A note on sequence-dependence of DNA structure

A circular dichroism study was conducted on the solution structure of several different oligonucleotides, whose X-ray structures have been solved. It is suggested that in aqueous solution the oligonucleotides can form structures that maintain geometrical elements which are typical of B-DNA, A-DNA, and their intermediate forms. It is shown that 5'GGATGGGAG:5'CTCCCATCC, which forms an A-DNA helix in the crystal state (McCall et al. 1986), in aqueous solution maintains an A-DNA like structure at temperatures below 10 degrees C. At temperatures between 10 degrees C and 25 degrees C it shows a tendency to form an intermediate structure between A-DNA and B-DNA. Also, it is shown that TFE does not cause a transition from B-DNA to A-DNA helix in short DNA fragments, but instead disrupts the helix.     

The potentially Z-DNA-forming sequence d(GTGTACAC) crystallizes as A-DNA

(GT)n/(CA)n sequences have stimulated much interest because of their frequent occurrence in eukaryotic DNA and their potential for forming the left-handed Z-DNA structure. We here report the X-ray crystal structure of a self-complementary octadeoxynucleotide, d(GTGTACAC), at 2.5 A resolution. The molecule adopts a right-handed double-helical conformation belonging to the A-DNA family. In this alternating purine-pyrimidine DNA minihelix the roll and twist angles show alternations qualitatively consistent with Calladine's rules. The average tilt angle of 9.3 degrees is between the values found in A-DNA (19 degrees) and B-DNA (-6 degrees) fibers. It is envisaged that such intermediate conformations may render diversity to genomic DNA. The base-pair tilt angles and the base-pair displacements from the helix axis are found to be correlated for the known A-DNA double-helical fragments.     

Base sequence, local helix structure, and macroscopic curvature of A-DNA and B-DNA

Given a specified DNA sequence and starting with an idealized conformation for the double helix (A-DNA or B-DNA), the dependence of conformational energy on variations in the local geometry of the double helix can be examined by computer modeling. By averaging over all thermally accessible states, it is possible to determine 1) how the optimum local structure differs from the initial idealized conformation and 2) the energetic costs of small structural deformations. This paper describes such a study. Tables are presented for the prediction of helix twist angles and base pair roll angles for both A-DNA and B-DNA when the sequence has been specified. Local deviations of helix parameters from their average values can accumulate to produce a net curvature of the molecule, a curvature that can be sharp enough to be experimentally detectable. As an independent check on the method, the calculations provide predictions for the longitudinal compressibility (Young's modulus) and the average torsional stiffness, both of which are in good agreement with experimental values. In examining the role of sequence-dependent variations in helix structure for the recognition of specific sequences by proteins, we have calculated the energy needed to deform the self-complementary hexanucleotide d(CAATTG) to match the local geometry of d(GAATTC), which is the sequence recognized by the EcoRI restriction endonuclease. That energy would be sufficient to reduce the binding of the incorrect sequence to the protein by over 2 orders of magnitude relative to the correct sequence.     

Three-dimensional structure of d(GGGATCCC) in the crystalline state.

The structure of the self-complementary octamer d(GGGATCCC) has been analysed by single crystal X-ray diffraction methods at a nominal resolution of 2.5 A. With acceptable stereochemistry of the model the crystallographic R factor was 16.6% after restrained least-squares refinement. In the crystal, d(GGGATCCC) forms an A-DNA double helix with slightly varying conformation of the two strands. The average displacement of the base pairs from the helix axis is unusually large and is accompanied by pronounced sliding of the base pairs along their long axes at all dinucleotide steps except for the central AT. With 12 base pairs per complete turn the helix is considerably underwound. As observed with most oligodeoxyribonucleotides analysed by X-ray crystallography so far, the octamer displays reduced base pair tilt, increased rise per base pair and a more open major groove compared with canonical A-DNA. We propose that, based on these parameters, three A-helical sub-families may be defined; d(GGGATCCC) then is a representative of the class with intermediate tilt, rise, and major groove width.     

Influence of counter-ions on the crystal structures of DNA decamers: binding of [Co(NH3)6]3+ and Ba2+ to A-DNA.

A-DNA is a stable alternative right-handed double helix that is favored by certain sequences (e.g., (dG)n.(dC)n) or under low humidity conditions. Earlier A-DNA structures of several DNA oligonucleotides and RNA.DNA chimeras have revealed some conformational variation that may be the result of sequence-dependent effects or crystal packing forces. In this study, four crystal structures of three decamer oligonucleotides, d(ACCGGCCGGT), d(ACCCGCGGGT), and r(GC)d(GTATACGC) in two crystal forms (either the P6(1)22 or the P2(1)2(1)2(1) space group) have been analyzed at high resolution to provide the molecular basis of the structural difference in an experimentally consistent manner. The study reveals that molecules crystallized in the same space group have a more similar A-DNA conformation, whereas the same molecule crystallized in different space groups has different (local) conformations. This suggests that even though the local structure is influenced by the crystal packing environments, the DNA molecule adjusts to adopt an overall conformation close to canonical A-DNA. For example, the six independent CpG steps in these four structures have different base-base stacking patterns, with their helical twist angles (omega) ranging from 28 degrees to 37 degrees. Our study further reveals the structural impact of different counter-ions on the A-DNA conformers. [Co(NH3)6]3+ has three unique A-DNA binding modes. One binds at the major groove side of a GpG step at the O6/N7 sites of guanine bases via hydrogen bonds. The other two modes involve the binding of ions to phosphates, either bridging across the narrow major groove or binding between two intra-strand adjacent phosphates. Those interactions may explain the recent spectroscopic and NMR observations that [Co(NH3)6]3+ is effective in inducing the B- to A-DNA transition for DNA with (G)n sequence. Interestingly, Ba2+ binds to the same O6/N7 sites on guanine by direct coordinations.     

Molecular structure of an A-DNA decamer d(ACCGGCCGGT)

The molecular structure of the DNA decamer d(ACCGGCCGGT) has been solved and refined by single-crystal X-ray-diffraction analysis at 0.20 nm to a final R-factor of 18.0%. The decamer crystallizes as an A-DNA double helical fragment with unit-cell dimensions of a = b = 3.923 nm and c = 7.80 nm in the space group P6(1)22. The overall conformation of this A-DNA decamer is very similar to that of the fiber model for A-DNA which has a large average base-pair tilt and hence a wide and shallow minor groove. This structure is in contrast to that of several A-DNA octamers in which the molecules all have low base-pair-tilt angles (8-12 degrees) resulting in an appearance intermediate between B-DNA and A-DNA. The average helical parameters of this decamer are typical of A-DNA with 10.9 base pairs/turn of helix, an average helical twist angle of 33.1 degrees, and a base-pair-tilt angle of 18.2 degrees. However, the CpG step in this molecule has a low local-twist angle of 24.5 degrees, similar to that seen in other A-DNA oligomers, and therefore appears to be an intrinsic stacking pattern for this step. The molecules pack in the crystal using a recurring binding motif, namely, the terminal base pair of one helix abuts the surface of the shallow minor groove of another helix. In addition, the GC base pairs have large propeller-twist angles, unlike those found most other A-DNA structures.     

The crystal structure of d(CCCCGGGG): a new A-form variant with an extended backbone conformation

The crystal structure of d(CCCCGGGG) has been determined at a resolution of 2.25 A. The oligomers crystallize as A-DNA duplexes occupying crystallographic two-fold axes. The backbone conformation is, in general, similar to that observed in previously reported crystal structures of A-DNA fragments, except for the central linkage, where it adopts an extended structure resulting from all trans conformation at the P-O5'-C5'-C4' bonds. This type of conformation facilitates interstrand stacking between the guanines at the C-G site. The local helix twist at this step is very small (25 degrees) compared to an overall average of 33.5 degrees. The unique structure of the C-G base-pair step, namely the extended backbone and the distinct stacking geometry, may be an important feature in the recognition mechanism between double-stranded DNA molecules and restriction endonucleases such as Msp I, which cuts the sequence CCGG very specifically with a rate unaffected by neighboring base pairs.     

A new D-DNA form of poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT): an A-DNA type structure with reversed Hoogsteen pairing

The D-DNA double helix model of poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) proposed in the literature is not in accordance with some notable experimental facts and physicochemical conditions to which it is related. Thus, the fibre X-ray diffraction pattern of D-DNA obtained at a relative humidity lower than that giving the A-DNA form is singularly not taken into account when one assumes that there is only one D structure of B-DNA type. We rather suggest that there are actually two different forms of D-DNA, namely D(A) which partakes in the D-A-B transitions and D(B) associated with the D-B change of conformation. Although these two DNA structures have the same helical parameters (pitch and number of residues per turn), in agreement with X-ray data, their detailed conformations are considerably different. Whereas D(B) is indeed the structure generally defined as D-DNA, a critical analysis based on a comparison between different possible DNA double helices leads us to propose dihedral angles, a set of atomic coordinates and a stereo view of another new form of D-DNA, the D(A) structural model. It is a right-handed double helix with a dinucleotide as the repeat unit. The furanose rings are of the A-DNA type (C3' endo) and the bases are hydrogen bonded according to the reversed Hoogsteen pairing. Such a disposition renders the D(A) model unsuitable for poly(dI-dC).poly(dI-dC), the other alternating polynucleotide observed in the D(B) structure. The consistency of these two different D-DNA structures of poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) with the general aspects of hydration and helix-helix transitions of DNA, as well as with the conformational variability of AT base sequences, is discussed.     

The Crystal Structure of d(CCCCGGGG): A New A-Form Variant with an Extended Backbone Conformation

Abstract

The crystal structure of d(CCCCGGGG) has been determined at a resolution of 2.25Å. The oligomers crystallize as A-DNA duplexes occupying crystallographic two-fold axes. The backbone conformation is, in general, similar to that observed in previously reported crystal structures of A-DNA fragments, except for the central linkage, where it adopts an extended structure resulting from all trans conformation at the P-05′-C5′-C4′ bonds. This type of conformation facilitates interstrand stacking between the guanines at the C-G site. The local helix twist at this step is very small (25°) compared to an overall average of 33.5°. The unique structure of the C-G base-pair step, namely the extended backbone and the distinct stacking geometry, may be an important feature in the recognition mechanism between double- stranded DNA molecules and restriction endonucleases such as Msp I, which cuts the sequence CCGG very specifically with a rate unaffected by neighboring base pairs.     

Neomycin, spermine and hexaamminecobalt (III) share common structural motifs in converting B- to A-DNA.

The (dG)n.(dC)n-containing 34mer DNA duplex [d(A2G15C15T2)]2 can be effectively converted from the B-DNA to the A-DNA conformation by neomycin, spermine and Co(NH3)6(3+). Conversion is demonstrated by a characteristic red shift in the circular dichroism spectra and dramatic NMR spectral changes in chemical shifts. Additional support comes from the substantially stronger CH6/GH8-H3'NOE intensities of the ligand-DNA complexes than those from the native DNA duplex. Such changes are consistent with a deoxyribose pucker transition from the predominate C2'-endo (S-type) to the C3'-endo (N-type). The changes for all three ligand-DNA complexes are identical, suggesting that those three complex cations share common structural motifs for the B- to A-DNA conversion. The A-DNA structure of the 4:1 complex of Co(NH3)6(3+)/d(ACCCGCGGGT) has been analyzed by NOE-restrained refinement. The structural basis of the transition may be related to the closeness of the two negatively charged sugar-phosphate backbones along the major groove in A-DNA, which can be effectively neutralized by the multivalent positively charged amine functions of these ligands. In addition, ligands like spermine or Co(NH3)6(3+) can adhere to guanine bases in the deep major groove of the double helix, as is evident from the significant direct NOE cross-peaks from the protons of Co(NH3)6(3+) to GH8, GH1 (imino) and CH4 (amino) protons. Our results point to future directions in preparing more potent derivatives of Co(NH3)6(3+) for RNA binding or the induction of A-DNA.     

The extended and eccentric E-DNA structure induced by cytosine methylation or bromination

Cytosine methylation or bromination of the DNA sequence d(GGCGCC)2 is shown here to induce a novel extended and eccentric double helix, which we call E-DNA. Like B-DNA, E-DNA has a long helical rise and bases perpendicular to the helix axis. However, the 3'-endo sugar conformation gives the characteristic deep major groove and shallow minor groove of A-DNA. Also, if allowed to crystallize for a period of time longer than that yielding E-DNA, the methylated sequence forms standard A-DNA, suggesting that E-DNA is a kinetically trapped intermediate in the transition to A-DNA. Thus, the structures presented here chart a crystallographic pathway from B-DNA to A-DNA through the E-DNA intermediate in a single sequence. The E-DNA surface is highly accessible to solvent, with waters in the major groove sitting on exposed faces of the stacked nucleotides. We suggest that the geometry of the waters and the stacked base pairs would promote the spontaneous deamination of 5-methylcytosine in the transition mutation of dm5C-dG to dT-dA base pairs.     

The crystal structure of d(GTACGTAC) at 2.25 A resolution: are the A-DNA's always unwound approximately 10 degrees at the C-G steps?

The structure of the self-complementary octamer d(GTACGTAC) has been analyzed by a single crystal X-ray diffraction method at 2.25 A resolution. The crystallographic R factor was 0.184 for all 1233 reflections at this resolution. In spite of the alternating purine-pyrimidine sequence, d(GTACGTAC) adopts the A-form conformation rather than the left-handed Z-form. The average helix twist and the mean rise per base pair are 32.1 degrees and 3.18 A, respectively. The d(GTACGTAC) helix is characterized by a wide open major groove and small base-pair tilt (9.7 degrees). The partial unwinding of the helix is observed only at the central pyrimidine-purine C-G step, but not at the other pyrimidine-purine T-A steps. Based on this study and six other X-ray studies, we propose a hypothesis that the A-DNA's are always unwound approximately 10 degrees at the C-G steps. Significant differences in base-pair stacking modes are seen between the purine-pyrimidine step and the pyrimidine-purine step. All deoxyribose rings adopt the C3'-endo conformation. All backbone torsion angles fall into the range expected for the A-DNA form, except for the nucleotide G5, whose alpha and gamma torsion angles adopt the trans, trans conformation instead of the common gauche-, gauche+ conformation.     

The synthetic DNA duplex of poly d(Abr5U).poly d(Abr5U) adopts an A-DNA-like structure

An X-ray fiber diffraction study of the synthetic DNA duplex poly d(Abr5U).poly d(Abr5U) shows that its sodium salt adopts an unexceptional A-DNA-like structure. Similar to A-DNA, two molecules are packed in a monoclinic unit cell (a = 2.23 nm, b = 4.14 nm, c = 5.61 nm and alpha = beta = gamma = 90 degrees) of space group C2. Because of its dinucleotide chemical motif, the c-repeat is twice that in A-DNA but, notably, corresponding backbone conformation angles of adjacent nucleotides are almost identical. This is in marked contrast to many B-like conformations of polydinucleotides.     

Crystal structure analysis of an A-DNA fragment at 1.8 A resolution: d(GCCCGGGC).

Single crystals of the self-complementary octadeoxyribonucleotide d(GCCCGGGC) have been analysed by X-ray diffraction methods at a resolution of 1.8 A. The tetragonal unit cell of space group P4(3)2(1)2 has dimensions of a = 43.25 A and c = 24.61 A and contains eight strands of the oligonucleotide. The structure was refined by standard crystallographic techniques to an R factor of 17.1% using 1359 3 sigma structure factor observations. Two strands of the oligonucleotide are related by the crystallographic dyad axis to form a DNA helix in the A conformation. The d(GCCCGGGC) helix is characterized by a wide open major groove, a near perpendicular orientation of base pairs to the helix axis and an unusually small average helix twist angle of 31.3 degrees indicating a slightly underwound helix with 11.5 base pairs per turn. Extensive cross-strand stacking between guanine bases at the central cytosine-guanine step is made possible by a number of local conformational adjustments including a fully extended sugar-phosphate backbone of the central guanosine nucleotide.     

Crystal structure of the self-complementary 5''-purine start decamer d(GCACGCGTGC) in the A-DNA conformation. II.

The crystal structure of the alternating 5'-purine start decamer d(GCGCGCGCGC) was found to be in the left-handed Z-DNA conformation. Inasmuch as the A.T base pair is known to resist Z-DNA formation, we substituted A.T base pairs in the dyad-related positions of the decamer duplex. The alternating self-complementary decamer d(GCACGCGTGC) crystallizes in a different hexagonal space group, P6(1)22, with very different unit cell dimensions a = b = 38.97 and c = 77.34 A compared with the all-G.C alternating decamer. The A.T-containing decamer has one strand in the asymmetric unit, and because it is isomorphous to some other A-DNA decamers it was considered also to be right-handed. The structure was refined, starting with the atomic coordinates of the A-DNA decamer d(GCGGGCCCGC), by use of 2491 unique reflections out to 1.9-A resolution. The refinement converged to an R value of 18.6% for a total of 202 nucleotide atoms and 32 water molecules. This research further demonstrates that A.T base pairs not only resist the formation of Z-DNA but can also assist the formation of A-DNA by switching the helix handedness when the oligomer starts with a 5'-purine; also, the length of the inner Z-DNA stretch (d(CG)n) is reduced from an octamer to a tetramer. It may be noted that these oligonucleotide properties are in crystals and not necessarily in solutions.     

Hexagonal crystal structure of the A-DNA octamer d(GTGTACAC) and its comparison with the tetragonal structure: correlated variations in helical parameters

The alternating DNA octamer d(GTGTACAC) has been grown in a novel hexagonal crystal form. The structure has been determined and refined to a 2-A resolution, with 51 water molecules. The A-DNA conformation is a variant of that observed for the tetragonal form of the same sequence (Jain et al., 1989) containing a bound spermine. The crystals belong to the space group P6(1)22, a = b = 32.40 A and c = 79.25 A, with one strand in the asymmetric unit. The new hexagonal structure was solved by rotation and translation searches in direct space and refined to a final R value of 12.7% by using 1561 unique reflections greater than 1.5 sigma (I). The electron density clearly shows that the penultimate A7 sugar had flipped into the alternative C2'-endo pucker. This dent in the molecule can be attributed to close intermolecular contacts. In contrast, in the tetragonal structure, the DNA is distorted in the central TA step, where the A5 backbone bonds C4'-C5' and O5'-P assume trans conformations. The hexagonal double helix more closely resembles the fiber diffraction A-DNA, compared to the tetragonal form. For instance, the tilt angle is higher (16 degrees vs 10 degrees), which is correlated with a larger displacement from the helix axis (3.5 vs 3.3), a lower rise per residue (2.9 vs 3.2), and a smaller major-groove width (6.1 vs 8.7), thus indicating that the variations in these global helical parameters are correlated. The propeller twist angles in both forms are higher for the G-C base pairs (15.3 degrees, 12.14 degrees) than for the A-T base pairs (10.8 degrees, 9.1 degrees), which is the reverse of the expected order. Unlike the tetragonal structure, the hexagonal crystal structure interestingly does not contain a bound spermine molecule. Our analysis reveals that the conformational differences between the tetragonal and hexagonal forms are not entirely due to the spermine binding, and crystal packing seems to play an important role.     

Nucleic acid-metal interactions: V. The effect of silver(I) on the structures of A- and B-DNA forms

The interaction of silver(I) with DNA has been studied with uv LD in aqueous solution and in a humid anisotropic poly(vinyl alcohol) host (B-DNA) and also in 80% ethanolic solution (A-DNA). Addition of silver ions has a pronounced effect on the dichroic spectra of DNA, indicating that the DNA structure is significantly altered. By correlation with calculated reduced LD spectra, using intensities and moments of the corresponding electronic transitions of the DNA bases, the experimental spectra of DNA at high silver content may be interpreted in terms of tilt and roll angles of the bases in the double helix. In ethanolic A-DNA solution there is a pronounced decrease in the orientation by flow of DNA, suggesting that the complexation of DNA to silver may be accompanied by the formation of compact tertiary structures.     

Progressive DNA bending is made possible by gradual changes in the torsion angle of the glycosyl bond.

Structural comparisons have led to the suggestion that the conformational rearrangement that would be required to change A-DNA into the TA-DNA form of DNA observed in the complex with the TATA box binding protein (TBP) could be completed by modifying only the value of the glycosyl bond chi by approximately 45 degrees. The lack of a high number of crystal structures of this type makes it difficult to conclude whether a smooth transition from A-DNA to TA-DNA can occur without disrupting at any point either the Watson-Crick base pairing or the A-DNA conformation of the backbone. To explore the possibility of such a smooth transition, constrained molecular dynamics simulations were carried out for the double-stranded dodecamer d(GGTATATAAAAC), in which a transition from A-DNA to TA-DNA was induced by modifying only the chi angle values. The results demonstrate the feasibility of a continuous path in the A-DNA to TA-DNA transition. Varying extents of DNA curvature are also attainable, by maintaining the A-DNA backbone structure and Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding while changing the chi angle value smoothly from that in A-DNA to one corresponding to B-DNA.     

Low-frequency dynamics and Raman scattering of crystals, of B-, A-, and Z-DNA, and fibers of C-DNA

Normal modes of vibration of DNA in the low-frequency region (10-300 cm-1 interval) have been identified from Raman spectra of crystals of B-DNA [d(CGCAAATTTGCG)], A-DNA [r(GCG)d(CGC) and d(CCCCGGGG)], and Z-DNA [d(CGCGCG) and d(CGCGTG)]. The lowest vibrational frequencies detected in the canonical DNA structures--at 18 +/- 2 cm-1 in the B-DNA crystal, near 24 +/- 2 cm-1 in A-DNA crystals, and near 30 +/- 2 cm-1 in Z-DNA crystals--are shown to correlate well with the degree of DNA hydration in the crystal structures, as well as with the level of hydration in calf thymus DNA fibers. These findings support the assignment [H. Urabe et al. (1985) J. Chem. Phys. 82, 531-535; C. Demarco et al. (1985) Biopolymers 24, 2035-2040] of the lowest frequency Raman band of each DNA to a helix mode, which is dependent primarily upon the degree of helix hydration, rather than upon the intrahelical conformation. The present results show also that B-, A-, C-, and Z-DNA structures can be distinguished from one another on the basis of their characteristic Raman intensity profiles in the region of 40-140 cm-1, even though all structures display two rather similar and complex bands centered within the intervals of 66-72 and 90-120 cm-1. The similarity of Raman frequencies for B-, A-, C-, and Z-DNA suggests that these modes originate from concerted motions of the bases (librations), which are not strongly dependent upon helix backbone geometry or handedness. Correlation of the Raman frequencies and intensities with the DNA base compositions suggests that the complex band near 90-120 cm-1 in all double-helix structures is due to in-plane librational motions of the bases, which involve stretching of the purine-pyrimidine hydrogen bonds. This would explain the centering of the band at higher frequencies in structures containing G.C pairs (greater than 100 cm-1) than in structures containing A.T pairs (less than 100 cm-1), consistent with the strengths of G.C and A.T hydrogen bonding.