Membrane topology of human ABC proteins

In this review, we summarize the currently available information on the membrane topology of some key members of the human ABC protein subfamilies, and present the predicted domain arrangements. In the lack of high-resolution structures for eukaryotic ABC transporters this topology is based only on prediction algorithms and biochemical data for the location of various segments of the polypeptide chain, relative to the membrane. We suggest that topology models generated by the available prediction methods should only be used as guidelines to provide a basis of experimental strategies for the elucidation of the membrane topology.     

Experimentally based topology models for E. coli inner membrane proteins

Membrane protein topology predictions can be markedly improved by the inclusion of even very limited experimental information. We have recently introduced an approach for the production of reliable topology models based on a combination of experimental determination of the location (cytoplasmic or periplasmic) of a protein's C terminus and topology prediction. Here, we show that determination of the location of a protein's C terminus, rather than some internal loop, is the best strategy for large-scale topology mapping studies. We further report experimentally based topology models for 31 Escherichia coli inner membrane proteins, using methodology suitable for genome-scale studies.     

The Erythrocyte/Brain Glucose Transporter (GLUT1) May Adopt a Two–Channel Transmembrane α/β Structure.

There are two models of topology for the membrane domains of the erythrocyte/brain facilitative glucose transporter, GLUT1. The first is composed of 12 membrane–spanning α–helices, the second of 16 membrane-spanning β-strands. We have used Jähnig′s and Eisenberg′s methods to identify possible transmembrane segments (10 spanning α-helices and 4 β-strands). The topology proposed is more consistent with available experimental data from FTIR, CD and mapping experiment than the previous models . We suggest that GLUT1 might form two channels, one of which is responsible for glucose transport. This agrees with the theoretical and experimental arguments. Finally, an analysis of the mutation periodicity and of the mean hydrophobicity for the GLUT family is provided in order to evaluate the packing of the protein in the membrane.     

Reliability measures for membrane protein topology prediction algorithms

We have developed reliability scores for five widely used membrane protein topology prediction methods, and have applied them both on a test set of 92 bacterial plasma membrane proteins with experimentally determined topologies and on all predicted helix bundle membrane proteins in three fully sequenced genomes: Escherichia coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Caenorhabditis elegans. We show that the reliability scores work well for the TMHMM and MEMSAT methods, and that they allow the probability that the predicted topology is correct to be estimated for any protein. We further show that the available test set is biased towards high-scoring proteins when compared to the genome-wide data sets, and provide estimates for the expected prediction accuracy of TMHMM across the three genomes. Finally, we show that the performance of TMHMM is considerably better when limited experimental information (such as the in/out location of a protein's C terminus) is available, and estimate that at least ten percentage points in overall accuracy in whole-genome predictions can be gained in this way.     

Topology of factor VIII bound to phosphatidylserine-containing model membranes

Factor VIII (FVIII), a plasma glycoprotein, is an essential cofactor in the blood coagulation cascade. It is a multidomain protein, known to bind to phosphatidylserine (PS)-containing membranes. Based on X-ray and electron crystallography data, binding of FVIII to PS-containing membranes has been proposed to occur only via the C2 domain. Based on these models, the molecular topology of membrane-bound FVIII can be envisioned as one in which only a small fraction of the protein interacts with the membrane, whereas the majority of the molecule is exposed to an aqueous milieu. We have investigated the topology of the membrane-bound FVIII using biophysical and biochemical techniques. Circular dichroism (CD) and fluorescence studies indicate no significant changes in the secondary and tertiary structure of FVIII associated with the membranes. Acrylamide quenching studies show that the protein is predominantly present on the surface of the membrane, exposed to the aqueous milieu. The light scattering and electron microscopy studies indicate the absence of vesicle aggregation and fusion. Binding studies with antibodies directed against specific epitopes in the A1, A2 and C2 domains suggest that FVIII binds to the membrane primarily via C2 domain including the specific phospholipid binding epitope (2303-2332) and may involve subtle conformational changes in this epitope region.     

Rapid screening of membrane topology of secondary transport proteins

Limited experimental data may be very useful to discriminate between membrane topology models of membrane proteins derived from different methods. A membrane topology screening method is proposed by which the cellular disposition of three positions in a membrane protein are determined, the N- and the C-termini and a position in the middle of the protein. The method involves amplification of the encoding genes or gene fragments by PCR, rapid cloning in dedicated vectors by ligation independent cloning, and determination of the cellular disposition of the three sites using conventional techniques. The N-terminus was determined by labeling with a fluorescent probe, the central position and the C-terminus by the reporter fusion technique using alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) and green fluorescence protein (GFP) as reporters. The method was evaluated using 16 transporter proteins of known function from four different structural classes. For 13 proteins a complete set of three localizations was obtained. The experimental data was used to discriminate between membrane topology models predicted by TMHMM, a widely used predictor using the amino acid sequence as input and by MemGen that uses hydropathy profile alignment and known 3D structures or existing models. It follows that in those cases where the models from the two methods were similar, the models were consistent with the experimental data. In those cases where the models differed, the MemGen model agreed with the experimental data. Three more recent predictors, MEMSAT3, OCTOPUS and TOPCONS showed a significantly higher consistency with the experimental data than observed with TMHMM.     

Prediction of the transmembrane regions of beta-barrel membrane proteins with a neural network-based predictor

A method based on neural networks is trained and tested on a nonredundant set of beta-barrel membrane proteins known at atomic resolution with a jackknife procedure. The method predicts the topography of transmembrane beta strands with residue accuracy as high as 78% when evolutionary information is used as input to the network. Of the transmembrane beta-strands included in the training set, 93% are correctly assigned. The predictor includes an algorithm of model optimization, based on dynamic programming, that correctly models eight out of the 11 proteins present in the training/testing set. In addition, protein topology is assigned on the basis of the location of the longest loops in the models. We propose this as a general method to fill the gap of the prediction of beta-barrel membrane proteins.     

Evidence that the transmembrane biogenesis of aquaporin 1 is cotranslational in intact mammalian cells

Most polytopic membrane proteins are believed to integrate into the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) cotranslationally. However, recent studies with Xenopus oocytes and dog pancreatic microsomes have suggested that this is not the case for human aquaporin 1 (AQP1). These experiments indicate that membrane-spanning segments (MSSs) 2 and 4 of AQP1 do not integrate into the membrane cotranslationally so that this protein initially adopts a four MSS topology. A later maturation event involving a 180-degree rotation of MSS 3 from an N(lum)/C(cyt) to an N(cyt)/C(lum) orientation and the concomitant integration of MSSs 2 and 4 into the membrane results in the final six MSS topology. Here we examine the biogenesis of AQP1 in the human embryonic kidney cell line HEK-293T. To do this, we constructed an expression vector for a fusion protein consisting of the enhanced green fluorescent protein followed by an insertion site for AQP1 sequences and a C-terminal glycosylation tag. We then transiently transfected HEK-293T cells with this vector containing the AQP1 sequence truncated after each MSS. Glycosylation of the C-terminal tag was used to monitor its location relative to the ER lumen and consequently the membrane integration and orientation of successive MSSs. In contrast to previous studies our results indicate that AQP1 integrates into the ER membrane cotranslationally in intact HEK-293T cells.     

Complete topology inversion can be part of normal membrane protein biogenesis

The topology of helical membrane proteins is generally defined during insertion of the transmembrane helices, yet it is now clear that it is possible for topology to change under unusual circumstances. It remains unclear, however, if topology reorientation is part of normal biogenesis. For dual topology dimer proteins such as the multidrug transporter EmrE, there may be evolutionary pressure to allow topology flipping so that the populations of both orientations can be equalized. We previously demonstrated that when EmrE is forced to insert in a distorted topology, topology flipping of the first transmembrane helix can occur during translation. Here, we show that topological malleability also extends to the C‐terminal helix and that even complete topology inversion of the entire EmrE protein can occur after the full protein is translated and inserted. Thus, topology rearrangements are possible during normal biogenesis. Wholesale topology flipping is remarkable given the physical constraints of the membrane and expands the range of possible membrane protein folding pathways, both productive and detrimental.     

Topology of the outer membrane usher PapC determined by site-directed fluorescence labeling

In contrast to typical membrane proteins that span the lipid bilayer via transmembrane alpha-helices, bacterial outer membrane proteins adopt a beta-barrel architecture composed of antiparallel transmembrane beta-strands. The topology of outer membrane proteins is difficult to predict accurately using computer algorithms, and topology mapping protocols commonly used for alpha-helical membrane proteins do not work for beta-barrel proteins. We present here the topology of the PapC usher, an outer membrane protein required for assembly and secretion of P pili by the chaperone/usher pathway in uropathogenic Escherichia coli. An initial attempt to map PapC topology by insertion of protease cleavage sites was largely unsuccessful due to lack of cleavage at most sites and the requirement to disrupt the outer membrane to identify periplasmic sites. We therefore adapted a site-directed fluorescence labeling technique to permit topology mapping of outer membrane proteins using small molecule probes in intact bacteria. Using this method, we demonstrated that PapC has the potential to encode up to 32 transmembrane beta-strands. Based on experimental evidence, we propose that the usher consists of an N-terminal beta-barrel domain comprised of 26 beta-strands and that a distinct C-terminal domain is not inserted into the membrane but is located instead within the lumen of the N-terminal beta-barrel similar to the plug domains encoded by the outer membrane iron-siderophore uptake proteins.     

Interferon-induced Transmembrane Protein 3 Is a Type II Transmembrane Protein

The interferon-induced transmembrane (IFITM) proteins are a family of small membrane proteins that inhibit the cellular entry of several genera of viruses. These proteins had been predicted to adopt a two-pass, type III transmembrane topology with an intracellular loop, two transmembrane helices (TM1 and TM2), and extracellular N and C termini. Recent work, however, supports an intramembrane topology for the helices with cytosolic orientation of both termini. Here we determined the topology of murine Ifitm3. We found that the N terminus of Ifitm3 could be stained by antibodies at the cell surface but that this conformation was cell type-dependent and represented a minority of the total plasma membrane pool. In contrast, the C terminus was readily accessible to antibodies at the cell surface and extracellular C termini comprised most or all of those present at the plasma membrane. The addition of a C-terminal KDEL endoplasmic reticulum retention motif to Ifitm3 resulted in sequestration of Ifitm3 in the ER, demonstrating an ER-luminal orientation of the C terminus. C-terminal, but not N-terminal, epitope tags were also degraded within lysosomes, consistent with their luminal orientation. Furthermore, epitope-tagged Ifitm3 TM2 functioned as a signal anchor sequence when expressed in isolation. Collectively, our results demonstrate a type II transmembrane topology for Ifitm3 and will provide insight into its interaction with potential targets and cofactors.     

Membrane topology of transmembrane proteins: determinants and experimental tools

Membrane topology refers to the two-dimensional structural information of a membrane protein that indicates the number of transmembrane (TM) segments and the orientation of soluble domains relative to the plane of the membrane. Since membrane proteins are co-translationally translocated across and inserted into the membrane, the TM segments orient themselves properly in an early stage of membrane protein biogenesis. Each membrane protein must contain some topogenic signals, but the translocation components and the membrane environment also influence the membrane topology of proteins. We discuss the factors that affect membrane protein orientation and have listed available experimental tools that can be used in determining membrane protein topology.     

The CbiB protein of Salmonella enterica is an integral membrane protein involved in the last step of the de novo corrin ring biosynthetic pathway

We report results of studies of the conversion of adenosylcobyric acid (AdoCby) to adenosylcobinamide-phosphate, the last step of the de novo corrin ring biosynthetic branch of the adenosylcobalamin (coenzyme B12) pathway of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2. Previous reports have implicated the CbiB protein in this step of the pathway. Hydropathy analysis predicted that CbiB would be an integral membrane protein. We used a computer-generated topology model of the primary sequence of CbiB to guide the construction of CbiB-LacZ and CbiB-PhoA protein fusions, which were used to explore the general topology of CbiB in the cell membrane. A refined model of CbiB as an integral membrane protein is presented. In vivo analyses of the effect of single-amino-acid changes showed that periplasm- and cytosol-exposed residues are critical for CbiB function. Results of in vivo studies also show that ethanolamine-phosphate (EA-P) is a substrate of CbiB, but l-Thr-P is not, and that CbiB likely activates AdoCby by phosphorylation. The latter observation leads us to suggest that CbiB is a synthetase not a synthase enzyme. Results from mass spectrometry and bioassay experiments indicate that serovar Typhimurium synthesizes norcobalamin (cobalamin lacking the methyl group at C176) when EA-P is the substrate of CbiB.     

Anti-parallel membrane topology of a homo-dimeric multidrug transporter, EmrE

EmrE in Escherichia coli belongs to the small multidrug resistance (SMR) transporter family. It functions as a homo-dimer, but the orientation of the two monomers in the membrane (membrane topology) is under debate. We expressed various single-cysteine EmrE mutants in E. coli cells lacking a major efflux transporter. Efflux from cells expressing the P55C or T56C mutant was blocked by the external application of membrane-impermeable SH-reagents. This is difficult to explain by the parallel topology configuration, because Pro55 and Thr56 are considered to be located in the cytoplasm. From both the periplasm and the cytoplasm, biotin-PE-maleimide, a bulky membrane-impermeable SH-reagent, could access the cysteine residue at the 25th position in the presence of transport substrates and at the 108th position. These observations support the anti-parallel topology in the membrane.     

α-螺旋跨膜蛋白拓扑结构预测方法的评价

在基因组数据中,有20%～30%的产物被预测为跨膜蛋白,本文通过对膜蛋白拓扑结构预测方法进行分析,并评价其结果,为选择更合适的拓扑结构预测方法预测膜蛋白结构。通过对目前已有的拓扑结构预测方法的评价分析,可以为我们在实际工作中提供重要的参考。比如对一个未知拓扑结构的跨膜蛋白序列,我们可以先进行是否含有信号肽的预测,参考Polyphobius和SignalP两种方法,若两种方法预测结果不一致,综合上述对两种方法的评价,Polyphobius预测的综合能力较好,可取其预测的结果,一旦确定含有信号肽,则N端必然位于膜外侧。然后结合序列的长度,判断蛋白是单跨膜还是多重跨膜,即可参照上述评价结果,选择合适的拓扑结构预测方法进行预测。     

Assessment of the integral membrane protein topology in living cells

The bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) phenomenon has been successfully applied for in vivo protein-protein interaction studies and protein tagging analysis. Here we report a novel BiFC-based technique for investigation of integral membrane protein topology in living plant cells. This technique relies on the formation of a fluorescent complex between a non-fluorescent fragment of the yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) targeted into a specific cellular compartment and a counterpart fragment attached to the integral membrane protein N- or C-terminus or inserted into the internal loop(s). We employed this technique for topological studies of beet yellows virus-encoded p6 membrane-embedded movement protein, a protein with known topology, and the potato mop-top virus-encoded integral membrane TGBp2 protein with predicted topology. The results confirm that p6 is a type III integral transmembrane protein. Using a novel method, the central hydrophilic region of TGBp2 was localized into the ER lumen, whereas the N- and C-termini localized to the cytosol. We conclude that the BiFC-based reporter system for membrane protein topology analysis is a relatively fast and efficient method that can be used for high-throughput analysis of proteins integrated into the endoplasmic reticulum in living plant cells.     

Topology of eukaryotic type II membrane proteins: importance of N-terminal positively charged residues flanking the hydrophobic domain

We have tested the role of different charged residues flanking the sides of the signal/anchor (S/A) domain of a eukaryotic type II (N(cyt)C(exo)) integral membrane protein in determining its topology. The removal of positively charged residues on the N-terminal side of the S/A yields proteins with an inverted topology, while the addition of positively charged residues to only the C-terminal side has very little effect on orientation. Expression of chimeric proteins composed of domains from a type II protein (HN) and the oppositely oriented membrane protein M2 indicates that the HN N-terminal domain is sufficient to confer a type II topology and that the M2 N-terminal ectodomain can direct a type II topology when modified by adding positively charged residues. These data suggest that eukaryotic membrane protein topology is governed by the presence or absence of an N-terminal signal for retention in the cytoplasm that is composed in part of positive charges.     

Topology of the membrane domain of human erythrocyte anion exchange protein, AE1

Anion exchanger 1 (AE1) is the chloride/bicarbonate exchange protein of the erythrocyte membrane. By using a combination of introduced cysteine mutants and sulfhydryl-specific chemistry, we have mapped the topology of the human AE1 membrane domain. Twenty-seven single cysteines were introduced throughout the Leu708-Val911 region of human AE1, and these mutants were expressed by transient transfection of human embryonic kidney cells. On the basis of cysteine accessibility to membrane-permeant biotin maleimide and to membrane-impermeant lucifer yellow iodoacetamide, we have proposed a model for the topology of AE1 membrane domain. In this model, AE1 is composed of 13 typical transmembrane segments, and the Asp807-His834 region is membrane-embedded but does not have the usual alpha-helical conformation. To identify amino acids that are important for anion transport, we analyzed the anion exchange activity for all introduced cysteine mutants, using a whole cell fluorescence assay. We found that mutants G714C, S725C, and S731C have very low transport activity, implying that this region has a structurally and/or catalytically important role. We measured the residual anion transport activity after mutant treatment with the membrane-impermeant, cysteine-directed compound, sodium (2-sulfonatoethyl)methanethiosulfonate) (MTSES). Only two mutants, S852C and A858C, were inhibited by MTSES, indicating that these residues may be located in a pore-lining region.     

Primary structure analysis of an integral membrane glycoprotein of the nuclear pore

The complete primary structure of an integral membrane glycoprotein of the nuclear pore was deduced from the cDNA sequence. The cDNA encodes a polypeptide of 204,205 D containing a 25-residue-long signal sequence, two hydrophobic segments that could function as transmembrane segments, and 13 potential N-linked oligosaccharide addition sites. Endoglycosidase H reduces the molecular mass by approximately 9 kD suggesting that not all of these 13 sites are used. We discuss possible models for the topology of this protein in the pore membrane as well as a possible role in the formation of pores and pore complexes.     

Unusual topological arrangement of structural motifs in the baboon reovirus fusion-associated small transmembrane protein

Select members of the Reoviridae are the only nonenveloped viruses known to induce syncytium formation. The fusogenic orthoreoviruses accomplish cell-cell fusion through a distinct class of membrane fusion-inducing proteins referred to as the fusion-associated small transmembrane (FAST) proteins. The p15 membrane fusion protein of baboon reovirus is unique among the FAST proteins in that it contains two hydrophobic regions (H1 and H2) recognized as potential transmembrane (TM) domains, suggesting a polytopic topology. However, detailed topological analysis of p15 indicated only the H1 domain is membrane spanning. In the absence of an N-terminal signal peptide, the H1 TM domain serves as a reverse signal-anchor to direct p15 membrane insertion and a bitopic N(exoplasmic)/C(cytoplasmic) topology. This topology results in the translocation of the smallest ectodomain ( approximately 20 residues) of any known viral fusion protein, with the majority of p15 positioned on the cytosolic side of the membrane. Mutagenic analysis indicated the unusual presence of an N-terminal myristic acid on the small p15 ectodomain is essential to the fusion process. Furthermore, the only other hydrophobic region (H2) present in p15, aside from the TM domain, is located within the endodomain. Consequently, the p15 ectodomain is devoid of a fusion peptide motif, a hallmark feature of membrane fusion proteins. The exceedingly small, myristoylated ectodomain and the unusual topological distribution of structural motifs in this nonenveloped virus membrane fusion protein necessitate alternate models of protein-mediated membrane fusion.