Spermatogenesis and germ cell transgene expression in xenografted bovine testicular tissue

The present study was conducted to evaluate the development of spermatogenesis and utility of using electroporation to stably transfect germ cells with the beta-galactosidase gene in neonatal bovine testicular tissue ectopically xenografted onto the backs of recipient nude mice. Bull testicular tissue from 4-wk donor calves, which contains a germ cell population consisting solely of gonocytes or undifferentiated spermatogonia, was grafted onto the backs of castrated adult recipient nude mice. Testicular grafts significantly increased in weight throughout the grafting period and the timing of germ cell differentiation in grafted tissue was consistent with postnatal testis development in vivo relative to the bull. Seminiferous tubule diameter also significantly increased with advancing time after grafting. At 1 wk after grafting, gonocytes in the seminiferous cords completed migration to the basement membrane and differentiated germ cell types could be observed 24 wk after grafting. The presence of elongating spermatids at 24 wk confirmed that germ cell differentiation occurred in the bovine tissue. Leydig cells in the grafted bovine tissue were also capable of producing testosterone in the castrated recipient mice from 4 wk to 24 wk after grafting at concentrations that were similar to levels in intact, nongrafted control mice. The testicular tissue that had been electroporated with a beta-galactosidase expression vector showed tubule-specific transgene expression 24 wk after grafting. Histological analysis showed that transgene expression was present in both Sertoli and differentiated germ cells but not in interstitial cells. The system reported here has the potential to be used for generation of transgenic bovine spermatozoa.     

Gonocyte development in rats: proliferation, distribution and death revisited

Spermatogonial stem cells are responsible for the constant production of spermatozoa. These cells differentiate from the gonocytes, but little is known about these cells and their differentiation into spermatogonia. This study analyzed rat gonocyte proliferation, death and distribution as well as their differentiation into spermatogonia. Rat testes were collected at 19 dpc and at 1, 3, 5, 8, 11 and 15 dpp and submitted to apoptosis investigation through morphological analysis and TUNEL, p53 and cleaved caspase 3 labeling. Ki67 and MVH labeling was used to check gonocyte proliferation and quantification, respectively. OCT4 and DBA labeling were used to check gonocyte differentiation. Seminiferous cord length and gonocyte numerical density were measured to check gonocyte distribution along the seminiferous cords. Although a reduction of gonocyte number per testicular section has been observed from 1 to 5 dpp, the total number of these cells did not change. Apoptotic gonocytes were not detected at these ages, suggesting that the reduction in gonocyte number per testicular section was due to their redistribution along the seminiferous cords, which showed continuous growth from 19 dpc to 5 dpp. The first proliferating germ cells were observed at 8 dpp, coinciding with OCT4 upregulation and with the emergence of the first spermatogonia. In conclusion, this study suggests that (a) gonocytes do not die in the first week after birth, but are rather redistributed along the seminiferous cords just before their differentiation into spermatogonia; (b) mitosis resumption and the emergence of the first spermatogonia are coincident with OCT4 upregulation.     

Conserved and divergent patterns of expression of DAZL,VASA and OCT4 in the germ cells of the human fetal ovary and testis

Background  

Germ cells arise from a small group of cells that express markers of pluripotency including OCT4. In humans formation of gonadal compartments (cords in testis, nests in ovary) takes place during the 1st trimester (6–8 weeks gestation). In the 2nd trimester germ cells can enter meiotic prophase in females whereas in males this does not occur until puberty. We have used qRTPCR, Westerns and immunohistochemical profiling to determine which of the germ cell subtypes in the human fetal gonads express OCT4, DAZL and VASA, as these have been shown to play an essential role in germ cell maturation in mice.     

Ultrastructure des cellules de Sertoli humaines aux stades embryonnaires précoces de la différenciation gonadique

The morphofunctional development of Sertoli cells defines the testicular differentiation. These somatic cells are mostly of mesonephric origin and can be first recognized in 7 week-old embryos altogether with the formation of testicular cords. The latter organize as primordial germ cells surrounded by pre-Sertoli cells. Due to the great synthetic activity of pre-Sertoli cells the rough endoplasmic reticulum develops. The basal lamina of the cords becomes distinguishable at 7 to 8 weeks of development. Either prespermatogonia and pre-Sertoli cells actively proliferate but the latter greatly outnumber prespermatogonia. Many interdigitations and cytoplasmic processes are observed between neighboring pre-Sertoli cells. Due to the proliferative activity a sort of compartmentalization is established inside the cords in which pre-Sertoli cells tend to localize closer to the basal membrane embracing the prespermatogonia with long and thin cytoplasmic processes. One of the main features typical of differentiating pre-Sertoli cells is the irregular nucleus and the prominent nucleolus. When the embryo is 14 to 20 weeks-old the most significative change is the maximum development of the Leydig cells. Testicular cords do not show lumen at all, so they cannot be termed “tubules”     

Cytological characterization of the germinal line during testicular differentiation in the lizard Liolaemus gravenhorsti (gray)

The gross morphology, histology, and ultrastructure of Liolaemus gravenhorsti gonads prior to and after differntiation are described. Special emphasis has been given to characterization and changes of the germ cell line throughout intrauterine development and 3 days postpartum. During the pregonadal stage, the primordial germ cell migrates toward gonadal rudiments by way of the mesenchyme. These cells can easily be identified by their great size, voluminous and lobulated nucleus, great quantities of yolk platelets, microtubules, and numerous lipid inclusions. In the undifferentiated gonad, the germ cells (type 1 gonocytes) have an ovoid or spherical shape and autodigestion of yolk platelets, great development of Golgi complex, and mitochondrial aggregation, though fewer liposomes, pseudopodes, and microtubules were noted. Concomitantly with the beginning of mitosis, a third type of germ cell appears, the type 2 gonocytes, which are smaller, with poorly defined membranous systems in various degrees of involution. The seminiferous cords are organized when somatic cells of the medullar portion of the gonad surround type 1 gonocytes. Germinal cells are centrally localized in the cords. Near birth many gonocytes migrate toward the basal lamina of cords and differentiate into spherical prespermatogonia, with few organoids. Sertoli cells eparate them from the basal lamina. In advanced pregnancy, Leyding cells become numerous with morphology typical of androgen-producing cells.     

The ADAM-integrin-tetraspanin complex in fetal and postnatal testicular cords

New insights have emerged about the expression, during testicular cord formation, of the ADAM (a disintegrin and metalloprotease) domain family of proteins that combines both cell surface adhesion and proteolytic activity; this family includes integrins alpha3beta1 and alpha6beta1 and tetraspanins, a distinct family of proteins containing four transmembrane domains, a small and a large extracellular loop, and short cytoplasmic tails. ADAM3 (cyritestin), ADAM5, ADAM6, and ADAM15 are expressed in fetal rat testes. In contrast, the expression of the ADAM1/ADAM2 pair (fertilin alpha/fertilin beta, respectively) is not detected in fetal testis. Yet the expression of ADAM1 starts immediately after birth, and is followed within 24 hr by the expression of ADAM2. Therefore, the ADAM1/ADAM2 heterodimer is visualized far in advance of the meiotic and spermiogenic phase of spermatogenesis. A similar expression pattern was observed for integrin subunits alpha3, alpha6, and beta1, as well as for tetraspanins CD9, CD81, and CD98; the latter is a single-pass integrin subunit beta1-binding protein. ADAM2, integrin subunits alpha3, alpha6, and beta1, and tetraspanin CD9 and CD81 immunoreactive sites are observed in prespermatogonia (also known as primordial germ cells or gonocytes). A model is proposed in which the ADAM-integrin-tetraspanin complex, known to constitute a network of membrane microdomains called the tetraspanin web, may be involved in the migration of prespermatogonia from the center to the periphery of the testicular cords and in the reinitiation of mitotic activity during the initial wave of spermatogenesis. A complementary model consists in the rearrangement of the tetraspanin web in prespermatogonia/spermatogonia undergoing spontaneous or Fas-induced apoptosis upon coculturing with Sertoli cells. In this model, the cellular site involved in the formation of preapoptotic bodies is devoid of tetraspanin-integrin clusters, in contrast with nonapoptotic cells, which display a diffuse circumferential distribution. In apoptotic prespermatogonia, immunoreactive clusters are restricted to sites where the attachment of prespermatogonia/spermatogonia to Sertoli cell surfaces is still preserved.     

Influence of adenosine 3':5'-cyclic monophosphate analogues on testicular organization of fetal mouse gonads in vitro

Gonadal primordia, isolated from fetal mice on the 11th or 12th day of gestation, differentiated in vitro into morphologically distinct testes or ovaries after 7 days in culture. The addition of cAMP analogues into culture media prevented the differentiation of testis cords. Histological examination indicated that the basement membranes of testis cords disintegrated after treatment with cAMP analogues, while development of germ cells and Leydig cells appeared to be unaffected. Fetal testes in culture secreted testosterone which increased following addition of dibutyryl-cAMP (Bt2 c-AMP). Primordial germ cells reached prespermatogonial stage in the presence or absence of Bt2 cAMP, suggesting that progressive differentiation of primordial germ cells is independent of testis cord organization. The Bt2 cAMP-treated explants resumed testicular development after transplantation into a site beneath the kidney capsules of adult mice, although the inhibitory effect appeared irreversible in vitro. The testicular organization-preventing effect of cAMP analogues was mimicked by prostaglandins or forskolin, which are known to stimulate adenylate cyclase. The inhibitory effect of either cAMP analogues or prostaglandins was potentiated when added in combination with phosphodiesterase inhibitors. The present results suggest that increase of intracellular cAMP prevents the development of basement membrane and the assembly of cells to form testicular structures.     

Regulation of the proliferation of cocultured gonocytes and Sertoli cells by retinoids,triiodothyronine, and intracellular signaling factors: differences between fetal and neonatal cells

The regulation of early fetal germ cell growth has not been studied in cell culture, probably due to the poor survival of these cells. However, cell culture is the only system in which the control of cell growth can be studied independently of the influence of secreted testicular factors, which are diluted in the medium. We successfully cultured dispersed testicular cells from 16.5-day-old rat fetuses in defined medium and compared the growth of these cells with that of cells from 3-day-old neonates. In this system, fetal gonocytes displayed low levels of mitotic activity and their numbers remained stable. In contrast, neonatal gonocytes displayed high levels of mitotic activity and increased in number, these characteristics resembling those observed in vivo. We found that retinoic acid had deleterious effects on the number of gonocytes but did not affect Sertoli cell proliferation in fetal and neonatal cell cultures. Moreover, in fetal cell cultures, the decrease in the number of gonocytes resulted from a decrease in mitotic activity, probably due to a direct effect of retinoids on fetal gonocytes. Among the selective agonists for the retinoic acid receptor (RARalpha agonist, RARbeta agonist, and RARgamma agonist) and the retinoic X receptor (pan-RXR agonist) tested, only the RARalpha agonist reproduced the effects of retinoic acid at concentrations lower than its Kd value in both fetal and neonatal cell cultures. As both RARalpha and RXRalpha are present in fetal and neonatal gonocytes, we suggest that retinoic acid exerts its effects on gonocytes via a RARalpha-RXRalpha heterodimer, with RARalpha functioning as an active partner and RXRalpha as a passive partner. In this culture system, we show for the first time that triiodothyronine (T3) inhibits testicular fetal Sertoli cell and germ cell growth. We also tested intracellular signaling factors and found that a cAMP analog increased Sertoli cell proliferation and germ cell survival in both fetal and neonatal cells whereas phorbol esters (PMA) strongly inhibited the proliferation of fetal but not of neonatal gonocytes. None of the tested factors (T3, dbcAMP, and PMA) seemed to interact with the all-trans retinoic acid pathway. Thus, fetal gonocytes and neonatal gonocytes differ in intrinsic properties, and their growth is not regulated in the same manner. Despite their low level of mitotic activity, fetal gonocytes were more sensitive to various factors than neonatal gonocytes.     

Induction of meiosis in fetal mouse testis in vitro

Fetal mouse testes and ovaries with their urogenital connections were cultured singly or in pairs on Nuclepore filters. When a testis in which the sex was not yet morphologically detectable was cultured together with older ovaries containing germ cells which were progressing through the meiotic prophase, the male germ cells were triggered to enter meiosis. When older fetal testes in which the testicular cords have developed were cultured together with ovaries of the same age with germ cells in meiosis, the oocytes were prevented from reaching diplotene stage. It was concluded that the fetal male and female gonads secrete diffusable substances which influence germ cell differentiation. The male gonad secretes a "meiosis-preventing substance" (MPS) which can arrest the female germ cells within the meiotic prophase. The female gonad secretes a "meiosis-inducing substance" (MIS) which can trigger the nondifferentiated male germ cells to enter meiosis.     

Influence of age and medium on formation of epithelial cords in the rat fetal ovary in vitro

Fetal ovaries of 14.5-day-old rats were cultured for periods of up to 19 days in control medium or in medium conditioned by the preliminary culture of testes from fetal or young rats. In all ovaries, after 12 days of culture in either medium, epithelial cords were noted having an aspect identical to that of seminiferous cords present in fetal testes explanted at 14.5 days and also cultured for 12 days, i.e. the epithelial cords appeared in ovaries when there was no 'male' or testicular influence. The appearance of histological preparations suggested that the disappearance of the germ cells might bring about a reorganization of the follicular cells in epithelial cords during the differentiation period of the first follicles. With ovaries cultured in conditioned medium, degeneration of the germ cells was more marked, follicles were rare and intra-ovarian cords were greater in number than in ovaries cultured in control medium. The ovaries thus transformed produced the anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) although they lacked the "germinostatic activity" normally developed by testes of fetal or young rats. This germinostatic activity prevents the multiplication of oogonia when the testes and ovaries are co-cultured in vitro. The transformed ovaries therefore do not have all the functional capacities of fetal testes.     

Delay of testicular differentiation in the B6.YDOM ovotestis demonstrated by immunocytochemical staining for müllerian inhibiting substance.

It has been found that when the Y chromosome from Mus musculus domesticus (YDOM) is placed onto the C57BL/6J (B6) mouse background, the XY progeny (B6.YDOM) develop ovaries or ovotestes but not normal testes during fetal life. We examined the ontogeny of the abnormal testicular differentiation in the B6.YDOM ovotestis by immunocytochemical staining for Müllerian inhibiting substance (MIS). We found that the B6.YDOM ovotestis initiated testicular differentiation later in development than did the control B6 testis. When the YDOM was transferred onto the SJL J mouse background by crossing B6.YDOM males with SJL/J females, all XY progeny developed normal testes. The onset of testicular differentiation was at the same developmental stage as in the B6 male fetus. These results suggest that the delay of testicular differentiation is not due to the effect of the YDOM chromosome itself, but due to improper interaction of the testis-determining gene on the YDOM chromosome with autosomal genes of B6. In addition, we found a close correlation between the arrest of germ cells at the prespermatogonia stage and MIS production of adjacent somatic cells in the B6.YDOM ovotestis. This result may support the hypothesis that MIS is involved in the regulation of germ cell differentiation.     

Effect of ethinyl estradiol on the differentiation of mouse fetal testis

In an evaluation of the effect of ethinyl estradiol (EE) on the differentiation of fetal mouse testes, the ratio of the seminiferous tubular region to the testicular tissue region, the ratio of Sertoli cells to gonocytes in tubule cross sections, and the size of Leydig cells were determined by the Texture Analyse System (T.A.S., Leitz) in histological preparations of the testes. The testes were those of fetuses taken from dams given orally 0, 0.02, 0.2 or 2.0 mg/kg of body weight of EE in olive oil from day 11 through day 17 of gestation and killed at term. From experimental and the control testes, five sections were taken at 40-micron intervals. The areas of the seminiferous tubular region and the testicular region were determined and the Sertoli cells and gonocytes in tubule cross section were counted in each of the five sections. The diameters of 100 Leydig cells selected at random were averaged. These data were analyzed by Student's t test. The seminiferous tubular region was significantly increased in the testes treated with 0.02 mg/kg of EE and significantly decreased in those treated with 0.2 mg/kg of EE. The number of gonocytes per tubule cross section was significantly increased in the testes treated with 0.02 or 2.0 mg/kg of EE. The number of Sertoli cells per tubule cross section and the number of Sertoli cells per gonocyte were significantly decreased in the experimental testes. The size of the Leydig cells was significantly decreased in the testes treated with 0.2 mg/kg of EE. These findings suggest that prenatal exposure to EE before testicular differentiation affects tubular formation, the proliferation of fetal Sertoli cells, and Leydig cell differentiation, resulting in disturbances of spermatogenesis.     

Germ cell deficiency causes testis cord differentiation in reconstituted mouse fetal ovaries

Sex-reversal in fetal ovaries was studied by using a dissociation-reconstitution technique. Gonads of 12.5 gestation-day male and female mouse fetuses were dissociated into single cells. To eliminate germ cells, the dissociated cells were cultured for 14 h, and then somatic cells attached to culture dishes were harvested and aggregated by gyratory culture for 24 h. The aggregates were then transplanted into ovarian bursa in ovary-ectomized nude mice. The recovered explants were examined histologically. Male somatic cells developed into testes containing Sertoli cells, Leidig cells, and tunica albuginea. Female somatic cells formed testis cords and differentiated into Sertoli cells, but they did not differentiate into other testis components or ovarian tissues. However, aggregates consisting of both female and male somatic cells differentiated into well-developed testes containing Leidig cells and tunica albuginea as well as Sertoli cells. Enzyme marker analysis showed significant contributions of female cells in these organized testes. In contrast, aggregates containing both female germ cells and somatic cells developed into ovaries and did not differentiate into any testicular tissues. The results indicate that female somatic cells in fetal gonads at 12.5 gestation day have the potency to form testis cords and differentiate into Sertoli cells. The subsequent steps in testis development require the contributions of male cells. The present study also suggests that testicular differentiation is independent of germ cells but ovarian development involves the interaction between germ cells and somatic cells.     

A unique combination of male germ cell miRNAs coordinates gonocyte differentiation

The last 100 years have seen a concerning decline in male reproductive health associated with decreased sperm production, sperm function and male fertility. Concomitantly, the incidence of defects in reproductive development, such as undescended testes, hypospadias and testicular cancer has increased. Indeed testicular cancer is now recognised as the most common malignancy in young men. Such cancers develop from the pre-invasive lesion Carcinoma in Situ (CIS), a dysfunctional precursor germ cell or gonocyte which has failed to successfully differentiate into a spermatogonium. It is therefore essential to understand the cellular transition from gonocytes to spermatogonia, in order to gain a better understanding of the aetiology of testicular germ cell tumours. MicroRNA (miRNA) are important regulators of gene expression in differentiation and development and thus highly likely to play a role in the differentiation of gonocytes. In this study we have examined the miRNA profiles of highly enriched populations of gonocytes and spermatogonia, using microarray technology. We identified seven differentially expressed miRNAs between gonocytes and spermatogonia (down-regulated: miR-293, 291a-5p, 290-5p and 294*, up-regulated: miR-136, 743a and 463*). Target prediction software identified many potential targets of several differentially expressed miRNA implicated in germ cell development, including members of the PTEN, and Wnt signalling pathways. These targets converge on the key downstream cell cycle regulator Cyclin D1, indicating that a unique combination of male germ cell miRNAs coordinate the differentiation and maintenance of pluripotency in germ cells.     

The role of p63 in germ cell apoptosis in the developing testis

The fetal and neonatal development of male germ cells (gonocytes) is a poorly understood but crucial process for establishing fertility. In rodents, gonocytes go through two phases of proliferation accompanied by apoptosis and separated by a quiescent period during the end of fetal development. P63 is a member of the P53 gene family that yields six isoforms. We detected only the p63 protein and no p53 and p73 in the nucleus of the gonocytes of mouse testes. We report for the first time the ontogeny of each p63 mRNA isoform during testis development. We observed a strong expression of p63gamma mRNA and protein when gonocytes are in the quiescent period. In vitro treatment with retinoic acid prevented gonocytes from entering the quiescent period and was correlated with a reduced production of p63gamma isoform mRNA. We investigated the function of p63 by studying the testicular phenotype of P63-null mice. P63 invalidation slightly, but significantly increased the number of gonocytes counted during the quiescent period. As P63-null animals die at birth we used an original organ culture that mimicked neonatal in vivo development to study further the testicular development. P63 invalidation resulted in a sharply increased number of gonocytes during the culture period due to a decrease in spontaneous apoptosis with no change in proliferation. P63 invalidation also caused abnormal morphologies in the germ cells that were also found in P63(+/-) adult male mice. Thus, p63 appears as an important regulator of germ cell development.     

Differentiation of murine premigratory primordial germ cells in culture.

In the mouse embryo, primordial germ cells first appear in the extraembryonic mesoderm and divide rapidly while migrating to the fetal gonad. Shortly after their arrival in the gonad, germ cells sexually differentiate as proliferation ceases. Previous studies have established that primordial germ cells proliferate and migrate in feeder layer culture. To explore cellular regulation of fetal germ cell development, we have used germ cell nuclear antigen 1 (GCNA1), a marker normally expressed only in postmigratory germ cells, to investigate the developmental potency of both pre- and postmigratory cells in this culture system. We found that explanted premigratory germ cells will initiate expression of this marker and are, therefore, capable of undertaking some aspects of gonocyte differentiation without intimate exposure to the fetal gonad. We have also tested whether postmigratory gonocytes are stable in culture. As detected by either alkaline phosphatase or GCNA1, we did not detect long-term survival of either prospermatogonia or oogonia under conditions that support the survival, proliferation, and differentiation of earlier premigratory cells. These observations are consistent with an autonomous cellular mechanism governing the initial stages of gonocyte differentiation, and suggest that differentiation towards gonocytes is accompanied by a change in requirements for cell survival.     

Identification and characterization of stem cells in prepubertal spermatogenesis in mice

The stem cell properties of gonocytes and prospermatogonia at prepubertal stages are still largely unknown: it is not clear whether gonocytes and prospermatogonia are a special cell type or similar to adult undifferentiated spermatogonia. To characterize these cells, we have established transgenic mice carrying EGFP (enhanced green fluorescence protein) cDNA under control of an Oct4 18-kb genomic fragment containing the minimal promoter and proximal and distal enhancers; Oct4 is reported to be expressed in undifferentiated spermatogonia at prepubertal stages. Generation of transgenic mice enabled us to purify gonocytes and prospermatogonia from the somatic cells of the testis. Transplantation studies of testicular cells so far have been done with a mixture of germ cells and somatic cells. This is the first report that establishes how to purify germ cells from total testicular cells, enabling evaluation of cell-autonomous repopulating activity of a subpopulation of prospermatogonia. We show that prospermatogonia differ markedly from adult spermatogonia in both the size of the KIT-negative population and cell cycle characteristics. The GFP(+) KIT(-) fraction of prospermatogonia has much higher repopulating activity than does the GFP(+)KIT(+) population in the adult environment. Interestingly, the GFP(+)KIT(+) population still exhibits repopulating activity, unlike adult KIT-positive spermatogonia. We also show that ALCAM, activated leukocyte cell adhesion molecule, is expressed transiently in gonocytes. Sertoli cells and myoid cells also express ALCAM at the same stage, suggesting that ALCAM may contribute to gonocyte-Sertoli cell adhesion and migration of gonoyctes toward the basement membrane.     

Developmental expression of the translocator protein 18 kDa (TSPO) in testicular germ cells

Translocator protein (TSPO) is a high affinity 18 kDa drug- and cholesterol-binding protein strongly expressed in steroidogenic tissues where it mediates cholesterol transport into mitochondria and steroid formation. Testosterone formation by Leydig cells in the testis is critical for the regulation of spermatogenesis and male fertility. Male germ cell development comprises two main phases, the pre-spermatogenesis phase occurring from fetal life to infancy and leading to spermatogonial stem cell (SSC) formation, and spermatogenesis, which consists of repetitive cycles of germ cell mitosis, meiosis and differentiation, starting with SSC differentiation and ending with spermiogenesis and spermatozoa formation. Little is known about the molecular mechanisms controlling the progression from one germ cell phenotype to the next. Here, we report that testicular germ cells express TSPO from neonatal to adult phases, although at lower levels than Leydig cells. TSPO mRNA and protein were found at specific steps of germ cell development. In fetal and neonatal gonocytes, the precursors of SSCs, TSPO appears to be mainly nuclear. In the prepubertal testis, TSPO is present in pachytene spermatocytes and dividing spermatogonia. In adult testes, it is found in a stage-dependent manner in pachytene spermatocyte and round spermatid nuclei, and in mitotic spermatogonia. In search of TSPO function, the TSPO drug ligand PK 11195 was added to isolated gonocytes with or without the proliferative factors PDGF and 17β-estradiol, and was found to have no effect on gonocyte proliferation. However, TSPO strong expression in dividing spermatogonia suggests that it might play a role in spermatogonial mitosis. Taken together, these results suggest that TSPO plays a role in specific phases of germ cell development.