Proboscidean DNA from Museum and Fossil Specimens: An Assessment of Ancient DNA Extraction and Amplification Techniques

Applications of reliable DNA extraction and amplification techniques to postmortem samples are critical to ancient DNA research. Commonly used methods for isolating DNA from ancient material were tested and compared using both soft tissue and bones from fossil and contemporary museum proboscideans. DNAs isolated using three principal methods served as templates in subsequent PCR amplifications, and the PCR products were directly sequenced. Authentication of the ancient origin of obtained nucleotide sequences was established by demonstrating reproducibility under a blind testing system and by phylogenetic analysis. Our results indicate that ancient samples may respond differently to extraction buffers or purification procedures, and no single method was universally successful. A CTAB buffer method, modified from plant DNA extraction protocols, was found to have the highest success rate. Nested PCR was shown to be a reliable approach to amplify ancient DNA templates that failed in primary amplification.     

Ancient DNA studies

Now that the hype surrounding Jurassic Park has settled down and we have become relatively used to dramatic headlines announcing the recovery of DNA from exotic fossilized remains, scientists working on ancient DNA are beginning to reflect on the long-term prospects and implications of the subject.¹ The science of ancient DNA has grown exponentially since its birth only ten years ago, and despite serious technical difficulties, it promises to become a revolutionary research tool in anthropology and molecular evolution. The use of bone DNA typing in particular has already yielded useful insights into Polynesian prehistory as well as spectacular applications in the forensic identification of skeletal remains.     

Extracting DNA from museum bird eggs, and whole genome amplification of archive DNA

We present a comprehensive protocol for extracting DNA from egg membranes and other internal debris recovered from the interior of blown museum bird eggs. A variety of commercially available DNA extraction methods were found to be applicable. DNA sequencing of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products for a 176‐bp fragment of mitochondrial DNA was successful for most egg samples (> 78%) even though the amount of DNA extracted (mean = 14.71 ± 4.55 ng/µL) was significantly less than that obtained for bird skin samples (mean = 67.88 ± 4.77 ng/µL). For PCR and sequencing of snipe (Gallinago) DNA, we provide eight new primers for the ‘DNA barcode’ region of COI mtDNA. In various combinations, the primers target a range of PCR products sized from 72 bp to the full ‘barcode’ of 751 bp. Not all possible combinations were tested with archive snipe DNA, but we found a significantly better success rate of PCR amplification for a shorter 176‐bp target compared with a larger 288‐bp fragment (67% vs. 39%). Finally, we explored the feasibility of whole genome amplification (WGA) for extending the use of archive DNA in PCR and sequencing applications. Of two WGA approaches, a PCR‐based method was found to be able to amplify whole genomic DNA from archive skins and eggs from museum bird collections. After WGA, significantly more archive egg samples produced visible PCR products on agarose (56.9% before WGA vs. 79.0% after WGA). However, overall sequencing success did not improve significantly (78.8% compared with 83.0%).     

Detection of mitochondrial DNA deletions by a screening procedure using the Polymerase Chain Reaction

We describe an accurate procedure for a rapid diagnosis of heteroplasmic mtDNA deletions based on the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). For a selective amplification of deleted mtDNA across the breakpoints of the deletion, we used seven combinations of primers surrounding the most common deleted region between the two origins of mtDNA replication. This procedure was performed on muscle biopsies of twenty patients harboring a single mtDNA deletion and one patient with multiple mtDNA deletions. The results were compared with Southern-blotting analysis. We conclude that this PCR procedure is a sensitive and convenient screening method for the detection of mtDNA deletions. (Mol Cell Biochem 174: 221–225, 1997)     

DNA stabilization and amplification from museum collections of extracts originally intended for allozyme analysis

Protein extracts originally prepared for isozyme electrophoresis two decades ago contain surviving DNA sequences susceptible to amplification by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Amplification was also possible after stabilization of such extracts on filter paper and immersion under mineral oil without refrigeration.     

Searching for DNA in museum specimens: a comparison of sources in a mammal species

The number of genetic studies that use preserved specimens as sources of DNA has been steadily increasing during the last few years. Therefore, selecting the sources that are more likely to provide a suitable amount of DNA of enough quality to be amplified and at the minimum cost to the original specimen is an important step for future research. We have compared different types of tissue (hides vs. bones) from museum specimens of Iberian lynx and multiple alternative sources within each type (skin, footpad, footpad powder, claw, diaphysis, maxilloturbinal bone, mastoid process and canine) for DNA yield and probability of amplification of both mitochondrial and nuclear targets. Our results show that bone samples yield more and better DNA than hides, particularly from sources from skull, such as mastoid process and canines. However, claws offer an amplification success as high as bone sources, which makes them the preferred DNA source when no skeletal pieces have been preserved. Most importantly, these recommended sources can be sampled incurring minimal damage to the specimens while amplifying at a high success rate for both mitochondrial and microsatellite markers.     

Amplification of DNA bound on clay minerals

DNA adsorbs and binds on clay minerals, which provides protection to the DNA against degradation by nucleases but does not eliminate the ability of bound DNA to transform cells. These observations support the concept that 'cryptic genes' can persist in the environment when bound on particles and that the genes could subsequently be expressed if an appropriate host was transformed. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify free and bound DNA from Bacillus subtilis and calf thymus. DNA bound on montmorillonite, but not on kaolinite, was amplified. However, amplification occurred when kaolinite was pretreated with sodium metaphosphate. DNA was not released from the clays during the amplification procedure. The type of clay (e.g. its structure and charges) affected amplification. Because DNA bound on clay is protected against biodegradation, the ability to amplify DNA bound on clay by the PCR has palaeontological, archaeological, and anthropological implications for the detection of 'ancient' DNA, as well as for monitoring the persistence of recombinant DNA introduced to the environment in genetically modified organisms.     

An evaluation of introgression of Atlantic coast striped bass mitochondrial DNA in a Gulf of Mexico population using formalin-preserved museum collections

Striped bass Morone saxatilis populations in drainages along the Gulf of Mexico coast (Gulf) were depleted in the 1950s and 1960s, probably because of anthropogenic influences. It is believed that only the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint (A-C-F) river system continually supported a naturally reproducing population of Gulf lineage. Striped bass juveniles of Atlantic coast (Atlantic) ancestry were introduced to restore population abundances in the A-C-F from the late 1960s to the mid 1970s and in many other Gulf rivers from the 1960s to the present. We previously identified mtDNA polymorphisms that were unique to ? 60% of striped bass from the A-C-F and which confirmed the continued successful natural reproduction of striped bass of Gulf maternal ancestry within the system. However, the genetic relatedness of the extant A-C-F population to ‘pure’ Gulf striped bass was not addressed. In this study, we determined the frequency of a diagnostic mtDNA XbaI polymorphism in samples of ‘pure’ Gulf striped bass that were collected from the A-C-F prior to the introduction of Atlantic fish, that were obtained from museum collections, and that were originally preserved in formalin. PCR primers were developed that allowed for amplification of a 191-bp mtDNA fragment that contained the diagnostic XbaI restriction site. Using RFLP and direct sequence analyses of the PCR amplicons, we found no significant differences in mtDNA XbaI genotype frequencies between the archived samples and extant A-C-F samples collected over a 15-year period. This indicates that significant maternally mediated introgression of Atlantic mtDNA genomes into the A-C-F gene pool has not occurred. Additionally, we found no evidence of the unique Gulf mtDNA genotype in striped bass from extant populations in Texas, Louisiana and the Mississippi River. These results highlight the importance of the A-C-F as a repository of striped bass to restore extirpated Gulf populations and the potential use of museum collections in retrospective population studies.     

Mitochondrial DNA variation in Atlantic capelin, Mallotus villosus: a comparison of restriction and sequence analyses

Divergence estimates were calculated using restriction analysis and cytochrome-b sequences for capelin Mallotus villosus mitochondrial genomes sampled from Newfoundland and Norwegian populations. On average, pairwise divergence values based on cytochrome-b sequences were 2.7 times greater than those based on restriction data. Since the rate of evolution in the cytochrome-b gene is low, it appears that restriction analysis underestimated divergence values, possibly due to limited sensitivity of this method when variable nucleotide positions are not randomly distributed. Mitochondrial genotypes were not shared among the two populations.     

Amplification and analysis of human DNA present in mosquito bloodmeals

Abstract. DNA fingerprinting should permit the identification of individual human hosts of haematophagous arthropods, providing epidemi-ologically useful information, for example, the biting rates on different people and the impact of insecticide-impregnated bednets.
Investigations reported here demonstrate that it is possible to extract, amplify and fingerprint human DNA from the bloodmeals of individual female Anopheles gambiae mosquitoes kept at 24^oC for up to 10–15 h post-ingestion.     

An effective method for isolating DNA from historical specimens of baleen

DNA was isolated from an early twentieth century museum specimen of northern right whale baleen. A system of stringent controls and a novel set of cetacean specific primers eliminated contamination from external sources and ensured the authenticity of the results. Sequence analysis revealed that there were informative nucleotide positions between the museum specimen and extant members of the population and closely related species. The results indicate that museum specimens of baleen can be used to assess historical genetic population structure of the great whales.     

Application of N-terminally Truncated DNA Polymerase from Thermus thermophilus ({Delta}Tth Polymerase) to DNA Sequencing and Polymerase Chain Reactions: Comparative Study of {Delta}Tth and Wild-Type Tth Polymerases

N-Terminally truncated DNA polymerase from Thermus thermophilus(Tth polymerase) lacking 5'-3' exonuclease activity was usedfor DNA sequencing and polymerase chain reaction (PCR). In contrastto the high background of the sequencing ladder observed withthe wild-type Tth polymerase, Tth polymerase gave readable sequencingpatterns which extend up to more than 500 bases from the primersite on cycle sequencing and automated sequencing. The Tth polymerasewas used for the standard and mutagenic PCR, and net amplificationof the DNA and the mutations accumulated during PCR were analyzed.Under mutagenic PCR, the mutation rates were 7.0 x 10^–4(Tth) and 8.3 x 10^–4 (Tth) per nucleotide per cycle ofamplification, which were 4–9 times higher than the ratesunder standard PCR.     

Comparison of rapid methods for the extraction of bacterial DNA from colonic and caecal lumen contents of the pig

AIMS: The increasing uses of DNA methodologies to study the micro flora of the pig gastrointestinal tract requires an efficient recovery of bacterial DNA from the intestinal sample. Thus, the objective of this study was to determine which DNA extraction methods are most effective for luminal samples from pigs. Several routinely used nucleic acid extraction procedures were compared based upon quantity and purity of extracted DNA. METHODS AND RESULTS: DNA was extracted from pig colonic and caecal lumen samples using 19 methods for bacterial DNA extraction. The quantity of total DNA recovered by each extraction method was determined and compared. Two methods using extraction with polyvinylpolypyrrolidone (PVPP) or phenol and two methods involving bead mill homogenization were found to provide the greatest quantity of extracted DNA for both colonic and caecal lumen. Extracted DNA from these four methods was further analysed for purity based upon the presence of PCR inhibitors, which was ascertained by determining the efficiency of amplification of a segment of the 16S rDNA. PCR amplification could be readily achieved with DNA extracted by each of these four methods, but efficiency of amplification tended to be higher with DNA from two of the methods (one extracted with PVPP and one with bead mill homogenization). CONCLUSIONS: Four extraction methods proved to be significantly superior in quantity of DNA extracted from luminal samples. Of these four, no strong inhibitors of PCR amplification were detected in any of the extracted DNA. However, the efficiency of amplification tended to be lower in DNA samples from two of the methods, suggesting the presence of low levels of PCR inhibitors. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Results of this study provide a basis for choosing which DNA extraction procedures are most effective for use with samples of pig lumen.     

Quantification of mitochondrial DNA mutation load

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations are an important cause of genetic disease and have been proposed to play a role in the ageing process. Quantification of total mtDNA mutation load in ageing tissues is difficult as mutational events are rare in a background of wild-type molecules, and detection of individual mutated molecules is beyond the sensitivity of most sequencing based techniques. The methods currently most commonly used to document the incidence of mtDNA point mutations in ageing include post-PCR cloning, single-molecule PCR and the random mutation capture assay. The mtDNA mutation load obtained by these different techniques varies by orders of magnitude, but direct comparison of the three techniques on the same ageing human tissue has not been performed. We assess the procedures and practicalities involved in each of these three assays and discuss the results obtained by investigation of mutation loads in colonic mucosal biopsies from ten human subjects.     

Subtractive Cloning of DNA from Polymyxa graminis– an Obligate Parasitic Plasmodiophorid

A simple subtractive hybridization was applied for cloning of Polymyxa graminis deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). Total DNA preparations from concentrated P. graminis resting spores and from roots of non‐infested (healthy) barley were digested with different restriction enzymes and batch hybridized, followed by cloning in a plasmid vector. Sequencing and blast analysis of coincidentally selected clones enabled construction of polymerase chain reaction primers specific to P. graminis DNA. Four Polymyxa‐specific primers showed different affinities to DNA of type I and type II P. graminis and to DNA of P. betae.     

Mitochondrial genome of the Komodo dragon: efficient sequencing method with reptile-oriented primers and novel gene rearrangements.

The mitochondrial genome of the Komodo dragon (Varanus komodoensis) was nearly completely sequenced, except for two highly repetitive noncoding regions. An efficient sequencing method for squamate mitochondrial genomes was established by combining the long polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technology and a set of reptile-oriented primers designed for nested PCR amplifications. It was found that the mitochondrial genome had novel gene arrangements in which genes from NADH dehydrogenase subunit 6 to proline tRNA were extensively shuffled with duplicate control regions. These control regions had 99% sequence similarity over 700 bp. Although snake mitochondrial genomes are also known to possess duplicate control regions with nearly identical sequences, the location of the second control region suggested independent occurrence of the duplication on lineages leading to snakes and the Komodo dragon. Another feature of the mitochondrial genome of the Komodo dragon was the considerable number of tandem repeats, including sequences with a strong secondary structure, as a possible site for the slipped-strand mispairing in replication. These observations are consistent with hypotheses that tandem duplications via the slipped-strand mispairing may induce mitochondrial gene rearrangements and may serve to maintain similar copies of the control region.     

Evaluation of Comparative DNA Amplification Fingerprinting for Rapid Species Identification within the Genus Clusia

Understanding the taxonomiy of the tropical genus Clusia (Fam. Clusiaceae, Ord. Theales) has been hampered by the difficulties inherent in studying tropical dioecious, succulent, arborescent, epi- or hemiepiphytic taxa. Species identification by morphological traits often requires the terminal inflorescences and/or the succulent capsular fruits. To allow species differentiation based exclusively on vegetative tissue, a frequent necessity during ecological field studies, a procedure has been developed for rapid isolation of genomic DNA from Clusia leaf tissue followed by DNA amplification fingerprinting with a set of single arbitrary oligomer primers (23–27 mers). Fingerprints obtained with independent DNA preparations from one individual as well as DNA preparations from several individuals of the same species were identical for the major amplification products, although minor bands were somewhat variable. Polymorphic fingerprints have been obtained with 3 different primers for 3 Clusia species (C. minor L., C. alata Pl. & Tr., C. multiflora H. B. K.), and the related Oedematopus obovatus Spruce ex. PL (Clusiaceae). The interspecific Randomly Amplified Polymorphic Markers (RAPDs) thus obtained allow a rapid identification of vegetative tissue samples collected in the field, and will assist in a revision of the controversial taxonomy of the genus Clusia.     

Unusual mitochondrial DNA polymorphism in two local populations of blue tit Parus caeruleus

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from 25 blue tits Parus caeruleus sampled from two populations of the Grenoble region (France) was assayed for polymorphism with 17 restriction endonucleases. Nine genotypes were found. Several mtDNA genotypes were also analysed by amplification via the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and direct sequencing of 903 bp of the cytochrome b gene. The mtDNA polymorphism is greater in P. caeruleus than in other comparable bird species and results from the presence of two clearly differentiated mitochondrial lineages. Using the data of restriction polymorphism, the mean sequence divergence between individuals of the two lineages is 1.23%. Therefore, P. caeruleus should fall into the category II of phylogeographic pattern sensu Avise et al. (1987): discontinuous mtDNA genotypes which co-occur in the same region. P. caeruleus, like humans and other mobile species with high gene flow, seems to have lost its geographic structure in terms of mtDNA phylogeny. This unusual mitochondrial polymorphism can be explained by the recent admixture of two long-term isolated populations. This could be accounted for by two different scenarios. One assumes a simultaneous post-glacial colonization of the Grenoble region by two isolated European populations of P. caeruleus. Alternatively, hybridization between P. caeruleus and P. cyanus could have caused the observed pattern of mtDNA variation.     

Comparative Analysis of Mitochondrial DNA Diversity in Smelts

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify a segment of the mitochondrial DNA coding for NADH-dehydrogenase subunits ND5/ND6 in five smelt species (family Osmeridae). Amplified DNA was screened for restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP). Nucleotide sequence divergence of mitochondrial DNA between species ranges from 11.9 (between Hypomesus nipponensis and H. japonicus) to 24.7% (between Osmerus mordax dentex and Mallotus villosus catervarius). The genetic divergence between populations of H. nipponensis, H. japonicus, and Osmerus mordax dentex was 0.32, 0.08 to 0.15, and 0.025%, respectively. The absence of common haplotypes enables differentiation of closely related smelt species and, therefore, can be used for solving current problems in the taxonomy and biogeography of this family.