Effects of fire on the vegetation of a lowland heathland in North-western Italy

This study focuses on the effect of fire on lowland heathlands at the extreme southern edge of their European distribution (Vauda Nature Reserve, NW Italy). Forty-nine plots (50 m radius) were surveyed between 1999 and 2006. Each year, fire occurrences were recorded and per cent cover of four vegetation types (grassland, heath, low shrubland, and tall shrubland) was estimated in each plot. Vascular plant species richness was also recorded in 255, 1 m² quadrats. After a fire, grassland vegetation expanded, but then declined rapidly as heath and shrubland recovered: 7 years after a fire, tall shrubland encroached on to more than 40% of the plots, and grassland declined from 50% to 20% cover. Between 1999 and 2006, Betula pendula shrubland greatly expanded, while grassland decreased over most of the Reserve, even where fire frequency was high. Tall shrubland had low plant diversity and was dominated by widespread species of lower conservation value. By contrast, early successional vegetation (grassland and low shrubland) had higher richness and more narrowly distributed species, indication that the development of tall shrubland causes significant species loss in the heathland. Italian lowland heathlands are characterized by high rates of shrubland encroachment that threatens both habitat and species diversity. Burning frequencies of once in 3–6 years seem appropriate in this habitat, but burning alone might not suffice without actions to increase herbivore grazing.     

Conservation of Calluno-Vaccinietum heathland in the Belgian Ardennes,an experimental approach

It is now difficult to manage the semi-natural groupings of heathland because of the tendency for succession towards forest stages.Several experiments were conducted in the Hautes Fagnes region (Belgium). After the vegetation was mapped, plots were treated by mowing, burn-beating, and burning.The changing floristic composition was followed from 1972 to 1980 in permanent quadrats. Burn-beating is an excellent method of management for old heath, because it reestablishes the properties of the heath ecosystem.Nomenclature follows de Langhe et al., 1978. Nouvelle flore de la Belgique, du Grand-Duché de Luxembourg, du Nord de la France et des Régions voisines, 2e éd.     

Pattern development of the vegetation during colonization of a burnt heathland in Brittany (France)

Plant Ecology - The main part of the heathlands in the Paimpont area (Morbihan, and Ille-et-Vilaine, France) was burnt during spring and summer 1976. The pattern development of the vegetation was...     

The role of catastrophic death of Calluna in heathland dynamics

In the Breckland heaths of East Anglia large patches of Calluna are often killed by adverse climatic conditions or insect attack. This paper studies one site, Cavenham Heath, where large areas of Calluna were killed between 1976–1979, and shows that older stands were most affected, and recovery was slowest compared to either younger stands, or stands with an uneven-aged structure. Moreover, where Calluna death was most severe, directional succession to birch woodland was accelerated. At this site, although Calluna regeneration has been previously assumed to be initiated by endogenous factors (i.e. by the life cycle of the Calluna), it is also clearly interrupted by exogenous factors. The implications of these results for heathland conservation are discussed, and it is suggested that intervention management by cutting and burning, to maintain large areas of Calluna in the building phase, may be the most appropriate long term strategy.This work was funded in part by the Nature Conservancy Council as part of its research programme into nature conservation. I thank Mr D. Malins and Mrs D. Reynolds for assistance in both the field and the laboratory, Ms S. Ide and Mr J. Pattin-gale for preparing the figures, and Professor C. H. Gimigham, Dr J. Miles and Dr I. C. Prentice for helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper.     

Shoot regeneration after fire or freezing temperatures and its relation to plant life-form for some heathland species

Shoot regeneration after prescribed burning or following the freezing temperatures of winter was monitored for nineteen heathland species present in an Arctostaphyleto-Callunetum community in northeast Scotland. Species whose renewal buds were near the surface of the ground started to grow earlier in the spring than species with renewal buds above the surface, but grouping species according to the position of their renewal bud (i.e. their life-form) did not account for all of the interspecific variation apparent. In the case of shoot regeneration after fire, species whose renewal buds were destroyed by fire because they were above-ground started to regenerate about the same time as species with belowground buds, protected from fire, but reached their maximum frequency of occurrence later. Grouping species by life-form was of limited value as a means of interpreting this interspecific variation in the timing of shoot regeneration after fire. It would be unwise to use plant life-form as the sole basis for interpreting or predicting a species' response to temperature stress when extreme temperatures occur regularly, as they do in heathland. The possible use of other plant traits to interpret and predict interspecific variation in the regeneration rate of heathland plants is discussed.Nomenclature follows Tutin et al. (1964–1980) for vascular plants. Acknowledgements. The Nature Conservancy Council and Mr J. J. Humphries kindly allowed Dinnet Moor to be used for the work presented here. One of us (RJR) received financial support for field work from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada.     

Short-term study of effects of fertilisation and cutting treatments on the vegetation dynamics of mountain heathlands in Spain

The influence of management and nutrient availability on the vegetation dynamics of heathlands characterised by Calluna vulgaris and Erica tetralix were studied in three mountain sites in Northern Spain. A total of 90 plots (1 m² each) received different combinations of cutting and twice the estimated background atmospheric deposition of nitrogen (56 kg ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹). One of the two dominant ericaceous species was selectively cut by hand at ground level and their regeneration compared in the presence or absence of the other. The results after 2 years showed significant effects of the fertiliser on the vegetation cover, mainly by favouring perennial herbaceous species. There were less noteworthy effects on the number of flowers and on the annual growth of the ericaceous species. It is concluded that, in the short term, increased nutrients alone, at twice the estimated current atmospheric deposition for the area, will not alter significantly the composition of the mountain heathlands. However, once the stands reach the mature phase, the capacity of the community to regenerate after a severe disturbance diminishes. A drastic impact, such as cutting may not result in re-growth of the same shrub species but in replacement by herbaceous species, which will also benefit from the increased nutrients.     

Effects of prescribed burning on plant available nutrients in dry heathland ecosystems

Heathland management is an important tool with which to modify ecosystem impacts caused by atmospheric nutrient deposition. Since changes in nutrient availability as a result of management measures affect the outcomes of heathland succession and species competition, studies on this issue are important from both a nature conservation and management point of view. This study reports the effects of prescribed burning on nutrient availability in dry heathland soils and the nutrient content of the two competing heathland species Calluna vulgaris and Deschampsia flexuosa, with particular reference to N and P. We hypothesise that winter prescribed burning leads to additional N availability, which enhances the importance of P in the context of nutrient limitation in heathland ecosystems. In the nature reserve “Lueneburg Heath” (NW Germany) we examined the availability of nutrients in the humus horizons and in the leachate as well as the relevant C:element ratios in Calluna and Deschampsia before and after a burning experiment. Our results show that prescribed burning resulted in drastically increased NH₄⁺ availability in the O-horizon. We observed only short-term effects (for NO₃⁻, PO₄³⁻, Mg) and insignificant effects on the availability of other nutrients (K, Ca). As a consequence of an increased nutrient availability in the humus horizons and a limited nutrient uptake by plants after burning, leaching increased significantly for N, Ca, K, and Mg after burning treatment. No significant changes were found in the foliar C:N ratios for either species after prescribed burning, although Deschampsia showed an increased deficiency for all the other nutrients, particularly for P, as expressed by increased foliar C:P and N:P ratios. By contrast, the nutrient content of Calluna did not change significantly, suggesting that prescribed burning favours the competitive capacity of Calluna as against Deschampsia. We assume that water shortage as a result of changes in the microclimate was mainly responsible for the deterioration of the nutrient content of Deschampsia. This gives Calluna a competitive advantage, enabling it to out-compete Deschampsia on burned heathlands, with respect to the key factor P-limitation.     

A model of Calluna population dynamics; the effects of varying seed and vegetative regeneration

Regeneration of Calluna vulgaris in heathlands occurs from both seed and layering, although the relative importance of these two strategies appears to vary. A population model based on transitions between growth phases has been devised and parameter values obtained from published and original work. The effects of differing amounts of seed and vegetative regeneration on the population changes were then tested.The model predicts that a population with a relatively high occurrence of layering will tend towards a steady state, with little temporal variation in population density and cover. Conversely, low layering capacity increases temporal variation with little effect on mean cover. Increased seed regeneration on the other hand, increases both the amplitude of temporal variation in population density, and the frequency of cycles, whereas low seed regeneration results in a stable age distribution at less than 100% cover.     

Markov models in the study of post-fire succession in heathland communities

Data on the presence of a number of vegetation states (defined in terms of species dominance in areas of 10×10 cm) and transition probabilities were derived from permanent quadrats in a number of recently burned heath stands. Data were taken from a species-rich community, a species-poor type and a high-level Calluna-Eriophorum bog. Simple Markovian models were constructed using these data, and the model predictions were compared with known or expected trends. Models for species-rich heath yielded poor simulations of expected trends since matrices derived from data for the first years after fire did not contain sufficient information on transitions to states important later in the developmental sequence. Model results for the simpler species-poor and bog communities were more satisfactory and simulated expected trends. In these types all species recovered quickly after fire and less rearrangement of species abundances took place. Maximum likelihood statistics carried out on the transition matrices produced inconclusive results for the species-rich and species-poor types, but indicated that the data from the Calluna-Eriophorum bog approximated a first-order time-homogeneous Markov chain. It was concluded that Markov models lack predictive ability except in relatively simple systems, but that they may be useful in illustrating variations in short-term community dynamics.Nomenclature follows Tutin et al. (1964–80) for vascular plants and Smith (1978) for mosses.I am grateful to Prof. C. H. Gimingham for help and advice during this study, which was carried out during tenure of a Natural Environment Research Council studentship. Thanks are also due to Dr M. B. Usher and an anonymous referee for their comments on the draft.     

Soil seed banks of woodland, heathland, grassland, mire and montane communities, Cairngorm Mountains, Scotland

The size and species composition of soil seed banks were assessed at 111 altitudinally diverse sites in the Cairngorm Mountains. Mean densities of germinable seeds varied from 83 000 m^–2 in Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) woodland at 230–490 m to 200 m^–2 in moss (Racomitrium lanuginosum (Hedw.) Brid.) heath at 1000–1120 m. Seed banks were dominated by Calluna vulgaris (L.) Hull, not only wherever it was prominent in the vegetation, but also at some sites with less than 5% cover of parent plants in the ground vegetation. Many species conspicuous in the vegetation were under-represented in or absent from the seed bank and surface vegetation generally was more species rich than was the underlying seed bank, especially in high montane communities. Multiple regression was used to examine the relationship between the density of buried Calluna seeds and the abundance of parent plants in the vegetation, site altitude and the organic matter content of the soil. The model fitted to woodland communities accounted for 95% of the variation in seed density. The heathland model was less predictive but still explained 52% of the variation in seed bank size. In mire communities there was no relationship, collective or individual, between buried seed density and the measured environmental variables, possibly due to variations in the duration and frequency of waterlogging at these sites. The potential role of seed banks for initiating the recolonisation of disturbed ground is discussed. Densities of buried seeds at most Calluna-dominant sites were probably sufficient to generate successful recolonisation but the prospects for recovery were poor at other sites, particularly in graminaceous communities at 800 m or higher.     

Nutrient leaching in dry heathland ecosystems: effects of atmospheric deposition and management

Atmospheric nutrient deposition has contributed to widespread changes in sensitive seminatural ecosystems throughout Europe. For an understanding of underlying processes it is important to quantify input–output flows in relation to ongoing atmospheric inputs and current management strategies. In this study we quantified losses of N, P, Ca, Mg, and K via leaching in heathland ecosystems (Lüneburger Heide, NW Germany) as a function of current deposition rates and different management measures (mowing, prescribed burning, choppering, sod-cutting) which aim to prevent shrub and tree encroachment. Leaching was only moderately related to atmospheric input rates, indicating that leaching was mostly affected by internal turnover processes. Leaching significantly increased for most of the nutrients after the application of management measures, particularly in the choppered and sod-cut plots. However, atmospheric nutrient inputs exceeded leaching outputs for most of the nutrients, even in the plots subjected to management. Despite high deposition rates (20–25 kg N ha⁻¹ year⁻¹), retention of atmospheric N input ranged between 74% and 92% in the control plots. In the treated plots, N retention decreased to 59–80%. However, in the study area mean N leaching in the controls has almost doubled since 1980 and currently amounts to 3.7 kg ha⁻¹ year⁻¹, indicating an early stage of N saturation. Our study provides evidence that leaching did not compensate for atmospheric nutrient deposition, particularly as regards N. Management, thus, will be an indispensable tool for the maintenance of the low-nutrient status as a prerequisite for the long-term preservation of heathland ecosystems.     

Transition from heathland to grassland initiated by the heather beetle

This paper discusses the transition from heather-dominated vegetation to one dominated by grass. The dominating species involved are Calluna vulgaris and Deschampsia flexuosa. The study covered three years, 1980–82, and was done at the Hoorneboeg heathland in the Netherlands. Several factors account for this transition: damage caused by the chrysomelid heather beetle Lochmaea suturalis Thomson, soil type, and interaction between beetle damage and Deschampsia when already present underneath or in the immediate vicinity of a Calluna canopy. There was a time-lag between beetle damage and grass establishment or expansion. In fact, this transition concerns a type of vegetation succession and can be treated as such. This succession therefore involves several causative factors external to the system Calluna-Deschampsia. The successional process is conceived as a stochastic one defined by transition probabilities which depend on a time component, a space component and a logistic response component. All these components are discussed in this paper, but the discussion of yet another component, the crowding of Deschampsia itself, will be treated separately.     

A reappraisal of cyclical processes in Calluna heath

Small-scale, short-term cycles constitute an important aspect of vegetation dynamics. It has been widely accepted that such cycles are characteristic of unmanaged heath communities where the dominant, Calluna vulgaris, undergoes an age-related series of changes in its growth and morphology. This is thought to give rise to a repetitive sequence of changes in the occupancy of gaps which form in the Calluna canopy and are first colonized by other species, with Calluna re-establishing later. Recently, doubts have been cast as to whether the changes are in fact often repetitive. A new study has shown much greater variability than was previously suspected in the transitions occurring in gaps. There is evidence that, in some instances though by no means all, Calluna can re-establish and thereby initiate a genuine cycle. It seems, however, that such re-entry is seldom by means of seedling establishment, but more frequently by development of adventitious shoots and roots on stems which have come to lie across the gap and have been covered by moss, moist litter or humus.     

Effects of a heather beetle attack on soil moisture and water balance at a Danish heathland

The effects of reclamation and high atmospheric nitrogen deposition have for long threatened the existence of heathlands in Denmark. A high nitrogen input increases the frequency and intensity of heather beetle attacks. However, any indirect effects of these attacks on the soil water balance are seldom investigated. In autumn 1994 a 2000-year old Danish inland heath was struck by a severe heather beetle attack and the effects on the soil moisture and the water balance were studied. Soil water content, gross precipitation and throughfall were measured continuously from 1993 to 1998 at the heath. The first signs of the attack on the water balance were seen in the dry summer of 1995 when the soil water content was relatively high. Four years after the beetle attack, new heather plants covered the area again and during summer the soil water seemed to be depleted to the same degree as before the beetle attack. In the years after the beetle attack a high coefficient of variation between individual soil moisture measurements was seen. It is proposed that the inhomogeneous wetting was caused by heterogeneous throughfall, water-repellent soil and break down of the structure of the organic top-horizons due to the beetle attack. The effect of the beetle attack was examined using a simple water balance model. Model simulations showed that evapotranspiration was reduced by respectively, 14, 29 and 5% in the three years following the beetle attack. From 1993 to 1998 percolation was on average 62% of precipitation with very little variation from year to year. Evapotranspiration was on average 38%, but in the years affected most by the beetle attack transpiration was relatively low whereas evaporation from soil was increased. A comparison between the modelled and measured throughfall, as well as percolation estimated by the chloride mass balance method, showed that the water balance parameters were estimated well in the two years which were most affected by the beetle attack, i.e. 1995 and 1996.     

Nitrification in Dutch heathland soils

A survey was conducted over a range of 17 Dutch heathland locations, subdivided into 41 sites dominated by either dwarf-shrubs (Calluna vulgaris or Erica tetralix) or grass species (Deschampsia flexuosa or Molinia caerulea). Among the habitats of the dominant plant species relatively little differences in general soil properties were observed. The P status of Deschampsia sites was relatively high as well as the NO₃ ^–-N concentrations in the 0–10 cm layer (FH included) at the grass-dominated sites. At sites with a dead or degenerating dwarf-shrub vegetation, NH₄ ⁺-N concentrations reached very high levels.Net production of nitrate was observed during incubation of intact 0–10 cm soil cores (FH-layer included) in the laboratory for all sites, even though in some instances, particularly at Calluna and Erica sites, no nitrate was initially measured. Generally, a higher nitrification rate was found for the grass-dominated sites, and for Deschampsia in particular. The net production of nitrate was highly significantly correlated with net N mineralization, being a reasonable predictor of nitrification in a simple regression model (R²=0.47; P<0.001). Net nitrification was also significantly correlated with the NO₃ ^–-N initially present at the start of the growing season (R=0.65; P<0.001) and with the labile organic P content of the soil (R=0.65; P<0.001). By including initial NO₃ ^–-N and labile organic P, together with net N mineralization and pH, in a multiple regression model, net nitrate production could be predicted with a much higher precision (R²=0.75; P<0.001). Although apparent nitrification was not significantly correlated with pH, the latter contributed significantly to the multiple regression equation for the prediction of the former.The influence of the labile organic P pool may act via its positive correlation with microbial biomass, thus more or less reflecting the potential mineralization/nitrifying capacity of a particular site.     

The interpretation of process from pattern using two-dimensional spectral analysis: modelling single species patterns in vegetation

Two-dimensional spectral analyses of spatial patterns are made using (i) the autocorrelation function, (ii) the periodogram, and its polar summary (iii) the R-spectrum and (iv) the -spectrum. Together these give a sensitive analysis of both the complete range of scales of pattern and directional components which exist in data sets and we illustrate how the significance of observed spectral features can be assessed.We investigate the spatial pattern of Calluna vulgaris in a regenerating woodland and of Epilobium angustifolium spreading in a woodland following the thinning of trees. Evidence in the spectra is found for directional, clumping and inhibition patterns, and is discussed in relation to spectra obtained from simulations of known pattern generating processes. Hypotheses about the important biological, environmental and management influences on the structure of the communities are examined.We gratefully acknowledge the Swedish Coniferous Biome Project and Dr P. J. Diggle for access to the heather data.     

The occurrence of former heathland vegetation in the coastal areas of the south-east Baltic sea,in particular Lithuania: a review

Previously published pollen diagrams from the coastal area of the south-east Baltic Sea including parts of the Polish and Lithuanian peninsulas, Mierzeja Wilana (Frische Nehrung) and Kuri Nerija (Courland Spit) respectively, document the former presence of heathland vegetation and an associated burning practice. This type of human influence can be dated back to ca. 1200 B.P. at the latest, and was maintained until the 18th century. It is suggested that this former Calluna-dominated vegetation belonged to the known west to north-west European heathland vegetation. Several dwarf shrub taxa, such as Genista spp. and Erica tetralix, normally connected to heathland vegetation, may have had a former wider distribution.     

The effect of nutrient supply and light intensity on tannins and mycorrhizal colonisation in Dutch heathland ecosystems

(1) Increased atmospheric nitrogen deposition has shifted plant dominance from ericaceous plants to grass species. To elucidate the reduced competitiveness of heather, we tested the hypothesis that additions of nitrogen reduce the concentrations of phenolics and condensed tannins in ericaceous leaves and retard mycorrhizal colonisation in ericaceous plants. We also tested the negative effects of reduced light intensity on carbon-based secondary compounds and mycorrhizal colonisation in ericaceous plants. (2) We performed a field inventory at three heathland sites in the Netherlands varying in nutrient supply and light intensity. Leaves of ericaceous plants and grasses were collected and analysed for concentrations of tannins, phenolics and nutrients. Similarly, we took root samples to record mycorrhizal colonisation and soil samples to measure the soil mineralisation. In addition, we conducted two-factorial experiments with Calluna vulgaris plants, in which we varied fertiliser and shade levels under greenhouse and field conditions. (3) The field inventory revealed that nitrogen addition and shading both negatively affected the concentration of total phenolics. The total phenolics and condensed tannin concentrations were positively correlated (P < 0.001), but in the field experiment, the condensed tannins were not significantly affected by the treatments. Our results provide the first evidence that the carbon nutrient balance can be used to predict the amount of total phenolics in the dwarf shrub C. vulgaris. (4) In the field experiments, shading of plants resulted in significantly less mycorrhizal colonisation. Only in the greenhouse experiment did addition of nitrogen negatively affect mycorrhizal colonisation. (5) Our results imply that increased atmospheric nitrogen deposition can depress the tannin concentrations in ericaceous plants and the mycorrhizal colonisation in roots, thereby reducing the plants’ competitiveness with respect to grasses. Additionally, if ericaceous plants are shaded by grasses that have become dominant due to increased nitrogen supply, these effects will be intensified and competitive replacement will be accelerated.