Fluorescent lipid probes: properties and application

This review is devoted to fluorescent lipid probes: the characteristics of their fluorophores; the main methods of their synthesis; and the potentialities, scope, and limitations of their use in studies of biological systems (cells, membranes and their models, enzymes of lipid metabolism, etc.). Particular attention is paid to the lipid specificity of the probes, i.e., the correspondence of their physicochemical characteristics and behavior in biological systems to those of natural lipids.     

Enantiomers of phospholipids and cholesterol: A key to decipher lipid-lipid interplay in membrane

Most phospholipids constituting biological membranes are chiral molecules with a hydrophilic head group and hydrophobic alkyl chains, rendering biphasic property characteristic of membrane lipids. Some lipids assemble into small domains via chirality-dependent homophilic and heterophilic interactions, the latter of which sometimes include cholesterol to form lipid rafts and other microdomains. On the other hand, lipid mediators and hormones derived from chiral lipids are recognized by specific membrane or nuclear receptors to induce downstream signaling. It is crucial to clarify the physicochemical properties of the lipid self-assembly for the study of the functions and behavior of biological membranes, which often become elusive due to effects of membrane proteins and other biological events. Three major lipids with different skeletal structures were discussed: sphingolipids including ceramides, phosphoglycerolipids, and cholesterol. The physicochemical properties of membranes and physiological functions of lipid enantiomers and diastereomers were described in comparison to natural lipids. When each enantiomer formed a self-assembly or interacted with achiral lipids, both lipid enantiomers exhibited identical membrane physicochemical properties, while when the enantiomer interacted with chiral lipids or with the opposite enantiomer, mixed membranes exhibited different properties. For example, racemic membranes comprising native sphingomyelin and its antipode exhibited phase segregation due to their strong homophilic interactions. Therefore, lipid enantiomers and diastereomers can be good probes to investigate stereospecific lipid-lipid and lipid-protein interactions occurring in biological membranes.     

Perylenoyl- and anthrylvinyl-labeled lipids as membrane probes

The properties of a new family of lipid-specific fluorescent probes, a fatty acid, a phosphatidylcholine and a sphingomyelin, bearing a 3-perylenoyl-labeled hydrophobic chain, are described. Perylenoyl-labeled lipids readily enter the lipid bilayer, the fluorophore being localized in the apolar region of the membrane. The perylenoyl fluorophore is characterized by a high quantum yield, its fluorescence parameters (λ_ex 446 nm, λ_em 479–545 nm) permit to apply it as an acceptor of excitation energy from the 9-anthrylvinyl fluorophore used earlier for phospholipid labeling (Molotkovsky, Jul. G.; Manevich, Y.M., Gerasimova, E.N., Molotkovskaya, I.M., Polessky, V.A. and Bergelson, L.D. (1982) Eur. J. Biochem. 122, 573–579). The anthrylvinyl-labeled lipids were shown to be capable to report phase segregation between the corresponding prototype lipids in model systems. The combined use of anthrylvinyl- and perylenoyl-labeled lipids opens additional possibilities for investigation of lipid-lipid and lipid-protein interactions in artificial and biological membranes. Perylenoyl-labeled lipids appeared also to be useful as fluorescent dyes in cytological studies.     

Calcium-Lipid Interactions Observed with Isotope-Edited Infrared Spectroscopy

Calcium ions bind to lipid membranes containing anionic lipids; however, characterizing the specific ion-lipid interactions in multicomponent membranes has remained challenging because it requires nonperturbative lipid-specific probes. Here, using a combination of isotope-edited infrared spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations, we characterize the effects of a physiologically relevant (2 mM) Ca²⁺ concentration on zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine and anionic phosphatidylserine lipids in mixed lipid membranes. We show that Ca²⁺ alters hydrogen bonding between water and lipid headgroups by forming a coordination complex involving the lipid headgroups and water. These interactions distort interfacial water orientations and prevent hydrogen bonding with lipid ester carbonyls. We demonstrate, experimentally, that these effects are more pronounced for the anionic phosphatidylserine lipids than for zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine lipids in the same membrane.     

Studies on mixed monolayers of phospholipids and fusogenic lipids.

1. The behaviour of mixed monolayers of 14 different lipids with preparations of erythrocyte lipids, purified natural and synthetic phospholipids, cholesterol and galactosylceramide was investigated. 2. The mean areas occupied per molecule in mixed films containing lipids that are fusogenic for hen erythrocytes were compared with those for corresponding films containing lipids that are inactive as fusogens. 3. Fusogenic lipids were found to exhibit interactions, which were not shown by non-fusogenic lipids, in mixed monolayers with several species of phospholipid, particularly those containing a choline head group. 4. Heterogeneity in the hydrophobic chains of phosphatidylcholine, their degree of unsaturation and the presence of cholesterol had little effect on the interaction of phosphatidylcholine with fusogenic lipids. 5. Fusogenic lipids showed little specific interaction with natural or synthetic preparations of phosphatidylethanolamine. 6. The possible significance of these observations in relation to the action of fusogenic lipids on biological membranes is discussed in the light of the asymmetrical distribution of phospholipids in erythrocyte membranes.     

Chemistry and biology of N-(7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl)-labeled lipids: fluorescent probes of biological and model membranes

Lipids that are covalently labeled with the 7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl (NBD) group are widely used as fluorescent analogues of native lipids in model and biological membranes to study a variety of processes. The fluorescent NBD group may be attached either to the polar or the apolar regions of a wide variety of lipid molecules. Synthetic routes for preparing the lipids, and spectroscopic and ionization properties of these probes are reviewed in this report. The orientation of various NBD-labeled lipids in membranes, as indicated by the location of the NBD group, is also discussed. The NBD group is uncharged at neutral pH in membranes, but loops up to the surface if attached to acyl chains of phospholipids. These lipids find applications in a variety of membrane-related studies which include membrane fusion, lipid motion and dynamics, organization of lipids and proteins in membranes, intracellular lipid transfer, and bilayer to hexagonal phase transition in liposomes. Use of NBD-labeled lipids as analogues of natural lipids is critically evaluated.     

Selective enzymatic radioactive and spin labelling of phospholipids in biological membranes: application to study of temperature-induced changes of microsomal phosphatidylinositols and mitochondrial polyglycerophosphatides.

A new method for the covalent radioactive and spin labelling of lipids within isolated biological membranes has been described in detail and applied to studies of temperature-induced changes of microsomal and mitochondrial membranes. The method is based on the enzymatic use of radioactive substrates carrying covalently bound doxyl derivatives of stearic acid in the biosynthesis of phospholipids in isolated membranes. Radioactive-and spin-labelled lipids bound to the microsomal and mitochondrial membranes were then used as internal probes in monitoring temperature-induced changes of these membranes. Since the analysis of isolated radioactive-and spin-labelled lipids revealed the exact composition of membrane-bound labelled lipids, specific temperature-induced changes were correlated with specific lipids of examined membranes. Phosphatidylinositol of microsomal membranes and polyglycerophosphatides (phosphatidyl-glycerol and cardiolipin) of mitochondrial and inner mitochondrial membranes were found to be involved in the apparent formation of lipid clusters at around 20-30 degrees C. Cardiolipin was found to be involved in the fluidization of inner mitochondrial membranes. These findings are discussed in view of the present state of knowledge of the organization of lipids in biological membranes.     

Depth profiling in membranes by fluorescence quenching

Membrane penetration depth is an important parameter in relation to membrane structure and organization. A methodology has been developed to analyze the membrane penetration depths of fluorescent molecules or groups utilizing differential fluorescence quenching caused by membrane embedded spin-label probes located at different depths. The method involves determination of the parallax in the apparent location of fluorophores, detected when quenching by phospholipids spin-labelled at two different depths is compared. By use of relatively simple algebraic expressions, the method allows calculation of depth in å. This method has been used to determine the location of fluorophores in NBD-labelled lipids and anthroyloxy-labelled fatty acids in model membranes and of the membrane embedded tryptophan residues in the reconstituted nicotinic acetylcholine receptor.     

Lipid regulation of cell membrane structure and function

Recent studies of structure-function relationships in biological membranes have revealed fundamental concepts concerning the regulation of cellular membrane function by membrane lipids. Considerable progress has been made in understanding the roles played by two membrane lipids: cholesterol and phosphatidyl-ethanolamine. Cholesterol has been shown to regulate ion pumps, which in some cases show an absolute dependence on cholesterol for activity. These studies suggest that an essential role that cholesterol plays in mammalian cell biology is to enable crucial membrane enzymes to provide function necessary for cell survival. Studies of phosphatidylethanolamine regulation of membrane protein activity and regulation of membrane morphology led to hypotheses concerning the roles for this particular lipid in biological membranes. New information on lipid-protein interactions and on the nature of the lipid head groups has permitted the development of mechanistic hypotheses for the regulation of membrane protein activity by phosphatidyl-ethanolamine. In addition, intermediates in the lamellar-nonlamellar phase transitions of membrane systems containing phosphatidylethanolamine, or other lipids with similar properties, have recently been implicated in facilitating membrane fusion. Finally, studies of transmembrane movement of lipids have provided new insight into the regulation of membrane lipid asymmetry and the biogenesis of cell membranes. These kinds of studies are harbingers of a new generation of progress in the field of cell membranes.     

Modulation of membrane surface curvature by peptide-lipid interactions

Recent reports on the interaction of cardiotoxin and melittin with phospholipid model membranes are reviewed and analyzed. These types of peptide toxins are able to modulate lipid surface curvature and polymorphism in a highly lipid-specific way. It is demonstrated that the remarkable variety of effects of melittin on the organization of different membrane phospholipids can be understood in a relatively simple model, based on the shape-structure concept of lipid polymorphism and taking into account the position of the peptide molecule with respect to the lipids. Based on the strong preference of the peptides for negatively charged lipids and the structural consequences thereof, and on preliminary studies of signal peptide-lipid interaction, a role of inverted or concave lipid structures in the process of protein translocation across membranes is suggested.     

Investigation on lipid asymmetry using lipid probes: Comparison between spin-labeled lipids and fluorescent lipids

Synthetic lipids with a nitroxide or a fluorescent probe have been extensively used during the last 30 years to determine the transmembrane diffusion of phospholipids in artificial or biological membranes. However, the relevance of data obtained with these modified lipids has sometimes been questioned. Beside possible artefacts introduced by the reporter probe, synthetic lipids used in cells often contain a short fatty acid chain in the sn-2 position, which gives them higher water solubility than naturally occurring lipids. In the present review, we have attempted to give a critical appraisal. Main strategies are recalled and important discoveries obtained with lipid probes on transmembrane lipid traffic in eukaryotic cells are briefly summarized. Examples of artefacts caused by lipid probes are given. Comparisons between data obtained by different techniques such as ESR and fluorescence allow us to emphasize the complementary character of the two approaches and more generally show the necessity to use several probes before drawing conclusions concerning endogenous lipids. In spite of these pitfalls, overall, lipid probes have provided a wealth of useful information that, to date, cannot be obtained with unlabeled lipids.     

Organization and dynamics of NBD-labeled lipids in lipid bilayer analyzed by FRET using the small membrane fluorescent probe AHBA as donor

Fluorescent probes are employed to investigate natural and model membranes. It is important to know probe location and extent of perturbations they cause into the lipid bilayer. Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) is a useful tool to investigate phenomena involving plasma membranes, and reports in literature used relatively large fluorophores like 1,6-diphenylhexatriene, located at the center of the hydrophobic region, 4-aminophthalimide-based molecules located at lipid/water interfaces and BODIPY-labeled phosphatidylcholine. In this work we explored FRET process in 1,2-dimyristoyl-L-α-GPC large unilamellar vesicles, in gel and fluid phase, using as donor the very small group o-Abz bound to hexadecyl chain (2-amino-N-hexadecyl-benzamide - AHBA) and 7-nitro-2-1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl (NBD) labeled lipids as acceptor. From the intensity decay of donor in presence of acceptors, the FRET efficiency was calculated, and used to fit the model proposed by Fung and Stryer to that efficiency. Using lipid bilayer structural data, the procedure allowed the determination of Förster distance for each donor-acceptor pair in vesicles, without imposing any value for the orientational factor κ². From distance distributions between o-Abz in AHBA and NBD in lipid bilayer obtained using the program CONTIN, we obtained donor-acceptor populations having different separation distances. The populations reflect the occurrence of FRET involving probes in the same or in opposite leaflet. A dynamic picture emerged showing how relative position of the probes is dependent on the structural thermal phase of the DMPC bilayer. The results emphasize the need of careful analysis in order to understand processes involving fluorescent probes in model membranes.     

Site-specific labeling of RNA with fluorophores and other structural probes

Site-specific probes provide a powerful tool for structure and function studies of nucleic acids, especially in elucidating tertiary structures of large ribozymes and other folded RNA molecules. Among many types of extrinsic labels, fluorophores are most attractive because they can provide structural information at millisecond time resolution, thus allowing real-time observation of structural transition during biological function. Methods for introducing fluorophores in RNA molecules are summarized here. These methods are robust and readily applicable to the labeling of other types of probes. However, as each case of RNA modification is unique, fine tuning of the general methodology is beneficial.     

Structure and dynamics of the phosphatidylcholine and the phosphatidylethanolamine head group in L-M fibroblasts as studied by deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance.

Mouse fibroblast L-M cells were grown in tissue culture medium containing selectively deuterated choline or ethanolamine. Both compounds were incorporated into the corresponding phospholipids at levels greater than 50% thus leading to a selective deuteration of these phospholipid head groups. Choline and ethanolamine were labeled at either the alpha- or the beta-carbon atom and well-resolved deuterium and phosphorus n.m.r. spectra were obtained from intact cells, crude plasma membranes and lipid extracts, leading to the following conclusions. (i) A large fraction, if not all, of the phospholipids in the intact L-M cell membranes were organized in a liquid crystalline bilayer. (ii) The phosphoethanolamine and the phosphocholine head group conformation were found to be remarkably similar in pure lipid bilayers and in intact L-M cell membranes with the head group dipoles being oriented parallel to the membrane surface. (iii) The deuterium T1 spin lattice relaxation times fell in the range of 7-25 ms and were similar in intact L-M cells and in pure lipid model membranes, suggesting that the two head groups are not involved in strong interactions with membrane proteins. The rotational diffusion rate of the two head groups was reduced by at least a factor of 10 compared to molecules of the same size in aqueous solution. (iv) The phosphocholine head group was sensitive to the size and sign of membrane surface charges as verified in mixing experiments with charged lipids. In L-M cell membranes the phosphocholine appeared to sense an electrically neutral environment in spite of the fact that L-M cell membranes contain 10-20% negatively charged lipids.     

NBD-cholesterol probes to track cholesterol distribution in model membranes

A series of cholesterol (Chol) probes with NBD and Dansyl fluorophores attached to the 3-hydroxyl position via carbamate linkers has been designed and synthesized and their ability to mimic the behavior of natural cholesterol in bilayer membranes has been examined. Fluorescence spectroscopy data indicate that the NBD-labeled lipids are located in the polar headgroup region of the bilayer with their position varying with the method of fluorophore attachment and the linker length. The partitioning of the Chol probes between liquid-ordered (L_o) and liquid-disordered (L_o) phases in supported bilayers prepared from ternary lipid mixtures of DOPC, Chol and either egg sphingomyelin or DPPC was examined by fluorescence microscopy. The carbamate-linked NBD-Chols show a stronger preference for partitioning into L_o domains than does a structurally similar probe with an ester linkage, indicating the importance of careful optimization of probe and linker to provide the best Chol mimic. Comparison of the partitioning of NBD probes to literature data for native Chol indicates that the probes reproduce well the modest enrichment of Chol in L_o domains as well as the ceramide-induced displacement of Chol. One NBD probe was used to follow the dynamic redistribution of Chol in phase separated membranes in response to in situ ceramide generation. This provides the first direct optical visualization of Chol redistribution during enzymatic ceramide generation and allows the assignment of new bilayer regions that exclude dye and have high lateral adhesion to ceramide-rich regions.     

Fluorescence depolarization measurements on oriented membranes.

We describe the theory and experimental application of fluorescence depolarization measurements on small molecules bound to oriented phospholipid bilayers. The results yield insight into both the orientation and the rotational motion of fluorophores in a membrane environment. To accomplish this the angular distribution of polarized fluorescence intensities is measured on a membrane preparation consisting of stacked phospholipid bilayers oriented in a known coordinate system. Considerably more information is available from this data than in comparable solution phase measurements. Three parameters are derived from the data: the rate of rotational diffusion and the second and fourth degree order parameters. These latter two parameters provide an assessment of the average distribution of fluorophore orientation in the membrane bilayer. The data have been carefully examined for systematic experimental artifacts and new protocols are presented which help to eliminate errors that have not been amply treated in the past. We present data for two types of fluorescent molecules: (a) conventional membrane probes like diphenylhexatriene, perylene and anthroyloxy fatty acids; and (b) the anticancer agent adriamycin and several congeneric anthracycline antibiotics. The results show that the hydrocarbon core of membranes is more rigid than previously thought, particularly above the thermal phase transition temperature. We also show that the orientation of small molecules is sensitive to both the phospholipid composition and to the interaction of specific functional groups with the lipid bilayer. The results are discussed in terms of energetic models describing the general patterns for the binding of small molecules to biological membranes.     

Chemical synthesis of fluorescent glycero- and sphingolipids

Glycero- and sphingolipids have been shown to be building blocks of membranes and lipoproteins, metabolites and important intermediaries in the signalling cascades involved in stress responses, proliferation of cells and also apoptosis. Investigations into the exact functions of these lipids have found that they are fundamentally more important than previously thought and that they are intricately involved in the processes of many significant metabolic pathways and diseases. Investigation of these functions requires the detection of the lipids in their natural environment within membranes. To this end, fluorescent labelling has become one of the preferred means in which to study these essential components due to the relative ease of detection. This review will look at the novel compounds that have been synthesised recently through various methodologies including classical lipid synthesis as well as the innovative application of organometallic chemistry. This field has expanded with the advancements in fluorescence detection and these lipids are being used as specific probes for an extensive range of applications in order to ascertain the mechanisms and signalling capabilities of this very important class of biological compounds.     

Methylation of ethanolamine groups in phosphoethanolamines is relevant for L-arginine insertion in lipid membranes

The interaction of L-arginine with membranes composed by phospholipids with different degrees of methylation of the ethanolamine group was studied by means of surface and dipole potentials and surface pressure variations. The subsequent methylation of the amine head group appears to hinder the synergic response of the adsorption observed in phosphatidylethanolamine membranes. The kinetics of the binding process denotes that the methyl groups are relevant in regulating the specific interaction of the amino acid with the interface by hydrogen bonds. This response can be put in correlation with the function of signal transduction assigned previously to methyl lipids [F. Hirata and J. Axelrod, 1980] and appears to be relevant to understand the mechanism of insertion of arginine residues in peptides of biological interest.     

Interaction of CAP18-derived peptides with membranes made from endotoxins or phospholipids

Antimicrobial peptides with alpha-helical structures and positive net charges are in the focus of interest with regard to the development of new antibiotic agents, in particular against Gram-negative bacteria. Interaction between seven polycationic alpha-helical CAP18-derived peptides and different types of artificial membranes composed of phosphatidylcholine or lipopolysaccharide of the Gram-negative bacterium Escherichia coli were investigated using different biophysical techniques. Results obtained from fluorescence energy transfer spectroscopy with liposomes, monolayer measurements on a Langmuir trough, and electrophysiological measurements on planar reconstituted asymmetric bilayer membranes including the lipid matrix of the outer membrane of E. coli were correlated, and these data were, furthermore, correlated with structural parameters of the peptides (net charge, alpha-helical content, hydrophobic moment, and hydrophobicity). All peptides induced current fluctuations in planar membranes due to the formation of transient lesions above a peptide- and lipid-specific minimal clamp voltage. Antibacterial activity was exhibited only by those peptides that induced lesion formation in the reconstituted outer membrane at clamp voltages below the transmembrane potential of the natural membrane. Thus, we propose that the physicochemical properties of both the peptides as well as of the target membranes are important for antibacterial activity.     

TTAPE-Me dye is not selective to cardiolipin and binds to common anionic phospholipids nonspecifically

Identification, visualization, and quantitation of cardiolipin (CL) in biological membranes is of great interest because of the important structural and physiological roles of this lipid. Selective fluorescent detection of CL using noncovalently bound fluorophore 1,1,2,2-tetrakis[4-(2-trimethylammonioethoxy)-phenylethene (TTAPE-Me) has been recently proposed. However, this dye was only tested on wild-type mitochondria or liposomes containing negligible amounts of other anionic lipids, such as phosphatidylglycerol (PG) and phosphatidylserine (PS). No clear preference of TTAPE-Me for binding to CL compared to PG and PS was found in our experiments on artificial liposomes, Escherichia coli inside-out vesicles, or Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondria in vitro or in situ, respectively. The shapes of the emission spectra for these anionic phospholipids were also found to be indistinguishable. Thus, TTAPE-Me is not suitable for detection, visualization, and localization of CL in the presence of other anionic lipids present in substantial physiological amounts. Our experiments and complementary molecular dynamics simulations suggest that fluorescence intensity of TTAPE-Me is regulated by dynamic equilibrium between emitting dye aggregates, stabilized by unspecific but thermodynamically favorable electrostatic interactions with anionic lipids, and nonemitting dye monomers. These results should be taken into consideration when interpreting past and future results of CL detection and localization studies with this probe in vitro and in vivo. Provided methodology emphasizes minimal experimental requirements, which should be considered as a guideline during the development of novel lipid-specific probes.