Mutational analysis of domain antibodies reveals aggregation hotspots within and near the complementarity determining regions

High-affinity antibodies are critical for numerous diagnostic and therapeutic applications, yet their utility is limited by their variable propensity to aggregate either at low concentrations for antibody fragments or high concentrations for full-length antibodies. Therefore, determining the sequence and structural features that differentiate aggregation-resistant antibodies from aggregation-prone ones is critical to improving their activity. We have investigated the molecular origins of antibody aggregation for human V(H) domain antibodies that differ only in the sequence of the loops containing their complementarity determining regions (CDRs), yet such antibodies possess dramatically different aggregation propensities in a manner not correlated with their conformational stabilities. We find the propensity of these antibodies to aggregate after being transiently unfolded is not a distributed property of the CDR loops, but can be localized to aggregation hotspots within and near the first CDR (CDR1). Moreover, we have identified a triad of charged mutations within CDR1 and a single charged mutation adjacent to CDR1 that endow the poorly soluble variant with the desirable biophysical properties of the aggregation-resistant antibody. Importantly, we find that several other charged mutations in CDR1, non-CDR loops and the antibody scaffold are incapable of preventing aggregation. We expect that our identification of aggregation hotspots that govern antibody aggregation within and proximal to CDR loops will guide the design and selection of antibodies that not only possess high affinity and conformational stability, but also extreme resistance to aggregation.     

An anti-hapten camelid antibody reveals a cryptic binding site with significant energetic contributions from a nonhypervariable loop

Conventional anti-hapten antibodies typically bind low-molecular weight compounds (haptens) in the crevice between the variable heavy and light chains. Conversely, heavy chain-only camelid antibodies, which lack a light chain, must rely entirely on a single variable domain to recognize haptens. While several anti-hapten VHHs have been generated, little is known regarding the underlying structural and thermodynamic basis for hapten recognition. Here, an anti-methotrexate VHH (anti-MTX VHH) was generated using grafting methods whereby the three complementarity determining regions (CDRs) were inserted onto an existing VHH framework. Thermodynamic analysis of the anti-MTX VHH CDR1-3 Graft revealed a micromolar binding affinity, while the crystal structure of the complex revealed a somewhat surprising noncanonical binding site which involved MTX tunneling under the CDR1 loop. Due to the close proximity of MTX to CDR4, a nonhypervariable loop, the CDR4 loop sequence was subsequently introduced into the CDR1-3 graft, which resulted in a dramatic 1000-fold increase in the binding affinity. Crystal structure analysis of both the free and complex anti-MTX CDR1-4 graft revealed CDR4 plays a significant role in both intermolecular contacts and binding site conformation that appear to contribute toward high affinity binding. Additionally, the anti-MTX VHH possessed relatively high specificity for MTX over closely related compounds aminopterin and folate, demonstrating that VHH domains are capable of binding low-molecular weight ligands with high affinity and specificity, despite their reduced interface.     

单域重链抗体的分子特征

源于软骨鱼或骆驼科动物的同型重链二聚体无轻链,用基因工程方法获得其单一重链可变区可保留完整的抗原结合活性,称为单域重链抗体。单域重链抗体具有分子小、稳定性高、体内组织渗透性好、可溶性好、易表达、抗原识别表位独特的结构特征,近年来在生物技术研究与诊断治疗应用领域得到广泛关注,取得了快速发展。     

Crystal structure of HEL4, a soluble, refoldable human V(H) single domain with a germ-line scaffold

The antigen binding site of antibodies usually comprises associated heavy (V(H)) and light (V(L)) chain variable domains, but in camels and llamas, the binding site frequently comprises the heavy chain variable domain only (referred to as V(HH)). In contrast to reported human V(H) domains, V(HH) domains are well expressed from bacteria and yeast, are readily purified in soluble form and refold reversibly after heat-denaturation. These desirable properties have been attributed to highly conserved substitutions of the hydrophobic residues of V(H) domains, which normally interact with complementary V(L) domains. Here, we describe the discovery and characterisation of an isolated human V(H) domain (HEL4) with properties similar to those of V(HH) domains. HEL4 is highly soluble at concentrations of > or =3 mM, essentially monomeric and resistant to aggregation upon thermodenaturation at concentrations as high as 56 microM. However, in contrast to V(HH) domains, the hydrophobic framework residues of the V(H):V(L) interface are maintained and the only sequence changes from the corresponding human germ-line segment (V3-23/DP-47) are located in the loops comprising the complementarity determining regions (CDRs). The crystallographic structure of HEL4 reveals an unusual feature; the side-chain of a framework residue (Trp47) is flipped into a cavity formed by Gly35 of CDR1, thereby increasing the hydrophilicity of the V(H):V(L) interface. To evaluate the specific contribution of Gly35 to domain properties, Gly35 was introduced into a V(H) domain with poor solution properties. This greatly enhanced the recovery of the mutant from a gel filtration matrix, but had little effect on its ability to refold reversibly after heat denaturation. Our results confirm the importance of a hydrophilic V(H):V(L) interface for purification of isolated V(H) domains, and constitute a step towards the design of isolated human V(H) domains with practical properties for immunotherapy.     

Role of the non‐hypervariable FR3 D‐E loop in single‐domain antibody recognition of haptens and carbohydrates

Single‐domain antibodies (sdAbs), the variable domains of camelid heavy chain‐only antibodies, are generally thought to poorly recognize nonproteinaceous small molecules and carbohydrates in comparison with conventional antibodies. However, the structures of anti‐methotrexate, anti‐triclocarban and anti‐cortisol sdAbs revealed unexpected contributions of the non‐hypervariable “CDR4” loop, formed between β‐strands D and E of framework region 3, in binding. Here, we investigated the potential role of CDR4 in sdAb binding to a hapten, 15‐acetyl‐deoxynivalenol (15‐AcDON), and to carbohydrates. We constructed and panned a phage‐displayed library in which CDR4 of the 15‐AcDON‐specific sdAb, NAT‐267, was extended and randomized. From this library, we identified one sdAb, MA‐232, bearing a 14‐residue insertion in CDR4 and showing improved binding to 15‐AcDON by ELISA and surface plasmon resonance. On the basis of these results, we constructed a second set of phage‐displayed libraries in which the CDR4 and other regions of three hapten‐ or carbohydrate‐binding sdAbs were diversified. With the goal of identifying sdAbs with novel glycan‐binding specificities, we panned the library against four tumor‐associated carbohydrate antigens but were unable to enrich binding phages. Thus, we conclude that while CDR4 may play a role in binding of some rare hapten‐specific sdAbs, diversifying this region through molecular engineering is probably not a general solution to sdAb carbohydrate recognition in the absence of a paired V_L domain.     

Protein mislocalization in plant cells using a GFP‐binding chromobody

A key challenge in cell biology is to directly link protein localization to function. The green fluorescent protein (GFP)‐binding protein, GBP, is a 13‐kDa soluble protein derived from a llama heavy chain antibody that binds with high affinity to GFP as well as to some GFP variants such as yellow fluorescent protein (YFP). A GBP fusion to the red fluorescent protein (RFP), a molecule termed a chromobody, was previously used to trace in vivo the localization of various animal antigens. In this study, we extend the use of chromobody technology to plant cells and develop several applications for the in vivo study of GFP‐tagged plant proteins. We took advantage of Agrobacterium tumefaciens‐mediated transient expression assays (agroinfiltration) and virus expression vectors (agroinfection) to express functional GBP:RFP fusion (chromobody) in the model plant Nicotiana benthamiana. We showed that the chromobody is effective in binding GFP‐ and YFP‐tagged proteins in planta. Most interestingly, GBP:RFP can be applied to interfere with the function of GFP fusion protein and to mislocalize (trap) GFP fusions to the plant cytoplasm in order to alter the phenotype mediated by the targeted proteins. Chromobody technology, therefore, represents a new alternative technique for protein interference that can directly link localization of plant proteins to in vivo function.     

Structural insights and biomedical potential of IgNAR scaffolds from sharks

In addition to antibodies with the classical composition of heavy and light chains, the adaptive immune repertoire of sharks also includes a heavy-chain only isotype, where antigen binding is mediated exclusively by a small and highly stable domain, referred to as vNAR. In recent years, due to their high affinity and specificity combined with their small size, high physicochemical stability and low-cost of production, vNAR fragments have evolved as promising target-binding scaffolds that can be tailor-made for applications in medicine and biotechnology. This review highlights the structural features of vNAR molecules, addresses aspects of their generation using immunization or in vitro high throughput screening methods and provides examples of therapeutic, diagnostic and other biotechnological applications.     

Structural insights and biomedical potential of IgNAR scaffolds from sharks

In addition to antibodies with the classical composition of heavy and light chains, the adaptive immune repertoire of sharks also includes a heavy-chain only isotype, where antigen binding is mediated exclusively by a small and highly stable domain, referred to as vNAR. In recent years, due to their high affinity and specificity combined with their small size, high physicochemical stability and low-cost of production, vNAR fragments have evolved as promising target-binding scaffolds that can be tailor-made for applications in medicine and biotechnology. This review highlights the structural features of vNAR molecules, addresses aspects of their generation using immunization or in vitro high throughput screening methods and provides examples of therapeutic, diagnostic and other biotechnological applications.     

Modifications to canonical structure sequence patterns: analysis for L1 and L3

The conformation of five of the six hypervariable loops that form the antigen-binding site of antibodies is limited to a small set of structures designated as canonical structures. The canonical structure model has been constituted as a fundamental tool for the modeling of antibodies. The detailed study of tens of crystallographic structures of antibodies has shown the validity of this model in the great majority of cases. The robustness of the forecast capacity of this model depends fundamentally on the precision with which the sequence patterns that characterize each canonical structure form can be defined. Nevertheless, due to the enormous quantity of structural information about antibodies generated during the last decade, it is difficult to avoid mistakes or confusion in the model. In the present work, we propose some corrections to the model for loops L1 and L3 that permit defining sequence patterns that avoid confusion and make better forecasting of the canonical structure model possible.     

A Combinatorial Histidine Scanning Library Approach to Engineer Highly pH-Dependent Protein Switches

There is growing interest in the development of protein switches, which are proteins whose function, such as binding a target molecule, can be modulated through environmental triggers. Efforts to engineer highly pH sensitive protein–protein interactions typically rely on the rational introduction of ionizable groups in the protein interface. Such experiments are typically time intensive and often sacrifice the protein's affinity at the permissive pH. The underlying thermodynamics of proton‐linkage dictate that the presence of multiple ionizable groups, which undergo a pK_a change on protein binding, are necessary to result in highly pH‐dependent binding. To test this hypothesis, a novel combinatorial histidine library was developed where every possible combination of histidine and wild‐type residue is sampled throughout the interface of a model anti‐RNase A single domain VHH antibody. Antibodies were coselected for high‐affinity binding and pH‐sensitivity using an in vitro, dual‐function selection strategy. The resulting antibodies retained near wild‐type affinity yet became highly sensitive to small decreases in pH, drastically decreasing their binding affinity, due to the incorporation of multiple histidine groups. Several trends were observed, such as histidine “hot‐spots,” which will help enhance the development of pH switch proteins as well as increase our understanding of the role of ionizable residues in protein interfaces. Overall, the combinatorial approach is rapid, general, and robust and should be capable of producing highly pH‐sensitive protein affinity reagents for a number of different applications.     

Recombinant expression and purification of human placental growth factor 1 and specific camel heavy chain polyclonal antibody preparation

Placental growth factor (PlGF) is a member of the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) family. Unlike VEGF, PlGF is dispensable for normal cell development as well as playing various roles in pathological angiogenesis which occurs in tissue ischemia, inflammation, and malignancy. The PlGF-1 has been considered as a potential candidate for the diagnosis and targeting of pathological angiogenesis. Camelidae serum contains an important fraction of functional antibodies, called heavy-chain antibodies (HcAbs) that are naturally devoid of light chains. Camelid HcAbs recognize their cognate antigens by a single variable-domain, referred to as VHH or Nanobody.Here, we describe the expression and purification of recombinant human PlGF-1 (rhPlGF-1). This protein was subsequently used for the preparation of camel heavy chain polyclonal antibody against rhPlGF-1.The recombinant expression plasmid pET-26b-hPlGF-1 was introduced into Escherichia coli BL21 cells to express the rhPlGF-1 protein. Purified rhPlGF-1 was used to immunize camel, the specific reactivity of HcAb was determined with ELISA and western blot. Western blot analysis indicated that the antiserum specifically reacted to the recombinant protein. The rhPlGF-1 protein and its antibody may be used for the development of detection assays needed for clinical research.     

纳米抗体技术及其在疾病诊断和治疗中的应用

单克隆抗体具有特异性结合抗原的能力,已被广泛应用于疾病诊断及治疗领域.但因单克隆抗体的组织渗透能力较差、体内的保留时间较长以及制备过程繁琐,从而限制了其在临床中的应用.自1993年首次报道在骆驼体内天然存在的单链抗体(HCAb)以来,由于其可变区间VHH(纳米抗体)具有体积小、溶解度高、特异性强以及可在细菌中大量表达等优点,较之传统单克隆抗体,VHH在疾病的诊断治疗及药物开发等医学领域具有更广阔的应用前景.本文综述了:纳米抗体的骨架区及互补决定区与传统抗体重链相应区间的结构比较;纳米抗体库的构建以及运用噬菌体展示技术对VHH库的筛选;纳米抗体技术在疾病诊断中的应用及其用于分子显像的优势,以及纳米抗体作为抗肿瘤免疫偶联物的靶向组分在癌症治疗领域中的最新进展.     

Single domain antibodies for the knockdown of cytosolic and nuclear proteins

Single domain antibodies (sdAbs) from camels or sharks comprise only the variable heavy chain domain. Human sdAbs comprise the variable domain of the heavy chain (VH) or light chain (VL) and can be selected from human antibodies. SdAbs are stable, nonaggregating molecules in vitro and in vivo compared to complete antibodies and scFv fragments. They are excellent novel inhibitors of cytosolic/nuclear proteins because they are correctly folded inside the cytosol in contrast to scFv fragments. SdAbs are unique because of their excellent specificity and possibility to target posttranslational modifications such as phosphorylation sites, conformers or interaction regions of proteins that cannot be targeted with genetic knockout techniques and are impossible to knockdown with RNAi. The number of inhibiting cytosolic/nuclear sdAbs is increasing and usage of synthetic single pot single domain antibody libraries will boost the generation of these fascinating molecules without the need of immunization. The most frequently selected antigenic epitopes belong to viral and oncogenic proteins, followed by toxins, proteins of the nervous system as well as plant‐ and drosophila proteins. It is now possible to select functional sdAbs against virtually every cytosolic/nuclear protein and desired epitope. The development of new endosomal escape protein domains and cell‐penetrating peptides for efficient transfection broaden the application of inhibiting sdAbs. Last but not least, the generation of relatively new cell‐specific nanoparticles such as polymersomes and polyplexes carrying cytosolic/nuclear sdAb‐DNA or –protein will pave the way to apply cytosolic/nuclear sdAbs for inhibition of viral infection and cancer in the clinic.     

基于细胞的抗单增李斯特菌单域重链抗体的筛选及鉴定

【目的】获得针对单增李斯特菌的特异性单域重链抗体,并对筛选过程中特异性克隆的富集规律进行分析,为筛选具有种属特异性的噬菌体展示抗体提供参考。【方法】采用固相筛选技术,以热灭活的单增李斯特菌菌体为抗原,通过四轮常规筛选和一轮消减筛选,从驼源天然噬菌体展示文库中筛选针对单增李斯特菌的单域重链抗体。采用Phage-ELISA法,对后四轮筛选洗脱物中随机挑选的噬菌体进行鉴定,阳性克隆进行基因测序及结合特异性分析。通过多序列比对分析将获得的基因序列进行分组和统计。【结果】成功筛选到2株单增李斯特菌特异性的单域重链抗体。【结论】在优化的筛选条件下,基于全细胞的筛选方法能够获得特异性识别单增李斯特菌的单域重链抗体,消减筛选对于去除非特异性克隆是有效的和必要的。     

Contributions of CDR3 to V H H domain stability and the design of monobody scaffolds for naive antibody libraries

Camelids produce functional antibodies devoid of light chains. Autonomous heavy chain variable (V(H)H) domains in these molecules have adapted to the absence of the light chain in the following ways: bulky hydrophobic residues replace small aliphatic residues in the former light chain interface, and residues from the third complementarity-determining region (CDR3) pack against the framework and stabilize the global V(H)H domain fold. To determine the specific roles of CDR3 residues in framework stabilization, we used nai;ve phage-displayed libraries, combinatorial alanine-scanning mutagenesis and biophysical characterization of purified proteins. Our results indicate that in the most stable scaffolds, the structural residues in CDR3 reside near the boundaries of the loop and pack against the framework to form a small hydrophobic core. These results allow us to differentiate between structural CDR3 residues that should remain fixed, and CDR3 residues that are tolerant to substitution and can therefore be varied to generate functional diversity within phage-displayed libraries. These methods and insights can be applied to the rapid design of heavy chain scaffolds for the identification of novel ligands using synthetic, antibody-phage libraries. In addition, they shed light on the relationships between CDR3 sequence diversity and the structural stability of the V(H)H domain fold.     

抗肠炎沙门氏菌单链抗体制备及其特异性分析

目的:利用基因工程技术制备抗肠炎沙门氏菌的单链抗体.方法:从抗肠炎沙门氏菌单克隆抗体的杂交瘤细胞中纯化RNA,反转录后扩增出抗体的重链可变区(VH)和轻链可变区(VL)基因片段,采用重叠延伸的方法,用柔性多肽Linker接头(Gly4 Ser)3按VL-Linker-VH方式将VH基因和VL基因拼接成单链抗体基因片段后,连接到pGEX-4T-1载体上,进行重组转化.挑取阳性克隆,经IPTG诱导后,通过GST柱进行亲和层析,最后利用ELISA检测抗体的活性.结果:成功构建了表达抗肠炎沙门氏菌单链抗体的基因工程菌株,经SDS-PAGE和ELISA检测结果表明,诱导表达的单链抗体scFv分子量约为60 kDa,其能特异与肠炎沙门氏菌结合,但与副甲伤寒沙门氏菌、鸭沙门氏菌、鼠伤寒沙门氏菌有轻度交叉反应.结论:成功构建了抗肠炎沙门氏菌单链抗体的表达菌株,表达的单链抗体scFv可作为沙门氏菌的检测的候选抗体分子.     

Structural basis for llama nanobody recognition and neutralization of HIV-1 at the CD4-binding site

1. Download : Download high-res image (320KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Modification of the first constant domain of heavy chain enabled effective folding of functional anti-forskolin antigen-binding fragment for sensitive quantitative analysis

The assembly between heavy and light chains is a critical step of immunoglobulin (Ig) and fragment antigen-binding (Fab) antibody expression and of their binding activity. The genes encoding Fab were obtained from hybridoma cells secreting monoclonal antibody (MAb, IgG2b) against adenylate cyclase activator forskolin (FOR). The subclass of the first constant domain of heavy chain (C_H1) of IgG2b was modified to IgG1 via overlap extension polymerase chain reaction and expressed via Escherichia coli bacterial system. Since both Fabs (IgG2b and IgG1) were expressed as inclusion bodies, functional analysis was performed after in vitro refolding via stepwise dialysis. The result indicated that the folding efficiency between V_H-C_H1 and V_L-C_L was improved by the C_H1 modification from IgG2b to IgG1 subclass, although their specificity for FOR was not altered. Effective folding of IgG1 was also observed when they were expressed in the hemolymph of silkworm larvae using the Bombyx mori nuclear polyhedrosis virus bacmid system. An indirect competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (icELISA) was then developed for the determination of FOR using effectively prepared Fab IgG1. The sensitivity of FOR determination was in the range of 3.91–62.5 ng/mL with less than 9% relative standard deviation, implying the sensitive and reliable analysis of developed icELISA. In addition, high accuracy of the icELISA was supported by the results of spiked-and-recovery tests, ranging from 100.2 to 102.3%. Therefore, Fab could be utilized reliably for icELISA instead of the more expensive MAb. Collectively, this approach improved productivity of Fab and reduced the cost of antibody production.     

Biochemistry,structure, and cellular internalization of a four nanobody‐bearing Fc dimer

VHH stands for the variable regions of heavy chain only of camelid IgGs. The VHH family forms a set of interesting proteins derived from antibodies that maintain their capacity to recognize the antigen, despite their relatively small molecular weight (in the 12,000 Da range). Continuing our exploration of the possibilities of those molecules, we chose to design alternative molecules with maintained antigen recognition, but enhanced capacity, by fusing four VHH with one Fc, the fragment crystallizable region of antibodies. In doing so, we aimed at having a molecule with superior quantitative antigen recognition (×4) while maintaining its size below the 110 kDa. In the present paper, we described the building of those molecules that we coined VHH₂‐Fc‐VHH₂. The structure of VHH₂‐Fc‐VHH₂ in complex with HER2 antigen was determined using electronic microscopy and modeling. The molecule is shown to bind four HER2 proteins at the end of its flexible arms. VHH₂‐Fc‐VHH₂ also shows an internalization capacity via HER2 receptor superior to the reference anti‐HER2 monoclonal antibody, Herceptin®, and to a simple fusion of two VHH with one Fc (VHH₂‐Fc). This new type of molecules, VHH₂‐Fc‐VHH₂, could be an interesting addition to the therapeutic arsenal with multiple applications, from diagnostic to therapy.     

Structural Basis of Epitope Recognition by Heavy-Chain Camelid Antibodies

Truncated versions of heavy-chain antibodies (HCAbs) from camelids, also termed nanobodies, comprise only one-tenth the mass of conventional antibodies, yet retain similar, high binding affinities for the antigens. Here we analyze a large data set of nanobody–antigen crystal structures and investigate how nanobody–antigen recognition compares to the one by conventional antibodies. We find that nanobody paratopes are enriched in aromatic residues just like conventional antibodies, but additionally, they also bear a more hydrophobic character. Most striking differences were observed in the characteristics of the antigen's epitope. Unlike conventional antibodies, nanobodies bind to more rigid, concave, conserved and structured epitopes enriched with aromatic residues. Nanobodies establish fewer interactions with the antigens compared to conventional antibodies, and we speculate that high binding affinities are achieved due to less unfavorable conformational and more favorable solvation entropy contributions. We observed that interactions with antigen are mediated not only by three CDR loops but also by numerous residues from the nanobody framework. These residues are not distributed uniformly; rather, they are concentrated into four structurally distinct regions and mediate mostly charged interactions. Our findings suggest that in some respects nanobody–antigen interactions are more similar to the general protein–protein interactions rather than antibody–antigen interactions.