Flexibility and bioactivity of insulin: an NMR investigation of the solution structure and folding of an unusually flexible human insulin mutant with increased biological activity

The structure and folding of a novel human insulin mutant, [Thr(B27) --> Pro, Pro(B28) --> Thr]insulin (PT insulin), in aqueous solution and in mixtures of water and 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) have been studied by NMR spectroscopy. It was found that PT insulin has a highly flexible structure in pure water and is present in at least two different conformations, although with an overall tertiary structure similar to that of native insulin. Furthermore, the native helical structures are poorly defined. Surprisingly, the mutant has a biological activity about 50% higher than native insulin. In contrast, in TFE/water solution the mutant reveals a propensity of forming a well-defined structure at the secondary structure level, similar to monomeric native insulin. Thus, as shown by a detailed determination of the structure from 208 distance restraints and 52 torsion angle restraints by distance geometry, simulated annealing, and restrained energy minimization, the native insulin helices (A2-A7, A13-A19, and B10-B19) as well as the beta-turn (B20-B23) are formed in 35% TFE. However, the amount of tertiary structure is decreased significantly in TFE/water solution. The obtained results suggest that only an overall tertiary fold, as observed for PT insulin in pure water, is necessary for expressing the biological activity of insulin, as long as the molecule is flexible and retains the propensity to form the secondary structure required for its receptor binding. In contrast, a compact secondary structure, as found for native insulin in solution, is unnecessary for the biological activity. A model for the receptor binding of insulin is suggested that relates the increased bioactivity to the enhanced flexibility of the mutant.     

胰岛素折叠、结合与稳定性的核磁共振研究(英)

Insulin is one of the most important hormonal regulators of metabolism. Since the diabetes patients increase dramatically, the chemical properties, biological and physiological effects of insulin had been extensively studied. In last decade the development of NMR technique allowed us to determine the solution structures of insulin and its variety mutants in various conditions, so that the knowledge of folding, binding and stability of insulin in solution have been largely increased. The solution structure of insulin monomers is essentially identical to those of insulin monomers within the dimer and bexamer as determined by X-ray diffraction. The studies of insulin mutants at the putative residues for receptor binding explored the possible conformational change and fitting between insulin and its receptor. The systematical studies of disulfide paring coupled insulin folding intermediates revealed that in spite of the conformational variety of the intermediates, one structural feature is always remained: a “native-like B chain super-secondary structure“, which consists of B9-B19 helix with adjoining B23-B26 segment folded back against the central segment of B chain, an internal cystine A20-B19 disulfide bridge and a short a-helix at C-terminal of A chain linked. The “super-secondary structure“ might be the “folding nucleus“ in insulin folding mechanism. Cystine A20-B19 is the most important one among three disulfides to stabilize the nascent polypeptide in early stage of the folding. The NMR structure of C. elegans insulin-like peptide resembles that of human insulin and the peptide interacts with human insulin receptor. Other members of insulin superfamily adopt the “insulin fold“ mostly. The structural study of insulin-insulin receptor complex, that of C elegans and other invertebrate insulin-like peptide, insulin fibril study and protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) assistant proinsulin folding study will be new topics in future to get insight into folding, binding, stability, evolution and fibrillation of insulin in detail.     

A comparative circular dichroism study of relaxin and insulin

The far UV CD spectra of insulin and relaxin have been compared and shown to possess essentially similar features. Where differences occur, such as in the 222 nm band, they can be attributed to the tendency of insulin to form dimers. The ratio of the 195/206 bands is 1.54 for porcine relaxin and thus intermediate between the value of 0.79 for insulin of hystricomorphs and 2.05 for porcine insulin. Comparison of porcine relaxin with desAsn-desAla insulin suggests that the relaxin structure is similar to the structure of insulin in solution and thus compatible with the models previously constructed on the insulin coordinates.     

Physicochemical basis for the rapid time-action of LysB28ProB29-insulin: dissociation of a protein-ligand complex.

The rate-limiting step for the absorption of insulin solutions after subcutaneous injection is considered to be the dissociation of self-associated hexamers to monomers. To accelerate this absorption process, insulin analogues have been designed that possess full biological activity and yet have greatly diminished tendencies to self-associate. Sedimentation velocity and static light scattering results show that the presence of zinc and phenolic ligands (m-cresol and/or phenol) cause one such insulin analogue, LysB28ProB29-human insulin (LysPro), to associate into a hexameric complex. Most importantly, this ligand-bound hexamer retains its rapid-acting pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics. The dissociation of the stabilized hexameric analogue has been studied in vitro using static light scattering as well as in vivo using a female pig pharmacodynamic model. Retention of rapid time-action is hypothesized to be due to altered subunit packing within the hexamer. Evidence for modified monomer-monomer interactions has been observed in the X-ray crystal structure of a zinc LysPro hexamer (Ciszak E et al., 1995, Structure 3:615-622). The solution state behavior of LysPro, reported here, has been interpreted with respect to the crystal structure results. In addition, the phenolic ligand binding differences between LysPro and insulin have been compared using isothermal titrating calorimetry and visible absorption spectroscopy of cobalt-containing hexamers. These studies establish that rapid-acting insulin analogues of this type can be stabilized in solution via the formation of hexamer complexes with altered dissociation properties.     

Two-dimensional NMR studies on des-pentapeptide-insulin. Proton resonance assignments and secondary structure analysis

The shortened analogue of insulin, des-(B26-B30)-pentapeptide insulin, has been characterized by two-dimensional 1H NMR. The 1H resonance assignments and the secondary structure in water solution are discussed The results indicate that the secondary structure in solution is very similar to that reported for the crystalline state. A high flexibility of both A and B chains is observed. Of the two conformations seen in the 2-Zn insulin crystals and indicated as molecules 1 and 2 (Chinese nomenclature), the structure of the analogue is more similar to that of molecule 1.     

Three-dimensional solution structure of an insulin dimer. A study of the B9(Asp) mutant of human insulin using nuclear magnetic resonance, distance geometry and restrained molecular dynamics.

The solution structure of the B9(Asp) mutant of human insulin has been determined by two-dimensional 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Thirty structures were calculated by distance geometry from 451 interproton distance restraints based on intra-residue, sequential and long-range nuclear Overhauser enhancement data, 17 restraints on phi torsional angles obtained from 3JH alpha HN coupling constants, and the restraints from 17 hydrogen bonds, and the three disulphide bridges. The distance geometry structures were optimized using restrained molecular dynamics (RMD) and energy minimization. The average root-mean-square deviation for the best 20 RMD refined structures is 2.26 A for the backbone and 3.14 A for all atoms if the less well-defined N and C-terminal residues are excluded. The helical regions are better defined, with root-mean-square deviation values of 1.11 A for the backbone and 2.03 A for all atoms. The data analysis and the calculations show that B9(Asp) insulin, in water solution at the applied pH (1.8 to 1.9), is a well-defined dimer with no detectable difference between the two monomers. The association of the two monomers in the solution dimer is relatively loose as compared with the crystal dimer. The overall secondary and tertiary structures of the monomers in the 2Zn crystal hexamer is found to be preserved. The conformation-averaged NMR structures obtained for the monomer is close to the structure of molecule 1 in the hexamer of the 2Zn insulin crystal. However, minor, but significant deviations from this structure, as well as from the structure of monomeric insulin in solution, exist and are ascribed to the absence of the hexamer and crystal packing forces, and to the presence of monomer-monomer interactions, respectively. Thus, the monomer in the solution dimer shows a conformation similar to that of the crystal monomer in molecular regions close to the monomer-monomer interface, whereas it assumes a conformation similar to that of the solution structure of monomeric insulin in other regions, suggesting that B9(Asp) insulin adopts a monomer-like conformation when this is not inconsistent with the monomer-monomer arrangement in the dimer.     

Insulin assembly damps conformational fluctuations: Raman analysis of amide I linewidths in native states and fibrils

The crystal structure of insulin has been investigated in a variety of dimeric and hexameric assemblies. Interest in dynamics has been stimulated by conformational variability among crystal forms and evidence suggesting that the functional monomer undergoes a conformational change on receptor binding. Here, we employ Raman spectroscopy and Raman microscopy to investigate well-defined oligomeric species: monomeric and dimeric analogs in solution, native T(6) and R(6) hexamers in solution and corresponding polycrystalline samples. Remarkably, linewidths of Raman bands associated with the polypeptide backbone (amide I) exhibit progressive narrowing with successive self-assembly. Whereas dimerization damps fluctuations at an intermolecular beta-sheet, deconvolution of the amide I band indicates that formation of hexamers stabilizes both helical and non-helical elements. Although the structure of a monomer in solution resembles a crystallographic protomer, its encagement in a native assembly damps main-chain fluctuations. Further narrowing of a beta-sheet-specific amide I band is observed on reorganization of insulin in a cross-beta fibril. Enhanced flexibility of the native insulin monomer is in accord with molecular dynamics simulations. Such conformational fluctuations may initiate formation of an amyloidogenic nucleus and enable induced fit on receptor binding.     

Unraveling the symmetry ambiguity in a hexamer: Calculation of the R6 human insulin structure

Crystallographic and NMR studies of insulin have revealed a highly flexible molecule with a range of different aggregation and structural states; the importance of these states for the function of the hormone is still unclear. To address this question, we have studied the solution structure of the insulin R₆ symmetric hexamer using NMR spectroscopy. Structure determination of symmetric oligomers by NMR is complicated due to `symmetry ambiguity' between intra- and intermonomer NOEs, and between different classes of intermonomer NOEs. Hence, to date, only two symmetric tetramers and one symmetric pentamer (VTB, B subunit of verotoxin) have been solved by NMR; there has been no other symmetric hexamer or higher-order oligomer. Recently, we reported a solution structure for R₆ insulin hexamer. However, in that study, a crystal structure was used as a reference to resolve ambiguities caused by the threefold symmetry; the same method was used in solving VTB. Here, we have successfully recalculated R₆ insulin using the symmetry-ADR method, a computational strategy in which ambiguities are resolved using the NMR data alone. Thus the obtained structure is a refinement of the previous R₆ solution structure. Correlated motions in the final structural ensemble were analysed using a recently developed principal component method; this suggests the presence of two major conformational substates. The study demonstrates that the solution structure of higher-order symmetric oligomers can be determined unambiguously from NMR data alone, using the symmetry-ADR method. This success bodes well for future NMR studies of higher-order symmetric oligomers. The correlated motions observed in the structural ensemble suggest a new insight into the mechanism of phenol exchange and the T ₆ R ₆ transition of insulin in solution.     

A new B-chain mutant of insulin: comparison with the insulin crystal structure and role of sulfonate groups in the B-chain structure.

The solution structure of a new B-chain mutant of bovine insulin, in which the cysteines B7 and B19 are replaced by two serines, has been determined by circular dichroism, 2D-NMR and molecular modeling. This structure is compared with that of the oxidized B-chain of bovine insulin [Hawkins et al. (1995) Int. J. Peptide Protein Res.46, 424-433]. Circular dichroism spectroscopy showed in particular that a higher percentage of helical secondary structure for the B-chain mutant is estimated in trifluoroethanol solution in comparison with the oxidized B-chain. 2D-NMR experiments confirmed, among multiple conformations, that the B-chain mutant presents defined secondary structures such as a alpha-helix between residues B9 and B19, and a beta-turn between amino acids B20 and B23 in aqueous trifluoroethanol. The 3D structures, which are consistent with NMR data and were obtained using a simulated annealing protocol, showed that the tertiary structure of the B-chain mutant is better resolved and is more in agreement with the insulin crystal structure than the oxidized B-chain structure described by Hawkins et al. An explanation could be the presence of two sulfonate groups in the oxidized insulin B-chain. Either by their charges and/or their size, such chemical groups could play a destructuring effect and thus could favor peptide flexibility and conformational averaging. Thus, this study provides new insights on the folding of isolated B-chains.     

Crystal structure of destripeptide (B28-B30) insulin: implications for insulin dissociation

Destripeptide (B28-B30) insulin (DTRI) is an insulin analogue that has much weaker association ability than native insulin but keeps most of its biological activity. It can be crystallized from a solution containing zinc ions at near-neutral pH. Its crystal structure has been determined by molecular replacement and refined at 1.9 A resolution. DTRI in the crystal exists as a loose hexamer compared with 2Zn insulin. The hexamer only contains one zinc ion that coordinates to the B10 His residues of three monomers. Although residues B28-B30 are located in the monomer-monomer interface within a dimer, the removal of them can simultaneously weaken both the interactions between monomers within the dimer and the interactions between dimers. Because the B-chain C-terminus of insulin is very flexible, we take the DTRI hexamer as a transition state in the native insulin dissociation process and suggest a possible dissociation process of the insulin hexamer based on the DTRI structure.     

2D 1H NMR studies of monomeric insulin

In order to establish the conditions required for the observation of monomeric insulin in solution, a series of proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of insulin in a variety of solvents was undertaken. Optimal spectra were recorded in trifluoroethanol- water mixtures in a 1:2 ratio. Using the sequential assignment approach the proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of insulin was then assigned. Aspects of the structure of monomeric insulin in solution have been determined using the observed NOE cross peaks and slow exchange protons.     

Changes in secondary structure follow the dissociation of human insulin hexamers: a circular dichroism study

Vacuum UV circular dichroism spectra measured down to 178 nm for hexameric 2-zinc human insulin, zinc-free human insulin, and the two engineered and biologically active monomeric mutants, [B/S9D] and [B/S9D,T27E] human insulin, show significant differences. The secondary structure analysis of the 2-zinc human insulin (T6) in neutral solution was determined: 57% helix, 1% beta-strand, 18% turn, and 24% random coil. This is very close to the corresponding crystal structure showing that the solution and solid structures are similar. The secondary structure of the monomer shows a 10-15% increase in antiparallel beta-structure and a corresponding reduction in random coil structure. These structural changes are consistent with an independent analysis of the corresponding difference spectra. The advantage of secondary structure analyses of difference spectra is that the contribution of odd spectral features stemming mainly from side chain chromophores is minimized and the sensitivity of the analyses improved. Analysis of the CD spectra of T6 2-zinc, zinc-free human insulin and monomeric mutant insulin by singular value decomposition indicates that the secondary structure changes following the dissociation of hexamers into dimers and monomers are two-state processes.     

The relation of conformation and association of insulin to receptor binding; x-ray and circular-dichroism studies on bovine and hystricomorph insulins.

Crystal and solution structure studies on insulins of different sequences and of widely different receptor binding affinities are reported. Bovine insulin, studied as a control, has a circular dichroism spectrum which is dependent both on protein concentration and zinc concentration. The spectrum appears to be related to the level of association of the insulin molecules. This implies that when using circular dichroism to compare solution structures of insulin derivatives or species variants one must make the comparison at equivalent levels of association and not merely at the same concentration. Changes in circular dichroism are related to the known crystal structure of zinc insulin hexamers. The chinchilla insulin spectrum shows a reduced zinc dependence in low-salt conditions which correlates with the inability to form crystals in similar conditions. This is attributed to an amino acid substitution at position B4. Crystals are obtained in high-salt conditions and X-ray diffraction patterns show these to be isomorphous with bovine 4Zn insulin crystals. Guinea pig insulin failed to crystallise under conditions which are normally conducive to the formation of crystals of zinc insulin hexamers and the circular dichroism showed no zinc dependence. This is consistent with a monomeric structure. The significance of the association behaviour of chinchilla and guinea pig insulins may be in the storage of the hormone in vivo. Whereas the monomeric form of chinchilla insulin has a structure closely related to bovine insulin, the circular dichroism indicates a gross structural difference for guinea pig insulin. This may be similar to that in des-A21, des-B30-insulin, as both lack the Arg-B22--Asn-A21 carboxylate ion pair. The similarity of structure of chinchilla and bovine insulins is reflected in their receptor binding whereas the low receptor binding of guinea pig insulin probably results from the changes in its conformation rather than an alteration in residues of a receptor binding region.     

Formation of insulin amyloid fibrils followed by FTIR simultaneously with CD and electron microscopy

Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), circular dichroism (CD), and electron microscopy (EM) have been used simultaneously to follow the temperature-induced formation of amyloid fibrils by bovine insulin at acidic pH. The FTIR and CD data confirm that, before heating, insulin molecules in solution at pH 2.3 have a predominantly native-like alpha-helical structure. On heating to 70 degrees C, partial unfolding occurs and results initially in aggregates that are shown by CD and FT-IR spectra to retain a predominantly helical structure. Following this step, changes in the CD and FTIR spectra occur that are indicative of the extensive conversion of the molecular conformation from alpha-helical to beta-sheet structure. At later stages, EM shows the development of fibrils with well-defined repetitive morphologies including structures with a periodic helical twist of approximately 450 A. The results indicate that formation of fibrils by insulin requires substantial unfolding of the native protein, and that the most highly ordered structures result from a slow evolution of the morphology of the initially formed fibrillar species.     

Characterization of the oligomeric states of insulin in self-assembly and amyloid fibril formation by mass spectrometry

The self-assembly and aggregation of insulin molecules has been investigated by means of nanoflow electrospray mass spectrometry. Hexamers of insulin containing predominantly two, but up to four, Zn(2+) ions were observed in the gas phase when solutions at pH 4.0 were examined. At pH 3.3, in the absence of Zn(2+), dimers and tetramers are observed. Spectra obtained from solutions of insulin at millimolar concentrations at pH 2.0, conditions under which insulin is known to aggregate in solution, showed signals from a range of higher oligomers. Clusters containing up to 12 molecules could be detected in the gas phase. Hydrogen exchange measurements show that in solution these higher oligomers are in rapid equilibrium with monomeric insulin. At elevated temperatures, under conditions where insulin rapidly forms amyloid fibrils, the concentration of soluble higher oligomers was found to decrease with time yielding insoluble high molecular weight aggregates and then fibrils. The fibrils formed were examined by electron microscopy and the results show that the amorphous aggregates formed initially are converted to twisted, unbranched fibrils containing several protofilaments. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy shows that both the soluble form of insulin and the initial aggregates are predominantly helical, but that formation of beta-sheet structure occurs simultaneously with the appearance of well-defined fibrils.     

The solution structure of a monomeric insulin. A two-dimensional 1H-NMR study of des-(B26-B30)-insulin in combination with distance geometry and restrained molecular dynamics.

The solution conformation of des-(B26-B30)-insulin (DPI) has been investigated by 1H-NMR spectroscopy. A set of 250 approximate interproton distance restraints, derived from two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectra, were used as the basis of a structure determination using distance geometry (DG) and distance-bound driven dynamics (DDD). Sixteen DG structures were optimized using energy minimization (EM) and submitted to short 5-ps restrained molecular dynamics (RMD) simulations. A further refinement of the DDD structure with the lowest distance errors was done by energy minimization, a prolonged RMD simulation in vacuo and a time-averaged RMD simulation. An average structure was obtained from a trajectory generated during 20-ps RMD. The final structure was compared with the des-(B26-B30)-insulin crystal structure refined by molecular dynamics and the 2-Zn crystal structure of porcine insulin. This comparison shows that the overall structure of des-(B26-B30)-insulin is retained in solution with respect to the crystal structures with a high flexibility at the N-terminal part of the A chain and at the N-terminal and C-terminal parts of the B chain. In the RMD run a high mobility of Gly A1, Asn A21 and of the side chain of Phe B25 is noticed. One of the conformations adopted by des-(B26-B30)-insulin in solution is similar to that of molecule 1 (Chinese nomenclature) in the crystal structure of porcine insulin.     

The self-association of zinc-free bovine insulin. A single model based on interactions in the crystal that describes the association pattern in solution at pH 2, 7 and 10

Sedimentation equilibrium studies are used to establish that a new pattern for the self-association of zinc-free insulin in solution is applicable over a wide range of conditions of pH, ionic strength and temperature. In this pattern, which is based on information from the existing literature on the X-ray crystal structure of insulin, the insulin monomer is viewed as having two distinct faces both capable of self-interaction. Sedimentation equilibrium experiments were analysed using expressions formulated for this association pattern that describe the dependence of weight average molecular weight and monomer concentration on total protein concentration. It has thereby been possible to obtain values for the two association constants which govern the system for each set of conditions studied, due allowance having been made for composition dependent non-ideality effects. Furthermore, by relating the pH, temperature and ionic strength dependence of the association constants with properties of various amino acid residues on the surface of the insulin monomer, it has also been possible to assign tentatively each constant to a particular reaction domain.     

Comparative 2D NMR studies of human insulin and des-pentapeptide insulin: sequential resonance assignment and implications for protein dynamics and receptor recognition

The solution structure and dynamics of human insulin are investigated by 2D 1H NMR spectroscopy in reference to a previously analyzed analogue, des-pentapeptide(B26-B30) insulin (DPI; Hua, Q.X., & Weiss, M.A. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 10545-10555). This spectroscopic comparison is of interest since (i) the structure of the C-terminal region of the B-chain has not been determined in the monomeric state and (ii) the role of this region in binding to the insulin receptor has been the subject of long-standing speculation. The present NMR studies are conducted in the presence of an organic cosolvent (20% acetic acid), under which conditions both proteins are monomeric and stably folded. Complete sequential assignment of human insulin is obtained and leads to the following conclusions. (1) The secondary structure of the insulin monomer (three alpha-helices and B-chain beta-turn) is similar to that observed in the 2-Zn crystal state. (2) The folding of DPI is essentially the same as the corresponding portion of intact insulin, in accord with the similarities between their respective crystal structures. However, differences between insulin and DPI are observed in the extent of conformational broadening of amide resonances, indicating that the presence or absence of residues B26-B30 influences the overall dynamics of the protein on the millisecond time scale. (3) Residues B24-B28 adopt an extended configuration in the monomer and pack against the hydrophobic core as in crystallographic dimers; residues B29 and B30 are largely disordered. This configuration differs from that described in a more organic milieu (35% acetonitrile; Kline, A.D., & Justice, R.M., Jr. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 2906-2913), suggesting that the conformation of insulin in the latter study may have been influenced by solvent composition. (4) The insulin fold is shown to provide a model for collective motions in a protein with implications for the mechanism of protein-protein recognition. To our knowledge, this paper describes the first detailed analysis of a protein NMR spectrum under conditions of extensive conformational broadening. Such an analysis is made possible in the present case by comparative study of an analogue (DPI) with more tractable spectroscopic properties.     

X-ray analysis of the single chain B29-A1 peptide-linked insulin molecule. A completely inactive analogue.

A crystal structure of a totally inactive insulin molecule has been determined. For this insulin molecule, the first without detectable activity to be characterized, the A and B-chains are linked by a peptide bond between A1 Gly and B29 Lys. The molecule has retained all its normal self-association properties and it can also accommodate the two different conformations designated T and R, as seen in 4Zn native pig insulin crystals. The hexamers of the crosslinked insulin molecule were crystallized using the 4Zn insulin recipe of Schlichtkrull. The structure has been crystallographically refined with data extending to 2 A using restrained least-square methods. Comparison of the B29-A1 peptide crosslink insulin and the 4Zn native insulin reveals close structural similarities with the native dimer. The analysis of the structure confirms the earlier hypothesis that insulin structures in crystals are not in an active conformation and that a separation of N-terminal A-chain and C-terminal B-chain is required for interaction with the insulin receptor.     

Insulin and its receptor: structure, function and evolution

I present here a personal perspective on more than three decades of research into the structural biology of the insulin-receptor interaction. The solution of the three-dimensional structure of insulin in 1969 provided a detailed understanding of the insulin surfaces involved in self-assembly. In subsequent years, hundreds of insulin analogues were prepared by insulin chemists and molecular biologists, with the goal of relating the structure to the biological function of the molecule. The design of methods for direct receptor-binding studies in the 1970s, and the cloning of the receptor in the mid 1980s, provided the required tools for detailed structure-function studies. In the absence of a full three-dimensional structure of the insulin-receptor complex, I attempt to assemble the existing pieces of the puzzle generated by our and other laboratories, in order to generate a plausible mechanistic model of the insulin-receptor interaction that explains its kinetics and negative cooperativity.