Evolution of structurally disordered proteins promotes neostructuralization

Protein structure is generally more conserved than sequence, but for regions that can adopt different structures in different environments, does this hold true? Understanding how structurally disordered regions evolve altered secondary structure element propensities as well as conformational flexibility among paralogs are fundamental questions for our understanding of protein structural evolution. We have investigated the evolutionary dynamics of structural disorder in protein families containing both orthologs and paralogs using phylogenetic tree reconstruction, protein structure disorder prediction, and secondary structure prediction in order to shed light upon these questions. Our results indicate that the extent and location of structurally disordered regions are not universally conserved. As structurally disordered regions often have high conformational flexibility, this is likely to have an effect on how protein structure evolves as spatially altered conformational flexibility can also change the secondary structure propensities for homologous regions in a protein family.     

Structural diversity of p63 and p73 isoforms

AbstractThe p53 protein family is the most studied protein family of all. Sequence analysis and structure determination have revealed a high similarity of crucial domains between p53, p63 and p73. Functional studies, however, have shown a wide variety of different tasks in tumor suppression, quality control and development. Here we review the structure and organization of the individual domains of p63 and p73, the interaction of these domains in the context of full-length proteins and discuss the evolutionary origin of this protein family. Facts

• Distinct physiological roles/functions are performed by specific isoforms.
• The non-divided transactivation domain of p63 has a constitutively high activity while the transactivation domains of p53/p73 are divided into two subdomains that are regulated by phosphorylation.
• Mdm2 binds to all three family members but ubiquitinates only p53.
• TAp63α forms an autoinhibited dimeric state while all other vertebrate p53 family isoforms are constitutively tetrameric.
• The oligomerization domain of p63 and p73 contain an additional helix that is necessary for stabilizing the tetrameric states. During evolution this helix got lost independently in different phylogenetic branches, while the DNA binding domain became destabilized and the transactivation domain split into two subdomains.

Open questions

• Is the autoinhibitory mechanism of mammalian TAp63α conserved in p53 proteins of invertebrates that have the same function of genomic quality control in germ cells?
• What is the physiological function of the p63/p73 SAM domains?
• Do the short isoforms of p63 and p73 have physiological functions?
• What are the roles of the N-terminal elongated TAp63 isoforms, TA* and GTA?

Subject terms: X-ray crystallography, Solution-state NMR     

Molecular dynamics of the full-length p53 monomer

The p53 protein is frequently mutated in a very large proportion of human tumors, where it seems to acquire gain-of-function activity that facilitates tumor onset and progression. A possible mechanism is the ability of mutant p53 proteins to physically interact with other proteins, including members of the same family, namely p63 and p73, inactivating their function. Assuming that this interaction might occurs at the level of the monomer, to investigate the molecular basis for this interaction, here, we sample the structural flexibility of the wild-type p53 monomeric protein. The results show a strong stability up to 850 ns in the DNA binding domain, with major flexibility in the N-terminal transactivations domains (TAD1 and TAD2) as well as in the C-terminal region (tetramerization domain). Several stable hydrogen bonds have been detected between N-terminal or C-terminal and DNA binding domain, and also between N-terminal and C-terminal. Essential dynamics analysis highlights strongly correlated movements involving TAD1 and the proline-rich region in the N-terminal domain, the tetramerization region in the C-terminal domain; Lys120 in the DNA binding region. The herein presented model is a starting point for further investigation of the whole protein tetramer as well as of its mutants.     

p63 and p73: roles in development and tumor formation

The tumor suppressor p53 is critically important in the cellular damage response and is the founding member of a family of proteins. All three genes regulate cell cycle and apoptosis after DNA damage. However, despite a remarkable structural and partly functional similarity among p53, p63, and p73, mouse knockout studies revealed an unexpected functional diversity among them. p63 and p73 knockouts exhibit severe developmental abnormalities but no increased cancer susceptibility, whereas this picture is reversed for p53 knockouts. Neither p63 nor p73 is the target of inactivating mutations in human cancers. Genomic organization is more complex in p63 and p73, largely the result of an alternative internal promoter generating NH2-terminally deleted dominant-negative proteins that engage in inhibitory circuits within the family. Deregulated dominant-negative p73 isoforms might play an active oncogenic role in some human cancers. Moreover, COOH-terminal extensions specific for p63 and p73 enable further unique protein-protein interactions with regulatory pathways involved in development, differentiation, proliferation, and damage response. Thus, p53 family proteins take on functions within a wide biological spectrum stretching from development (p63 and p73), DNA damage response via apoptosis and cell cycle arrest (p53, TAp63, and TAp73), chemosensitivity of tumors (p53 and TAp73), and immortalization and oncogenesis (DeltaNp73).     

p53 Family members p63 and p73 are SAM domain-containing proteins.

Homologs of the tumor suppressor p53, called p63 and p73, have been identified. The p63 and p73 family members possess a domain structure similar to p53, but contain variable C-terminal extensions. We find that some of the C-terminal extensions contain Sterile Alpha Motif (SAM) domains. SAM domains are protein modules that are involved in protein-protein interactions. Consistent with this role, the C-terminal SAM domains of the p63 and p73 may regulate function by recruiting other protein effectors.     

Structure and Stability Insights into Tumour Suppressor p53 Evolutionary Related Proteins

The p53 family of genes and their protein products, namely, p53, p63 and p73, have over one billion years of evolutionary history. Advances in computational biology and genomics are enabling studies of the complexities of the molecular evolution of p53 protein family to decipher the underpinnings of key biological conditions spanning from cancer through to various metabolic and developmental disorders and facilitate the design of personalised medicines. However, a complete understanding of the inherent nature of the thermodynamic and structural stability of the p53 protein family is still lacking. This is due, to a degree, to the lack of comprehensive structural information for a large number of homologous proteins and to an incomplete knowledge of the intrinsic factors responsible for their stability and how these might influence function. Here we investigate the thermal stability, secondary structure and folding properties of the DNA-binding domains (DBDs) of a range of proteins from the p53 family using biophysical methods. While the N- and the C-terminal domains of the p53 family show sequence diversity and are normally targets for post-translational modifications and alternative splicing, the central DBD is highly conserved. Together with data obtained from Molecular Dynamics simulations in solution and with structure based homology modelling, our results provide further insights into the molecular properties of evolutionary related p53 proteins. We identify some marked structural differences within the p53 family, which could account for the divergence in biological functions as well as the subtleties manifested in the oligomerization properties of this family.     

Intrinsically disordered regions of p53 family are highly diversified in evolution

Proteins of the p53 family are expressed in vertebrates and in some invertebrate species. The main function of these proteins is to control and regulate cell cycle in response to various cellular signals, and therefore to control the organism's development. The regulatory functions of the p53 family members originate mostly from their highly-conserved and well-structured DNA-binding domains. Many human diseases (including various types of cancer) are related to the missense mutations within this domain. The ordered DNA-binding domains of the p53 family members are surrounded by functionally important intrinsically disordered regions. In this study, substitution rates and propensities in different regions of p53 were analyzed. The analyses revealed that the ordered DNA-binding domain is conserved, whereas disordered regions are characterized by high sequence diversity. This diversity was reflected both in the number of substitutions and in the types of substitutions to which each amino acid was prone. These results support the existence of a positive correlation between protein intrinsic disorder and sequence divergence during the evolutionary process. This higher sequence divergence provides strong support for the existence of disordered regions in p53 in vivo for if they were structured, they would evolve at similar rates as the rest of the protein.     

Phylogeny and Function of the Invertebrate p53 Superfamily

The origin of the p53 superfamily predates animal evolution and first appears in unicellular Flagellates. Invertebrate p53 superfamily members appear to have a p63-like domain structure, which seems to be evolutionarily ancient. The radiation into p53, p63, and p73 proteins is a vertebrate invention. In invertebrate models amenable to genetic analysis p53 superfamily members mainly act in apoptosis regulation in response to genotoxic agents and do not have overt developmental functions. We summarize the literature on cnidarian and mollusc p53 superfamily members and focus on the function and regulation of Drosophila melanogaster and Caenorhabditis elegans p53 superfamily members in triggering apoptosis. Furthermore, we examine the emerging evidence showing that invertebrate p53 superfamily proteins also have functions unrelated to apoptosis, such as DNA repair, cell cycle checkpoint responses, compensatory proliferation, aging, autophagy, and innate immunity.The vertebrate p53 family of proteins consists of three members, p53, p63, and p73. p53 has received considerable attention because of the fact that it is mutated in approximately 50% of all human cancers and plays an important role in protecting cells against DNA damage and cellular stressors. p63 and p73 on the other hand, seem to be less involved in tumorigenesis but play important roles in epithelial development and neurogenesis, respectively. p53 related sequences also exist in invertebrate species. We review the functional data on invertebrate p53 superfamily proteins, largely focusing on the model organisms, Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster. Invertebrate p53 superfamily members act in apoptosis regulation in response to genotoxic agents and the deletion of invertebrate p53 superfamily proteins does not lead to overall developmental defects. Nevertheless, there is emerging evidence that invertebrate p53-like proteins also have functions unrelated to apoptosis.There has been a debate whether invertebrate p53 superfamily proteins are phylogenetically more related to vertebrate p53 or p63. Taking advantage of recent genome sequencing projects, we analyze the phylogenetic relationships of the p53 superfamily from vertebrates and invertebrates. Consistent with previous reports, our phylogenetic analysis supports the conclusion that a p63-like domain structure is evolutionarily more ancient. It thus appears that a protein with a p63-like domain structure originally evolved, possibly to mediate apoptosis of damaged cells. In vertebrates, this earlier role of p53-like proteins is largely performed by p53. However, it appears that p63 has maintained the evolutionary ancient role of apoptosis in the female germline (Suh et al. 2006)     

Analysis of molecular interactions of the p53-family p51(p63) gene products in a yeast two-hybrid system: homotypic and heterotypic interactions and association with p53-regulatory factors

p51 in the p53 tumor suppressor family, also referred to as p63, encodes multiple isoforms including p51A (TAp63gamma) and p51B (TAp63alpha). The p53 protein forms a tetramer, and its stability and activity are regulated by molecular association with viral and cellular proteins and by biochemical modifications. Using a yeast two-hybrid system, the p51A and p51B isoforms were examined for homotypic and heterotypic interactions in the p53 family proteins and for their affinity to the p53-regulatory factors. Results indicate a homotypic interaction dependent on the presumed oligomerization domain of the p51 proteins. The possibility of a weak heterotypic interaction between p51 and p73 proteins was suggested, while association between p51 and p53 appeared improbable. Furthermore, unlike p53, the p51 proteins failed to display an affinity to SV40 large T antigen or MDM2-family proteins. Having several features in common with p53, the p51 proteins may function in biological processes apart from p53.     

Gain of function of mutant p53 by coaggregation with multiple tumor suppressors

Many p53 missense mutations possess dominant-negative activity and oncogenic gain of function. We report that for structurally destabilized p53 mutants, these effects result from mutant-induced coaggregation of wild-type p53 and its paralogs p63 and p73, thereby also inducing a heat-shock response. Aggregation of mutant p53 resulted from self-assembly of a conserved aggregation-nucleating sequence within the hydrophobic core of the DNA-binding domain, which becomes exposed after mutation. Suppressing the aggregation propensity of this sequence by mutagenesis abrogated gain of function and restored activity of wild-type p53 and its paralogs. In the p53 germline mutation database, tumors carrying aggregation-prone p53 mutations have a significantly lower frequency of wild-type allele loss as compared to tumors harboring nonaggregating mutations, suggesting a difference in clonal selection of aggregating mutants. Overall, our study reveals a novel disease mechanism for mutant p53 gain of function and suggests that, at least in some respects, cancer could be considered an aggregation-associated disease.     

4-Hydroxynonenal modulation of p53 family gene expression in the SK-N-BE neuroblastoma cell line

4-Hydroxynonenal (HNE), a product of lipid peroxidation, inhibits proliferation of several tumor cells. The p53 tumor suppressor protein plays a critical role in cell cycle control, by inducing p21 expression, and in apoptosis, by inducing bax expression. Recently, two other proteins with many p53-like properties, TAp73 (p73) and TAp63 (p63), have been discovered. SK-N-BE human neuroblastoma cells express the three p53 family proteins and can be used for the study of their induction. We investigated HNE action in the control of proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis in SK-N-BE cells and the HNE effect on the expression of p53, p63, p73, p21, bax, and G1 cyclins. Retinoic acid (RA) was used as a positive control. HNE inhibited cell proliferation without inducing differentiation; it decreased S-phase cells and increased the number of apoptotic cells. RA reduced the proportion of S-phase cells and did not induce apoptosis. HNE increased p53, p73, p63, p21, and bax expression at different time points. HNE reduced cyclin D2 expression and the phosphorylation of pRb protein. Our results demonstrated that HNE inhibits SK-N-BE cell proliferation by increasing the expression of p53 family proteins and p53 target proteins which modulate cell cycle progression and apoptosis.