Photocrosslinking detects a compact, active structure of the hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme has been intensively studied for approximately 15 years, but its cleavage mechanism is not yet understood. Crystal structures reveal a Y-shaped molecule in which the cleavage site is not ideally aligned for an S(N)2 reaction and no RNA functional groups are positioned appropriately to perform the roles of acid and base or other functions in the catalysis. If the ribozyme folds to a more compact structure in the transition state, it probably does so only transiently. We have used photocrosslinking as a tool to trap hammerhead ribozyme-substrate complexes in various stages of folding. Results suggest that the two substrate residues flanking the cleavage site approach and stack upon two guanosines (G8 and G12) in domain 2, moving 10-15 A closer to domain 2 than they appear in the crystal structure. Most crosslinks obtained with the nucleotide analogues positioned in the ribozyme core are catalytically inactive; however, one cobalt(III) hexaammine-dependent crosslink of an unmodified ribozyme retains catalytic activity and confirms the close stacking of cleavage site residue C17 with nucleotide G8 in domain 2. These findings suggest that residues involved in the chemistry of hammerhead catalysis are likely located in that region containing G8 and G12.     

Model for general acid-base catalysis by the hammerhead ribozyme: pH-activity relationships of G8 and G12 variants at the putative active site

We have used nucleobase substitution and kinetic analysis to test the hypothesis that hammerhead catalysis occurs by a general acid-base mechanism, in which nucleobases are directly involved in deprotonation of the attacking 2'-hydroxyl group and protonation of the 5'-oxygen that serves as the leaving group in the cleavage reaction. We demonstrate that simultaneous substitution of two important nucleobases, G8 and G12, with 2,6-diaminopurine shifts the pH optimum of the cleavage reaction from greater than 9.5 to approximately 6.8 in two different hammerhead constructs. Controls involving substitution with other nucleobases and combinations of nucleobases at G5, G8, and/or G12 do not show this behavior. The observed changes in the pH-rate behavior are consistent with a mechanism in which N1 protonation-deprotonation events of guanine or 2,6-diaminopurine at positions 8 and 12 are essential for catalysis. Further support for the participation of G8 and G12 comes from photochemical cross-linking experiments, which show that G8 and G12 can stack upon the two substrate nucleobases at the reactive linkage, G(or U)1.1 and C17 (Heckman, J. E., Lambert, D., and Burke, J. M. (2005) Photocrosslinking detects a compact active structure of the hammerhead ribozyme, Biochemistry 44, 4148-4156). Together, these results support a model in which the hammerhead undergoes a transient conformational change into a catalytically active structure, in which stacking of G8 and G12 upon the nucleobases spanning the cleavage site provides an appropriate architecture for general acid-base catalysis. The hammerhead and hairpin ribozymes may share similarities in the organization of their active sites and their catalytic mechanism.     

When to believe what you see

The recent X-ray crystal structure of a hammerhead ribozyme derived from Schistosoma mansoni containing the rate-enhancing peripheral domain has a catalytic core that is very different from the catalytic core present in the structure of the "minimal" hammerhead, which lacks a peripheral domain (Martick and Scott, 2006). The new structure reconciles many of the disagreements between the minimal hammerhead structure and the biochemical data on the cleavage properties of chemically modified hammerheads. The new structure also emphasizes the dynamic nature of small RNA domains and provides a cautionary tale for everyone who tries to use structure to understand function.     

Characterization of a native hammerhead ribozyme derived from schistosomes

A recent re-examination of the role of the helices surrounding the conserved core of the hammerhead ribozyme has identified putative loop-loop interactions between stems I and II in native hammerhead sequences. These extended hammerhead sequences are more active at low concentrations of divalent cations than are minimal hammerheads. The loop-loop interactions are proposed to stabilize a more active conformation of the conserved core. Here, a kinetic and thermodynamic characterization of an extended hammerhead sequence derived from Schistosoma mansoni is performed. Biphasic kinetics are observed, suggesting the presence of at least two conformers, one cleaving with a fast rate and the other with a slow rate. Replacing loop II with a poly(U) sequence designed to eliminate the interaction between the two loops results in greatly diminished activity, suggesting that the loop-loop interactions do aid in forming a more active conformation. Previous studies with minimal hammerheads have shown deleterious effects of Rp-phosphorothioate substitutions at the cleavage site and 5' to A9, both of which could be rescued with Cd2+. Here, phosphorothioate modifications at the cleavage site and 5' to A9 were made in the schistosome-derived sequence. In Mg2+, both phosphorothioate substitutions decreased the overall fraction cleaved without significantly affecting the observed rate of cleavage. The addition of Cd2+ rescued cleavage in both cases, suggesting that these are still putative metal binding sites in this native sequence.     

Sequence requirements of the hammerhead RNA self-cleavage reaction.

A previously well-characterized hammerhead catalytic RNA consisting of a 24-nucleotide substrate and a 19-nucleotide ribozyme was used to perform an extensive mutagenesis study. The cleavage rates of 21 different substrate mutations and 24 different ribozyme mutations were determined. Only one of the three phylogenetically conserved base pairs but all nine of the conserved single-stranded residues in the central core are needed for self cleavage. In most cases the mutations did not alter the ability of the hammerhead to assemble into a bimolecular complex. In the few cases where mutant hammerheads did not assemble, it appeared to be the result of the mutation stabilizing an alternate substrate or ribozyme secondary structure. All combinations of mutant substrate and mutant ribozyme were less active than the corresponding single mutations, suggesting that the hammerhead contains few, if any, replaceable tertiary interactions as are found in tRNA. The refined consensus hammerhead resulting from this work was used to identify potential hammerheads present in a variety of Escherichia coli gene sequences.     

A covalent crosslink converts the hammerhead ribozyme from a ribonuclease to an RNA ligase

The hammerhead ribozyme is a more efficient ribonuclease than an RNA ligase. Under typical reaction conditions, the rate of RNA chain cleavage is approximately 100-fold faster than the rate of the reverse ligation reaction such that virtually all of the hammerhead is in its cleaved form at equilibrium. Here we show that the introduction of a crosslink away from the catalytic core of the hammerhead has little effect on the cleavage rate but dramatically increases the ligation rate, thereby making the hammerhead an efficient RNA ligase. This experiment emphasizes the role of molecular flexibility in defining the properties of a macromolecular catalyst and suggests why other small ribozymes are more efficient ligases than ribonucleases.     

Catalytic diversity of extended hammerhead ribozymes

Chimeras of the well-characterized minimal hammerhead 16 and nine extended hammerheads derived from natural viroids and satellite RNAs were constructed with the goal of assessing whether their very different peripheral tertiary interactions modulate their catalytic properties. For each chimera, three different assays were used to determine the rate of cleavage and the fraction of full-length hammerhead at equilibrium and thereby deduce the elemental cleavage ( k 2) and ligation ( k -2) rate constants. The nine chimeras were all more active than minimal hammerheads and exhibited a very broad range of catalytic properties, with values of k 2 varying by 750-fold and k -2 by 100-fold. At least two of the hammerheads exhibited an altered dependence of k obs on magnesium concentration. Since much less catalytic diversity is observed among minimal hammerheads that lack the tertiary interactions, a possible role for the different tertiary interaction is to modulate the hammerhead cleavage properties in viroids. For example, differing hammerhead cleavage and ligation rates could affect the steady state concentrations of linear, circular, and polymeric genomes in infected cells.     

The effect of structure in a long target RNA on ribozyme cleavage efficiency.

Inhibition of gene expression by catalytic RNA (ribozymes) requires that ribozymes efficiently cleave specific sites within large target RNAs. However, the cleavage of long target RNAs by ribozymes is much less efficient than cleavage of short oligonucleotide substrates because of higher order structure in the long target RNA. To further study the effects of long target RNA structure on ribozyme cleavage efficiency, we determined the accessibility of seven hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites in a target RNA that contained human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) vif - vpr . The base pairing-availability of individual nucleotides at each cleavage site was then assessed by chemical modification mapping. The ability of hammerhead ribozymes to cleave the long target RNA was most strongly correlated with the availability of nucleotides near the cleavage site for base pairing with the ribozyme. Moreover, the accessibility of the seven hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites in the long target RNA varied by up to 400-fold but was directly determined by the availability of cleavage sites for base pairing with the ribozyme. It is therefore unlikely that steric interference affected hammerhead ribozyme cleavage. Chemical modification mapping of cleavage site structure may therefore provide a means to identify efficient hammerhead ribozyme cleavage sites in long target RNAs.     

Importance of purine-pyridine hydroxyl and purine amino groups for hammerhead ribozyme cleavage

The importance of the 2′-hydroxyl and 2-amino groups of guanosine residues for the catalytic efficiency of a hammerhead ribozyme has been investigated. The three guanosines in the central core of a hammerhead ribozyme were replaced by deoxyinosine, inosine, and deoxyguanosine, and ribozymes containing these analogues were chemically synthesized. Most of the modified ribozymes are drastically descreased in their cleavage efficiency. However. deletion of the 2-amino group at G₈ (replacement with inosine, deoxyguanosine, deoxyinosine) caused little alteration in the catalytic activity relative to that obtained with the unmodified ribozyme. Whereas, deletion of the 2′-amino group at G₁₂ and G₅ (replacement with inosine, deoxyinosine, and deoxyguanosine) resulted in ribozymes with drastic decrease in the catalytic activity relative to that obtained with the unmodified ribozyme. In contrast, two uridine residues, U⁷ and U⁴, in the ribozyne sequence were replaced by deoxyuridine (dU). The dU4 complex resulted in a decrease in the catalytic rate, with relative cleavage activity that ws about half that observed for the native complex. By comparison, the dU⁷ complex exhibited a relative cleavage activity within 3.3-fold of that observed with native ribozyme/substrate complex. This result suggests that the 2′-hydroxyl group at U ⁷ is not essential for activity.

The importance of the 2′-hydroxyl, and 2-amino groups of guanosine residues for the catalytic efficiency of a hammerhead roibozyme has been investigated. Most of the modified rybozymes are drastically decreased in their cleavage efficiency. However, deletion of the 2-amino group at G₈ or deletion of the 2′-hydroxyl group at G₁₂ caused little alteration in the catalytic activity relative to that obtained with the unmodified ribozyme. In contrast, two uridine residues, U₇ and U₄, in the ribozyme sequence were replaced by deoxyuridine (dU). The U4 complex resulted in a decrease in the catalytic rate, with relative cleavage activity that was about half that observed for the native complex.     

Kinetic characterization of two I/II format hammerhead ribozymes.

Five new hammerhead ribozymes were designed that assemble through the formation of helices I and II (I/II format) instead of the more standard assembly through helices I and III (I/III format). The substrate binding and cleavage properties of such hammerheads could potentially be different due to the absence of loop II and the requirement for the entire catalytic core to assemble. Two I/II format hammerheads, HHalpha1 and HHalpha5, which show structural homogeneity on native gels, were characterized kinetically. The association rate constants of both I/II hammerheads are unusually slow compared to the rate of RNA duplex formation. The dissociation rate constants indicate that the hammerhead core destabilizes an uninterrupted RNA helix somewhat less than was observed for I/III hammerheads. Whereas the cleavage rate constant of HHalpha5 is similar to that observed for I/III hammerheads, HHalpha1 cleaves 10-fold faster than any hammerhead previously reported. The temperature and pH dependence of the cleavage rate constant of HHalpha1 are similar to those reported for I/III hammerheads, suggesting a similar mechanism of cleavage.     

An ultraviolet crosslink in the hammerhead ribozyme dependent on 2-thiocytidine or 4-thiouridine substitution.

The hammerhead domain is one of the smallest known ribozymes. Like other ribozymes it catalyzes site-specific cleavage of a phosphodiester bond. The hammerhead ribozyme has been the subject of a vast number of biochemical and structural studies aimed at determining the structure and mechanism of cleavage. Recently crystallographic analysis has produced a structure for the hammerhead. As the hammerhead is capable of undergoing cleavage within the crystal, it would appear that the crystal structure is representative of the catalytically active solution structure. However, the crystal structure conflicts with much of the biochemical data and reveals a catalytic metal ion binding site expected to be of very low affinity. Clearly, additional studies are needed to reconcile the discrepancies and provide a clear understanding of the structure and mechanism of the hammerhead ribozyme. Here we demonstrate that a unique crosslink can be induced in the hammerhead with 2-thiocytidine or 4-thiouridine substitution at different locations within the conserved core. Generation of the same crosslink with different modifications at different positions suggests that the structure trapped by the crosslink may be relevant to the catalytically active solution structure of the hammerhead ribozyme. As this crosslink appears to be incompatible with the crystal structure, this provides yet another indication that the active solution and crystal structures may differ significantly.     

Folding of the hammerhead ribozyme: pyrrolo-cytosine fluorescence separates core folding from global folding and reveals a pH-dependent conformational change

The catalytic activity of the hammerhead ribozyme is limited by its ability to fold into the native tertiary structure. Analysis of folding has been hampered by a lack of assays that can independently monitor the environment of nucleobases throughout the ribozyme-substrate complex in real time. Here, we report the development and application of a new folding assay in which we use pyrrolo-cytosine (pyC) fluorescence to (1) probe active-site formation, (2) examine the ability of peripheral ribozyme domains to support native folding, (3) identify a pH-dependent conformational change within the ribozyme, and (4) explore its influence on the equilibrium between the folded and unfolded core of the hammerhead ribozyme. We conclude that the natural ribozyme folds in two distinct noncooperative steps and the pH-dependent correlation between core folding and activity is linked to formation of the G8-C3 base pair.     

Zinc-dependent cleavage in the catalytic core of the hammerhead ribozyme: evidence for a pH-dependent conformational change

We have characterized a novel Zn²⁺-catalyzed cleavage site between nucleotides C3 and U4 in the catalytic core of the hammerhead ribozyme. In contrast to previously described divalent metal-ion-dependent cleavage of RNA, U4 cleavage is only observed in the presence of Zn²⁺. This new cleavage site has an unusual pH dependence, in that U4 cleavage products are only observed above pH 7.9 and reach a maximum yield at about pH 8.5. These data, together with the fact that no metal ion-binding site is observed in proximity to the U4 cleavage site in either of the crystal structures, point toward a pH-dependent conformational change in the hammerhead ribozyme. We have described previously Zn²⁺-dependent cleavage between G8 and A9 in the hammerhead ribozyme and have discovered that U4 cleavage occurs only after A9 cleavage. To our knowledge, this is the first example of sequential cleavage events as a possible regulatory mechanism in ribozymes.     

Role of an active site adenine in hairpin ribozyme catalysis

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA that accelerates reversible cleavage of a phosphodiester bond. Structural and mechanistic studies suggest that divalent metals stabilize the functional structure but do not participate directly in catalysis. Instead, two active site nucleobases, G8 and A38, appear to participate in catalytic chemistry. The features of A38 that are important for active site structure and chemistry were investigated by comparing cleavage and ligation reactions of ribozyme variants with A38 modifications. An abasic substitution of A38 reduced cleavage and ligation activity by 14,000-fold and 370,000-fold, respectively, highlighting the critical role of this nucleobase in ribozyme function. Cleavage and ligation activity of unmodified ribozymes increased with increasing pH, evidence that deprotonation of some functional group with an apparent pK(a) value near 6 is important for activity. The pH-dependent transition in activity shifted by several pH units in the basic direction when A38 was substituted with an abasic residue, or with nucleobase analogs with very high or low pK(a) values that are expected to retain the same protonation state throughout the experimental pH range. Certain exogenous nucleobases that share the amidine group of adenine restored activity to abasic ribozyme variants that lack A38. The pH dependence of chemical rescue reactions also changed according to the intrinsic basicity of the rescuing nucleobase, providing further evidence that the protonation state of the N1 position of purine analogs is important for rescue activity. These results are consistent with models of the hairpin ribozyme catalytic mechanism in which interactions with A38 provide electrostatic stabilization to the transition state.     

Hammerheads derived from sTRSV show enhanced cleavage and ligation rate constants

The catalytic properties of the hammerhead ribozyme embedded in the (+) strand of the satellite tobacco ringspot viral genome are analyzed with the goal of obtaining the elemental rate constants of the cleavage (k(2)) and ligation (k(-)(2)) steps. Two different chimeras combining the sTRSV (+) hammerhead and the well-characterized hammerhead 16 were used to measure the cleavage rate constant (k(2)), the rate of approach to equilibrium (k(obs) = k(2) + k(-)(2)), and the fraction of full-length hammerhead at equilibrium (k(-)(2)/k(2) + k(-)(2)). When compared to minimal hammerheads that lack the recently discovered loop I-loop II interaction, an extended format hammerhead derived from sTRSV studied here shows at least a 20-fold faster k(2) and a 1300-fold faster k(-)(2) at 10 mM MgCl(2). However, the magnesium dependence of the cleavage rate is not significantly changed. Thus, the enhanced cleavage of this hammerhead observed in vivo is due to its higher intrinsic rate and not due to its tighter binding of magnesium ions. The faster k(-)(2) of this hammerhead suggests that ligation may be used to form circular RNA genomes. This in vitro system will be valuable for experiments directed at understanding the hammerhead mechanism and the role of the loop I-loop II interaction.     

A strategy for developing a hammerhead ribozyme for selective RNA cleavage depending on substitutional RNA editing

Substitutional RNA editing plays a crucial role in the regulation of biological processes. Cleavage of target RNA that depends on the specific site of substitutional RNA editing is a useful tool for analyzing and regulating intracellular processes related to RNA editing. Hammerhead ribozymes have been utilized as small catalytic RNAs for cleaving target RNA at a specific site and may be used for RNA-editing-specific RNA cleavage. Here we reveal a design strategy for a hammerhead ribozyme that specifically recognizes adenosine to inosine (A-to-I) and cytosine to uracil (C-to-U) substitutional RNA-editing sites and cleaves target RNA. Because the hammerhead ribozyme cleaves one base upstream of the target-editing site, the base that pairs with the target-editing site was utilized for recognition. RNA-editing-specific ribozymes were designed such that the recognition base paired only with the edited base. These ribozymes showed A-to-I and C-to-U editing-specific cleavage activity against synthetic serotonin receptor 2C and apolipoprotein B mRNA fragments in vitro, respectively. Additionally, the ribozyme designed for recognizing A-to-I RNA editing at the Q/R site on filamin A (FLNA) showed editing-specific cleavage activity against physiologically edited FLNA mRNA extracted from cells. We demonstrated that our strategy is effective for cleaving target RNA in an editing-dependent manner. The data in this study provided an experimental basis for the RNA-editing-dependent degradation of specific target RNA in vivo.     

Effects of phosphorothioate and 2-amino groups in hammerhead ribozymes on cleavage rates and Mg2+ binding

Mg2+ is important for the RNase activity of the hammerhead ribozyme. To investigate the binding properties of Mg2+ to the hammerhead ribozyme, cleavage rates and CD spectra for substrates containing inosine or guanosine at the cleavage site were measured. The 2-amino group of this guanosine interfered with the rate of the cleavage reaction and did not affect the amount of Mg2+ bound to the hammerhead RNA. The kinetics and CD spectra for chemically synthesized oligoribonucleotides with a Sp or Rp phosphorothioate diester bond at the cleavage site indicated that 1 mol of Mg2+ binds to the pro-R oxygen of phosphate. The binding constant for Mg2+ was about 10(4) M-1, which represents outer-sphere complexation. The hammerhead ribozyme catalyzes the cleavage reaction via an in-line pathway. This mechanism has been proved for RNA cleavage by RNase A by using a modified oligonucleotide that has an Sp phosphorothionate bond at the cleavage site. From these results, we present the reaction pathway and a model for Mg2+ binding to the hammerhead ribozyme.     

Minimal and extended hammerheads utilize a similar dynamic reaction mechanism for catalysis

Analysis of the catalytic activity of identical mutations in the catalytic cores of nHH8, a very active "extended" hammerhead, and HH16, a less active "minimal" hammerhead, reveal that the tertiary Watson-Crick base pair between C3 and G8 seen in the recent structure of the Schistosoma mansoni extended hammerhead can be replaced by other base pairs in both backgrounds. This supports the model that both hammerheads utilize a similar catalytic mechanism but HH16 is slower because it infrequently samples the active conformation. The relative effect of different mutations at positions 3 and 8 also depends on the identity of residue 17 in both nHH8 and HH16. This synergistic effect can best be explained by transient pairing between residues 3 and 17 and 8 and 13, which stabilize an inactive conformation. Thus, mutants of nHH8 and possibly nHH8 itself are also in dynamic equilibrium with an inactive conformation that may resemble the X-ray structure of a minimal hammerhead. Therefore, both minimal and extended hammerhead structures must be considered to fully understand hammerhead catalysis.     

Role of an active site guanine in hairpin ribozyme catalysis probed by exogenous nucleobase rescue

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA with reversible phosphodiester cleavage activity. Biochemical and structural studies exclude a requirement for divalent metal cation cofactors and implicate one active site nucleobase in particular, G8, in the catalytic mechanism. Our previous work demonstrated that the cleavage activity that is lost when G8 is replaced by an abasic residue is restored when certain nucleobases are provided in solution. The specificity and pH dependence of exogenous nucleobase rescue were consistent with several models of the rescue mechanism, including general acid base catalysis, electrostatic stabilization of negative charge in the transition state or a requirement for protonation to facilitate exogenous nucleobase binding. Detailed analyses of exogenous nucleobase rescue for both cleavage and ligation reactions now allow us to refine models of the rescue mechanism. Activity increased with increasing pH for both unmodified ribozyme reactions and unrescued reactions of abasic variants lacking G8. This similarity in pH dependence argues against a role for G8 as a general base catalyst, because G8 deprotonation could not be responsible for the pH-dependent transition in the abasic variant. Exogenous nucleobase rescue of both cleavage and ligation activity increased with decreasing pH, arguing against a role for rescuing nucleobases in general acid catalysis, because a nucleobase that contributes general acid catalysis in the cleavage pathway should provide general base catalysis in ligation. Analysis of the concentration dependence of cytosine rescue at high and low pH demonstrated that protonation promotes catalysis within the nucleobase-bound ribozyme complex but does not stabilize nucleobase binding in the ground state. These results support an electrostatic stabilization mechanism in which exogenous nucleobase binding counters negative charge that develops in the transition state.     

Extension of helix II of an HIV-1-directed hammerhead ribozyme with long antisense flanks does not alter kinetic parameters in vitro but causes loss of the inhibitory potential in living cells.

When designed to cleave a target RNA in trans, the hammerhead ribozyme contains two antisense flanks which form helix I and helix III by pairing with the complementary target RNA. The sequences forming helix II are contained on the ribozyme strand and represent a major structural component of the hammerhead structure. In the case of an inhibitory 429 nucleotides long trans-ribozyme (2as-Rz12) which was directed against the 5'-leader/gag region of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), helix II was not pre-formed in the single-stranded molecule. Thus, major structural changes are necessary before cleavage can occur. To study whether pre-formation of helix II in the non-paired 2as-Rz12 RNA could influence the observed cleavage rate in vitro and its inhibitory activity on HIV-1 replication, we extended the 4 base pair helix II of 2as-Rz12 to 6, 10, 21, and 22 base pairs respectively. Limited RNase cleavage reactions performed in vitro at 37 degrees C and at physiological ion strength indicated that a helix II of the hammerhead domain was pre-formed when its length was at least six base pairs. This modification neither affected the association rate with target RNA nor the cleavage rate in vitro. In contrast to this, extension of helix II led to a significantly decreased inhibition of HIV-1 replication in human cells. Together with the finding of others that shortening of helix II to less than two base pairs reduces the catalytic activity in vitro, this observation indicates that the length of helix II in the naturally occurring RNAs with a hammerhead domain is already close or identical to the optimal length for catalytic activity in vitro and in vivo.