Playing Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde: combined mechanisms of phase variation in bacteria

Phase variation is the adaptive process by which bacteria undergo frequent and reversible phenotypic changes resulting from genetic alterations in specific loci of their genomes. This process is crucial for the survival of pathogens and commensals in hostile and ever-changing host environments. Despite important differences in the molecular mechanisms that mediate and regulate phase variation, related strategies have evolved to generate high levels of genetic diversity through complex and combinatorial reshuffling of genetic information. Recent studies, supported by the emergence of global genomic approaches, have revealed that bacterial pathogens often use a combination of different mechanisms to vary the expression of a variety of biological functions, providing new insights into bacterial adaptation and virulence mechanisms. Recent advances in the understanding of the molecular mechanisms of phase variation are reviewed, and differences in these mechanisms outlined.     

Selective and non-selective bottlenecks as drivers of the evolution of hypermutable bacterial loci

Bottlenecks reduce the size of the gene pool within populations of all life forms with implications for their subsequent survival. Here, we examine the effects of bottlenecks on bacterial commensal-pathogens during transmission between, and dissemination within, hosts. By reducing genetic diversity, bottlenecks may alter individual or population-wide adaptive potential. A diverse range of hypermutable mechanisms have evolved in infectious agents that allow for rapid generation of genetic diversity in specific genomic loci as opposed to the variability arising from increased genome-wide mutation rates. These localised hypermutable mechanisms include multi-gene phase variation (PV) of outer membrane components, multi-allele PV of restriction systems and recombination-driven antigenic variation. We review selected experimental and theoretical (mathematical) models pertaining to the hypothesis that localised hypermutation (LH) compensates for fitness losses caused by bottlenecks and discuss whether bottlenecks have driven the evolution of hypermutable loci.     

Effects of recA Mutations on Pilus Antigenic Variation and Phase Transitions in Neisseria gonorrhoeae

Intragenic recombination between the single complete pilin gene (expression locus) and multiple, distinct, partial pilin gene copies (silent, storage loci) is thought to account for the generation of pilus antigenic diversity and piliation phase (on-off) changes exhibited by Neisseria gonorrhoeae. The mechanisms operating in the genomic rearrangements associated with these forms of pilus variation were investigated through the study of isogenic strains of gonococci bearing either wild-type or altered recA alleles. Examination of the rates of pilus phase variation and the genetic basis for changes in piliation status displayed by these strains show that recA mediated homologous recombination is required for these high frequency events and confirm that the nonpiliated state results from mutations in the expressed pilin gene. In a strain that is deficient in recA mediated homologous recombination, pilus phase variation occurs at a 100-1000-fold reduced rate and results predominantly from one class of spontaneous frameshift mutations within the pilin structural gene.     

Sequence diversity and haplotype associations with phenotypic responses to crowding: GIGANTEA affects fruit set in Arabidopsis thaliana

Identifying the molecular genetic basis of intraspecific variation in quantitative traits promises to provide novel insight into their evolutionary history as well as genetic mechanisms of adaptation. In an attempt to identify genes responsible for natural variation in competitive responses in Arabidopsis thaliana, we examined DNA sequence diversity at seven loci previously identified as members of the phytochrome B signalling network. For one gene, GIGANTEA (GI), we detected significant haplotype structure. To test for GI haplogroup-phenotype associations, we genotyped 161 A. thaliana accessions at GI and censused the same accessions for total fruit set and the expression of three phenotypic traits (days to flowering, petiole length, and inflorescence height) in a greenhouse experiment where plants were grown in crowded and uncrowded environments. We detected a significant association between GI and total fruit set that resulted in a 14% difference in average fruit set among GI haplogroups. Given that fruit set is an important component of fitness in this species and given the magnitude of the effect, the question arises as to how variation at this locus is maintained. Our observation of frequent and significant epistasis between GI and background single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP), where the fitness ranking of the GI allele either reverses or does not differ depending on the allele at the interacting SNP, suggests that epistatic selection may actively maintain or at least slow the loss of variation at GI. This result is particularly noteworthy in the light of the ongoing debate regarding the genetic underpinnings of phenotypic evolution and recent observations that epistasis for phenotypic traits and components of fitness is common in A. thaliana.     

Phase variable genes of Campylobacter jejuni exhibit high mutation rates and specific mutational patterns but mutability is not the major determinant of population structure during host colonization

Phase variation of surface structures occurs in diverse bacterial species due to stochastic, high frequency, reversible mutations. Multiple genes of Campylobacter jejuni are subject to phase variable gene expression due to mutations in polyC/G tracts. A modal length of nine repeats was detected for polyC/G tracts within C. jejuni genomes. Switching rates for these tracts were measured using chromosomally-located reporter constructs and high rates were observed for cj1139 (G8) and cj0031 (G9). Alteration of the cj1139 tract from G8 to G11 increased mutability 10-fold and changed the mutational pattern from predominantly insertions to mainly deletions. Using a multiplex PCR, major changes were detected in 'on/off' status for some phase variable genes during passage of C. jejuni in chickens. Utilization of observed switching rates in a stochastic, theoretical model of phase variation demonstrated links between mutability and genetic diversity but could not replicate observed population diversity. We propose that modal repeat numbers have evolved in C. jejuni genomes due to molecular drivers associated with the mutational patterns of these polyC/G repeats, rather than by selection for particular switching rates, and that factors other than mutational drift are responsible for generating genetic diversity during host colonization by this bacterial pathogen.     

Compensatory Evolution and the Origins of Innovations

Cryptic genetic sequences have attenuated effects on phenotypes. In the classic view, relaxed selection allows cryptic genetic diversity to build up across individuals in a population, providing alleles that may later contribute to adaptation when co-opted—e.g., following a mutation increasing expression from a low, attenuated baseline. This view is described, for example, by the metaphor of the spread of a population across a neutral network in genotype space. As an alternative view, consider the fact that most phenotypic traits are affected by multiple sequences, including cryptic ones. Even in a strictly clonal population, the co-option of cryptic sequences at different loci may have different phenotypic effects and offer the population multiple adaptive possibilities. Here, we model the evolution of quantitative phenotypic characters encoded by cryptic sequences and compare the relative contributions of genetic diversity and of variation across sites to the phenotypic potential of a population. We show that most of the phenotypic variation accessible through co-option would exist even in populations with no polymorphism. This is made possible by a history of compensatory evolution, whereby the phenotypic effect of a cryptic mutation at one site was balanced by mutations elsewhere in the genome, leading to a diversity of cryptic effect sizes across sites rather than across individuals. Cryptic sequences might accelerate adaptation and facilitate large phenotypic changes even in the absence of genetic diversity, as traditionally defined in terms of alternative alleles.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cis</Emphasis>-acting variation in the expression of a high proportion of genes in human brain

Much of the genetic component of human phenotypic diversity, including susceptibility to disease, is proposed to be the result of cis-acting influences on gene expression. If this hypothesis is correct, it implies that cis-acting regulatory variation is a common phenomenon. However, direct evidence in support of this view is scarce. We have applied highly quantitative measures of allele-specific expression in order to screen an average of 19 informative subjects (range 8-26) for the presence of common cis-acting influences on the expression of 15 genes by using RNA derived from human brain. We found that, in seven of the 15 assayed genes, at least one individual exhibited relative differences in allelic expression of 20% or more and, in one gene (DTNBP1), allelic expression differences exceeded 50%. These results suggest that cis-acting variation in gene expression commonly occurs in native tissue and hence provide empirical support for the hypothesis that this is potentially an important mechanism underlying human phenotypic diversity.     

Going for baroque at the Escherichia coli K1 cell surface

Phase variation is usually thought of as the stochastic switching between alternatively expressed ('on') and unexpressed ('off') phenotypic states. However, coupling synthesis of a monotonous homopolysaccharide to a mechanism of random but incomplete chemical modification produces almost infinite structural variation. Potentially limitless variability implies that evolution can produce highly ornate or extravagant flourishes reminiscent of the baroque style. Here, we describe an analysis of capsular polysialic acid form variation in Escherichia coli K1, demonstrating that the large number of variant structures is controlled by a single contingency locus. The mechanism for generating maximum structural diversity from maximal genetic parsimony is conferred by a simple translational switch carried on a K1-specific prophage.     

Phase variation: how to create and coordinate population diversity

Phase variation yields phenotypic heterogeneity in a clonal population as the result of one of a limited number of known molecular mechanisms. These include slipped strand mispairing, site-specific recombination and epigenetic regulation mediated by DNA methylation. Recently new regulatory variants utilizing these mechanisms have been identified, which is facilitating the identification of additional phase variation events solely from genome sequence analysis. Furthermore, it is becoming increasingly clear that in many cases phase variation control is integrated with regulatory networks and with cellular processes of a growing cell. This review focuses specifically on these recent advances in the understanding of the regulation of phase variation.     

Approaches to Macroevolution: 1. General Concepts and Origin of Variation

Approaches to macroevolution require integration of its two fundamental components, i.e. the origin and the sorting of variation, in a hierarchical framework. Macroevolution occurs in multiple currencies that are only loosely correlated, notably taxonomic diversity, morphological disparity, and functional variety. The origin of variation within this conceptual framework is increasingly understood in developmental terms, with the semi-hierarchical structure of gene regulatory networks (GRNs, used here in a broad sense incorporating not just the genetic circuitry per se but the factors controlling the timing and location of gene expression and repression), the non-linear relation between magnitude of genetic change and the phenotypic results, the evolutionary potential of co-opting existing GRNs, and developmental responsiveness to nongenetic signals (i.e. epigenetics and plasticity), all requiring modification of standard microevolutionary models, and rendering difficult any simple definition of evolutionary novelty. The developmental factors underlying macroevolution create anisotropic probabilities—i.e., an uneven density distribution—of evolutionary change around any given phenotypic starting point, and the potential for coordinated changes among traits that can accommodate change via epigenetic mechanisms. From this standpoint, “punctuated equilibrium” and “phyletic gradualism” simply represent two cells in a matrix of evolutionary models of phenotypic change, and the origin of trends and evolutionary novelty are not simply functions of ecological opportunity. Over long timescales, contingency becomes especially important, and can be viewed in terms of macroevolutionary lags (the temporal separation between the origin of a trait or clade and subsequent diversification); such lags can arise by several mechanisms: as geological or phylogenetic artifacts, or when diversifications require synergistic interactions among traits, or between traits and external events. The temporal and spatial patterns of the origins of evolutionary novelties are a challenge to macroevolutionary theory; individual events can be described retrospectively, but a general model relating development, genetics, and ecology is needed. An accompanying paper (Jablonski in Evol Biol 2017) reviews diversity dynamics and the sorting of variation, with some general conclusions.     

No genetic diversity at molecular markers and strong phenotypic plasticity in populations of Ranunculus nodiflorus, an endangered plant species in France

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Although conservation biology has long focused on population dynamics and genetics, phenotypic plasticity is likely to play a significant role in population viability. Here, an investigation is made into the relative contribution of genetic diversity and phenotypic plasticity to the phenotypic variation in natural populations of Ranunculus nodiflorus, a rare annual plant inhabiting temporary puddles in the Fontainebleau forest (Paris region, France) and exhibiting metapopulation dynamics. METHODS: The genetic diversity and phenotypic plasticity of quantitative traits (morphological and fitness components) were measured in five populations, using a combination of field measurements, common garden experiments and genotyping at microsatellite loci. KEY RESULTS: It is shown that populations exhibit almost undetectable genetic diversity at molecular markers, and that the variation in quantitative traits observed among populations is due to a high level of phenotypic plasticity. Despite the lack of genetic diversity, the natural population of R. nodiflorus exhibits large population sizes and does not appear threatened by extinction; this may be attributable to large phenotypic plasticity, enabling the production of numerous seeds under a wide range of environmental conditions. CONCLUSIONS: Efficient conservation of the populations can only be based on habitat management, to favour the maintenance of microenvironmental variation and the resulting strong phenotypic plasticity. In contrast, classical actions aiming to improve genetic diversity are useless in the present case.     

草鱼全同胞鱼苗不同个体甲基化位点的差异

本研究通过甲基化敏感扩增多态性(Methylation sensitive amplification polymorphism)对一对草鱼亲本的20个子代甲基化位点进行了研究。从20对引物组合中扩增出311个位点,其中甲基化位点236个,占总扩增位点的75.9%,表明草鱼水花期基因组甲基化水平已经很高,说明它们大部分组织分化基本完成;其中甲基化多态位点65个,占甲基化位点的27.5%,说明这些子代草鱼甲基化位点已经有相当的差异。对其他两对亲本的后代用六个引物组合扩增的结果表明,同一亲本的子代在甲基化模式上有差异可能是普遍现象。本研究结果说明,即使来自同一对草鱼亲本的不同子代个体在基因表达上也有较大的差异,因此很多性状在草鱼后代的分离和一些基因表达的改变有一定的关系。     

Genetic evidence for founder effects in the introduced range of houndstongue (Cynoglossum officinale)

Phenotypic differentiation can occur between the native and introduced ranges of a species as a result of novel selective pressures, or by neutral processes and historical events. Our aim was to determine how underlying patterns of genetic diversity and potential population origin might have contributed to phenotypic differentiation between the native and introduced ranges of an herbaceous weed. We combined data from microsatellite markers from 16 native and 16 introduced populations of Cynoglossum officinale, a noxious weed of the western US, with previously published phenotypic data from common gardens to investigate genetic diversity in both ranges and relate population structure to phenotypic differentiation. Several lines of evidence suggest loss of genetic diversity during the introduction of C. officinale. Despite reduced diversity, introduced plants out-performed natives in a common garden in one environment. We found little evidence that population-level variation in diversity contributed to phenotypic variation (e.g. through inbreeding depression). Our results suggest that establishment, spread, and potentially adaptation of a species to a new range is not prevented by reductions in genetic diversity of the magnitude we observed. Further, we suggest that non-random filtering or biased introduction at the point of emigration may contribute to phenotypic divergence between ranges.     

DNA metabolism and genetic diversity in Trypanosomes

Trypanosomes are protozoan parasites that cause major diseases in humans and other animals. Trypanosoma brucei and Trypanosoma cruzi are the etiologic agents of African and American Trypanosomiasis, respectively. In spite of large amounts of information regarding various aspects of their biology, including the essentially complete sequences of their genomes, studies directed towards an understanding of mechanisms related to DNA metabolism have been very limited. Recent reports, however, describing genes involved with DNA recombination and repair in T. brucei and T. cruzi, indicated the importance of these processes in the generation of genetic variability, which is crucial to the success of these parasites. Here, we review these data and discuss how the DNA repair and recombination machineries may contribute to strikingly different strategies evolved by the two Trypanosomes to create genetic variability that is needed for survival in their hosts. In T. brucei, two genetic components are critical to the success of antigenic variation, a strategy that allows the parasite to evade the host immune system by periodically changing the expression of a group of variant surface glycoproteins (VSGs). One component is a mechanism that provides for the exclusive expression of a single VSG at any one time, and the second is a large repository of antigenically distinct VSGs. Work from various groups showing the importance of recombination reactions in T. brucei, primarily to move a silent VSG into an active VSG expression site, is discussed. T. cruzi does not use the strategy of antigenic variation for host immune evasion but counts on the extreme heterogeneity of their population for parasite adaptation to different hosts. We discuss recent evidence indicating the existence of major differences in the levels of genomic heterogeneity among T. cruzi strains, and suggest that metabolic changes in the mismatch repair pathway could be an important source of antigenic diversity found within the T. cruzi population.     

Genome hyperevolution and the success of a parasite

The strategy of antigenic variation is to present a constantly changing population phenotype that enhances parasite transmission, through evasion of immunity arising within, or existing between, host animals. Trypanosome antigenic variation occurs through spontaneous switching among members of a silent archive of many hundreds of variant surface glycoprotein (VSG) antigen genes. As with such contingency systems in other pathogens, switching appears to be triggered through inherently unstable DNA sequences. The archive occupies subtelomeres, a genome partition that promotes hypermutagenesis and, through telomere position effects, singular expression of VSG. Trypanosome antigenic variation is augmented greatly by the formation of mosaic genes from segments of pseudo-VSG, an example of implicit genetic information. Hypermutation occurs apparently evenly across the whole archive, without direct selection on individual VSG, demonstrating second-order selection of the underlying mechanisms. Coordination of antigenic variation, and thereby transmission, occurs through networking of trypanosome traits expressed at different scales from molecules to host populations.