Fluorescence correlation studies of lipid domains in model membranes (Review)

Advances in optical microscopy techniques and single-molecule detection have paved the way to exploring new approaches for investigating membrane dynamics and organization, thereby revealing details on the processing of signals, complex association/dissociation, chemical reactions and transport at and around the membrane. These events rely on a tight regulation of lipid-protein and protein-protein interactions in space and time. Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy (FCS) provides exquisite sensitivity in measuring local concentrations, association/dissociation constants, chemical rate constants and, in general, in probing the chemical environment of the species of interest and its interactions with potential partners. Here, we review some applications of FCS to lipid and protein organization in biomimetic membranes with lateral heterogeneities, which share some physico-chemical properties with cellular rafts. What we learn from investigations of lipid-lipid and lipid-protein interactions in simple model membranes can be regarded as an essential basic lecture for studies in more complex cellular membranes.     

Fluorescence studies of lipid regular distribution in membranes

This article reviews the use of fluorescent lipids and free probes in the studies of lipid regular distribution in model membranes. The first part of this article summarizes the evidence and physical properties for lipid regular distribution in pyrene-labeled phosphatidylcholine (PC)/unlabeled PC binary mixtures as revealed by the fluorescence of pyrene-labeled PC. The original and the extended hexagonal superlattice model are discussed. The second part focuses on the fluorescence studies of sterol regular distributions in membranes. The experimental evidence for sterol superlattice formation obtained from the fluorescent sterol (i.e. dehydroergosterol) and non-sterol fluorescent probes (e.g. DPH and Laurdan) are evaluated. Prospects and concerns are given with regard to the sterol regular distribution. The third part deals briefly with the evidence for polar headgroup superlattices. The emphasis of this article is placed on the new concept that membrane properties and activities, including the activities of surface acting enzymes, drug partitioning, and membrane free volume, are fine-tuned by minute changes in the concentration of bulky lipids (e.g. sterols and pyrene-containing acyl chains) in the vicinities of the critical mole fractions for superlattice formation.     

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy relates rafts in model and native membranes

The lipid raft model has evoked a new perspective on membrane biology. Understanding the structure and dynamics of lipid domains could be a key to many crucial membrane-associated processes in cells. However, one shortcoming in the field is the lack of routinely applicable techniques to measure raft association without perturbation by detergents. We show that both in cell and in domain-exhibiting model membranes, fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) can easily distinguish a raft marker (cholera toxin B subunit bound to ganglioside (GM1) and a nonraft marker (dialkylcarbocyanine dye diI)) by their decidedly different diffusional mobilities. In contrast, these markers exhibit only slightly different mobilities in a homogeneous artificial membrane. Performing cholesterol depletion with methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, which disrupts raft organization, we find an analogous effect of reduced mobility for the nonraft marker in domain-exhibiting artificial membranes and in cell membranes. In contrast, cholesterol depletion has differential effects on the raft marker, cholera toxin B subunit-GM1, rendering it more mobile in artificial domain-exhibiting membranes but leaving it immobile in cell membranes, where cytoskeleton disruption is required to achieve higher mobility. Thus, fluorescence correlation spectroscopy promises to be a valuable tool to elucidate lipid raft associations in native cells and to gain deeper insight into the correspondence between model and natural membranes.     

Interaction of human apolipoprotein A-I with model membranes exhibiting lipid domains

Several mechanisms for cell cholesterol efflux have been proposed, including membrane microsolubilization, suggesting that the existence of specific domains could enhance the transfer of lipids to apolipoproteins. In this work isothermal titration calorimetry, circular dichroism spectroscopy, and two-photon microscopy are used to study the interaction of lipid-free apolipoprotein A-I (apoA-I) with small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs) of 1-palmitoyl, 2-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine (POPC) and sphingomyelin (SM), with and without cholesterol. Below 30 degrees C the calorimetric results show that apoA-I interaction with POPC/SM SUVs produces an exothermic reaction, characterized as nonclassical hydrophobic binding. The heat capacity change (DeltaCp degrees ) is small and positive, whereas it was larger and negative for pure POPC bilayers, in the absence of SM. Inclusion of cholesterol in the membranes induces changes in the observed thermodynamic pattern of binding and counteracts the formation of alpha-helices in the protein. Above 30 degrees C the reactions are endothermic. Giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) of identical composition to the SUVs, and two-photon fluorescence microscopy techniques, were utilized to further characterize the interaction. Fluorescence imaging of the GUVs indicates coexistence of lipid domains under 30 degrees C. Binding experiments and Laurdan generalized-polarization measurements suggest that there is no preferential binding of the labeled apoA-I to any particular domain. Changes in the content of alpha-helix, binding, and fluidity data are discussed in the framework of the thermodynamic parameters.     

Fluorescence coupling across lipid bilayer membranes

Summary An energy transfer between donor and acceptor fluorophores across single lipid bilayer membranes is demonstrated. Anilino-naphthalene sulfonate is used as the donor chromophore: its fluorescence is enhanced by the presence of lipid and thus indicates association with the purely lipid membranes of our preparation of vesicles in suspension. Light emit ted by the donor molecules excites fluorescence of acriflavine, a suitable acceptor enclosed inside the vesicles. Absorption and fluorescence spectra of this system, in its components and as a whole, are presented in evidence for an energy transfer.Supported by a grant from the Medical Research Council of Canada. The results of this work were presented, in part, at the 17th Annual Meeting of the Biophysical Society, February 27–March 2, 1973, Columbus, Ohio.Scholar of the Medical Research Council of Canada.     

Bull sperm plasma and acrosomal membranes: Fluorescence studies of lipid phase fluidity

Bull sperm plasma and outer acrosomal membranes have been isolated by discontinuous sucrose density gradient centrifugation and Ca²⁺-ATPase activity has been determined for both the membranes. Pyrene excimer fluorescence and diphenylhexatriene fluorescence polarization studies show that the lipid phase of the sperm plasma membranes is more fluid than the lipids of the outer acrosomal membranes. Approximately, a three fold increase in the cholesterol content has been found in the outer acrosomal membranes as compared to that in the plasma membranes.     

Probing lipid mobility of raft-exhibiting model membranes by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Confocal fluorescence microscopy and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) have been employed to investigate the lipid spatial and dynamic organization in giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) prepared from ternary mixtures of dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine/sphingomyelin/cholesterol. For a certain range of cholesterol concentration, formation of domains with raft-like properties was observed. Strikingly, the lipophilic probe 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3,3,3',3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate (DiI-C18) was excluded from sphingomyelin-enriched regions, where the raft marker ganglioside GM1 was localized. Cholesterol was shown to promote lipid segregation in dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine-enriched, liquid-disordered, and sphingomyelin-enriched, liquid-ordered phases. Most importantly, the lipid mobility in sphingomyelin-enriched regions significantly increased by increasing the cholesterol concentration. These results pinpoint the key role, played by cholesterol in tuning lipid dynamics in membranes. At cholesterol concentrations >50 mol%, domains vanished and the lipid diffusion slowed down upon further addition of cholesterol. By taking the molecular diffusion coefficients as a fingerprint of membrane phase compositions, FCS is proven to evaluate domain lipid compositions. Moreover, FCS data from ternary and binary mixtures have been used to build a ternary phase diagram, which shows areas of phase coexistence, transition points, and, importantly, how lipid dynamics varies between and within phase regions.     

Stable and unstable lipid domains in ceramide-containing membranes

We applied x-ray diffraction, calorimetry, and infrared spectroscopy to lipid mixtures of palmitoyl-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine, sphingomyelin, and ceramide. This combination of experimental techniques allowed us to probe the stability and structural properties of coexisting lipid domains without resorting to any molecular probes. In particular, we found unstable microscopic domains (compositional/phase fluctuations) in the absence of ceramide, and macroscopically separated fluid and gel phases upon addition of ceramide. We also observed phase fluctuations in the presence of ceramide within the broad phase transition regions. We compare our results with fluorescence spectroscopy data and complement the previously reported phase diagram. We also obtained electron paramagnetic resonance data to assess the possible limitations of techniques employing a single label. Our study demonstrates the necessity of applying a combination of experimental techniques to probe local/global structural and fast/slow motional properties in complex lipid mixtures.     

Detection of lipid domains in model and cell membranes by fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy

The discovery that the lipids constituting the plasma membrane are not randomly distributed, but instead are able to form laterally segregated lipid domains with different properties has given hints how the formation of such lipid domains influences and regulates many processes occurring at the plasma membrane. While in model systems these lipid domains can be easily accessed and their properties studied, it is still challenging to determine the properties of cholesterol rich lipid domains, the so called “Rafts”, in the plasma membrane of living cells due to their small size and transient nature. One promising technique to address such issues is fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM) microscopy, as spatially resolved images make the visualization of the lateral lipid distribution possible, while at the same time the fluorescence lifetime of a membrane probe yields information about the bilayer structure and organization of the lipids in lipid domains and various properties like preferential protein-protein interactions or the enrichment of membrane probes. This review aims to give an overview of the techniques underlying FLIM probes which can be applied to investigate the formation of lipid domains and their respective properties in model membrane and biological systems. Also a short technical introduction into the techniques of a FLIM microscope is given.     

Neutron diffraction studies of oral stratum corneum model lipid membranes

In this work we have investigated model lipid mixtures simulating a lipid component of oral stratum corneum (OSC). Neutron diffraction experiments on oriented samples have revealed that SM (bovine brain)/dipalmitoylphosphatidylethanolamine/dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPE/DPPC) mixtures at molar ratios of 1/2/1 and 1/1/1 are one-phase membranes. The incorporation of low concentrations of ceramide 6 and cholesterol into SM/DPPC/DPPE bilayers does not result in a phase separation, affecting membrane hydration. The model OSC membrane composed of ceramide 6/cholesterol/fatty acids/cholesterol sulfate/SM (bovine brain)/DPPE/DPPC is characterized by coexistence of several lamellar phases, that behave differently during their hydration in water excess. The phase with lamellar repeat distance of about 45 Å is likely a ceramide-rich phase and shows a restricted swelling in water, while another phase with repeat distance of 50 Å swells very quickly on 15 Å and then disappears. Our results indicate that phospholipid-rich and ceramide-rich domains could possibly coexist in the intercellular space of oral epithelium.     

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy with single-molecule sensitivity on cell and model membranes.

We report on the successful application of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to the analysis of single fluorescently labeled lipid analogue molecules diffusing laterally in lipid bilayers, as exemplified by time traces of fluorescence bursts of individual molecules entering and leaving the excitation area. FCS measurements performed on lipid probes in rat basophilic leukemia cell membranes showed deviations from two-dimensional Brownian motion with a single uniform diffusion constant. Giant unilamellar vesicles were employed as model systems to characterize diffusion of fluorescent lipid analogues in both homogeneous and mixed lipid phases with diffusion heterogeneity. Comparing the results of cell membrane diffusion with the findings on the model systems suggests possible explanations for the observations: (a) anomalous subdiffusion in which evanescent attractive interactions with disparate mobile molecules modifies the diffusion statistics; (b) alternatively, probe molecules are localized in microdomains of submicroscopic size, possibly in heterogeneous membrane phases.     

Detection of lipid domains in model and cell membranes by fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy of fluorescent lipid analogues

The presence of lipid domains in cellular membranes and their characteristic features are still an issue of dividing discussion. Several recent studies implicate lipid domains in plasma membranes of mammalian cells as short lived and in the submicron range. Measuring the fluorescence lifetime of appropriate lipid analogues is a proper approach to detect domains with such properties. Here, the sensitivity of the fluorescence lifetime of1-palmitoyl-2-[6-[(7-nitro-2-1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)amino]-hexanoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phospholipid (C6-NBD-phospholipid) analogues has been employed to characterize lipid domains in giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) and the plasma membrane of mammalian cells by fluorescence lifetime imaging (FLIM). Fluorescence decay of C6-NBD-phosphatidylcholine is characterized by a short and long lifetime. For GUVs forming microscopically visible lipid domains the longer lifetime in the liquid disordered (ld) and the liquid ordered (lo) phase was clearly distinct, being approximately 7 ns and 11 ns, respectively. Lifetimes were not sensitive to variation of cholesterol concentration of domain-forming GUVs indicating that the lipid composition and physical properties of those lipid domains are well defined entities. Even the existence of submicroscopic domains can be detected by FLIM as demonstrated for GUVs of palmitoyloleoyl phosphatidylcholine/N-palmitoyl-d-sphingomyelin/cholesterol mixtures. A broad distribution of the long lifetime was found for C6-NBD-phosphatidylcholine inserted in the plasma membrane of HepG2 and HeLa cells centered around 11 ns. FLIM studies on lipid domains forming giant vesicles derived from the plasma membrane of HeLa cells may suggest that a variety of submicroscopic lipid domains exists in the plasma membrane of intact cells.     

Fluctuation domains in myoglobin. Fluorescence quenching studies

The dynamics of two domains in the myoglobin molecule, close to the heme and inside the protein medium including the surface, are investigated through the study of the fluorescence oxygen quenching of two probes imbedded in the heme pocket: zinc protoporphyrin IX (with a fluorescence lifetime of 2.1 ns) and metal-free protoporphyrin IX (with a fluorescence lifetime of 17.8 ns).     

Partitioning of lipidated peptide sequences into liquid-ordered lipid domains in model and biological membranes.

We have used a fluorescence assay and detergent fractionation to examine the partitioning of different fluorescent lipidated peptides, with sequences and lipid substituents matching those found in various classes of lipidated cellular proteins, into liquid-ordered (raft-like) domains in lipid bilayers. Peptides incorporating isoprenyl groups, or multiple unsaturated acyl chains, show negligible affinity for liquid-ordered domains in mixed-phase liquid-ordered/liquid-disordered (l(o)/l(d)) bilayers composed of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, a spin-labeled unsaturated phosphatidylcholine, and cholesterol. By contrast, peptides incorporating multiple S- and/or N-acyl chains, or a cholesterol residue plus an N-terminal palmitoyl chain, show significant partitioning into liquid-ordered domains under the same conditions. Interestingly, the affinity of a lipidated peptide for l(o) domains can be strongly influenced, not only by the structures of the lipid substituents but also by the nature and the positions of their attachment to the peptide chain. These results are well correlated with those obtained from parallel assays based on low-temperature detergent fractionation. Using the latter approach, we further demonstrate that a truly minimal l(o) domain partitioning motif [myristoylGlyCys(palmitoyl)-] can mediate efficient incorporation into the "raft" fraction of COS-7 cell membranes.     

Low levels of irradiation modify lipid domains in model membranes: a laser Raman study

We have used Raman spectroscopy to study the effects of ionizing radiation on thermal transitions of dipalmitoyl lecithin + polyunsaturated fatty acid liposomes. Raman spectra in the CH (2800-3000 cm-1), C = C (1600-1680 cm-1), and C-C (1000-1150 cm-1) stretching regions are sensitive to ionizing radiation. The CH stretching of acyl chains yields three strong bands around 2850, 2880, and 2930 cm-1. The ratios of the relative intensities of 2880 and 2850 cm-1 bands, i.e., I2880/2850, when plotted against temperature show multiple infection points which correspond to multiple spectroscopic transitions. These are ascribed to a separate phase with distinctive proportions of lecithin and polyunsaturated fatty acids. We find these transitions sensitive to low levels of ionizing radiation. Doses as low as 5-15 rad after 48 h of 60Co gamma irradiation and 60 kVp X irradiation drastically broaden and shift the polyunsaturated rich phase which occurs at lower temperatures (-7 to +5 degrees C) than that of pure dipalmitoyl lecithin (39 degrees C). In addition a new transition around 46 degrees C also emerges upon irradiation (48 h postirradiation). These irradiation effects can be accelerated by the presence of catalytic amounts of Fe2+/EDTA +H2O2. The membrane transition modification is more sensitive to 60 kVp X rays in comparison to 60Co gamma rays owing to the high LET component of the former. The intensity of 1660 cm-1 band, assigned to C = C stretching in the cis-configuration, loses intensity upon irradiation. Concomitantly, a new band around 1675 cm-1, assigned to trans-configuration, emerges. Similarly the increase in the "order parameter" as calculated from the relative intensities of C--C stretching bands indicates rigidification of membrane. Various factors such as reduction in unsaturation, increase in trans-configuration, and the formation of multiple peroxidation products are invoked as lipid phase modifiers.     

Photon correlation spectroscopy of bilayer lipid membranes

Light scattering by thermal fluctuations on simple monoglyceride bilayer membranes has been used to investigate the viscoelastic properties of these structures. Spectroscopic analysis of these fluctuations (capillary waves) permits the nonperturbative measurement of the interfacial tension and a shear interfacial viscosity acting normal to the membrane plane. The methods were established by studies of solvent and nonsolvent bilayers of glycerol monooleate (GMO). Changes in the tension of GMO/n-decane membranes induced by altering the composition of the parent solution were detected and quantified. In a test of the reliability of the technique controlled variations of the viscosity of the aqueous bathing solution were accurately monitored. The technique was applied to solvent-free bilayers formed from dispersions of GMO in squalane. The lower tensions observed attested to the comparative absence of solvent in such bilayers. In contrast to the solvent case, the solvent-free membranes exhibited a significant transverse shear viscosity, indicative of the enhanced intermolecular interactions within the bilayer.     

Visualizing the localization of sulfoglycolipids in lipid raft domains in model membranes and sperm membrane extracts

Sulfogalactosylglycerolipid (SGG) is found in detergent-resistant lipid raft fractions isolated from sperm plasma membranes and has been shown to be important in sperm-egg adhesion. In order to provide more direct evidence for the association of sulfoglycolipids with lipid raft domains, we have examined the distribution of two sulfoglycolipids in supported membranes prepared from artificial lipid mixtures and cellular lipid extracts. Atomic force microscopy has been used to visualize the localization of SGG and sulfogalactosylceramide (SGC) in liquid-ordered domains in supported bilayers of ternary lipid mixtures comprised of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, cholesterol and palmitoyldocosahexaenoylphosphatidylcholine. The localization of SGC/SGG in the liquid-ordered raft domains is demonstrated by changes in bilayer morphology in the presence of sulfoglycolipid, by selective antibody labeling of the domains with anti-SGC/SGG and by the effects of the cholesterol-sequestering agent, methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, on the supported membranes. In addition, we use a combination of atomic force microscopy and immunofluorescence to show that supported bilayers made from lipids extracted from sperm anterior head plasma membranes (APM) and isolated APM vesicles exhibit small SGG-rich domains that are similar to those observed in bilayers of artificial lipid mixtures. The possible implications of these results for the involvement of SGG-rich lipid rafts in modulating sperm-egg interactions in vivo and the utility of model membranes for studying the behavior of lipid rafts are discussed.     

Visualizing the localization of sulfoglycolipids in lipid raft domains in model membranes and sperm membrane extracts

Sulfogalactosylglycerolipid (SGG) is found in detergent-resistant lipid raft fractions isolated from sperm plasma membranes and has been shown to be important in sperm-egg adhesion. In order to provide more direct evidence for the association of sulfoglycolipids with lipid raft domains, we have examined the distribution of two sulfoglycolipids in supported membranes prepared from artificial lipid mixtures and cellular lipid extracts. Atomic force microscopy has been used to visualize the localization of SGG and sulfogalactosylceramide (SGC) in liquid-ordered domains in supported bilayers of ternary lipid mixtures comprised of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, cholesterol and palmitoyldocosahexaenoylphosphatidylcholine. The localization of SGC/SGG in the liquid-ordered raft domains is demonstrated by changes in bilayer morphology in the presence of sulfoglycolipid, by selective antibody labeling of the domains with anti-SGC/SGG and by the effects of the cholesterol-sequestering agent, methyl-β-cyclodextrin, on the supported membranes. In addition, we use a combination of atomic force microscopy and immunofluorescence to show that supported bilayers made from lipids extracted from sperm anterior head plasma membranes (APM) and isolated APM vesicles exhibit small SGG-rich domains that are similar to those observed in bilayers of artificial lipid mixtures. The possible implications of these results for the involvement of SGG-rich lipid rafts in modulating sperm-egg interactions in vivo and the utility of model membranes for studying the behavior of lipid rafts are discussed.     

Fluorescence studies of the aged erythrocyte membranes

The most important purpose of this research is to characterize by means of fluorescence polarization the structural and functional changes which occur in the membrane of the human erythrocytes during aging process. Our results provide evidence of a significant increase of membrane fluidity in the deep lipid core and in the lipid/protein boundary, in the aged erythrocytes. These features are associated with a rigidity of the membrane surface, as revealed by the anisotropy increase of a specific probe suitable for monitoring the membrane protein behaviour. These modifications could be considered as one of the mechanisms which contribute to alter erythrocyte rheological properties sufficiently to be recognised and removed within circulation.