A mutation in the 530 loop of Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA causes resistance to streptomycin.

Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis was used to introduce an A to C transversion at position 523 in the 16S ribosomal RNA gene of Escherichia coli rrnB operon cloned in plasmid pKK3535. E. coli cells transformed with the mutated plasmid were resistant to streptomycin. The mutated ribosomes isolated from these cells were not stimulated by streptomycin to misread the message in a poly(U)-directed assay. They were also restrictive to the stimulation of misreading by other error-promoting related aminoglycoside antibiotics such as neomycin, kanamycin or gentamicin, which do not compete for the streptomycin binding site. The 530 loop where the mutation in the 16S rRNA is located has been mapped at the external surface of the 30S subunit, and is therefore distal from the streptomycin binding site at the subunit interface. Our results support the conclusion that the mutation at position 523 in the 16S rRNA does not interfere with the binding of streptomycin, but prevents the drug from inducing conformational changes in the 530 loop which account for its miscoding effect. Since this effect primarily results from a perturbation of the translational proofreading control, our results also provide evidence that the 530 loop of the 16S rRNA is involved in this accuracy control.     

Structural changes in the 530 loop of Escherichia coli 16S rRNA in mutants with impaired translational fidelity.

The higher order structure of the functionally important 530 loop in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA was studied in mutants with single base changes at position 517, which significantly impair translational fidelity. The 530 loop has been proposed to interact with the EF-Tu-GTP-aatRNA ternary complex during decoding. The reactivity at G530, U531 and A532 to the chemical probes kethoxal, CMCT and DMS respectively was increased in the mutant 16S rRNA compared with the wild-type, suggesting a more open 530 loop structure in the mutant ribosomes. This was supported by oligonucleotide binding experiments in which probes complementary to positions 520-526 and 527-533, but not control probes, showed increased binding to the 517C mutant 70S ribosomes compared with the non-mutant control. Furthermore, enzymatic digestion of 70S ribosomes with RNase T1, specific for single-stranded RNA, substantially cleaved both wild-type and mutant rRNAs between G524 and C525, two of the nucleotides involved in the 530 loop pseudoknot. This site was also cleaved in the 517C mutant, but not wild-type rRNA, by RNase V1. Such a result is still consistent with a more open 530 loop structure in the mutant ribosomes, since RNase V1 can cut at appropriately stacked single-stranded regions of RNA. Together these data indicate that the 517C mutant rRNA has a rather extensively unfolded 530 loop structure. Less extensive structural changes were found in mutants 517A and 517U, which caused less misreading. A correlation between the structural changes in the 530 loop and impaired translational accuracy is proposed.     

Increase of fidelity of polypeptide synthesis by spermidine in eukaryotic cell-free systems

The mechanism of spermidine-induced increase of fidelity of polypeptide synthesis in a wheat germ cell-free system has been studied. It was found that the increase of fidelity in the presence of spermidine occurred mainly at the level of binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to ribosomes, that reduction of misreading was more marked at the 5'-base than at the 3'-base of the codon and that misreading caused by paromomycin and kanamycin C was not significantly decreased by spermidine. It was deduced from these results that spermidine inhibited low-frequency misreading more strongly than high-frequency misreading. In addition, spermidine was found to stimulate the rejection of non-cognate aminoacyl-tRNA mainly at an initial discrimination step during the binding of amino-acyl-tRNA to ribosomes, and slightly at a subsequent GTP-dependent discrimination step, the so-called proofreading step. In yeast, rabbit reticulocyte, and Artemia salina cell-free systems, spermidine was found to increase the fidelity of protein synthesis.     

Effect of Mg2+ concentration, polyamines, streptomycin, and mutations in ribosomal proteins on the accuracy of the two-step selection of aminoacyl-tRNAs in protein biosynthesis

Discrimination against the binding of noncognate aminoacyl (aa)-tRNAs by mRNA-programmed ribosomes is the outcome of two selection steps, one involving an aa-tRNA.EFTu.GTP complex, which occurs prior to and includes GTP hydrolysis, the other involving the aa-tRNA alone, which follows GTP hydrolysis. Conditions which lead to errors in protein synthesis have been found to influence the accuracy of one or both selection steps in a system measuring poly(U)-directed binding of Leu-tRNA2Leu. Streptomycin has a large effect only on the discrimination process following GTP hydrolysis, but the other pertubations of recognition studied, high [Mg2+], polyamines, the strA1 and ram1 mutations, affect both discrimination processes. The general result is consistent with the view that proofreading of aa-tRNA by ribosomes for the most part uses the same specificity determinants used in the initial selection of a ternary complex.     

The effect of mutations in ribosomal proteins S4, S12 and L7/L12 on EF-Tu-dependent expenditure of GTP in the process of codon-specific elongation and misreading of poly(U)

The effect of mutations in ribosomal proteins S4 (rpsD12), S12 (rpsL282) and L7/L12 (rplL265) of Escherichia coli K12 on the EF-Tu-dependent expenditure of GTP during codon-specific elongation (poly(Phe) synthesis on poly(U] and misreading (poly(Leu) synthesis on poly(U], was studied. Under the conditions used the mutations in proteins S4 and L7/L12 did not practically affect the EF-Tu-dependent expenditure of GTR during the poly(Phe) synthesis on poly(U): the GTP/Phe ratio was about 1, as in the case of the wild strain. Under the same conditions, the ribosomes with a mutant S12 protein tended to discard some amount of Phe-tRNA, as a result of which the GTP/Phe ratio increased to about 3. The marked inhibition of misreading by ribosomes with a mutant S12 protein was accompanied by a significant increase of GTP expenditure at the stage of EF-Tu-dependent non-cognate aminoacyl-tRNA binding. In mutant S 12 proteins the GTP/Leu ratio was about 30-40, whereas in the wild type it was about 12. In contrast, stimulation of misreading by ribosomes with mutant S4 and L7/L12 proteins was accompanied by a decrease of the EF-Tu-dependent expenditure of GTP by 2-3 GTP molecules per one Leu residue included into the peptide.     

The interaction between streptomycin and ribosomal RNA

The present study shows that a mutation in the 530 loop of 16S rRNA impairs the binding of streptomycin to the bacterial ribosome, thereby restricting the misreading effect of the drug. Previous reports demonstrated that proteins S4, S5 and S12 as well as the 915 region of 16S rRNA are involved in the binding of streptomycin, and indicated that the drug not only interacts with the 30S subunit but also with the 50S subunit. The relationship between the target of streptomycin and its known interference with the proofreading control of translational accuracy is examined in light of these results.     

The excess GTP hydrolyzed during mistranslation is expended at the stage of EF-Tu-promoted binding of non-cognate aminoacyl-tRNA

The system of translation of Sepharose-bound poly(U) in which all ribosomes are active in peptide elongation was used to determine the stoichiometry of GTP hydrolysis at the stage of EF-Tu-promoted aminoacyl-tRNA binding. The ratio of GTP hydrolyzed at this stage per peptide bond was assayed during codon-specific elongation (polyphenylalanine synthesis) and misreading (polyleucine synthesis). It was demonstrated directly that the excess GTP hydrolyzed during misreading [(1984) FEBS Letters 178, 283-287] is expended at the stage of Ef-Tu-promoted binding of non-cognate aminoacyl-tRNA.     

Novel mutants of 23S RNA: characterization of functional properties.

Single point mutations corresponding to the positions G2505 and G2583 have been constructed in the gene encoding E.coli 23S rRNA. These mutations were linked to the second mutation A1067 to T, known to confer resistance to thiostrepton (1). Mutant ribosomes were analyzed in vitro for their ability to direct poly(U) dependent translation, their missence error frequency and in addition their sensitivity to peptidyltransferase inhibitors. It was evident that the mutated ribosomes had an altered dependence on [Mg2+] and an increased sensitivity to chloramphenicol during poly(U) directed poly(Phe) synthesis. In a transpeptidation assay mutated ribosomes were as sensitive to chloramphenicol as wild-type ribosomes. However, the mutant ribosomes exhibited an increased sensitivity to lincomycin. An increase in translational accuracy was attributed to the mutations at the position 2583: accuracy increased in the order G less than A less than U less than C.     

ms2i6A deficiency enhances proofreading in translation.

The hypermodified base 2-methylthio-N6-isopentenyladenosine (ms2i6A) at position 37 occurs frequently in tRNAs that read codons starting with uridine. Here we have studied how ms2i6A affects the accuracy of poly(U) translation in vitro. Deficiency leads to a higher rejection rate of tRNA4(Leu) by more aggressive proofreading on the wild-type ribosome, but with the initial selection step unchanged. Our data indicate that ms2i6A has no effect on codon-anticodon interactions on wild-type ribosomes as long as aminoacyl-tRNA is in ternary complex with EF-Tu and GTP. ms2i6A deficiency in the cognate poly(U) reader tRNA(Phe) leads to increased misreading when the near-cognate competitor tRNA4(Leu) is wild-type. ms2i6A deficiency in tRNA4(Leu) gives a decreased error level in competition with wild-type tRNA(Phe).     

Biogenesis of mitochondria 51

Summary An examination of the effect of the aminoglycoside antibiotics paromomycin and neomycin on mitochondrial ribosome function in yeast has been made. Both antibiotics are potent inhibitors of protein synthesis in isolated mitochondria. With isolated mitochondrial ribosomes programmed with polyuridylic acid (poly U), the drugs are shown to inhibit polyphenylalanine synthesis at moderately high concentrations (above 100 g/ml). At lower concentrations (about 10 g/ml), paromomycin and neomycin cause a 2–3 fold stimulation in the extent of misreading of the UUU codons in poly U, over and above the significant level of misreading catalyzed by the ribosomes in the absence of drugs.Comparative studies have been made between a paromomycin sensitive strain D585-11C and a mutant strain 4810P carrying the parl-r mutation in mtDNA, which leads tohigh resistance to both paromomycin and neomycin in vivo. A high level of resistance to these antibiotics is observed in strain 4810P at the level of mitochondrial protein synthesis in vitro. Whilst the degree of resistance of isolated mitochondrial ribosomes from strain 4810P judged by the inhibition of polyphenylalanine synthesis by paromomycin and neomycin is not extensive, studies on misreading of the poly U message promoted by these drugs demonstrate convincingly the altered properties of mitochondrial ribosomes from the mutant strain 4810P. These ribosomes show resistance to the stimulation of misreading of the codon UUU brought about by paromomycin and neomycin in wild-type mitochondrial ribosomes. Although strain 4810P was originally isolated as being resistant to paromomycin, in all the in vitro amino acid incorporation systems tested here, the 4810P mitochondrial ribosomes show a higher degree of resistance to neomycin than to paromomycin.It is concluded that the parl-r mutation in strain 4810P affects a component of the mitochondrial ribosome, possibly by altering the 15S rRNA or a protein of the small ribosomal subunit. The further elucidation of the functions in the ribosomes that are modified by the parl-r mutation was hampered by the inability of current preparations of yeast mitochondrial ribosomes to translate efficiently natural messenger RNAs from the several sources tested.     

Hyper-accurate ribosomes inhibit growth.

We have compared both in vivo and in vitro translation by ribosomes from wild-type bacteria with those from streptomycin-resistant (SmR), streptomycin-dependent (SmD) and streptomycin-pseudo-dependent (SmP) mutants. The three mutant bacteria translate more accurately and more slowly in the absence of streptomycin (Sm) than do wild-type bacteria. In particular, the SmP bacteria grow at roughly half the rate of the wild-type in the absence of Sm. The antibiotic stimulates both the growth rate and the translation rate of SmP bacteria by approximately 2-fold, but it simultaneously increases the nonsense suppression rate quite dramatically. Kinetic experiments in vitro show that the greater accuracy and slower translation rates of mutant ribosomes compared with wild-type ribosomes are associated with much more rigorous proofreading activities of SmR, SmD and SmP ribosomes. Sm reduces the proofreading flows of the mutant ribosomes and stimulates their elongation rates. The data suggest that these excessively accurate ribosomes are kinetically less efficient than wild-type ribosomes, and that this inhibits mutant growth rates. The stimulation of the growth of the mutants by Sm results from the enhanced translational efficiency due to the loss of proofreading, which more than offsets the loss of accuracy caused by the antibiotic.     

Investigating the entire course of telithromycin binding to Escherichia coli ribosomes

Applying kinetics and footprinting analysis, we show that telithromycin, a ketolide antibiotic, binds to Escherichia coli ribosomes in a two-step process. During the first, rapidly equilibrated step, telithromycin binds to a low-affinity site (K(T) = 500 nM), in which the lactone ring is positioned at the upper portion of the peptide exit tunnel, while the alkyl-aryl side chain of the drug inserts a groove formed by nucleotides A789 and U790 of 23S rRNA. During the second step, telithromycin shifts slowly to a high-affinity site (K(T)* = 8.33 nM), in which the lactone ring remains essentially at the same position, while the side chain interacts with the base pair U2609:A752 and the extended loop of protein L22. Consistently, mutations perturbing either the base pair U2609:A752 or the L22-loop hinder shifting of telithromycin to the final position, without affecting the initial step of binding. In contrast, mutation Lys63Glu in protein L4 placed on the opposite side of the tunnel, exerts only a minor effect on telithromycin binding. Polyamines disfavor both sequential steps of binding. Our data correlate well with recent crystallographic data and rationalize the changes in the accessibility of ribosomes to telithromycin in response to ribosomal mutations and ionic changes.     

A GTPase reaction accompanying the rejection of Leu-tRNA2 by UUU-programmed ribosomes. Proofreading of the codon-anticodon interaction by ribosomes

The characteristics of a GTPase reaction between poly(U)-programmed ribosomes, EFTu . GTP, and the near-cognate aminoacyl (aa)-tRNA, Leu-tRNA Leu 2, have been studied to assess the role of this reaction in proofreading of the codon-anticodon interaction. The reaction resembles the GTPase reaction with cognate aa-tRNAs and EFTu . GTP in its substrate requirements, in its involving EFTu . GTP . aa-tRNA ternary complexes, and in its requiring a free ribosomal A-site. The noncognate reaction differs from the cognate one in that aa-tRNA becomes stably bound to the ribosomes only 5% of the time; it therefore seems best characterized as an abortive enzymatic binding reaction. The rate of reaction is a significant fraction (4%) of that of the cognate aa-tRNA, indicating that recognition of ternary complexes by ribosomes involves a level of error greater than that of translation as a whole. The rejection of the noncognate aa-tRNA following GTP hydrolysis is therefore a vital step in the translation process and fulfills the criteria set for a proofreading reaction. Leu-tRNA Leu 2 which escapes rejection through proofreading, forms a stable complex with the ribosomal A-site, so it appears that the Leu-tRNA2 which was rejected never reached the A-site and that proofreading precedes full A-site binding.     

Mapping of chloroplast genes involved in chloroplast ribosome biogenesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Summary Chloroplast gene mutations which confer antibiotic resistance on chloroplast ribosomes of the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii have been tested for allelism and mapped by recombination analysis of progeny from biparental zygote clones. Thirty-one independently isolated streptomycin resistant mutants have chloroplast ribosomes which are resistant to this drug in an assay based on misreading of isoleucine in response to a poly U template, and comprise one nuclear and four chloroplast gene loci. Four mutants resistant to spectinomycin, and three mutants resistant to neamine and kanamycin, which have chloroplast ribosomes resistant to their respective antibiotics in poly U directed phenylalanine incorporation, appear to map in a single chloroplast gene locus. Representative alleles of this nr/spr locus, the four streptomycin resistance loci, and two chloroplast gene loci for erythromycin resistance, have been analyzed in a series of parallel crosses to establish the following map order for these seven genes in the chloroplast genome: er-u-la-er-u-37-nr-u-2-1/spr-u-1-H-4-sr-u-2-23-sr-u-2-60-sr-u-sm3-sr-u-sm2. These seven genes may constitute a ribosomal region within the chloroplast genome of Chlamydomonas comparable to the ribosomal gene clusters in bacteria.     

Ribosomes containing mutants of L4 ribosomal protein from Thermus thermophilus display multiple defects in ribosomal functions and sensitivity against erythromycin

Protein L4 from Thermus thermophilus (TthL4) was heterologously overproduced in Escherichia coli cells. To study the implication of the extended loop of TthL4 in the exit-tunnel and peptidyltransferase functions, the highly conserved E56 was replaced by D or Q, while the semiconserved G55 was changed to E or S. Moreover, the sequence -G55E56- was inverted to -E55G56-. When we incorporated these mutants into E. coli ribosomes and investigated their impact on poly(Phe) synthesis, high variations in the synthetic activity and response to erythromycin of the resulting ribosomes were observed. In the absence of erythromycin, ribosomes harboring mutations G55E and E56D in TthL4 protein were characterized by low activity in synthesizing poly(Phe) and decreased capability in binding tRNA at the A site. On the other hand, ribosomes possessing mutations G55E, G55S, G55E-E56G, or E56Q in TthL4 protein were unexpectedly more sensitive to erythromycin. Evidence in support of these findings was drawn by in vivo experiments, assessing the erythromycin sensitivity of E. coli cells expressing wild-type or mutant TthL4 proteins. Our results emphasize the role of the extended loop of L4 ribosomal protein in the exit-tunnel and peptidyltransferase center functions.     

Is efficiency of suppressor tRNAs controlled at the level of ribosomal proofreading in vivo?

Ribosomal rpsD mutations did not stimulate nonsense suppressor tRNAs in a general manner according to their increased ribosomal ambiguity and decreased proofreading efficiency. Streptomycin, which stimulates error production by blocking proofreading in vitro, did not increase efficiency of suppressor tRNAs in strains with normal or streptomycin-resistant (rpsL) ribosomes. It did so only in combination with one rpsL mutation which is associated with streptomycin pseudodependence.     

Ribosomal proteins at the stalk region modulate functional rRNA structures in the GTPase center

Replacement of the L10.L7/L12 protein complex and L11 in Escherichia coli ribosomes with the respective rat counterparts P0.P1/P2 and eukaryotic L12 causes conversion of ribosomal specificity for elongation factors from prokaryotic elongation factor (EF)-Tu/EF-G to eukaryotic EF (eEF)-1alpha/eEF-2. Here we have investigated the effects of protein replacement on the structure and function of two rRNA domains around positions 1070 and 2660 (sarcin/ricin loop) of 23 S rRNA. Protein replacement at the 1070 region in E. coli 50 S subunits was demonstrated by chemical probing analysis. Binding of rat proteins to the 1070 region caused increased accessibility of the 2660 and 1070 regions to ligands for eukaryotic ribosomes: the ribotoxin pepocin for the 2660 region (E. coli numbering), anti-28 S autoantibody for the 1070 region, and eEF-2 for both regions. Moreover, binding of the E. coli L10.L7/L12 complex and L11 to the 1070 region was shown to be responsible for E. coli ribosomal accessibility to another ribotoxin, gypsophilin. Ribosomal proteins at the 1070 region appear to modulate the structures and functions of the 2660 and 1070 RNA regions in slightly different modes in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.     

Comparison of the misreading induced by streptomycin and neomycin

In a poly(U)-programmed translation system, neomycin stimulates the misincorporation of tyrosine and of serine which, according to Thompson and Stone (Thompson, R.C. and Stone, P.J. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 74, 198-202), are normally rejected at an initial discrimination step during the binding of charged tRNAs to the ribosome. In contrast, streptomycin favors the misincorporation of isoleucine which is normally rejected at a subsequent GTP-dependent discrimination step, the so-called proofreading step. The labeling of the ribosome with N-ethylmaleimide mimics the effect of streptomycin in that it stimulates the misincorporation of isoleucine but not of tyrosine or serine. This effect is correlated with the labeling of protein S18 but not with that of protein S1. These observations indicate that the sulfhydryl group of protein S18 is located within a ribosomal domain involved in the proofreading control of tRNA selection. Taking into account our previous results that streptomycin and neomycin perturb ribosomal areas around the sulfhydryl groups of proteins S18 and S1, respectively, we suggest that these antibiotics induce misreading by different mechanisms which are linked to such perturbations.     

Positions 13 and 914 in Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA are involved in the control of translational accuracy.

Using a conditional expression system with the temperature-inducible lambda PL promoter, we previously showed that the single mutations 13U-->A and 914A-->U, and the double mutation 13U-->A and 914A-->U in Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA impair the binding of streptomycin (Pinard et al., The FASEB Journal, 1993, 7, 173-176). In this study, we found that the two single mutations and the double mutation increase translational fidelity, reducing in vivo readthrough of nonsense codons and frameshifting, and decreasing in vitro misincorporation in a poly(U)-directed system. Using oligodeoxyribonucleotide probes which hybridize to the 530 loop and to the 1400 region of 16S rRNA, two regions involved in the control of tRNA binding to the A site, we observed that the mutations in rRNA increase the binding of the probe to the 530 loop but not to the 1400 region. We suggest that the mutations at positions 13 and 914 of 16S rRNA induce a conformational rearrangement in the 530 loop, which contributes to the increased accuracy of the ribosome.