A proposed classification of environmental adaptation: the example of high altitude

Extreme environments are defined as the opposite of usual environments where the evoked physiological responses are unperceivable, repeatable and adjusted to the constraint. Adaptation strategies to a given environment show three levels: cultural or technological, where a buffer space is built to protect the organism from the hostile milieu, physiological, where temporary adaptive mechanisms are developed, and genetic, where full adaptation is possible with normal life and reproduction. The cost of adaptation increases from the genetic level (minimal cost) to the technological level. These concepts are illustrated by the example of adaptation to altitude hypoxia. The technological level is given by the use of oxygen bottles by high altitude climbers. The physiological level involves various physiological and biological systems (increase in heart rate, ventilation, erythropoiesis, expression of hypoxia-inducible factors, etc.). The genetic level has been reached by some animal species such as Yaks, Llamas, Pikas but has not yet been demonstrated in humans. Diseases developed during exposure to acute or chronic hypoxia may be considered as “adaptive crises” that mimic the transition to a lower energy level of adaptation.     

The role of heparin and tissue-type plasminogen activator in the adaptation of the hemostatic system to high altitude]

The role of endogenous heparin and tissue-type plasminogen activator in the middle-period (25 days) adaptation of haemostasis to high altitude (altitude 3200 m) and formation or "high-altitude hypocoagulation" was studied in the experiments on white rats. It was observed that the formation of "high-altitude hypocoagulation" is connected with an increase of heparin and tissue-type plasminogen activator level due to its release from must and endothelial cells to the bloodstream. Histochemical analysis showed that at the course of adaptation to high altitude the increase in blood heparin level was caused by the stimulation of must cells secretory activity. The endothelium of lung vessels is the main source of tissue-type plasminogen activator release into the blood. The existence of interconnection between the changes in haemostasis and stimulation of angiogenesis at high altitude is proposed.     

Spleen and thymus lymphoid tissue in hypoxia (a biometric study)

The spleen and thymus have been studied macro- and microscopically in rats (180-200 g body mass) on the 1st, 3d, 5th, 7th, 14th and 28th days of adaptation to a decreased atmospheric pressure in the altitude chamber corresponding to lifting to 5,000 and 7,500 m (after a preliminary gradual acclimatization) and on the 14th, 28th, 42d, 56th days of readaptation. A relative mass of the organs, the white pulp section area--the transversal section area of the spleen ratio, the summation section area of its lymph nodules have been estimated. In the thymus the cortico-medullary index (CMI) has been defined. A relative mass of the spleen increases during the first week of hypoxia, and during adaptation period it somewhat decreases and stabilizes, remaining higher than in the control. At the altitude of 5,000 m the cross section area of the lymph nodules decreases by 17% on the 28th adaptation day and at the altitude of 7,500 m--by 27% beginning from the 14th up to the 28th adaptation days. In the thymus the CMI, after some decrease during the first days of hypoxia at the altitude of 5,000 m, increases and normalizes on the 28th adaptation day, and at the altitude of 7,500 m stabilizes on the 14th - 28th days of hypoxia. When the rats are at the altitudes of 5,000 and 7,500 m the thymus lymphoid tissue reacts more quickly to the hypoxia effect and much sooner normalizes during the readaptation period than does the white pulp of the spleen. The main changes in the lymphoid tissue of the spleen and thymus take place on the 7th - 28th days of hypoxia.     

Selection signatures for high-altitude adaptation in ruminants

High-altitude areas are important socio-economical habitats with ruminants serving as a major source of food and commodities for humans. Living at high altitude, however, is extremely challenging, predominantly due to the exposure to hypoxic conditions, but also because of cold temperatures and limited feed for livestock. To survive in high-altitude environments over the long term, ruminants have evolved adaptation strategies, e.g. physiological and morphological modifications, which allow them to cope with these harsh conditions. Identification of such selection signatures in ruminants may contribute to more informed breeding decisions, and thus improved productivity. Moreover, studying the genetic background of altitude adaptation in ruminants provides insights into a common molecular basis across species and thus a better understanding of the physiological basis of this adaptation. In this paper, we review the major effects of high altitude on the mammalian body and highlight some of the most important short-term (coping) and genetically evolved (adaptation) physiological modifications. We then discuss the genetic architecture of altitude adaptation and target genes that show evidence of being under selection based on recent studies in various species, with a focus on ruminants. The yak is presented as an interesting native species that has adapted to the high-altitude regions of Tibet. Finally, we conclude with implications and challenges of selection signature studies on altitude adaptation in general. We found that the number of studies on genetic mechanisms that enable altitude adaptation in ruminants is growing, with a strong focus on identifying selection signatures, and hypothesise that the investigation of genetic data from multiple species and regions will contribute greatly to the understanding of the genetic basis of altitude adaptation.     

Hemoglobin levels in a Himalayan high altitude population

This report presents data on hemoglobin concentrations in a sample of Himalayan high altitude natives measured at their habitual altitude of residence. In this sample of 270 healthy Tibetan adults resident at 3250–3560 m in Upper Chumik, Nepal, the mean hemoglobin concentration is 16.1 ± 1.2 gm/dl among adult males, 14.4 ± 1.4 gm/dl among premenopausal and 15.0 ± 1.1 gm/dl among postmenopausal adult females. 123 of 126 (98%) males, 96 of 100 (96%) premenopausal and 36 of 44 (82%) postmenopausal females have hemoglobin concentrations within two standard deviations of the sea level mean. These data demonstrate that a healthy population may reside at high altitude without the degree of elevation in hemoglobin widely known and cited for Andean highlanders. Comparing published data on mean hemoglobin concentrations of adult Himalayan and Andean samples residing between 3200 m and 4100 m reveals that Himalayan means are systematically lower. This in turn may account for the reported population differences in the prevalence of chronic mountain sickness (Monge's disease). It is hypothesized that Himalayan and Andean highlanders represent alternative patterns of high altitude hematological adaptation.     

A model of erythropoiesis in adults with sufficient iron availability

In this paper we present a model for erythropoiesis under the basic assumption that sufficient iron availability is guaranteed. An extension of the model including a sub-model for the iron dynamics in the body is topic of present research efforts. The model gives excellent results for a number of important situations: recovery of the red blood cell mass after blood donation, adaptation of the number of red blood cells to changes in the altitude of residence and, most important, the reaction of the body to different administration regimens of erythropoiesis stimulating agents, as for instance in the case of pre-surgical administration of Epoetin-α. The simulation results concerning the last item show that choosing an appropriate administration regimen can reduce the total amount of the administered drug considerably. The core of the model consists of structured population equations for the different cell populations which are considered. A key feature of the model is the incorporation of neocytolysis.     

A genetic response to high altitude hypoxia: high hemoglobin-oxygen affinity in chicken (Gallus gallus) from the Peruvian Andes.

A population of chicken (Gallus gallus) from the Peruvian Andes (4,000 m) carrying a high hemoglobin-oxygen affinity has been identified. This property remained stable after over 1 year residence at sea level and was transmitted to the descendants born at sea level. Chicken were introduced in South America during the Spanish conquest and therefore their adaptation time to high altitude is less than 500 years. This finding shows that a genotypic change in hemoglobin function can occur in an extremely short evolutionary time and leads to some reflections on the high altitude adaptation of the mammals that migrated to South America during the great Plio-Pleistocene interchange.     

Increased affinity to substrate in sarcolemmal ATPases from hearts acclimatized to high altitude hypoxia

It has been well documented that acclimatization to chronic high altitude hypoxia involves a complex of adaptation changes which are capable of protecting the myocardium in diverse situations such as in acute hypoxia, coronary occlusion-induced ischaemia or isoprenaline-induced calcium overload. Since many of the former changes concern membrane functions, namely those of the sarcolemma, the activities and kinetic properties of sarcolemmal Mg2+-, Ca2+- and (Na+ + K+)-ATPase were investigated in right heart ventricles of rats acclimatized to intermittent high altitude hypoxia simulated in a barochamber. In the course of the experiment, the ventricles were subjected to a special anoxic test in vitro. The high altitude induced increase in cardiac tolerance to anoxia was not accompanied by any preservation of the sarcolemmal ATPase activities. On the contrary, membrane preparations obtained from the right ventricles of hearts acclimatized to high altitude exhibited significantly lower ATPase activities in comparison to non-acclimatized controls. The significant diminution in Km values of ATPases established in acclimatized hearts points to an increase in the affinity of their active sites to ATP. The latter effect is in agreement with the lowered rate of both the decrease in ATPase activities and the reduction of contractility in acclimatized hearts during the anoxic test, as well as with the considerably improved postanoxic reparability of contractions as compared to the controls. It is being concluded that the sarcolemmal changes at the level of ATPases involved in ionic transport processes represent an integral part of the adaptation complex to chronic high altitude hypoxia.     

Blood pressure and plasma catecholamines in acute and prolonged hypoxia: effects of local hypothermia.

This study measured the pressor and plasma catecholamine response to local hypothermia during adaptation to hypobaric hypoxia. Eight healthy men were studied at rest and after 10 and 45 min of local cooling of one hand and forearm as well as after 30 min of rewarming at sea level and again 24 h and 5 days after rapid, passive transport to high altitude (4,559 m). Acute mountain sickness scores ranged from 5 to 16 (maximal attainable score: 20) on the first day but were reduced to 0-8 by the fifth day. Systolic blood pressure, heart rate, and plasma epinephrine increased on day 1 at altitude compared with sea level but declined again on day 5, whereas diastolic and mean blood pressures continued to rise in parallel with plasma norepinephrine. With local cooling, an increased vasoactive response was seen on the fifth day at altitude. Very high pressures were obtained, and the pressure elevation was prolonged. Heart rate increased twice as much on day 5 compared with the other two occasions. Thoracic fluid index increased with cooling on day 5, suggesting an increase in pulmonary vascular resistance. In conclusion, prolonged hypoxia seems to elicit an augmented pressor response to local cooling in the systemic and most likely also the pulmonary circulation.     

Age as a cause of chronic mountain sickness (Monge's disease)

Chronic mountain sickness (CMS) or Monge's disease is a clinical entity observed among residents at altitude characterized by polycythaemia increased above the physiological level due to altitude adaptation. From correlation studies of haematocrit with ventilation rate of healthy and diseased native high altitude residents (4,540 m) it was found that CMS is a clinical manifestation of aging. The higher the altitude the sooner the symptoms of excessive polycythaemia will become evident.     

The effects of nightly normobaric hypoxia and high intensity training under intermittent normobaric hypoxia on running economy and hemoglobin mass.

We investigated the effects of nightly intermittent exposure to hypoxia and of training during intermittent hypoxia on both erythropoiesis and running economy (RE), which is indicated by the oxygen cost during running at submaximal speeds. Twenty-five college long- and middle- distance runners [maximal oxygen uptake (Vo(2max)) 60.3 +/- 4.7 ml x kg(-1) x min(-1)] were randomly assigned to one of three groups: hypoxic residential group (HypR, 11 h/night at 3,000 m simulated altitude), hypoxic training group (HypT), or control group (Con), for an intervention of 29 nights. All subjects trained in Tokyo (altitude of 60 m) but HypT had additional high-intensity treadmill running for 30 min at 3,000 m simulated altitude on 12 days during the night intervention. Vo(2) was measured at standing rest during four submaximal speeds (12, 14, 16, and 18 km/h) and during a maximal stage to volitional exhaustion on a treadmill. Total hemoglobin mass (THb) was measured by carbon monoxide rebreathing. There were no significant changes in Vo(2max), THb, and the time to exhaustion in all three groups after the intervention. Nevertheless, HypR showed approximately 5% improvement of RE in normoxia (P < 0.01) after the intervention, reflected by reduced Vo(2) at 18 km/h and the decreased regression slope fitted to Vo(2) measured during rest position and the four submaximal speeds (P < 0.05), whereas no significant corresponding changes were found in HypT and Con. We concluded that our dose of intermittent hypoxia (3,000 m for approximately 11 h/night for 29 nights) was insufficient to enhance erythropoiesis or Vo(2max), but improved the RE at race speed of college runners.     

Effect of phosphate supplementation on oxygen delivery at high altitude

In the present communication, effect of low doses of phosphate supplementation on short-term high altitude adaptation has been examined. Studies were carried out in 36 healthy, male, sea-level residents divided in a double blind fashion into drug and placebo treated groups. 3.2 mmol of phosphate were given orally to each subject of the drug treated group once a day for 4 days on arrival at an altitude of 3,500 m. Sequential studies were done in the subjects in both groups on the 3rd, 7th, 14th and 21st day of their altitude stay. Haemoglobin, haematocrit, erythrocyte and reticulocyte counts increased to the similar extent in both groups. Blood pH, pO₂ and adenosine tri-phosphate (ATP) did not differ between the two groups. On 3rd day of the altitude stay, inorganic phosphate and 2,3-diphosphoglycerate (2,3 DPG) levels in the drug treated group increased significantly as compared to the placebo group. No significant difference in inorganic phosphate and 2,3 DPG was observed later on in the two groups. Psychological and clinical tests also indicated that the drug treated subjects felt better as compared to the placebo treated subjects. The present study suggests that low doses of phosphate increases circulating 2,3-DPG concentration which in turn brings about beneficial effect towards short term high altitude adaptation.     

Effects of PHD and HSP90 on erythropoietin production in yak (Bos grunniens) renal interstitial fibroblast-like cells under hypoxia

Journal of Molecular Histology - Erythropoietin (EPO), a central protein of erythropoiesis, plays an important role during hypoxia adaptation and is regulated by hypoxia-inducible factor (HIF)....     

The concentration and bisynthesis of ubiquinone-9 in the liver of white rats adapted to altitude hypoxia]

The content and biosynthesis of ubiquinone-9 in the thin slices of the liver of rats was studied during altitude adaptation. There was a three-fold acceleration of ubiquinone biosynthesis during the first period of altitude adaptation. Acceleration of biosynthesis of ubiquinone-9 in rat liver was insignificant after two weeks of adaptation. The content of ubiquinone-9 in rat liver changed but insignificantly in the course of one month of altitude adaptation.     

Widespread Signals of Convergent Adaptation to High Altitude in Asia and America

Living at high altitude is one of the most difficult challenges that humans had to cope with during their evolution. Whereas several genomic studies have revealed some of the genetic bases of adaptations in Tibetan, Andean, and Ethiopian populations, relatively little evidence of convergent evolution to altitude in different continents has accumulated. This lack of evidence can be due to truly different evolutionary responses, but it can also be due to the low power of former studies that have mainly focused on populations from a single geographical region or performed separate analyses on multiple pairs of populations to avoid problems linked to shared histories between some populations. We introduce here a hierarchical Bayesian method to detect local adaptation that can deal with complex demographic histories. Our method can identify selection occurring at different scales, as well as convergent adaptation in different regions. We apply our approach to the analysis of a large SNP data set from low- and high-altitude human populations from America and Asia. The simultaneous analysis of these two geographic areas allows us to identify several candidate genome regions for altitudinal selection, and we show that convergent evolution among continents has been quite common. In addition to identifying several genes and biological processes involved in high-altitude adaptation, we identify two specific biological pathways that could have evolved in both continents to counter toxic effects induced by hypoxia.     

Hypoxia controls Flvcr1 gene expression in Caco2 cells through HIF2α and ETS1

The tissue-specific gene expression changes mediated by the hypoxia inducible factors (HIFs) allow the adaptation of cells to low oxygen tension and control several processes including erythropoiesis, angiogenesis and vasculogenesis. The Feline Leukemia Virus, subgroup C, Receptor 1 (Flvcr1) gene encodes for two isoforms, Flvcr1a and 1b, involved in the export of heme out of the cell and of mitochondria respectively. Studies in mouse models demonstrated a crucial role of Flvcr1 isoforms in erythropoiesis and during embryo development.     

Nitric oxide in adaptation to altitude

This review summarizes published information on the levels of nitric oxide gas (NO) in the lungs and NO-derived liquid-phase molecules in the acclimatization of visitors newly arrived at altitudes of 2500 m or more and adaptation of populations whose ancestors arrived thousands of years ago. Studies of acutely exposed visitors to high altitude focus on the first 24-48 h with just a few extending to days or weeks. Among healthy visitors, NO levels in the lung, plasma, and/or red blood cells fell within 2h, but then returned toward baseline or slightly higher by 48 h and increased above baseline by 5 days. Among visitors ill with high-altitude pulmonary edema at the time of the study or in the past, NO levels were lower than those of their healthy counterparts. As for highland populations, Tibetans had NO levels in the lung, plasma, and red blood cells that were at least double and in some cases orders of magnitude greater than other populations regardless of altitude. Red blood cell-associated nitrogen oxides were more than 200 times higher. Other highland populations had generally higher levels although not to the degree shown by Tibetans. Overall, responses of those acclimatized and those presumed to be adapted are in the same direction, although the Tibetans have much larger responses. Missing are long-term data on lowlanders at altitude showing how similar they become to the Tibetan phenotype. Also missing are data on Tibetans at low altitude to see the extent to which their phenotype is a response to the immediate environment or expressed constitutively. The mechanisms causing the visitors' and the Tibetans' high levels of NO and NO-derived molecules at altitude remain unknown. Limited data suggest processes including hypoxic upregulation of NO synthase gene expression, hemoglobin-NO reactions, and genetic variation. Gains in understanding will require integrating appropriate methods and measurement techniques with indicators of adaptive function under hypoxic stress.     

A randomly-controlled study on the cardiac function at the early stage of return to the plains after short-term exposure to high altitude

High altitude acclimatization and adaptation mechanisms have been well clarified, however, high altitude de-adaptation mechanism remains unclear. In this study, we conducted a controlled study on cardiac functions in 96 healthy young male who rapidly entered the high altitude (3700 m) and returned to the plains (1500 m) after 50 days. Ninety eight healthy male who remained at low altitude were recruited as control group. The mean pulmonary arterial pressure (mPAP), left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF), left ventricular fraction shortening (LVFS), cardiac function index (Tei index) were tested. Levels of serum creatine kinase isoform MB (CK-MB), lactate dehydrogenase isoenzyme-1 (LDH-1), endothelin-1 (ET-1), nitrogen oxide (NO), serum hypoxia-inducible factor-1α (HIF-1α), 8-iso-prostaglandin F(2α) (8-iso PGF(2α)), superoxide dismutase (SOD) and malonaldehyde (MDA) were measured at an altitude of 3700 m and 1500 m respectively. The results showed that after short-term exposure to high altitude mPAP and Tei index increased significantly, while LVEF and LVFS decreased significantly. These changes were positively correlated with altitude. On the 15(th) day after the subjects returned to low altitude, mPAP, LVEF and LVFS levels returned to the same level as those of the control subjects, but the Tei index in the returned subjects was still significantly higher than that in the control subjects (P<0.01). We also found that changes in Tei index was positively correlated with mPAP, ET-1, HIF-1α and 8-iso PGF(2α) levels, and negatively correlated with the level of NO, LVEF, LVFS, CK-MB and LDH-1. These findings suggest that cardiac function de-adapts when returning to the plains after short-term exposure to high altitude and the function recovery takes a relatively long time.     

Study of the respiratory sensation on high-altitude andeans

The respiratory sensation and some routine cardiorespiratory parameters were studied on native Highlanders from the Argentine Andes and on Lowlanders from Europe, already tested during previous high altitude expeditions. The tests were performed at various altitude levels from 2688m e.i., the village altitude for Highlanders, to 5600m during an expedition to Mt. Aconcagua (6990m). At rest, the perception of 4 external inspiratory resistive loads (ranged between 2.5 and 13 cm.H2O.L-1.s) can allow us to fix by discrimination the sensitivity index P(A) independently of response bias (B) according to Sensory Decision Theory (SDT). The Andean highlanders did not experience the respiratory sensation at the same limits as the European lowlanders well adaptated to high altitude. At higher altitudes than their village altitude, their respiratory sensation presented a lower threshold of perception and a weaker discrimination which might be partly explained by the evolution of some parameters of their cardio-respiratory function when altitude increased. Indeed, in response to high altitude hypoxia (5600m), they increased their respiratory frequency and not their minuteventilation or mouth pressure. This chosen ventilatory pattern was opposite to the one chosen by the Lowlanders and did not allow for sufficient adaptation to a more important altitude hypoxia than that of their village altitude. In conclusion, the Andean highlanders wellbeing adapted to their village altitude, exhibited a difficult acclimatization to higher altitudes which might be due to the characteristics of their respiratory sensation. These results might explain their weak physical performances during ascent to the Mt. Aconcagua summit in spite of special training.