Quantitative Analysis of Eumelanin and Pheomelanin in Humans,Mice, and Other Animals: a Comparative Review

The color of hair, skin, and eyes in animals mainly depends on the quantity, quality, and distribution of the pigment melanin, which occurs in two types: black to brown eumelanin and yellow to reddish pheomelanin. Microanalytical methods to quantify the amounts of eumelanin and pheomelanin in biological materials were developed in 1985. The methods are based on the chemical degradation of eumelanin to pyrrole‐2,3,5‐tricarboxylic acid and of pheomelanin to aminohydroxyphenylalanine isomers, which can be analyzed and quantitated by high performance liquid chromatography. This review summarizes and compares eumelanin and pheomelanin contents in various pigmented tissues obtained from humans, mice, and other animals. These methods have become valuable tools to study the functions of melanin, the control of melanogenesis, and the actions and interactions of pigmentation genes. The methods have also found applications in many clinical studies. High levels of pheomelanin are found only in yellow to red hairs of mammals and in red feathers of birds. It remains an intriguing question why lower vertebrates such as fishes do not synthesize pheomelanin. Detectable levels of pheomelanin are detected in human skin regardless of race, color, and skin type. However, eumelanin is always the major constituent of epidermal melanin, and the skin color appears to be determined by the quantity of melanin produced but not by the quality.     

Quantitative analysis of eumelanin and pheomelanin in humans,mice, and other animals: a comparative review

The color of hair, skin, and eyes in animals mainly depends on the quantity, quality, and distribution of the pigment melanin, which occurs in two types: black to brown eumelanin and yellow to reddish pheomelanin. Microanalytical methods to quantify the amounts of eumelanin and pheomelanin in biological materials were developed in 1985. The methods are based on the chemical degradation of eumelanin to pyrrole-2,3,5-tricarboxylic acid and of pheomelanin to aminohydroxyphenylalanine isomers, which can be analyzed and quantitated by high performance liquid chromatography. This review summarizes and compares eumelanin and pheomelanin contents in various pigmented tissues obtained from humans, mice, and other animals. These methods have become valuable tools to study the functions of melanin, the control of melanogenesis, and the actions and interactions of pigmentation genes. The methods have also found applications in many clinical studies. High levels of pheomelanin are found only in yellow to red hairs of mammals and in red feathers of birds. It remains an intriguing question why lower vertebrates such as fishes do not synthesize pheomelanin. Detectable levels of pheomelanin are detected in human skin regardless of race, color, and skin type. However, eumelanin is always the major constituent of epidermal melanin, and the skin color appears to be determined by the quantity of melanin produced but not by the quality.     

The degree of pigmentation modulates the radiosensitivity of human melanoma cells

The relationship between cell pigmentation and radiosensitivity was investigated in two selected human melanoma cell lines with different melanin content (mixed type: eumelanin and pheomelanin, and pheomelanotic phenotypes). The same study was also done after stimulation of melanogenesis (1) by addition of the melanin precursor l-tyrosine to each of the cell lines separately and (2) by irradiation alone with doses ranging from 0 to 10 Gy. We found that a decrease in cell radiosensitivity was correlated with the type of melanin, with a clear involvement of eumelanin rather than pheomelanin. Increasing the intracellular content of both melanins promoted the growth of irradiated cells. Moreover, at a dose of 10 Gy, both tyrosinase activity and melanin cell content were significantly increased in the absence of any other melanogenesis promoter. Our data suggest that the amount of intracellular melanin is inversely related to the radiosensitivity of melanoma cells and may explain at least in part the controversial responses to ionizing radiations reported for melanoma.     

Effects of Melanogenesis‐Inducing Nitric Oxide and Histamine on the Production of Eumelanin and Pheomelanin in Cultured Human Melanocytes

Melanin pigments produced in human melanocytes are classified into two categories; black coloured eumelanin and reddish‐yellow pheomelanin. Stimulation of melanocytes with α‐melanocyte‐stimulating hormone (α‐MSH), one of several melanogenic factors, has been reported to enhance eumelanogenesis to a greater degree than pheomelanogenesis, which contributes to hyperpigmentation in skin. Nitric oxide (NO) and histamine are also melanogenesis‐stimulating factors that are released from cells surrounding melanocytes following ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. In this study, the effects of NO and histamine on the ratio of eumelanin and pheomelanin were examined in human melanocytes, and then compared with that of α‐MSH. The amounts of eumelanin and pheomelanin were quantified using high‐performance liquid chromatography analysis after oxidation and hydrolysis of melanin. Melanogenesis was induced by the addition of α‐MSH, NO, or histamine to melanocytes. The amount of eumelanin production significantly increased with independent stimulation by these melanogenic factors, especially histamine, while that of pheomelanin significantly increased with α‐MSH and NO, but only slightly with histamine. As a result, the ratio of eumelanin and pheomelanin increased significantly with the addition of NO or histamine. These results suggest that NO and histamine, as in the case of α‐MSH, may contribute to UV‐induced hyperpigmentation by enhancing eumelanogenesis.     

Skin phototype: a new perspective

Cutaneous phototype is considered mainly related to cutaneous pigmentation and to the eumelanin/pheomelanin ratio, which is mostly genetically determined by the melanocortin 1 receptor (MC1R) polymorphisms. However, data in literature indicate that, in addition to stimulation of eumelanin synthesis, the MC1R signalling activates antioxidant, DNA repair and survival pathways. New emerging aspects regarding photoprotection and skin phototypes are going beyond those features connected to the melanin content in the skin. Important new findings link the MC1R to nuclear receptors activation, shedding light on new extra‐melanogenic effects dependent on the α‐melanocyte‐stimulating hormone (α‐MSH) activity and new ways through which such functions are modulated. These evidences indicate that several factors including melanin play a part in defining the basis for individual sun sensitivity, suggesting that the cutaneous phototype represents a ‘biochemical fingerprint’.     

Pharmacologic Induction of Epidermal Melanin and Protection Against Sunburn in a Humanized Mouse Model

Fairness of skin, UV sensitivity and skin cancer risk all correlate with the physiologic function of the melanocortin 1 receptor, a G_s-coupled signaling protein found on the surface of melanocytes. Mc1r stimulates adenylyl cyclase and cAMP production which, in turn, up-regulates melanocytic production of melanin in the skin. In order to study the mechanisms by which Mc1r signaling protects the skin against UV injury, this study relies on a mouse model with "humanized skin" based on epidermal expression of stem cell factor (Scf). K14-Scf transgenic mice retain melanocytes in the epidermis and therefore have the ability to deposit melanin in the epidermis. In this animal model, wild type Mc1r status results in robust deposition of black eumelanin pigment and a UV-protected phenotype. In contrast, K14-Scf animals with defective Mc1r signaling ability exhibit a red/blonde pigmentation, very little eumelanin in the skin and a UV-sensitive phenotype. Reasoning that eumelanin deposition might be enhanced by topical agents that mimic Mc1r signaling, we found that direct application of forskolin extract to the skin of Mc1r-defective fair-skinned mice resulted in robust eumelanin induction and UV protection ¹. Here we describe the method for preparing and applying a forskolin-containing natural root extract to K14-Scf fair-skinned mice and report a method for measuring UV sensitivity by determining minimal erythematous dose (MED). Using this animal model, it is possible to study how epidermal cAMP induction and melanization of the skin affect physiologic responses to UV exposure.     

Dysplastic Melanocytic Nevi Contain High Levels of Pheomelanin: Quantitative Comparison of Pheomelanin/Eumelanin Levels Between Normal Skin,Common Nevi,and Dysplastic Nevi

The degree and type of melanogenesis, i.e., either eumelanin of pheomelanin, has been shown to be a reliable marker for the differentiation of the melanocyte. If exposed to UV light, these two melanins were reported to behave differently; eumelanin was photoprotective whereas pheomelanin was phototoxic to cultured tumor cells. Our previous study indicated that dysplastic melanocytic nevus (DMN) undergoes altered melanogenesis, forming pheomelanosome-like granules. The present study examined chemically the type and degree of melanin synthesized in 31 melanocytic nevi excised from 27 patients as compared with that occurring in the surrounding normal skin. The tissue content of eumelanin and pheomelanin was expressed by the amounts of pyrrole-2,3,5-tricarboxylic acid (PTCA) and aminohydroxyphenylalanine (AHP), respectively. We found that DMN lesions contain significantly higher amounts of pheomelanin than either common melanocytic nevus (CMN) or normal skin. Differences in pheomelanin content between DMN and CMN could not be accounted for by inherently higher levels of pheomelanin within the skin in general from DMN patients. Our present finding substantiates our previous claim that epidermal melanocytes in DMN undergo deranged melanogenesis.     

Dysplastic melanocytic nevi contain high levels of pheomelanin: quantitative comparison of pheomelanin/eumelanin levels between normal skin, common nevi, and dysplastic nevi.

The degree and type of melanogenesis, i.e., either eumelanin of pheomelanin, has been shown to be a reliable marker for the differentiation of the melanocyte. If exposed to UV light, these two melanins were reported to behave differently; eumelanin was photoprotective whereas pheomelanin was phototoxic to cultured tumor cells. Our previous study indicated that dysplastic melanocytic nevus (DMN) undergoes altered melanogenesis, forming pheomelanosome-like granules. The present study examined chemically the type and degree of melanin synthesized in 31 melanocytic nevi excised from 27 patients as compared with that occurring in the surrounding normal skin. The tissue content of eumelanin and pheomelanin was expressed by the amounts of pyrrole-2,3,5-tricarboxylic acid (PTCA) and aminohydroxyphenylalanine (AHP), respectively. We found that DMN lesions contain significantly higher amounts of pheomelanin than either common melanocytic nevus (CMN) or normal skin. Differences in pheomelanin content between DMN and CMN could not be accounted for by inherently higher levels of pheomelanin within the skin in general from DMN patients. Our present finding substantiates our previous claim that epidermal melanocytes in DMN undergo deranged melanogenesis.     

Characterization of Melanogenesis in Normal Human Epidermal Melanocytes by Chemical and Ultrastructural Analysis

Chemical and ultrastructural studies were conducted to define the relationship between type of melanogenesis and fine structures of melanosomes in normal human epidermal melanocytes. Chemical analysis of epidermal melanin demonstrated that the ratio of eumelanin/pheomelanin varied individually, ranging from 1.31 to exclusively eumelanic. Ultrastructural analysis of fine structures of melanosomes revealed that spheroid melanosomes were frequently observed in melanocytes of the epidermis whose eumelanin/pheomelanin ratio was less than 5. Conversely, ellipsoid melanosomes predominated in melanocytes of the epidermis whose ratio was more than 10. On the basis of these findings, it seems reasonable to conclude that 1) normal human epidermal melanocytes synthesize both eumelanin and pheomelanin and 2) pheomelanin synthesis may be characterized by the presence of spheroid melanosomes whereas eumelanin synthesis is ascribed to ellipsoid melanosomes.     

Morphology of hair pigmentation in wild red foxes,silver foxes,and their hybrids

The effects of dominant allele Ar of locus Agouti on the morphology of hair pigmentation were described in foxes. The Ar allele was shown to determine the type of melanin and its content in hair with no effect on the morphology of pigment granules and their distribution throughout a hair. Using the method of electron spin resonance (ESR), the types of melanin (eumelanin and pheomelanin) and their content in the hair of red (ArArEE) and silver (aaEE) foxes and their hybrids (AraEE) were determined. In silver foxes, only one type of melanin (eumelanin) was found. In red foxes and their hybrids (which are phenotypically similar but darker than red foxes), both types of melanin (eu- and pheomelanin) were found. The highest melanin content was detected in the coat of silver foxes. In the hybrids, the total melanin content was lower than in silver foxes, but significantly higher than in red foxes. In red foxes, the contribution of pheomelanin to the total hair melanin content was twice as large as in the hybrids.     

Eumelanin and pheomelanin concentrations in human epidermis before and after UVB irradiation

Pheomelanin is widely thought to be causally related to susceptibility to the harmful effects of ultraviolet radiation: epidemiological studies show that those with a higher ratio of pheomelanin to eumelanin in hair have higher rates of melanoma, and work in mouse and cell culture shows that pheomelanin generates excess free radicals after UVR exposure. By contrast, based on measurements of eumelanin and pheomelanin in human skin, before and following irradiation, we now report that both pheomelanin and eumelanin are positively related to skin colour, and by inference, inversely with cancer susceptibility. The ratio of melanin classes is similar in people with widely different cancer rates and UVR sensitivity. Although our numbers are small, our results extend previous work in man, and lead us to speculate that factors other than the amount of pheomelanin may be important in determining UVR susceptibility in persons with red hair.     

Visible light accelerates the ultraviolet A‐induced degradation of eumelanin and pheomelanin

Exposure to excess ultraviolet (UV) A radiation induces the degradation/modification of both eumelanin and pheomelanin that may be deleterious to pigmented tissues. Although the spectral distribution of solar energy comprises nearly half of visible light (VL), few studies have been conducted to examine the role of VL in the photodegradation of both types of melanin, either VL alone or in combination with UVA. In this study, we examined the effects of physiological doses of VL (150 to 300 J cm^?2) alone or in combination with a physiological dose of UVA (20 J cm^?2) in normal human epidermal melanocytes. The degradation/modification of melanin structures was evaluated by our chemical degradation—high performance liquid chromatography methods. The results show that VL accelerates UVA‐induced changes in the structural features of both eumelanin and pheomelanin, although VL or UVA alone induced only minor changes in melanin structure. The differential spectral method provides support for the additive effects of VL.     

Acid hydrolysis reveals a low but constant level of pheomelanin in human black to brown hair

We previously reported a constant ratio of the benzothiazole pheomelanin marker thiazole‐2,4,5‐tricarboxylic acid (TTCA) to the eumelanin marker pyrrole‐2,3,5‐tricarboxylic acid (PTCA) in eumelanic, black human hair. A constant level (20%–25%) of benzothiazole‐type pheomelanin was recently demonstrated in human skin with varying concentrations of melanin. Therefore, in this study, we aimed to investigate the origin of pheomelanin markers in black to brown human hair by developing a method to remove protein components from hair by heating with 6 M HCl at 110°C for 16 hr. For comparison, synthetic melanins were prepared by oxidizing mixtures of varying ratios of dopa and cysteine with tyrosinase. Hair melanins and synthetic melanins were subjected to acid hydrolysis followed by alkaline H₂O₂ oxidation. The results show that the hydrolysis leads to decarboxylation of the 5,6‐di‐hydroxyindole‐2‐carboxylic acid moiety in eumelanin and the benzothiazole moiety in pheomelanin and that eumelanic human hair contains 11%–17% benzothiazole‐type pheomelanin.     

Insect cuticular melanins are distinctly different from those of mammalian epidermal melanins

Melanin from several insect samples was isolated and subjected to chemical degradation and HPLC analysis for melanin markers. Quantification of different melanin markers reveals that insect melanins are significantly different from that of the mammalian epidermal melanins. The eumelanin produced in mammals is derived from the oxidative polymerization of both 5,6‐dihydroxyindole and 5,6‐dihydroxyindole‐2‐carboxylic acids. The pheomelanin is formed by the oxidative polymerization of cysteinyldopa. Thus, dopa is the major precursor for both eumelanin and pheomelanin in mammals. But insect eumelanin appears to be mostly made from 5,6‐dihydroxyindole and originates from dopamine. More importantly, our study points out the wide spread occurrence of pheomelanin in many insect species. In addition, cysteinyldopamine and not cysteinyldopa is the major precursor for insect pheomelanin. Thus, both eumelanin and pheomelanin in insects differ from higher animals using dopamine and not dopa as the major precursor.     

Keratinocytes control the pheo/eumelanin ratio in cultured normal human melanocytes

The pheo/eumelanin ratio of cultured normal human melanocytes is distinct from the ratio observed for the same cells in vivo where they are in close contact with keratinocytes. To study the possible involvement of keratinocytes in the control of melanogenesis, we compared quantitatively and qualitatively the melanin production in melanocyte mono-cultures, in melanocyte-keratinocyte co-cultures and in pigmented reconstructed epidermis. Pheomelanin and eumelanin contents were assessed by high-performance liquid chromatography with electrochemical and fluorometric detection of their specific degradation products and revealed striking differences in the presence of keratinocytes. In the absence of keratinocytes (melanocyte mono-cultures), we observed a very limited eumelanin production and a very high pheomelanin synthesis. The pheo/eumelanin ratio in mono-cultures could be slightly influenced by changing the composition of the culture medium, however, the very strong imbalance in favor of pheomelanin remained unchanged. An induction of eumelanin synthesis accompanied by an important reduction of pheomelanin formation was only observed in the presence of keratinocytes. The pheo/eumelanin ratio in melanocyte mono-culture dropped from 1043 down to about 25 in the presence of keratinocytes (co-cultures). The same observations were made when the melanocytes were integrated into a reconstructed human epidermis. Interestingly, under co-culture conditions resulting in only a partial contact between melanocytes and keratinocytes, the reduction of the pheo/eumelanin ratio were less pronounced. From these results we conclude that keratinocytes play an important role in the melanin production, affecting the melanogenic pathways.     

Effects of melanogenesis-inducing nitric oxide and histamine on the production of eumelanin and pheomelanin in cultured human melanocytes

Melanin pigments produced in human melanocytes are classified into two categories; black coloured eumelanin and reddish-yellow pheomelanin. Stimulation of melanocytes with alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone (alpha-MSH), one of several melanogenic factors, has been reported to enhance eumelanogenesis to a greater degree than pheomelanogenesis, which contributes to hyperpigmentation in skin. Nitric oxide (NO) and histamine are also melanogenesis-stimulating factors that are released from cells surrounding melanocytes following ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. In this study, the effects of NO and histamine on the ratio of eumelanin and pheomelanin were examined in human melanocytes, and then compared with that of alpha-MSH. The amounts of eumelanin and pheomelanin were quantified using high-performance liquid chromatography analysis after oxidation and hydrolysis of melanin. Melanogenesis was induced by the addition of alpha-MSH, NO, or histamine to melanocytes. The amount of eumelanin production significantly increased with independent stimulation by these melanogenic factors, especially histamine, while that of pheomelanin significantly increased with alpha-MSH and NO, but only slightly with histamine. As a result, the ratio of eumelanin and pheomelanin increased significantly with the addition of NO or histamine. These results suggest that NO and histamine, as in the case of alpha-MSH, may contribute to UV-induced hyperpigmentation by enhancing eumelanogenesis.     

Melanin in human irides of different color and age of donors

Melanin is the main chromophore of the human iris. This pigment is considered to be the most important factor that determines the color of the irides. Previous studies based mainly on chemical degradation methods showed that brown irides contain more melanin than blue ones. In our study, we used electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy to detect and characterize melanin free radical centers and associated iron in human irides. Based on this method, we determined the amount of melanin in the irides and the relative content of iron in iridial melanin as a function of their color, shade, and the age of their donors. Chemical degradation of iridial homogenates enabled us to characterize the structure of eumelanin and determine the content of pheomelanin present in human and bovine irides. The ESR amplitude, the normalized intensity obtained by double integration of the ESR signal of melanin, and the content of the pigment in the irides depended on color and shade of the eyes being 40% higher in the brown group of the irides compared with all other groups. On the other hand, the relative iron content normalized to the melanin content in light blue irides showed a small decrease with age of donors. Melanin in human and bovine irides was mostly composed of eumelanin, and pheomelanin content was of the order of a few percent. Although some differences in the structure of eumelanin present in the human and bovine irides are possible, the results obtained in this study suggest that human irides contain eumelanin with very similar chemical properties.     

Cutaneous Photobiology. The Melanocyte vs. the Sun: Who Will Win the Final Round?

Solar ultraviolet radiation (UV) is a major environmental factor that dramatically alters the homeostasis of the skin as an organ by affecting the survival, proliferation and differentiation of various cutaneous cell types. The effects of UV on the skin include direct damage to DNA, apoptosis, growth arrest, and stimulation of melanogenesis. Long‐term effects of UV include photoaging and photocarcinogenesis. Epidermal melanocytes synthesize two main types of melanin: eumelanin and pheomelanin. Melanin, particularly eumelanin, represents the major photoprotective mechanism in the skin. Melanin limits the extent of UV penetration through the epidermal layers, and scavenges reactive oxygen radicals that may lead to oxidative DNA damage. The extent of UV‐induced DNA damage and the incidence of skin cancer are inversely correlated with total melanin content of the skin. Given the importance of the melanocyte in guarding against the adverse effects of UV and the fact that the melanocyte has a low self‐renewal capacity, it is critical to maintain its survival and genomic integrity in order to prevent malignant transformation to melanoma, the most fatal form of skin cancer. Melanocyte transformation to melanoma involves the activation of certain oncogenes and the inactivation of specific tumor suppressor genes. This review summarizes the current state of knowledge about the role of melanin and the melanocyte in photoprotection, the responses of melanocytes to UV, the signaling pathways that mediate the biological effects of UV on melanocytes, and the most common genetic alterations that lead to melanoma.     

Environmental constraints for plumage melanization in the northern goshawk Accipiter gentilis

Although it is recognized that certain environmental factors are important determinants of the expression of melanin‐based traits, their influence in wild populations of animals is poorly known. One of these factors is the availability of amino acids that serve as precursors of melanins. Here we measured eumelanin and pheomelanin content in feathers of northern goshawk Accipiter gentilis nestlings, hypothesizing that, if the availability of melanin precursors is related to food abundance and habitat quality, plumage melanization should be affected by those variables. Although the eumelanin content increased with food abundance as predicted, the levels of this variable were higher in low‐quality habitats (homogeneous coniferous forests) and in nestlings in poor condition, and the pheomelanin content and eumelanin:pheomelanin ratio were lower and higher, respectively, in subpopulations where nestlings were in poorer condition. Therefore, environmental availability of melanin precursors seems to determine plumage melanization in goshawks, but our findings may also be explained by the differential effects of environmental oxidative stress on both forms of melanin, as eumelanin and pheomelanin production are favoured under high and low levels, respectively, of oxidative stress.     

Regulation of eumelanin/pheomelanin synthesis and visible pigmentation in melanocytes by ligands of the melanocortin 1 receptor

The production of melanin in the hair and skin is tightly regulated by the melanocortin 1 receptor (MC1R) whose activation is controlled by two secreted ligands, alpha-melanocyte stimulating hormone (alphaMSH) and agouti signal protein (ASP). As melanin is extremely stable, lasting years in biological tissues, the mechanism underlying the relatively rapid decrease in visible pigmentation elicited by ASP is of obvious interest. In this study, the effects of ASP and alphaMSH on the regulation of melanin synthesis and on visible pigmentation were assessed in normal murine melanocytes and were compared with the quick depigmenting effect of the tyrosinase inhibitor, phenylthiourea (PTU). alphaMSH increased pheomelanin levels prior to increasing eumelanin content over 4 days of treatment. Conversely, ASP switched off the pigment synthesis pathway, reducing eu- and pheo-melanin synthesis within 1 day of treatment that was proportional to the decrease in tyrosinase protein level and activity. These results demonstrate that the visible depigmentation of melanocytes induced by ASP does not require the degradation of existing melanin but rather is due to the dilution of existing melanin by melanocyte turnover, which emphasizes the importance of pigment distribution to visible color.