The regulation of carbamoyl phosphate synthase activity in rat liver mitochondria.

The rate at which isolated rat liver mitochondria synthesized citrulline with NH4C1 as nitrogen source was markedly dependent on the protein content of the diet. 2. Citrulline synthesis was not rate-limited by substrate concentration, substrate transport or ornithine transcarbamoylase activity under the conditions used. 3. The intramitochondrial content of an activator of carbamoyl phosphate synthase, assumed to be N-acetyl-glutamate, varied markedly with dietary protein content. The variation in the concentration of this activator was sufficient to account for the observed variation in the rates of citrulline synthesis if this synthesis were rate-limited by the activity of carbamoyl phosphate synthase. 4. The rates of urea formation from NH4Cl as nitrogen source in isolated liver cells showed variations in response to diet that closely paralleled the variations in the rates of citrulline synthesis observed in isolated mitochondria. 5. These results are consistent with the postulate that when NH4Cl plus ornithine are present in an excess, the rate of urea synthesis is regulated at the level of carbamoyl phosphate synthase activity.     

The interaction of rat liver carbamoyl phosphate synthetase and ornithine transcarbamoylase with inner mitochondrial membranes

The intramitochondrial localization of the urea cycle enzymes, carbamoyl phosphate synthetase and ornithine transcarbamoylase, has been examined by both in vitro and in situ studies. The following three lines of evidence are presented to establish that significant fractions of the rat liver enzymes are loosely associated with the inner mitochondrial membrane: 1) when the mitochondrion is fractionated, the enzymes partition between the matrix and membrane fractions in the absence of detergent and partition solely to the matrix in the presence of detergent; 2) the purified enzymes associate with purified inner membrane preparations; and, 3) protein A-gold electron microscopic immunocytochemical analysis of rat liver sections reveals a nonrandom arrangement of the enzyme, with the maximal enzyme density adjacent to the inner mitochondrial membrane. These findings serve as the basis for novel potential mechanisms for regulation of the activity of the enzymes and provide additional evidence for the extensive organization of the mitochondrial matrix. The membrane interaction might also serve as the organizing factor for a carbamoyl phosphate synthetase-ornithine transcarbamoylase or other multienzyme complex.     

Properties and subcellular distribution of two partially purified ornithine transcarbamoylases in cell suspensions of sugarcane

The spatially separated forms of ornithine transcarbamoylase (EC 2.1.3.3) of different molecular weights coexist in sugarcane (Saccharum sp.). The smaller form of the enzyme (mol wt 79,000) appears to be cytoplasmic, while a larger form (mol wt 224,000) sedimented with mitochondria. The Km of the cytoplasmic enzyme for ornithine was 3.11 mm, while the enzyme in the mitochondrial fraction had a Km of 0.50 mm for this substrate; both enzymes had similar affinity for carbamoyl phosphate (0.12 mm). Characteristics of the smaller ornithine transcarbamoylase are in keeping with a predominantly catabolic function, those of the enzyme which sediments with mitochondria, with an anabolic function. Only the mitochondrial enzyme was regulated in vivo by exogenous arginine.     

The inhibition of ornithine transcarbamoylase from Escherichia coli W by phaseolotoxin.

The mechanism of inhibition of ornithine transcarbamoylase by the bacterial toxin phaseolotoxin [N-delta-(phosphosulphamyl)ornithylalanylhomoarginine] was investigated. Ornithine transcarbamoylase was purified by affinity chromatography from Escherichia coli W argR- by using N-delta-(phosphonoacetyl)ornithine as the ligand. Under steady-state conditions phaseolotoxin inhibition was reversible and exhibited mixed kinetics with respect to carbamoyl phosphate. The apparent Ki and apparent K'i were 0.2 microM and 10 microM respectively. Inhibition with respect to ornithine was noncompetitive, with an apparent Ki of 0.9 microM. These data are consistent with competitive binding of phaseolotoxin to the carbamoyl phosphate-binding site of the enzyme. The toxin also appears to be able to bind to the enzyme-carbamoyl phosphate complex, although, since K'i is 50 times greater than Ki, this event is kinetically much less significant. In the presence of phaseolotoxin ornithine transcarbamoylase exhibited a transient phase of activity before a steady state. This is consistent with low rates of association and dissociation for the toxin with enzyme and the enzyme-toxin complex. Rate constants of 2.5 X 10(4)M-1 X s-1 and 5 X 10(-3)s-1 were estimated for the association and dissociation constants respectively.     

Purification and properties of ornithine carbamoyl transferase from liver of Squalus acanthias

Citrulline synthesis from ammonia by hepatic mitochondria in elasmobranchs involves intermediate formation of glutamine as the result of the presence of high levels of glutamine synthetase and a unique glutamine- and N-acetyl-glutamate-dependent carbamoyl phosphate synthetase, both of which have properties unique to the function of glutamine-dependent synthesis of urea, which is retained in the tissues of elasmobranchs at high concentrations for the purpose of osmoregulation [P.M. Anderson and C.A. Casey (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 456-462; R.A. Shankar and P.M. Anderson (1985) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 239, 248-259]. The objective of this study was to determine if ornithine carbamoyl transferase, which catalyzes the last step of mitochondrial citrulline synthesis and which has not been previously isolated from any species of fish, also has properties uniquely related to this function. Ornithine carbamoyl transferase was highly purified from isolated liver mitochondria of Squalus acanthias, a representative elasmobranch. The purified enzyme is a trimer with a subunit molecular weight of 38,000 and a native molecular weight of about 114,000. The effect of pH is significantly influenced by ornithine concentration; optimal activity is at pH 7.8 when ornithine is saturating. The apparent Km values for ornithine and carbamoyl phosphate at pH 7.8 are 0.71 and 0.05 mM, respectively. Ornithine displays considerable substrate inhibition above pH 7.8. The activity is not significantly affected by physiological concentrations of the osmolyte urea or trimethylamine-N-oxide or by a number of other metabolites. The results of kinetic studies are consistent with a steady-state ordered addition of substrates (carbamoyl phosphate binding first) and rapid equilibrium random release of products. Except for an unusually low specific activity, the properties of the purified elasmobranch enzyme are similar to the properties of ornithine carbamoyl transferase from mammalian ureotelic and other species and do not appear to be unique to its role in glutamine-dependent synthesis of urea for the purpose of osmoregulation.     

Changes in the activities of the enzymes of urea synthesis caused by dexamethasone and dibutyryladenosine 3'':5''-cyclic monophosphate in foetal rat liver maintained in organ culture.

Liver explants from 19-day foetal rats were maintained in organ culture, in a defined medium, for up to 48h. Both 6-N,2'-O-dibutyryl cyclic AMP, in the presence of theophylline, and dexamethasone caused an increase in the activities of carbamoyl phosphate synthase, argininosuccinate synthetase, argininosuccinate lyase and arginase. These increases could be abolished by simultaneously incubating the explants with cycloheximide. No change in the activity of ornithine transcarbamoylase was found with either hormone. Previous work has shown that injection of corticosteroids into 19.5-day foetal rats in utero did not cause an increase in the arginine synthetase system. Present results suggest that this lack of effect is not due to any incompetence of the foetal rat liver at this stage to respond to this agent. The observations on ornithine transcarbamoylase activity suggest that this enzyme is induced in the liver of the perinatal rat by neither corticosteroids nor hormones acting via cyclic AMP, and it may be that all the enzymes of the urea cycle are induced physiologically by an agent or agents as yet unidentified.     

Structures of N-acetylornithine transcarbamoylase from Xanthomonas campestris complexed with substrates and substrate analogs imply mechanisms for substrate binding and catalysis

N-acetyl-L-ornithine transcarbamoylase (AOTCase) is a new member of the transcarbamoylase superfamily that is essential for arginine biosynthesis in several eubacteria. We report here crystal structures of the binary complexes of AOTCase with its substrates, carbamoyl phosphate (CP) or N-acetyl-L-ornithine (AORN), and the ternary complex with CP and N-acetyl-L-norvaline. Comparison of these structures demonstrates that the substrate-binding mechanism of this novel transcarbamoylase is different from those of aspartate and ornithine transcarbamoylases, both of which show ordered substrate binding with large domain movements. CP and AORN bind to AOTCase independently, and the main conformational change upon substrate binding is ordering of the 80's loop, with a small domain closure around the active site and little movement of the 240's loop. The structures of the complexes provide insight into the mode of substrate binding and the mechanism of the transcarbamoylation reaction.     

The inactivation of ornithine transcarbamoylase by N delta-(N''-sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine.

Phaseolotoxin, a tripeptide inhibitor of ornithine transcarbamoylase, is a phytotoxin produced by Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola, the causal agent of halo-blight in beans. In vivo the toxin is cleaved to release N delta-(N'-sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine, the major toxic chemical species present in diseased leaf tissue. This paper reports on the interaction between N delta-(N'-sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine and ornithine transcarbamoylase. N delta-(N'-Sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine was found to be a potent inactivator of the enzyme, in contrast with phaseolotoxin, which previously has been reported to inhibit the enzyme reversibly. Inactivation by N delta-(N'-[35S]sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine resulted in the incorporation of 35S into ethanol-precipitated protein. The stoicheiometry of 35S incorporation was approximately 1 mol/mol of active sites. Inactivation was second-order and a rate constant of 10(6) M-1 X s-1 at 0 degree C in 50 mM-Tris/HCl, pH 9.0, was obtained. Carbamoyl phosphate, a substrate of ornithine transcarbamoylase, protected the enzyme from inactivation. A dissociation constant of 3 microM for the enzyme-carbamoyl phosphate complex was calculated. L-Ornithine, the second substrate for ornithine transcarbamoylase, protected the enzyme only at high concentrations. The results are consistent with N delta-(N'-sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine being a potent affinity label that binds via the carbamoyl phosphate-binding site of ornithine transcarbamoylase. Cleavage of phaseolotoxin to N delta-(N'-sulpho-diaminophosphinyl)-L-ornithine in vivo appears to be an important function in the physiology of the disease.     

Partial Purification and Properties of Ornithine Transcarbamoylase from Nostoc muscorum Kützing

Ornithine transcarbamoylase (carbamoyl phosphate:l-ornithine carbamoyltransferase, EC 2.1.3.3) has been partially purified from the blue-green alga Nostoc muscorum Kützing, an organism in which the enzyme seems to be involved in a bicarbonate-fixing pathway leading to citrulline. Pertinent to possible regulation of this pathway, the enzyme shows hyperbolic substrate kinetics, has a molecular weight estimated at 75,000 daltons, and its catalytic capability is little influenced by a selection of metabolites that might conceivably act as regulators in vivo. Thus it seems unlikely that this enzyme is the control point for bicarbonate fixation. In terms of energy of activation (12.3 kcal/mole), size and Km for carbamoylphosphate, the Nostoc enzyme resembled preparations from liver and higher plants more than preparations from Streptococcus and Mycoplasma. The enzymes from Streptococcus and Mycoplasma are probably specialized for citrulline breakdown rather than citrulline synthesis. The Km for ornithine was 2.5 mm at a saturating concentration of carbamoylphosphate and the Km for carbamoylphosphate was 0.7 mm at an ornithine concentration of 2 mm. Ornithine was inhibitory at concentrations greater than 2 mm. Phosphate was a competitive inhibitor with respect to carbamoylphosphate. The pH optimum for citrulline synthesis was 9.5.     

Role of polyols in thermal inactivation of shark ornithine transcarbamoylase

The ability of activity modulators of ornithine transcarbamoylase (OCT) from the liver of the thresher shark Alopias vulpinus to stabilize the enzyme against thermal denaturation was investigated in the tri-buffer at pH 7.8, at temperatures ranging from 60 to 70 (o)C, in the presence of polyhydroxylic molecules such as glycerol and sugars. The study indicated that in the presence of 0.5 M sugars and 1.6 M glycerol in the preincubation medium the OCT activity increases. When trehalose is introduced directly in the reaction mixture in a range of concentration of 0.25-0.5 M, the activity is lower than that with maltose, glycerol and buffer alone. Kinetic data for carbamoyl phosphate and ornithine with and without maltose and glycerol are similar, whereas trehalose increases the kinetic values. Arrhenius plots show an increase of activation energy due to trehalose, whereas values obtained with maltose and glycerol are similar to the control.     

Fermentation of Agmatine in Streptococcus faecalis: Occurrence of Putrescine Transcarbamoylase

Putrescine transcarbamoylase, EC 2.1.3.x (carbamoylphosphate:putrescine transcarbamoylase), has been purified from Streptococcus faecalis 10C1 grown on agmatine as primary energy source. The formation of N-carbamoylputrescine from putrescine and carbamoylphosphate serves as a convenient and sensitive assay for this enzymatic activity. The enzyme catalyzes both the phosphorolysis arsenolysis of N-carbamoylputrescine. Arginine does not induce the synthesis of putrescine transcarbamoylase in S. faecalis. Furthermore, the putrescine transcarbamoylase activity is easily separated from ornithine transcarbamoylase activity by gel filtration on Sephadex G-100 indicating that the two activities are associated with different proteins. The significance of this new enzyme in the fermentation of agmatine and its relation to the other known transcarbamoylases are discussed.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of Escherichia coli ornithine transcarbamoylase: role of arginine-57 in substrate binding and catalysis

In the carbamoyl-transfer reaction catalyzed by ornithine transcarbamoylase, an arginine residue in the active site of the Escherichia coli enzyme has been suggested to bind the phosphate moiety of the substrate carbamoyl phosphate. With the application of site-specific mutagenesis, the most likely arginine residue among three candidates at the binding site of carbamoyl phosphate, Arg-57, has been replaced with a glycine. The resultant Gly-57 mutant enzyme is drastically inefficient in catalysis. In the synthesis of L-citrulline from carbamoyl phosphate and L-ornithine with the release of inorganic phosphate, the turnover rate of the mutant is 21,000-fold lower than that of the wild type. However, the mutation of Arg-57 affects only moderately the binding of carbamoyl phosphate; the dissociation constant of this substrate, measured under steady-state turnover condition, is increased from 0.046 to 3.2 mM by the mutation. On the other hand, ornithine binding is substantially affected as estimated by the change in the dissociation constant of its analogue L-norvaline. The dissociation constant of L-norvaline increases about 500-fold from 54 microM for the wild type to 25 mM for the mutant. Since Arg-57 is expected to be distal from the ornithine site and the amino acid (both ornithine and norvaline) binds only after carbamoyl phosphate in the wild-type reaction, the poor norvaline affinity to the mutant suggests that Arg-57 is involved in interactions essential for productive addition of the amino acid. This interpretation is supported by difference ultraviolet absorption spectra which show that the conformational changes induced in the wild type by carbamoyl phosphate upon binding are absent in the mutant. Furthermore, steady-state kinetic data reveal that the ordered binding mechanism of the wild-type enzyme is transformed into a random binding mechanism in the mutant. Thus, the presence of carbamoyl phosphate in the mutant active site is no longer a requisite for ornithine binding. In the 5-50 degrees C temperature range, transcarbamoylation catalyzed by either the wild type or the mutant observes the Arrhenius rate law with almost identical enthalpies of activation, 11 and 10 kcal/mol, respectively. The entropy of activation is -5.5 eu for the wild-type reaction and -29 eu for the mutant reaction, accounting for a loss of 6-7 kcal/mol in the rate-determining step of the enzymic reaction.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Carbamoyl phosphate biosynthesis in Streptococci

Nine streptococcal strains belonging to different serological groups (A, B, C, D) were shown to synthesize carbamoyl phosphate from ammonium hydrocarbonate and ATP. The reaction was catalyzed by carbamate kinase (EC 2.7.2.2). The speed of the reaction was evaluated according to the increase of the content of citrullin (the combination of carbamate kinase and ornithine transcarbamoylase). The representatives of different serological groups were found to have quantitative differences in carbamate kinase activity: the highest specific activity (13 nmol of citrullin per minute in 1 mg of dried microbial biomass) was detected in group A streptococci, while group D streptococci showed the lowest specific activity (0.5 nmol).     

Substrate specificity and protonation state of Escherichia coli ornithine transcarbamoylase as determined by pH studies. Binding of carbamoyl phosphate

Binding of carbamoyl phosphate to Escherichia coli ornithine transcarbamoylase and its relation to turnover have been examined as a function of pH under steady-state conditions. The pH profile of the dissociation constant of carbamoyl phosphate (Kiacp) shows that the affinity of the substrate increases as pH decreases. Two ionizing groups are involved in carbamoyl phosphate binding. Protonation of an enzymic group with pKa 9.6 results in productive binding of the substrate with a moderate affinity of Kiacp approximately 30 microM. Protonation of a second group further enhances binding by roughly another order of magnitude. This ionization occurs with a pKa that shifts from less than 6 in the free enzyme to 7.3 in the binary complex. However, tighter binding of carbamoyl phosphate due to this ionization does not contribute to catalysis. The turnover rate (kcat) of the enzyme diminishes in the acidic pH range and is governed by an ionization with a pKa of 7.2. Both the catalytic pKa of 7.2 and the productive binding pKa of 9.6 appear in the pH profile of kcat/KMcp. Together with earlier kinetic results (Kuo, L. C., Herzberg, W., and Lipscomb, W. N. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 4754-4761), these data suggest that the step which modulates kcat may occur prior to the binding of the second substrate L-ornithine.     

The apparent Km of ammonia for carbamoyl phosphate synthetase (ammonia) in situ.

Experiments with carbamoyl phosphate synthetase (ammonia) in solution and in isolated mitochondria are reported which show the following. NH3 rather than NH4+ is the substrate of the enzyme. The apparent Km of NH3 for the purified enzyme is about 38 microM. The apparent Km for NH3 measured in intact isolated mitochondria is about 13 microM. This value was obtained for both coupled and uncoupled mitochondria and was unchanged when the rate of carbamoyl phosphate synthesis was increased 2-fold by incubating uncoupled mitochondria in the presence of 5 mM-N-acetylglutamate. According to the literature, the concentration of NH3 in liver is well below the measured apparent Km. On the basis of this and previous work we conclude that, quantitatively, changes in liver [NH3] and [ornithine] are likely to be the most important factors in the fast regulation of synthesis of carbamoyl phosphate and urea. This conclusion is consistent with all available evidence obtained with isolated mitochondria, isolated hepatocytes, perfused liver and whole animals.     

Citrulline synthesis in rat tissues and liver content of carbamoyl phosphate and ornithine

Rat liver ornithine carbamoyltransferase appears to be located exclusively in the mitochondria; the activity that is found in the soluble fraction is indistinguishable from mitochondrial ornithine carbamoyltransferase by simple kinetic criteria, and seems to result from breakage of mitochondria during homogenization. Of several rat tissues studied, only the liver and the mucosa of small intestine contain significant amounts of ornithine carbamoyltransferase; the activity in intestinal mucosa is less than one thousandth of that in liver. Qualitatively, this distribution coincides with that of carbamoyl phosphate synthetase I and its cofactor, acetylglutamate. The rat liver contents of carbamoyl phosphate and ornithine were 0.1 and 0.15mumol/g wet wt. of tissue respectively. On the basis of these values, it is proposed that in vivo the ornithine carbamoyltransferase activity of liver may be much lower than its maximal activity in vitro might suggest.     

Insulin regulation of RNA synthesis

During periods of nitrogen exportation from the cell, mitochondrial carbamoyl phosphate is synthesized, thus initiating the urea cycle. During times of nitrogen conservation by the liver cell, carbamoyl phosphate is synthesized in the cytosol of the cell, whereupon the de novo pyrimidine synthesis pathway is initiated. The de novo pathway provides pyrimidines for increased ribonucleic acid synthesis. Formerly, it was believed that these two pathways functioned irrespective of one another. However, recent experimental evidence indicates that, when excess ammonia is present, mitochondrial carbamoyl phosphate passes from the mitochondria into the cell cytosol, where it is metabolized by the de novo pyrimidine synthesis pathway. When ornithine and excess ammonia are both present, mitochondrial carbamoyl phosphate no longer passes from the mitochondria into the cytosol to be metabolized by the de nova pathway. Thus the metabolic fate of mitochondrial carbamoyl phosphate, and that of excess nitrogen, is determined by the presence or absence of ornithine. In turn, this key molecule is the substrate for the cytoplasmic enzyme ornithine decarboxylase. When ornithine decarboxylase is stimulated by insulin, ornithine is metabolized to putrescine. The activated ornithine decarboxylase combines with ribonucleic acid polymerase, activating the later enzyme. When ornithine is acted upon by ornithine decarboxylase, it is no longer available for the perpetuation of the urea cycle and mitochondrial carbamoyl phosphate levels rise until the carbamoyl phosphate passes into the cytosol to be metabolized by the de novo pathway. Increased amounts of pyrimidines are available for the activated ribonucleic acid polymerase. Therefore insulin, through its stimulation of ornithine decarboxylase, achieves cellular nitrogen retention by regulating nitrogen incorporation into newly synthesized ribonucleic acid.     

Activities of ornithine aminotransferase and ornithine decarboxylase in chronically uremic rats

The activities of two enzymes mediating different pathways of ornithine catabolism were measured in liver and kidney of chronically uremic rats and their pair-fed controls. Two months following partial nephrectomy hepatic ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) activity tended to be lower in uremic rats and was correlated with urea clearance and with carbamoyl phosphate synthetase activity. Renal OAT activity in uremic rats was also correlated with urea clearance. When uremic rats were maintained for five months, OAT activity was significantly decreased in liver but not in kidney and the activity of ornithine decarboxylase (ODC), the enzyme regulating polyamine biosynthesis, was reduced in both liver and kidney. In cross-over experiments, evidence was obtained for a factor in uremic kidney cytosol which inhibited renal ODC activity.     

Pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthesis in Phaseolus aureus. Enzymic aspects of the control of carbamoyl phosphate synthesis and utilization

1. Aspartate transcarbamoylase from 4-day-old radicles of Phaseolus aureus was purified 190-fold by (NH(4))(2)SO(4) fractionation, DEAE-cellulose and DEAE-Sephadex chromatography and Sephadex-gel filtration. The partially purified enzyme, which required P(i) for maximum stability, had an apparent molecular weight of 83000+/-5000. 2. Uridine nucleotides were found to inhibit the activity; UMP was the most potent inhibitor, followed by UDP and UTP. No other nucleotide was found to affect the enzyme, nor could UMP inhibition be overcome by adding another nucleotide. Aspartate gives a hyperbolic substrate-saturation curve, both with and without UMP. The nucleotide inhibitor is non-competitive with respect to this substrate. Carbamoyl phosphate also yields a hyperbolic substrate-saturation curve in the absence of feedback inhibitor, but when UMP is added a sigmoidal pattern results, and the inhibition is competitive with carbamoyl phosphate. 3. The degree of inhibition by UMP is not affected by p-chloromercuribenzoate, urea, mild heat pretreatment or change in pH over the range 8.5-10.5, but is affected by temperature. 4. The aspartate analogue, succinate, both activates and inhibits the reaction, depending on the concentrations of aspartate and succinate used. 5. Kinetic studies with the partially purified enzyme showed that the K(m) for carbamoyl phosphate (0.091 mm) is much lower than that for aspartate (1.7mm). A sequential reaction mechanism was inferred from product-inhibition kinetics, with carbamoyl phosphate binding to the enzyme before aspartate, and the product, carbamoylaspartate, being released ahead of P(i). Initial-velocity studies gave a set of parallel reciprocal plots, compatible with an essentially irreversible step occurring before the binding of aspartate.     

Chicken ornithine transcarbamylase: purification and some properties

Ornithine transcarbamylase [EC 2.1.3.3] has been purified from chick kidney to homogeneity. The molecular weight is 110,000 as determined by gel filtration. Sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of the enzyme showed that the enzyme exists as a trimer of identical subunits of 36,000 daltons like other mammalian species ornithine transcarbamylases. In 0.1 M triethanolamine/HCl, the apparent optimum pH of the purified enzyme was 7.5 in the presence of 5 mM ornithine. The curve shifted toward a more alkaline region with a decrease in ornithine concentration. The specific activity of the purified enzyme as 77 units at pH 7.5. The Km for carbamyl phosphate was 0.11 mM and the Km for ornithine was 1.21 mM. With an increase in pH, a decrease in Km values for ornithine and an increase in the extent of inhibition by ornithine were observed. On using antibody against bovine liver ornithine transcarbamylase, the precipitin lines for the chick and bovine enzymes showed a spur pattern. Even when excess amounts of the antibody were added, the chick enzyme did not lose the activity while the bovine enzyme activity was inhibited completely.