Reversible and irreversible unfolding of multi-domain proteins

In contrast to single-domain proteins unfolding of larger multi-domain proteins is often irreversible. In a comparative case study on three different multi-domain proteins (phosphoglycerate kinase: PGK and two homologous alpha-amylases: TAKA and BLA) we investigated properties of unfolded states and their ability to fold back into the native state. For this purpose guanidine hydrochloride, alkaline pH, and thermal unfolded states were characterized. Structural alterations upon unfolding and refolding transitions were monitored using fluorescence and CD spectroscopy. Static and dynamic light scattering was employed to follow aggregation processes. Furthermore, proper refolding was also investigated by enzyme activity measurements. While for PGK at least partial reversible unfolding transitions were observed in most cases, we found reversible unfolding for TAKA in the case of alkaline pH and GndHCl induced unfolding. BLA exhibits reversible unfolding only under conditions with high concentrations of protecting osmolytes (glycerol), indicating that aggregation of the unfolded state is the main obstacle to achieve proper refolding for this protein. Structural properties, such as number and size of domains, secondary structure contents and compositions within domains, and domain topology were analyzed and considered in the interpretation of differences in refolding behavior of the investigated proteins.     

Protein thermal aggregation involves distinct regions: sequential events in the heat-induced unfolding and aggregation of hemoglobin

Protein thermal aggregation plays a crucial role in protein science and engineering. Despite its biological importance, little is known about the mechanism and pathway(s) involved in the formation of aggregates. In this report, the sequential events occurring during thermal unfolding and aggregation process of hemoglobin were studied by two-dimensional infrared correlation spectroscopy. Analysis of the infrared spectra recorded at different temperatures suggested that hemoglobin denatured by a two-stage thermal transition. At the initial structural perturbation stage (30-44 degrees C), the fast red shift of the band from alpha-helix indicated that the native helical structures became more and more solvent-exposed as temperature increased. At the thermal unfolding stage (44-54 degrees C), the unfolding of solvent-exposed helical structures dominated the transition and was supposed to be responsible to the start of aggregation. At the thermal aggregation stage (54-70 degrees C), the transition was dominated by the formation of aggregates and the further unfolding of the buried structures. A close inspection of the sequential events occurring at different stages suggested that protein thermal aggregation involves distinct regions.     

Irreversible gelation of thermally unfolded proteins: structural and mechanical properties of lysozyme aggregates

The formation of protein aggregates is important in many fields of life science and technology. The morphological and mechanical properties of protein solutions depend upon the molecular conformation and thermodynamic and environmental conditions. Non-native or unfolded proteins may be kinetically trapped into irreversible aggregates and undergo precipitation or gelation. Here, we study the thermal aggregation of lysozyme in neutral solutions. We characterise the irreversible unfolding of lysozyme by differential scanning calorimetry. The structural properties of aggregates and their mechanisms of formation with the eventual gelation are studied at high temperature by spectroscopic, rheological and scattering techniques. The experiments show that irreversible micron-sized aggregates are organised into larger clusters according to a classical mechanism of diffusion and coagulation, which leads to a percolative transition at high concentrations. At a smaller length scale, optical and atomic force microscopy images reveal the existence of compact aggregates, which are the origin of the aggregation irreversibility.     

A measure of conformational entropy change during thermal protein unfolding using neutron spectroscopy

Thermal unfolding of proteins at high temperatures is caused by a strong increase of the entropy change which lowers Gibbs free energy change of the unfolding transition (DeltaG(unf) = DeltaH - TDeltaS). The main contributions to entropy are the conformational entropy of the polypeptide chain itself and ordering of water molecules around hydrophobic side chains of the protein. To elucidate the role of conformational entropy upon thermal unfolding in more detail, conformational dynamics in the time regime of picoseconds was investigated with neutron spectroscopy. Confined internal structural fluctuations were analyzed for alpha-amylase in the folded and the unfolded state as a function of temperature. A strong difference in structural fluctuations between the folded and the unfolded state was observed at 30 degrees C, which increased even more with rising temperatures. A simple analytical model was used to quantify the differences of the conformational space explored by the observed protein dynamics for the folded and unfolded state. Conformational entropy changes, calculated on the basis of the applied model, show a significant increase upon heating. In contrast to indirect estimates, which proposed a temperature independent conformational entropy change, the measurements presented here, demonstrated that the conformational entropy change increases with rising temperature and therefore contributes to thermal unfolding.     

Cation binding effects on the pH, thermal and urea denaturation transitions in alpha-lactalbumin

The binding of monovalent (Na+, K+) and divalent (Ca2+, Mg2+) cations to bovine alpha-lactalbumin at 20 and 37 degrees C has been studied by means of intrinsic protein fluorescence. The values of apparent binding constants for these ions obtained at 37 degrees C are about one order of magnitude lower than those measured at 20 degrees C. Urea and alkali (pH greater than 10) induce unfolding transitions which involve stable partially unfolded intermediates for all metal ion-bound forms of alpha-lactalbumin. Heating induces similar partially unfolded states. Nevertheless, the partially unfolded states induced by heating, urea, alkaline or acidic treatments are somewhat different in their tryptophan residue environment properties. The results have been interpreted in terms of a simple scheme of equilibria between metal-free and metal-bound forms in their native, partially unfolded and unfolded states. The scheme provides an approach to the quantitative interpretation of any transition equilibrium shift induced by a low molecular mass species able to be bound by a protein.     

Amyloid fibril formation can proceed from different conformations of a partially unfolded protein

Protein misfolding and aggregation are interconnected processes involved in a wide variety of nonneuropathic, systemic, and neurodegenerative diseases. More generally, if mutations in sequence or changes in environmental conditions lead to partial unfolding of the native state of a protein, it will often aggregate, sometimes into well-defined fibrillar structures. A great deal of interest has been directed at discovering the characteristic features of metastable partially unfolded states that precede the aggregated states of proteins. In this work, human muscle acylphosphatase (AcP) has been first destabilized, by addition of urea or by means of elevated temperatures, and then incubated in the presence of different concentrations of 2,2,2, trifluoroethanol ranging from 5% to 25% (v/v). The results show that AcP is able to form both fibrillar and nonfibrillar aggregates with a high beta-sheet content from partially unfolded states with very different structural features. Moreover, the presence of alpha-helical structure in such a state does not appear to be a fundamental determinant of the ability to aggregate. The lack of ready aggregation under some of the conditions examined here is attributable primarily to the intrinsic properties of the solutions rather than to specific structural features of the partially unfolded states that precede aggregation. Aggregation appears to be favored when the solution conditions promote stable intermolecular interactions, particularly hydrogen bonds. In addition, the structures of the resulting aggregates are largely independent of the conformational properties of their soluble precursors.     

Thermostability of irreversible unfolding alpha-amylases analyzed by unfolding kinetics

For most multidomain proteins the thermal unfolding transitions are accompanied by an irreversible step, often related to aggregation at elevated temperatures. As a consequence the analysis of thermostabilities in terms of equilibrium thermodynamics is not applicable, at least not if the irreversible process is fast with respect the structural unfolding transition. In a comparative study we investigated aggregation effects and unfolding kinetics for five homologous alpha-amylases, all from mesophilic sources but with rather different thermostabilities. The results indicate that for all enzymes the irreversible process is fast and the precedent unfolding transition is the rate-limiting step. In this case the kinetic barrier toward unfolding, as measured by unfolding rates as function of temperature, is the key feature in thermostability. The investigated enzymes exhibit activation energies (E(a)) between 208 and 364 kJmol(-1) and pronounced differences in the corresponding unfolding rates. The most thermostable alpha-amylase from Bacillus licheniformis (apparent transition temperature, T(1/2) approximately 100 degrees C) shows an unfolding rate which is four orders of magnitude smaller as compared with the alpha-amylase from pig pancreas (T(1/2) approximately 65 degrees C). Even with respect to two other alpha-amylases from Bacillus species (T(1/2) approximately 86 degrees C) the difference in unfolding rates is still two orders of magnitude.     

Comparative Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy study of cold-, pressure-, and heat-induced unfolding and aggregation of myoglobin

We studied the cold unfolding of myoglobin with Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and compared it with pressure and heat unfolding. Because protein aggregation is a phenomenon with medical as well as biotechnological implications, we were interested in both the structural changes as well as the aggregation behavior of the respective unfolded states. The cold- and pressure-induced unfolding both yield a partially unfolded state characterized by a persistent amount of secondary structure, in which a stable core of G and H helices is preserved. In this respect the cold- and pressure-unfolded states show a resemblance with an early folding intermediate of myoglobin. In contrast, the heat unfolding results in the formation of the infrared bands typical of intermolecular antiparallel beta-sheet aggregation. This implies a transformation of alpha-helix into intermolecular beta-sheet. H/2H-exchange data suggest that the helices are first unfolded and then form intermolecular beta-sheets. The pressure and cold unfolded states do not give rise to the intermolecular aggregation bands that are typical for the infrared spectra of many heat-unfolded proteins. This suggests that the pathways of the cold and pressure unfolding are substantially different from that of the heat unfolding. After return to ambient conditions the cold- or pressure-treated proteins adopt a partially refolded conformation. This aggregates at a lower temperature (32 degrees C) than the native state (74 degrees C).     

Acid denaturation of recombinant porcine growth hormone: formation and self-association of folding intermediates

We have investigated the conformational changes incurred during the acid-induced unfolding and self-association of recombinant porcine growth hormone (pGH). Acidification (pH 8 to pH 2) of pGH resulted in intrinsic fluorescence, UV absorbance, and near-UV CD transitions centered at pH 4.10. At pH 2.0, a red shift in the fluorescence emission maximum of approximately 3 nm and a 15% loss of the far-UV CD signal at 222 nm imply that the protein did not become extensively unfolded. Acidification in the presence of 4 M urea resulted in similar pH-dependent transitions. However, these occurred at a higher pH (approximately 5.2). At pH 2.0 + 4 M urea, an 8 nm red shift in the fluorescence emission maximum suggests that unfolding was greater than in the absence of urea. The presence of a prominent peak centered at 298 nm in the near-UV CD spectrum, which is absent without urea, signifies further differences in the intermediates generated at pH 2. Sedimentation equilibrium experiments in the analytical ultracentrifuge showed that native pGH and the partially unfolded intermediates reversibly self-associate. Self-association was strongly promoted at pH 2 while urea reduced self-association at both pH 8 and pH 2. These results demonstrate that acidification of pGH in the absence or presence of 4 M urea induced the formation of molten globule-like states with measurable differences in conformation. Similarities and differences in these structural conformations with respect to other growth hormones are discussed.     

Concomitant Raman spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering for characterization of therapeutic proteins at high concentrations

A Raman spectrometer and dynamic light scattering system were combined in a single platform (Raman–DLS) to provide concomitant higher order structural and hydrodynamic size data for therapeutic proteins at high concentration. As model therapeutic proteins, we studied human serum albumin (HSA) and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG). HSA concentration and temperature interval during heating did not affect the onset temperatures for conformation perturbation or aggregation. The impact of pH on thermal stability of HSA was tested at pHs 3, 5, and 8. Stability was the greatest at pH 8, but distinct unfolding and aggregation behaviors were observed at the different pHs. HSA structural transitions and aggregation kinetics were also studied in real time during isothermal incubations at pH 7. In a forced oxidation study, it was found that hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) treatment reduced the thermal stability of HSA. Finally, the structure and thermal stability of IVIG were studied, and a comprehensive characterization of heating-induced structural perturbations and aggregation was obtained. In conclusion, by providing comprehensive data on protein tertiary and secondary structures and hydrodynamic size during real-time heating or isothermal incubation experiments, the Raman–DLS system offers unique physical insights into the properties of high-concentration protein samples.     

Structure of stable protein folding intermediates by equilibrium phi-analysis: the apoflavodoxin thermal intermediate

Protein intermediates in equilibrium with native states may play important roles in protein dynamics but, in cases, can initiate harmful aggregation events. Investigating equilibrium protein intermediates is thus important for understanding protein behaviour (useful or pernicious) but it is hampered by difficulties in gathering structural information. We show here that the phi-analysis techniques developed to investigate transition states of protein folding can be extended to determine low-resolution three-dimensional structures of protein equilibrium intermediates. The analysis proposed is based solely on equilibrium data and is illustrated by determination of the structure of the apoflavodoxin thermal unfolding intermediate. In this conformation, a large part of the protein remains close to natively folded, but a 40 residue region is clearly unfolded. This structure is fully consistent with the NMR data gathered on an apoflavodoxin mutant designed specifically to stabilise the intermediate. The structure shows that the folded region of the intermediate is much larger than the proton slow-exchange core at 25 degrees C. It also reveals that the unfolded region is made of elements whose packing surface is more polar than average. In addition, it constitutes a useful guide to rationally stabilise the native state relative to the intermediate state, a far from trivial task.     

Thermodynamic features of the chemical and thermal denaturations of human serum albumin

The unfolding process of human serum albumin between pH 5.4 and 9.9 was studied by chemical and thermal denaturations. The experimental results showed that there is no correlation between the stability of albumin at different pH values determined by both methods. The free energy change of unfolding versus concentration of guanidine showed a close dependence on the pH, suggesting that the variation of the electrical charge of albumin influences the final state of the unfolded form of the protein. Spectroscopic techniques, such as native fluorescence of the protein and circular dichroism, demonstrated that the unfolded state of the protein obtained from both methods possesses a different helical content. The solvophobic effect and the entropy of the chains have no influence on the final unfolding state when the protein is unfolded by thermal treatment, while, when the protein is unfolded by chemical denaturants, both effects depend on the medium pH. The results indicate that guanidine and urea interact with albumin by electrostatic forces, yielding a randomly coiled conformation in its unfolded state, while thermal denaturation produces a molten globule state and the aggregation of the protein; therefore, both methods yield different structurally unfolded states of the albumin.     

Thermal dissociation and unfolding of insulin

The thermal stability of human insulin was studied by differential scanning microcalorimetry and near-UV circular dichroism as a function of zinc/protein ratio, to elucidate the dissociation and unfolding processes of insulin in different association states. Zinc-free insulin, which is primarily dimeric at room temperature, unfolded at approximately 70 degrees C. The two monomeric insulin mutants Asp(B28) and Asp(B9),Glu(B27) unfolded at higher temperatures, but with enthalpies of unfolding that were approximately 30% smaller. Small amounts of zinc caused a biphasic thermal denaturation pattern of insulin. The biphasic denaturation is caused by a redistribution of zinc ions during the heating process and results in two distinct transitions with T(m)'s of approximately 70 and approximately 87 degrees C corresponding to monomer/dimer and hexamer, respectively. At high zinc concentrations (>or=5 Zn(2+) ions/hexamer), only the hexamer transition is observed. The results of this study show that the thermal stability of insulin is closely linked to the association state and that the zinc hexamer remains stable at much higher temperatures than the monomer. This is in contrast to studies with chemical denaturants where it has been shown that monomer unfolding takes place at much higher denaturant concentrations than the dissociation of higher oligomers [Ahmad, A., et al. (2004) J. Biol. Chem. 279, 14999-15013].     

Resolving multiple protein conformers in equilibrium unfolding reactions: a time-resolved emission spectroscopic (TRES) study of Azurin

Unlike steady-state spectrofluorimetry, time-resolved emission spectroscopy (TRES) can resolve emissions from fluorophores with similar quantum yields and overlapping steady-state emission spectra. Time-resolved emission studies of the protein-intrinsic fluorophore, tryptophan (Trp), can thus potentially be used to examine protein conformational heterogeneity in solution, as well as to investigate the existence of populated intermediate structural states in equilibrium unfolding reactions of single-tryptophan proteins. Here, the single-Trp copper protein, azurin, is examined in various concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride (GdnCl) with its disulphide bond in an intact state. Interestingly, multiple envelopes of Trp emission are observed in all TRES spectra acquired, instead of just two emission envelopes (corresponding to the native and unfolded states) expected from two-state unfolding. These envelopes appear to be centred around the same set of emission wavelengths in different TRES spectra, and only intensities and decay rates vary with the concentration of denaturant used. This suggests that structural states representing different levels of exposure of Trp to the aqueous solvent might, in fact, be populated at equilibrium during the unfolding of azurin by GdnCl.     

Exploiting the Link between Protein Rigidity and Thermostability for Data‐Driven Protein Engineering

Understanding and exploiting the relationship between microscopic structure and macroscopic stability is important for developing strategies to improve protein stability at high temperatures. The thermostability of proteins has been repeatedly linked to an enhanced structural rigidity of the folded native state. In the current study, the rigidity of protein structures from mesophilic and thermophilic organisms along a thermal unfolding trajectory is directly probed. In order to perform this, protein structures were modeled as constraint networks, and the rigidity in these networks was quantified using the Floppy Inclusion and Rigid Substructure Topography (FIRST) method. During the thermal unfolding, a phase transition was observed that defines the rigidity percolation threshold and corresponds to the folded‐unfolded transition in protein folding. Using concepts from percolation theory and network science, a higher phase transition temperature was observed for ca. two‐thirds of the proteins from thermophilic organisms compared to their mesophilic counterparts, when applied to a data set of 20 pairs of homologues. From both the analysis of the microstructure of the constraint networks and monitoring the macroscopic behavior during the thermal unfolding, direct evidence was found for the “corresponding states” concept, which states that mesophilic and thermophilic enzymes are in corresponding states of similar flexibility at their respective optimal temperature. Finally, the current approach facilitated the identification of structural features from which a destabilization of the structure originates upon thermal unfolding. These predictions show a good agreement with the experimental data. Therefore, the information might be exploited in data‐driven protein engineering by pointing to residues that should be varied to obtain a protein with higher thermostability.     

Comparison of heat- and pressure-induced unfolding of ribonuclease a: the critical role of Phe46 which appears to belong to a new hydrophobic chain-folding initiation site

To clarify the structural role of Phe46 inside the hydrophobic core of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A), thermal and pressure unfolding of wild-type RNase A and three mutant forms (F46V, F46E, and F46K) were analyzed by fourth-derivative UV absorbance spectroscopy. All the mutants, as well as the wild type, exhibited a two-state transition during both thermal and pressure unfolding, and both T(m) and P(m) decreased markedly when Phe46 was replaced with valine, glutamic acid, or lysine. The strongest effect was on the F46K mutant and the weakest on F46V. Both unfolding processes produced identical blue shifts in the fourth-derivative spectra, indicating that the tyrosine residues are similarly exposed in the temperature- and pressure-induced unfolded states. A comparison of Gibbs free energies determined from the pressure and temperature unfoldings, however, gave DeltaG(p)/DeltaG(t) ratios (r) of 1.7 for the wild type and 0.92 +/- 0.03 for the mutants. Furthermore, the DeltaV value for each mutant was larger than that for the wild type. CD spectra and activity measurements showed no obvious major structural differences in the folded state, indicating that the structures of the Phe46 mutants and wild type differ in the unfolded state. We propose a model in which Phe46 stabilizes the hydrophobic core at the boundary between two structural domains. Mutation of Phe46 decreases protein stability by weakening the unfolding cooperativity between these domains. This essential function of Phe46 in RNase A stability indicates that it belongs to a chain-folding initiation site.     

Abstracts: Albany 2007, The 15th Conversation

Abstract

Forty nine molecular dynamics simulations of unfolding trajectories of the segment B1 of streptococcal protein G (GB1) provide a direct demonstration of the diversity of unfolding pathway and give a statistically utmost unfolding pathway under the physical property space. Twelve physical properties of the protein were chosen to construct a 12-dimensional property space. Then the 12-dimentional property space was reduced to a 3-dimentional principle component property space. Under the property space, the multiple unfolding trajectories look like “trees”, which have some common characters. The “root of the tree” corresponds to the native state, the “bole” homologizes the partially unfolded conformations, and the “crown” is in correspondence to the unfolded state. These unfolding trajectories can be divided into three types. The first one has the characters of straight “bole” and “crown” corresponding to a fast two-state unfolding pathway of GB1. The second one has the character of “the standstill in the middle tree bole”, which may correspond to a three-state unfolding pathway. The third one has the character of “the circuitous bole” corresponding to a slow two-state unfolding pathway. The fast two-state unfolding pathway is a statistically utmost unfolding pathway or preferred pathway of GB1, which occupies 53% of 49 unfolding trajectories. In the property space all the unfolding trajectories construct a thermal unfolding pathway ensemble of GB1. The unfolding pathway ensemble resembles a funnel that is gradually emanative from the native state ensemble to the unfolded state ensemble. In the property space, the thermal unfolded state distribution looks like electronic cloud in quantum mechanics. The unfolded states of the independent unfolding simulation trajectories have substantial overlaps, indicating that the thermal unfolded states are confined by the physical property values, and the number of protein unfolded state are much less than that was believed before.     

Detection and characterization of partially unfolded oligomers of the SH3 domain of alpha-spectrin

For the purpose of equilibrium and kinetic folding-unfolding studies, the SH3 domain of alpha-spectrin (spc-SH3) has long been considered a classic two-state folding protein. In this work we have indeed observed that the thermal unfolding curves of spc-SH3 measured at pH 3.0 by differential scanning calorimetry, circular dichroism, and NMR follow apparently the two-state model when each unfolding profile is considered individually. Nevertheless, we have found that protein concentration has a marked effect upon the thermal unfolding profiles. This effect cannot be properly explained in terms of the two-state unfolding model and can only be interpreted in terms of the accumulation of intermediate associated states in equilibrium with the monomeric native and unfolded states. By chemical cross-linking and pulsed-field gradient NMR diffusion experiments we have been able to confirm the existence of associated states formed during spc-SH3 unfolding. A three-state model, in which a dimeric intermediate state is assumed to be significantly populated, provides the simplest interpretation of the whole set of thermal unfolding data and affords a satisfactory explanation for the concentration effects observed. Whereas at low concentrations the population of the associated intermediate state is negligible and the unfolding process consequently takes place in a two-state fashion, at concentrations above approximately 0.5 mM the population of the intermediate state becomes significant at temperatures between 45 degrees C and 80 degrees C and reaches up to 50% at the largest concentration investigated. The thermodynamic properties of the intermediate state implied by this analysis fall in between those of the unfolded state and the native ones, indicating a considerably disordered conformation, which appears to be stabilized by oligomerization.     

Study of multiple unfolding trajectories and unfolded states of the protein GB1 under the physical property space

Forty nine molecular dynamics simulations of unfolding trajectories of the segment B1 of streptococcal protein G (GB1) provide a direct demonstration of the diversity of unfolding pathway and give a statistically utmost unfolding pathway under the physical property space. Twelve physical properties of the protein were chosen to construct a 12-dimensional property space. Then the 12-dimensional property space was reduced to a 3-dimensional principle component property space. Under the property space, the multiple unfolding trajectories look like "trees", which have some common characters. The "root of the tree" corresponds to the native state, the "bole" homologizes the partially unfolded conformations, and the "crown" is in correspondence to the unfolded state. These unfolding trajectories can be divided into three types. The first one has the characters of straight "bole" and "crown" corresponding to a fast two-state unfolding pathway of GB1. The second one has the character of "the standstill in the middle tree bole", which may correspond to a three-state unfolding pathway. The third one has the character of "the circuitous bole" corresponding to a slow two-state unfolding pathway. The fast two-state unfolding pathway is a statistically utmost unfolding pathway or preferred pathway of GB1, which occupies 53% of 49 unfolding trajectories. In the property space all the unfolding trajectories construct a thermal unfolding pathway ensemble of GB1. The unfolding pathway ensemble resembles a funnel that is gradually emanative from the native state ensemble to the unfolded state ensemble. In the property space, the thermal unfolded state distribution looks like electronic cloud in quantum mechanics. The unfolded states of the independent unfolding simulation trajectories have substantial overlaps, indicating that the thermal unfolded states are confined by the physical property values, and the number of protein unfolded state are much less than that was believed before.