Characterization of Two Sibling Species of the Genus Stylonychia (Ciliata,Hypotricha): S. mytilus Ehrenberg, 1838 and S. lemnae n. sp. II. Biochemical Characterization1

The two closely related hypotrichous ciliate species, Stylonychia lemnae and S. mytilus, have been compared with respect to their isoenzyme patterns, their macronuclear DNA banding patterns, and micronuclear DNA banding patterns after restriction enzyme digestion. Since macronuclear DNA contains mainly protein-coding sequences and since the micronuclear DNA patterns represent mainly the repetitive fraction of the genome, these results, together with the isoenzyme patterns, reflect differences on three different levels of molecular evolution between morphologically very similar species. Each of the three methods allows an unequivocal identification of each of the two species. Intraspecific variation seems to be greatest among the repetitive sequences of the micronuclear genomes. By using the isoenzyme data and the formula of Nei (19) the genetic distance between the two species is calculated and compared with the results from other protozoa and different Drosophila species. Despite their morphological similarity, the two species show a considerable amount of evolutionary divergence on the three molecular levels which have been investigated.     

Large scale synchronous mating and the study of macronuclear development in Euplotes crassus

After conjugation in hypotrichous ciliates, a new macronucleus is produced from a copy of the micronucleus. This transformation involves large-scale reorganization of DNA, with conversion of the chromosomal micronuclear genome into short, gene-sized DNA molecules in the macronucleus. To study directly the changes that occur during this process, we have developed techniques for synchronous mating of large populations of the hypotrichous ciliate Euplotes crassus. Electron microscope studies show that the micronuclear chromosomes are polytenized during the first 20 h of macronuclear development. The polytene chromosomes lack the band-interband organization observed in other hypotrichs and in the Diptera. Polytenization is followed by transectioning of the chromosomes. We isolated DNA at various times of macronuclear development and found that the average molecular weight of the DNA decreases at the time of chromosome transectioning. In addition, we have shown that a small size group of macronuclear DNA molecules (450-550 base pairs) is excised from the chromosomal DNA approximately 10 h later in macronuclear development.     

Macronuclear gene-sized molecules of hypotrichs.

The macronuclear genome of hypotrichous ciliates consists of DNA molecules of gene-sized length. A macronuclear DNA molecule contains a single coding region. We have analyzed the many hypotrich macronuclear DNA sequences sequenced by us and others. No highly conserved promoter sequences nor replication initiation sequences have been identified in the 5' nor in the 3' non-translated regions, suggesting that promoter function in hypotrichs may differ from other eukaryotes. The macronuclear genes are intron-poor; approximately 19% of the genes sequenced to date have one to three introns. Not all macronuclear DNA molecules may be transcribed; some macronuclear molecules may not have any coding function. Codon bias in hypotrichs is different in many respects from other ciliates and from other eukaryotes.     

Invention and Mystery in Hypotrich DNA1

ABSTRACT “The capacity to blunder slightly is the real marvel of DNA. Without this special attribute, we would still be anaerobic bacteria and there would be no music.” Lewis Thomas³ Hypotrichs have evolved extraordinary ways of organizing, manipulating, and replicating the DNA in their micronuclear and macronuclear genomes. Short macronuclear DNA molecules containing single genes are created by excision from chromosomes, accompanied by massive elimination of the germline DNA sequences between genes. Germline genes themselves are interrupted by multiple noncoding segments called internal eliminated segments, or IESs, that divide genes into multiple macronuclear-destined segments, or MDSs. The functional significance of this organization is unknown. Over evolutionary time IESs accumulate mutations rapidly are inserted into or excised from genes, and shift position along DNA molecules. MDSs are ligated to create functional genes when IESs are spliced out of micronuclear DNA during macronuclear development. MDSs in some germline genes are in scrambled disorder and become unscrambled in association with IES elimination. Replication of DNA in the macronucleus is accomplished by organization of replication enzymes and factors into a structure that sweeps through the macronucleus to replicate the many millions of gene-sized DNA molecules. The significance of many of the bizarre DNA phenomena in the evolutionary/functional success of hypotrichs is still unclear.     

Characterization of macronuclear DNA in five species of ciliates

Macronuclear DNA of four hypotrichous and one holotrichous ciliate species was characterized by biochemical techniques. The renaturation kinetics of the macronuclear DNAs of all five species were similar. Repetitive sequences occur only in an amount below 2%. Although the DNA content of the macronuclei of the species differs considerably, the kinetic complexity of the macronuclear DNA is rather uniform (around 3 × 10¹⁰ daltons, i.e., 4–11 x the E. coli genome). Only in the macronuclei of the hypotrichous species the DNA exists as gene-sized fragments.Dedicated to Professor W. Beermann on the occasion of his 60th birthday     

Genome gymnastics: unique modes of DNA evolution and processing in ciliates

In some ciliates, the DNA sequences of the germline genomes have been profoundly modified during evolution, providing unprecedented examples of germline DNA malleability. Although the significance of the modifications and malleability is unclear, they may reflect the evolution of mechanisms that facilitate evolution. Because of the modifications, these ciliates must perform remarkable feats of cutting, splicing, rearrangement and elimination of DNA sequences to convert the chromosomal DNA in the germline genome (micronuclear genome) into gene-sized DNA molecules in the somatic genome (macronuclear genome). How these manipulations of DNA are guided and carried out is largely unknown. However, the organization and manipulation of ciliate DNA sequences are new phenomena that expand a general appreciation for the flexibility of DNA in evolution and development.     

Overamplification of genes in macronuclei of hypotrichous ciliates

The macronuclei of hypotrichous ciliates contain gene-sized DNA molecules. The copy number of individual gene-sized pieces is species-specific and different for different genes. Some strains of different hypotrichous ciliate species show an overamplification of one or a few individual gene-sized pieces in the macronucleus. The results of crossing experiments show that this relative overrepresentation of certain sequences is an inherent genetic property of the strain. The copy number increases with the age of the strain. Overamplified sequences may display sequence heterogeneity as revealed by restriction endonuclease digestion. They are transcribed into mRNA and seem, therefore, to code for proteins. However, no function related to these genes could be detected. The sequences that are overamplified in one strain do not crosshybridize with overamplified sequences in another strain. Possible mechanisms of overamplification are discussed in the context of gene amplification in eucaryotic cells.     

A simple and rapid PCR-based method to isolate complete small macronuclear minichromosomes from hypotrich ciliates: 5S rDNA and S26 ribosomal protein gene of Oxytricha (Sterkiella) nova

Hypotrich ciliates present a macronuclear genome consisting of gene-sized instead of chromosome-sized DNA molecules. Exploiting this unique eukaryotic genome feature, we introduce, for the first time in ciliates, a rapid and easy PCR method using telomeric primers to isolate small complete macronuclear DNA molecules or minichromosomes. Two presumably abundant macronuclear DNA molecules, containing ribosomal genes, were amplified from the Oxytricha (Sterkiella) nova complete genome after using this method, and then were cloned and sequenced. The 5S rDNA sequence of O. (S.) nova is the third one reported among hypotrich ciliates; its primary and secondary structure is compared with other eukaryotic 5S rRNAs. The ribosomal protein S26 gene is the first one reported among ciliates. This "End-End-PCR" method might be useful to obtain similar gene-sized macronuclear molecules from other hypotrich ciliates, and, therefore, to increase our knowledge on ribosomal genes in these eukaryotic microorganisms.     

Low molecular weight DNA in the heteromeric macronuclei of two cyrtophorid ciliates

Summary— The size range of the native DNA molecules in the heteromeric macronuclei of two cyrtophorid ciliates (Trithigmostoma cucullulus, Chilodonella uncinata) was mainly investigated by using agarose gel electrophoresis. Numerous bands superimposed on a continuous spectrum of molecular sizes between about 0.35 kb and 30 kb were resolved by conventional electrophoresis. Species-specific banding patterns indicate a variation between species in the copy number of individual DNA fragments. A slight intra-specific variability of banding patterns can exist. Electrophoretic distributions for two strains of T cucullulus were indeed found to differ by at least one more intense band (‘overamplified’ sequences?). Fractionation by contour-clamped homogeneous electric field (CHEF) gel electrophoresis revealed that the size continum of macronuclear DNA molecules does not extend beyond 60–70 kb. The average size was estimated to be around 4 kb. Unresolved DNA fraction (> 1000 kb) accounted for less than 10% of the mass of cellular DNA entering CHEF gels. Macronuclear ribosomal DNA of each cyrtophorid species was identified by Southern hybridization with a Tetrahymena rDNA probe. The hybridization signal was observed on a single band of low molecular weight DNA. The corresponding size was close to 14.5 kb in Trithigmostoma and 15.5 kb in Chilodonella, which is about twice the size of monomeric rDNA in hypotrichous ciliates. We showed that S1 nuclease resistant duplexes wit half the length of the native rDNA can be formed by rapid renaturation of heat-denatured molecules and hybridized with native rDNA. This strongly suggests that the nucleotide sequence of this rDNA is a large palindrome. Unlike the hypotrichs, macronuclear rDNA in cyrtophorids should be organized into palindromic dimers as in Tetrahymena species.     

Chromosome organization and gene expansion in the highly fragmented genome of the ciliate Strombidium stylifer

Chromosomes are well-organized carriers of genetic information in eukaryotes and are usually quite long, carrying hundreds and thousands of genes. Intriguingly, a clade of single-celled ciliates, Spirotrichea, feature nanochromosomes—also called “gene-sized chromosomes”. These chromosomes predominantly carry only one gene, flanked by short telomere sequences. However, the organization and copy number variation of the chromosomes in these highly fragmented genomes remain unexplored in many groups of Spirotrichea, including the marine Strombidium. Using deep genome sequencing, we assembled the macronuclear genome of Strombidium stylifer into more than 18,000 nanochromosomes (~2.4 Kb long on average). Our results show that S. stylifer occupies an intermediate position during the evolutionary history of Strombidium lineage and experienced significant expansions in several gene families related to guanyl ribonucleotide binding. Based on the nucleotide distribution bias analysis and conserved motifs search in non-genic regions, we found that the subtelomeric regions have a conserved adenine-thymine (AT)-rich sequence motif. We also found that the copy number of nanochromosomes lacks precise regulation. This work sheds light on the unique features of chromosome structure in eukaryotes with highly fragmented genomes and reveals that a rather specialized evolutionary strategy at the genomic level has resulted in great diversity within the ciliated lineages.     

Replication forms of the gene-sized DNA molecules of hypotrichous ciliates.

Using a method for obtaining DNA from 10 to 40 macronuclei for electron microscopy, we analyzed the structure of gene-sized, linear DNA molecules from S-phase macronuclei of two hypotrichous ciliates, Euplotes eurystomus and Styx sp. Three types of putative replicating intermediates were observed: (i) molecules with a bubble close to one end, (ii) molecules with single forks, and (iii) molecules with two forks. We conclude that: (i) each macronuclear DNA molecule replicates as an independent unit, (ii) the molecules contain an origin of replication close to one or both ends, and (iii) the mode of replication is bidirectional.     

A Simple and Rapid PCR-based Method to Isolate Complete Small Macronuclear Minichromosomes from Hypotrich Ciliates: 5S rDNA and S26 Ribosomal Protein Gene of Oxytricha (Sterkiella) nova

Hypotrich ciliates present a macronuclear genome consisting of gene-sized instead of chromosome-sized DNA molecules. Exploiting this unique eukaryotic genome feature, we introduce, for the first time in ciliates, a rapid and easy PCR method using telomeric primers to isolate small complete macronuclear DNA molecules or minichromosomes. Two presumably abundant macronuclear DNA molecules, containing ribosomal genes, were amplified from the Oxytricha (Sterkiella) nova complete genome after using this method, and then were cloned and sequenced. The 5S rDNA sequence of O. (S.) nova is the third one reported among hypotrich ciliates; its primary and secondary structure is compared with other eukaryotic 5S rRNAs. The ribosomal protein S26 gene is the first one reported among ciliates. This “End-End-PCR” method might be useful to obtain similar gene-sized macronuclear molecules from other hypotrich ciliates, and, therefore, to increase our knowledge on ribosomal genes in these eukaryotic microorganisms.     

Alternative use of chromosome fragmentation sites in the ciliated protozoan Oxytricha nova.

During its life cycle, the hypotrichous ciliated protozoan Oxytricha nova transforms a copy of its micronucleus, which contains chromosome-sized DNA, into a macronucleus containing linear, gene-sized DNA molecules. A region of the micronuclear genome has been defined that gives rise to two distinct macronuclear DNA molecules during development. Through analysis of recombinant macronuclear and micronuclear clones, the generation of the two macronuclear DNA molecules was shown to be the result of alternative use of chromosome fragmentation sites. In addition, evidence was obtained that adjacent micronuclear precursors of macronuclear DNA molecules can overlap by a few base pairs. The significance of these findings in relation to developmental chromosome fragmentation is discussed.     

Evidence of Extensive Fragmentation of Macronuclear DNA in Two Non-Hypotrichous Ciliates

ABSTRACT. Total cellular DNA from the ciliates Halteria grandinella and Trithigmostoma cucullulus was analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis. The macronuclear DNA (MAC DNA) of Halteria consisted of very small fragments, which suggests that the MAC DNA organization of oligotrichs resembles that of hypotrichs (gene-sized DNA). The MAC DNA of Trithigmostoma , a cyrtophorid having a heteromeric MAC, also existed as small fragments, but with a significant fraction (20–30%) comprising larger molecules unresolved by the method used. It is suggested that MAC heteromery is related to the differential localization of two kinds of DNA molecules of different sizes.     

Evolution of the Germline Actin Gene in Hypotrichous Ciliates: Multiple Nonscrambled IESs at Extremely Conserved Locations in Two Urostylids

In hypotrichous ciliates, macronuclear chromosomes are gene‐sized, and micronuclear genes contain short, noncoding internal eliminated segments (IESs) as well as macronuclear‐destined segments (MDSs). In the present study, we characterized the complete macronuclear gene and two to three types of micronuclear actin genes of two urostylid species, i.e. Pseudokeronopsis rubra and Uroleptopsis citrina. Our results show that (1) the gain/loss of IES happens frequently in the subclass Hypotrichia (formerly Stichotrichia), and high fragmentation of germline genes does not imply for gene scrambling; and (2) the micronuclear actin gene is scrambled in the order Sporadotrichida but nonscrambled in the orders Urostylida and Stichotrichida, indicating the independent evolution of MIC‐actin gene patterns in different orders of hypotrichs; (3) locations of MDS–IES junctions of micronuclear actin gene in coding regions are conserved among closely related species.     

Organization of the Euplotes crassus micronuclear genome

Euplotes crassus, like other hypotrichous ciliated protozoa, eliminates most of its micronuclear chromosomal DNA in the process of forming the small linear DNA molecules that comprise the macronuclear genome. By characterizing randomly selected lambda phage clones of E. crassus micronuclear DNA, we have determined the distribution of repetitive and unique sequences and the arrangement of macronuclear genes relative to eliminated DNA. This allows us to compare the E. crassus micronuclear genome organization to that of another distantly related hypotrichous ciliate, Oxytricha nova. The clones from E. crassus segregate into three prevalent classes: those containing primarily eliminated repetitive DNA (Class I); those containing macronuclear genes in addition to repetitive sequences (Class II); and those containing only eliminated unique sequence DNA (Class III). All of the repetitive sequences in these clones belong to the same highly abundant repetitive element family. Our results demonstrate that the sequence organization of the E. crassus and O. nova micronuclear genomes is related in that the macronuclear genes are clustered together in the micronuclear genome and the eliminated unique sequences occur in long stretches that are uninterrupted by repetitive sequences. In both organisms a single repetitive element family comprises the majority of the eliminated interspersed middle repetitive DNA and appears to be preferentially associated with the macronuclear sequence clusters. The similarities in the sequence organization in these two organisms suggest that clustering of macronuclear genes plays a role in the chromosome fragmentation process.