almost exclusively in the inner monolayer. Several evidences are now available to suggest that this distribution of membrane phospholipids in red cells is directly or indirectly maintained by the membrane-associated cytoskeleton (membrane skeleton). This belief is well supported by the previous as well as recent studies carried out in the authors laboratory. Previously, it has been shown that lipid-lipid interactions play no major role in maintaining the transmembrane phospholipid asymmetry in erythrocytes, and that the asymmetry is lost upon covalent crosslinking of the major membrane skeletal protein, spectrin. The recent data presented here further shows that degradation or denaturation of spectrin indices rapid transbilayer movement of membrane phospholipids in the cells which, in turn, leads to more random phospholipid distributions across the membrane. These studies taken together strongly suggest that the skeleton-membrane associations are the major determinants of the transmembrane phospholipid asymmetry in erythrocytes, and that the dissociation of the skeleton from the membrane bilayer probably results in generation of new reorientation sites for phospholipids in the membrane. Communication No 3648 from C.D.R.I., Lucknow.