Redox proteomics: from residue modifications to putative biomarker identification by gel- and LC-MS-based approaches

Quantitative determination of reactive oxygen species and reactive nitrogen species in body fluids, tissues or cells has always been problematic due to their high chemical reactivity and the resulting short half-life. This high reactivity may involve reversible and/or irreversible protein modifications, in particular the covalent oxidative modification of specific amino acid residues. Thus, the occurrence of reactive oxygen species and reactive nitrogen species can be monitored indirectly from the identification of specific protein-chemical footprints. In combination with classical gel-based proteomics or liquid chromatography labeling or label-free techniques, mass spectrometry has emerged as a powerful tool to identify these protein modifications in biological samples. In this review, we present the main methodological approaches for gel-based proteomics and quantitative mass spectrometry applied to oxidative protein modifications, mainly Cys. Representative examples from their application in identifying respective biomarkers in diseases related to oxidative stress are also presented.     

Reactive nitrogen species in cellular signaling

The transduction of cellular signals occurs through the modification of target molecules. Most of these modifications are transitory, thus the signal transduction pathways can be tightly regulated. Reactive nitrogen species are a group of compounds with different properties and reactivity. Some reactive nitrogen species are highly reactive and their interaction with macromolecules can lead to permanent modifications, which suggested they were lacking the specificity needed to participate in cell signaling events. However, the perception of reactive nitrogen species as oxidizers of macromolecules leading to general oxidative damage has recently evolved. The concept of redox signaling is now well established for a number of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species. In this context, the post-translational modifications introduced by reactive nitrogen species can be very specific and are active participants in signal transduction pathways. This review addresses the role of these oxidative modifications in the regulation of cell signaling events.     

Interaction of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species with proteins

Free radicals and reactive oxygen or nitrogen species generated during oxidative stress and as by-products of normal cellular metabolism may damage all types of biological molecules. Proteins are major initial targets in cell. Reactions of a variety of free radicals and reactive oxygen and nitrogen species with proteins can lead to oxidative modifications of proteins such as protein hydroperoxides formation, hydroxylation of aromatic groups and aliphatic amino acid side chains, nitration of aromatic amino acid residues, oxidation of sulfhydryl groups, oxidation of methionine residues, conversion of some amino acid residues into carbonyl groups, cleavage of the polypeptide chain and formation of cross-linking bonds. Such modifications of proteins leading to loss of their function (enzymatic activity), accumulation and inhibition of their degradation have been observed in several human diseases, aging, cell differentiation and apoptosis. Formation of specific protein oxidation products may be used as biomarkers of oxidative stress.     

Introduction to the Thematic Minireview Series on Redox-active Protein Modifications and Signaling

The dynamics of redox metabolism necessitate cellular strategies for sensing redox changes and for responding to them. A common mechanism for receiving and transmitting redox changes is via reversible modifications of protein cysteine residues. A plethora of cysteine modifications have been described, including sulfenylation, glutathionylation, and disulfide formation. These post-translational modifications have the potential to alter protein structure and/or function and to modulate cellular processes ranging from division to death and from circadian rhythms to secretion. The focus of this thematic minireview series is cysteine modifications in response to reactive oxygen and nitrogen species.     

Oxidative alternations in rat heart homogenate and mitochondria during ageing

Our understanding of the role played by reactive oxygen and nitrogen species in disease pathology and ageing is still insufficient. Reactive oxygen species and reactive nitrogen species can initiate protein and lipid oxidative damage that may be the most important contribution to ageing and age-related heart diseases. In the present study, we investigated the effect of ageing on oxidative damage of protein amino acid residues and lipids in heart homogenate and mitochondria of 4- and 26-month-old Wistar rats. Levels of dityrosine and levels of lysine conjugates increased in heart homogenate during ageing, although levels of conjugated dienes did not change. We observed significantly oxidative modification of tryptophan in heart mitochondria and increased levels of dityrosine with advancing age. However, levels of lysine conjugates, conjugated dienes as well as relative level of cytochrome c oxidase were unchanged in heart mitochondria during ageing. The results of this study suggest a different mechanism of oxidative modification in heart compartments during ageing and moreover, mitochondria and other cellular compartments are targets for oxidative modifications.     

Methods for detection of reactive metabolites of oxygen and nitrogen: in vitro and in vivo considerations

Facile detection of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species in biologic systems is often problematic. This is a result of the numerous cellular mechanisms, both enzymatic and nonenzymatic involved in their catabolism/decomposition, the complex and overlapping nature of their reactivities, as well as the often limited intracellular access of detector systems. This review describes approaches to the direct and indirect measurement of different reactive metabolites of oxygen and nitrogen. Particular attention to a method's applicability for in vivo determinations will be addressed.     

A novel strategy for global analysis of the dynamic thiol redox proteome

Nitroxidative stress in cells occurs mainly through the action of reactive nitrogen and oxygen species (RNOS) on protein thiol groups. Reactive nitrogen and oxygen species-mediated protein modifications are associated with pathophysiological states, but can also convey physiological signals. Identification of Cys residues that are modified by oxidative stimuli still poses technical challenges and these changes have never been statistically analyzed from a proteome-wide perspective. Here we show that GELSILOX, a method that combines a robust proteomics protocol with a new computational approach that analyzes variance at the peptide level, allows a simultaneous analysis of dynamic alterations in the redox state of Cys sites and of protein abundance. GELSILOX permits the characterization of the major endothelial redox targets of hydrogen peroxide in endothelial cells and reveals that hypoxia induces a significant increase in the status of oxidized thiols. GELSILOX also detected thiols that are redox-modified by ischemia-reperfusion in heart mitochondria and demonstrated that these alterations are abolished in ischemia-preconditioned animals.     

Oxidative stress in haemostasis

The normal hemostatic mechanisms consist of a balance between hemorrhage and thrombosis that is achieved through the interaction of the blood vessels, blood platelets, the coagulation and fibrinolytic factors. The vascular endothelium sustains the balance between prevention and stimulation of platelet activation, thrombogenesis and fibrinolysis and between vasoconstriction and vasodilatation. Endothelial dysfunction associated with different cardiovascular diseases is related to the local formation of reactive oxygen/nitrogen species, mainly peroxynitrite that is produced in a rapid reaction between nitric oxide and superoxide anion. Reactive oxygen/nitrogen species induce changes in the structure and function in hemostatic elements. Proteins and lipids are major initial targets in endothelial cells, blood platelets and plasma. Reaction of reactive oxygen species and nitrogen species, including peroxynitrite, with cellular proteins can lead to nitration of aromatic amino acid residues, oxidation of thiol groups and conversion of some amino acid residues into carbonyl derivative. Oxidative/nitrative modifications of platelet proteins may induce changes of their signaling and haemostatic function (activation). Peroxynitrite also causes oxidation and nitration of fibrinogen--a key protein in coagulation cascade and plasminogen (the main protein of fibrinolysisprocess) changing their hemostatic functions. Oxidative/nitrative modifications of different components of haemostasis system have been observed in several cardiovascular diseases.     

Oxidant Sensing by Reversible Disulfide Bond Formation

Maintenance of the cellular redox balance is crucial for cell survival. An increase in reactive oxygen, nitrogen, or chlorine species can lead to oxidative stress conditions, potentially damaging DNA, lipids, and proteins. Proteins are very sensitive to oxidative modifications, particularly methionine and cysteine residues. The reversibility of some of these oxidative protein modifications makes them ideally suited to take on regulatory roles in protein function. This is especially true for disulfide bond formation, which has the potential to mediate extensive yet fully reversible structural and functional changes, rapidly adjusting the protein''s activity to the prevailing oxidant levels.     

A sensitive method for the quantitative measurement of protein thiol modification in response to oxidative stress

The combination of proteomics with highly specific and sensitive affinity techniques is important for the identification of posttranslational modifications by reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (ROS/RNS). One of the most pressing problems with this approach is to determine accurately the extent of modification of specific amino acids, such as cysteine residues, in a complex protein sample. A number of techniques relevant to free radical biology use biotin tagging as a method to follow protein modification with high sensitivity and specificity. To realize the potential of this approach to provide quantitative data, we have prepared a series of biotinylated proteins through the modification of lysine residues. These proteins were then used as quantitative standards in electrophoretic separation of protein samples labeled with biotin-conjugated iodoacetamide. The utility of the approach was assessed by measuring modification of thiols in response to exposure to thiol oxidants, as well as the amount of protein adduct formation with a biotin-tagged electrophilic lipid. Furthermore, using a combination of native and biotin-tagged cytochrome c, this method was used to quantitate the amount of thiol relative to the amount of protein in a given spot on a two-dimensional gel. Thus, we have developed a versatile, cost-effective standard that can be used in proteomic methods to quantitate biotin tags in response to oxidative stress.     

Mitochondrial protein tyrosine nitration

Mitochondria are primary loci for the intracellular formation and reactions of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species including superoxide (O???), hydrogen peroxide (H?O?) and peroxynitrite (ONOO?). Depending on formation rates and steady-state levels, the mitochondrial-derived short-lived reactive species contribute to signalling events and/or mitochondrial dysfunction through oxidation reactions. Among relevant oxidative modifications in mitochondria, the nitration of the amino acid tyrosine to 3-nitrotyrosine has been recognized in vitro and in vivo. This post-translational modification in mitochondria is promoted by peroxynitrite and other nitrating species and can disturb organelle homeostasis. This study assesses the biochemical mechanisms of protein tyrosine nitration within mitochondria, the main nitration protein targets and the impact of 3-nitrotyrosine formation in the structure, function and fate of modified mitochondrial proteins. Finally, the inhibition of mitochondrial protein tyrosine nitration by endogenous and mitochondrial-targeted antioxidants and their physiological or pharmacological relevance to preserve mitochondrial functions is analysed.     

Proteomic approaches to the characterization of protein thiol modification

Protein cysteine residues are central to redox signaling and to protection against oxidative damage through their interactions with reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, and electrophiles. Although there is considerable evidence for a functional role for cysteine modifications, the identity and physiological significance of most protein thiol alterations are unknown. One way to identify candidate proteins involved in these processes is to utilize the proteomic methodologies that have been developed in recent years for the identification of proteins that undergo cysteine modification in response to redox signals or oxidative damage. These tools have proven effective in uncovering novel protein targets of redox modification and are important first steps that allow for a better understanding of how reactive molecules may contribute to signaling and damage. Here, we discuss a number of these approaches and their application to the identification of a variety of cysteine-centered redox modifications.     

Retinal pigment epithelium lipofuscin proteomics

Lipofuscin accumulates with age in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) in discrete granular organelles and may contribute to age-related macular degeneration. Because previous studies suggest that lipofuscin contains protein that may impact pathogenic mechanisms, we pursued proteomics analysis of lipofuscin. The composition of RPE lipofuscin and its mechanisms of pathogenesis are poorly understood in part because of the heterogeneity of isolated preparations. We purified RPE lipofuscin granules by treatment with proteinase K or SDS and showed by light, confocal, and transmission electron microscopy that the purified granules are free of extragranular material and associated membranes. Crude and purified lipofuscin preparations were quantitatively compared by (i) LC MS/MS proteomics analyses, (ii) immunoanalyses of oxidative protein modifications, (iii) amino acid analysis, (iv) HPLC of bisretinoids, and (v) assaying phototoxicity to RPE cells. From crude lipofuscin preparations 186 proteins were identified, many of which appeared to be modified. In contrast, very little protein ( approximately 2% (w/w) by amino acid analysis) and no identifiable protein were found in the purified granules, which retained full phototoxicity to cultured RPE cells. Our analyses showed that granules in purified and crude lipofuscin preparations exhibit no statistically significant differences in diameter or circularity or in the content of the bisretinoids A2E, isoA2E, and all-trans-retinal dimer-phosphatidylethanolamine. The finding that the purified granules contain minimal protein yet retain phototoxic activity suggests that RPE lipofuscin pathogenesis is largely independent of associated protein. The purified granules also exhibited oxidative protein modifications, including nitrotyrosine generated from reactive nitrogen oxide species and carboxyethylpyrrole and iso[4]levuglandin E(2) adducts generated from reactive lipid fragments. This finding is consistent with previous studies demonstrating RPE lipofuscin to be a potent generator of reactive oxygen species and supports the hypothesis that such species, including reactive fragments from lipids and retinoids, contribute to the mechanisms of RPE lipofuscin pathogenesis.     

Structural proteomics of macromolecular assemblies using oxidative footprinting and mass spectrometry

Understanding the composition, structure and dynamics of macromolecules and their assemblies is at the forefront of biological science today. Hydroxyl-radical-mediated protein footprinting using mass spectrometry can define macromolecular structure, macromolecular assembly and conformational changes of macromolecules in solution based on measurements of reactivity of amino acid side-chain groups with covalent-modification reagents. Subsequent to oxidation by reactive oxygen species, proteins are digested by specific proteases to generate peptides for analysis by mass spectrometry. Accurate measurements of side-chain reactivity are achieved using quantitative liquid-chromatography-coupled mass spectrometry, whereas the side-chain sites within the macromolecular probes are identified using tandem mass spectrometry. In addition, the use of footprinting data in conjunction with computational modeling approaches is a powerful new method for testing and refining structural models of macromolecules and their complexes.     

SP3-Enabled Rapid and High Coverage Chemoproteomic Identification of Cell-State–Dependent Redox-Sensitive Cysteines

Proteinaceous cysteine residues act as privileged sensors of oxidative stress. As reactive oxygen and nitrogen species have been implicated in numerous pathophysiological processes, deciphering which cysteines are sensitive to oxidative modification and the specific nature of these modifications is essential to understanding protein and cellular function in health and disease. While established mass spectrometry-based proteomic platforms have improved our understanding of the redox proteome, the widespread adoption of these methods is often hindered by complex sample preparation workflows, prohibitive cost of isotopic labeling reagents, and requirements for custom data analysis workflows. Here, we present the SP3-Rox redox proteomics method that combines tailored low cost isotopically labeled capture reagents with SP3 sample cleanup to achieve high throughput and high coverage proteome-wide identification of redox-sensitive cysteines. By implementing a customized workflow in the free FragPipe computational pipeline, we achieve accurate MS1-based quantitation, including for peptides containing multiple cysteine residues. Application of the SP3-Rox method to cellular proteomes identified cysteines sensitive to the oxidative stressor GSNO and cysteine oxidation state changes that occur during T cell activation.     

SP3-Enabled Rapid and High Coverage Chemoproteomic Identification of Cell-State–Dependent Redox-Sensitive Cysteines

Proteinaceous cysteine residues act as privileged sensors of oxidative stress. As reactive oxygen and nitrogen species have been implicated in numerous pathophysiological processes, deciphering which cysteines are sensitive to oxidative modification and the specific nature of these modifications is essential to understanding protein and cellular function in health and disease. While established mass spectrometry-based proteomic platforms have improved our understanding of the redox proteome, the widespread adoption of these methods is often hindered by complex sample preparation workflows, prohibitive cost of isotopic labeling reagents, and requirements for custom data analysis workflows. Here, we present the SP3-Rox redox proteomics method that combines tailored low cost isotopically labeled capture reagents with SP3 sample cleanup to achieve high throughput and high coverage proteome-wide identification of redox-sensitive cysteines. By implementing a customized workflow in the free FragPipe computational pipeline, we achieve accurate MS1-based quantitation, including for peptides containing multiple cysteine residues. Application of the SP3-Rox method to cellular proteomes identified cysteines sensitive to the oxidative stressor GSNO and cysteine oxidation state changes that occur during T cell activation.     

Multiple Proteases to Localize Oxidation Sites

Proteins present in cellular environments with high levels of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species and/or low levels of antioxidants are highly susceptible to oxidative post-translational modification (PTM). Irreversible oxidative PTMs can generate a complex distribution of modified protein molecules, recently termed as proteoforms. Using ubiquitin as a model system, we mapped oxidative modification sites using trypsin, Lys-C, and Glu-C peptides. Several M+16 Da proteoforms were detected as well as proteoforms that include other previously unidentified oxidative modifications. This work highlights the use of multiple protease digestions to give insights to the complexity of oxidative modifications possible in bottom-up analyses.     

Analysis of human phagocyte flavocytochrome b(558) by mass spectrometry

The catalytic core of the phagocyte NADPH oxidase is a heterodimeric integral membrane protein (flavocytochrome b (Cyt b)) that generates superoxide and initiates a cascade of reactive oxygen species critical for the host inflammatory response. In order to facilitate structural characterization, the present study reports the first direct analysis of human phagocyte Cyt b by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization and nanoelectrospray mass spectrometry. Mass analysis of in-gel tryptic digest samples provided 73% total sequence coverage of the gp91(phox) subunit, including three of the six proposed transmembrane domains. Similar analysis of the p22(phox) subunit provided 72% total sequence coverage, including assignment of the hydrophobic N-terminal region and residues that are polymorphic in the human population. To initiate mass analysis of Cyt b post-translational modifications, the isolated gp91(phox) subunit was subject to sequential in-gel digestion with Flavobacterium meningosepticum peptide N-glycosidase F and trypsin, with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry/mass spectrometry used to demonstrate that Asn-132, -149, and -240 are genuinely modified by N-linked glycans in human neutrophils. Since the PLB-985 cell line represents an important model system for analysis of the NADPH oxidase, methods were developed for the purification of Cyt b from PLB-985 membrane fractions in order to confirm the appropriate modification of N-linked glycosylation sites on the recombinant gp91(phox) subunit. This study reports extensive sequence coverage of the integral membrane protein Cyt b by mass spectrometry and provides analytical methods that will be useful for evaluating posttranslational modifications involved in the regulation of superoxide production.     

The Redox Biochemistry of Protein Sulfenylation and Sulfinylation

Controlled generation of reactive oxygen species orchestrates numerous physiological signaling events (Finkel, T. (2011) Signal transduction by reactive oxygen species. J. Cell Biol. 194, 7–15). A major cellular target of reactive oxygen species is the thiol side chain (RSH) of Cys, which may assume a wide range of oxidation states (i.e. −2 to +4). Within this context, Cys sulfenic (Cys-SOH) and sulfinic (Cys-SO₂H) acids have emerged as important mechanisms for regulation of protein function. Although this area has been under investigation for over a decade, the scope and biological role of sulfenic/sulfinic acid modifications have been recently expanded with the introduction of new tools for monitoring cysteine oxidation in vitro and directly in cells. This minireview discusses selected recent examples of protein sulfenylation and sulfinylation from the literature, highlighting the role of these post-translational modifications in cell signaling.