An embryological study ofPlatanthera bifolia (Orchidaceae)

Flowers ofPlatanthera bifolia were hand-pollinated and fixed in FPA₅₀ after 2, 5, 7, 14, and 21 days. Ovules, made transparent in Herr's clearing fluid, were investigated using confocal scanning laser microscopy. Pollination initiates the megasporogenesis. Two days after pollination dyads are frequent. Three days later most embryo sacs contain two nuclei. Seven days after pollination the embryo sacs are 4–8-nucleate and some are organized, and a week later all embryo sacs are organized and fertilization takes place. The embryo sac development follows thePolygonum type. Twenty-one days after pollination the egg nuclei have been fertilized and the embryo sacs contain 2- to many-celled embryos. A suspensor is formed during early stages of embryo development but degenerates later. Fertilization of the central nucleus does not lead to endosperm development.     

Nuclear DNA amount during sporogenesis and gametogenesis in sexual and aposporous buffelgrass

Nuclear DNA amounts (C values) were measured in Feulgen-stained sections of anthers and ovules of sexual plant B-2s (genotype aaaa) and aposporous cultivar Higgins (genotype AAaa) of buffelgrass (Pennisetum ciliare). The mass of the unreplicated nuclear genome of a gamete equals 1C DNA. In both lines, pollen mother cell nuclei were 4C before leptotene; anther wall, dyad, 1-nucleate pollen, and generative cell nuclei were 2C; microspore tetrad, enlarging microspore, and sperm nuclei were 1C. The tapetum persisted as uninucleate cells with 4C DNA. Archespores (2-4C) of both lines initiated meiosis to form megaspore tetrad nuclei with 1-2C DNA. In B-2s, chalazal megaspores (2-4C) formed reduced 8-nucleate Polygonum type embryo sacs, and sacs at 2- and 4-nucleate stages showed distributions with peaks near C1 and C2, corresponding to G1 and G2 cell cycle phases; this is characteristic of active mitosis. Nuclei of 8-nucleate sacs and of eggs and polars were 1C, indicating chromosomes were not duplicated before fertilization. Antipodal nuclei had levels from 1 to 36C, possibly due to polyteny or endopolyploidy. In Higgins, aposporous initials and 2-nucleate embryo sacs showed bimodal distributions of 2n nuclei with peaks at 2C and 4C DNA. Nuclei of newly formed 4-nucleate Panicum type aposporous sacs and of polars were 2C; aposporous eggs stained too faintly for reliable measurement.Names of products are included for the benefit of the reader and do not imply endorsement or preferential treatment by USDA     

EFFECTS OF SPACE FLIGHT (BIOSATELLITE II) AND RADIATION ON FEMALE GAMETOPHYTE DEVELOPMENT IN TRADESCANTIA

The mode of female gametophyte development and the cytological effects of orbital flight factors, with and without radiation, on embryo sac development were studied in Tradescantia clone 02 flown in Biosatellite II. One package of 32 rooted inflorescences was exposed during the free-flight phase of the two-day orbital flight to about 220 R gamma radiation from an ⁸⁵Sr source, and a nonirradiated package was flown as a flight control. Two similar packages, one irradiated and one unirradiated, were maintained in a ground-based vehicle as concurrent nonflight controls. Various postflight ground experiments were conducted in an attempt to associate with specific flight factors the effects observed in the orbited plants. Mature ovaries were fixed daily as the flowers opened for at least 20 days after the treatment, sectioned, stained, and analyzed for the rate of embryo sac abortion and other developmental abnormalities. The embryo sac in Tradescantia clone 02 is eight-nucleate with a Polygonum type of development. Irradiation during megasporogenesis produced an increased rate of embryo sac abortion and this radiation effect was greater in the environment of the flight vehicle than in the nonflight vehicle. This effect may be due to an increase in concentration of ethylene in the flight vehicle. A synergism between some undetermined flight factor and radiation was found to produce underdeveloped embryo sacs. Malfunctioning of the spindle, most probably due to free flight, was evidenced by the increased number of embryo sacs with misoriented nuclei.     

Fertilization in maize indeterminate gametophyte1 mutant

Summary. Mature embryo sacs of the maize mutant indeterminate gametophyte1 displayed different cellular patterns compared to those of the wild type. About 40% of the ig1 embryo sacs contained three or more synergids and two or more egg cells at the micropylar end. During fertilization in embryo sacs with two synergids, both of them frequently degenerated and were penetrated by two pollen tubes. 75% of the embryo sacs containing three or more synergid cells were penetrated by two or more pollen tubes, although most of them had only one degenerated synergid. Multiple fusions between the sperm cells and eggs frequently occurred in the same embryo sac, which subsequently generated multiple embryos. There were two or more central cells in about 33% of ig1 embryo sacs. The largest central cell was usually adjacent to the egg apparatus and contained two unfused polar nuclei, while those extra central cells located at the chalazal end usually had a single nucleus. Fertilization occurred only between the male gamete and the largest binucleate central cell. The extra central cells eventually degenerated after fertilization.Present address: GI Basic Research Center, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, U.S.A.Correspondence and reprints: State Key Laboratory of Plant Physiology and Biochemistry, College of Biological Science, China Agricultural University, Beijing 100094, Peoples Republic of China.     

Studies on systematic embryology inScilla (Hyacinthaceae)

Scilla persica and 5 species of the so-calledS. hohenackeri group, namely,S. furseorum, S. puschkinioides, S. vvedenskyi, S. hohenackeri, andS. greilhuberi, have been investigated embryologically with special reference to embryo sac and endosperm development.Polygonum-type embryo sac development was stated inS. puschkinioides andS. greilhuberi. 8-nucleate, normally structured embryo sacs, which could not be specified further due to sparse availability of the material, were stated inS. furseorum, S. vvedenskyi, andS. hohenackeri. InS. persica the embryo sac develops according to the bisporicAllium-type. In most species endosperm development was stated to be nuclear, exceptS. hohenackeri, where the type could not be specified. Other traits of possible taxonomic significance are the number of layers in the outer integument, which is mostly 4, or 5–6 inS. furseorum, and the occurrence of polyploid versus haploid and early degenerating antipodal nuclei, the latter occurring only inS. persica andS. furseorum. These embryological characters may be useful for assessing taxonomic relationship of the present species with other allied groups withinScilla, in particular, theS. siberica alliance,S. messeniaca, and theS. bifolia alliance. TheAllium-type embryo sac, which occurs inS. persica, is also characteristic for theS. siberica alliance, and may be a common derived character. Lack of antipodal polyploidization, as characteristic forS. persica andS. furseorum, occurs also in theS. siberica alliance, and is perhaps another common derived trait indicating phylogenetic relationship. Nuclear endosperm development is more frequent in spring-flowering squills than helobial development, which has previously been stated inS. messeniaca, some species of theS. siberica alliance, and inS. litardierei. While helobial endosperm may be primitive forHyacinthaceae in general, it may, by reversal, also occur as a derived character, at least in some species of theS. siberica alliance.     

THE FEMALE GAMETOPHYTE OF MACHAERANTHERA PATTERSONII (ASTER PATTERSONII) AND OF M. TANACETIFOLIA

The nucellus of Machaeranthera pattersonii (A. Gray) Greene (Aster pattersonii A. Gray) contains only one megaspore mother cell, and the female gametophyte develops from the chalazal megaspore of a row of four, thus conforming to the Polygonum type of development. These observations are contrary to the older work of Palm. Three nuclear divisions produce the typical eight nuclei with the egg apparatus, primary endosperm cell with two polar nuclei, and two antipodal cells, the micropylar one containing two nuclei. Usually no more antipodal cells are formed, although there is further nuclear division, apparently followed by nuclear fusion. The antipodal cells remain about the same size without forming an antipodal haustorium. Cell division accompanies the first division of the primary endosperm nucleus. The early stages of the embryo resemble those of other Compositae. Machaeranthera tanacetifolia (HBK) Nees also shows the Polygonum type of development of the female gametophyte. It is suggested that Palm may have been working on some species of Erigeron that had been wrongly identified, which would account for the difference in observations.     

Developmental events in ovules of the ornamental plant Rudbeckia bicolor Nutt

Microscopic observations of R. bicolor ovules showed that tetrasporic embryo sacs of Fritillaria type are formed. In the mature female gametophytes modifications in antipodal cell formation and egg apparatus organization were observed, e.g. morphological resemblance was evident of antipode or synergid to the egg cell. In the central cell cytoplasm of the mature gametophytes the presence of small bodies was a characteristic feature. Development of both embryo and endosperm was observed in ∼73% of ovules at the embryo stage, while retarded or arrested development of the endosperm was found in ∼26% of them. Occasionally, two embryos occurred in the embryo sac. This is the first record of polyembryony in this species. Although hemigamy has been previously described in Rudbeckia bicolor Nutt., in the present investigations mosaic structure of embryos was not detected. Measurements of the C-DNA amount (flow cytometry) revealed embryo nuclei with 2C DNA content only, and endosperm nuclei with 5C DNA content in the mature seeds. No peak corresponding to 1C nuclei was detected in the histograms obtained from the nuclear preparation of seeds or seedling parts. These results suggest that hemigamy is not an obligatory phenomenon in R. bicolor. The mean 2C DNA value was determined as 14.51 pg (the first estimation for this species).     

Polarity of nuclear and organellar DNA during megasporogenesis and megagametogenesis in Plumbago zeylanica

Summary Megasporogenesis and megagametogenesis of Plumbago zeylanica were studied using isolated megasporocytes, megaspores, and embryo sacs labeled with Hoechst 33258 for nuclear and organellar (presumably plastid) DNA. Megasporogenesis conforms to the tetrasporic Plumbago type, producing a coenomegaspore with four megaspore nuclei. Organeller DNA is polarized in the micropylar end of the coenomegaspore and embryo sac, reflecting the site of egg cell formation. The three remaining nuclei are somewhat displaced to the chalazal pole, producing a variable number of accessory cells and a 4N secondary central cell nucleus. Ultimately, the mature embryo sac consists of two to five cells including an egg cell, a central cell, zero to two lateral cells, and zero to one antipodal cell depending on the degeneration of the lateral or chalazal nuclei during megagametogenesis.     

Anatomy of Watermelon Embryo Sacs Following Pollination, Non-pollination or Parthenocarpic Induction of Fruit Development

There is little information on the fate of embryo sacs in plantovules if pollination is prevented. In this study embryo sacsfrom watermelon were observed over a 13 day period followingflowering with (a) normal pollination, (b) non-pollination and(c) induction of parthenocarpic fruit development with naphthaleneacetic acid. Following pollination, and prior to fertilizationapproximately 2 days later, the embryo sacs completed developmentand consisted of two synergids with prominent filiform apparatus,an egg cell, a central cell with two polar nuclei and threeantipodal cells. Sperm nuclei were observed within the embryosac at 2 days and by 4 days the endosperm was proliferating.In the non-pollination treatment the embryo sac was still intactafter 4 days although the antipodal nuclei were becoming hardto distinguish. By 7 days only the two synergids and the eggcell were still well defined, the polar nuclei appeared in somepreparations to be fused, and the antipodals had degenerated.By 10 days the embryo sac was a structure-less watery mass.In parthenocarpic fruit the fate of the embryo sac was similarto that in non-pollinated fruit except that final breakdownwas delayed past 10 days. Maturity of the majority of embryo sacs in an ovary appearedto be contemporaneous with penetration of the pollen tube, andon the basis of the anatomical results it seems possible thatembryo sacs could be fertilized up to 2 days beyond the normaltime. Citrullus lanatus, watermelon, embryo sac, anatomy, pollination, parthenocarpy     

Isolation of embryo sacs from Dianthus ovules by enzymatic treatments and microdissection

 Mature ovules of Dianthus (Caryophyllaceae) were histologically observed by clearing and serial sectioning to characterize the cells of the embryo sac. The results show that the mature embryo sac was located deep inside the hemitropous ovule due to thick nucellar tissue at the micropylar region. For the isolation of the embryo sacs, ovules were collected from ovaries of flowers 1 day after anthesis, and treated with an enzyme solution for digesting cell walls on a gyratory shaker. After 12 h of enzyme treatment, these ovules were dissected using a glass needle under an inverted microscope to release the embryo sacs. The embryo sacs, characterized by their specific size, were successfully released by these successive treatments. The viability of the embryo sacs was more than 80% as assessed with fluorescein diacetate staining. Fluorescent staining with 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole revealed the nuclei of the egg apparatus in the isolated embryo sacs. The procedure for isolating embryo sacs established in this study will offer a new approach to further in vitro studies on fertilization in Dianthus. Received: 20 January 1999 / Revision received: 12 July 1999 / Accepted: 17 August 1999     

Deficiency analysis of female gametogenesis in maize

Plants produce female gametes through mitotic division in the multicellular, meioticolly reduced (haploid) megagametophyte phase. In flowering plants, the megagametophyte is the embryo sac; female gametogenesis or megagametogenesis comprises the ontogeny of the embryo sac. As a step toward understanding the role of embryo sac-expressed genes in megagametogenesis, development of normal, haploid embryo sacs in maize was compared with development of embryo sacs deficient for various small, cytologically defined chromosomal regions. This analysis allowed us to screen 18% of the maize genome, including most of chromosome arms 1L and 3L, for phenotypes due specifically to deletion of essential, embryo sac-expressed genes. Confocal laser scanning microscopy of whole developing embryo sacs confirmed that normal megagameto-genesis in maize is of the highly stereotyped, bipolar Polygonum type common to most flowering plants examined to date. Deficiency embryo sac phenotypes were grouped into three classes, suggesting each deficient region contained one or more of at least three basic types of haploid-expressed gene functions. In the first group, three chromosome regions contained genes required for progression beyond early, free-nuclear stages of embryo sac development. Maintaining synchrony between events at the two poles of the embryo sac required genes located within two deficiencies. Finally, three chromosome regions harbored loci required for generation of normal cellular patterns typical of megagametogenesis. This analysis demonstrates that the embryo sac first requires postmeiotic gene expression at least as early as the first postmeiotic mitosis. Furthermore, our data show that a variety of distinct, genetically separable programs require embryo sac-expressed gene products during megagametogenesis, and suggest the nature of some of those developmental mechanisms. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Embryology ofCrocus thomasii (Iridaceae)

The embryology ofCrocus thomasii is described. Male meiosis is of simultaneous type, and gives rise to starchy microspores which develop into lipoid pollen grains; these are two-celled and show a spinulate acolpate, abaculate exine lacking apertures. The tapetum is glandular and its cells become bi- or sometimes multinucleate. The ovule is anatropous and bitegmic; the inner integument forms the micropyle. Megasporogenesis is heteropolar with starch accumulation in the functional chalazal megaspore. Embryo sac development conforms to thePolygonum type. The endosperm development is nuclear. The embryo develops according to the Caryophyllad type. In the ripe seed it is differentiated and enveloped by a starchy cellular endosperm. The embryological characters observed strongly favour a close relation betweenC. thomasii andC. sativus.     

The embryology ofStegnospermataceae,with a discussion on its status,affinities and systematic position

The embryology ofStegnosperma halimifolium andS. watsonii has been studied in detail. The tapetum is of the secretory type and its cells become multinucleate. Simultaneous cytokinesis in the pollen mother cells follows meiosis. The ripe pollen grains are 3-celled. The ovule is crassinucellate, bitegmic and amphitropous, with the micropyle formed by the inner integument alone. The female archesporium is one celled, and the parietal tissue 3–5 layered. The embryo sac development conforms to thePolygonum type. A central strand, 6 or 7 cells thick, differentiates inside the nucellus and extends from the base of the embryo sac to the chalazal region. The endosperm is nuclear. The embryogeny conforms to the Caryophyllad type. The seed coat is formed by the outer epidermis of the outer integument and the inner epidermis of the inner integument. Based on this evidence and other data, the status of the genus as an independent family,Stegnospermataceae (Stegnospermaceae) is confirmed. Apparently, it forms a connecting link betweenPhytolaccaceae andCaryophyllaceae.     

Inorganic salts modify embryo sac development in sexual and aposporous Cenchrus ciliaris

Summary Sexual and aposporously apomictic plants of buffelgrass (Cenchrus ciliaris L.) form megaspore tetrads. In sexual plants the chalazal megaspore develops into a single Polygonum type embryo sac. In aposporous plants the megaspores degenerate, and one or more un-reduced nucellar cells form Panicum type embryo sacs. Apospory is conditioned by gene A; the dominant allele of gene B is epistatic to A and preserves sexual reproduction. We recently observed that heavy application of (NH₄)₂SO₄ to the soil induced multiple embryo sacs in a sexual line. Therefore we tested the effect of salt stress on embryo sac formation in sexual and aposporous genotypes. One molar solutions of CaCl₂, NaCl, (NH₄)₂SO₄, NH₄Cl, NaNO₃, or Na₂SO₄ were applied to the soil of greenhouse plants every day or two starting at the archespore stage. Some of the pistils in salt-treated plants of sexual genotypes AaBb, aaBb, and aabb showed features not seen in untreated controls: (1) multiple Polygonum type embryo sacs in 1%–7% of pistils depending upon the salt; (2) embryo sacs without antipodals (0%–7%); (3) embryo sacs protruding through the micropyle (1%–16%). Some pistils of salt-treated obligately aposporous lines, but not controls, developed Polygonum type embryo sacs (4%–13%) and protruding embryo sacs (0%–6%). There was no ion specificity for induction of abnormal features. We postulate that salt stress suppresses the developmental priority of nucellar embryo sacs over megaspores in aposporous lines and of the chalazal megaspore over other megaspores in all lines. This may permit megaspores of aposporous plants to form reduced Polygonum type gametophytes, and permit more than one megaspore to form reduced embryo sacs in all lines. Protrusion of sacs and failure of antipodal formation in reduced embryo sacs may be the consequence of uncoordinated expansion of the embryo sacs and surrounding tissue.Joint contribution of the Department of Biology, The Pennsylvania State University, and USDA-ARS, U.S. Regional Pasture Research Laboratory. Names of products are included for the benefit of the reader and do not imply endorsement or preferential treatment by USDA     

EMBRYO SAC DEVELOPMENT IN THE CV. KS MALE-STERILE,FEMALE-STERILE LINE OF SOYBEAN (GLYCINE MAX)

Light microscopic observations were made on 22 ovules from fertile plants and 108 ovules from sterile plants of the cv. KS synaptic mutant, a highly male-sterile, female-sterile line of soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] (2n = 2x = 40). Ovules of fertile siblings contained normal embryo sacs and embryos. Ovules from sterile plants contained various irregularities. The most consistent abnormality was the failure of the embryo sac to attain normal size. Small megasporocytes of irregular shape were seen; only one megasporocyte of normal shape and size was noted. No linear tetrads were found. However, two ovules contained nonlinear triads. A range from zero to 28 cells and nuclei, of various sizes, were identifiable in small megagametophytes and embryo sacs. Degeneration of these nuclei and cells was noted as early as the four-nucleate gametophyte stage. Other ovules contained degenerated nucellar centers without embryo sacs. Two ovules appeared to be normal. Late postpollination stages were marked by shrunken nucellus and integuments. The presence of pollen tube traces, endosperm, and aborting embryos in ovules of hand-pollinated flowers from sterile plants suggested that no incompatibility was involved. Degeneration of the gametophyte and embryo sac contents at many developmental stages indicated a wide array of effects, possibly resulting from meiotic irregularities similar to those seen in microsporogenesis of this mutant.     

Reproductive biology of the native forage grass Trichloris crinita (Poaceae,Chloridoideae)

• Trichloris crinita is a perennial forage grass species native to arid regions of the American continent. Due to its extensive area of distribution, good forage quality and resistance to drought and grazing, this species is widely utilised as forage and for revegetation purposes in environments with low water availability. Despite its importance, genetic improvement of T. crinita has been very limited, partly as consequence of the lack of knowledge on its mode of reproduction.
• In the present work, we studied the reproductive biology of T. crinita by means of embryological analyses, flow cytometric seed screen (FCSS), self‐compatibility tests and progeny testing with morphological and molecular markers.
• Cytological analyses revealed embryo sacs with eight nuclei and of Polygonum type for all T. crinita accessions analysed. FCSS histograms exhibited two clear peaks corresponding to 2C and 3C DNA content, indicating embryo sacs of sexual origin. Controlled pollination experiments designed to evaluate seed set (%) demonstrated that T. crinita is self‐compatible, whereas results from morphological and simple sequence repeat (SSR) marker analysis of progeny revealed lack of outcrossing.
• Together, these results indicate that T. crinita reproduces sexually. It is a self‐compatible and autogamous species. It is expected that these data will have a positive impact in the genetics and breeding of this species, and therefore contribute to its proper utilisation in arid regions.

     

APOMIXIS AND POLYEMBRYONY IN HIEROCHLOË ODORATA

Norstog , Knut . (Wittenberg U., Springfield, Ohio.) Apomixis and polyembryony in Hierochloe odorata. Amer. Jour. Bot. 50(8): 815–821. Illus. 1963.—Hierochloë odorata from Michigan, having 2n = 56 chromosomes, was found to reproduce by pseudogamous fertilization of diploid aposporous embryo sacs. Diploid embryos, 2n= 56, and 5n = 140 ± endosperm occurred together. Megasporogenesis was incomplete, and aposporous embryo sac initials developed directly into 8-nucleate Polygonum type embryo sacs. Microsporogenesis was irregular with univalent, bivalent and multivalent chromosomes in meiosis-I. Dyads and microspores varied between n = 24 and n = 32, and less than 50% of the pollen grains stained with acetocarmine. Two other races of H. odorata are known to occur in North America. They are an apparently infertile type in Canada with 2n = 28, and a perfectly fertile race from coastal Connecticut also with 2n = 28. It is suggested that the H. odorata with 2n = 56 is a derivative of the sterile Canadian race.     

Enzymatic isolation of viable nucelli at the megaspore mother cell stage and in developing embryo sacs in Nicotiana tabacum

Summary Nucelli and developing embryo sacs were enzymatically isolated from ovules of Nicotiana tabacum. Megaspore mother cells, tetrads, uninucleate, binucleate, four-nucleate, eight-nucleate and mature embryo sacs were obtained. The isolated embryo sacs were intact and living, and maintained their original shape and organization. Cytoplasmic streaming was clearly observed. Prolonged incubation of ovules or reincubation of isolated embryo sacs in the maceration mixture resulted in the liberation of the gametophytic cells as individual, living protoplasts.     

Embryological Studies on Narcissus tazetta var. chinensis

Chinese narcissus (Narcissus tazetta var. chinensis Roem) blooms but has no seeds. Embryological studies on the species were conducted to discover the causes of its sterility. Its anther wall is composed of four layers of cells, and its tapetum is of the secretory type. The cytokinesis of microspore mother cells is of the successive type, and the tetrad is tetrahedral. During meiosis of microspore mother cells, some chromosomes lagged, and several micronuclei were found in tetrads. Only 27.7% of the pollen grains contained full cytoplasm, and 1.3% of them germinated in culture medium. No pollen grain, however, could germinate on the stigma. The ovary is trilocular with axile placenta, and the ovules are bitegmic, tenuinucellate, and anatropous. Its embryo sac is of the polygonum type. Most embryo sacs degenerated, and only about 4.5% of the ovules contained a normal embryo sac with an egg cell, two synergids, three antipodal, and a central cell containing two polar nuclei. One reason for the sterility of Chinese narcissus is the abnormality of microsporogenesis and megasporogenesis, in which only a few functional pollen grains and embryo sacs are produced. The other reason is that the pollen grains cannot germinate on the stigma. This paper was translated from Journal of Xiamen University (Natural Science), 2005, 44(1) (in Chinese)     

Reproductive morphology of Sargentodoxa cuneata (Lardizabalaceae) and its systematic implications

The reproductive morphology of Sargentodoxa cuneata (Oliv) Rehd. et Wils. is investigated through field, herbarium, and laboratory observations. Sargentodoxa may be either dioecious or monoecious. The functionally unisexual flowers are morphologically bisexual, at least developmentally. The anther is tetrasporangiate, and its wall, of which the development follows the basic type, is composed of an epidermis, endothecium, two middle layers, and a tapetum. The tapetum is of the glandular type. Microspore cytokinesis is simultaneous, and the microspore tetrads are tetrahedral. Pollen grains are two-celled when shed. The mature ovule is crassinucellate and bitegmic, and the micropyle is formed only by the inner integument. Megasporocytes undergo meiosis resulting in the formation of four megaspores in a linear tetrad. The functional megaspore develops into an eight-nucleate embryo sac after three rounds of mitosis. The mature embryo sac consists of an egg apparatus (an egg and two synergids), a central cell, and three antipodal cells. The pattern of the embryo sac development follows a monosporic Polygonum type. Comparisons with allied groups show that Sargentodoxa shares more synapomorphies with the Lardizabalaceae than other Ranunculales. Characteristics of its reproductive morphology are consistent with the placement of Sargentodoxa as the sister group of the remaining Lardizabalaceae. It does not possess a sufficient number of apomorphic characters to justify its separation into a separate family or subfamily. It is best retained as a member of the Lardizabalaceae.