Development of chicken intrafusal muscle fibers

The first sign of developing intrafusal fibers in chicken leg muscles appeared on embryonic day (E) 13 when sensory axons contacted undifferentiated myotubes. In sections incubated with monoclonal antibodies against myosin heavy chains (MHC) diverse immunostaining was observed within the developing intrafusal fiber bundle. Large primary intrafusal myotubes immunostained moderately to strongly for embryonic and neonatal MHC, but they were unreactive or reacted only weakly with antibodies against slow MHC. Smaller, secondary intrafusal myotubes reacted only weakly to moderately for embryonic and neonatal MHC, but 1–2 days after their formation they reacted strongly for slow and slow-tonic MHC. In contrast to mammals, slow-tonic MHC was also observed in extrafusal fibers. Intrafusal fibers derived from primary myotubes acquired fast MHC and retained at least a moderate level of embryonic MHC. On the other hand, intrafusal fibers developing from secondary myotubes lost the embryonic and neonatal isoforms prior to hatching and became slow. Based on relative amounts of embryonic, neonatal and slow MHC future fast and slow intrafusal fibers could be first identified at E14. At the polar regions of intrafusal fibers positions of nerve endings and acetylcholinesterase activity were seen to match as early as E16. Approximately equal numbers of slow and fast intrafusal fibers formed prenatally; however, in postnatal muscle spindles fast fibers were usually in the majority, suggesting that some fibers transformed from slow to fast.     

The adult fast isozyme of myosin is present in a nerve-muscle tissue culture system

Abstract. Organotypic nerve-muscle cultures were prepared from foetal mouse spinal cord and adult mouse muscle fibres. In this system, the adult fibres degenerate and new myotubes form. The regenerated muscle fibres become innervated, develop cross-striations, and survive for several months. We have investigated the isozymes of myosin present in these muscle fibres using histochemistry and immunocytochemistry with antibodies to rat embryonic, neonatal, and adult fast myosins. We demonstrate that some of the regenerated fibres contain adult fast but not embryonic or neonatal myosin. This is the first demonstration of the production of adult myosin heavy chain in tissue culture. This system therefore offers the possibility for further study of the development of adult myosin isoforms in vitro.     

The adult fast isozyme of myosin is present in a nerve-muscle tissue culture system

Organotypic nerve-muscle cultures were prepared from foetal mouse spinal cord and adult mouse muscle fibres. In this system, the adult fibres degenerate and new myotubes form. The regenerated muscle fibres become innervated, develop cross-striations, and survive for several months. We have investigated the isozymes of myosin present in these muscle fibres using histochemistry and immunocytochemistry with antibodies to rat embryonic, neonatal, and adult fast myosins. We demonstrate that some of the regenerated fibres contain adult fast but not embryonic or neonatal myosin. This is the first demonstration of the production of adult myosin heavy chain in tissue culture. This system therefore offers the possibility for further study of the development of adult myosin isoforms in vitro.     

Developmentally regulated expression of three slow isoforms of myosin heavy chain: diversity among the first fibers to form in avian muscle.

At least three slow myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms were expressed in skeletal muscles of the developing chicken hindlimb, and differential expression of these slow MHC isoforms produced distinct fiber types from the outset of skeletal muscle myogenesis. Immunohistochemistry with isoform-specific monoclonal antibodies demonstrated differences in MHC content among the fibers of the dorsal and ventral premuscle masses and distinctions among fibers before splitting of the premuscle masses into individual muscles (Hamburger and Hamilton Stage 25). Immunoblot analyses by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of myosin extracted from the hindlimb demonstrated the presence throughout development of different mobility classes of MHCs with epitopes associated with slow MHC isoforms. Immunopeptide mapping showed that one of the MHCs expressed in the embryonic limb was the same slow MHC isoform, slow MHC1 (SMHC1), that is expressed in adult slow muscles. SMHC1 was expressed in the dorsal and ventral premuscle masses, embryonic, fetal, and some neonatal and adult hindlimb muscles. In the embryo and fetus SMHC1 was expressed in future fast, as well as future slow muscles, whereas in the adult only the slow muscles retained expression of SMHC1. Those embryonic muscles destined in the adult to contain slow fibers or mixed fast/slow fibers not only expressed SMHC1, but also an additional slow MHC not previously described, designated as slow MHC3 (SMHC3). Slow MHC3 was shown by immunopeptide mapping to contain a slow MHC epitope (reactive with mAb S58) and to be structurally similar to a MHC expressed in the atria of the adult chicken heart. SMHC3 was designated as a slow MHC isoform because (i) it was expressed only in those muscles destined to be of the slow type in the adult, (ii) it was expressed only in primary fibers of muscles that subsequently are of the slow type, and (iii) it had an epitope demonstrated to be present on other slow, but not fast, isoforms of avian MHC. This study demonstrates that a difference in phenotype between fibers is established very early in the chicken embryo and is based on the fiber type-specific expression of three slow MHC isoforms.     

Treatment with beta bungarotoxin blocks muscle spindle formation in fetal rats

Sensory and motor fibers of peripheral nerves were irreversibly destroyed in fetal rats by administering beta bungarotoxin (BTX) on embryonic day 16 or 17, after assembly of primary myotubes, but before the formation of muscle spindles. Soleus muscles of toxin-treated fetuses and their untreated littermates were removed just prior to birth and were examined by light microscopy of serial transverse sections for the presence of spindles and immunocytochemical expression of several isoforms of myosin heavy chains (MHC). Untreated muscles exhibited numerous spindles that were innervated by branches of intramuscular nerves and contained muscle fibers expressing a slow-tonic MHC isoform characteristic of the intrafusal but not extrafusal fibers. Toxin-treated muscles were devoid of intramuscular nerve bundles and perineurial structures. Encapsulations of muscle fibers resembling spindles were absent and no myotubes expressed the slow-tonic MHC isoform associated with intrafusal fibers in beta BTX-treated muscles. Thus, the assembly of muscle spindles, formation of the spindle capsule, and transformation of undifferentiated myotubes into the intrafusal fibers that contain spindle-specific myosin isoforms all depend on the presence of innervation in prenatal rat muscles.     

Regenerating adult chicken skeletal muscle and satellite cell cultures express embryonic patterns of myosin and tropomyosin isoforms

Regenerating areas of adult chicken fast muscle (pectoralis major) and slow muscle (anterior latissimus dorsi) were examined in order to determine synthesis patterns of myosin light chains, heavy chains and tropomyosin. In addition, these patterns were also examined in muscle cultures derived from satellite cells of adult fast and slow muscle. One week after cold-injury the regenerating fast muscle showed a pattern of synthesis that was predominately embryonic. These muscles synthesized the embryonic myosin heavy chain, beta-tropomyosin and reduced amounts of myosin fast light chain-3 which are characteristic of embryonic fast muscle but synthesized very little myosin slow light chains. The regenerating slow muscle, however, showed a nearly complete array of embryonic peptides including embryonic myosin heavy chain, fast and slow myosin light chains and both alpha-fast and slow tropomyosins. Peptide map analysis of the embryonic myosin heavy chains synthesized by regenerating fast and slow muscles showed them to be identical. Thus, in both muscles there is a return to embryonic patterns during regeneration but this return appears to be incomplete in the pectoralis major. By 4 weeks postinjury both regenerating fast and slow muscles had stopped synthesizing embryonic isoforms of myosin and tropomyosin and had returned to a normal adult pattern of synthesis. Adult fast and slow muscles yielded a satellite cell population that formed muscle fibers in culture. Fibers derived from either population synthesized the embryonic myosin heavy chain in addition to alpha-fast and beta-tropomyosin. Thus, muscle fibers derived in culture from satellite cells of fast and slow muscles synthesized a predominately embryonic pattern of myosin heavy chains and tropomyosin. In addition, however, the satellite cell-derived myotubes from fast muscle synthesized only fast myosin light chains while the myotubes derived from slow muscle satellite cells synthesized both fast and slow myosin light chains. Thus, while both kinds of satellite cells produced embryonic type myotubes in culture the overall patterns were not identical. Satellite cells of fast and slow muscle appear therefore to have diverged from each other in their commitment during maturation in vivo.     

Neural control of the sequence of expression of myosin heavy chain isoforms in foetal mammalian muscles

The expression of myosin isoforms was studied during development of calf muscles in foetal and neonatal rats, using monoclonal antibodies against slow, embryonic and neonatal isoforms of myosin heavy chain (MHC). Primary myotubes had appeared in all prospective rat calf muscles by embryonic day 16 (E16). On both E16 and E17, primary myotubes in all muscles with the exception of soleus stained for slow, embryonic and neonatal MHC isoforms; soleus did not express neonatal MHC. In earlier stages of muscle formation staining for the neonatal isoform was absent or faint. Secondary myotubes were present in all muscles by E18, and these stained for both embryonic and neonatal MHCs, but not slow. In mixed muscles, primary myotubes destined to differentiate into fast muscle fibres began to lose expression of slow MHC, and primary myotubes destined to become slow muscle fibres began to lose expression of neonatal MHC. This pattern was further accentuated by E19, when many primary myotubes stained for only one of these two isoforms. Chronic paralysis or denervation from E15 or earlier did not disrupt the normal sequence of maturation of primary myotubes up until E18, but secondary myotubes did not form. By E19, however, most primary myotubes in aneural or paralyzed tibialis anterior muscles had lost expression of slow MHC and expressed only embryonic and neonatal MHCs. Similar changes occurred in other muscles, except for soleus which never expressed neonatal MHC, as in controls. Paralysis or denervation commencing later than E15 did not have these effects, even though it was initiated well before the period of change in expression of MHC isoforms. In this case, some secondary myotubes appeared in treated muscles. Paralysis initiated on E15, followed by recovery 2 days later so that animals were motile during the period of change in expression of MHC isoforms, was as effective as full paralysis. These experiments define a critical period (E15-17) during which foetuses must be active if slow muscle fibres are to differentiate during E19-20. We suggest that changes in expression of MHC isoforms in primary myotubes depend on different populations of myoblasts fusing with the myotubes, and that the normal sequence of appearance of these myoblasts has a stage-dependent reliance on active innervation of foetal muscles. A critical period of nerve-dependence for these myoblasts occurs several days before their action can be noted.     

Diversity of myosin heavy chain expression in satellite cells from mouse soleus and EDL muscles.

Postnatal myoblasts, the satellite cells, originating from slow and fast skeletal muscle fibres differentiate and fuse into myotubes expressing different phenotype of myosin heavy chain (MyHC) isoforms. Little is known, however, of factors which establish and maintain this phenotypic diversity. We used immunofluorescent labelling and Western blotting to examine the expression of slow and fast MyHC isoforms in myotubes formed in vitro from satellite cells isolated from mouse fast twitch extensor digitorum longus (EDL) and slow twitch soleus muscles. Satellite cells were cultured in serum-rich growth medium promoting myoblast proliferation until cross-striated and self-contracting myotubes were formed. We report that in both cultures myotubes expressed slow as well as fast MyHC isoforms, but the level of slow MyHC was higher in soleus culture than in EDL culture. Hence, the pattern of expression of slow and fast MyHC was characteristic of the muscle fibre type from which these cells derive. These results support the concept of phenotypic diversity among satellite cells in mature skeletal muscles and suggest that this diversity is generated in vitro irrespectively of serum mitogens.     

Origin of intrafusal muscle fibers in the rat

The expression of several isoforms of myosin heavy chain (MHC) by intrafusal and extrafusal fibers of the rat soleus muscle at different stages of development was compared by immunocytochemistry. The first intrafusal myotube to form, the bag2 fiber, expressed a slow-twitch MHC isoform identical to that expressed by the primary extrafusal myotubes. The second intrafusal myotube to form, the bag1 fiber, expressed a fast-twitch MHC similar to that initially expressed by the secondary extrafusal myotubes. At subsequent stages of development, the equatorial and juxtaequatorial regions of bag2 and bag1 intrafusal myofibers began to express a slow-tonic myosin isoform not expressed by extrafusal fibers, and ceased to express some of the MHC isoforms present initially. Myotubes which eventually matured into chain fibers expressed initially both the slow-twitch and fast-twitch MHC isoforms similar to some secondary extrafusal myotubes. In contrast, adult chain fibers expressed the fast-twitch MHC isoform only. Hence intrafusal myotubes initially expressed no unique MHCs, but rather expressed MHCs similar to those expressed by extrafusal myotubes at the same chronological stage of muscle development. These observations suggest that both intrafusal and extrafusal fibers develop from common pools of bipotential myotubes. Differences in MHC expression observed between intrafusal and extrafusal fibers of rat muscle might then result from a morphogenetic effect of afferent innervation on intrafusal myotubes.     

Skeletal muscle satellite cell diversity: satellite cells form fibers of different types in cell culture

Following skeletal muscle injury, new fibers form from resident satellite cells which reestablish the fiber composition of the original muscle. We have used a cell culture system to analyze satellite cells isolated from adult chicken and quail pectoralis major (PM; a fast muscle) and anterior latissimus dorsi (ALD; a slow muscle) to determine if satellite cells isolated from fast or slow muscles produce one or several types of fibers when they form new fibers in vitro in the absence of innervation or a specific extracellular milieu. The types of fibers formed in satellite cell cultures were determined using immunoblotting and immunocytochemistry with monoclonal antibodies specific for avian fast and slow myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms. We found that satellite cells were of different types and that fast and slow muscles differed in the percentage of each type they contained. Primary satellite cells isolated from the PM formed only fast fibers, while up to 25% of those isolated from ALD formed fibers that were both fast and slow (fast/slow fibers), the remainder being fast only. Fast/slow fibers formed from chicken satellite cells expressed slow MHC1, while slow MHC2 predominated in fast/slow fibers formed from quail satellite cells. Prolonged primary culture did not alter the relative proportions of fast to fast/slow fibers in high density cultures of either chicken or quail satellite cells. No change in commitment was observed in fibers formed from chicken satellite cell progeny repeatedly subcultured at high density, while fibers formed from subcultured quail satellite cell progeny demonstrated increasing commitment to fast/slow fiber type formation. Quail satellite cells cloned from high density cultures formed colonies that demonstrated a similar change in commitment from fast to fast/slow, as did serially subcloned individual satellite cell progeny, indicating that the observed change from fast to fast/slow differentiation resulted from intrinsic changes within a satellite cell. Thus satellite cells freshly isolated from adult chicken and quail are committed to form fibers of at least two types, satellite cells of these two types are found in different proportions in fast and slow muscles, and repeated cell proliferation of quail satellite cell progeny may alter satellite cell progeny to increasingly form fibers of a single type.     

Origin of intrafusal muscle fibers in the rat

Summary The expression of several isoforms of myosin heavy chain (MHC) by intrafusal and extrafusal fibers of the rat soleus muscle at different stages of development was compared by immunocytochemistry. The first intrafusal myotube to form, the bag₂ fiber, expressed a slow-twitch MHC isoform identical to that expressed by the primary extrafusal myotubes. The second intrafusal myotube to form, the bag₁ fiber, expressed a fast-twitch MHC similar to that initially expressed by the secondary extrafusal myotubes. At subsequent stages of development, the equatorial and juxtaequatorial regions of bag₂ and bag₁ intrafusal myofibers began to express a slow-tonic myosin isoform not expressed by extrafusal fibers, and ceased to express some of the MHC isoforms present initially. Myotubes which eventually matured into chain fibers expressed initially both the slow-twitch and fast-twitch MHC isoforms similar to some secondary extrafusal myotubes. In contrast, adult chain fibers expressed the fast-twitch MHC isoform only. Hence intrafusal myotubes initially expressed no unique MHCs, but rather expressed MHCs similar to those expressed by extrafusal myotubes at the same chronological stage of muscle development. These observations suggest that both intrafusal and extrafusal fibers develop from common pools of bipotential myotubes. Differences in MHC expression observed between intrafusal and extrafusal fibers of rat muscle might then result from a morphogenetic effect of afferent innervation on intrafusal myotubes.     

Embryonic and fetal rat myoblasts express different phenotypes following differentiation in vitro

Myosin heavy chain (MHC) is encoded by a multigene family containing members which are expressed in developmental and fiber type-specific patterns. In developing rats, primary (1°) and secondary (2°) myotjbes can be disfinguished by differences in MHC expression: 1° myotubes coexpress embryonic and slow MHC, while 2° myotubes initially express only embryonic MHC. We have used monoclonal antibodies which recognize the embryonic, slow, neonatal, and adult fast IIB/IIX MHCs to examine MHC accumulation in myoblasts obtained from hindlimbs of embryonic day (ED) 14 and ED 20 Sprague-Dawley rats during differentiation in vitro. Embryonic myoblasts (ED 14), which develop into 1° myotubes in vivo, differentiate as myocytes or small myotubes (i.e., 1–4 nuclei) which express both embryonic and slow MHC. They do not accumulate detectable levels of neonatal or adult fast IIB/IIX MHC. Fetal myoblasts, which develop into secondary myotubes in vivo, fuse to form large myotubes (i.e., 10–50 nuclei) and express predominantly embryonic MHC at 3 days in culture. These myotubes accumulate neonatal and adult fast IIB/IIX isoforms of MHC and eventually contract spontaneously. In contrast to embryonic myotubes, they do not accumulate slow MHC. Our results demonstrate that embryonic and fetal rat myoblasts express different phenotypes in vitro and suggest that they represent distinct myoblast lineages similar to those previously described in chickens and mice. These two lineages may be responsible for the generation of distinct populations of 1° and 2° myotubes in vivo. © 1993Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Transient expression of a ventricular myosin heavy chain isoform in developing chicken intrafusal muscle fibers

Sections of chicken tibialis anterior and extensor digitorium longus muscles were incubated with monoclonal antibodies against myosin heavy chains (MHC). Ventricular myosin was present in developing secondary intrafusal myotubes when they were first recognized at embryonic days (E) 13–14, and in developing extrafusal fibers prior to that date. The reaction in intrafusal fibers began to fade at E17, and in 2-week-old postnatal and older muscles the isoform was no longer recognized. Only those intrafusal fibers which also reacted with a monoclonal antibody against atrial and slow myosin contained ventricular MHC. Intrafusal myotubes which developed into fast fibers did not express the isoform. Hence, based on the presence or absence of ventricular MHC, two lineages of intrafusal fiber are evident early in development. Strong immunostaining for ventricular MHC was observed in primary extrafusal myotubes at E10, but the isoform was already downregulated at E14, when secondary intrafusal myotubes were still forming and expressed ventricular MHC. Only light to moderate and transient immunostaining was observed in coexisting secondary extrafusal myotubes, most of which developed into fast fibers. Thus at the time when nascent muscle spindles are first recognized, differences in MHC profiles already exist between prospective intrafusal and extrafusal fibers. If intrafusal fibers stem from a pool of primordial muscle cells, which is common to intrafusal and extrafusal myotubes, they diverged from it some time prior to E13.This paper is dedicated to Prof. D. Pette, Konstanz, on the occasion of his 60th birthday     

Force-calcium relationship depends on myosin heavy chain and troponin isoforms in rat diaphragm muscle fibers.

The present study examined Ca(2+) sensitivity of diaphragm muscle (Dia(m)) fibers expressing different myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms. We hypothesized that Dia(m) fibers expressing the MHC(slow) isoform have greater Ca(2+) sensitivity than fibers expressing fast MHC isoforms and that this fiber-type difference in Ca(2+) sensitivity reflects the isoform composition of the troponin (Tn) complex (TnC, TnT, and TnI). Studies were performed in single Triton-X-permeabilized Dia(m) fibers. The Ca(2+) concentration at which 50% maximal force was generated (pCa(50)) was determined for each fiber. SDS-PAGE and Western analyses were used to determine the MHC and Tn isoform composition of single fibers. The pCa(50) for Dia(m) fibers expressing MHC(slow) was significantly greater than that of fibers expressing fast MHC isoforms, and this greater Ca(2+) sensitivity was associated with expression of slow isoforms of the Tn complex. However, some Dia(m) fibers expressing MHC(slow) contained the fast TnC isoform. These results suggest that the combination of TnT, TnI, and TnC isoforms may determine Ca(2+) sensitivity in Dia(m) fibers.     

Maximum specific force depends on myosin heavy chain content in rat diaphragm muscle fibers.

In the present study, myosin heavy chain (MHC) content per half sarcomere, an estimate of the number of cross bridges available for force generation, was determined in rat diaphragm muscle (Dia(m)) fibers expressing different MHC isoforms. We hypothesize that fiber-type differences in maximum specific force [force per cross-sectional area (CSA)] reflect the number of cross bridges present per CSA. Studies were performed on single, Triton X-100-permeabilized rat Dia(m) fibers. Maximum specific force was determined by activation of single Dia(m) fibers in the presence of a high-calcium solution (pCa, -log Ca(2+) concentration of 4.0). SDS-PAGE and Western blot analyses were used to determine MHC isoform composition and MHC content per half sarcomere. Differences in maximum specific force across fast MHC isoforms were eliminated when controlled for half-sarcomere MHC content. However, the force produced by slow fibers remained below that of fast fibers when normalized for the number of cross bridges available. On the basis of these results, the lower force produced by slow fibers may be due to less force per cross bridge compared with fast fibers.     

Expression of unique and developmental myosin heavy chain isoforms in adult human digastric muscle.

Digastric muscle (DGM) is a powerful jaw-opening muscle that participates in chewing, swallowing, breathing, and speech. For better understanding of its contractile properties, five pairs of adult human DGMs were obtained from autopsies and processed with immunocytochemistry and/or immunoblotting. Monoclonal antibodies against alpha-cardiac, slow tonic, neonatal, and embryonic myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms were employed to determine whether the DGM fibers contain these MHC isoforms, which have previously been demonstrated in restricted specialized craniocervical skeletal muscles but have not been reported in normal adult human trunk and limb muscles. The results showed expression of all these MHC isoforms in adult human DGMs. About half of the fibers reacted positively to the antibody specific for the alpha-cardiac MHC isoform in DGMs, and the number of these fibers decreased with age. Slow tonic MHC isoform containing fibers accounted for 19% of the total fiber population. Both the alpha-cardiac and slow tonic MHC isoforms were found to coexist mainly with the slow twitch MHC isoform in a fiber. A few DGM fibers expressed the embryonic or neonatal MHC isoform. The findings suggest that human DGM fibers may be specialized to facilitate performance of complex motor behaviors in the upper airway and digestive tract.     

Expression of adult fast pattern of acetylcholinesterase molecular forms by mouse satellite cells in culture

The pattern of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) molecular forms, obtained by sucrose gradient sedimentation, was studied at different in vitro developmental stages of myogenic cells isolated from adult mouse skeletal muscle. Only the globular forms were present in rapidly dividing satellite cells during the first days in culture. After myotube formation, a pattern similar to that described in mammalian fast-twitch skeletal muscle was observed. This pattern did not change during the following period in culture (up to 1 month) nor could it be modified by co-culturing with spinal cord motoneurons or by addition of brain-derived extracts. The internal-external localization of AChE molecular forms has been determined by the use of echothiophate iodide, a membrane-impermeant irreversible inhibitor of AChE. Echothiophate-treated cultures showed about 40% of both asymmetric and globular forms localized on the sarcolemma, with their active sites oriented outward. Analysis of culture medium from untreated cultures revealed the presence of both asymmetric and globular forms. When the same analysis was repeated on cultures of myoblasts derived from 16-day-old mouse embryos, the pattern of AChE forms was different. The myotubes derived from these cells exhibit a very small proportion of asymmetric form, which was not released into the medium. This pattern was not further modified during the following days of culture, nor by co-cultures with spinal cord motoneurons or by incubations with brain-derived extracts. Thus, the myotubes derived from myoblasts express in culture a clear phenotypic difference when compared to the corresponding myotubes from satellite cells, supporting the view that these two myogenic cells are endowed with different developmental programs.     

Expression of fast and slow isoforms of the Ca2+-ATPase in developing chick skeletal muscle

The expression of fast and slow isoforms of the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase was studied in the developing chick embryo and in tissue-cultured myotubes. Monoclonal antibodies specific for each isoform were used as probes of protein expression. Analysis of expression of Ca2+-ATPase isoforms in chick thigh muscles by immunofluorescence microscopy revealed that all muscle fibers expressed both isoforms during their development. Primary generation muscle fibers expressed predominantly the slow isoform. Secondary generation fibers expressed both isoforms at comparable levels. Loss of the "inappropriate" isoforms occurred late in embryonic development. Immunoblot analysis of embryonic thigh muscle proteins indicated that the expression of the slow isoform varied little from embryonic Day 6 (ED6) to ED19, while expression of the fast isoform increased dramatically just prior to ED19. Tissue-cultured myotubes derived from ED12 chick thigh muscle myoblasts, plated at high density, expressed both isoforms of the Ca2+-ATPase at very similar levels. Clonal analysis of myoblasts taken from early (ED6) and late (ED12) chick thigh muscles showed that all muscle colonies expressed both forms, consistent with in vivo results. Fiber-type specific isoforms of the Ca2+-ATPase and myosin heavy chain are not coordinately expressed in developing chick skeletal muscle.