Mouse and human granzyme B have distinct tetrapeptide specificities and abilities to recruit the bid pathway

Granzyme B is an important mediator of cytotoxic lymphocyte granule-induced death of target cells, accomplishing this through cleavage of Bid and cleavage and activation of caspases as well as direct cleavage of downstream substrates. Significant controversy exists regarding the primary pathways used by granzyme B to induce cell death, perhaps arising from the use of different protease/substrate combinations in different studies. The primary sequence of human, rat, and mouse granzymes B is well conserved, and the substrate specificity and crystal structure of the human and rat proteases are extremely similar. Although little is known about the substrate specificity of mouse granzyme B, recent studies suggest that it may differ significantly from the human protease. In these studies we show that the specificities of human and mouse granzymes B differ significantly. Human and mouse granzyme B cleave species-specific procaspase-3 more efficiently than the unmatched substrates. The distinct specificities of human and mouse granzyme B highlight a previously unappreciated requirement for Asp(192) in the acquisition of catalytic activity upon cleavage of procaspase-3 at Asp(175). Although human granzyme B efficiently cleaves human or mouse Bid, these substrates are highly resistant to cleavage by the mouse protease, strongly indicating that the Bid pathway is not a major primary mediator of the effects of mouse granzyme B. These studies provide important insights into the substrate specificity and function of the granzyme B pathway in different species and highlight that caution is essential when designing and interpreting experiments with different forms of granzyme B.     

Probing the efficiency of proteolytic events by positional proteomics

Several mass spectrometry-driven techniques allow to map the substrate repertoires and specificities of proteases. These techniques typically yield long lists of protease substrates and processed sites with (potential) physiological relevance, but in order to understand the primary function of a protease, it is important to discern bystander substrates from critical substrates. Because the former are generally processed with lower efficiency, data on the actual substrate cleavage efficiency could assist in categorizing protease substrates. In this study, quantitative mass spectrometry following metabolic proteome labeling (SILAC), combined with the isolation of N-terminal peptides by Combined Fractional Diagonal Chromatography, was used to monitor fluxes in the concentration of protease-generated neo-N-termini. In our experimental setup, a Jurkat cell lysate was treated with the human serine protease granzyme B (hGrB) for three different incubation periods. The extensive list of human granzyme B substrates previously catalogued by N-terminal Combined Fractional Diagonal Chromatography (1) was then used to assign 101 unique hGrB-specific neo-N-termini in 86 proteins. In this way, we were able to define several sites as getting efficiently cleaved in vitro and consequently recognize potential physiologically more relevant substrates. Among them the well-known hGrB substrate Bid was confirmed as being an efficient hGrB substrate next to several other potential regulators of hGrB induced apoptosis such as Bnip2 and Akap-8. Several of our proteomics results were further confirmed by substrate immunoblotting and by using peptide substrates incubated with human granzyme B.     

Human and mouse granzyme M display divergent and species-specific substrate specificities

Cytotoxic lymphocyte protease GrM (granzyme M) is a potent inducer of tumour cell death and a key regulator of inflammation. Although hGrM (human GrM) and mGrM (mouse GrM) display extensive sequence homology, the substrate specificity of mGrM remains unknown. In the present study, we show that hGrM and mGrM have diverged during evolution. Positional scanning libraries of tetrapeptide substrates revealed that mGrM is preferred to cleave after a methionine residue, whereas hGrM clearly favours a leucine residue at the P1 position. The kinetic optimal non-prime subsites of both granzymes were also distinct. Gel-based and complementary positional proteomics showed that hGrM and mGrM have a partially overlapping set of natural substrates and a diverged prime and non-prime consensus cleavage motif with leucine and methionine residues being major P1 determinants. Consistent with positional scanning libraries of tetrapeptide substrates, P1 methionine was more frequently used by mGrM as compared with hGrM. Both hGrM and mGrM cleaved α-tubulin with similar kinetics. Strikingly, neither hGrM nor mGrM hydrolysed mouse NPM (nucleophosmin), whereas human NPM was hydrolysed efficiently by GrM from both species. Replacement of the putative P1'-P2' residues in mouse NPM with the corresponding residues of human NPM restored cleavage of mouse NPM by both granzymes. This further demonstrates the importance of prime sites as structural determinants for GrM substrate specificity. GrM from both species efficiently triggered apoptosis in human but not in mouse tumour cells. These results indicate that hGrM and mGrM not only exhibit divergent specificities but also trigger species-specific functions.     

The oligomeric structure of human granzyme A is a determinant of its extended substrate specificity

The cell death-inducing serine protease granzyme A (GzmA) has a unique disulfide-linked quaternary structure. The structure of human GzmA bound to a tripeptide CMK inhibitor, determined at a resolution of 2.4 A, reveals that the oligomeric state contributes to substrate selection by limiting access to the active site for potential macromolecular substrates and inhibitors. Unlike other serine proteases, tetrapeptide substrate preferences do not correlate well with natural substrate cleavage sequences. This suggests that the context of the cleavage sequence within a macromolecular substrate imposes another level of selection not observed with the peptide substrates. Modeling of inhibitors bound to the GzmA active site shows that the dimer also contributes to substrate specificity in a unique manner by extending the active-site cleft. The crystal structure, along with substrate library profiling and mutagenesis, has allowed us to identify and rationally manipulate key components involved in GzmA substrate specificity.     

Human and murine granzyme B exhibit divergent substrate preferences

The cytotoxic lymphocyte protease granzyme B (GzmB) can promote apoptosis through direct processing and activation of members of the caspase family. GzmB can also cleave the BH3-only protein, BID, to promote caspase-independent mitochondrial permeabilization. Although human and mouse forms of GzmB exhibit extensive homology, these proteases diverge at residues predicted to influence substrate binding. We show that human and mouse GzmB exhibit radical differences in their ability to cleave BID, as well as several other key substrates, such as ICAD and caspase-8. Moreover, pharmacological inhibition of caspases clonogenically rescued human and mouse target cells from apoptosis initiated by mouse GzmB, but failed to do so in response to human GzmB. These data demonstrate that human and murine GzmB are distinct enzymes with different substrate preferences. Our observations also illustrate how subtle differences in enzyme structure can radically affect substrate selection.     

Filamin (280-kDa actin-binding protein) is a caspase substrate and is also cleaved directly by the cytotoxic T lymphocyte protease granzyme B during apoptosis

We used yeast two-hybrid screening to identify the cytoskeletal protein filamin as a ligand for the proapoptotic protease granzyme B, produced by cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Filamin was directly cleaved by granzyme B when target cells were exposed to granzyme B and the lytic protein perforin, but it was also cleaved in a caspase-dependent manner following the ligation of Fas receptors. A similar pattern of filamin cleavage to polypeptides of approximately 110 and 95 kDa was observed in Jurkat cells killed by either mechanism. However, filamin cleavage in response to granzyme B was not inhibited by the caspase inhibitor z-Val-Ala-Asp-fluoromethylketone at concentrations that abolished DNA fragmentation. Filamin staining was redistributed from the cell membrane into the cytoplasm of Jurkat cells exposed to granzyme B and perforin and following ligation of Fas receptors, coincident with the morphological changes of apoptosis. Filamin-deficient human melanoma cells were significantly (although not completely) protected from granzyme B-mediated death compared with isogenic filamin-expressing cells, both in clonogenic survival and (51)Cr release assays, whereas death from multiple other stimuli was not affected by filamin deficiency. Thus, filamin is a functionally important substrate for granzyme B, as its cleavage may account at least partly for caspase-independent cell death mediated by the granzyme.     

The structure of the pro-apoptotic protease granzyme B reveals the molecular determinants of its specificity

Granzyme B is a serine protease of the chymotrypsin fold that mediates cell death by cytotoxic lymphocytes. It is a processing enzyme, requiring extended peptide substrates containing an Asp residue. The determinants that allow for this substrate specificity are revealed in the three-dimensional structure of granzyme B in complex with a macromolecular inhibitor. The primary specificity for Asp occurs through a side-on interaction with Arg 226, a buried Arg side chain of granzyme B. An additional nine amino acids make contact with the substrate and define the granzyme B extended substrate specificity profile. The substrate determinants found in this structure are shared by other members of this protein class and help to reveal the properties that define substrate specificity.     

A Colorimetric Assay that Specifically Measures Granzyme B Proteolytic Activity: Hydrolysis of Boc-Ala-Ala-Asp-S-Bzl

The serine protease Granzyme B (GzmB) mediates target cell apoptosis when released by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) or natural killer (NK) cells. GzmB is the most studied granzyme in humans and mice and therefore, researchers need specific and reliable tools to study its function and role in pathophysiology. This especially necessitates assays that do not recognize proteases such as caspases or other granzymes that are structurally or functionally related. Here, we apply GzmB’s preference for cleavage after aspartic acid residues in a colorimetric assay using the peptide thioester Boc-Ala-Ala-Asp-S-Bzl. GzmB is the only mammalian serine protease capable of cleaving this substrate. The substrate is cleaved with similar efficiency by human, mouse and rat GzmB, a property not shared by other commercially available peptide substrates, even some that are advertised as being suitable for this purpose. This protocol is demonstrated using unfractionated lysates from activated NK cells or CTL and is also suitable for recombinant proteases generated in a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems, provided the correct controls are used. This assay is a highly specific method to ascertain the potential pro-apoptotic activity of cytotoxic molecules in mammalian lymphocytes, and of their recombinant counterparts expressed by a variety of methodologies.     

Robust substrate profiling method reveals striking differences in specificities of serum and lung fluid proteases

Proteases are candidate biomarkers and therapeutic targets for many diseases. Sensitive and robust techniques are needed to quantify proteolytic activities within the complex biological milieu. We hypothesized that a combinatorial protease substrate library could be used effectively to identify similarities and differences between serum and bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), two body fluids that are clinically important for developing targeted therapies and diagnostics. We used a concise library of fluorogenic probes to map the protease substrate specificities of serum and BALF from guinea pigs. Differences in the proteolytic fingerprints of the two fluids were striking: serum proteases cleaved substrates containing cationic residues and proline, whereas BALF proteases cleaved substrates containing aliphatic and aromatic residues. Notably, cleavage of proline-containing substrates dominated all other protease activities in both human and guinea pig serum. This substrate profiling approach provides a foundation for quantitative comparisons of protease specificities between complex biological samples.     

Granzyme B proteolyzes receptors important to proliferation and survival, tipping the balance toward apoptosis

Granzyme B is critical to the ability of natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes to induce efficient cell death of virally infected or tumor cell targets. Although granzyme B can cleave and activate caspases to induce apoptosis, granzyme B can also cause caspase-independent cell death. Thirteen prospective granzyme B substrates were identified from a cDNA expression-cleavage screen, including Hsp70, Notch1, fibroblast growth factor receptor-1 (FGFR1), poly-A-binding protein, cAbl, heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein H', Br140, and intersectin-1. Validation revealed that Notch1 is a substrate of both granzyme B and caspases, whereas FGFR1 is a caspase-independent substrate of granzyme B. Proteolysis of FGFR1 in prostate cancer cells has functionally relevant consequences that indicate its cleavage may be advantageous for granzyme B to kill prostate cancer cells. Therefore, granzyme B not only activates pro-death functions within a target, but also has a previously unidentified role in inactivating pro-growth signals to cause cell death.     

Caspase-specific and nonspecific in vivo protein processing during Fas-induced apoptosis

We generated a comprehensive picture of protease substrates in anti-Fas-treated apoptotic human Jurkat T lymphocytes. We used combined fractional diagonal chromatography (COFRADIC) sorting of protein amino-terminal peptides coupled to oxygen-16 or oxygen-18 differential labeling. We identified protease substrates and located the exact cleavage sites within processed proteins. Our analysis yielded 1,834 protein identifications and located 93 cleavage sites in 71 proteins. Indirect evidence of apoptosis-specific cleavage within 21 additional proteins increased the total number of processed proteins to 92. Most cleavages were at caspase consensus sites; however, other cleavage specificities suggest activation of other proteases. We validated several new processing events by immunodetection and by an in vitro assay using recombinant caspases and synthetic peptides containing presumed cleavage sites. The spliceosome complex appeared a preferred target, as 14 of its members were processed. Differential isotopic labeling further revealed specific release of nucleosomal components from apoptotic nuclei.     

Granzyme M is a regulatory protease that inactivates proteinase inhibitor 9, an endogenous inhibitor of granzyme B

Granzyme M is a trypsin-fold serine protease that is specifically found in the granules of natural killer cells. This enzyme has been implicated recently in the induction of target cell death by cytotoxic lymphocytes, but unlike granzymes A and B, the molecular mechanism of action of granzyme M is unknown. We have characterized the extended substrate specificity of human granzyme M by using purified recombinant enzyme, several positional scanning libraries of coumarin substrates, and a panel of individual p-nitroanilide and coumarin substrates. In contrast to previous studies conducted using thiobenzyl ester substrates (Smyth, M. J., O'Connor, M. D., Trapani, J. A., Kershaw, M. H., and Brinkworth, R. I. (1996) J. Immunol. 156, 4174-4181), a strong preference for leucine at P1 over methionine was demonstrated. The extended substrate specificity was determined to be lysine = norleucine at P4, broad at P3, proline > alanine at P2, and leucine > norleucine > methionine at P1. The enzyme activity was found to be highly dependent on the length and sequence of substrates, indicative of a regulatory function for human granzyme M. Finally, the interaction between granzyme M and the serpins alpha(1)-antichymotrypsin, alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor, and proteinase inhibitor 9 was characterized by using a candidate-based approach to identify potential endogenous inhibitors. Proteinase inhibitor 9 was effectively hydrolyzed and inactivated by human granzyme M, raising the possibility that this orphan granzyme bypasses proteinase inhibitor 9 inhibition of granzyme B.     

Subsite specificities of granzyme M: a study of inhibitors and newly synthesized thiobenzyl ester substrates

Granzyme M is a member of a family of granule serine proteases that participate in target cell death initiated by cytotoxic lymphocytes. The enzyme is almost exclusively expressed in NK cell types. Granzyme M cleaves at the carboxy side of amino acids with long, hydrophobic side chains like Met, Leu, and Nle. To further study the substrate specificity of the enzyme, a series of peptide thiobenzyl esters was synthesized. The hydrolysis of the substrates with murine and human recombinant forms of granzyme M was observed. The results show that the enzyme has a strong preference for Pro at the P2 position and Ala, Ser, or Asp at the P3 position. These results suggest that the protein residues of the S2 and S3 subsites form important binding interactions that aid in the selection of specific natural substrates for granzyme M. A series of inhibitors was also tested with granzyme M. None of the inhibitors were effective inactivators of granzyme M, including the general serine protease inhibitor, 3,4-dichloroisocoumarin, which is usually a potent inactivator of serine proteases. This suggests that inhibition of granzyme M may be difficult. Also reported for the first time is the method utilized to isolate granzyme M used in this and previous publications. The observations in this paper will be valuable in development of new potent inhibitors for granzyme M as well as assist in determining the biological function of the enzyme.     

Electrostatic reversal of serine proteinase substrate specificity.

Mouse granzyme B is a member of the chymotrypsin family of serine proteinases that has an unusual preference for cleavage of substrates following aspartate residues. We show here that granzyme B can be redesigned by a single amino acid substitution in one wall of the specificity pocket, arginine-226 to glutamate, to hydrolyze preferentially thioester substrates following basic amino acids. Amide substrates, however, were not hydrolyzed by the variant granzyme B. These results show that residue 226 is a primary determinant of granzyme B specificity and imply that additional structural components are required for catalysis of amide bonds. Molecular modeling indicated subtle variation in glutamate-226 orientation depending upon the state of protonation of the gamma-carboxylate, which may account for the secondary specificity of this enzyme for substrates containing phenylalanine. This represents the first example of electrostatic reversal of serine proteinase substrate specificity and suggests that residue 226 is a primary substrate specificity determinant in the granzyme B lineage of serine proteinases.     

Enteroviral protease 2A directly cleaves dystrophin and is inhibited by a dystrophin-based substrate analogue

Enteroviruses such as Coxsackievirus B3 can cause dilated cardiomyopathy through unknown pathological mechanism(s). Dystrophin is a large extrasarcomeric cytoskeletal protein whose genetic deficiency causes hereditary dilated cardiomyopathy. In addition, we have recently shown that dystrophin is proteolytically cleaved by the Coxsackievirus protease 2A leading to functional impairment and morphological disruption. However, the mechanism of dystrophin cleavage and the exact cleavage site remained to be identified. Antibody epitope mapping of endogenous dystrophin indicated protease 2A-mediated cleavage at the site in the hinge 3 region predicted by a neural network algorithm (human, amino acid 2434; mouse, amino acid 2427). Using site-directed mutagenesis, peptide sequencing, and fluorescence resonance energy transfer assays with recombinant dystrophin, we demonstrate that this putative site in mouse and human dystrophin is a direct substrate for the Coxsackieviral protease 2A both in vitro and in vivo. The substrate analogue protease inhibitor z-LSTT-fmk was designed based on the dystrophin sequence that interacts with the protease 2A and was found to have an IC(50) of 550 nM in vitro. Dystrophin is the first cellular substrate of the enteroviral protease 2A that was identified using by a bioinformatic approach and for which the cleavage site was molecularly mapped within living cells.     

Mitochondria at the heart of the cytotoxic attack

Granzyme B is a serine proteinase that acts as a key effector of cell death mediated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes. The enzyme is transferred from the cytotoxic cell to the pathogenic target cell where it cleaves and activates a number of substrates involved in the induction of apoptosis. However, recent evidence implicates mitochondria as playing an important role in both the initiation of apoptosis and control of substrate cleavage by granzyme B in cytotoxic T lymphocyte induced death. This review focuses on current research in this rapidly expanding field, specifically the role of mitochondria in cell death induced by components of cytotoxic granules in particular granzyme B.     

Profiling serine protease substrate specificity with solution phase fluorogenic peptide microarrays

A novel microarray-based proteolytic profiling assay enabled the rapid determination of protease substrate specificities with minimal sample and enzyme usage. A 722-member library of fluorogenic protease substrates of the general format Ac-Ala-X-X-(Arg/Lys)-coumarin was synthesized and microarrayed, along with fluorescent calibration standards, in glycerol nanodroplets on microscope slides. The arrays were then activated by deposition of an aerosolized enzyme solution, followed by incubation and fluorometric scanning. The specificities of human blood serine proteases (human thrombin, factor Xa, plasmin, and urokinase plasminogen activator) were examined. The arrays provided complete maps of protease specificity for all of the substrates tested and allowed for detection of cooperative interactions between substrate subsites. The arrays were further utilized to explore the conservation of thrombin specificity across species by comparing the proteolytic fingerprints of human, bovine, and salmon thrombin. These enzymes share nearly identical specificity profiles despite approximately 390 million years of divergent evolution. Fluorogenic substrate microarrays provide a rapid way to determine protease substrate specificity information that can be used for the design of selective inhibitors and substrates, the study of evolutionary divergence, and potentially, for diagnostic applications.     

Hip is a pro-survival substrate of granzyme B

The extended substrate specificity of granzyme B (GrB) was used to identify substrates among the chaperone superfamily. This approach identified Hsp90 and Bag1-L as novel GrB substrates, and an additional GrB cleavage site was identified in the Hsc70/Hsp70-Interacting Protein, Hip. Hsp90, Bag1L, and Hip were validated as GrB substrates in vitro, and mutational analysis confirmed the additional cleavage site in Hip. Because the role of Hip in apoptosis is unknown, its proteolysis by GrB was used as a basis to test whether it has anti-apoptotic activity. Previous work on Hip was limited to in vitro characterization; therefore, it was important to demonstrate Hip cleavage in a physiological context and to show its relevance to natural killer (NK) cell-mediated death. Hip is cleaved at both GrB cleavage sites during NK-mediated cell death in a caspase-independent manner, and its cleavage is due solely to GrB and not other granule components. Furthermore, Hip is not cleaved upon stimulation of the Fas receptor in the Jurkat T-cell line, suggesting that Hip is a substrate unique to GrB. RNA interference-mediated reduction of Hip within the K562 cell line rendered the cells more susceptible to NK cell-mediated lysis, indicating that proteolysis by GrB of Hip contributes to death induction. The small effect of RNA interference-mediated Hip deficiency on cytotoxicity is in agreement with the inherent redundancy of NK cell-mediated cell death. The identification of additional members of the chaperone superfamily as GrB substrates and the validation of Hip as an anti-apoptotic protein contribute to understanding the interplay between stress response and apoptosis.     

Granzyme B cleavage of fibronectin disrupts endothelial cell adhesion,migration and capillary tube formation

Dysregulated angiogenesis contributes to the pathogenesis of chronic inflammatory diseases. Modulation of the extracellular matrix by immune-derived proteases can alter endothelial cell–matrix interactions as well as endothelial cell sprouting, migration and capillary formation. Granzyme B is a serine protease that is expressed by a variety of immune cells, and accumulates in the extracellular milieu in many chronic inflammatory disorders that are associated with dysregulated angiogenesis. Although granzyme B is known to cleave fibronectin, an essential glycoprotein in vascular morphogenesis, the role of granzyme B in modulating angiogenesis is unknown. In the present study, granzyme B cleaved both plasma fibronectin and cell-derived fibronectin, resulting in the release of multiple fibronectin fragments. Granzyme B cleavage of fibronectin resulted in a dose-dependent reduction in endothelial cell adhesion to fibronectin as well as reduced endothelial cell migration and tubular formation. These events were prevented when granzyme B activity was inhibited by a small molecule inhibitor. In summary, granzyme B-mediated cleavage of fibronectin contributes to attenuated angiogenesis through the disruption of endothelial cell — fibronectin interaction resulting in impaired endothelial cell migration and tubular formation.     

A catalogue of putative HIV-1 protease host cell substrates

Abstract Processing of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) proteins by the HIV-1 protease is essential for HIV infectivity. In addition, several studies have revealed cleavage of human proteins by this viral protease during infection; however, no large-scale HIV-1 protease degradomics study has yet been performed. To identify putative host substrates in an unbiased manner and on a proteome-wide scale, we used positional proteomics to identify peptides reporting protein processing by the HIV-1 protease, and a catalogue of over 120 cellular HIV-1 protease substrates processed in vitro was generated. This catalogue includes previously reported substrates as well as recently described interaction partners of HIV-1 proteins. Cleavage site alignments revealed a specificity profile in good correlation with previous studies, even though the ELLE consensus motif was not cleaved efficiently when incorporated into peptide substrates due to subsite cooperativity. Our results are further discussed in the context of HIV-1 infection and the complex substrate recognition by the viral protease.