Effects of environmental estrogenic chemicals on AP1 mediated transcription with estrogen receptors alpha and beta

There has been much discussion concerning endocrine disrupting chemicals suspected of exerting adverse effects in both wildlife and humans. Since the majority of these compounds are estrogenic, a large number of in vitro tests for estrogenic characteristics have been developed for screening purpose. One reliable and widely used method is the reporter gene assay employing estrogen receptors (ERs) and a reporter gene with a cis-acting estrogen responsive element (ERE). Other elements such as AP1 also mediate estrogenic signals and the manner of response could be quite different from that of ERE. Since this has yet to be explored, the ER mediated AP1 activity in response to a series of environmental estrogens was investigated in comparison with ERE findings. All the compounds exhibited estrogenic properties with ERE-luc and their AP1 responses were quite similar. These was one exception, however, p,p'-DDT (1,1,1,-trichloro-2,2-bis(p-chlorophenyl)ethane) did not exert any AP1-luc activity, while it appeared to be estrogenic at 10(-7) to 10(-5)M with the ERE action. None of the compounds demonstrated ER beta:AP1 activity. These data suggest that significant differences can occur in responses through the two estrogen pathways depending on environmental chemicals.     

Comparative effect of seeds of Rhynchosia volubilis and soybean on MG-63 human osteoblastic cell proliferation and estrogenicity

The seeds of Rhynchosia volubilis (SRV) (Leguminosae) and soybean have been used in oriental folk medicine to prevent postmenopausal osteoporosis. Their beneficial effects are caused by a high content of isoflavone, which function as partial agonists or antagonists of estrogen. To compare the estrogenic effects of SRV and soybean on the MG-63 osteoblastic cell proliferation, 70% methanol extracts of SRV or soybean were treated on MG-63 cells. Although biphasic over a concentration range of 0.001 mg/ml-0.1 mg/ml, both SRV and soybean extracts increased MG-63 cell proliferation. However SRV was more effective at increasing the cell proliferation that paralleled with the greater estrogenic effects as determined by estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) expression, an estrogenic response element (ERE)-luciferase activity and the selective expression of insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I). SRV-induced IGF-I expression resulted from increases in the mRNA levels. Despite the increased expression of ERbeta, ERE activity and IGF-I expression by soybean were lower than those by SRV. Furthermore, the comparable estrogenic effects between SRV and the combined treatment of genistein and daidzein standards at 0.5 x 10(-8) M, which is a concentration of these two isoflavones similar to that of SRV at 0.001 mg/ml, demonstrate that the greater estrogenicity of SRV for MG-63 cell proliferation is mediated by the synergism of low levels of isoflavones for the selective expression of IGF-I.     

Activities of a non-classical estrogen,Z-bis-dehydrodoisynolic acid,with ERalpha and ERbeta

(+/-)-Z-bis-Dehydrodoisynolic acid [(+/-)-Z-BDDA] is highly estrogenic in vivo, yet binds to estrogen receptor (ER) poorly. This paradox has raised the possibility of alternative ERs and/or molecular mechanisms. To address the possibility of high activities of Z-BDDA with ERbeta, we determined the activities of (+)-Z-BDDA and (-)-Z-BDDA, in cell culture and in vitro, comparing ERbeta to ERalpha. Transfectional analysis in Hela cells showed (-)-Z-BDDA is an agonist for gene activation with both ERalpha (EC(50) congruent with 0.3nM) and ERbeta (EC(50) congruent with 5nM), while little to no activity was observed with (+)-Z-BDDA. Similarly, in gene repression assays, (-)-Z-BDDA was active (EC(50) congruent with 0.2nM), but again minimal activity was exhibited by (+)-Z-BDDA. Binding to ERalpha and ERbeta in vitro used both competition and a direct binding assay. For ERalpha, the relative affinity of (-)-Z-BDDA was approximately 6% by competition and 1.7% by direct binding versus 17beta-estradiol (E2; 100%), while (+)-Z-BDDA also demonstrated binding, but with relative affinities of only 0.08% by competition and 0.3% by the direct assay. For ERbeta, the affinity of (-)-Z-BDDA was approximately 7% by competition and 1.5% by the direct assay relative to E2 (100%), while (+)-Z-BDDA had lower affinity, approximately 0.2% that of E2 by both assays.The paradox of potent in vivo activity but lower activity in receptor binding and in cell culture reporter gene assays, previously seen with ERalpha is now also associated with ERbeta. The failure of ERbeta to explain the activity-binding paradox indicates the need for additional in vivo metabolic and pharmacokinetic studies and continued consideration of alternative mechanisms.     

Isoflavones stimulate estrogen receptor-mediated core histone acetylation

The isoflavones genistein and daidzein and the daidzein metabolite equol have been reported to interact with estrogen receptors (ERs). Some studies indicate that they behave clinically like estrogen in some estrogen-deficiency diseases. However, the detailed molecular mechanism used by these compounds to create beneficial effects in patients with estrogen-related diseases has not been clarified. Using histone acetyltransferase (HAT) assay, we found that equol, genistein, and AglyMax had significant effects on ERalpha-mediated histone acetylation. Although 17beta-estradiol (E2)-dependent HAT activity of steroid receptor coactivators 2 (SRC2) and p300 mediated by ERbeta could be detected, it was weaker than that mediated by ERalpha. Equol, genistein, AglyMax, and daidzein all markedly stimulated ERbeta-mediated histone acetylation. On the other hand, anti-estrogenic compounds ICI 182,780 (ICI) and tamoxifen (TA) did not have an effect on HAT activity mediated by either ERalpha or ERbeta. Our data indicate that estrogenic ligands exert their effects by elevating histone acetylation and coactivator activity of ER, and suggest that the risk of estrogen-related diseases might be reduced by a sufficient amount of genistein or AglyMax supplements.     

Interaction of tetrahydrocrysene ketone with estrogen receptors alpha and beta indicates conformational differences in the receptor subtypes

Estrogen receptors (ER) alpha and beta bind estradiol (E2) and other estrogenic ligands with different affinities. To measure the rate of E2 association with ERa and ERbeta, we employed tetrahydrocrysene ketone (THCK), a fluorescent ligand that is an agonist with ERalpha and an antagonist with ERbeta. We report that THCK binds E2-liganded and unliganded ERalpha and ERbeta, indicating a THCK binding site(s) other than the E2 binding pocket. THCK fluorescence was greater for ligand-occupied ERbeta than ERalpha, suggesting differences in the microenvironment of the THCK binding site(s). THCK fluorescence was also significantly greater for E2-, 4-hydroxytamoxifen-, and tamoxifen aziridine-liganded versus unliganded ER, allowing calculations of E2 association rate constants (ka) of 7.60 +/- 0.75 and 5.12 +/- 0.30 x 10(5) M(-1) s(-1) for E2-ERalpha and E2-ERbeta, respectively. THCK did not affect ERalpha binding to estrogen response element (ERE) DNA, but decreased ERbeta-ERE binding. We conclude that THCK binding site(s) on ERalpha versus ERbeta are different and important for ER function.     

Membrane ERalpha-dependent activation of PKCalpha in endometrial cancer cells by estradiol

The purpose of this study was to investigate the role of the oestrogen receptor subtypes ERalpha and ERbeta in mediating the non-genomic effects of 17-beta-estradiol (E(2)) in two human endometrial cancer cell lines (RL95-2 and HEC-1A) expressing different levels of these receptor subtypes. Western blotting analysis using phosphorylation site-specific antibodies showed that physiological concentrations of E(2) rapidly (<20 min) activated PKCalpha, but not PKCdelta in the RL95-2 cell line. E(2) had no effect on PKCalpha or PKCdelta activity in the HEC-1A cell line and suppressed basal levels of PKA activity in both cell lines. PKCalpha activation coincided with its membrane translocation. ERalpha was detected in the RL95-2 cell line by Western blotting and RT-PCR but not in the HEC-1A cells, which did express ERbeta. A selective ERalpha agonist PPT had the same effect as E(2) on PKCalpha activation in the RL95-2 cells, but the selective ERbeta agonist DPN had no such effect. A 46kDa variant of ERalpha increased in abundance in the cell membrane within 20 min of E(2) treatment suggesting that ERalpha mediated the E(2) non-genomic effects on PKCalpha through the formation of a membrane associated signalling complex.