Biological bleaching of hardwood kraft pulp using Trametes (Coriolus) versicolor immobilized in polyurethane foam

Summary Incubation of hardwood kraft pulp (HWKP) in agitated aerated cultures of the white-rot fungus Trametes versicolor increases pulp brightness and decreases its residual lignin content. A consequence of this biobleaching with whole cultures is that the resulting pulp also contains fungal biomass (up to ca. 10% (w/w)). In this report culture conditions for the immobilization of T. versicolor on polyurethane foam and bleaching of HWKP with the immobilized fungus are described. The major advantage of using immobilized fungus to bleach HWKP is that the fungal biomass can be separated from the pulp after treatment, resulting in a biologically bleached pulp free of fungal mycelium. From an analysis of pulp samples bleached with free and foam-immobilized mycelium, we conclude that fungal biomass in pulp treated with free mycelium accounts for up to 25% of the reduction in pulp viscosity (indication of cellulose chain length) whereas the zero span breaking length (indication of fibre strength) is not significantly affected by the presence of the fungus. Immobilization of the fungus on polyurethane foam also allows the repeated use of the same fungal biomass to bleach successive batches of pulp, either immediately or after storage at 4°C. Offprint requests to: I. D. ReidIssued as NRCC no. 30975     

Lignin Peroxidase Activity Is Not Important in Biological Bleaching and Delignification of Unbleached Kraft Pulp by Trametes versicolor

The discovery in 1983 of fungal lignin peroxidases able to catalyze the oxidation of nonphenolic aromatic lignin model compounds and release some CO₂ from lignin has been seen as a major advance in understanding how fungi degrade lignin. Recently, the fungus Trametes versicolor was shown to be capable of substantial decolorization and delignification of unbleached industrial kraft pulps over 2 to 5 days. The role, if any, of lignin peroxidase in this biobleaching was therefore examined. Several different assays indicated that T. versicolor can produce and secrete peroxidase proteins, but only under certain culture conditions. However, work employing a new lignin peroxidase inhibitor (metavanadate ions) and a new lignin peroxidase assay using the dye azure B indicated that secreted lignin peroxidases do not play a role in the T. versicolor pulp-bleaching system. Oxidative activity capable of degrading 2-keto-4-methiolbutyric acid (KMB) appeared unique to ligninolytic fungi and always accompanied pulp biobleaching.     

Role of Organic Acids in the Manganese-Independent Biobleaching System of Bjerkandera sp. Strain BOS55

Bjerkandera sp. strain BOS55 is a white rot fungus that can bleach EDTA-extracted eucalyptus oxygen-delignified kraft pulp (OKP) without any requirement for manganese. Under manganese-free conditions, additions of simple physiological organic acids (e.g., glycolate, glyoxylate, oxalate, and others) at 1 to 5 mM stimulated brightness gains and pulp delignification two- to threefold compared to results for control cultures not receiving acids. The role of the organic acids in improving the manganese-independent biobleaching was shown not to be due to pH-buffering effects. Instead, the stimulation was attributed to enhanced production of manganese peroxidase (MnP) and lignin peroxidase (LiP) as well as increased physiological concentrations of veratryl alcohol and oxalate. These factors contributed to greatly improved production of superoxide anion radicals, which may have accounted for the more extensive biobleaching. Optimum biobleaching corresponded most to the production of MnP. These results suggest that MnP from Bjerkandera is purposefully produced in the absence of manganese and can possibly function independently of manganese in OKP delignification. LiP probably also contributed to OKP delignification when it was present.     

Manganese Peroxidase, Produced by Trametes versicolor during Pulp Bleaching, Demethylates and Delignifies Kraft Pulp

Previous work has shown that Trametes (Coriolus) versicolor bleaches kraft pulp brownstock with the concomitant release of methanol. In this work, the fungus is shown to produce both laccase and manganese peroxidase (MnP) but not lignin peroxidase during pulp bleaching. MnP production was enhanced by the presence of pulp and/or Mn(II) ions. The maximum level of secreted MnP was coincident with the maximum rate of fungal bleaching. Culture filtrates isolated from bleaching cultures produced Mn(II)- and hydrogen peroxide-dependent pulp demethylation and delignification. Laccase and MnP were separated by ion-exchange chromatography. Purified MnP alone produced most of the demethylation and delignification exhibited by the culture filtrates. On the basis of the methanol released and the total and phenolic methoxyl contents of the pulp, it appears that MnP shows a preference for the oxidation of phenolic lignin substructures. The extensive increase in brightness observed in the fungus-treated pulp was not found with MnP alone. Therefore, either the MnP effect must be optimized or other enzymes or compounds from the fungus are also required for brightening.     

Bleaching of Hardwood Kraft Pulp with Manganese Peroxidase Secreted from Phanerochaete sordida YK-624

In vitro bleaching of an unbleached hardwood kraft pulp was performed with manganese peroxidase (MnP) from the fungus Phanerochaete sordida YK-624. When the kraft pulp was treated with partially purified MnP in the presence of MnSO₄, Tween 80, and sodium malonate with continuous addition of H₂O₂ at 37°C for 24 h, the pulp brightness increased by about 10 points and the kappa number decreased by about 6 points compared with untreated pulp. The pulp brightness was also increased by 43 points to 75.5% by multiple (six) treatments with MnP combined with alkaline extraction. Our results indicate that in vitro degradation of residual lignin in hardwood kraft pulp with MnP is possible.     

Effect of Residual Lignin Type and Amount on Bleaching of Kraft Pulp by Trametes versicolor

The white rot fungus Trametes (Coriolus) versicolor can delignify and brighten unbleached hardwood kraft pulp within a few days, but softwood kraft pulps require longer treatment. To determine the contributions of higher residual lignin contents (kappa numbers) and structural differences in lignins to the recalcitrance of softwood kraft pulps to biobleaching, we tested softwood and hardwood pulps cooked to the same kappa numbers, 26 and 12. A low-lignin-content (overcooked) softwood pulp resisted delignification by T. versicolor, but a high-lignin-content (lightly cooked) hardwood pulp was delignified at the same rate as a normal softwood pulp. Thus, the longer time taken by T. versicolor to brighten softwood kraft pulp than hardwood pulp results from the higher residual lignin content of the softwood pulp; possible differences in the structures of the residual lignins are important only when the lignin becomes highly condensed. Under the conditions used in this study, when an improved fungal inoculum was used, six different softwood pulps were all substantially brightened by T. versicolor. Softwood pulps whose lignin contents were decreased by extended modified continuous cooking or oxygen delignification to kappa numbers as low as 15 were delignified by T. versicolor at the same rate as normal softwood pulp. More intensive O₂ delignification, like overcooking, decreased the susceptibility of the residual lignin in the pulps to degradation by T. versicolor.     

The use of extracellular enzymes from Streptomyces albus ATCC 3005 for the bleaching of eucalyptus kraft pulp

The suitability of culture supernatant from Streptomyces albus ATCC 3005 for use in the biobleaching of eucalyptus kraft pulp was investigated. S. albus was found to grow on a minimal salts medium containing oat spelts xylan and yeast extract as the main carbon and nitrogen sources, respectively. Maximal extracellular xylanase and peroxidase production was detected after 120 h (11.97 U ml(-1)) and 72 h (0.58 U ml(-1)), respectively. Importantly, no cellulase activity could be detected. When the effect of pH on enzyme activity was examined, maximal xylanase and peroxidase activity was obtained at pH 6.5 and pH 9.9, respectively. The optimum hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) concentration for peroxidase activity was found to occur at 20 mM, with peroxidase remaining active at 100 mM H2O2 after 1 h incubation at 53 degrees C; the half-life of the enzyme at that temperature was estimated to be 33 min. Short-term (1 h) biobleaching of eucalyptus kraft pulp with culture supernatant from S. albus in the presence of H2O2 resulted in a significant reduction of kappa number (2.85 units) with no change in viscosity. These results suggest a potential application of cellulase-free culture supernatants from S. albus in biobleaching.     

Extracellular Enzyme Production and Synthetic Lignin Mineralization by Ceriporiopsis subvermispora

The ability of the white rot fungus Ceriporiopsis subvermispora to mineralize ¹⁴C-synthetic lignin was studied under different culture conditions, and the levels of two extracellular enzymes were monitored. The highest mineralization rates (28% after 28 days) were obtained in cultures containing a growth-limiting amount of nitrogen source (1.0 mM ammonium tartrate); under this condition, the levels of manganese peroxidase (MnP) and laccase present in the culture supernatant solutions were very low compared with cultures containing 10 mM of the nitrogen source. In contrast, cultures containing a limiting concentration of the carbon source (0.1% glucose) showed low levels of both enzymes and also very low mineralization rates compared with cultures containing 1% glucose. Cultures containing 11 ppm of Mn(II) showed a higher rate of mineralization than those containing 0.3 or 40 ppm of this cation. Levels of MnP and laccase were higher when 40 ppm of Mn(II) was used. Mineralization rates were slightly higher in cultures flushed daily with oxygen, whereas laccase levels were lower and MnP levels were approximately the same as in cultures maintained under an air atmosphere. The presence of 0.4 mM veratryl alcohol reduced both mineralization rates and MnP levels, without affecting laccase levels. Lignin peroxidase activity was not detected under any condition. Addition of purified lignin peroxidase to the cultures in the presence or absence of veratryl alcohol did not enhance mineralization rates significantly.     

Manganese Is Not Required for Biobleaching of Oxygen-Delignified Kraft Pulp by the White Rot Fungus Bjerkandera sp. Strain BOS55

The white rot fungus Bjerkandera sp. strain BOS55 extensively delignified and bleached oxygen-delignified eucalyptus kraft pulp handsheets. Biologically mediated brightness gains of up to 14 ISO (International Standards Organization units) were obtained, providing high final brightness values of up to 80% ISO. In nitrogen-limited cultures (2.2 mM N), manganese (Mn) greatly improved manganese-dependent peroxidase (MnP) production. However, the biobleaching was not affected by the Mn nutrient regimen, ranging from 1,000 (mu)M added Mn to below the detection limit of 0.26 (mu)M Mn in EDTA-extracted pulp medium. The lowest Mn concentration tested was at least several orders of magnitude lower than the K(infm) known for MnP. Consequently, it was concluded that Mn is not required for biobleaching in Bjerkandera sp. strain BOS55. Nonetheless, fast protein liquid chromatography profiles indicated that MnP was the predominant oxidative enzyme produced even under culture conditions in the near absence of manganese. High nitrogen (22 mM N) and exogenous veratryl alcohol (2 mM) repressed biobleaching in Mn-deficient but not in Mn-sufficient culture medium. No correlation was observed between the titers of extracellular peroxidases and the biobleaching. However, the decolorization rate of the polyaromatic dye Poly R-478 was moderately correlated to the biobleaching under a wide range of Mn and N nutrient regimens.     

Degradation of synthetic lignin by the protoplasts of Phanerochaete chrysosporium in the presence of lignin peroxidase or manganese peroxidase

Lignin was mineralized in the experiments in which ¹⁴C-lignin was incubated with lignin peroxidase or manganese peroxidase in a tartrate buffer in the presence of cycloheximide-treated protoplasts obtained from the ligninolytic mycelia of Phanerochaete chrysosporium. The rate of lignin mineralization was dependent on the lignin peroxidase or manganese peroxidase concentration in the medium. In the experiments in which lignin was incubated with lignin peroxidase or manganese peroxidase, lignin was repolymerized irrespective of the presence of protoplasts mineralizing lignin, suggesting that an active degradation of lignin and repolymerization took place. Taking into account that lignin peroxidase and manganese peroxidase were the only extracellular enzymes in the experiments in which lignin was mineralized by the protoplasts, it is postulated that lignin peroxidase and/or manganese peroxidase can degrade lignin into small fragments which can then be further absorbed by the fungal cells and subsequently degraded to CO₂.     

New Pulp Biobleaching System Involving Manganese Peroxidase Immobilized in a Silica Support with Controlled Pore Sizes

Attempts have been made to use manganese peroxidase (MnP) for chlorine-free pulp biobleaching, but they have not been commercially viable because of the enzyme's low stability. We developed a new pulp biobleaching method involving mesoporous material-immobilized manganese peroxidase from Phanerochaete chrysosporium. MnP immobilized in FSM-16, a folded-sheet mesoporous material whose pore size is nearly the same as the diameter of the enzyme, had the highest thermal stability and tolerance to H₂O₂. MnP immobilized in FSM-16 retained more than 80% of its initial activity even after 10 days of continuous reaction. We constructed a thermally discontinuous two-stage reactor system, in which the enzyme (39°C) and pulp-bleaching (70°C) reactions were performed separately. When the treatment of pulp with MnP by means of the two-stage reactor system and alkaline extraction was repeated seven times, the brightness of the pulp increased to about 88% within 7 h after completion of the last treatment.     

Production of Manganese Peroxidase and Organic Acids and Mineralization of 14C-Labelled Lignin (14C-DHP) during Solid-State Fermentation of Wheat Straw with the White Rot Fungus Nematoloma frowardii

The basidiomycetous fungus Nematoloma frowardii produced manganese peroxidase (MnP) as the predominant ligninolytic enzyme during solid-state fermentation (SSF) of wheat straw. The purified enzyme had a molecular mass of 50 kDa and an isoelectric point of 3.2. In addition to MnP, low levels of laccase and lignin peroxidase were detected. Synthetic ¹⁴C-ring-labelled lignin (¹⁴C-DHP) was efficiently degraded during SSF. Approximately 75% of the initial radioactivity was released as ¹⁴CO₂, while only 6% was associated with the residual straw material, including the well-developed fungal biomass. On the basis of this finding we concluded that at least partial extracellular mineralization of lignin may have occurred. This conclusion was supported by the fact that we detected high levels of organic acids in the fermented straw (the maximum concentrations in the water phases of the straw cultures were 45 mM malate, 3.5 mM fumarate, and 10 mM oxalate), which rendered MnP effective and therefore made partial direct mineralization of lignin possible. Experiments performed in a cell-free system, which simulated the conditions in the straw cultures, revealed that MnP in fact converted part of the ¹⁴C-DHP to ¹⁴CO₂ (which accounted for up to 8% of the initial radioactivity added) and ¹⁴C-labelled water-soluble products (which accounted for 43% of the initial radioactivity) in the presence of natural levels of organic acids (30 mM malate, 5 mM fumarate).     

Fate of Residual Lignin during Delignification of Kraft Pulp by Trametes versicolor

The fungus Trametes versicolor can delignify and brighten kraft pulps. To better understand the mechanism of this biological bleaching and the by-products formed, I traced the transformation of pulp lignin during treatment with the fungus. Hardwood and softwood kraft pulps containing ¹⁴C-labelled residual lignin were prepared by laboratory pulping of lignin-labelled aspen and spruce wood and then incubated with T. versicolor. After initially polymerizing the lignin, the fungus depolymerized it to alkali-extractable forms and then to soluble forms. Most of the labelled carbon accumulated in the water-soluble pool. The extractable and soluble products were oligomeric; single-ring aromatic products were not detected. The mineralization of the lignin carbon to CO₂ varied between experiments, up to 22% in the most vigorous cultures. The activities of the known enzymes laccase and manganese peroxidase did not account for all of the lignin degradation that took place in the T. versicolor cultures. This fungus may produce additional enzymes that could be useful in enzyme bleaching systems.     

Relationship between Fungal Biomass Production and the Brightening of Hardwood Kraft Pulp by Coriolus versicolor

The white-rot fungus Coriolus versicolor increased the brightness of hardwood kraft pulp by two mechanisms depending on the concentration of available nitrogen. In low-nitrogen conditions, the brightening process was a chemical effect mediated by the fungus, associated with the removal of residual lignin in the pulp; kappa number was used as an indicator of lignin concentration. A five-day treatment in low-nitrogen conditions increased the brightness of hardwood kraft pulp from 36.2 to 54.5%, with a corresponding decrease in kappa number from 12.0 to 8.5, equivalent to a reduction in the lignin concentration from ca. 2.0% (wt/wt) to ca. 1.4% (wt/wt). Under these conditions, we concluded that the brightening of the pulp was a secondary metabolic event initiated after the depletion of available nitrogen. This method of brightening has been described as bleaching or biobleaching. By contrast, in high-nitrogen conditions, the brightening was a physical effect associated with the dilution of the dark pulp fibers by the relatively high levels of brighter fungal mycelium produced. Since this method of brightening was not evidently associated with lignin removal, it cannot be described as bleaching. In pulp samples brightened in high-nitrogen conditions, as brightness increased, there was a corresponding increase in kappa number. This observation was explained by the consumption of potassium permanganate by the fungal mycelium, which interfered with kappa number determinations at high fungal biomass levels.     

Secretion of Ligninolytic Enzymes and Mineralization of 14C-Ring-Labelled Synthetic Lignin by Three Phlebia tremellosa Strains

Production of ligninolytic enzymes by three strains of the white rot fungus Phlebia tremellosa (syn. Merulius tremellosus) was studied in bioreactor cultivation under nitrogen-limiting conditions. The Mn(II) concentration of the growth medium strongly affected the secretion patterns of lignin peroxidase and laccase. Two major lignin peroxidase isoenzymes were expressed in all strains. In addition, laccase and glyoxal oxidase were purified and characterized in one strain of P. tremellosa. In contrast, manganese peroxidase was not found in fast protein liquid chromatography profiles of extracellular proteins under either low (2.4 μM) or elevated (24 and 120 μM) Mn(II) concentrations. However, H₂O₂- and Mn-dependent phenol red-oxidizing activity was detected in cultures supplemented with higher Mn(II) levels. Mineralization rates of ¹⁴C-ring-labelled synthetic lignin (i.e., dehydrogenation polymerizate) by all strains under a low basal Mn(II) level were similar to those obtained for Phanerochaete chrysosporium and Phlebia radiata. A high manganese concentration repressed the evolution of ¹⁴CO₂ even when a chelating agent, sodium malonate, was included in the medium.     

Physiological Role of Chlorinated Aryl Alcohols Biosynthesized De Novo by the White Rot Fungus Bjerkandera sp. Strain BOS55

The white rot fungus Bjerkandera sp. strain BOS55 produces veratryl, anisyl, 3-chloroanisyl, and 3,5-dichloroanisyl alcohol and the corresponding aldehydes de novo from glucose. All metabolites are produced simultaneously with the extracellular ligninolytic enzymes and have an important physiological function in the fungal ligninolytic system. Both mono- and dichlorinated anisyl alcohols are distinctly better substrates for the extracellular aryl alcohol oxidases than veratryl alcohol. The aldehydes formed are readily recycled by reduction by washed fungal mycelium, thus creating an extracellular H₂O₂ production system regulated by intracellular enzymes. Lignin peroxidase does not oxidize the chlorinated anisyl alcohols either in the absence or in the presence of veratryl alcohol. It was therefore concluded that the chlorinated anisyl alcohols are well protected against the fungus's own aggressive ligninolytic enzymes. The relative amounts of veratryl alcohol and the chlorinated anisyl alcohols differ significantly according to the growth conditions, indicating that production of veratryl alcohol and the production of the (chlorinated) anisyl metabolites are independently regulated. We conclude that the chlorinated anisyl metabolites biosynthesized by the white rot fungus Bjerkandera sp. strain BOS55 can be purposefully produced for ecologically significant processes such as lignin degradation.     

Production of ligninolytic enzymes and synthetic lignin mineralization by the bird's nest fungus Cyathus stercoreus

Production of ligninolytic enzymes and degradation of ¹⁴C-ring labeled synthetic lignin by the white-rot fungus Cyathus stercoreus ATCC 36910 were determined under a variety of conditions. The highest mineralization rate for ¹⁴C dehydrogenative polymerizates (DHP; 38% ¹⁴CO₂ after 30 days) occurred with 1 mM ammonium tartrate as nitrogen source and 1% glucose as additional carbon source, but levels of extracellular laccase and manganese peroxidase (MnP) were low. In contrast, 10 mM ammonium tartrate with 1% glucose gave low mineralization rates (10% ¹⁴CO₂ after 30 days) but higher levels of laccase and manganese peroxidase. Lignin peroxidase was not produced by C. stercoreus under any of the studied conditions. Mn(II) at 11 ppm gave a higher rate of ¹⁴C DHP mineralization than 0.3 or 40 ppm, but the highest manganese peroxidase level was obtained with Mn(II) at 40 ppm. Cultivation in aerated static flasks gave rise to higher levels of both laccase and manganese peroxidase compared to the levels in shake cultures. 3,4-Dimethoxycinnamic acid at 500 μM concentration was the most effective inducer of laccase of those tested. The purified laccase was a monomeric glycoprotein having an apparent molecular mass of 70 kDa, as determined by calibrated gel filtration chromatography. The pH optimum and isoelectric point of the purified laccase were 4.8 and 3.5, respectively. The N-terminal amino acid sequence of C. stercoreus laccase showed close homology to the N-terminal sequences determined from other basidiomycete laccases. Information on C. stercoreus, whose habitat and physiological requirements for lignin degradation differ from many other white-rot fungi, expands the possibilities for industrial application of biological systems for lignin degradation and removal in biopulping and biobleaching processes. Received: 29 January 1999 / Received revision: 5 July 1999 / Accepted: 9 July 1999     

In Vitro Bleaching of Hardwood Kraft Pulp by Extracellular Enzymes Excreted from White Rot Fungi in a Cultivation System Using a Membrane Filter

To clarify the role of excreted extracellular enzymes during long-term incubation in a pulp biobleaching system with white rot fungi, we developed a cultivation system in which a membrane filter is used; this membrane filter can prevent direct contact between hyphae and kraft pulp, but allows extracellular enzymes to attack the kraft pulp. Phanerochaete sordida YK-624 brightened the pulp 21.4 points to 54.0% brightness after a 5-day in vitro treatment; this value was significantly higher than the values obtained with Phanerochaete chrysosporium and Coriolus versicolor after a 7-day treatment. Our results indicate that cell-free, membrane-filtered components from the in vitro bleaching system are capable of delignifying unbleached kraft pulp. Obvious candidates for filterable reagents capable of delignifying and bleaching kraft pulp are peroxidase and phenoloxidase proteins. The level of secreted manganese peroxidase activity in the filterable components was substantial during strain YK-624 in vitro bleaching. A positive correlation between the level of manganese peroxidase and brightening of the pulp was observed.     

Evaluating biopulping as an alternative application on oil palm trunk using the white-rot fungus Trametes versicolor

The objective of the research was to investigate the suitability of the white-rot fungus Trametes versicolor for biopulping using oil palm biomass as the substrate. Fungi are grown on solid-state cultures Kirk's enrichment media to determine the lignocellulolytic activities. Samples subjected to fungal pretreatment for periods of 1, 2, 3, and 4 weeks were investigated and compared to the untreated control. The crude enzyme extracts were assayed using specific substrates and enzyme activities were calculated. The highest level of laccase activity was 218.66 U/L; the peak activity of manganese peroxidase was 162.10 U/L, and lignin peroxidase is 42.56 U/L. The activity levels of cellulase and hemicellulase were insignificant in all extracts (53.30 and 1.50 U/L, respectively). When the chips were pulped mechanically the Kappa number, pulp yield, and screened pulp yield decreased significantly and paper strength increased marginally with the exposure time. Hand sheet properties were also improved significantly by fungal treatment. Weight loss, lignin loss, cellulose, and holocellulose loss were 8.45%, 9.35%, 4.58%, and 7.2%, respectively. Images from SEM seem to indicate a simultaneous type of decay pattern involving cell wall breakdown combined with lignin modification. Considering all its pulping and papermaking properties, the performance of T. versicolor is good and has potential for use in large-scale biotechnological processes.     

Removal of Aroclor 1254 by the white rot fungus Coriolus versicolor in the presence of different concentrations of Mn(IV)oxide

Lignin peroxidase (LiP) plays an active role in the biodegradation of lignin and phenolic structures resembling lignin. The role of other enzymes in the biodegradation of recalcitrant compounds, e.g. manganese(II)-peroxidase, is uncertain. Solid manganese(IV)oxide addition improved the production of manganese(II)-dependant peroxidase (MnP) and H₂O₂ and increased the rate of biodegradation of Aroclor 1254 in a nitrogen-limited medium by the white rot fungus Coriolus versicolor. MnP activity was detected 48 h after the addition of MnO₂ to the cultures and was absent in cultures that did not receive MnO₂. The rate of Aroclor 1254 removal by C. versicolor was influenced by the concentration of MnO₂. 34.5 mM concentrations only increased the H₂O₂ production. Removal of Aroclor 1254 in the absence of MnO₂ still took place which implied the presence of (LiP) or nonspecific absorption. The cultures containing 57.5 mM MnO₂ removed ca. 84% of the initial 750 mg l⁻¹ Aroclor in 6 days of incubation. Cultures with no MnO₂ and 34.5 mM removed 79 and 76%, respectively. Cultures with MnP or LiP as the dominant enzyme species removed penta- and hexachlorobiphenyls at a slower rate than tri- and tetrachlorobiphenyl.