SYMBIODINIUM (PYRRHOPHYTA) GENOME SIZES (DNA CONTENT) ARE SMALLEST AMONG DINOFLAGELLATES1

Using flow cytometric analysis of fluorescence, we measured the genome sizes of 18 cultured “free‐living” species and 29 Symbiodinium spp. isolates cultured from stony corals, gorgonians, anemones, jellyfish, and giant clams. Genome size directly correlated with cell size, as documented previously for most eukaryotic cell lines. Among the smallest of dinoflagellates, Symbiodinium spp. (6–15 μm) possessed the lowest DNA content that we measured (1.5–4.8 pg·cell^?1). Bloom‐forming or potentially harmful species in the genera Alexandrium, Karenia, Pfiesteria, and Prorocentrum possessed genomes approximately 2 to 50 times larger in size. A phylogenetic analysis indicated that genome/cell size has apparently increased and decreased repeatedly during the evolution of dinoflagellates. In contrast, genome sizes were relatively consistent across distantly and closely related Symbiodinium spp. This may be the product of intracellular host habitats imposing strong selective pressures that have restricted symbiont size.     

DNA LIBRARIES FOR SEQUENCING THE GENOME OF OSTREOCOCCUS TAURI (CHLOROPHYTA,PRASINOPHYCEAE): THE SMALLEST FREE‐LIVING EUKARYOTIC CELL1

Ostreococcus tauri is a marine photosynthetic picoeukaryote presenting a minimal cellular organization with one nucleus, one chloroplast, and one mitochondrion. It has the smallest genome described among free‐living eukaryotic cells, and we showed by pulsed‐field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) that it is divided between 15 bands ranging from 1.2 to 0.15 Mb, giving a total size of 9.7 Mb. A Bacterial Artificial Chromosome (BAC) library was prepared from genomic DNA extracted from a culture of O. tauri. A total of 2457 clones was obtained with an average insert size of around 70 kb, representing an 18‐fold coverage of the genome. The library was spotted on high density filters, and several probes of coding sequences were hybridized to both the high density BAC library filters and directly to the dried PFGE gels of the O. tauri genomic DNA. These hybridizations allowed a preliminary organization of the library and the localization of several markers on the chromosomes. Randomly selected fragments were also sequenced, representing 12% of the O. tauri genome. Many sequences showed significant similarities in data banks, mainly with plant and algae sequences. About 1000 coding sequences could be identified. These data confirmed the position of O. tauri in the green lineage and the hypothesis of a very compact organization of its genome.     

SYMBIODINIUM NATANS SP. NOV.: A “FREE‐LIVING” DINOFLAGELLATE FROM TENERIFE (NORTHEAST‐ATLANTIC OCEAN)1

We examined a free‐living Symbiodinium species by light and electron microscopy and nuclear‐encoded partial LSU rDNA sequence data. The strain was isolated from a net plankton sample collected in near‐shore waters at Tenerife, the Canary Islands. Comparing the thecal plate tabulation of the free‐living Symbiodinium to that of S. microadriaticum Freud., it became clear that a few but significant differences could be noted. The isolate possessed two rather than three antapical plates, six rather than seven to eight postcingular plates, and finally four rather than five apical plates. The electron microscopic study also revealed the presence of an eyespot with brick‐shaped contents in the sulcal region and a narrow anterior plate with small knob‐like structures. Bayesian analysis revealed the free‐living Symbiodinium to be a member of the earliest diverging clade A. However, it did not group within subclade A_I (=temperate A) or any other subclades within clade A. Rather, it occupied an isolated position, and this was also supported by sequence divergence estimates. On the basis of comparative analysis of the thecal plate tabulation and the inferred phylogeny, we propose that the Symbiodinium isolate from Tenerife is a new species (viz. S. natans). To elucidate further the species diversity of Symbiodinium, particularly those inhabiting coral reefs, we suggest combining morphological features of the thecal plate pattern with gene sequence data. Indeed, future examination of motile stages originating from symbiont isolates will demonstrate if this proves a feasible way to identify and characterize additional species of Symbiodinium and thus match ribotypes or clusters of ribotypes to species.     

Genetic identity of free‐living Symbiodinium obtained over a broad latitudinal range in the Japanese coast

The dinoflagellate Symbiodinium is well known to engage symbiosis with various marine animals, including corals. Recent records of environmental Symbiodinium (occurring in the environment and separately from host animals; usually referred to as ‘free‐living’ Symbiodinium) are of special interest, since these environmental populations are essential as symbiont sources for many host animals. In the present study, we carried out a phylogenetic analysis of environmental Symbiodinium isolates (culture strains) from sand, tide pools, or macroalgal surfaces, and environmental DNA clones extracted from the water‐column, at numerous sites around Japan. Our phylogenetic analysis based on the nuclear rRNA gene (internal transcribed spacers ‐1, ‐2, and 5.8S), indicated that most of the environmental isolates form monophyletic subclades within the Clade‐A lineage, and separate from a host‐associated Clade‐A population with high bootstrap values. Results of the partial nuclear 28S rDNA phylogeny and thecal‐plate observations revealed that these environmental isolates were closely related to a previously‐described ‘planktonic species’, Symbiodinium natans Gert Hansen et Daugbjerg, which was isolated from a plankton‐net sample from the Northeast‐Atlantic Ocean. On the other hand, the environmental DNA clones were also noted to be mostly nested within host‐associated Symbiodinium groups scattered in various clades. These results led to the assumption that the environmental Symbiodinium can be divided into two groups. One group, as typified by environmental isolates in the present study and previous reports, may be exclusively free‐living; the other group exists transiently in free‐living forms, possibly having been expelled from animal hosts. The populations within the latter group probably represent environmental sources of viable symbionts, because these are normally host‐associated. However, the Symbiodinium in the former group are not expected to engage in stable symbioses with host cnidarians.     

Symbiodinium (Dinophyceae) diversity in reef‐invertebrates along an offshore to inshore reef gradient near Lizard Island,Great Barrier Reef

Despite extensive work on the genetic diversity of reef invertebrate‐dinoflagellate symbioses on the Great Barrier Reef (GBR; Australia), large information gaps exist from northern and inshore regions. Therefore, a broad survey was done comparing the community of inshore, mid‐shelf and outer reefs at the latitude of Lizard Island. Symbiodinium (Freudenthal) diversity was characterized using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis fingerprinting and sequencing of the ITS2 region of the ribosomal DNA. Thirty‐nine distinct Symbiodinium types were identified from four subgeneric clades (B, C, D, and G). Several Symbiodinium types originally characterized from the Indian Ocean were discovered as well as eight novel types (C1kk, C1LL, C3nn, C26b, C161a, C162, C165, C166). Multivariate analyses on the Symbiodinium species diversity data showed a strong link with host identity, consistent with previous findings. Of the four environmental variables tested, mean austral winter sea surface temperature (SST) influenced Symbiodinium distribution across shelves most significantly. A similar result was found when the analysis was performed on Symbiodinium diversity data of genera with an open symbiont transmission mode separately with chl a and PAR explaining additional variation. This study underscores the importance of SST and water quality related variables as factors driving Symbiodinium distribution on cross‐shelf scales. Furthermore, this study expands our knowledge on Symbiodinium species diversity, ecological partitioning (including host‐specificity) and geographic ranges across the GBR. The accelerating rate of environmental change experienced by coral reef ecosystems emphasizes the need to comprehend the full complexity of cnidarian symbioses, including the biotic and abiotic factors that shape their current distributions.     

The endosymbiotic dinoflagellates (Symbiodinium sp.) of corals are parasites and mutualists

The evolutionary success and continued survival of reef-building corals under increasing environmental change will, in part, be determined by the composition of their endosymbiotic dinoflagellate communities (Symbiodinium sp.). Recent research suggests that differences in the phylotype composition of Symbiodinium in the same host can lead to different outcomes for the host when exposed to similar environmental conditions. One explanation for these observations is that symbioses between corals and Symbiodinium represent a continuum of interaction states that encompass mutualisms and parasitisms consistent with current evolutionary theory developed for other symbiotic systems. Here, we discuss the evidence supporting the existence of a parasitic to mutualistic continuum in Symbiodinium interactions and propose that a consideration of the evolutionary ecology of these associations will advance our understanding of how environmental change will influence the ecological outcomes in these important symbioses. We advocate that a robust taxonomic structure for Symbiodinium sp. and empirical studies on sexual reproduction in Symbiodinium, the stability of interaction states among Symbiodinium symbioses spatially and temporally and how interaction states change as the environment changes will generate data for models that accurately forecast how climate change will influence the persistence of corals and the reefs they structure.     

SYMBIODINIUM (DINOPHYTA) DIVERSITY AND STABILITY IN AQUARIUM CORALS1

Indo‐Pacific reef corals growing for years in closed‐system aquaria provide an alternate means to investigate host–symbiont specificity and stability. The diversity of dinoflagellate endosymbionts (Symbiodinium spp.) from coral communities in private and public aquaria was investigated using molecular‐genetic analyses. Of the 29 symbiont types (i.e., species) identified, 90% belonged to the most prevalent group of Symbiodinium harbored by Indo‐Pacific reef corals, Clade C, while the rest belonged to Clade D. Sixty‐five percent of all types were known from field surveys conducted throughout the Pacific and Indian oceans. Because specific coral–dinoflagellate partnerships appear to have defined geographic distributions, correspondence of the same symbionts in aquarium and field‐collected specimens identifies regions where particular colonies must have been collected in the wild. Symbiodinium spp. in clade D, believed to be “stress‐tolerant” and/or “opportunistic,” occurred in a limited number of individual colonies. The absence of a prevalent, or “weedy,” symbiont suggests that conditions under which aquarium corals are grown do not favor competitive replacements of their native symbiont populations. The finding of typical and diverse assemblages of Symbiodinium spp. among aquarium corals living many years under variable chemical/physical conditions, artificial and natural light, while undergoing fragmentation periodically, indicates that individual colonies maintain stable, long‐term symbiotic associations.     

Phylogenetic incongruence between dinoflagellate endosymbionts (Symbiodinium) and their host foraminifera (Sorites): small-subunit ribosomal RNA gene sequence evidence

Phototrophic dinoflagellate zooxanthellae commonly occur as endosymbionts in many planktic and certain benthic foraminifera (soritids). Many taxonomic issues and specific identities of foraminiferal dinoflagellates are not yet resolved. To assess taxonomic affinities among other dinoflagellates, we have determined the complete nucleotide sequence of the small-subunit rRNA coding region from Symbiodinium sp., an endosymbiotic dinoflagellate of the larger foraminifer Sorites orbiculus. The poly merase chain reaction was adopted for the in vitro amplification of ribosomal DNA, utilizing primers complementary to conserved regions. PCR-amplified DNA was directly sequenced and the sequence was aligned to all complete 18S-rDNA dinoflagellate sequences currently available through GenBank. Apicomplexan, ciliate, chromistacean, and rhodophycean sequences were added to infer across-kingdom phylogenetic relationships. Phylogenetic analysis of aligned nucleotide sequences produced a single most parsimonious tree (generated by the branch and bound method of PAUP). The inferred phylogeny indicates that the dinoflagellate extracted from the foraminifer Sorites orbiculus is a sister taxon to the symbiont present in the larger foraminifera Marginopora kudakajimaensis, but only distantly related to the dinoflagellate isolated from the soritid Amphisorus hemprichii. The sequence heterogeneity demonstrates a high degree of genetic diversity among Symbiodinium-like zooxanthellae and re-emphasizes that they are a variety of distinct entities.The inferred molecular phylogenetic relationships among symbiotic dinoflagellates are not congruent with the foraminiferal phylogeny based on cladistic methodology. The lack of correlation between the evolutionary history of dinoflagellate symbionts and their foraminiferal hosts argues against co-evolution. This lack of co-evolution implies that flexible recombinations among hosts and symbionts are evolutionarily favorable over permanently associated lineages, at least in these benthic foraminifera.     

PHYLOGENETIC POSITION OF SYMBIODINIUM (DINOPHYCEAE) ISOLATES FROM TRIDACNIDS (BIVALVIA), CARDIIDS (BIVALVIA), A SPONGE (PORIFERA), A SOFT CORAL (ANTHOZOA), AND A FREE-LIVING STRAIN

The genus Symbiodinium is the commonly observed symbiotic dinoflagellate (zooxanthellae) that forms mutual associations with various marine invertebrates. Numerous studies have revealed that the genus is comprised of a group of diverse taxa, and information on the phylogenetic relationships among the genus’ members is increasing. In this study, small subunit (SSU) ribosomal RNA (ssrRNA) gene sequences were determined for 15 more Symbiodinium strains from 12 relatively unstudied host taxa (Indo-Pacific tridacnids, cardiids, sponge, and soft coral), 1 hitherto unreported free-living Symbiodinium strain, and 4 other Symbiodinium strains from four other host taxa (Indo-Pacific zoanthid, foraminifer, jellyfish, and mid-Pacific hard coral). Their respective phylogenetic positions were inferred, and strains that are either closely related to or distinct from previously reported Symbiodinium taxa were revealed. The cultured Symbiodinium strains isolated from individuals of six species of tridacnids and three species of cardiids all had identical ssrRNA gene sequences, are closely related to S. microadriaticum Freudenthal, and are indistinguishable from the RFLP Type A strain previously reported. However, the ssrRNA gene sequences of clam symbionts that were obtained via gene cloning were different from those of the cultured isolates and represent strains that are close to the RFLP Type C strains. The Symbiodinium-like dinoflagellate from the Indo-Pacific sponge Haliclona koremella De Laubenfels is distinct from any of the Symbiodinium taxa studied and may be similar to the symbiont previously isolated from the stony coral Montipora patula Quelch. The isolates from the soft coral Sarcophyton glaucum Quoy et Gaimard and from the zoanthid Zoanthus sp. are both very closely related to S. pilosum Trench et Blank. The free-living Symbiodinium isolate is very closely related to the symbiont isolated from the Indo-Pacific foraminifer Amphisorus hemprichii Ehrenberg, which in turn is distinct from the Red Sea strain isolated from a similar host. Theisolate from Cassiopeia sp. is different from S. microadriaticum F., the type species harbored by Cassiopeia xamachana Bigelow, and is instead very closely related to S. pulchrorum Trench isolated from a sea anemone. The symbiont from the stony coral M. verrucosa Lamarck is a sister taxon to the symbionts isolated from the foraminifera Marginopora kudakajimensis Gudmundsson and Sorites orbiculus Forskål. These data suggest that polymorphic symbioses extend from cnidarians to some bivalve, foraminifer, and jellyfish host species.     

Understanding diversity in coral-algal symbiosis: a cluster-based approach to interpreting fine-scale genetic variation in the genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Symbiodinium</Emphasis>

Reef corals associate with an extraordinary diversity of dinoflagellate endosymbionts (genus Symbiodinium), and this diversity has become critical to understanding how corals respond to environmental changes. A popular molecular marker for Symbiodinium diversity, the Internal Transcribed Spacer-2 (ITS-2) region of ribosomal DNA, has revealed hundreds of distinct variants that are generally interpreted as representing different species, even though many have not been systematically tested for functional or ecological differentiation. Many of these variants are only minimally divergent from one another (1 bp or less), and others occupy basal nodes of traditional species phylogenies (“living ancestors”), indicating that some Symbiodinium ITS-2 diversity may represent intraspecific sequence variation. This hypothesis was tested for Symbiodinium clades A–D (the dominant symbionts of reef corals) through the construction of statistical parsimony networks of ITS-2 sequence diversity, and identification of clusters of closely related sequences within these networks. Initial assessments indicated that ecological differentiation exists between, but not within, these clusters. This approach, although imperfect in its ability to identify species boundaries in all cases, nevertheless dramatically reduces “species” diversity in Symbiodinium (from ~175 to 35). This testable alternative hypothesis indicates that, in Symbiodinium, “species” consist of clusters of closely related ITS-2 sequences diverging from ancestral variants that are typically ecologically dominant. A cluster-based view of Symbiodinium ITS-2 diversity improves our ability to: (1) construct well-supported symbiont phylogenies; (2) establish functional niches for symbiont species; and (3) understand flexibility and specificity within coral-algal symbioses. This cluster-based approach can ultimately be integrated with emerging population-level datasets (microsatellites and microsatellite flanking regions) to improve understanding of species diversity in Symbiodinium. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Communicated by Biology Editor Dr Ruth Gates     

STRUCTURE AND EVOLUTION OF THE RDNA INTERNAL TRANSCRIBED SPACER (ITS) REGION 2 IN THE SYMBIOTIC DINOFLAGELLATES (SYMBIODINIUM,DINOPHYTA)1

Internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions of the eukaryotic rDNA operon are integral to the correct processing and maturation of rRNAs. To further understand the evolution of this region, we elucidated the secondary structure of ITS2 from representatives of the eight divergent clades of Symbiodinium Freud., a large genus of dinoflagellate endosymbionts occurring in association with zooxanthellate marine protists and invertebrates. Symbiodinium ITS2 molecules folded into one of two distinct conformations. One conformation, the “four‐fingered hand” model, has been described from a wide variety of eukaryotes, including free‐living dinoflagellates. A monophyletic assemblage comprising several Symbiodinium clades shared an unusual conformation, a five‐stem model previously known only from drosopholids, indicating that it arose in the common ancestor to this “superclade” of Symbiodinium. Several conserved features were identified in the ITS2 secondary structures, including a pyrimidine–pyrimidine bulge and a highly conserved 11 bp sequence motif, that correspond to known processing sites in other eukaryotes. Lastly, the ITS2 structural data are discussed in the context of Symbiodinium evolution, phylogenetics, and ecology.     

PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS OF A FREE‐LIVING STRAIN OF SYMBIODINIUM ISOLATED FROM JIAOZHOU BAY,P.R. CHINA1

Recently, the isolation of a free‐living strain of symbiotic dinoflagellate belonging to the genus Symbiodinium was reported. Although the specimen procured and characterization from Jiaozhou Bay, P.R. China is a Symbiodinium spp., the manner in which this isolate was classified is inconsistent with the currently used and accepted Symbiodinium cladal nomenclature. To avert unnecessary confusion in the field, I place this important scientific contribution into the proper context and state of Symbiodinium research.     

Population genetics of reef coral endosymbionts (Symbiodinium,Dinophyceae)

Symbiodinium is a diverse genus of unicellular dinoflagellate symbionts associating with various marine protists and invertebrates. Although the broadscale diversity and phylogenetics of the Symbiodinium complex is well established, there have been surprisingly few data on fine‐scale population structure and biogeography of these dinoflagellates. Yet population‐level processes contribute strongly to the biology of Symbiodinium, including how anthropogenic‐driven global climate change impacts these symbionts and their host associations. Here, we present a synthesis of population‐level characteristics for Symbiodinium, with an emphasis on how phylogenetic affinities, dynamics within and among host individuals, and a propensity towards clonality shape patterns on and across reefs. Major inferences include the following: (i) Symbiodinium populations within individual hosts are comprised mainly of cells belonging to a single or few genetic clones. (ii) Symbiont populations exhibit a mixed mode of reproduction, wherein at least one sexual recombination event occurs in the genealogy between most genotypes, but clonal propagation predominates overall. (iii) Mutualistic Symbiodinium do not perpetually persist outside their hosts, instead undergoing turnover and replacement via the continuous shedding of viable clonal cells from host individuals. (iv) Symbiont populations living in the same host, but on different reefs, are often genetically subdivided, suggesting low connectivity, adaptation to local conditions, or prolific asexual reproduction and low effective population sizes leading to disproportionate success within and among hosts. Overall, this synthesis forms a basis for future investigations of coral symbiosis ecology and evolution as well as delimitation of species boundaries in Symbiodinium and other eukaryotic microorganisms.     

Antigenic variation in mucilage secreted by members of the genus Symbiodinium (Dinophyceae)

Symbiodinium reside intracellularly in a complex symbiosome (host and symbiont‐derived) within cnidarian hosts in a specific host‐symbiont association. Symbiodinium is a diverse genus with variation greater than other dinoflagellate orders. In this paper, our investigation into specificity examines antigenic variation in the algal mucilage secretions at the host‐symbiont interface. Cultured Symbiodinium from a variety of clades were labeled with one of two antibodies to symbiont mucilage (PC3, developed using a clade B alga cultured from Aiptasia pallida; BF10, developed using a clade F alga cultured from Briareum sp.). The labeling was visualized with a fluorescent marker and examined with epifluorescence and confocal microscopy. PC3 antigen was found in cultured Symbiodinium from clades A and B, but not clades C, D, E and F. The correlation between labeling and clade may account for some of the specificity between host and symbiont in the field. Within clades A and B there was variation in the amount of label present. BF10 antigen was more specific and only found in cultures of the same cp23S‐rDNA strain the antibody was created against. These results indicate that the mucilage secretions do vary both qualitatively and quantitatively amongst Symbiodinium strains. Since the mucilage forms the host‐symbiont interface, variation in its molecular composition is likely to be the source of any signals involved in recognition and specificity.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Symbiodinium</Emphasis> associations with diseased and healthy scleractinian corals

Despite recent advances in identifying the causative agents of disease in corals and understanding the impact of epizootics on reef communities, little is known regarding the interactions among diseases, corals, and their dinoflagellate endosymbionts (Symbiodinium spp.). Since the genotypes of both corals and their resident Symbiodinium contribute to colony-level phenotypes, such as thermotolerance, symbiont genotypes might also contribute to the resistance or susceptibility of coral colonies to disease. To explore this, Symbiodinium were identified using the internal transcribed spacer-2 region of ribosomal DNA from diseased and healthy tissues within individual coral colonies infected with black band disease (BB), dark spot syndrome (DSS), white plague disease (WP), or yellow blotch disease (YB) in the Florida Keys (USA) and the US Virgin Islands. Most of the diseased colonies sampled contained B1, B5a, or C1 (depending on host species), while apparently healthy colonies of the same coral species frequently hosted these types and/or additional symbiont diversity. No potentially “parasitic” Symbiodinium types, uniquely associated with diseased coral tissue, were detected. Within most individual colonies, the same dominant Symbiodinium type was detected in diseased and visually healthy tissues. These data indicate that specific Symbiodinium types are not correlated with the infected tissues of diseased colonies and that DSS and WP onset do not trigger symbiont shuffling within infected tissues. However, few diseased colonies contained clade D symbionts suggesting a negative correlation between hosting Symbiodinium clade D and disease incidence in scleractinian corals. Understanding the influence of Symbiodinium diversity on colony phenotypes may play a critical role in predicting disease resistance and susceptibility in scleractinian corals.     

PHOTOSYNTHESIS AND PRODUCTION OF HYDROGEN PEROXIDE BY SYMBIODINIUM (PYRRHOPHYTA) PHYLOTYPES WITH DIFFERENT THERMAL TOLERANCES1

Occurrences whereby cnidaria lose their symbiotic dinoflagellate microalgae (Symbiodinium spp.) are increasing in frequency and intensity. These so‐called bleaching events are most often related to an increase in water temperature, which is thought to limit certain Symbiodinium phylotypes from effectively dissipating absorbed excitation energy that is otherwise used for photochemistry. Here, we examined photosynthetic characteristics and hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) production, a possible signal involved in bleaching, from two Symbiodinium types (a thermally “tolerant” A1 and “sensitive” B1) representative of cnidaria–Symbiodinium symbioses of reef‐building Caribbean corals. Under steady‐state growth at 26°C, a higher efficiency of PSII photochemistry, rate of electron turnover, and rate of O₂ production were observed for type A1 than for B1. The two types responded very differently to a period of elevated temperature (32°C): type A1 increased light‐driven O₂ consumption but not the amount of H₂O₂ produced; in contrast, type B1 increased the amount of H₂O₂ produced without an increase in light‐driven O₂ consumption. Therefore, our results are consistent with previous suggestions that the thermal tolerance of Symbiodinium is related to adaptive constraints associated with photosynthesis and that sensitive phylotypes are more prone to H₂O₂ production. Understanding these adaptive differences in the genus Symbiodinium will be crucial if we are to interpret the response of symbiotic associations, including reef‐building corals, to environmental change.