Trees before and after Darwin

Phylogenetic trees published before Darwin’s On the Origin of Species are scarce. Lamarck (1809) and Barbançois (1816; J Phys Chim Hist Nat Arts 82, 444) are the first and only trees devoted to illustrating the genealogical connections between organisms of different species and different higher taxa. In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, most of the trees depicted in papers dealing with natural history were classifications; classifications in the shape of trees, but classifications nonetheless. Those published by Bronn (1858) are a good example. After Darwin, phylogenetic trees incorporating the time dimension flourished. In the first half of the 20th century, the Modern Synthesis failed to renew and rejuvenate the intuitive construction of trees. It wasn’t until the appearance of Hennig’s phylogenetic systematics that the real nature of the connection between phylogeny and the pre‐Darwinian concept of homology was made clear.     

Darwin after 100 years. 1983.]

The triumph of Darwinism, together with the rise of Genetics, produced the virtual abandonment of the problem of form in Biology. The statement that any adaptive theory is tautological is however poor, the adaptation concept having an evident intuitive content. As in Geometrical Optics, a ray of light is, among the crowd of continuous curves uniting two points, the one requiring the minimum time for the light to go from one point to the other, so actual evolution, among the crowd of virtual evolutions between two forms, is the one best fitted to face 'selective pressure' in a given environment. The effect of selective pressure on the genome is unfortunately a merely theoretical not quantifiable concept. Most biological forms are forced by their internal stability to an essential fixity, so that the leap from one type-form to another should be abrupt-catastrophic. A good theory of evolution depends on a proper understanding of specific form stability. Biology must eventually return to the concept of ideal structure, the Goethian 'Urbild'.     

Modus Darwin

Modus Darwin is a principle of inference that licenses the conclusion that two species have a common ancestor, based on the observation that they are similar. The present paper investigates the principle's probabilistic foundations.     

Darwin would have loved DNA: celebrating Darwin 200

Analysis of DNA sequences now plays a key role in evolutionary biology research. If Darwin were to come back today, I think he would be absolutely delighted with molecular evolutionary genetics, for three reasons. First, it solved one of the greatest problems for his theory of evolution by natural selection. Second, it gives us a tool that can be used to investigate many of the questions he found the most fascinating. And third, DNA data confirm Darwin''s grand view of evolution.