The translocation of negatively charged residues across the membrane is driven by the electrochemical potential: evidence for an electrophoresis-like membrane transfer mechanism.

The role of the membrane electrochemical potential in the translocation of acidic and basic residues across the membrane was investigated with the M13 procoat protein, which has a short periplasmic loop, and leader peptidase, which has an extended periplasmically located N-terminal tail. For both proteins we find that the membrane potential promotes membrane transfer only when negatively charged residues are present within the translocated domain. When these residues are substituted by uncharged amino acids, the proteins insert into the membrane independently of the potential. In contrast, when a positively charged residue is present within the N-terminal tail of leader peptidase, the potential impedes translocation of the tail domain. However, an impediment was not observed in the case of the procoat protein, where positively charged residues in the central loop are translocated even in the presence of the membrane potential. Intriguingly, several of the negatively charged procoat proteins required the SecA and SecY proteins for optimal translocation. The studies reported here provide insights into the role of the potential in membrane protein assembly and suggest that electrophoresis can play an important role in controlling membrane topology.     

The internal signal sequence of Escherichia coli leader peptidase is necessary, but not sufficient, for its rapid membrane assembly

Leader peptidase of Escherichia coli, a protein of 323 residues, has three hydrophobic domains. The first, residues 1-22, is the most apolar and is followed by a polar region (23-61) which faces the cytoplasm. The second hydrophobic domain (residues 62-76) spans the membrane. The third hydrophobic domain, which has a minimal apolar character, and the polar, carboxyl-terminal two-thirds of the protein are exposed to the periplasm. Deletion of either the amino terminus (residues 4-50) or the third hydrophobic region (residues 83-98) has almost no effect on the rate of leader peptidase membrane assembly, while the second hydrophobic domain is essential for insertion (Dalbey, R., and Wickner, W. (1987) Science 235, 783-787). To further define the roles of these domains, we have replaced the normal, cleaved leader sequence of pro-OmpA and M13 procoat with regions containing either the first or second apolar domain of leader peptidase. The second apolar domain supports the translocation of OmpA or coat protein across the plasma membrane, establishing its identity as an internal, uncleaved signal sequence. In addition to this sequence, we now find that leader peptidase needs either the amino-terminal domain or the third hydrophobic domain to permit its rapid membrane assembly. These results show that, although a signal sequence is necessary for rapid membrane assembly of leader peptidase, it is not sufficient.     

Use of site-directed mutagenesis to define the limits of sequence variation tolerated for processing of the M13 procoat protein by the Escherichia coli leader peptidase.

Leader peptidase cleaves the leader sequence from the amino terminus of newly made membrane and secreted proteins after they have translocated across the membrane. Analysis of a large number of leader sequences has shown that there is a characteristic pattern of small apolar residues at -1 and -3 (with respect to the cleavage site) and a helix-breaking residue adjacent to the central apolar core in the region -4 to -6. The conserved sequence pattern of small amino acids at -1 and -3 around the cleavage site most likely represents the substrate specificity of leader peptidase. We have tested this by generating 60 different mutations in the +1 to -6 domain of the M13 procoat protein. These mutants were analyzed for in vivo and in vitro processing, as well as for protein insertion into the cytoplasmic membrane. We find that in vivo leader peptidase was able to process procoat with an alanine, a serine, a glycine, or a proline residue at -1 and with a serine, a glycine, a threonine, a valine, or a leucine residue at -3. All other alterations at these sites were not processed, in accordance with predictions based on the conserved features of leader peptides. Except for proline and threonine at +1, all other residues at this position were processed by leader peptidase. None of the mutations at -2, -4, or -5 of procoat (apart from proline at -4) completely abolished leader peptidase cleavage in vivo although there were large effects on the kinetics of processing.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Distinct domains of an oligotopic membrane protein are Sec-dependent and Sec-independent for membrane insertion.

Leader peptidase of Escherichia coli spans the plasma membrane twice with its amino terminus on the periplasmic surface of the membrane and its large carboxyl-terminal domain protruding into the periplasm. To monitor the transfer of the amino terminus of leader peptidase to the periplasm, we have constructed a fusion protein between the 18-residue amino-terminal periplasmic domain of Pf3 bacteriophage coat protein and the beginning of leader peptidase. We find that neither the SecA or SecY proteins nor a transmembrane electrochemical potential is required for insertion of the amino terminus, while the transfer of the carboxyl-terminal domain of leader peptidase has these requirements. The first 35 residues of leader peptidase, which include the first hydrophobic domain and the carboxyl-terminal positively charged cluster, are sufficient to insert the amino terminus. When positively charged residues are introduced before the first transmembrane segment, translocation of the amino terminus is abolished. These studies in protein membrane topogenesis, showing that there are different requirements for amino and carboxyl termini insertion, indicate that multiple mechanisms exist even within the same protein.     

M13 procoat protein insertion into YidC and SecYEG proteoliposomes and liposomes

M13 procoat protein was one of the first model proteins used to study bacterial membrane protein insertion. It contains a signal peptide of 23 amino acid residues and is not membrane targeted by the signal recognition particle. The translocation of its periplasmic domain is independent of the preprotein translocase (SecAYEG) but requires electrochemical membrane potential and the membrane insertase YidC of Escherichia coli. We show here that YidC is sufficient for efficient membrane insertion of the purified M13 procoat protein into energized YidC proteoliposomes. When no membrane potential is applied, the insertion is substantially reduced. Only in the presence of YidC, membrane insertion occurs if bilayer integrity is preserved and membrane potential is stable for more than 20 min. A mutant of the M13 procoat protein, H5EE, with two additional negatively charged residues in the periplasmic domain inserted into YidC proteoliposomes and SecYEG proteoliposomes with equal efficiencies. We conclude that the protein can use both the YidC-only pathway and the Sec pathway. This poses the questions of how procoat H5EE is inserted in vivo and how insertion pathways are selected in the cell.     

Initial steps in protein membrane insertion. Bacteriophage M13 procoat protein binds to the membrane surface by electrostatic interaction.

Bacteriophage M13 procoat protein is synthesized on free polysomes prior to its assembly into the inner membrane of Escherichia coli. As an initial step of the membrane insertion pathway, the precursor protein interacts with the cytoplasmic face of the inner membrane. We have used oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis to study the regions of the procoat protein involved in membrane binding. We find that there is an absolute requirement for positively charged amino acids at both ends of the protein. Replacing these with negatively charged residues resulted in an accumulation of the precursor in the cytoplasm. We propose that the positively charged amino acids are directly involved in membrane binding, possibly directly to the negatively charged phospholipid head groups. This was tested in vitro with artificial liposomes. Whereas wild-type procoat interacted with these liposomes, we found that procoat mutants with negatively charged amino acids at both ends did not bind. Therefore, we conclude that newly synthesized M13 procoat protein binds electrostatically to the negatively charged inner membrane of E. coli.     

Direct evidence that the proton motive force inhibits membrane translocation of positively charged residues within membrane proteins

The M13 phage procoat protein requires both its signal sequence and its membrane anchor sequence in the mature part of the protein for membrane insertion. Translocation of its short acidic periplasmic loop is stimulated by the proton motive force (pmf) and does not require the Sec components. We now find that the pmf becomes increasingly important for the translocation of negatively charged residues within procoat when the hydrophobicity of the signal or membrane anchor is incrementally reduced. In contrast, we find that the pmf inhibits translocation of the periplasmic loop when it contains one or two positively charged residues. This inhibitory effect of the pmf is stronger when the hydrophobicity of the inserting procoat protein is compromised. No pmf effect is observed for translocation of an uncharged periplasmic loop even when the hydrophobicity is reduced. We also show that the Delta Psi component of the pmf is necessary and sufficient for insertion of representative constructs and that the translocation effects of charged residues are primarily due to the DeltaPsi component of the pmf and not the pH component.     

Positive charges in the cytoplasmic domain of Escherichia coli leader peptidase prevent an apolar domain from functioning as a signal.

Leader peptidase, an integral transmembrane protein of Escherichia coli, requires two apolar topogenic elements for its membrane assembly: a 'hydrophobic helper' and an internal signal. The highly basic cytoplasmic region between these domains is a translocation poison sequence, which we have shown blocks the function of a preceding signal sequence. We have used oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis to remove positively charged residues within this polar domain to determine if it is the basic character in this region that has the negative effect on translocation. Our results show that mutations that remove two or more of the positively charged residues within the polar region no longer block membrane assembly of leader peptidase. In addition, when the translocation poison domain (residues 30-52) is replaced with six lysine residues, the preceding apolar domain cannot function as an export signal, whereas it can with six glutamic acids. Thus, positively charged residues within membrane proteins may have a major role in determining the function of hydrophobic domains in membrane assembly.     

Both a short hydrophobic domain and a carboxyl-terminal hydrophilic region are important for signal function in the Escherichia coli leader peptidase

Leader peptidase, typical of inner membrane proteins of Escherichia coli, does not have an amino-terminal leader sequence. This protein contains an internal signal peptide, residues 51-83, which is essential for assembly and remains as a membrane anchor domain. We have employed site-directed mutagenesis techniques to either delete residues within this domain or substitute a charged amino acid for one of these residues to determine the important properties of the internal signal. The deletion analysis showed that a very small apolar domain, residues 70-76, is essential for assembly, whereas residues that flank it are dispensable for its function. However, point mutations with charged amino acid residues within the polar sequence (residues 77-82) slow or abolish leader peptidase membrane assembly. Thus, a polar region, Arg-Ser-Phe-Ile-Tyr-Glu, is important for the signal peptide function of leader peptidase, unlike other signals identified thus far.     

Polarity and Charge of the Periplasmic Loop Determine the YidC and Sec Translocase Requirement for the M13 Procoat Lep Protein

During membrane biogenesis, the M13 procoat protein is inserted into the lipid bilayer in a strictly YidC-dependent manner with both the hydrophobic signal sequence and the membrane anchor sequence promoting translocation of the periplasmic loop via a hairpin mechanism. Here, we find that the translocase requirements can be altered for PClep in a predictable manner by changing the polarity and charge of the peptide region that is translocated across the membrane. When the polarity of the translocated peptide region is lowered and the charged residues in this region are removed, translocation of this loop region occurs largely by a YidC- and Sec-independent mechanism. When the polarity is increased to that of the wild-type procoat protein, the YidC insertase is essential for translocation. Further increasing the polarity, by adding charged residues, switches the insertion pathway to a YidC/Sec mechanism. Conversely, we find that increasing the hydrophobicity of the transmembrane segments of PClep can decrease the translocase requirement for translocation of the peptide chain. This study provides a framework to understand why the YidC and Sec machineries exist in parallel and demonstrates that the YidC insertase has a limited capacity to translocate a peptide chain on its own.     

Membrane protein topology: effects of delta mu H+ on the translocation of charged residues explain the ''positive inside'' rule.

The membrane electrochemical potential is critical for the export of most periplasmic proteins in Escherichia coli. Its exact role during insertion of integral inner membrane proteins, however, remains obscure. Using derivatives of the inner membrane protein leader peptidase (Lep), we now show that the membrane potential appears to stimulate the membrane translocation of chain segments containing negatively charged residues, that positively charged regions appear to be more easily translocated in the absence of a potential, and that certain Lep constructs insert with different topologies in the presence and absence of a membrane potential, suggesting that the electrochemical potential introduces an asymmetry between the topological effects of positively and negatively charged amino acids during the process of membrane protein insertion in E. coli.     

Both hydrophobic domains of M13 procoat are required to initiate membrane insertion.

M13 procoat protein has two hydrophobic domains, one in the leader peptide and one which anchors the mature coat protein in the membrane. Disruption of the membrane anchor region by insertion of arginyl residues does not yield periplasmic coat protein. Instead, the rate of membrane assembly is slowed greater than 100-fold (t1/2 less than 5 s for wild-type, t1/2 greater than 10 min for mutant). The hydrophobic region of mature coat protein not only functions as a membrane anchor, but has an important role in the membrane assembly process per se.     

Competition between neighboring topogenic signals during membrane protein insertion into the ER

To better define the mechanism of membrane protein insertion into the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum, we measured the kinetics of translocation across microsomal membranes of the N-terminal lumenal tail and the lumenal domain following the second transmembrane segment (TM2) in the multispanning mouse protein Cig30. In the wild-type protein, the N-terminal tail translocates across the membrane before the downstream lumenal domain. Addition of positively charged residues to the N-terminal tail dramatically slows down its translocation and allows the downstream lumenal domain to translocate at the same time as or even before the N-tail. When TM2 is deleted, or when the loop between TM1 and TM2 is lengthened, addition of positively charged residues to the N-terminal tail causes TM1 to adopt an orientation with its N-terminal end in the cytoplasm. We suggest that the topology of the TM1-TM2 region of Cig30 depends on a competition between TM1 and TM2 such that the transmembrane segment that inserts first into the ER membrane determines the final topology.     

Membrane protein insertion of variant MscL proteins occurs at YidC and SecYEG of Escherichia coli

The mechanosensitive channel MscL in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli is a homopentameric complex involved in homeostasis when cells are exposed to hypoosmotic conditions. The E. coli MscL protein is synthesized as a polypeptide of 136 amino acid residues and uses the bacterial signal recognition particle for membrane targeting. The protein is inserted into the membrane independently of the Sec translocon but requires YidC. Depletion of YidC inhibits translocation of the protein across the membrane. Insertion of MscL occurs primarily in a proton motive force-independent manner. The hydrophilic loop region of MscL has 29 residues that include 5 charged residues. Altering the charges in the periplasmic loop of MscL affects the requirements for membrane insertion. The introduction of one, two or three negatively charged amino acids makes the insertion dependent on the electrochemical membrane potential and gradually dependent on the Sec translocon, whereas the addition of five negatively charged residues as well as the addition of three positively charged residues inhibits membrane insertion of MscL. However, we find that the mutant with three uncharged residues requires both the SecYEG complex and YidC but not SecA for membrane insertion. In vivo cross-linking data showed that the newly synthesized MscL interacts with YidC and with SecY. Therefore, the MscL mutants use a membrane insertion mechanism that involves SecYEG and YidC simultaneously.     

Sec dependent and sec independent assembly of E. coli inner membrane proteins: the topological rules depend on chain length.

Translocation of proteins across the inner membrane of Escherichia coli normally requires the participation of the sec machinery. A number of proteins are known, however, where translocation can proceed unhindered even when the function of either SecA or SecY, central components of the sec machinery, is blocked. We now show that there is a linear correlation between the length of a translocated region and its degree of dependence on SecA and SecY for lengths between 25 and 55 residues. We also find that positively charged residues have distinctly different topological effects during SecA dependent and SecA independent membrane protein insertion, and that a short cytoplasmic segment in Lep can be converted to a translocated segment (with a concomitant inversion of the original topology of the whole molecule) by increasing its length into the SecA/Y dependent realm.     

Cysteine residues in the transmembrane regions of M13 procoat protein suggest that oligomeric coat proteins assemble onto phage progeny

The M13 phage assembles in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli. During maturation, about 2,700 copies of the major coat protein move from the membrane onto a single-stranded phage DNA molecule that extrudes out of the cell. The major coat protein is synthesized as a precursor, termed procoat protein, and inserts into the membrane via a Sec-independent pathway. It is processed by a leader peptidase from its leader (signal) peptide before it is assembled onto the phage DNA. The transmembrane regions of the procoat protein play an important role in all these processes. Using cysteine mutants with mutations in the transmembrane regions of the procoat and coat proteins, we investigated which of the residues are involved in multimer formation, interaction with the leader peptidase, and formation of M13 progeny particles. We found that most single cysteine residues do not interfere with the membrane insertion, processing, and assembly of the phage. Treatment of the cells with copper phenanthroline showed that the cysteine residues were readily engaged in dimer and multimer formation. This suggests that the coat proteins assemble into multimers before they proceed onto the nascent phage particles. In addition, we found that when a cysteine is located in the leader peptide at the -6 position, processing of the mutant procoat protein and of other exported proteins is affected. This inhibition of the leader peptidase results in death of the cell and shows that there are distinct amino acid residues in the M13 procoat protein involved at specific steps of the phage assembly process.     

Conserved residues of the leader peptide are essential for cleavage by leader peptidase

Gene 8 of bacteriophage M13 codes for procoat, the precursor of its major coat protein. Gene 8 has been cloned into a plasmid and mutagenized. We have isolated mutants of this gene in which procoat is synthesized but is not processed to coat protein. We now describe mutants in the leader region of procoat, at positions -6, -3, and -1 with respect to the leader peptidase cleavage site. These positions are quite conserved among the leader peptides of various pre-proteins. Each of these mutant procoats is synthesized at a normal rate and inserts correctly into the plasma membrane, as judged by its accessibility to protease in intact spheroplasts. Procoat accumulates, largely in its transmembrane form, and is not cleaved to coat. In detergent extracts, the mutant procoats are very poor substrates for added leader peptidase. We conclude that these 3 residues are not conserved for insertion across the membrane but are part of an essential recognition site for the leader peptidase.     

Requirements for substrate recognition by bacterial leader peptidase.

Many secreted and membrane proteins have amino-terminal leader peptides which are essential for their insertion across the membrane bilayer. These precursor proteins, whether from prokaryotic or eukaryotic sources, can be processed to their mature forms in vitro by bacterial leader peptidase. While different leader peptides have shared features, they do not share a unique sequence at the cleavage site. To examine the requirements for substrate recognition by leader peptidase, we have truncated M13 procoat, a membrane protein precursor, from both the amino- and carboxy-terminal ends with specific proteases or chemical cleavage agents. The fragments isolated from these reactions were assayed as substrates for leader peptidase. A 16 amino acid residue peptide which spans the leader peptidase cleavage site is accurately cleaved. Neither the basic amino-terminal region nor most of the hydrophobic central region of the leader peptide are essential for accurate cleavage.     

Mechanism and hydrophobic forces driving membrane protein insertion of subunit II of cytochrome bo 3 oxidase

Subunit II (CyoA) of cytochrome bo₃ oxidase, which spans the inner membrane twice in bacteria, has several unusual features in membrane biogenesis. It is synthesized with an amino-terminal cleavable signal peptide. In addition, distinct pathways are used to insert the two ends of the protein. The amino-terminal domain is inserted by the YidC pathway whereas the large carboxyl-terminal domain is translocated by the SecYEG pathway. Insertion of the protein is also proton motive force (pmf)-independent. Here we examined the topogenic sequence requirements and mechanism of insertion of CyoA in bacteria. We find that both the signal peptide and the first membrane-spanning region are required for insertion of the amino-terminal periplasmic loop. The pmf-independence of insertion of the first periplasmic loop is due to the loop's neutral net charge. We observe also that the introduction of negatively charged residues into the periplasmic loop makes insertion pmf dependent, whereas the addition of positively charged residues prevents insertion unless the pmf is abolished. Insertion of the carboxyl-terminal domain in the full-length CyoA occurs by a sequential mechanism even when the CyoA amino and carboxyl-terminal domains are swapped with other domains. However, when a long spacer peptide is added to increase the distance between the amino-terminal and carboxyl-terminal domains, insertion no longer occurs by a sequential mechanism.     

Energetics and intermediates of the assembly of Protein OmpA into the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

OmpA is a major protein of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. It is made as a larger precursor, pro-OmpA, which requires a membrane potential for processing. We now show that pro-OmpA accumulates in the cytoplasm of cells treated with carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone, an uncouple which lowers the membrane potential. Upon restoration of the potential, this pro-OmpA is secreted, processed, and assembled into the outer membrane. Pro-OmpA made in vitro is also recovered with the postribosomal supernatant. It is efficiently processed to OmpA by liposomes which have bacterial leader peptidase that is exclusively internally oriented. These experiments show that: (i) the insertion of pro-OmpA into the plasma membrane is not coupled to its synthesis; (ii) insertion is promoted by the transmembrane electrochemical potential; (iii) pro-OmpA can cross a bilayer spontaneously; and (iv) pro-OmpA is processed by the same leader peptidase which converts M13 procoat to coat.