Structure and plasticity of the human immunodeficiency virus gp41 fusion domain in lipid micelles and bilayers

A thorough understanding of the structure of fusion domains of enveloped viruses in changing lipid environments helps us to formulate mechanistic models on how they might function in mediating viral entry by membrane fusion. We have expressed the N-terminal fusion domain of HIV-1 gp41 as a construct that is water-soluble in the absence of membranes, but that also binds with high affinity to lipid micelles and bilayers in their presence. We have solved the structure and studied the dynamics of this domain bound to dodecylphosphocholine micelles by homo- and heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. The fusion peptide forms a stable hydrophobic helix from Ile(4) to Ala(14), but is increasingly more disordered and dynamic in a segment of intermediate polarity that stretches from Ala(15) to Ser(23). When bound to lipid bilayers at low concentration, the HIV fusion domain is also largely alpha-helical, as determined by CD and FTIR spectroscopy. However, at higher protein/lipid ratios, the domain is partially converted to form beta-structures in lipid bilayers. Controlled lipid mixing occurs at concentrations that support the alpha-helical, but not the beta-strand conformation.     

Mechanisms of Initiation of Membrane Fusion: Role of Lipids

Main emphasis in studies on the mechanisms of fusion of cellular membranes has been in the roles of various proteins, with far less interest in the properties of lipids. Yet, on a molecular level fusion involves the merging of lipid bilayers. Studies so far have revealed lipids forming inverted non-lamellar phases to be important in controlling membrane fusion. However, the underlying molecular level mechanisms have remained controversial. While this review is focused on presenting one possible mechanism, involving so-called extended lipid conformation, we are also advocating the view, that in order to obtain a more complete understanding of this process it is necessary to merge the relevant physicochemical properties of lipids with the models describing the specific functions of proteins. To this end, taking into account the central importance of fusion in a wide range of cellular processes, we may anticipate its control to open novel possibilities also for therapeutic intervention.     

pH-dependent fusion of phosphatidylcholine small vesicles. Induction by a synthetic amphipathic peptide

A synthetic, amphipathic 30-amino acid peptide with the major repeat unit Glu-Ala-Leu-Ala (GALA) was designed to mimic the behavior of the fusogenic sequences of viral fusion proteins. GALA is a water-soluble peptide with an aperiodic conformation at neutral pH and becomes an amphipathic alpha-helix as the pH is lowered to 5.0 where it interacts with bilayers. Fluorescence energy transfer measurements indicated that GALA induced lipid mixing between phosphatidylcholine small unilamellar vesicles but not large unilamellar vesicles. This lipid mixing occurred only at pH 5.0 and not at neutral pH. Concomitant with lipid mixing, the vesicles increased in diameter from 500 to 750 to 1000 A as measured by dynamic light scattering and internal volume determination. GALA induced leakage of small molecules (Mr 450) at pH 5.0 was too rapid to permit detection of contents mixing. However, retention of larger molecules (Mr 4100) under the same conditions suggests that vesicle fusion is occurring. For a 100/1 lipid/peptide ratio all vesicles fused just once, whereas for a 50/1 ratio higher order fusion products formed. A mass action model gives good simulation of the kinetics of increase in fluorescence intensity and yields rate constants of aggregation and fusion. As the lipid to peptide ratio decreases from 100/1 to 50/1 both rate constants of aggregation and fusion increase, indicating that GALA is a genuine inducer of vesicle fusion. The presence of divalent cations which can alter GALAs conformation at pH 7.5 had little effect on its lipid mixing activity. GALA was modified by altering the sequence while keeping the amino acid composition constant or by shortening the sequence. These peptides did not have any lipid mixing activity nor did they induce an increase in vesicle size. Together, these results indicate that fusion of phosphatidylcholine small unilamellar vesicles induced by GALA requires both a peptide length greater than 16 amino acids as well as a defined topology of the hydrophobic residues.     

Rabies virus-induced membrane fusion pathway

Fusion of rabies virus with membranes is triggered at low pH and is mediated by the viral glycoprotein (G). The rabies virus-induced fusion pathway was studied by investigating the effects of exogenous lipids having various dynamic molecular shapes on the fusion process. Inverted cone-shaped lysophosphatidylcholines (LPCs) blocked fusion at a stage subsequent to fusion peptide insertion into the target membrane. Consistent with the stalk-hypothesis, LPC with shorter alkyl chains inhibited fusion at lower membrane concentrations and this inhibition was compensated by the presence of oleic acid. However, under suboptimal fusion conditions, short chain LPCs, which were translocated in the inner leaflet of the membranes, considerably reduced the lag time preceding membrane merging, resulting in faster kinetics of fusion. This indicated that the rate limiting step for fusion is the formation of a fusion pore in a diaphragm of restricted hemifusion. The previously described cold-stabilized prefusion complex was also characterized. This intermediate is at a well-advanced stage of the fusion process when the hemifusion diaphragm is destabilized, but lipid mixing is still restricted, probably by a ring-like complex of glycoproteins. I provide evidence that this state has a dynamic character and that its lipid organization can reverse back to two lipid bilayers.     

Evidence for the extended phospholipid conformation in membrane fusion and hemifusion

Molecular-level mechanisms of fusion and hemifusion of large unilamellar dioleoyl phosphatidic acid/phosphocholine (DOPA/DOPC, 1:1 molar ratio) vesicles induced by millimolar Ca2+ and Mg2+, respectively, were investigated using fluorescence spectroscopy. In keeping with reduction of membrane free volume Vf, both divalent cations increased the emission polarization for 1,6-diphenyl-1,3, 5-hexatriene (DPH). An important finding was a decrease in excimer/monomer emission intensity ratio (Ie/Im) for the intramolecular excimer-forming probe 1, 2-bis[(pyren-1-)yl]decanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (bis-PDPC) in the course of fusion and hemifusion. Comparison with another intramolecular excimer-forming probe, namely, 1-[(pyren-1)-yl]decanoyl-2-[(pyren-1)-yl]tetradecanoyl-sn-gl ycero-3-p hosphocholine (PDPTPC), allowed us to exclude changes in acyl chain alignment to be causing the decrement in Ie/Im. As a decrease in Vf should increase Ie/Im for bis-PDPC and because contact site between adhering liposomes was required we conclude the most feasible explanation to be the adoption of the extended conformation (P.K.J., Chem. Phys. Lipids 63:251-258) by bis-PDPC. In this conformation the two acyl chains are splaying so as to become embedded in the opposing leaflets of the two adhered bilayers, with the headgroup remaining between the adjacent surfaces. Our data provide evidence for a novel mechanism of fusion of the lipid bilayers.     

Oligomerization of Fusogenic Peptides Promotes Membrane Fusion by Enhancing Membrane Destabilization

A key element of membrane fusion reactions in biology is the involvement of specific fusion proteins. In many viruses, the proteins that mediate membrane fusion usually exist as homotrimers. Furthermore, they contain extended triple-helical coiled-coil domains and fusogenic peptides. It has been suggested that the coiled-coil domains present the fusogenic peptide in a conformation or geometry favorable for membrane fusion. To test the hypothesis that trimerization of fusogenic peptide is related to optimal fusion, we have designed and synthesized a triple-stranded coiled-coil X31 peptide, also known as the ccX31, which mimics the influenza virus hemagglutinin fusion peptide in the fusion-active state. We compared the membrane interactive properties of ccX31 versus the monomeric X31 fusogenic peptide. Our data show that trimerization enhances peptide-induced leakage of liposomal contents and lipid mixing. Furthermore, studies using micropipette aspiration of single vesicles reveal that ccX31 decreases lysis tension, τ_lysis, but not area expansion modulus, K_a, of phospholipid bilayers, whereas monomeric X31 peptide lowers both τ_lysis and K_a. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that oligomerization of fusogenic peptide promotes membrane fusion, possibly by enhancing localized destabilization of lipid bilayers.     

Conformational dynamics of a lipid-interacting protein: MD simulations of saposin B

Saposin B is a water soluble alpha-helical protein which can bind to membranes and extract selected lipids, especially cerebroside sulfates. The X-ray structure of saposin B is homodimeric. There are two conformations of the dimer in the crystal-one with a closed central cavity (the AB dimer) and one (the CD dimer) with a more open cavity. We have conducted a series of short (5 ns) molecular dynamics simulations of saposin B, starting from both the AB and CD conformations and with/without bound lipid and/or water molecules within the central hydrophobic cavity. The more open (CD) dimer showed greater conformational drift than the AB dimer. The conformational drift was also somewhat higher in the absence of bound lipid. Two more extended (30 ns) simulations of AB and CD dimers were performed and analyzed in terms of changes in intersubunit packing within the dimers. The AB dimer remained largely unchanged in conformation over the duration of the extended simulation. In contrast, the CD dimer underwent a substantial conformational change corresponding to a 'scissor' motion of the two monomers so as to compress the central cavity to a more closed conformation than that seen in the AB dimer structure. A H-bond between the Q53 and Y54 side chains of the alpha3 helices of the two opposing monomers seems to hold the dimer in this 'scissor-closed' conformation. We suggest that a cycle of conformational changes, expanding and compressing the central cavity of the saposin B dimer, may play a key role in facilitating lipid extraction from bilayers.     

Structure of polymerizable lipid bilayers. I--1,2-bis(10,12-tricosadiynoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, a tubule-forming phosphatidylcholine

This report presents the first X-ray diffraction data on diacetylenic phospholipids. The tubule-forming polymerizable lipid, 1,2-bis(10,12-tricosadiynoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DC8,9PC), was studied by low angle X-ray diffraction from partially dehydrated oriented multibilayers in both polymerized and unpolymerized form. Bilayers of this material were found to be highly ordered, yielding as many as 16 orders of lamellar diffraction, in both the polymerized and unpolymerized states. The unit cell dimension was very small for a lipid of this size. In addition to the features usually observed in the electron density profile structure of phospholipid bilayers, the electron-dense diacetylenic portions of the fatty acyl chain produced electron density maxima at two well-defined levels on each side of the bilayer approximately 15 A and 9 A from the bilayer midplane. A model molecular conformation deduced from the one-dimensional electron density map features all-trans acyl chains tilted at approximately 28 degrees from the bilayer normal that are interdigitated with chains of the opposing monolayer by approximately two carbons at the bilayer center. The linear diacetylene moieties on beta- and gamma-chains appear at different positions along the bilayer normal axis and are roughly parallel to the bilayer surface. This model is discussed in terms of a polymerization mechanism.     

Differential Association of Syntrophin Pairs with the Dystrophin Complex

While the specificity and timing of membrane fusion in diverse physiological reactions, including virus–cell fusion, is determined by proteins, fusion always involves the merger of membrane lipid bilayers. We have isolated a lipid-dependent stage of cell–cell fusion mediated by influenza hemagglutinin and triggered by cell exposure to mildly acidic pH. This stage preceded actual membrane merger and fusion pore formation but was subsequent to a low pH–induced change in hemagglutinin conformation that is required for fusion. A low pH conformation of hemagglutinin was required to achieve this lipid-dependent stage and also, downstream of it, to drive fusion to completion. The lower the pH of the medium applied to trigger fusion and, thus, the more hemagglutinin molecules activated, the less profound was the dependence of fusion on lipids. Membrane-incorporated lipids affected fusion in a manner that correlated with their dynamic molecular shape, a characteristic that determines a lipid monolayer's propensity to bend in different directions. The lipid sensitivity of this stage, i.e., inhibition of fusion by inverted cone–shaped lysophosphatidylcholine and promotion by cone-shaped oleic acid, was consistent with the stalk hypothesis of fusion, suggesting that fusion proteins begin membrane merger by promoting the formation of a bent, lipid-involving, stalk intermediate.     

Bilayer conformation of fusion peptide of influenza virus hemagglutinin: a molecular dynamics simulation study

Unraveling the conformation of membrane-bound viral fusion peptides is essential for understanding how those peptides destabilize the bilayer topology of lipids that is important for virus-cell membrane fusion. Here, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were performed to investigate the conformation of the 20 amino acids long fusion peptide of influenza hemagglutinin of strain X31 bound to a dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) bilayer. The simulations revealed that the peptide adopts a kinked conformation, in agreement with the NMR structures of a related peptide in detergent micelles. The peptide is located at the amphipathic interface between the headgroups and hydrocarbon chains of the lipid by an energetically favorable arrangement: The hydrophobic side chains of the peptides are embedded into the hydrophobic region and the hydrophilic side chains are in the headgroup region. The N-terminus of the peptide is localized close to the amphipathic interface. The molecular dynamics simulations also revealed that the peptide affects the surrounding bilayer structure. The average hydrophobic thickness of the lipid phase close to the N-terminus is reduced in comparison with the average hydrophobic thickness of a pure dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine bilayer.     

Theoretical conformational analysis of phospholipids bilayers

We present a computational approach describing the conformation of lipid molecules (1-2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3 phosphocholine (DPPC)) organized in bilayers. The classical semi-empirical method used in peptide conformational analysis has been extended successfully to lipids. The excellent agreement between our theoretical predictions and recent experimental data on the molecular organization of lipid bilayers suggests that the method could be a valuable tool in the lipid conformational analysis but also in the prediction of orientation and mode of insertion of amphiphilic molecules into the lipid bilayer.     

Membrane fusion in cells: molecular machinery and mechanisms

Membrane fusion is a sine qua non process for cell physiology. It is critical for membrane biogenesis, intracellular traffic, and cell secretion. Although investigated for over a century, only in the last 15 years, the molecular machinery and mechanism of membrane fusion has been deciphered. The membrane fusion event elicits essentially three actors on stage: anionic phospholipids - phosphatidylinositols, phosphatidyl serines, specific membrane proteins, and the calcium ions, all participating in a well orchestrated symphony. Three soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor (NSF)-attachment protein receptors (SNAREs) have been implicated in membrane fusion. Target membrane proteins, SNAP-25 and syntaxin (t- SNARE) and secretory vesicle-associated membrane protein (v-SNARE) or VAMPwere discovered in the 1990's and suggested to be the minimal fusion machinery. Subsequently, the molecular mechanism of SNARE-induced membrane fusion was discovered. It was demonstrated that when t-SNARE-associated lipid membrane is exposed to v-SNARE-associated vesicles in the presence of Ca(2+), the SNARE proteins interact in a circular array to form conducting channels, thus establishing continuity between the opposing bilayers. Further it was proved that SNAREs bring opposing bilayers close to within a distance of 2-3 Angstroms, allowing Ca(2+) to bridge them. The bridging of bilayers by Ca(2+) then leads to the expulsion of water between the bilayers at the contact site, allowing lipid mixing and membrane fusion. Calcium bridging of opposing bilayers leads to the release of water, both from the water shell of hydrated Ca(2+) ions, as well as the displacement of loosely coordinated water at the phosphate head groups in the lipid membrane. These discoveries provided for the first time, the molecular mechanism of SNARE-induced membrane fusion in cells. Some of the seminal discoveries are briefly discussed in this minireview.     

A theoretical model for lipid mixtures, phase transitions, and phase diagrams.

We present a new model for the thermodynamic properties of lipid bilayers. The model consists of a system of hard cylinders of varying radii that correspond to the different molecular radii of lipids having different numbers of gauche rotations in their chains. Scaled particle theory is used to provide an accurate estimate of the entropy of packing of the cylinders. To apply the model to bilayers we introduce a semiempirical attractive potential energy. Once the form of this potential is chosen, we adjust one parameter, the interaction strength, so that the model fits the transition temperatures and entropies for various phospholipids. The model then agrees quite well with other published data for these systems. We also directly generalize our model to lipid mixtures, and we obtain phase diagrams that we compare to existing data for these systems. We use the model to describe lipid protein interactions in bilayers as well.     

Secondary structure, orientation, oligomerization, and lipid interactions of the transmembrane domain of influenza hemagglutinin

Influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA), the viral envelope glycoprotein that mediates fusion between the viral and cellular membranes, is a homotrimer of three subunits, each containing two disulfide-linked polypeptide chains, HA(1) and HA(2). Each HA(2) chain spans the viral membrane with a single putative transmembrane alpha-helix near its C-terminus. Fusion experiments with recombinant HAs suggest that this sequence is required for a late step of membrane fusion, as a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored analogue of HA only mediates "hemifusion" of membranes, i.e., the merging of the proximal, but not distal, leaflets of the two juxtaposed lipid bilayers [Kemble et al. (1994) Cell 76, 383-391]. To find a structural explanation for the function of the transmembrane domain of HA(2) in membrane fusion, we have studied the secondary structure, orientation, oligomerization, and lipid interactions of a synthetic peptide representing the transmembrane segment of X:31 HA (TMX31) by circular dichroism and attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and by gel electrophoresis. The peptide was predominantly alpha-helical in detergent micelles and in phospholipid bilayers. The helicity was increased in lipid bilayers composed of acidic lipids compared to pure phosphatidylcholine bilayers. In planar lipid bilayers, the helices were oriented close to the membrane normal. TMX31 aggregated into small heat-resistant oligomers composed of two to five subunits in SDS micelles. Amide hydrogen exchange experiments indicated that a large fraction of the helical residues were accessible to water, suggesting the possibility that TMX31 forms pores in lipid bilayers. Finally, the peptide increased the acyl chain order in lipid bilayers, which may be related to the preferential association of HA with lipid "rafts" in the cell surface and which may be an important prerequisite for complete membrane fusion.     

Osmotic control of bilayer fusion

We have used photography and capacitance measurement to monitor the steps in the interaction and eventual fusion of optically black lipid bilayers (BLMs), hydrostatically bulged to approximately hemispherical shape and pushed together mechanically. A necessary first step is drainage of aqueous solution from between the bilayers to allow close contact of the bilayers. The drainage can be controlled by varying the osmotic difference across the bilayers. If the differences are such as to remove water from between the bilayers, fusion occurs after a time that depends on the net osmotic difference and the area of contact. If there is an osmotic flow of water into the space between the bilayers, fusion never occurs. In the fusion process, a single central bilayer forms from the original apposed pair of bilayers. The central bilayer may later burst to allow mixing of the two volumes originally bounded by the separate bilayer; the topological equivalent of exocytosis.     

Phase equilibria in the phosphatidylcholine-cholesterol system

A thermodynamic and a microscopic interaction model are proposed to describe the phase equilibria in the phosphatidylcholine-cholesterol system. The model calculations allow for a solid phase with conformationally ordered acyl chains and liquid phases with conformationally ordered as well as disordered chains. The resulting phase diagram is in excellent agreement with the experimental phase diagram for dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers with cholesterol as determined by a recent NMR and calorimetry study. It is thus demonstrated that the phase behaviour of phosphatidylcholine-cholesterol mixtures can be rationalized using only a few basic assumptions: (i) Cholesterol interacts favourably with phosphatidylcholine chains in an extended conformation, (ii) the main transition of pure phosphatidylcholine bilayers takes place in terms of translational variables as well acyl-chain conformational variables, and (iii) cholesterol disturbs the translational order in the crystalline (gel) state of phosphatidylcholine. These results suggest that the occurrence of specific phosphatidylcholine-cholesterol complexes is not implied by the experimental thermodynamic data.     

Effect of lipid composition on the "membrane response" induced by a fusion peptide

To understand the initial stages of membrane destabilization induced by viral proteins, the factors important for binding of fusion peptides to cell membranes must be identified. In this study, effects of lipid composition on the mode of peptides' binding to membranes are explored via molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the peptide E5, a water-soluble analogue of influenza hemagglutinin fusion peptide, in two full-atom hydrated lipid bilayers composed of dimyristoyl- and dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC and DPPC, respectively). The results show that, although the peptide has a common folding motif in both systems, it possesses different modes of binding. The peptide inserts obliquely into the DMPC membrane mainly with its N-terminal alpha helix, while in DPPC, the helix lies on the lipid/water interface, almost parallel to the membrane surface. The peptide seriously affects structural and dynamical parameters of surrounding lipids. Thus, it induces local thinning of both bilayers and disordering of acyl chains of lipids in close proximity to the binding site. The "membrane response" significantly depends upon lipid composition: distortions of DMPC bilayer are more pronounced than those in DPPC. Implications of the observed effects to molecular events on initial stages of membrane destabilization induced by fusion peptides are discussed.     

Analysis of membrane fusion as a two-state sequential process: evaluation of the stalk model

We propose a model that accounts for the time courses of PEG-induced fusion of membrane vesicles of varying lipid compositions and sizes. The model assumes that fusion proceeds from an initial, aggregated vesicle state ((A) membrane contact) through two sequential intermediate states (I(1) and I(2)) and then on to a fusion pore state (FP). Using this model, we interpreted data on the fusion of seven different vesicle systems. We found that the initial aggregated state involved no lipid or content mixing but did produce leakage. The final state (FP) was not leaky. Lipid mixing normally dominated the first intermediate state (I(1)), but content mixing signal was also observed in this state for most systems. The second intermediate state (I(2)) exhibited both lipid and content mixing signals and leakage, and was sometimes the only leaky state. In some systems, the first and second intermediates were indistinguishable and converted directly to the FP state. Having also tested a parallel, two-intermediate model subject to different assumptions about the nature of the intermediates, we conclude that a sequential, two-intermediate model is the simplest model sufficient to describe PEG-mediated fusion in all vesicle systems studied. We conclude as well that a fusion intermediate "state" should not be thought of as a fixed structure (e.g., "stalk" or "transmembrane contact") of uniform properties. Rather, a fusion "state" describes an ensemble of similar structures that can have different mechanical properties. Thus, a "state" can have varying probabilities of having a given functional property such as content mixing, lipid mixing, or leakage. Our data show that the content mixing signal may occur through two processes, one correlated and one not correlated with leakage. Finally, we consider the implications of our results in terms of the "modified stalk" hypothesis for the mechanism of lipid pore formation. We conclude that our results not only support this hypothesis but also provide a means of analyzing fusion time courses so as to test it and gauge the mechanism of action of fusion proteins in the context of the lipidic hypothesis of fusion.     

Lipid Tail Protrusion in Simulations Predicts Fusogenic Activity of Influenza Fusion Peptide Mutants and Conformational Models

Fusion peptides from influenza hemagglutinin act on membranes to promote membrane fusion, but the mechanism by which they do so remains unknown. Recent theoretical work has suggested that contact of protruding lipid tails may be an important feature of the transition state for membrane fusion. If this is so, then influenza fusion peptides would be expected to promote tail protrusion in proportion to the ability of the corresponding full-length hemagglutinin to drive lipid mixing in fusion assays. We have performed molecular dynamics simulations of influenza fusion peptides in lipid bilayers, comparing the X-31 influenza strain against a series of N-terminal mutants. As hypothesized, the probability of lipid tail protrusion correlates well with the lipid mixing rate induced by each mutant. This supports the conclusion that tail protrusion is important to the transition state for fusion. Furthermore, it suggests that tail protrusion can be used to examine how fusion peptides might interact with membranes to promote fusion. Previous models for native influenza fusion peptide structure in membranes include a kinked helix, a straight helix, and a helical hairpin. Our simulations visit each of these conformations. Thus, the free energy differences between each are likely low enough that specifics of the membrane environment and peptide construct may be sufficient to modulate the equilibrium between them. However, the kinked helix promotes lipid tail protrusion in our simulations much more strongly than the other two structures. We therefore predict that the kinked helix is the most fusogenic of these three conformations.     

Differences in hydrocarbon chain tilt between hydrated phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylcholine bilayers. A molecular packing model.

Both wide-angle and lamellar x-ray diffraction data are interpreted in terms of a difference in hydrocarbon chain tilt between fully hydrated dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and dipalmitoyl phosphatidylethanolamine (DPPE). Although the hydrocarbon chains of multilayers of DPPC tilt ty approximately 30 degrees relative to the normal to the plane of the bilayer, as previously reported by others, the hydrocarbon chains of DPPE appear to be oriented approximately normal to the plane of the bilayer. It is found that the chain tilt in DPPC bilayers can be reduced by either: (a) adding an n-alkane to the bilayer interiors or (b) adding lanthanum ions to the fluid layers between bilayers. A molecular packing model is presented which accounts for these data. According to this model, DPPC chains tilt because of the size and conformation of the PC polar head group.