Multilocus enzyme analysis in aerobic and anaerobic bacteria using gel electrophoresis-nitrocellulose blotting

An optimized multilocus enzyme electrophoresis method, which involves polyacrylamide-agarose gel electrophoresis followed by electrophoretic transfers on nitrocellulose sheets, was developed for the analysis of enzyme polymorphism in several aerobic and anaerobic bacterial species including Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus pneumoniae, S. agalactiae, Klebsiella pneumoniae and K. oxytoca, Clostridium bifermentans and C. sordellii, and Prevotella bivia. Serial electrophoretic transfers (during 5-15 min each) from a single polyacrylamide gel could be achieved for most enzymes studied, and allowed an increased definition of enzyme bands on nitrocellulose as compared to migration gels. Four enzymes, which could not be blotted in such conditions, could still be stained in gels after blotting. Thus, the method allowed the combined analysis of several enzymes after a single gel electrophoresis separation. The analysis of enzyme polymorphism in the various species studied raised the interest of polymorphic loci such as esterase or glutamic-oxaloacetic transaminase for epidemiologic studies. The method characterized a genetic diversity of enzyme loci of S. pneumoniae higher than previously reported, and is thus convenient for the analysis of genetic relationships between related isolates. Since the present method reduces the tediousness of multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and requires experimental conditions that are not specific for the bacterial population studied, it may be proposed for rapid population genetics analysis of a wide variety of bacteria.     

Esterase electrophoretic polymorphism ofBacillus thuringiensis andBacillus cereus reference strains

The genomic diversity and relationship among 61Bacillus thuringiensis andBacillus cereus reference strains were investigated by electrophoretic analysis of esterase enzymes on native polyacrylamide gel. Polymorphism of the esterolytic bands revealed seven esterases, designed as Est A to Est G in order of decreasing anodal migration. Each esterase showed two to three mobility variants that assigned the analysed strains into 35 electrophoretic types (ETs). This high diversity allowed the identification of several serovar or strain-specific ETs. Cluster analysis of ETs showed three major groups in which the strains belonging to the serovartolworthi were the most distant. The ETs distribution showed thatB. thuringiensis andB. cereus are intermingled in the dendrogram with the resolution of some common serovars ofB. thuringiensis in tight phylogenetic lineages. These results indicate that the esterase enzyme electrophoresis, applied as a sole typing method for the closely related speciesB. thuringiensis andB. cereus is suitable to highlight the intraspecific genetic diversity.     

Characterization of Listeria monocytogenes isolates by esterase electrophoresis.

Multiple bands of alpha-naphthyl-propionyl esterase (alpha NPE) activity observed following starch gel electrophoresis of cell extracts allowed 219 Listeria monocytogenes isolates from milk, nondairy foods, and clinical and veterinary sources to be assigned to 17 different alpha NPE types. Multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MEE) analysis was used to obtain electrophoretic mobility data for alpha NPEs and nine other metabolic enzymes; on the basis of these data, the 219 strains were assigned to 59 electrophoretic types. Each of the methods separated the strains into two main groups, and there was extensive agreement on assignment of the strains to the groups. Although the method is less discriminatory than MEE, the usefulness of alpha NPE electrophoresis alone as a rapid, simple typing method for L. monocytogenes for certain purposes is indicated by agreement among alpha NPE, MEE, and restriction fragment length polymorphism types as molecular markers for persistent and transient L. monocytogenes strains found in sequential raw-milk and nondairy food samples obtained from different processors.     

Serial electrophoretic transfers: A technique for the identification of numerous enzymes from single polyacrylamide gels

We describe an electrophoretic method for the transfer of macromolecules from polyacrylamide slab gels to ion-exchange paper without loss of clarity or resolution. A series of partial transfers provides numerous copies of a single gel separation, and these copies may be assayed independently with enzyme specific stains. This method therefore combines the advantages of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis for detecting enzyme variation with an efficient method for examining numerous enzymes from a single gel separation.This work was supported by NIH Grants GM 24849 and GM 27119 to R. C. Lewontin.     

Comparative zone electrophoresis of catalase of Staphylococcus species isolated from mammalian skin.

Vertical polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis was conducted for the catalase enzymes of representative strains of 18 proposed species and subspecies of the genus Staphylococcus. The catalase bands which resulted were predominantly monomorphic within each of the species and differences in catalase mobilities were observed between many of the species. The electrophoretic mobilities of the catalases were supportive to the scheme of classification used. Many strains of certain species demonstrated multiple catalase bands which are suggestive of multimolecular forms of the enzyme. Horizontal starch gel electrophoresis of representative strains of S. capitis produced catalase bands with relative mobilities that were different from those obtained with polyacrylamide electrophoresis, presumably due to a difference in molecular sieving between the gels.     

Biochemical genetic relationship of Thailand and Hawaii isolates of Parastrongylus cantonensis (Nematoda: Angiostrongylidae)

The genetic relationship of the Thailand and Hawaii isolates (strains) of the rat lungworm Parastrongylus (=Angiostrongylus) cantonensis was investigated by gene–enzyme systems using vertical polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis. Six gene–enzyme systems were successfully determined, with each being represented by two presumptive loci. Glucose phosphate dehydrogenase, glucose phosphate isomerase, lactate dehydrogenase, malate dehydrogenase and malic enzyme were monomorphic at both loci, and the respective bands exhibited similar mobility in both isolates implying absence of genetic variation.     

The complete karyotype of Aspergilius niger: the use of introduced electrophoretic mobility variation of chromosomes for gene assignment studies

A method is described for unambiguous assignment of cloned genes to Aspergillus niger chromosomes by CHEF gel electrophoresis and Southern analysis. All of the eight linkage groups (LGs), with the exception of LG VII, have previously been assigned to specific chromosomal bands in the electrophoretic karyotype of A. niger. Using a LG VII-specific probe (nicB gene of A. niger) we have shown that LG VII corresponds to a chromosome of about 4.1 Mb. Furthermore, genetic localization of three unassigned genes (glaA, agIA and pepA) in strains in which these genes had been replaced by a selectable marker gene led to a revised karyotype for the chromosomes corresponding to LGs VIII and VI. The revised electrophoretic karyotype reveals only 5 distinct bands. The presence of three pairs of equally sized chromosomes precluded assignment of genes to one specific chromosome in the wild-type strain. However, unambiguous chromosome assignment of cloned genes using CHEF-Southern analysis was demonstrated using a set of A. niger strains with introduced chromosomal size variation. The availability of these tester strains obviates the need to isolate or construct mutant. strains for the purpose of chromosome assignment.     

Immunological Studies on Antisera of Mice Immunized with Dried or DEPC-treated Ehrlich Ascites Tumor Cells

Intracellular arylsulfatases from Klebsiella aerogenes W70 cells grown in methionine medium (M enzyme) and inorganic sulfate medium containing tyramine (T enzyme) were purified respectively by fractionation with (NH₄)₂SO₄, followed by successive chromatographies on DEAE cellulose, hydroxylapatite, Sephadex G-100 and DEAE Sephadex A-25. On polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, the two enzymes gave single bands with the same mobilities. Molecular weights of both, determined by SDS gel electrophoresis and by Sephadex G-100 chromatography, were 47,000 and 45,000, respectively. Their activities were maximal at pH 7.5. The affinities of the enzymes (M and T enzymes) for their substrate (Km) and the maximum velocity of hydrolysis (V_max) were enhanced by addition of electron withdrawing substituents. The enzymes were inhibited by inorganic phosphate, cyanide, hydroxylamine and tyramine. The inhibition by tyramine was competitive (Ki = 1.0 × 10^?4 m). These results show that the two enzymes were identical. This was confirmed by the fact that mutant strains, which were unable to synthesize arylsulfatase when grown with methionine, could also not synthesize the enzyme when grown with tyramine.     

Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis of Corynebacterium diphtheriae: a Possible Epidemiological Aid

In this preliminary study, the use of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis as an aid in the characterization of Corynebacterium diphtheriae was evaluated and a standardized method was developed. The electrophoretic patterns of 17 gravis, 14 mitis, and 2 intermedius types of C. diphtheriae were compared with the electrophoretic patterns of 5 Robinson and Peeney stock gravis serotype strains. Each of the 5 stock serotype strains had different electrophoretic patterns, although some common bands were present. The 17 gravis strains isolated in the United States showed patterns identical to those of the stock gravis serotype II strain. The 14 mitis strains examined produced 6 different electrophoretic patterns, irrespective of geographical location. One mitis pattern corresponded with the pattern of gravis serological type II. The two intermedius strains examined had identical electrophoretic patterns that resembled the pattern of gravis serotype IV. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of C. diphtheriae strains may prove to be a useful epidemiologic tool in establishing the distribution and occurrence of various C. diphtheriae types.     

Characterization of Enterobacter cloacae and E. sakazakii by electrophoretic polymorphism of acid phosphatase, esterases, and glutamate, lactate and malate dehydrogenases

Acid phosphatase, esterases, and glutamate, lactate and malate dehydrogenases of 34 strains of Enterobacter cloacae and 22 strains of Enterobacter sakazakii were analysed by horizontal polyacrylamide agarose gel electrophoresis and by isoelectrofocusing in thin-layer polyacrylamide gel. The two species could be separated on the basis of distinct electrophoretic patterns of all enzymes analysed. Glutamate dehydrogenase and acid phosphatase were detected exclusively in E. cloacae, whereas esterase bands were more intensively stained in E. sakazakii. For each species, two zymotypes could be distinguished, on the basis of electrophoretic mobilities of malate dehydrogenase and banding patterns of esterase for E. cloacae, and by both isoelectric point and electrophoretic mobilities of an esterase and of lactate and malate dehydrogenases for E. sakazakii. The high degree of enzyme polymorphism within the two species permitted precise identification of strains. The variations in electrophoretic patterns might therefore provide useful epidemiological markers.     

Genetic Diversity among Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. Trifolii Strains Revealed by Allozyme and Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analyses

Allozyme electrophoresis and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analyses were used to examine the genetic diversity of a collection of 18 Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii, 1 R. leguminosarum bv. viciae, and 2 R. meliloti strains. Allozyme analysis at 28 loci revealed 16 electrophoretic types. The mean genetic distance between electrophoretic types of R. leguminosarum and R. meliloti was 0.83. Within R. leguminosarum, the single strain of bv. viciae differed at an average of 0.65 from strains of bv. trifolii, while electrophoretic types of bv. trifolii differed at a range of 0.23 to 0.62. Analysis of RFLPs around two chromosomal DNA probes also delineated 16 unique RFLP patterns and yielded genetic diversity similar to that revealed by the allozyme data. Analysis of RFLPs around three Sym (symbiotic) plasmid-derived probes demonstrated that the Sym plasmids reflect genetic divergence similar to that of their bacterial hosts. The large genetic distances between many strains precluded reliable estimates of their genetic relationships.     

Genetic relationships among the oral streptococci.

Genetic relationships and species limits among the oral streptococci were determined by an analysis of electrophoretically demonstrable variation in 16 metabolic enzymes. Fifty isolates represented 40 electrophoretic types, among which the mean genetic diversity per locus was 0.857. Mannitol-1-phosphate dehydrogenase was not detected in isolates of the sanguis species complex, and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase were absent in species of the mutans complex. Clustering from a matrix of Gower's coefficient of genetic similarity placed the 40 electrophoretic types in 10 well-defined groups corresponding to the Streptococcus species S. mutans, S. sobrinus, S. cricetus, S. rattus, S. ferus, S. oralis (mitior), two distinct assemblages of S. sanguis strains, and two subdivisions of "S. milleri." The assignments of isolates to these groups were the same as those indicated by DNA hybridization experiments, and the coefficient of correlation between genetic distance estimated by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and genetic similarity indexed by DNA hybridization was -0.897 (P less than 0.001) for 50 pairwise combinations of isolates. S. ferus, which is widely believed to be a member of the mutans complex, was shown to be phylogenetically closer to species of the sanguis complex.     

A direct method for the chromosomal assignment of DNA markers in Leishmania

A simple method for the chromosomal assignment of any DNA marker would be an important tool for the ongoing project to map the genome of the protozoan parasite Leishmania. The Leishmania chromosomes enter pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) gels under current electrophoretic conditions, but their direct identification in a given strain is hampered by their stacking in a few chromosomal bands, and by the very frequent size variations of the same chromosome among parasite strains. To overcome these problems, we determined the complete karyotypes of 12 Old World Leishmania cloned strains. This enabled us to select three of these strains that display great chromosome size polymorphisms, such that every chromosome can be individualized by a specific pattern after hybridization onto these three karyotypes. The complete resolution of the genomes of these three strains can be carried out with only three electrophoretic conditions. This makes a series of three blots sufficient for the assignment of any new marker on a particular Leishmania chromosome.     

Substrate-containing gel electrophoresis: sensitive detection of amylolytic, nucleolytic, and proteolytic enzymes

Electrophoresis of hydrolytic enzymes under nondenaturing conditions on acrylamide gels containing the appropriate high-molecular-weight substrates entrapped on the gel has been explored as a general method for sensitive enzyme resolution and detection. Under electrophoresis conditions of optimal enzyme activity, the enzymes may bind tightly to the fixed substrate and can only migrate in the electrophoretic field as the substrate is hydrolyzed. When the gels after electrophoresis in this “binding mode” are stained with substrate-detecting reagents, clear tracks of enzyme migration are observed, and the length of each track is a function of the amount of enzyme present in that track. Multiple forms of a given enzyme activity have not been and are not likely to be observed under these conditions. Under electrophoresis conditions of minimal (or suboptimal) enzyme activity, the enzymes do not bind to the fixed substrate and their mobility in the electrophoretic field does not appear to be significantly affected by the presence of substrate. After electrophoresis in this “nonbinding mode” the gels are incubated under conditions of optimal enzyme activity to allow substrate hydrolysis to take place before they are stained with substrate-detecting reagents, and active enzymes are detected as clear bands. Multiple forms of a given activity which were resolved during electrophoresis in the nonbinding mode are reflected by the presence of individual bands. The substrate-containing gel electrophoresis technique does not appear to be amenable to precise quantification of enzymes. By comparing the length of the clear tracks or the degree of staining of the activity bands for a range of enzyme concentrations, however, it is possible to establish the smallest amount of enzyme that can unequivocally be detected under a given set of conditions; from such studies we estimate that the sensitivity of detection with the substrate-containing gel electrophoresis technique can be orders of magnitude better than that obtained with other methods. The levels of detection observed in the work presented here were about 50 pg for α-amylase run on starch-containing gels, 1 pg to 1 ng for nucleases run on DNA- or RNA-containing gels, and 100 pg to 10 ng for 11 different pure and crude protease preparations run on gels containing heat-denatured bovine serum albumin.     

Molecular differentiation of sibling species in the Galactomyces geotrichum complex

PCR-analysis, multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and molecular karyotyping were used to characterize 52 strains belonging to the genus Galactomyces. The resultant data revealed that a PCR method employing the universal primer N21 and microsatellite primer (CAC)₅ is appropriate for the distinction of four Ga. geotrichum sibling species, Ga. citri-aurantii and Ga. reessii. Better separation was achieved with the UP primer N21; each species displayed a specific pattern with very low intraspecific variation. We propose to use the primer N21 for the differentiation of the six taxa composing the genus Galactomyces. Multilocus enzyme electrophoresis revealed genetic homogeneity of each sibling species within the Ga. geotrichum complex. On the other hand, the four sibling species, having from 41 to 59% of nDNA homology and similar phenotypic characteristics, are clearly distinguished based on their electrophoretic profiles using two enzymes: mannose-6-phosphate isomerase (MPI) and phosphoglucomutase (PGM). Despite the same number of chromosomal bands, different karyotype patterns were found in Ga. geotrichum sensu stricto and its two sibling species A and B. Within each sibling species, chromosome length polymorphism was observed, in particular for small bands, allowing discrimination to the strain level.     

Disc electrophoretic studies of hemoglobin dissociation by p-hydroxymercury benzoate

The reaction of excess p-mercurybenzoate with human hemoglobin produces five electrophoretic species on polyacrylamide gel. Only two of these bands have been previously observed when starch gel was employed. The chemical and electrophoretic studies presented in this paper illustrate that the appearance of an “extra” band in the β zone is due to the ability of PAGE to separate the βb₂^PMB ? β^PMB equilibrium to its discrete components. The remaining bands are accounted for by the superior resolution of PAGE over starch gel electrophoresis which allowed the detection of two (αβ)^PMB dimer species.     

Genetic relatedness amongst intestinal spirochaetes isolated from rate and brids.

Multilocus enzyme electrophoresis was used to determine genetic relationships amongst 32 intestinal sprrochaetes ( Serpulina spp.) isolated from rats (17), rheas (7), chickens (4), ducks (2), a swan (1) and a flamingo (1). The strains were divided into 20 electrophoretic types (ETs), with a mean genetic diversity per locus of 0.62. The results were compared with those previously published for procine intestinal spirochaetes. One strain from a healthy rat, and three rhea strains which were recovered from cases of necrotizing typhlitis, were grouped in the same ETs as certain procine strains of Serpulina hydysenteriae . The rhea strains could be differentiated from these by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. Fifteen of the rat strains could be differentiated from these by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. Fifteen of the rat strains were genetically and phenotypically closely related. In contrast the avian strains were genetically more heterogeneous, with pathogenic isolates located in three different genetic groups.     

Gel-Electrophoretic Separation, Detection, and Characterization of Plant and Bacterial UDP-Glucose Glucosyltransferases

We have developed procedures for detection and characterization of UDP-glucose: glucosyltransferases following electrophoretic separation in nondenaturing polyacrylamide gels. Using digitonin-solubilized membrane protein preparations from a variety of plants and two cellulose-producing bacteria, activity can be demonstrated for several UDP-glucose:β-glucan synthases with an in situ assay following gel electrophoresis. These enzymes can be characterized within the gels with respect to effector requirements and products produced, and several advantages of this assay over solution assays are demonstrated. For example, the clear dependence of plant UDP-glucose:(1→3)-β-glucan synthase on both Ca²⁺ and a β-linked glucoside is shown; bacterial cellulose synthases show direct stimulation within the gel by guanyl oligonucleotide, and the Acetobacter xylinum enzyme appears more stable in the gel assay than in solution assay.     

Isozyme Variation among 40 Frankia Strains

Forty Frankia strains belonging to the Alnus and Elaeagnus host specificity groups and isolated from various plant species from different geographical areas were characterized by the electrophoretic separation of isozymes of eight enzymes. All the enzyme systems that were investigated showed large variation. Diaphorases and esterases gave multiple band patterns and confirmed the identification of specific Frankia strains. Less variability was observed with enzymes such as phosphoglucose isomerase, leucine aminopeptidase, and malate dehydrogenase, which allowed for the delineation of larger groups of Frankia strains. Cluster analysis, based on the pair-wise similarity coefficients calculated between strains, delineated three large, dissimilar groups of Frankia strains, although each of these groups contained a large amount of heterogeneity. However, numerous Frankia strains, mainly from the Alnus host specificity group, demonstrated a perfect homology for all the enzymes tested.     

Genetic relationships among Neisseria species assessed by comparative enzyme electrophoresis

The electrophoretic mobilities of 12 enzymes from 19 Neisseria species (including 6 strains of N. perflava), Gemella haemolysans, Escherichia coli and Branhamella catarrhalis were characterized by polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis. All strains and species tested exhibited qualitatively different zymogram patterns. Species and strain relationships were quantified by pairwise comparisons of all 12 enzyme systems to obtain similarity indices; these data were subjected to numerical clustering methods to obtain groups and a phenogram. The electrophoretic classification compared favourably with those obtained by other criteria. In addition, the quantitative clustering data indicated that N. ovis and N. caviae are sufficiently different from the other Neisseria species to warrant their separation into a distinct group. These two species also lacked the characteristic NADPH-diaphorase zymogram pattern found in all the other Neisseria species. Intra-species similarity indices were generally greater than the inter-species index values. However, certain species such as N. meningitidis and N. gonorrhoeae had similarity index values in the range of inter-strain index values.