Antigen modulation of the immune response. III. Evaluation of the hypothetical short-lived memory cell

The putative short-lived memory cells, whose existence has been suggested by the results of secondary adoptive transfer experiments, was investigated. On the basis of the following evidences we have concluded that the short-lived memory cell is probably an artifact of the adoptive transfer technique: (a) when immune thoracic duct lymphocytes, known to consist predominantly of long-lived memory cells, were transferred to irradiated recipients and challenged at various times after transfer, approximately 80–90% of the initial response was absent by Day 14 challenge; (b) Preirradiating adoptive recipients with increasing dose of X-irradiation tended to lengthen the observed half life of memory cells; (c) single or multiple treatments of immune donors with 0.3 mg Vinblastin before transfer resulted in neither a depression of the initial secondary response nor an alteration in the rate of decline of the memory potential; (d) reconstitution of irradiated hosts with normal spleen cells one day before transfer of memory cells and challenge resulted in inhibition of the adoptive secondary response; and (e) the transfer of memory cells to antigen free intermediate hosts, in which they were allowed to reside for one day or fourteen days before transfer to irradiated recipients, resulted in only a slight decline in their capacity to respond.We propose that the rapid decline of memory potential in adoptive recipients challenged at various times after transfer is due to modulating effects by the hosts as it recovers from irradiation. These effects may be the result of cell crowding or the loss of irradiation-produced stimulatory factors. The relevance of these findings to adoptive transfer systems in general and the secondary response of intact animals is discussed.     

What people believe about how memory works: a representative survey of the U.S. population

Incorrect beliefs about the properties of memory have broad implications: the media conflate normal forgetting and inadvertent memory distortion with intentional deceit, juries issue verdicts based on flawed intuitions about the accuracy and confidence of testimony, and students misunderstand the role of memory in learning. We conducted a large representative telephone survey of the U.S. population to assess common beliefs about the properties of memory. Substantial numbers of respondents agreed with propositions that conflict with expert consensus: Amnesia results in the inability to remember one's own identity (83% of respondents agreed), unexpected objects generally grab attention (78%), memory works like a video camera (63%), memory can be enhanced through hypnosis (55%), memory is permanent (48%), and the testimony of a single confident eyewitness should be enough to convict a criminal defendant (37%). This discrepancy between popular belief and scientific consensus has implications from the classroom to the courtroom.     

Antigen modulation of the secondary immune response. VI. Contribution of cells recruited from precursor pool to expression of memory.

The adoptive transfer system has been used extensively to study the ability of antigen triggered memory cells to become antibody forming cells and/or to proliferate and expand the memory cell population. Selective antigen triggering of the memory cells for low and high affinity antibody formation has also been studied in this way. One of the main counter-arguments to the interpretation of these data is that the presence of antigen in the adoptive host may lead to recruitment of new memory cells from either a host or donor precursor population. In this paper we examined the contribution of both host and donor precursor cells to the total antibody response in adoptive secondary recipients. The following donor-host combinations were used in which the recipients were given 1 mg fluid antigen intravenously: (A) normal (non-immune) donors to normal irradiated recipients; (B) normal donors to carrier primed irradiated recipients; (C) carrier primed donors to normal irradiated recipients; (D) normal donors to carrier primed recipients with challenge and subsequent transfer to additional carrier primed recipients; (E) carrier primed donor to normal recipients to carrier primed recipients; (F) repeat of B and C above with multiple antigen administration; (G) purified immune (DNP-BGG) donor T cells mixed with normal B cells transferred to normal irradiated recipients. In most cases recruitment was seen but this represented less than 4% of the responses seen with immune cells. Thus we conclude that this level of recruitment does not compromise the use of the adoptive transfer system for studying selective antigen triggering of memory cells.     

Animal models of memory impairment.

Memory impairment in the elderly resembles a mild temporal lobe dysfunction. Alterations in the hippocampal formation are also a probable basis for cognitive deficits in some animal models of ageing. For example, aged rats are impaired in hippocampal-dependent tests of spatial memory. Recent studies have revealed considerable structural integrity in the aged hippocampus, even in aged rats with the most impaired spatial memory. In contrast, atrophy/loss of cholinergic neurons in the basal forebrain and deficiency in cholinergic transduction in hippocampus correlate with the severity of spatial memory impairment in aged rats. This evidence supports the longstanding view that age-related loss of memory has a cholinergic basis. In this context, it is somewhat surprising that the use of a selective cholinergic immunotoxin in young rats to further test this hypothesis has revealed normal spatial memory after removing septo-hippocampal cholinergic neurons. Young rats with immunotoxic lesions, however, have other behavioural impairments in tests of attentional processing. These lines of research have implications for understanding the neurobiological basis of memory deficits in ageing and for selecting an optimal behavioural setting in which to examine therapies aimed at restoring neurobiological function.     

Hierarchical organization of cognitive memory.

This paper addresses the question of the organization of memory processes within the medial temporal lobe. Evidence obtained in patients with late-onset amnesia resulting from medial temporal pathology has given rise to two opposing interpretations of the effects of such damage on long-term cognitive memory. One view is that cognitive memory, including memory for both facts and events, is served in a unitary manner by the hippocampus and its surrounding cortices; the other is that the basic function affected in amnesia is event memory, the memory for factual material often showing substantial preservation. Recent findings in patients with amnesia resulting from relatively selective hippocampal damage sustained early in life suggest a possible reconciliation of the two views. The new findings suggest that the hippocampus may be especially important for event as opposed to fact memory, with the surrounding cortical areas contributing to both. Evidence from neuroanatomical and neurobehavioural studies in monkeys is presented in support of this proposal.     

I.S. Beritashvili (Beritov) is one of the founders of the modern biobehavioral science (to the 120th anniversary)

Ivan Solomonovich Beritashvili (Beritov) is one of the great Russian physiologists who have created the Russian route of the modern science of behavior. He has proposed and experimentally substantiated a concept of psychoneural activity according to which the behavior controlled by images is the main and higher form of the behavior of vertebrates. Behaviors on the basis of conditioned reflexes and images are qualitatively different activities underlain by different neural substrates. Recently, the Beritashvili's principle ideas have been confirmed by multiple experimental studies of the animal and human cognitive behavior. At present, the concept of the procedural memory formed by training and acquisition and episodic memory formed on the basis of images is commonly accepted. The episodic memory stores the environmental events and phenomena perceived by an animal or a human. Each time when the image is reproduced during perception of environment or its part, an animal performs the same behavioral act as during the actual perception. Beritashvili's viewpoint that the procedural and declarative memories are controlled by different brain structures has been confirmed by experiments.     

Immunological memory: contribution of memory B cells expressing costimulatory molecules in the resting state.

Traditionally, emphasis has been placed on the roles of Th cells in generating and amplifying both cellular and humoral memory responses. Little is known about the potential contributions of B cell subsets to immunological memory. Resting memory B cells have generally been regarded as poor APC, attributed in part to the relative paucity of costimulatory molecules identified on their surface. We describe a novel subpopulation of human memory B cells that express CD80 in their resting state, are poised to secrete particularly large amounts of class switched Igs, and can efficiently present Ag to and activate T cells. This functionally distinct B cell subset may represent an important mechanism by which quiescent human B cells can initiate and propagate rapid and vigorous immune memory responses. Finally, these studies extend recent observations in the murine system and highlight the phenotypic and functional diversity that exists within the human B cell memory compartment.     

Episodic memory: new insights from the study of semantic dementia.

The study of patients with semantic dementia, the temporal variant of frontotemporal dementia, has provided new insights into the interaction between episodic and semantic memory, and the different roles played by various structures in the temporal lobe. Recent findings indicate that the syndrome of semantic dementia can inform us about the organisation of long-term memory and the relationship between semantic memory and other cognitive systems.     

Further studies on amplification of cell-associated immunological memory by secondary antigenic stimulus.

Using the hapten-carrier system in which the dinitrophenyl group (DNP) served as a B cell reactive hapten and bovine serum albumin (BSA) or human gammaglobulin (HGG) as a T cell reactive carrier, changes in the hapten-specific memory (B cell-associated memory) and the carrier-specific memory (T cell-associated memory) after a secondary antigenic stimulus were analyzed in mice. Since an immunological adjuvant was indispensable in the induction of the primary increase in memory, antigen used for the primary antigenic stimulus was injected together with the capsular polysaccharide of Klebsiella pneumoniae (CPS-K) which has already been shown to exhibit a potent adjuvant effect. With the cell-transfer technique, it was found that the cell-associated hapten-specific memory for anti-DNP antibody response to DNP-BSA was truly amplified by the secondary injection of DNP-HGG into mice primed with DNP-HGG, and that the cell-associated carrier-specific memory as judged by the helper effect on anti-DNP response to DNP-BSA was also truly amplified by the secondary injection of BSA into mice primed with BSA. However, when memory was assessed in actively immunized mice, the secondary injection of BSA into mice primed with DNP-BSA and HGG decreased anti-DNP responsiveness to the tertiary injection of DNP-BSA, whereas the secondary injection of DNP-HGG secondarily increased anti-DNP responsiveness. In mice primed with DNP-BSA the titers of serum antibodies to BSA increased after the secondary injection of DNP-BSA or BSA. From these results it has been concluded that, like B cell-associated memory, T cell-associated memory is also amplified by a secondary antigenic stimulus, although its expression is inhibited in actively immunized mice through negative control by their antibodies.     

An analysis of B cell memory. I. Interaction of helper and suppressor effects in the in vitro expression of IgM memory.

The pfc response of Srbc primed IgM memory cells has been characterized by limiting dilution analysis in vitro, in which LPS was used to maximize the response of spleen cells to Srbc. The analysis suggested that, even under these conditions, expression of B cell memory was not directly assayed and cell collaboration effects were still basic to the system.Two types of cells, as defined by function, appeared necessary to elicit optimal clonal proliferation of IgM B memory cells: firstly, helper T cells were essential for B cell proliferation even with LPS present in culture. Under appropriate conditions, helper activity could be provided by normal thymus cells. Secondly, activated T cells were required for the maximal conversion of normal thymus cells to helper cells. A third activity, T cell-dependent suppression, was observed at high cell doses. The implications of these results and the need for a comprehensive analysis of in vitro conditions for each individual type of experiment is discussed.     

Antigen modulation of the immune response. V. Generation of large memory cells in antigen draining lymph nodes.

We have studied the distribution of memory B cell subpopulations by using 1g velocity sedimentation and adoptive transfer. When the non-antigen-draining mesenteric lymph nodes were examined 4 weeks after intraperitoneal immunization with DNPBGG, large memory cells were present in only very low numbers. However, when the draining parathymic nodes were removed, a significant enrichment of large memory cell activity was seen. When these results were corrected for the cell yields in each 1g separated fraction we found that 59% of the total memory cells were small, 36% medium and 5% large in the mesenteric lymph node preparations and 40% were small, 46% medium and 14% large in the parathymic lymph node suspensions. When popliteal lymph nodes were removed after footpad immunization, 32% of the total memory cell activity was in the small cell fraction while 49% was in the medium fraction and 18% in the large cell fraction. Control experiments were also run to show that the shift in the velocity sedimentation profile of the various memory cell populations was not an artifact of the adoptive transfer system nor a result of selective antigen triggering.From these results it would appear that the size distribution of memory cells depends upon the source of cells studied, large memory cells being found predominantly only in lymph nodes draining the site of antigen injection. Since the large memory cells can also be found in the thoracic duct lymph after footpad immunization but not after intraperitoneal immunization, it is suggested that the larger cells can circulate to other lymphoid tissues but cannot recirculate.     

Differential susceptibility of naive and memory CD4+ T cells to the cytopathic effects of infection with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 strain LAI.

CD4+ T lymphocytes of individuals infected with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) exhibit a qualitative defect in their ability to mount memory responses to previously encountered antigens although their responses to mitogens remain normal. T cells responsible for memory responses can be distinguished from naive T cells based on differential expression of isoforms of the tyrosine phosphatase CD45. It has been suggested that memory CD4+ T cells from infected individuals have a greater virus burden than naive CD4+ T cells and that this accounts for the loss of recall responses in infected individuals. However, it has been unclear whether naive and memory T cells are equally susceptible to infection and to the cytopathic effects of the virus. We therefore infected highly purified resting naive and memory CD4+ T cells from HIV-1-seronegative individuals with HIV-1(LAI). Infected cells were then stimulated with phytohemagglutinin to render them permissive for viral replication. Cell viability and growth rate were monitored for 8 to 10 days as indicators of cytopathic effects induced by HIV-1(LAI). Our results indicated that naive and memory CD4+ T cells display marked differences in susceptibility to the cytopathic effects induced by HIV-1(LAI), infection. The cytopathic effects induced by HIV-1(LAI) were much more severe in memory CD4+ T cells than in naive CD4+ T cells. Differential cytopathic effects in naive and memory T cells were not due to differences in virus entry into and replication in these cell populations. Rather, memory cells were more susceptible to cytopathic effects. Pronounced cytopathic effects in memory cells were clearly detectable at 7 day postinfection. Cell death occurred at the single-cell level and was not accompanied by syncytium formation. The growth rate of infected memory CD4+ T cells was also severely compromised compared to that of naive CD4+ T cells, whereas the growth rates of both uninfected naive and memory CD4+ T cells were approximately the same. At least a portion of the dying cells exhibited biochemical changes characteristic of apoptosis. These results suggest that the selective functional defects present in the memory CD4+ T-cell subset of HIV-1-infected individuals may in part be the result of the greater susceptibility of memory T cells to cytopathic effects induced by HIV-1.     

Studies on immunological memory. I. Different requirements for induction and recall of memory in antibody-mediated cellular cytotoxicity.

A system of antibody-mediated cellular immunity against chemically defined haptens has been adopted in order to study the requirements for induction and recall of immunological memory. Hapten-protein conjugates with different molar ratios of hapten to protein were used for immunization. Primed spleen cells were incubated together with ⁵¹Cr-labeled CRBC on which the conjugate was coupled by ECDI. Release of radioactivity was assayed.The induction of memory to the hapten was possible regardless of the degree of substitution. Recall of memory, however, was only possible with low substituted conjugates on either homologous or heterologous carriers. The data demonstrate different requirements for induction and recall of memory which possibly are T cell-independent and T cell-dependent processes, respectively.     

Generation of immune memory by haptenated derivatives of thymus-independent antigens in C57BL/6 mice. I. The differentiation of memory B lymphocytes into antibody-secreting cells depends on the nature of the thymus-independent carrier used for memory induction and/or revelation

It has been previously reported that trinitrophenylated lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS), a thymus-independent (TI)-1 antigen, elicits an anamnestic response to TNP in C57BL/6 mice. The ability of these mice to mount a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was analyzed. Priming with DNP-Ficoll or DNP-Dextran, both TI-2 antigens, resulted in an increased frequency of TNP-binding B lymphocytes. Evidence is presented that memory cell-induction by DNP-Ficoll does not require functional T cells. The differentiation into antibody-forming cells (AFC) of memory cells generated by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll cannot be obtained by a challenge with either antigen. There was no indication that the lack of a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was related to suppressive T cells interfering with memory expression. Memory cells induced by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll can nevertheless be activated by TNP-LPS. In contrast to the restricted sensitivity of TNP-memory cells generated by TI-2 antigens, TNP-LPS-induced memory cells are indifferently susceptible to TI-1 or TI-2 antigenic stimulation. These results are discussed in terms of memory B-cell subpopulations.     

Molecular mechanisms of synaptic plasticity and memory.

To unravel the molecular and cellular bases of learning and memory is one of the most ambitious goals of modern science. The progress of recent years has not only brought us closer to understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying stable, long-lasting changes in synaptic strength, but it has also provided further evidence that these mechanisms are required for memory formation.     

Olfactory memory: the long and short of it

It has been proposed that memory for odors does not have a short-term (or working) memory system. The distinction between short- and long- term memory in other sensory modalities has been generally supported by three main lines of evidence: capacity differences between the proposed systems, evidence of differential coding, and differential memory losses in neuropsychological patients. The present paper examines these issues in an effort to establish a similar distinction for the memory of olfactory stimuli. Each of these lines of evidence is examined in relation to the literature on olfactory memory. Based on this examination, it seems that there is at least preliminary support from each of these lines of evidence to advocate a distinction between a long- and short-term memory for olfactory stimuli. Emphasis is placed upon the qualitative similarity of olfactory memory to other memory systems. This similarity is further highlighted through an examination of the literature pertinent to serial position effects in memory for olfactory stimuli.      

Amnesia and neglect: beyond the Delay-Brion system and the Hebb synapse.

Hippocampal damage in people causes impairments of episodic memory, but in rats it causes impairments of spatial learning. Experiments in macaque monkeys show that these two kinds of impairment are functionally similar to each other. After any lesion that interrupts the Delay-Brion system (hippocampus, fornix, mamillary bodies and anterior thalamus) monkeys are impaired in scene-specific memory, where an event takes place against a background that is specific to that event. Scene-specific memory in the monkey corresponds to human episodic memory, which is the memory of a unique event set in a particular scene, as opposed to scene-independent human knowledge, which is abstracted from many different scenes. However, interruption of the Delay-Brion system is not sufficient to explain all of the memory impairments that are seen in amnesic patients. To explain amnesia the specialized function of the hippocampus in scene memory needs to be considered alongside the other, qualitatively different functional specializations of other memory systems of the temporal lobe, including the perirhinal cortex and the amygdala. In all these specialized areas, however, including the hippocampus, there is no fundamental distinction between memory systems and perceptual systems. In explaining memory disorders in amnesia it is also important to consider them alongside the memory disorders of neglect patients. Neglect patients fail to represent in memory the side of the world that is contralateral to the current fixation point, in both short- and long-term memory retrieval. Neglect was produced experimentally by unilateral visual disconnection in the monkey, confirming the idea that visual memory retrieval is retinotopically organized; patients with unilateral medial temporal-lobe removals showed lateralized memory impairments for half-scenes in the visual hemifield contralateral to the removal. Thus, in scene-memory retrieval the Delay-Brion system contributes to the retrieval of visual memories into the retinotopically organized visual cortex. This scene memory interpretation of hippocampal function needs to be contrasted with the cognitive-map hypothesis. The cognitive-map model of hippocampal function shares some common assumptions with the Hebb-synapse model of association formation, and the Hebb-synapse model can be rejected on the basis of recent evidence that monkeys can form direct associations in memory between temporally discontiguous events. Our general conclusion is that the primate brain encompasses widespread and powerful memory mechanisms which will continue to be poorly understood if theory and experimentation continue to concentrate too much, as they have in the past, on the hippocampus and the Hebb synapse.     

Memory of MEL cells to a previous exposure to inducer.

The mechanism of commitment of murine erythroleukemia (MEL) cells to terminal differentiation has been examined. Before a significant proportion of cells becomes committed, a lag period of at least 9 hr of exposure to inducer is observed. Cells withdrawn from inducer can reinitiate commitment without a lag when reexposed. The proportion of committed cells in a culture discontinuously exposed to inducer is identical to that in a continuously exposed culture even if withdrawal from inducer lasts for 18 hr. The ability to tolerate an interruption in the exposure has been termed "memory." The memory of a previous exposure to inducer is complete up to 18 hr. It is partially erased after 36 hr and completely erased after 72 hr. The length of time the memory persists is not affected by the length of the initial exposure to inducer. These results suggest that a cellular component necessary for the commitment event accumulates in response to inducer and that this component has a decay time on the order of 10 hr.     

Cellular and molecular mechanisms of memory: the LTP connection.

Studies of the cellular and molecular mechanisms of memory formation have focused on the role of long-lasting forms of synaptic plasticity such as long-term potentiation (LTP). A combination of genetic, electrophysiological and behavioral techniques have been used to examine the possibility that LTP is a cellular mechanism of memory storage in the mammalian brain. Although a definitive answer remains elusive, it is clear that in many cases manipulations that alter LTP alter memory, and training regimens that produce memory can produce LTP-like potentiation of synaptic transmission.