Deciphering structure-activity relationships in a series of Tat/TAR inhibitors

A series of pentameric “Polyamide Amino Acids” (PAAs) compounds derived from the same trimeric precursor have been synthesized and investigated as HIV TAR RNA ligands, in the absence and in the presence of a Tat fragment. All PAAs bind TAR with similar sub-micromolar affinities but their ability to compete efficiently with the Tat fragment strongly differs, IC₅₀ ranging from 35 nM to >2 μM. While NMR and CD studies reveal that all PAA interact with TAR at the same site and induce globally the same RNA conformational change upon binding, a comparative thermodynamic study of PAA/TAR equilibria highlights distinct TAR binding modes for Tat competitor and non-competitor PAAs. This led us to suggest two distinct interaction modes that have been further validated by molecular modeling studies. While the binding of Tat competitor PAAs induces a contraction at the TAR bulge region, the binding of non-competitor ones widens it. This could account for the distinct PAA ability to compete with Tat fragment. Our work illustrates how comparative thermodynamic studies of a series of RNA ligands of same chemical family are of value for understanding their binding modes and for rationalizing structure-activity relationships.     

Polyamidoamine dendrimers inhibit binding of Tat peptide to TAR RNA

The binding of polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimer or Tat peptide to trans-acting responsive element (TAR) RNA has been studied using microgravimetric quartz crystal microbalance (QCM). Experimental results showed that PAMAM dendrimer could form complexes with TAR RNA. Especially, PAMAM dendrimer could disrupt the interaction of Tat peptide with TAR RNA, which is essential for HIV-1 virus replication, suggesting that QCM is a powerful tool for studying the binding processes of Tat peptide-TAR RNA and drug-TAR RNA and has great significance for the design of new drugs. An equation to measure the binding ability between TAR RNA and other species has been proposed.     

Probing Tat peptide-TAR RNA interactions by psoralen photo-cross-linking

Replication of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) requires specific interactions of Tat protein with the trans-activation responsive region (TAR) RNA, a 59-base stem-loop structure located at the 5'-end of all HIV mRNAs. We have used a site-specific cross-linking method based on psoralen photochemistry to determine the effect of core residues from the Tat sequence on the protein orientation in the Tat-TAR complex and on the specificity of Tat-TAR binding. We synthesized two Tat fragments, Tat(42-72) and Tat(37-72), and incorporated a psoralen-modified amino acid at position 41 during solid-phase assembly of the peptides. We used these psoralen-Tat conjugates to form specific complexes with TAR RNA. Upon near-ultraviolet irradiation (360 nm), psoralen-Asp41-Tat(37-72) cross-linked to a single site in the TAR RNA sequence. The RNA-protein complex was purified and the cross-link site on TAR RNA was determined by primer extension analysis, which revealed that Asp41 of Tat is close to U42 of the lower stem region of TAR RNA. Specificity of the RNA-peptide cross-linking reactions was determined by competition experiments. Our results show that the addition of only four residues (Cys37-Thr40) from the Tat core region significantly enhanced the specificity of the Tat peptide-TAR interactions without altering the site or chemical nature of the cross-link. These studies provide new insights into RNA-protein recognition that could be useful in designing peptidomimetics for RNA targeting. Such psoralen-peptide conjugates provide a new class of probes for sequence-specific protein-nucleic acid interactions and could be used to selectively control gene expression or to induce site-directed mutations.     

Polyamide amino acids trimers as TAR RNA ligands and anti-HIV agents

Based on a split-and-mix strategy, a library of trimeric Polyamide Amino Acids (PAA) incorporating four different amino acids (Lys, Ala, Arg, and Phe) has been prepared. Screening of the batches for HIV TAR RNA binding in a fluorescent assay allowed the identification of several components that interact with TAR RNA at a micromolar concentration, with a good TAR versus tRNA specificity. Some of these compounds compete efficiently with the association of TAR and Tat protein. In cell cultures, these compounds display a moderate antiviral activity, associated nevertheless with some toxicity. Overall, these results confirm that this new family can be a basis for the design of novel RNA targeting drugs.     

Aptamers targeted to an RNA hairpin show improved specificity compared to that of complementary oligonucleotides

Aptamers interacting with RNA hairpins through loop-loop (so-called kissing) interactions have been described as an alternative to antisense oligomers for the recognition of RNA hairpins. R06, an RNA aptamer, was previously shown to form a kissing complex with the TAR (trans-activating responsive) hairpin of HIV-1 RNA (Ducongé and Toulmé (1999) RNA 5, 1605). We derived a chimeric locked nucleic acid (LNA)/DNA aptamer from R06 that retains the binding properties of the originally selected R06 aptamer. We demonstrated that this LNA/DNA aptamer competes with a peptide of the retroviral protein Tat for binding to TAR, even though the binding sites of the two ligands do not overlap each other. This suggests that upon binding, the aptamer TAR adopts a conformation that is no longer appropriate for Tat association. In contrast, a LNA/DNA antisense oligomer, which exhibits the same binding constant and displays the same base-pairing potential as the chimeric aptamer, does not compete with Tat. Moreover, we showed that the LNA/DNA aptamer is a more specific TAR binder than the LNA/DNA antisense sequence. These results demonstrate the benefit of reading the three-dimensional shape of an RNA target rather than its primary sequence for the design of highly specific oligonucleotides.     

Essential structural requirements for specific recognition of HIV TAR RNA by peptide mimetics of Tat protein

The pharmacological disruption of the interaction between the HIV Tat protein and its cognate transactivation response RNA (TAR) would generate novel anti-viral drugs with a low susceptibility to drug resistance, but efforts to discover ligands with sufficient potency to warrant pharmaceutical development have been unsuccessful. We have previously described a family of structurally constrained β-hairpin peptides that potently inhibits viral growth in HIV-infected cells. The nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structure of an inhibitory complex revealed that the peptide makes intimate contacts with the 3-nt bulge and the upper helix of the RNA hairpin, but that a single residue contacts the apical loop where recruitment of the essential cellular co-factor cyclin T₁ occurs. Attempting to extend the peptide to form more interactions with the RNA loop, we examined a library of longer peptides and achieved >6-fold improvement in affinity. The structure of TAR bound to one of the extended peptides reveals that the peptide slides down the major groove of the RNA, relative to our design, in order to maintain critical interactions with TAR. These conserved contacts involve three amino acid side chains and identify critical interaction points required for potent and specific binding to TAR RNA. They constitute a template of essential interactions required for inhibition of this RNA.     

A human chromosome 12-associated 83-kilodalton cellular protein specifically binds to the loop region of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 trans-activation response element RNA.

trans activation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) involves the viral trans-activator protein (Tat) and a cellular factor(s) encoded on human chromosome 12 (HuChr12) that targets the trans-activation response element (TAR) in the viral long terminal repeat. Because nascent TAR RNA is predicted to form a secondary structure that specifically binds cellular proteins, we investigated the composition of the TAR RNA-protein complex for HuChr12-specific proteins. UV cross-linking of TAR RNA-nuclear protein complexes formed in vitro identified an 83-kDa protein in human cells and in a human-hamster hybrid cell containing only HuChr12. The 83-kDa TAR RNA-binding protein was absent in the parental hamster cells. TAR RNA mutations that inhibited binding of the 83-kDa protein in vitro also inhibited HuChr12-dependent Tat trans activation. These TAR mutations changed the native sequence or secondary structure of the TAR loop. The TAR RNA binding activity of the 83-kDa protein also correlated with a HuChr12-dependent increase in steady-state HIV-1 RNA expression during Tat trans activation. Our results suggest that either a species-specific 83-kDa TAR RNA loop-binding protein is directly encoded on HuChr12 or a HuChr12 protein(s) induces the expression of an 83-kDa TAR-binding protein in nonprimate cells.     

Bimodal loop-loop interactions increase the affinity of RNA aptamers for HIV-1 RNA structures

Multiple loop-loop interactions between adjacent RNA hairpins regulate gene expression in different organisms. To demonstrate that such natural interactions could be mimicked for generating RNA ligands that are able to recognize simultaneously at least two structured RNA targets, a double kissing complex model was designed. The target consisted of two HIV-1 transactivating responsive (TAR) RNA variants, BRU and MAL, connected by a non-nucleotidic linker. The double ligand was generated by combining the corresponding hairpin aptamers, R06BRU and R06MAL, identified previously by in vitro selection [Ducongé, F., and Toulmé, J. J (1999) RNA 5, 1605-1614]. The resulting interaction was analyzed by thermal denaturation monitored by UV spectroscopy, electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSAs), and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) experiments. The bimodal complex was characterized by a binding equilibrium constant increased by at least 1 order of magnitude compared to that of the complexes between the individual parent hairpins. This resulted from a slower dissociation rate. We then made use of such a strategy for targeting two structured functional motifs of the folded 5' untranslated region (5'UTR) of HIV-1. Two bivalent RNA ligands were designed that targeted simultaneously the TAR and dimerization initiation site (DIS) hairpins or the TAR and poly(A) ones. The results show that these ligands also displayed enhanced affinity for their target compared to the individual molecules. The work reported here suggests that bimodal structured RNA ligands might provide a way of increasing the affinity of aptamers for folded RNA targets.