Macromolecular organization of F1-ATPase isolated from Clostridium thermoaceticum as revealed by electron microscopy.

Membrane vesicles and the F1-ATPase from Clostridium thermoaceticum were examined by electron microscopy. F1-ATPase particles projecting from the vesicles have a diameter of 10 to 12 nm. The F1-ATPase has an alpha 3 beta 3 gamma delta structure. The alpha and beta subunits are most likely arranged in an alternating sequence around a central protein mass consisting of the gamma and delta subunits.     

Guanidine-induced dissociation of mitochondrial F1-ATPase

The effect of guanidine hydrochloride on ATPase activity, gel filtration, turbidity, and the fluorescence emission intensity of mitochondrial F1-ATPase was examined. Purified F1 from bovine heart mitochondria was slowly inactivated at low denaturant concentration, and inactivation was associated with delta and epsilon subunit dissociation. delta and epsilon subunits were bound together to form a stable and soluble heterodimer. In parallel, appearance of turbidity was observed. This was caused by the formation of alpha3beta3gamma non-covalent aggregates, as analyzed by SDS-PAGE. Short periods of exposition of the F1 complex to high concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride (0.8-3 M) again induced deltaepsilon dissociation as a heterodimer and the formation of an inactive alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex. This eventually dissociated progressively into single subunits caused by partial unfolding, as evidenced through changes of the protein intrinsic fluorescence emission. Our results suggest that the delta and epsilon subunits are loosely bound to alpha3beta3gamma , and play an important role in determining structural stability to isolated mitochondrial F1-ATPase.     

ATP synthase complex from bovine heart mitochondria. Subunit arrangement as revealed by nearest neighbor analysis and susceptibility to trypsin

The nearest neighbor relationships of bovine mitochondrial H(+)-ATPase subunits were investigated by the chemical cross-linking approach using the homobifunctional cleavable reagents dithiobis(succinimidyl propionate) and disuccinimidyl tartrate. Cross-linked proteins were resolved by one- and two-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Individual subunits were detected by silver staining or by Western blotting and staining with subunit-specific antisera. Products larger than 80,000 daltons were not analyzed. Interactions between F1 subunits included cross-links between gamma and delta as well as gamma and epsilon subunits. Among F0 subunit interactions were observed cross-links of (i) coupling factor 6 (F6) with 8-, 20-, and 24-kDa proteins, (ii) oligomycin sensitivity-conferring protein (OSCP) with 24-kDa protein, and (iii) 20-kDa protein with 24-kDa protein. In addition, several cross-links among subunits involving F1 and F0 sectors were detected. These included cross-links between F6 and alpha, F6 and gamma, OSCP and alpha/beta, and 24-kDa protein and alpha/beta. Thus, OSCP, F6, and the 24-kDa protein were found to form cross-links with both F1 and F0 subunits. The surface accessibility of F0 subunits was investigated by subjecting aliquots of F0 to trypsin treatment. Our data demonstrated that the rate of degradation was in the order OSCP greater than 24-kDa protein greater than or equal to F6 greater than subunit 6. The degradation of subunits of F0 was prevented in intact or reconstituted F1-F0. Based on our present and previously published observations, a model of H(+)-ATPase has been proposed wherein OSCP, F6, and the 24-kDa protein are placed in the stalk region and the alpha and beta subunits of F1-ATPase have been extended down to the membrane surface to enclose the stalk segment.     

A normal mode analysis of structural plasticity in the biomolecular motor F(1)-ATPase

Normal modes have been used to explore the inherent flexibility of the alpha, beta and gamma subunits of F(1)-ATPase in isolation and as part of the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex. It was found that the structural plasticity of the gamma and beta subunits, in particular, correlates with their functions. The N and C-terminal helices forming the coiled-coil domain of the gamma subunit are highly flexible in the isolated subunit, but more rigid in the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex due to interactions with other subunits. The globular domain of the gamma subunit is structurally relatively rigid when isolated and in the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex; this is important for its functional role in coupling the F(0) and F(1) complex of ATP synthase and in inducing the conformational changes of the beta subunits in synthesis. Most important, the character of the lowest-frequency modes of the beta(E) subunit is highly correlated with the large beta(E) --> beta(TP) transition. This holds for the C-terminal domain and the nucleotide-binding domain, which undergo significant conformational transitions in the functional cycle of F(1)-ATPase. This is most evident in the ligand-free beta(E) subunit; the flexibility in the nucleotide-binding domain is reduced somewhat in the beta(TP) subunit in the presence of Mg(2+).ATP. The low-frequency modes of the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex show that the motions of the globular domain of the gamma subunit and of the C-terminal and nucleotide binding domains of the beta(E) subunits are coupled, in accord with their function. Overall, the normal mode analysis reveals that F(1)-ATPase, like other macromolecular assemblies, has the intrinsic structural flexibility required for its function encoded in its sequence and three-dimensional structure. This inherent plasticity is an essential aspect of assuring a small free energy cost for the large-scale conformational transition that occurs in molecular motors.     

Structure of bovine mitochondrial F(1)-ATPase inhibited by Mg(2+) ADP and aluminium fluoride

BACKGROUND: The globular domain of the membrane-associated F(1)F(o)-ATP synthase complex can be detached intact as a water-soluble fragment known as F(1)-ATPase. It consists of five different subunits, alpha, beta, gamma, delta and epsilon, assembled with the stoichiometry 3:3:1:1:1. In the crystal structure of bovine F(1)-ATPase determined previously at 2.8 A resolution, the three catalytic beta subunits and the three noncatalytic alpha subunits are arranged alternately around a central alpha-helical coiled coil in the gamma subunit. In the crystals, the catalytic sites have different nucleotide occupancies. One contains the triphosphate form of the nucleotide, the second contains the diphosphate, and the third is unoccupied. Fluoroaluminate complexes have been shown to mimic the transition state in several ATP and GTP hydrolases. In order to understand more about its catalytic mechanism, F(1)-ATPase was inhibited with Mg(2+)ADP and aluminium fluoride and the structure of the inhibited complex was determined by X-ray crystallography. RESULTS: The structure of bovine F(1)-ATPase inhibited with Mg(2+)ADP and aluminium fluoride determined at 2.5 A resolution differs little from the original structure with bound AMP-PNP and ADP. The nucleotide occupancies of the alpha and beta subunits are unchanged except that both aluminium trifluoride and Mg(2+)ADP are bound in the nucleotide-binding site of the beta(DP) subunit. The presence of aluminium fluoride is accompanied by only minor adjustments in the surrounding protein. CONCLUSIONS: The structure appears to mimic a possible transition state. The coordination of the aluminofluoride group has many features in common with other aluminofluoride-NTP hydrolase complexes. Apparently, once nucleotide is bound to the catalytic beta subunit, no additional major structural changes are required for catalysis to occur.     

The structure of the central stalk in bovine F(1)-ATPase at 2.4 A resolution

The central stalk in ATP synthase, made of gamma, delta and epsilon subunits in the mitochondrial enzyme, is the key rotary element in the enzyme's catalytic mechanism. The gamma subunit penetrates the catalytic (alpha beta)(3) domain and protrudes beneath it, interacting with a ring of c subunits in the membrane that drives rotation of the stalk during ATP synthesis. In other crystals of F(1)-ATPase, the protrusion was disordered, but with crystals of F(1)-ATPase inhibited with dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, the complete structure was revealed. The delta and epsilon subunits interact with a Rossmann fold in the gamma subunit, forming a foot. In ATP synthase, this foot interacts with the c-ring and couples the transmembrane proton motive force to catalysis in the (alpha beta)(3) domain.     

Photolabeling of mitochondrial F1-ATPase by an azido derivative of the oligomycin-sensitivity conferring protein

An azido derivative of the oligomycin sensitivity conferring protein (OSCP) was prepared by alkylation with the bifunctional reagent p-azido phenacyl bromide. Azido-OSCP was fully biologically active in the dark. Upon photoirradiation of a mixture of beef heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase and azido-OSCP, the resulting covalent photoproducts were separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of Na dodecyl sulfate and characterized by an immunochemical procedure. OSCP was found to react with the alpha and the beta subunits of F1 with strong preference for the alpha subunit.     

Archaebacterial ATPase: studies on subunit composition and quaternary structure of the F1-analogous ATPase from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius

A modified procedure for the purification of soluble ATPase from the thermoacidophilic archaebacterium Sulfolobus acidocaldarius is described. In addition to (alpha) 65 and (beta) 51 kDa polypeptides, further subunits gamma * (20 kDa) and delta * (12 kDa) are demonstrated to be components of the enzyme, exhibiting a total molecular mass of 380 kDa. Molecular electron microscopic images of the native enzyme indicate a quaternary structure probably formed by the gamma *, delta *-complex as a central mass surrounded by a pseudohexagon of the peripherally arranged larger alpha and beta subunits. As can be derived from both molecular mass and electron microscopy data, the archaebacterial Sulfolobus-ATPase emerges to exist as an alpha 3 beta 3-quaternary structure with respect to the larger subunits. This is normally found in typical F1-ATPases of eubacterial and eukaryotic organisms. Therefore it is postulated that F1- and F0F1-ATPases, respectively, can occur ubiquitously in all urkingdoms of organisms as functional units of energy-transducing membranes.     

Stabilization of rat liver mitochondrial F1-adenosine triphosphatase during chloroform-induced solubilization.

1. Isolation of ATPase from rat liver submitochondrial particles by chloroform treatment requires the presence of ATP or ADP during enzyme solubilization. In the absence of adenine nucleotides the enzyme activity is very low although all protein components of F1-ATPase are released. The low concentrations of ATP or ADP required (5 microM) indicate that the high affinity nucleotide-binding sites are involved in enzyme stabilization. Other nucleotides tested (ITP, GTP, UTP, CTP) were found to be less effective. 2. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and immunodiffusion in agar plates revealed that in the absence of adenine nucleotides a fraction of F1-ATPase released by chloroform treatment is split into fragments. The part of the dissociated enzyme molecule has a molecular weight identical with that of a beta-subunit of F1-ATPase. 3. Dissociation of the F1-ATPase molecule could also be prevented by aurovertin. 4. Crude F1-ATPase solubilized by chloroform treatment can be further purified by Sepharose 6B gel filtration. Specific ATPase activity of the purified enzyme was 90 mumol Pi/min per mg protein and the enzyme was composed of five protein subunits (alpha, beta, gamma, delta, epsilon) with molecular weights 58 000, 55 000, 28 000, 13 000 and 8000, respectively. 5. Chloroform-released F1-ATPase from rat liver mitochondria displayed immunochemical cross-reactivity with that isolated from beef heart mitochondria.     

Inherent asymmetry of the structure of F1-ATPase from bovine heart mitochondria at 6.5 A resolution.

ATP synthase, the assembly which makes ATP in mitochondria, chloroplasts and bacteria, uses transmembrane proton gradients generated by respiration or photosynthesis to drive the phosphorylation of ADP. Its membrane domain is joined by a slender stalk to a peripheral catalytic domain, F1-ATPase. This domain is made of five subunits with stoichiometries of 3 alpha: 3 beta: 1 gamma: 1 delta: 1 epsilon, and in bovine mitochondria has a molecular mass of 371,000. We have determined the 3-dimensional structure of bovine mitochondrial F1-ATPase to 6.5 A resolution by X-ray crystallography. It is an approximately spherical globule 110 A in diameter, on a 40 A stem which contains two alpha-helices in a coiled-coil. This stem is presumed to be part of the stalk that connects F1 with the membrane domain in the intact ATP synthase. A pit next to the stem penetrates approximately 35 A into the F1 particle. The stem and the pit are two examples of the many asymmetric features of the structure. The central element in the asymmetry is the longer of the two alpha-helices in the stem, which extends for 90 A through the centre of the assembly and emerges on top into a dimple 15 A deep. Features with threefold and sixfold symmetry, presumed to be parts of homologous alpha and beta subunits, are arranged around the central rod and pit, but the overall structure is asymmetric. The central helix provides a possible mechanism for transmission of conformational changes induced by the proton gradient from the stalk to the catalytic sites of the enzyme.     

Novel features in the structure of bovine ATP synthase.

The F1F0-ATP synthase from bovine heart mitochondria catalyses the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate by using the energy of an electrochemical proton gradient derived from electron transport. The enzyme consists of three major domains: the globular F1catalytic domain of known atomic structure lies outside the lipid bilayer and is attached by a central stalk to the intrinsic membrane domain, F0, which transports protons through the membrane. Proton transport through F0evokes structural changes that are probably transmitted by rotation of the stalk to the catalytic sites in F1. In an alpha3beta3gamma1subcomplex, the rotation of the central gamma subunit driven by ATP hydrolysis has been visualised by optical microscopy. In order to prevent the alpha3beta3structure from following the rotation of the central gamma subunit, it has been proposed that the enzyme might have a stator connecting static parts in F0to alpha3beta3,thereby keeping it fixed relative to the rotating parts. Here we present electron microscopy images that reveal three new features in bovine F1F0-ATPase, one of which could be a stator. The second feature is a collar structure above the membrane domain and the third feature is some additional density on top of the F1domain.     

Cross-linking of two beta subunits in the closed conformation in F1-ATPase

In the crystal structure of mitochondrial F1-ATPase, two beta subunits with a bound Mg-nucleotide are in "closed" conformations, whereas the third beta subunit without bound nucleotide is in an "open" conformation. In this "CCO" (beta-closed beta-closed beta-open) conformational state, Ile-390s of the two closed beta subunits, even though they are separated by an intervening alpha subunit, have a direct contact. We replaced the equivalent Ile of the alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex of thermophilic F1-ATPase with Cys and observed the formation of the beta-beta cross-link through a disulfide bond. The analysis of conditions required for the cross-link formation indicates that: (i) F1-ATPase takes the CCO conformation when two catalytic sites are filled with Mg-nucleotide, (ii) intermediate(s) with the CCO conformation are generated during catalytic cycle, (iii) the Mg-ADP inhibited form is in the CCO conformation, and (iv) F1-ATPase dwells in conformational state(s) other than CCO when only one (or none) of catalytic sites is filled by Mg-nucleotide or when catalytic sites are filled by Mg2+-free nucleotide. The alpha3beta3gamma subcomplex containing the beta-beta cross-link retained the activity of uni-site catalysis but lost that of multiple catalytic turnover, suggesting that open-closed transition of beta subunits is required for the rotation of gamma subunit but not for hydrolysis of a single ATP.     

Electron-microscopic studies on location of SH-groups in mitochondrial F1-ATPase using a ferritin label

A new approach has been suggested for electron-microscopic study of the structure of mitochondrial F1-ATPase based on ferritin labeling. By means of sequential treatment with 2-iminothiolane and Nbs2 we obtained a modified ferritin (NbsSPrCNH-Ft) able to react with SH-groups of proteins and to form conjugates in which the protein and ferritin are bound by disulfide bonds. An electron-microscopic investigation of the negatively stained preparations of mitochondrial F1-ATPase, preincubated with modified ferritin, revealed such enzyme-ferritin conjugates. In case of modified ferritin, containing 360 mol SH-groups per mol protein, and F1-ATPase, pretreated with N-ethylmaleimide and then with dithiothreitol, conjugates were obtained in which ferritin molecules are bound to several (as many as four) of the six protein masses, comprising a bilayer molecule of the enzyme. Taking into consideration the biochemical data on the location of accessible SH-groups (only in alpha, gamma or epsilon subunits), it is inferred from the results obtained that one of the protein masses is a complex between beta subunit and at least one of the minor subunits located partially on the molecule's external side. This indicates the nonequivalence of different copies of the major subunits. Averaged images of the particles of the F1-F0 complex from bovine heart mitochondria and bacteria Micrococcus lysodeicticus were obtained. It was found that F0 component is bound to two adjacent protein masses of the F1-ATPase molecule. It is suggested that this binding may be due the nonequivalency of single-type major subunits.     

The coupled chemomechanics of the F(1)-ATPase molecular motor

The enzyme F(1)-ATPase is a rotary nanomotor in which the central gamma subunit rotates inside the cavity made of alpha(3)beta(3) subunits. The experiments showed that the rotation proceeds in steps of 120 degrees and each 120 degrees step consists of 80 degrees and 40 degrees substeps. Here the Author proposes a stochastic wave mechanics of the F(1)-ATPase motor and combines it with the structure-based kinetics of the F(1)-ATPase to form a chemomechanic coupled model. The model can reproduce quantitatively and explain the experimental observations about the F(1) motor. Using the model, several rate-limited situations about gamma subunit rotation are proposed, the effects of the friction and the load on the substeps are investigated and the chemomechanic coupled time during ATP hydrolysis cycle is determined.     

Ligand-induced conformational changes in the Escherichia coli F1 adenosine triphosphatase probed by trypsin digestion

Digestion of the F1-ATPase of Escherichia coli with trypsin stimulated ATP hydrolytic activity and removed the delta and epsilon subunits of the enzyme. A species represented by the formula alpha 1(3) beta 1(3) gamma 1, where alpha 1, beta 1 and gamma 1 are forms of the native alpha, beta and gamma subunits which have been attacked by trypsin, was formed by trypsin digestion in the presence of ATP. In the presence of ATP and MgCl2, conversion of gamma to gamma 1 was retarded and the enzyme retained the epsilon subunit. These results imply that binding of ATP to the beta subunits alters the conformation of ECF1 to increase the accessibility of the gamma subunit to trypsin. The likely trypsin cleavage sites in the alpha, beta and gamma subunits are discussed. ECF1 from the alpha subunit-defective mutant uncA401, or after treatment with N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide or 4-chloro-7-nitrobenzofurazan, was present in a conformation in which the gamma subunit was readily accessible to trypsin and could not be protected by the presence of ATP and MgCl2. In a similar manner to native E. coli F1-ATPase, the hydrolytic activity of the trypsin-digested enzyme was stimulated by the detergent lauryldimethylamine N-oxide. Since the digested enzyme lacked the epsilon subunit, a putative inhibitor of hydrolytic activity, a mechanism for the stimulation which involves loss or movement of this subunit is untenable.     

F1-ATPase rotates by an asymmetric, sequential mechanism using all three catalytic subunits

F1-ATPase, the catalytic part of FoF1-ATP synthase, rotates the central gamma subunit within the alpha3beta3 cylinder in 120 degrees steps, each step consuming a single ATP molecule. However, how the catalytic activity of each beta subunit is coordinated with the other two beta subunits to drive rotation remains unknown. Here we show that hybrid F1 containing one or two mutant beta subunits with altered catalytic kinetics rotates in an asymmetric stepwise fashion. Analysis of the rotations reveals that for any given beta subunit, the subunit binds ATP at 0 degrees, cleaves ATP at approximately 200 degrees and carries out a third catalytic event at approximately 320 degrees. This demonstrates the concerted nature of the F1 complex activity, where all three beta subunits participate to drive each 120 degrees rotation of the gamma subunit with a 120 degrees phase difference, a process we describe as a 'sequential three-site mechanism'.     

Interactions between the oligomycin sensitivity conferring protein (OSCP) and beef heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase. 2. Identification of the interacting F1 subunits by cross-linking

Interactions between oligomycin sensitivity conferring protein (OSCP) and subunits of beef heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase have been explored by cross-linking at an OSCP/F1 molar ratio close to 1 to ensure specific high-affinity binding of OSCP to F1 [see Dupuis et al. [Dupuis, A., Issartel, J.-P., Lunardi, J., Satre, M., & Vignais, P.V. (1985) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)]]. Cross-links between F1 subunits and OSCP were established by means of two zero length cross-linkers, 1-[3-(dimethylamino)propyl]-3-ethylcarbodiimide and N-(ethoxycarbonyl)-2-ethoxydihydroquinoline. The cross-linked products were separated by sodium dodecyl suflate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Coomassie blue staining revealed two cross-linked products of Mr 75 000 and 80 000 which could result from the binding of OSCP to the alpha and beta subunits of F1. Definite identification of the cross-linked products was achieved by chemical labeling with specific radiolabeled reagents and by blotting on nitrocellulose filters followed by immunocharacterization with anti-alpha, anti-beta, and anti-OSCP antibodies. OSCP was found to cross-link with the alpha and beta subunits of F1.     

F1-ATPase from Micrococcus sp. ATCC 398. Purification by ion-exchange chromatography and further characterization. (Auto)proteolysis and dissociative effects.

The preparation of highly purified F1-ATPase from Micrococcus sp. ATCC 398 by application of DEAE-Sepharose CL-6B chromatography as final step is described. This enzyme consists of five subunits of different molecular weight: alpha (65000), beta (55000),gamma (35000), delta (20000), and epsilon (17000). Disc electrophoresis on 5% polyacrylamide gels removes the epsilon-polypeptide yielding an active ATPase complex with four different subunits: alpha, beta, gamma, delta. Additionally, by variation of the ionic strength delta can (partly) removed allowing the isolation by disc electrophoresis of an active ATPase complex which consists only of three different subunits alpha, beta, and gamma. If the DEAE-Sepharose chromatography is carried out in the absence of diisopropyl phosphofluoridate (auto)proteolysis yields both an active ATPase with the subunits alpha+ (mol. wt 61000), beta, gamma, and delta and an inactive protein complex with the subunits alpha+, beta, gamma, delta, and two additional polypeptides a (mol. wt 38000) and b (mol. wt 23000). The latter two polypeptides are supposedly fragments of alpha+-chains which have become partially cleaved by (auto)proteolysis.     

Failure to assemble the alpha 3 beta 3 subcomplex of the ATP synthase leads to accumulation of the alpha and beta subunits within inclusion bodies and the loss of mitochondrial cristae in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The F(1) component of mitochondrial ATP synthase is an oligomeric assembly of five different subunits, alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon. In terms of mass, the bulk of the structure ( approximately 90%) is provided by the alpha and beta subunits, which form an (alphabeta)(3) hexamer with adenine nucleotide binding sites at the alpha/beta interfaces. We report here ultrastructural and immunocytochemical analyses of yeast mutants that are unable to form the alpha(3)beta(3) oligomer, either because the alpha or the beta subunit is missing or because the cells are deficient for proteins that mediate F assembly (e.g. Atp11p, Atp12p, or Fmc1p). The F(1) alpha(1) and beta subunits of such mutant strains are detected within large electron-dense particles in the mitochondrial matrix. The composition of the aggregated species is principally full-length F(1) alpha and/or beta subunit protein that has been processed to remove the amino-terminal targeting peptide. To our knowledge this is the first demonstration of mitochondrial inclusion bodies that are formed largely of one particular protein species. We also show that yeast mutants lacking the alpha(3)beta(3) oligomer are devoid of mitochondrial cristae and are severely deficient for respiratory complexes III and IV. These observations are in accord with other studies in the literature that have pointed to a central role for the ATP synthase in biogenesis of the mitochondrial inner membrane.     

A homologous sequence between H+-ATPase (F0F1) and cation-transporting ATPases. Thr-285----Asp replacement in the beta subunit of Escherichia coli F1 changes its catalytic properties

A sequence of 10 amino acids (I-C-S-D-K-T-G-T-L-T) of ion motive ATPases such as Na+/K+-ATPase is similar to the sequence of the beta subunit of H+-ATPases, including that of Escherichia coli (I-T-S-T-K-T-G-S-I-T) (residues 282-291). The Asp (D) residue phosphorylated in ion motive ATPase corresponds to Thr (T) of the beta subunit. This substitution may be reasonable because there is no phosphoenzyme intermediate in the catalytic cycle of F1-ATPase. We replaced Thr-285 of the beta subunit by an Asp residue by in vitro mutagenesis and reconstituted the alpha beta gamma complex from the mutant (or wild-type) beta and wild-type alpha and gamma subunits. The uni- and multisite ATPase activities of the alpha beta gamma complex with mutant beta subunits were about 20 and 30% of those with the wild-type subunit. The rate of ATP binding (k1) of the mutant complex under uni-site conditions was about 10-fold less than that of the wild-type complex. These results suggest that Thr-285, or the region in its vicinity, is essential for normal catalysis of the H+-ATPase. The mutant complex could not form a phosphoenzyme under the conditions where the H+/K+-ATPase is phosphorylated, suggesting that another residue(s) may also be involved in formation of the intermediate in ion motive ATPase. The wild-type alpha beta gamma complex had slightly different kinetic properties from the wild-type F1, possibly because it did not contain the epsilon subunit.