The structural basis of cooperative regulation at an alternate genetic switch

Bacteriophage lambda is a paradigm for understanding the role of cooperativity in gene regulation. Comparison of the regulatory regions of lambda and the unrelated temperate bacteriophage 186 provides insight into alternate ways to assemble functional genetic switches. The structure of the C-terminal domain of the 186 repressor, determined at 2.7 A resolution, reveals an unusual heptamer of dimers, consistent with presented genetic studies. In addition, the structure of a cooperativity mutant of the full-length 186 repressor, identified by genetic screens, was solved to 1.95 A resolution. These structures provide a molecular basis for understanding lysogenic regulation in 186. Whereas the overall fold of the 186 and lambda repressor monomers is remarkably similar, the way the two repressors cooperatively assemble is quite different and explains in part the differences in their regulatory activity.     

Wrapping of flanking non-operator DNA in lac repressor-operator complexes: implications for DNA looping

In our studies of lac repressor tetramer (T)-lac operator (O) interactions, we observed that the presence of extended regions of non-operator DNA flanking a single lac operator sequence embedded in plasmid DNA produced large and unusual cooperative and anticooperative effects on binding constants (Kobs) and their salt concentration dependences for the formation of 1:1 (TO) and especially 1:2 (TO2) complexes. To explore the origin of this striking behavior we report and analyze binding data on 1:1 (TO) and 1:2 (TO2) complexes between repressor and a single O(sym) operator embedded in 40 bp, 101 bp, and 2514 bp DNA, over very wide ranges of [salt]. We find large interrelated effects of flanking DNA length and [salt] on binding constants (K(TO)obs, K(TO2)obs) and on their [salt]-derivatives, and quantify these effects in terms of the free energy contributions of two wrapping modes, designated local and global. Both local and global wrapping of flanking DNA occur to an increasing extent as [salt] decreases. Global wrapping of plasmid-length DNA is extraordinarily dependent on [salt]. We propose that global wrapping is driven at low salt concentration by the polyelectrolyte effect, and involves a very large number (>/similar 20) of coulombic interactions between DNA phosphates and positively charged groups on lac repressor. Coulombic interactions in the global wrap must involve both the core and the second DNA-binding domain of lac repressor, and result in a complex which is looped by DNA wrapping. The non-coulombic contribution to the free energy of global wrapping is highly unfavorable ( approximately +30-50 kcal mol(-1)), which presumably results from a significant extent of DNA distortion and/or entropic constraints. We propose a structural model for global wrapping, and consider its implications for looping of intervening non-operator DNA in forming a complex between a tetrameric repressor (LacI) and one multi-operator DNA molecule in vivo and in vitro. The existence of DNA wrapping in LacI-DNA interactions motivates the proposal that most if not all DNA binding proteins may have evolved the capability to wrap and thereby organize flanking regions of DNA.     

Neck muscle paths and moment arms are significantly affected by wrapping surface parameters

In this paper, we studied the effects of wrapping surfaces on muscle paths and moment arms of the neck muscle, semispinalis capitis. Sensitivities to wrapping surface size and the kinematic linkage to vertebral segments were evaluated. Kinematic linkage, but not radius, significantly affected the accuracy of model muscle paths compared to centroid paths from images. Both radius and linkage affected the moment arm significantly. Wrapping surfaces that provided the best match to centroid paths over a range of postures had consistent moment arms. For some wrapping surfaces with poor matches to the centroid path, a kinematic method (tendon excursion) predicted flexion moment arms in certain postures, whereas geometric method (distance to instant centre) predicted extension. This occurred because the muscle lengthened as it wrapped around the surface. This study highlights the sensitivity of moment arms to wrapping surface parameters and the importance of including multiple postures when evaluating muscle paths and moment arm.     

Neck muscle paths and moment arms are significantly affected by wrapping surface parameters

In this paper, we studied the effects of wrapping surfaces on muscle paths and moment arms of the neck muscle, semispinalis capitis. Sensitivities to wrapping surface size and the kinematic linkage to vertebral segments were evaluated. Kinematic linkage, but not radius, significantly affected the accuracy of model muscle paths compared to centroid paths from images. Both radius and linkage affected the moment arm significantly. Wrapping surfaces that provided the best match to centroid paths over a range of postures had consistent moment arms. For some wrapping surfaces with poor matches to the centroid path, a kinematic method (tendon excursion) predicted flexion moment arms in certain postures, whereas geometric method (distance to instant centre) predicted extension. This occurred because the muscle lengthened as it wrapped around the surface. This study highlights the sensitivity of moment arms to wrapping surface parameters and the importance of including multiple postures when evaluating muscle paths and moment arm.     

Comparisons of the Distribution of Nucleotides and Common Sequences in Deoxyribonucleic Acid from Selected Bacteriophages

Results from comparisons of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) from several classes of bacteriophages suggest that most phage chromosomes contain either a homogeneous distribution of nucleotides or are made up of a few, rather large segments of different quanine plus cytosine (G + C) contents which are internally homogeneous. Among those temperate phages tested, most contained segmented DNA. Comparisons of sequence similarities among segments from lambdoid phage DNA species revealed the following order in relatedness to lambda: 82 (and 434) > 21 > 424 > phi80. Most common sequences are found in the highest G + C segments, which in lambda contain head and tail genes. Hybridization tests with lambda and 186 or P2 DNA species verified that the lambdoids and 186 and P2 belong to two distinct groups. There are fewer homologous sequences between the DNA species of coliphages lambda and P2 or 186 than there are between the DNA species of coliphage lambda and salmonella phage P22.     

The helix-turn-helix motif of the coliphage 186 immunity repressor binds to two distinct recognition sequences.

The CI protein of coliphage 186 is responsible for maintaining the stable lysogenic state. To do this CI must recognize two distinct DNA sequences, termed A type sites and B type sites. Here we investigate whether CI contains two separate DNA binding motifs or whether CI has one motif that recognizes two different operator sequences. Sequence alignment with 186-like repressors predicts an N-terminal helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif, albeit with poor homology to a large master set of such motifs. The domain structure of CI was investigated by linker insertion mutagenesis and limited proteolysis. CI consists of an N-terminal domain, which weakly dimerizes and binds both A and B type sequences, and a C-terminal domain, which associates to octamers but is unable to bind DNA. A fusion protein consisting of the 186 N-terminal domain and the phage lambda oligomerization domain binds A and B type sequences more efficiently than the isolated 186 CI N-terminal domain, hence the 186 C-terminal domain likely mediates oligomerization and cooperativity. Site-directed mutation of the putative 186 HTH motif eliminates binding to both A and B type sites, supporting the idea that binding to the two distinct DNA sequences is mediated by a variant HTH motif.     

ATP‐dependent looping of DNA by ISWI

Snf2 related chromatin remodelling enzymes possess an ATPase subunit similar to that of the SF‐II helicases which hydrolyzes ATP to track along DNA. Translocation and any resulting torque in the DNA could drive chromatin remodeling. To determine whether the ISWI protein can translocate and generate torque, tethered particle motion experiments and atomic force microscopy have been performed using recombinant ISWI expressed in E. coli. In the absence of ATP, ISWI bound to and wrapped DNA thereby shortening the overall contour length measured in atomic force micrographs. Although naked DNA only weakly stimulates ATP hydrolysis by ISWI, both atomic force microscopy and tethered particle motion data indicate that the protein generated loops in the presence of ATP. The duration of the looped state of the DNA measured using tethered particle motion was ATP‐dependent. Finally, ISWI relaxed positively supercoiled plasmids visualized by atomic force microscopy. While other chromatin remodeling ATPases catalyze either DNA wrapping or looping, both are catalyzed by ISWI. (© 2008 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)     

Stability of a Lac repressor mediated "looped complex"

The quantitation of the stability of a protein-mediated "looped complex" of the Lac repressor and DNA containing two protein-binding sites whose centers of symmetry are separated by 11 helical turns (114 bp) was accomplished by footprint and gel mobility-shift titration techniques. Lac repressor binding to this DNA was only moderately cooperative; a cooperative free energy of -1.0 kcal/mol was calculated in a model-independent fashion from the individual-site loading energies obtained from the footprint titration studies. In order to partition the cooperative binding energy into components representing the dimer-tetramer association of Lac repressor and the cyclization probability of the intervening DNA, advantage was taken of the presence of experimental measures that were in proportion to the concentration of the looped complex present in solution. One measure was the DNase I hypersensitivity observed in footprint titrations in bands located between the two binding sites. The second measure resulted from the electrophoretic resolution in the gel mobility-shift titrations of the band representing the doubly liganded "tandem complex" from the band representing the singly liganded complexes, including the looped complex. Analysis of the footprint and mobility-shift titration data utilizing this additional information showed that approximately 65% of the molecules present in solution are looped complexes at pH 7.0, 100 mM KCl, and 20 degrees C when the binding sites on the DNA are saturated with protein. Reconciliation of the observed low binding cooperativity and the high proportion of looped complexes could only be obtained when the titration data were analyzed by a model in which Lac repressor tetramers dissociate into dimers in solution. The proportion of looped complexes present in solution is highly dependent on the dimer-tetramer association constant, delta Gtet. This result is consistent with the determination by high-pressure fluorescence techniques that Lac repressor tetramers dissociate with an association free energy comparable to their DNA-binding free energies [Royer, C. A., Chakerian, A. E., & Matthews, K. S. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 4959-4966]. However, when the value of delta Gtet of -10.6 kcal/mol (at 20 degrees C) reported by Royer et al. (1990) is assumed, the titration data demand that tetramers bind DNA with much greater affinity than dimers: a result inconsistent with the destabilization of tetramers by the operator observed in the dimer-tetramer dissociation studies.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The Effect of Nonspecific Binding of Lambda Repressor on DNA Looping Dynamics

The λ repressor (CI) protein-induced DNA loop maintains stable lysogeny, yet allows efficient switching to lysis. Herein, the kinetics of loop formation and breakdown has been characterized at various concentrations of protein using tethered particle microscopy and a novel, to our knowledge, method of analysis. Our results show that a broad distribution of rate constants and complex kinetics underlie loop formation and breakdown. In addition, comparison of the kinetics of looping in wild-type DNA and DNA with mutated o3 operators showed that these sites may trigger nucleation of nonspecific binding at the closure of the loop. The average activation energy calculated from the rate constant distribution is consistent with a model in which nonspecific binding of CI between the operators shortens their effective separation, thereby lowering the energy barrier for loop formation and broadening the rate constant distribution for looping. Similarly, nonspecific binding affects the kinetics of loop breakdown by increasing the number of loop-securing protein interactions, and broadens the rate constant distribution for this reaction. Therefore, simultaneous increase of the rate constant for loop formation and reduction of that for loop breakdown stabilizes lysogeny. Given these simultaneous changes, the frequency of transitions between the looped and the unlooped state remains nearly constant. Although the loop becomes more stable thermodynamically with increasing CI concentration, it still opens periodically, conferring sensitivity to environmental changes, which may require switching to lytic conditions.     

Key players in the genetic switch of bacteriophage TP901-1

After infection of a sensitive host temperate phages may enter either a lytic or a lysogenic pathway leading to new phage assembly or silencing as a prophage, respectively. The decision about which pathway to enter is centered in the genetic switch of the phage. In this work, we explore the bistable genetic switch of bacteriophage TP901-1 through experiments and statistical mechanical modeling. We examine the activity of the lysogenic promoter Pr at different concentrations of the phage repressor, CI, and compare the effect of CI on Pr in the presence or absence of the phage-encoded MOR protein expressed from the lytic promoter Pl. We find that the presence of large amounts of MOR prevents repression of the Pr promoter, verifying that MOR works as an antirepressor. We compare our experimental data with simulations based on previous mathematical formulations of this switch. Good agreement between data and simulations verify the model of CI repression of Pr. By including MOR in the simulations, we are able to discard a model that assumes that CI and MOR do not interact before binding together at the DNA to repress Pr. The second model of Pr repression assumes the formation of a CI:MOR complex in the cytoplasm. We suggest that a CI:MOR complex may exist in different forms that either prevent or invoke Pr repression, introducing a new twist on mixed feedback systems.     

DNA-binding properties of a lac repressor mutant incapable of forming tetramers

The interaction of proteins bound to sites widely separated on the genome is a recurrent motif in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic regulatory systems. Lac repressor mediates the formation of "DNA loops" by the simultaneous interaction of a single protein tetramer with two DNA-binding sites. The DNA-binding properties of a Lac repressor mutant (LacIadi) deficient in the association of protein dimers to tetramers was investigated. The results of quantitative footprint and gel mobility-shift titrations suggest that the wild-type Lac repressor (LacI+) binds cooperatively to two operator sites separated by 11 helical turns on a linear DNA restriction fragment by the formation of a "looped complex." LacIadi binds to this two-site operator non-cooperatively and without formation of a looped complex. These results demonstrate that the dimer-tetramer association of LacI+ is directly responsible for its cooperative binding and its ability to mediate formation of a looped complex. The Iadi mutation disrupts the monomer-dimer as well as eliminating the dimer-tetramer association equilibria while the DNA binding affinity of LacIadi to a single site is unchanged relative to the wild-type protein. These results suggest that DNA binding and dimer-tetramer association are functionally unlinked. The similarity of the DNA-binding properties of LacIadi and Gal repressor, a protein believed to function by mediating the formation of a looped complex, are discussed.     

Structure and distribution of inverted repeats (palindromes)

The size and distribution of renatured inverted repeats (palindromes) in Mus musculus DNA were examined by electron microscopy (EM). The majority (85%) of palindromes were found to be clustered in about one half of the DNA strands. The rest of the DNA strands were seen with a solitary looped structure. — The unlooped palindromes constituted 53% of all palindromes and were always clustered. There was a significant reduction in the number of unlooped palindromes in comparison to D. melanogaster DNA (Biezunski, 1981) and as a result the palindrome clusters were smaller and contained 2–8 palindromes [4–16 inverted repeats (ir)] per DNA strand. The looped palindromes had a wide and regular distribution with spacing lengths similar to those found in D. melanogaster DNA, and showed some periodicity. The average spacing between centers of all palindromes (inside a cluster) was 4.325 kb, and between centers of looped palindromes 8.544 kb. — The lengths of the ir of unlooped and looped palindromes were grouped (similar to D. melanogaster DNA) in one size-class with a range of 30–240 bp and an average length of 130 bp. Longer ir were also observed and the average length of ir in unlooped palindromes was 186 bp, in looped 588 bp, and the total average length was 375 bp. — It was calculated that there are about 224,000–320,000 palindromes (ir pairs) in the mouse genome, with the spacing between centers of all palindromes about 13-9 kb in length. — In high molecular weight mouse DNA, complex looped structures composed of rows of 5–8 looped palindromes one on top the other, formed by renaturation of multiple ir, were observed. It is suggested, that clustered repetitive sequences, in direct and inverted orientation, might be of one family and homologous to one another, and be able to reassociate, in vitro and in vivo, into structures of different forms, which could function as binding sites for various regulatory proteins during mouse development.     

The N-Terminal Domain of the Repressor of Staphylococcus aureus Phage Φ11 Possesses an Unusual Dimerization Ability and DNA Binding Affinity

Bacteriophage Φ11 uses Staphylococcus aureus as its host and, like lambdoid phages, harbors three homologous operators in between its two divergently oriented repressor genes. None of the repressors of Φ11, however, showed binding to all three operators, even at high concentrations. To understand why the DNA binding mechanism of Φ11 repressors does not match that of lambdoid phage repressors, we studied the N-terminal domain of the Φ11 lysogenic repressor, as it harbors a putative helix-turn-helix motif. Our data revealed that the secondary and tertiary structures of the N-terminal domain were different from those of the full-length repressor. Nonetheless, the N-terminal domain was able to dimerize and bind to the operators similar to the intact repressor. In addition, the operator base specificity, binding stoichiometry, and binding mechanism of this domain were nearly identical to those of the whole repressor. The binding affinities of the repressor and its N-terminal domain were reduced to a similar extent when the temperature was increased to 42°C. Both proteins also adequately dislodged a RNA polymerase from a Φ11 DNA fragment carrying two operators and a promoter. Unlike the intact repressor, the binding of the N-terminal domain to two adjacent operator sites was not cooperative in nature. Taken together, we suggest that the dimerization and DNA binding abilities of the N-terminal domain of the Φ11 repressor are distinct from those of the DNA binding domains of other phage repressors.     

Effect of DNA looping on the induction kinetics of the lac operon

The induction of the lac operon follows cooperative kinetics. The first mechanistic model of these kinetics is the de facto standard in the modeling literature [Yagil, G., Yagil, E., 1971. On the relation between effector concentration and the rate of induced enzyme synthesis. Biophys. J. 11, 11-17]. Yet, subsequent studies have shown that the model is based on incorrect assumptions. Specifically, the repressor is a tetramer with four (not two) inducer-binding sites, and the operon contains two auxiliary operators (in addition to the main operator). Furthermore, these structural features are crucial for the formation of DNA loops, the key determinants of lac repression and induction. Indeed, the repression is determined almost entirely (>95%) by the looped complexes [Oehler, S., Eismann, E.R., Kr?mer, H., Müller-Hill, B., 1990. The three operators of the lac operon cooperate in repression. EMBO J. 9(4), 973-979], and the pronounced cooperativity of the induction curve hinges upon the existence of the looped complexes [Oehler, S., Alberti, S., Müller-Hill, B., 2006. Induction of the lac promoter in the absence of DNA loops and the stoichiometry of induction. Nucleic Acids Res. 34(2), 606-612]. Here, we formulate a model of lac induction taking due account of the tetrameric structure of the repressor and the existence of looped complexes. We show that: (1) The kinetics are significantly more cooperative than those predicted by the Yagil and Yagil model. The cooperativity is higher because the formation of looped complexes is easily abolished by repressor-inducer binding. (2) The model provides good fits to the repression data for cells containing wild-type tetrameric or mutant dimeric repressor, as well as the induction curves for 6 different strains of Escherichia coli. It also implies that the ratios of certain looped and non-looped complexes are independent of inducer and repressor levels, a conclusion that can be rigorously tested by gel electrophoresis. (3) Repressor overexpression dramatically increases the cooperativity of the induction curve. This suggests that repressor overexpression can induce bistability in systems, such as growth of E. coli on lactose, that are otherwise monostable.