Extraembryonic Endoderm cells as a model of endoderm development

In recent years the multipotent extraembryonic endoderm (XEN) stem cells have been the center of much attention. In vivo, XEN cells contribute to the formation of the extraembryonic endoderm, visceral and parietal endoderm and later on, the yolk sac. Recent data have shown that the distinction between embryonic and extraembryonic endoderm is not as strict as previously thought due to the integration, and not the displacement, of the visceral endoderm into the definitive embryonic endoderm. Therefore, cells from the extraembryonic endoderm also contribute to definitive endoderm. Many research groups focused on unraveling the potential and ability of XEN cells to both support differentiation and/or differentiate into endoderm‐like tissues as an alternative to embryonic stem (ES) cells. Moreover, the conversion of ES to XEN cells, shown recently without genetic manipulations, uncovers significant and novel molecular mechanisms involved in extraembryonic endoderm and definitive endoderm development. XEN cell lines provide a unique model for an early mammalian lineage that complements the established ES and trophoblast stem cell lines. Through the study of essential genes and signaling requirements for XEN cells in vitro, insights will be gained about the developmental program of the extraembryonic and embryonic endodermal lineage in vivo. This review will provide an overview on the current literature focusing on XEN cells as a model for primitive endoderm and possibly definitive endoderm as well as the potential of using these cells for therapeutic applications.     

Ras/MAPK pathway confers basement membrane dependence upon endoderm differentiation of embryonic carcinoma cells

The formation of extraembryonic endoderm is one of the earliest steps in the differentiation of pluripotent cells of the inner cell mass during the early stages of embryonic development. The primitive endoderm cells and the derived parietal and visceral endoderm cells gain the capacity to produce collagen IV and laminin. The deposition of these components results in the formation of basement membrane and epithelium of the endoderm, with polarized cells covering the inner surface of the blastocoels. We used retinoic acid-induced endoderm differentiation of stem cell-like F9 embryonic carcinoma cells to study the role of the Ras pathway and its regulation in the formation of the visceral endoderm. Upon endoderm differentiation of F9 cells induced by retinoic acid, c-Fos expression, the downstream target of the Ras pathway, is suppressed by uncoupling Elk-1 phosphorylation/activation to MAPK activity. However, attachment to matrix gel greatly enhances the activation of MAPK in endoderm cells but not in undifferentiated F9 cells. Enhanced MAPK activation as a result of contact with basement membrane is able to compensate for reduced Elk-1 phosphorylation and c-Fos expression. We conclude that endoderm differentiation renders the activation of the Ras pathway basement membrane dependent, contributing to the epithelial organization of the visceral endoderm.     

Paracrine promotion of cardiomyogenesis in embryoid bodies by LIF modulated endoderm

In the vertebrate embryo the heart is the first organ to form. Embryonic and extra-embryonic tissues are supposed to contribute to cardiac lineage commitment before and during gastrulation in a paracrine fashion. Evidence has accumulated that factors secreted by the anterior lateral endoderm and extra-embryonic endoderm contribute to cardiomyogenesis. Here we exploit in vitro differentiation of embryonic stem cells in embryoid bodies to study differentiation of the extraembryonic endodermal lineage, gastrulation-like processes, and the influence of endoderm on cardiomyogenesis. We demonstrate that in embryoid bodies primitive endoderm differentiates to visceral and parietal endoderm and that parietal endoderm influences onset of cardiomyogenesis in a concentration-dependent manner. Both increased concentrations of leukemia inhibitory factor and its absence in lif-/- embryoid bodies hampered parietal endoderm formation. Reduced differentiation of parietal endoderm correlated with an attenuation of cardiomyogenesis even in the presence of LIE These and previous results suggest that leukemia inhibitory factor is directly and indirectly, via endoderm formation, involved in the regulation of cardiomyogenesis. Increased proliferation of parietal endoderm in lifr -/- embryoid bodies and addition of conditioned lif -/- cell culture supernatant promoted cardiomyogenesis, demonstrating for the first time that parietal endoderm also contributes to cardiomyogenesis in embryoid bodies in a paracrine and leukemia inhibitory factor and its receptor independent pathway. New factors signaling independently of the leukemia inhibitory-factor receptor pathway may sustain cardiomyocyte cell proliferation and thus be a future target for gene therapy of cardiomyopathies and cell therapy of the myocardium.     

FGF10 signaling controls stomach morphogenesis

Maintenance of progenitor cell properties in development is required for proper organogenesis of most organs, including those derived from the endoderm. FGF10 has been shown to play a role in both lung and pancreatic development. Here we find that FGF10 signaling controls stomach progenitor maintenance, morphogenesis and cellular differentiation. Through a characterization of the initiation of terminal differentiation of the three major gastric regions in the mouse, forestomach, corpus and antrum, we first describe the existence of a "secondary transition" event occurring in mouse stomach between E15.5 and E16.5. This includes the formation of terminally differentiated squamous cells, parietal, chief and gastric endocrine cells from a pre-patterned gastric progenitor epithelium. Expression analysis of both FGF and Notch signaling components suggested a role of these networks in such progenitors, which was tested through ectopically expressing FGF10 in the developing posterior stomach. These data provide evidence that gastric gland specification and progenitor cell maintenance is controlled by FGF10. The glandular proliferative niche was disrupted in pPDX-FGF10(FLAG) mice leading to aberrant gland formation, and endocrine and parietal cell differentiation was attenuated. These effects were paralleled by changes in Hes1, Shh and Wnt6 expression, suggesting that FGF10 acts in concert with multiple morphogenetic signaling systems during gastric development.     

RXRalpha-null F9 embryonal carcinoma cells are resistant to the differentiation, anti-proliferative and apoptotic effects of retinoids.

The F9 murine embryonal carcinoma (EC) cell line, a well established model system for the study of retinoic acid (RA)-induced differentiation, differentiates into cells resembling three types of extra-embryonic endoderm (primitive, parietal and visceral), depending on the culture conditions and RA concentration used. A number of previously identified genes are differentially expressed during this process and serve as markers for the different endodermal cell types. Differentiation is also accompanied by a decreased rate of proliferation and an apoptotic response. Using homologous recombination, we have disrupted both alleles of the retinoid X receptor (RXR) alpha gene in F9 cells to investigate its role in mediating these responses. The loss of RXRalpha expression impaired the morphological differentiation of F9 EC cells into primitive and parietal endoderm, but has little effect on visceral endodermal differentiation. Concomitantly the inducibility of most primitive and parietal endoderm differentiation-specific genes was impaired, while several genes upregulated during visceral endodermal differentiation were induced normally. We also demonstrate that RXRalpha is required for both the anti-proliferative and apoptotic responses in RA-treated F9 cells. Additionally, we provide further evidence that retinoic acid receptor (RAR)-RXR heterodimers are the functional units transducing the effects of retinoids in F9 cells.     

Wnt6 induces the specification and epithelialization of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells to primitive endoderm

Epithelial-to-mesenchymal transitions (EMTs) play key roles in the normal development of an organism as well as its demise following the metastasis of a malignant tumour. An EMT during early mouse development results in the differentiation of primitive endoderm into the parietal endoderm that forms part of the parietal yolk sac. In the embryo, primitive endoderm develops from cells in the inner cell mass, but the signals that instruct these cells to become specified and adopt an epithelial fate are poorly understood. The mouse F9 teratocarcinoma cell line, a model that can recapitulate the in vivo primitive to parietal endoderm EMT, has been used extensively to elucidate the signalling cascades involved in extraembryonic endoderm differentiation. Here, we identified Wnt6 as a gene up-regulated in F9 cells in response to RA and show that Wnt6 expressing cells or cells exposed to Wnt6 conditioned media form primitive endoderm. Wnt6 induction of primitive endoderm is accompanied by beta-catenin and Snail1 translocation to the nucleus and the appearance of cytokeratin intermediate filaments. Attenuating glycogen synthase kinase 3 activity using LiCl gave similar results, but the fact that cells de-differentiate when LiCl is removed reveals that other signalling pathways are required to maintain cells as primitive endoderm. Finally, Wnt6-induced primitive endodermal cells were tested to determine their competency to complete the EMT and differentiate into parietal endoderm. Towards that end, results show that up-regulating protein kinase A activity is sufficient to induce markers of parietal endoderm. Together, these findings indicate that undifferentiated F9 cells are responsive to canonical Wnt signalling, which negatively regulates glycogen synthase kinase 3 activity leading to the epithelialization and specification of primitive endoderm competent to receive additional signals required for EMT. Considering the ability of F9 cells to mimic an in vivo EMT, the identification of this Wnt6-beta-catenin-Snail signalling cascade has broad implications for understanding EMT mechanisms in embryogenesis and metastasis.     

Signals governing extraembryonic endoderm formation in the mouse: involvement of the type 1 parathyroid hormone-related peptide (PTHrP) receptor, p21Ras and cell adhesion molecules

The formation of parietal endoderm (PE) from primitive endoderm (PrE) immediately after implantation of the early mouse embryo can be seen as the earliest example of an epithelio-mesenchyme transition (EMT) in murine development. Since EMT and EMI (epithelium-mesenchyme interactions) are at the very heart of morphogenesis, identifying molecular mechanisms governing these processes is of utmost importance. An excellent in vitro model system to study PE formation, i.e. F9 embryonal carcinoma cells, is available to this end. In the present paper we review our own recent results and those of others using these cells, and present our current view on the molecular mechanisms involved in PE formation.     

Establishing three blastocyst lineages--then what?

Development of the mouse embryo to the blastocyst stage occurs over 3 to 4 days following fertilization of the oocyte. During this time, several molecular and morphological events take place that result in the formation of three distinct cell lineages: the trophectoderm, the epiblast, and the primitive endoderm. Many studies have investigated the processes that control lineage specification in the blastocyst including gene expression, cell signaling, cell-cell contact/positional relationships, and most recently, epigenetics. Here we review, at the molecular level, recent contributions to our understanding of the mechanisms that play a role in formation of these lineages. Additionally, we focus on the next steps in differentiation to highlight processes important in the development of those lineages that contribute to the extraembryonic tissues. In this context, we discuss the establishment of extraembryonic ectoderm and the contributions of parietal and visceral endoderm to yolk sac formation.     

casanova plays an early and essential role in endoderm formation in zebrafish.

The cellular and molecular mechanisms that regulate endoderm development in vertebrates have only recently begun to be explored. Here we show that the zebrafish locus casanova plays an early and essential role in this process. casanova mutants lack a gut tube and do not express any molecular markers of endoderm differentiation. The early endodermal expression of genes such as axial, gata5, and fkd2 does not initiate in casanova mutants, indicating that the endoderm is defective from the onset of gastrulation. Mosaic analysis demonstrates that casanova functions cell autonomously within the endodermal progenitors. We also report the isolation of a zebrafish homologue of Mixer, a gene important for early endoderm formation in Xenopus. casanova does not encode zebrafish Mixer, and mixer expression is normal in casanova mutants, indicating that casanova acts downstream of, or parallel to, mixer to promote endoderm formation. We further find that the forerunner cells, a specialized group of noninvoluting dorsal mesendodermal cells, do not form in casanova mutants. Studies of casanova mutants do not support an important role for the forerunner cells in either dorsal axis or tail development, as has been previously proposed. In addition, although different populations of mesodermal precursors are generated normally in casanova mutants, morphogenetic defects in the heart, vasculature, blood, and kidney are apparent, suggesting a possible role for the endoderm in morphogenesis of these organs.     

Galpha13 activation rescues moesin-depletion induced apoptosis in F9 teratocarcinoma cells

Mouse F9 cells differentiate into primitive endoderm when treated with retinoic acid (RA) and into parietal endoderm in response to RA and dibutyryl (db-) cAMP. G protein signaling either blocks or mimics RA-induced differentiation, the latter signaling through the Wnt-beta-catenin pathway. In our study, we found that a constitutively active Galpha13 mutant induces F9 cells to differentiate into parietal endoderm in the absence of exogenous agents. Galpha13 expression and subsequent differentiation are accompanied by beta-catenin translocation to the nucleus. Differentiation and changes in cell morphology are supported by rearrangements to the F-actin cytoskeleton. ERM (ezrin-radixin-moesin) proteins, known to link F-actin to transmembrane receptors, are also redistributed during differentiation. Furthermore, morpholino antisense and shRNA approaches show that moesin expression is essential since its knockdown leads to altered F-actin distribution and subsequent apoptosis. Moesin-depleted cells, however, remain attached to the substrate when Galpha13 is constitutively expressed, but they do not differentiate into extraembryonic endoderm. Our study demonstrates a link between Galpha13 signaling that regulates differentiation of F9 cells through primitive to parietal endoderm and a moesin requirement for cell survival.     

Stepwise differentiation of human embryonic stem cells into early endoderm derivatives and their molecular characterization

Human embryonic stem cells have the potential to differentiate into all human cell types and therefore hold a great therapeutic promise. Differentiation into the embryonic endoderm and its derivatives is of special interest since it can provide a cure for severe widespread clinical conditions such as diabetes and hepatic failure. In this work we established a unique experimental outline that enables the study of early human endoderm development and can help improve and create new differentiation protocols. To this end we started with mesendoderm cells and separated them into early endoderm and mesoderm progenitor cells using CXCR4 and PDGFRA cell surface markers. We molecularly characterized the different lineages, and demonstrated the importance of the TGFβ pathway in definitive endoderm initiation. The endoderm progenitor cells were then purified creating an endodermal differentiation niche that is not affected by other cell populations. We followed the differentiation of these cells at different time points, and demonstrated an up regulation of genes indicative to differentiation into both foregut and hindgut. Surprisingly, upon continued culture, there was significant down regulation of the hepatic gene signature. This down regulation could be rescued with FGF2 treatment demonstrating its importance in hepatic cell maintenance. In conclusion, we suggest that isolating endoderm progenitor cells is crucial for the analysis of their fate, and enables the identification of factors involved in their differentiation and maintenance.     

Dynamic connexin43 expression and gap junctional communication during endoderm differentiation of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells

Gap junctional communication permits the direct intercellular exchange of small molecules and ions. In vertebrates, gap junctions are formed by the conjunction of two connexons, each consisting of a hexamer of connexin proteins, and are either established or degraded depending on the nature of the tissue formed. Gap junction function has been implicated in both directing developmental cell fate decisions and in tissue homeostasis/metabolite exchange. In mouse development, formation of the extra embryonal parietal endoderm from visceral endoderm is the first epithelial-mesenchyme transition to occur. This transition can be mimicked in vitro, by F9 embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells treated with retinoic acid, to form (epithelial) primitive or visceral endoderm, and then with parathyroid hormone-related peptide (PTHrP) to induce the transition to (mesenchymal) parietal endoderm. Here, we demonstrate that connexin43 mRNA and protein expression levels, protein phosphorylation and subcellular localization are dynamically regulated during F9 EC cell differentiation. Dye injection showed that this complex regulation of connexin43 is correlated with functional gap junctional communication. Similar patterns of connexin43 expression, localization and communication were found in visceral and parietal endoderm isolated ex vivo from mouse embryos at day 8.5 of gestation. However, in F9 cells this tightly regulated gap junctional communication does not appear to be required for the differentiation process as such.     

Identification of a novel glycopeptide species that correlates with differentiation of F9 cells

The high-molecular-weight fucosyl glycopeptides of differentiated F9 cells have been analyzed. We found that these high-molecular-weight surface structures contain two components with different molecular weights, the largest of which, peak I, has never before been reported. The material eluting in this peak seems to contain only acidic species. Removal of sialic acid from both the peak I and the peak II species does not eliminate the differences in molecular weight, indicating that the two species have more profound structural differences than can be accounted for by sialic acid. Since peak I glycopeptides were found both in differentiated F9 cells and in two parietal endoderm cell lines, we suggest that its presence is related to parietal endoderm differentiation.     

Evidence for the existence of an early common biochemical pathway in the differentiation of F9 cells into visceral or parietal endoderm: Modulation by cyclic AMP

The addition of dibutyryl cyclic AMP (dbcAMP) to aggregate cultures of F9 cells in medium containing retinoic acid (RA) directs the pathway of differentiation into parietal endoderm instead of visceral endoderm. We examined the levels of some of the markers that characterize the two pathways and studied the time of commitment of cells to either direction of differentiation by using immunoprecipitation and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA). For either pathway, the levels and patterns of laminin, type IV collagen, and fibronectin are the same on the first day of differentiation, characterized by slightly decreased levels of laminin and type IV collagen synthesis and an increased level of fibronectin synthesis. These levels reverse on the second day of culture when the pathways diverge markedly. The differentiation pathway, however, can be redirected into the alternate one; parietal endoderm cells become committed after 3 days, whereas visceral endoderm cells are able to change into parietal endoderm cells at any time. Thus, α-fetoprotein (AFP)-producing F9 embryoid bodies switched to dbcAMP-containing medium lose the capacity to synthesize AFP and start to express genes characteristic of parietal endoderm. Our results indicate that at least some visceral endoderm cells may redifferentiate into parietal endoderm cells. These phenomena thus mimic features of endoderm differentiation in the mouse embryo.     

A teratocarcinoma-derived endoderm stem cell line (1H5) that can differentiate into extra-embryonic endoderm cell types

We investigated the ability of the teratocarcinoma-derived, epithelial-type cell line 1H5 to differentiate into either of the two pathways to primary endoderm, and tested the hypothesis that 1H5 represents a state similar to primitive endoderm in the late 4th-day blastocyst. Like other endodermal cell types, 1H5 cells mixed with embryonal-carcinoma cells sort out into "embryoid bodies" or structures that resemble 4th-day mouse embryos. The epithelial line conforms morphologically and biochemically to the few known characteristics typical of primitive endoderm. The present study demonstrates that the formation in vitro of overt visceral endoderm is readily achieved. The spontaneous arrangement of the cells into a cystic form is followed by the appearance of several markers of visceral endoderm, most notably alphafetoprotein, which is detected when 1H5 cells are cultured either in the presence of retinoic acid or when the cells interact with embryonal-carcinoma cells in a specific spatial arrangement after sorting out. However, some less specific properties of visceral endoderm are not expressed. Although 1H5 differentiates histologically into parietal-like endoderm in the tumor form, parietal cells cannot yet be identified with certainty in vitro because of the paucity of parietal-specific markers. The 1H5 cell line could provide a useful system for studying the characteristics and mechanisms underlying visceral-endoderm differentiation in vitro, since it has the distinct advantage that homogeneous cultures are produced, in contrast to other teratocarcinoma cell lines such as F9 which differentiate into a mixture of cell types.     

A system to enrich for primitive streak-derivatives, definitive endoderm and mesoderm, from pluripotent cells in culture

Two lineages of endoderm develop during mammalian embryogenesis, the primitive endoderm in the pre-implantation blastocyst and the definitive endoderm at gastrulation. This complexity of endoderm cell populations is mirrored during pluripotent cell differentiation in vitro and has hindered the identification and purification of the definitive endoderm for use as a substrate for further differentiation. The aggregation and differentiation of early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells, resulting in the formation of EPL-cell derived embryoid bodies (EPLEBs), is a model of gastrulation that progresses through the sequential formation of primitive streak-like intermediates to nascent mesoderm and more differentiated mesoderm populations. EPL cell-derived EBs have been further analysed for the formation of definitive endoderm by detailed morphological studies, gene expression and a protein uptake assay. In comparison to embryoid bodies derived from ES cells, which form primitive and definitive endoderm, the endoderm compartment of embryoid bodies formed from EPL cells was comprised almost exclusively of definitive endoderm. Definitive endoderm was defined as a population of squamous cells that expressed Sox17, CXCR4 and Trh, which formed without the prior formation of primitive endoderm and was unable to endocytose horseradish peroxidase from the medium. Definitive endoderm formed in EPLEBs provides a substrate for further differentiation into specific endoderm lineages; these lineages can be used as research tools for understanding the mechanisms controlling lineage establishment and the nature of the transient intermediates formed. The similarity between mouse EPL cells and human ES cells suggests EPLEBs can be used as a model system for the development of technologies to enrich for the formation of human ES cell-derived definitive endoderm in the future.