A mechanism of respiratory control: studies with proteoliposomes containing cytochrome oxidase and bacteriorhodopsin

Both beef heart cytochrome oxidase and bacteriorhodopsin of Halobacterium halobium were reconstituted into liposomes by the sonication-cholate dialysis method. The proteoliposomes showed the respiratory control ratio of 4.2, and steady-state illumination of the vesicles lead to the 2.7-fold stimulation of the oxidase activity in the absence of uncouplers. The light-stimulated state 4 respiration increased with light intensity, but light had no effect on the oxidase activity that had been relieved by addition of uncouplers. Proteoliposomes with the photosensitive oxidase activity were also obtained when cytochrome oxidase vesicles were fused with bacteriorhodopsin vesicles in the presence of calcium chloride, and the extent of photoactivation was maximally 1.4-fold. The light-induced respiratory release was observed even in the presence of valinomycin or nigericin, indicating that the oxidase activity was sensitive to both the membrane potential and the pH gradient. We propose as a mechanism of the respiratory control that the process of proton transport to the reaction center for water formation is the rate limiting step for the cytochrome oxidase activity.     

Cation transport in cytochrome oxidase reconstituted vesicles.

Cation translocation across the membrane of cytochrome oxidase reconstituted vesicles may be followed with a simple spectrophotometric method. Cytochrome oxidase reconstituted vesicles, supplemented with ascorbate and cytochrome c. induce large spectral changes of the positive dye safranine, reversed by uncouplers and inhibitors of respiration. The dye is probably accumulated in the inner space of the vesicles, where it reaches high concentrations and aggregates. The spectral shifts and the absorbance changes, due to aggregation, are proportional to the amount of the dye taken up and depend on the respiratory control. In the presence of potassium, valinomycin causes an inhibition, whereas nigericin stimulates the dye uptake. The data are discussed in terms of electrical potential dependent fluxes.     

Energized transport of potassium ions in the absence of valinomycin by cytochrome c oxidase-reconstituted vesicles

Valinomycin-independent energized uptake of K⁺ was observed in cytochrome c oxidase reconstituted proteoliposome. The rate of K⁺ influx was proportoinal to the magnitude of electron flux. The energized uptake of K⁺ was abolished by p-trifluoromethoxycarbonylcyanide phenylhydrazone or by nigericin. Using the safranine fluorescence technique, it was demonstrated that even in the absence of valinomycin, liposomes and proteoliposomes reconstituted with cytochrome c oxidase are able to discriminate between Na⁺ and K⁺ and show a preference for K⁺ in the presence of excess Na⁺.     

Control of proteoliposomal cytochrome c oxidase: the partial reactions

The steady-state spectroscopic behaviour and the turnover of cytochrome c oxidase incorporated into proteoliposomes have been investigated as functions of membrane potential and pH gradient. The respiration rate is almost linearly dependent on [cytochrome c2+] at high flux, but while the cytochrome a redox state is always dependent on the [cytochrome c2+] steady state, it reaches a maximum reduction level less than 100% in each case. The maximal aerobic steady-state reduction level of cytochrome a is highest in the presence of valinomycin and lowest in the presence of nigericin. The proportion of [cytochrome c2+] required to achieve 50% of maximal reduction of cytochrome a varies with the added ionophores; the apparent redox potential of cytochrome a is most positive in the fully decontrolled system (plus valinomycin and nigericin). At low levels of cytochrome a reduction, the rate of respiration is no longer a linear function of [cytochrome c2+], but is dependent upon the redox state of both cytochromes a and c. That is, proteoliposomal oxidase does not follow Smith-Conrad kinetics at low cytochrome c reduction levels, especially in the controlled states. The control of cytochrome oxidase turnover by delta pH and by delta psi can be explained either by an allosteric model or by a model with reversed electron transfer between the binuclear centre and cytochrome a. Other evidence suggests that the reversed electron transfer model may be the correct one.     

Effect of membrane potential and pH gradient on electron transfer in cytochrome oxidase

Steady-state spectra of cytochrome oxidase in phospholipid vesicles were obtained by using hexaammineruthenium(II) and ascorbate as reductants. Cytochrome a was up to 80% reduced in the steady state in coupled vesicles. Upon addition of nigericin or acetate, which decrease delta pH, resulting in an increase in delta psi, cytochrome a became more oxidized in the steady state with no change in the rate of respiration. On the other hand, uncouplers or valinomycin plus nigericin, which lower both delta psi and delta pH, stimulated respiration 2-8-fold and also lowered the steady-state level of reduction of cytochrome a. These experiments indicate that electron transfer between cytochromes a and a 3 is sensitive primarily to the pH gradient. Studies with the reconstituted and the soluble enzyme at various pH values indicated that the pH on the matrix side of the membrane, rather than delta pH, controlled the steady-state level of reduced cytochrome a. Hexaammineruthenium(II) substituted for cytochrome c in measurements of proton pumping by cytochrome oxidase. Dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, which eliminated proton pumping by cytochrome oxidase, decreased the effect of ionophores on the steady-state level of reduced cytochrome a.     

Oxidative phosphorylation and respiratory control in lysolecithin treated electron transport particles

Lysolecithin treatment of electron transport particles (ETP) generated non-vesicular fragments of membrane that can catalyze oxidative phosphorylation. Electron micrographs of ultrathin sections of lysolecithin treated ETP were devoid of circular patterns characteristic of closed vesicular structures. No synergistic uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation by valinomycin plus nigericin in the presence of K⁺ was observed in such fragments of membrane, which remained sensitive to classical uncouplers and to oligomycin. Preceding total destruction of closed vesicular structure, lysolecithin caused a drastic alteration in the membrane as evidenced by a greatly diminished effect of the ionophores in releasing respiratory control.     

Proton electrochemical gradient and phosphate potential in mitochondria

The paper reports an analysis of the relationship between deltamuH the proton electrochemical potential difference, and deltaGp, the phosphate potential. Depression of deltamuH and deltaGp has been obtained by titration with: (a) carbonylcyanide trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone; (b) nigericin (+ valinomycin); (c) KCl (+ valinomycin); and (d) rotenone. The uncoupler depresses deltamuH more than nigericin (+ valinomycin), KCl (+ valinomycin) and rotenone at equivalent deltaGp. The deltaGp/deltamuH ratio is about 3 at high values of deltamuH. When deltaGp and deltamuH are depressed by nigericin (4 valinomycin) the deltaGp/deltamuH ratio remains constant. When deltaGp and deltamuH are depressed by uncouplers, the deltaGp/deltamuH ratio increases hyperbolically tending to infinity while deltamuH tends to zero. The absence of constant proportionality between deltaGp and deltamuH indicates that the proton gradients driving ATP synthesis presumably operate within microscopic environments.     

Control of respiration in proteoliposomes containing cytochrome aa3. I. Stimulation by valinomycin and uncoupler.

1. Both valinomycin and p-trifluoromethoxy carbonyl cyanide phenylhydrazone (FCCP) are required for full release of respiration by cytochrome c oxidase-containing proteoliposomes (prepared by sonicating beef heart cytochrome aa3 in salt solution with 4 parts phosphatidylcholine, 4 parts phosphatidylethanolamine and 2 parts cardiolipin) in the presence of external ascorbate and cytochrome c. In the absence of valinomycin the response to FCCP is rather sluggish, as reported by Wrigglesworth et al. (1976) (Abstracts, 10th Int. Congr. Biochem., No. 06-6-230). 2. The Km for cytochrome c in 67 mM, pH 7.4, phosphate buffer with ascorbate as substrate, was 9 micrometer in both absence and presence of valinomycin and FCCP. Energization thus acts non-competitively towards cytochrome c oxidation. 3. The apparent Km for oxygen is greater in the energized than in the deenergized state; double reciprocal plots of respiration rate versus oxygen concentration are concave downward in the absence of uncouplers, as found with intact mitochondria. Energization thus acts "competitively" towards oxygen. 4. Despite the lack of a functional ATPase system, all the kinetic features of energization found in intact mitochondria can be mimicked in the reconstituted liposomes. This supports the chemiosmotic idea that electrical and perhaps H+ gradients modify the oxidase activity in reconstituted vesicles.     

Control of respiration in proteoliposomes containing cytochrome aa3. I. Stimulation by valinomycin and uncoupler

1. Both valinomycin and p-trifluoromethoxy carbonyl cyanide phenylhydrazone (FCCP) are required for full release of respiration by cytochrome c oxidase-containing proteoliposomes (prepared by sonicating beef heart cytochrome aa₃ in salt solution with 4 parts phosphatidylcholine, 4 parts phosphatidylethanolamine and 2 parts cardiolipin) in the presence of external ascorbate and cytochrome c. In the absence of valinomycin the response to FCCP is rather sluggish, as reported by Wrigglesworth et al. (1976) (Abstracts, 10th Int. Congr. Biochem., No. 06-6-230).2. The K_m for cytochrome c in 67 mM, pH 7.4, phosphate buffer with ascorbate as substrate, was 9 μM in both absence and presence of valinomycin and FCCP. Energization thus acts non-competitively towards cytochrome c oxidation.3. The apparent K_m for oxygen is greater in the energized than in the deenergized state; double reciprocal plots of respiration rate versus oxygen concentration are concave downward in the absence of uncouplers, as found with intact mitochondria. Energization thus acts “competitively” towards oxygen.4. Despite the lack of a functional ATPase system, all the kinetic features of energization found in intact mitochondria can be mimicked in the reconstituted liposomes. This supports the chemiosmotic idea that electrical and perhaps H⁺ gradients modify the oxidase activity in reconstituted vesicles.     

Mechanism of uncoupling by uncouples of oxidative phosphorylation

Classical uncouplers duplicate exactly the uncoupling actions of the valinomycin-nigericin ionophoric combination in presence of K⁺ — a combination that mediates cyclical transport of K⁺ driven by electron transfer or pyrophosphorolysis of ATP in mitochondria. Evidence has been presented that uncouplers have the properties essential for mediating coupled cyclical transport of cations and that uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation can be rationalized in terms of one coupled process being displaced and replaced by another. The critical demonstrations were first that uncoupling is a cation-dependent process and that only those cations that can undergo complexation with uncouplers are effective in restoring mitochondrial uncoupler action in a cation-deficient medium. The second demonstration was that uncouplers are ionophores, not only of the nigericin type but also of the valinomycin type (electrogenic). This combination in one molecule of electrogenic as well as non-electrogenic ionophoric activity for cations endows uncouplers with the capability for duplicating the uncoupling action of the valinomycin-nigericin combination and for mediating coupled cyclical transport of cations.     

Measurements of the proton motive force generated by cytochrome c oxidase from Bacillus subtilis in proteoliposomes and membrane vesicles

Cytochrome c oxidase from Bacillus subtilis was reconstituted in liposomes and its energy-transducing properties were studied. The reconstitution procedure used included Ca2+-induced fusion of pre-formed membranes. The orientation of the enzyme in liposomes is influenced by the phospholipid composition of the membrane. Negatively charged phospholipids are essential for high oxidase activity and respiratory control. Analyses of the proteoliposomes by gel filtration, density gradient centrifugation and electron microscopy indicated a heterogeneity of the proteoliposomes with respect to size and respiratory control. Cytochrome c oxidase activity in the proteoliposomes resulted in the generation of a proton motive force, internally negative and alkaline. In the presence of the electron donor, ascorbate/N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine/cytochrome c or ascorbate/phenazine methosulphate, the reconstituted enzyme generated an electrical potential of 84 mV which was increased by the addition of nigericin to 95 mV and a pH gradient of 32 mV which was increased by the addition of valinomycin to 39 mV. Similar results were obtained with beef-heart cytochrome c oxidase reconstituted in liposomes. The maximal proton motive force which could be generated, assuming no endogenous ion leakage, varied over 110-140 mV. From this the efficiency of energy transduction by cytochrome c oxidase was calculated to be 18-23%, indicating that the oxidase is an efficient proton-motive-force-generating system.     

Valinomycin binds stoichiometrically to cytochrome c oxidase and changes its structure and function

Valinomycin binds to soluble and reconstituted cytochrome c oxidase (COX) in a stoichiometric manner, as shown by a spectral shift of the oxidized gamma-band. No spectral change is found with nigericin or 18-crown-6 and in the absence of potassium ions. Titration of the proton pumping activity of reconstituted COX with valinomycin reached a maximum of H+/e- - 0.73 after addition of 1 mole of valinomycin per mole of reconstituted COX. It is concluded that K+-translocation in proton-pumping COX vesicles occurs via enzyme-bound valinomycin.     

Fusion of phospholipid vesicles reconstituted with cytochromec oxidase and mitochondrial hydrophobic protein

Summary Reconstituted cytochrome oxidase liposomes were fused with liposomes reconstituted with mitochondrial hydrophobic protein, which acts as a membrane-bound uncoupler of cytochrome oxidase. Fusion was assayed by the loss of respiratory control of cytochrome oxidase as measured by the increased rate of ascorbate oxidation induced by hydrophobic protein when both proteins shared the same vesicles. Fusion was dependent on the presence of phosphatidylserine in the liposomes and Ca⁺⁺ in the aqueous medium. Phosphatidylcholine-phosphatidylserine liposomes required higher concentrations of phosphatidylserine and Ca⁺⁺ than did phosphatidylethanolamine-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high concentrations of phosphatidylserine showed little or no respiratory control, while those with lower concentrations showed high respiratory control; respiratory control could be induced by fusing cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high phosphatidylserine with protein-free liposomes containing low phosphatidylserine concentration. If cytochrome oxidase vesicles and hydrophobic protein vesicles were prefused separately for 15 min, they lost the ability to fuse upon being subsequently mixed together. The reconstituted vesicles had diameters of about 200 Å; fusion yielded vesicles with diameters in excess of 1000 Å.     

Control of Respiration by Cytochrome c Oxidase in Intact Cells: ROLE OF THE MEMBRANE POTENTIAL*

Metabolic control analysis was applied to intact HepG2 cells. The effect on the control coefficient of cytochrome c oxidase (CcOX) over cell respiration of both the electrical (Δψ) and chemical (ΔpH) component of the mitochondrial transmembrane proton electrochemical gradient (Δμ_H⁺) was investigated. The overall O₂ consumption and specific CcOX activity of actively phosphorylating cells were titrated with cyanide under conditions in which Δψ and ΔpH were selectively modulated by addition of ionophores. In the absence of ionophores, CcOX displayed a high control coefficient (C_IV = 0.73), thus representing an important site of regulation of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation. A high control coefficient value (C_IV = 0.85) was also measured in the presence of nigericin, i.e. when Δψ is maximal, and in the presence of nigericin and valinomycin (C_IV = 0.77), when Δμ_H⁺ is abolished. In contrast, CcOX displayed a markedly lower control coefficient (C_IV = 0.30) upon addition of valinomycin, when Δψ is converted into ΔpH. These results show that Δψ is responsible for the tight control of CcOX over respiration in actively phosphorylating cells.     

The cytochrome c oxidase of Paracoccus denitrificans pumps protons in a reconstituted system

The purified two-subunit cytochrome c oxidase of Paracoccus denitrificans was reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles having a high internal buffering capacity and exhibiting a respiratory control index greater than 6.6. With these proteoliposomes, pH changes of the suspending medium were monitored in response to reductant pulses in the presence of valinomycin and potassium. When reduced cytochrome c was added to allow for a limited number of turnovers (2-12), a net acidification of the extravesicular space could be observed. This apparent proton ejection by the vesicles was abolished by inhibition of the oxidase with azide, by bypassing the oxidase with ferricyanide, or by preventing charge compensation by omitting valinomycin. Addition of uncoupler led to an alkalinization, rather than an acidification, of the extravesicular space in response to reduced cytochrome c. We thus conclude that cytochrome c oxidase of P. denitrificans is a proton pump. Under the conditions described here, an apparent stoichiometry of 0.6 proton ejected/electron was obtained by extrapolation to zero turnovers.     

Control of proteoliposomal cytochrome c oxidase: the overall reaction

The control of cytochrome c oxidase incorporated into proteoliposomes has been investigated as a function of membrane potential (delta psi) and pH gradient (delta pH). The oxidase generates a pH gradient (alkaline inside) and a membrane potential (negative inside) when respiring on external cytochrome c. Low levels of valinomycin collapse delta psi and increase delta pH; the respiration rate decreases. High levels of valinomycin, however, decrease delta pH as valinomycin can also act as a protonophore. Nigericin (in the absence of valinomycin) increases delta psi and collapses delta pH; the respiration rate increases. On a millivolt equivalent basis delta pH is a more effective inhibitor of activity than is delta psi. In the absence of any ionophores the cytochrome oxidase proteoliposomes enter a steady state, in which there are both delta pH and delta psi components of control. Present and previous data suggest that the respiration rate responds in a linear way ("ohmically") to increasing delta pH but in a nonlinear way to delta psi ("non-ohmically"). High levels of both delta psi and delta pH do not completely inhibit turnover (maximal respiratory control values lie between 6 and 10). The controlled steady state involves the electrophoretic entry and electroneutral exit of K+ from the vesicles. A model is presented in which the enzyme responds to both delta pH and delta psi components of the proton-motive force, but is more sensitive to delta pH than to delta psi at an equivalent delta mu H+. The steady state of the proteoliposome system can be represented for any set of permeabilities and enzyme activity levels using the computer simulation programme Stella.     

Reconstitution of the membrane-bound, ubiquinone-dependent pyruvate oxidase respiratory chain of Escherichia coli with the cytochrome d terminal oxidase

Pyruvate oxidase is a flavoprotein dehydrogenase located on the inner surface of the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane and coupled to the E. coli aerobic respiratory chain. In this paper, the role of quinones in the pyruvate oxidase system is investigated, and a minimal respiratory chain is described consisting of only two pure proteins plus ubiquinone 8 incorporated in phospholipid vesicles. The enzymes used in this reconstitution are the flavoprotein and the recently purified E. coli cytochrome d terminal oxidase. The catalytic velocity of the reconstituted liposome system is about 30% of that observed when the flavoprotein is reconstituted with E. coli membranes. It is also shown that electron transport from pyruvate to oxygen in the liposome system generates a transmembrane potential of at least 180 mV (negative inside), which is sensitive to the uncouplers carbonyl cyanide p-(tri-chloromethoxy)phenylhydrazone and valinomycin. A trans-membrane potential is also generated by the oxidation of ubiquinol 1 by the terminal oxidase in the absence of the flavoprotein. It is concluded that (1) the flavoprotein can directly reduce ubiquinone 8 within the phospholipid bilayer, (2) menaquinone 8 will not effectively substitute for ubiquinone 8 in this electron-transfer chain, and (3) the cytochrome d terminal oxidase functions as a ubiquinol 8 oxidase and serves as a "coupling site" in the E. coli aerobic respiratory chain. These investigations suggest a relatively simple organization for the E. coli respiratory chain.     

Independent control of respiration in cytochrome c oxidase vesicles by pH and electrical gradients

The effects of altering the pH and electrical components of the membrane potential on the visible spectra and oxygen consumption rates of cytochrome oxidase vesicles were examined during steady-state respiration using cytochrome c as the substrate. Heme a was found to be 30-55% reduced in the presence of a membrane potential, becoming more reduced when the electrical gradient (delta psi) was abolished by valinomycin and more oxidized when the pH gradient (delta pH) was abolished by nigericin, with little increase (1.2-1.8-fold) in the rates of oxygen consumption in either case. When both gradients were eliminated, heme a reduction was close to initial levels, and activity was stimulated up to 8-fold. The magnitude of the changes in heme a reduction levels upon elimination of a gradient component was shown to be positively correlated with the magnitude of the respiratory control ratio of the vesicle preparation. Kinetic analysis of the dependence of oxidase activity on cytochrome c concentration indicated that changes in the Michaelis constant of the enzyme for its substrate are not a major factor in regulation by either delta pH or delta psi. These results suggest a dual mechanism for respiratory control in cytochrome oxidase vesicles under steady-state conditions, in which the electrical gradient predominantly affects electron transfer from cytochrome c to heme a, possibly by altering the reduction potential of heme a, while the pH gradient affects electron transfer from heme a (CuA) to heme a3 (CuB), possibly by a conformationally mediated change in the reduction potential of heme a3 or in the kinetics of the electron-transfer process.     

K+-independent effects of valinomycin in photosynthetic systems

With chromatophores ofRhodospirillum rubrum, valinomycin inhibited electron transport in the presence or absence of K⁺. NH₄Cl had no effect on photophosphorylation but uncoupled with valinomycin present. ATPase activity was stimulated by NH₄Cl plus valinomycin but not by either alone. K⁺ partially reversed the inhibition of phosphorylation and the stimulation of ATPase by valinomycin plus NH₄Cl.With chloroplasts, valinomycin inhibited coupled but not basal electron transport. The inhibition was only partially reversed by uncouplers. Valinomycin stimulated the light-activated Mg²⁺-dependent ATPase similar to several uncouplers such as quinacrine, methylamine, and S-13. In addition, valinomycin inhibited delayed light emission and stimulated the H⁺/e^– ratio. These contrasting activities in chloroplasts are not easily explained.Contribution number 389 of the Charles F. Kettering Research Laboratory.     

Fusion of phospholipid vesicles reconstituted with cytochrome c oxidase and mitochondrial hydrophobic protein.

Reconstituted cytochrome oxidase liposomes were fused with liposomes reconstituted with mitochondrial hydrophobic protein, which acts as a membrane-bound uncoupler of cytochrome oxidase. Fusion was assayed by the loss of respiratory control of cytochrome oxidase as measured by the increased rate of ascorbate oxidation induced by hydrophobic protein when both proteins shared the same vesicles. Fusion was dependent on the presence of phosphatidylserine in the liposomes Ca++ in the aqueous medium. Phosphatidylcholine-phosphatidylserine liposomes required higher concentrations of phosphatidylserine and Ca++ than did phosphatidylethanolamine-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high concentrations of phosphatidylserine showed little or no respiratory control, while those with lower concentrations showed high respiratory control; respiratory control could be induced by fusing cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high phosphatidylserine with protein-free liposomes containing low phosphatidylserine concentration. If cytochrome oxidase vesicles and hydrophobic protein vesicles were prefused separately for 15 min, they lost the ability to fuse upon being subsequently mixed together. The reconstituted vesicles had diameters of about 200 A; fusion yielded vesicles with diameters in excess of 1000 A.