The role of cell-cell contact in "contact" inhibition of cell division: a review and new evidence

The term “contact inhibition of cell division” was borrowed from “contact inhibition of cell movement.” We prefer the term “postconfluence inhibition of cell division” as being more operational and less mechanistically biased; it is operationally defined as a pronounced depression of the mitotic rate in a postconfluent culture which displays a stationary density despite periodic nutrient renewal, the inhibition being locally reversibly by removal of the adjacent cells. The mechanism of postconfluence inhibition is of considerable interest because of the inverse correlation between postconfluence inhibition and the tumorigenicity of a number of cell lines. Several hypotheses, involving direct cell-to-cell contacts or locally restricted diffusion gradiens, could explain postconfluence inhibition. With the goal of discriminating among these hypotheses, time-lapse films were taken of carefully regulated, perfused cultures of 3T3 mouse cells, in which the transition from rapid growth to the stationary phase was recorded. Measurements of cell-to-cell contact, local cell density, and generation times were made on an individual cell level and analyzed with the aid of a computer. We observed that all-around cell-cell contact or a high local cell density present throughout G1 often did not produce immediate inhibition of cell division. We conclude that either (i) simple visible cell-cell contacts or a high local cell density are not the direct cause of postconfluence inhibition of cell division, or (ii) their effects often do not inhibit cell division until after a delay of about one cell generation time. Such a delay may be partly responsible for the 50% overshoot past the stationary density that we observed in 3T3 cultures.     

Contact inhibition of what? An analytical review

Quite a number of phenomena having to do with cells' influences upon one another's movements have come to be regarded as expressions of “contact inhibition.” However, no single, central mechanism has been shown to underlie them all. Consequently, the term “contact inhibition” should not be used without operational modifiers. Inhibitions of individual cell movements imputed to be mediated by cell-cell contacts include inhibition of overlapping (which results in monolayering), of colony expansion, of cell speed (nuclear translocation), of ruffling, of orthogonal movement (proposed to explain spontaneous parallel alignment of cells), and of neighbor exchanges. The six inhibitions listed above are operationally distinct, and only two (overlapping and colony expansion) are known to result from a common mechanism. A seventh phenomenon, so-called “contact inhibition of cell division” (more operationally termed postconfluence inhibition of cell division) is in a separate category and is not considered here. Evidence eliminating action-at-a-distance is available only for the first three, and hence only these should at present be termed contact inhibitions. Inhibition of neighbor exchanges is yet hypothetical; at its extreme, it would immobilize cells in a confluent monolayer, but such immobilization has been found not to occur. Contact inhibition of overlapping, the most studied of the six, is not displayed by invasive cells with respect to normal cells; invasive tumor cells overlap freely upon normal cells, although not necessarily upon one another. Contact inhibition of overlapping, and its loss by invasive cells, can readily be interpreted, by means of the differential adhesion hypothesis, as consequences of cell-type-specific differences in cell-cell and cell-substratum “strengths of adhesion.” These strengths of adhesion are formulated as specific interfacial free energies, which are the only parameters of cellular adhesiveness that have been rigorously shown to determine equilibrium configurations of cell populations.     

Comprehension of attachment and multiplication properties by observing individual cell behaviors in anchorage-dependent culture

The behavioral properties of cell attachment and division were characterized by direct observation of individual cells in the culture of murine fibroblasts. At the cell attachment stage in the culture for early 10 h, the extent of cell spreading, which was defined as a ratio of the projected area of each cell against its saturated value, had a relatively broad distribution at 0.25 h, and it shifted to a higher level with elapsed time up to 10 h with narrowing in the distribution. The critical value of the extent of cell spreading was determined to be 0.54 as a threshold at which a cell is assumed to complete its adhesion to culture surface. The ratio of the number of cells with the extent of cell spreading over 0.54 against the total number of examined cells fairly followed the profile of cell adhesion which was obtained by measuring the number of adherent cells on culture surface.

At the cell growth stage in the culture for 20–64 h, doubling time of cell population increased gradually as the culture progressed toward confluence. Generation times (or cell-dividing spans) of individual cells, however, did not show a discriminating dependency on cell concentration and culture time. To clarify the influence of local congestion on the cell division, the generation time was formulated as a function of the number of contact cells around each target cell. Applying the cell placement growth model to estimating the extent of contact inhibition, the reciprocal value of doubling time could be correlated with the average of reciprocal generation times, implying that the doubling time on a cell-population basis is explained by considering the variation in dividing spans of individual cells affected by local contact environment.     

Flattening,movement and control of division of epithelial-like cells

The kinetics of cell division and movement in four epithelial-like cell lines, grown in continuously perfused culture medium, were studied by time-lapse cinemicrography. One line exhibited “contact regulation of cell division,” so that the rate of mitosis per cell decreased steadily as population density increased. In the other three lines mitosis was not controlled as a function of population density until the cells became very crowded. An explanation for this difference was sought in terms of the hypothesis that the rate of division depends on the area of the cell membrane. Cells of the contact-regulated line flattened uniformly on the substrate. Their motility was restrained by adhesion between their borders. As they crowded together, contact inhibition of cell overlap caused a steady decrease in average surface area per cell. All three of the non-controlled lines also had contact inhibition of overlap. Cells of two of them flattened on the substrate; but these cells had little mutual adhesion and were highly motile, so that they continually changed their shapes. The areas of their cell membranes were therefore not subject to a restraint that could control the rate of division. Cells of the fourth line remained rounded or only slightly flattened during culture growth, so that no change in cell membrane area occurred that could change the rate of division.     

Analysis of pigmentation in individual cultured plant cells using an image processing system

Anthocyanin accumulation in strawberry (Fragaria ananassa) cells cultured on a solid medium was monitored using an image-processing system that did not require direct sampling or destruction of the cells. Because of the intercellular heterogeneity of secondary metabolite production in plant cell cultures, the maximum metabolite concentration in individual cells is often more than 10 times higher than that of the average concentration. An image-processing based method enabled the growth and the pigmentation behavior of individual cells to be traced. Changes in the time courses of the anthocyanin content of individual cells differed from each other, although the average anthocyanin contents increased gradually with time in a batch culture. However, these various changing patterns in the anthocyanin content of each cell were independent of the cell cycle. In addition, image analysis revealed that the two cells just after cell division were almost identical to each other both in size and anthocyanin content. The proposed method which uses an image-processing system provides a useful tool for analyzing the secondary metabolism in individual cultured plant cells.     

Locomotory behavior, contact inhibition, and pattern formation of 3T3 and polyoma virus-transformed 3T3 cells in culture

The social behavior of 3T3 cells and their polynoma virus-transformed derivative (Py3T3 cells) was examined by time-lapse cinemicrography in order to determine what factors are responsible for the marked differences in the patterns formed by the two cell lines in culture. Contrary to expectations, both cell types have been found to exhibit contact inhibition of cell locomotion. Therefore, the tendency of 3T3 cells to form monolayers and of Py3T3 cells to form crisscrossed multilayers cannot be explained on the basis of the presence versus the absence of contact inhibition. Morevover, with the exception of cell division control, the social behavior of the two cell types is qualitively similar. Both exhibit cell underlapping and, after contact between lamelliopodia, both show inhibition of locomotory activity and adhesion formation. Neither cell type was observed to migrate over the surface of another cell. The two cell types do show quantitative differences in the frequency of underlapping, the frequency with which contact results in inhibition of locomotion, and the proportion of the cell margin that adheres to the substratum. The increased frequency pf Py3T3 underlapping is correlated with the reduced frequency of substratum adhesions, which in turn favors underlapping. On the basis of these observations, it is concluded that the differences in culture patterns are the result of differences in the shapes of the individual cells, such that underlapping, and hence crisscrossing, is favored in Py3T3 cell interactions and discouraged in 3T3 cells.     

Phosphorylation-dephosphorylation of retinoblastoma protein not necessary for passage through the mammalian cell division cycle

Phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein (Rb) during the G1-phase of the mammalian cell division cycle is currently believed to be a controlling element regulating the passage of cells into S-phase. We find, however, that the suspension-grown cell lines U937, L1210, and MOLT-4 contain exclusively hyperphosphorylated Rb. Furthermore, when adherent NIH3T3 cells are grown at very low densities to avoid overgrowth and contact inhibition, they also contain only hyperphosphorylated Rb. NIH3T3 cells exhibit hypophosphorylation when the cells are grown at moderate to high cell densities. We propose that cultures of adherent cells such as NIH3T3, when grown to moderate cell densities, are made up of two populations of cells: (a) cells that are relatively isolated and therefore growing exponentially without contact inhibition, and (b) cells that are growth-inhibited by local cell density or contact inhibition. The common observation in adherent cell lines, that Rb is both hyper- and hypophosphorylated in the G1-phase and only hyperphosphorylated in the S- and G2-phases, is explained by the effects of cell density and contact inhibition. Thus, phosphorylation-dephosphorylation of Rb protein during the G1 phase is not a necessary process during the NIH3T3, L1210, MOLT-4, and U937 division cycles. We propose that phosphorylation-dephosphorylation of Rb is independent of the division cycle and is primarily determined by growth conditions throughout the division cycle.     

Sloppy size control of the cell division cycle

In an asynchronous, exponentially proliferating cell culture there is a great deal of variability among individual cells in size at birth, size at division and generation time (= age at division). To account for this variability we assume that individual cells grow according to some given growth law and that, after reaching a minimum size, they divide with a certain probability (per unit time) which increases with increasing cell size. This model is called sloppy size control because cell division is assumed to be a random process with size-dependent probability. We derive general equations for the distribution of cell size at division, the distribution of generation time, and the correlations between generation times of closely related cells. Our theoretical results are compared in detail with experimental results (obtained by Miyata and coworkers) for cell division in fission yeast, Schizosaccharomyces pombe. The agreement between theory and experiment is superior to that found for any other simple models of the coordination of cell growth and division.     

Growth control in miniclones of human glial cells

An improved method for the production of haptotactic palladium islands is described. Tissue culture dishes were coated with a thin layer of agarose, which was air-dried. Palladium was evaporated, using electron-microscope grids for masking. When seeded on such dishes, glial cell attachment and spreading was entirely confined to the palladium-coated areas. The method allowed the analysis of the clonal growth of several hundreds of glial cells seeded on 7 200 and 12 500 μm² squares. It was found that the mass population consisted of cells with widely differing potentials for clonal growth. A fraction of non-dividing cells increased with increasing passage level. Eventually, after more than a week of incubation, proliferation ceased on the squares although a considerable part of the periphery of the marginal cells was free of contacts with other cells. The finding is compatible with the idea that restriction of cell spreading, and not cell contact, may cause density-dependent inhibition of proliferation.     

Biphasic calcium response of platelet-derived growth factor stimulated glioblastoma cells is a function of cell confluence.

BACKGROUND: Previous reports have linked the spiking or two-phased character of calcium transients evoked by platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) to the position of cells in the cell cycle without regard to cell-cell contact and communication. Because cell confluence can regulate growth factor receptor expression and dephosphorylation, we investigated the effect of cell culture confluence and cell cycle on calcium responses of PDGF-BB-stimulated A172 glioblastoma cells. METHODS: Digital imaging cytometry was used to correlate the peak and duration of calcium response with bromodeoxyuridine positivity and DNA content and with culture confluence on a cell-by-cell basis. RESULTS: In serum-starved cultures, complete two-phase calcium signals and shorter, lower spikes occurred independent of cell cycle phase. However, the confluence of cell culture seemed essential for inducing a complete response because cells in sparse cultures exhibited mostly short spikes with lower peaks or no transients at all. CONCLUSION: Because cell confluence, by virtue of cell-cell contacts, is assumed to be an important regulator of proliferation, one is tempted to speculate that in transformed cells the ability to produce stronger growth signals upon reaching confluence and facing contact inhibition could provide a proliferative advantage.     

The relation of karyotypic change to loss of contact inhibition of division in human diploid cells after SV40 infection

Following in vitro infection of human cell cultures with simian virus 40, karyotypic analyses were performed on the earliest serial culture in which cells were released from contact inhibition of division. In these cultures of diploid fibroblast-like cells, normal karyotypes were found in excess of the statistical expectation for the number of background dividing cells. Thus, loss of contact inhibition of cell division occurs prior to the alteration of chromosome morphology. These events are two of the prime alterations in the series of steps comprising transformation by this virus. The chromosomal changes which were present represent the first cytological alteration detectable. Their distribution in the human karyotype was examined, but was found to have no relation to any specific chromosome or chromosome group.     

Adhesion, alignment, and migration of cultured Schwann cells on ultrathin fibronectin fibres

Individual fibres of fibronectin (Fn-fibres), an extracellular matrix cell adhesion glycoprotein, were produced from a purified solution of fibronectin. These fibres range from 0.5-7 microm in width and have been engineered to produce mats (Fn-mats) by using a unidirectional shear force to orientate the fibres. Fn-fibres have been shown to promote alignment by contact guidance of human dermal fibroblasts, neurites, macrophages, and epitenon fibroblasts. Fn-mats have been used to orientate and enhance the regeneration of peripheral nerve components. We investigated cell spreading, orientation, formation of focal contacts, and the speed of cell movement on individual Fn-fibres, glass-covered with poly-L-lysine and poly-L-lysine/laminin/Fn. Fibronectin fibres significantly promoted cell spreading and the speed of cell migration with alignment of focal contacts and F-actin filaments to the axis of the fibres. The study reveals the potential of Fn-fibres to guide and direct cellular behaviour by contact guidance. The increase in migration and other behaviour exhibited by Schwann cells on Fn-fibres justifies the use of Fn-mats for peripheral nerve repair and is clinically important in that atrophy of the target organ, which is the most common failure of nerve repair, may be minimised.     

Effects of androgen and antiandrogen on growth, morphology and synthesis of specific proteins in mouse mammary carcinoma cells

Primary cell cultures derived from an androgen-dependent mouse mammary carcinoma, the Shionogi SC-115 tumor, display characteristic changes in growth, morphology and protein synthesis according to the presence or absence of testosterone. In the presence of testosterone, cell proliferation was increased and cells formed characteristic clones having no contact inhibition. Ultrastructural studies of cells showed close contacts of plasma membranes having little or no gap between cells. Some cells were related by bridges of extracellular matrix. Testosterone-induced synthesis of several intracellular and secreted proteins was observed after [35S]methionine-labeling of cells, SDS-PAGE and autoradiography, as well as the disappearance of a protein in androgen-treated cells. In the absence of testosterone, cells grow as a monolayer, have contact inhibition and flattened morphology. The ultrastructurally observed cell-to-cell contacts were usually less intimate, showing spaces of irregular width between cells. None of the testosterone-induced proteins were observed in the absence of hormone. The antiandrogen cyproterone acetate, which by itself was inactive, completely suppressed the androgen-induced effects on growth, morphology and specific protein synthesis. Glycosylation of membrane proteins, as measured after labeling of cells with [3H]N-acetyl-D-glucosamine, was increased by approximately 30% in the presence of testosterone. A similar observation was made in situ by autoradiography on intact cells. Finally, we found that culture medium conditioned by testosterone-treated Shionogi cells had significant mitogenic activity on L-929 mouse fibroblasts.     

Stimulating the proliferation of quiescent 3T3 fibroblasts by peptide growth factors or by agents which elevate cellular cyclic AMP level has opposite effects on motility

The effects of some chemically defined growth factors on the locomotion of quiescent Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts have been studied. A computer digitiser has been used to facilitate recording the paths followed by cells in time-lapse films; this method allows 500 cell-hours to be recorded in 1 h of real time. Individual cells in the same culture vary widely in speed. This variation is not associated with the positions of the cells in the cell cycle; a small deceleration which seems to occur in G2 cannot account for any significant part of the variation seen. Nor is it related to the time elapsing before the cell divides, although this is equally variable; the speed and age at division of particular cells appear to be entirely independent of one another. Nevertheless, good reproducibility is seen between the mean speeds of large numbers of cells from the same type of culture. The mean speed of quiescent cells is less than 2 microns/h. A mixture of epidermal growth factor (EGF) and vasopressin, in the presence of insulin, is known to be a potent promoter of proliferation in this system. We have found it to increase speed to 30 microns/h. Agents which stimulate the cellular level of cAMP are also known to be potent promoters of proliferation in the presence of insulin. We have found these agents to be inhibitors of locomotion; several cycles of cell division take place while the cells move at a speed no greater than that seen in the presence of cytochalasin B (CB) or colchicine. These findings therefore give further support to the idea that there may be two different classes of growth-promoting factors, with major differences in their mode of action. They show that some members of these two different classes have opposite effects on motility.     

Surface ATPase activity at cell-cell contacts in hepatic parenchymal cells and in cAMP-treated hepatoma cells in monolayer culture.

Histochemical investigation shows that ATPase activity is located intensively on the surface of cell contacts in hepatoma cells grown in confluent monolayer culture. Dibutyryl cyclic AMP and theophylline-treated hepatoma cells which exhibit contact-inhibited growth show the absence of localization of intense ATPase activity at cell-cell contacts. However, after removal of these additives the activity fully recovers to the intense level of control cells, when the release of cells from contact inhibition of growth occurs. Cultured hepatic parenchymal cells in monolayer have little or no ATPase activity at their surface immediately after contacts are established, and again after growth to a confluent state. In a different type of hepatoma cell which is less malignant and forms a small tissue mass or island, cell surface ATPase activity at cell-cell contacts in an island is very weak or scarcely detected even when cells are not treated with dibutyryl cyclic AMP and theophylline.     

Stepwise effects of cytokinin activity and DNA synthesis upon mitotic cycle events in partially synchronized tobacco cells

Cytokinin addition to tobacco cell suspensions induced synchronous cell division after an 18 h lag period. Although continuous presence of the cytokinin in the culture medium during this lag period was essential to division, cytokinin was not required during mitosis itself. For each cell generation, cytokinin-dependent events are thus completed before mitosis occurs.Two experiments suggested that these cytokinin-dependent events are independent of DNA synthesis:

1. (i) With or without cytokinin, DNA synthesis proceeded normally in the presence of auxin, for at least the time required for one cell generation in complete medium.

2. (ii) In the presence of cytokinin, when DNA synthesis in the lag period was inhibited by FUdR, one normal cell division occurred when cytokinin was withdrawn and DNA synthesis restored by thymidine addition.

In cytokinin-starved cells, metaphase was greatly prolonged although prophase was unaffected.     

The catalytic activity of the Src family kinases is required to disrupt cadherin-dependent cell-cell contacts

Despite the importance of epithelial cell contacts in determining cell behavior, we still lack a detailed understanding of the assembly and disassembly of intercellular contacts. Here we examined the role of the catalytic activity of the Src family kinases at epithelial cell contacts in vitro. Like E- and P-cadherin, Ca(2+) treatment of normal and tumor-derived human keratinocytes resulted in c-Yes (and c-Src and Fyn), as well as their putative substrate p120(CTN), being recruited to cell-cell contacts. A tyrosine kinase inhibitor with selectivity against the Src family kinases, PD162531, and a dominant-inhibitory c-Src protein that interferes with the catalytic function of the endogenous Src kinases induced cell-cell contact and E-cadherin redistribution, even in low Ca(2+), which does not normally support stable cell-cell adhesion. Time-lapse microscopy demonstrated that Src kinase inhibition induced stabilization of transiently formed intercellular contacts in low Ca(2+). Furthermore, a combination of E- and P-cadherin-specific antibodies suppressed cell-cell contact, indicating cadherin involvement. As a consequence of contact stabilization, normal cells were unable to dissociate from an epithelial sheet formed at high density and repair a wound in vitro, although individual cells were still motile. Thus, cadherin-dependent contacts can be stabilized both by high Ca(2+) and by inhibiting Src activity in low (0.03 mM) Ca(2+) in vitro.     

The need for direct cell contact in "contact" inhibition of cell division in culture

Non-dividing mouse embryo fibroblasts which grew to a confluent cell density on one side of an ultra-thin filter did not inhibit the active multiplication of the same type of cells growing at low cell density on the other side of the filter directly opposite the confluent side. The close proximity of the cells across the filter was not sufficient to cause inhibition of cell division. The phenomenon of “contact” or “density dependent” inhibition of cell division is therefore probably not mediated by a cellular product which remains concentrated near the cell surface. The degree of contact inhibition of cell division was correlated with the local cell density on the same side of the filter. This relationship was found to be influenced strongly by the surface on which the cells were growing.     

Recovery of Saccharomyces cerevisiae mating-type a cells from G1 arrest by alpha factor.

Mating-type a cells of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae that had been specifically arrested in the G1 phase of the cell cycle by alpha factor, an oligopeptide pheromone made by alpha cells, recovered and resumed cell division after a period of inhibition which was dependent on the concentration of alpha factor used. These treated a cells were more resistant to alpha factor than untreated a cells, but lost their resistance upon further cell division. However, cells arrested for 6 h were no more resistant to alpha factor than cells arrested for only 2.5 h. Mating-type a strains could inactivate or remove alpha factor from the culture fluid, but two a sterile (nonmating) mutants and an a/alpha diploid strain could not. These results suggest that a cells have a mechanism, which may involve uptake or inactivation of alpha factor, for recovering from alpha factor arrest. However, the results do not distinguish between a recovery mechanism which is constitutive and one which is induced by alpha factor. The loss of alpha factor activity during recovery appeared to be primarily cell contact mediated, although an extracellular, diffusible inhibitor of alpha factor that is labile or that functions stoichiometrically could not be ruled out.     

Contact regulation of cell division in an epithelial-like cell line

The rate of cell division in an epithelial-like cell line, 1S1, was examined by time-lapse cinemicrography. When precautions were taken to insure a sufficient nutrient supply, the number of mitoses per unit time in any given area of a confluent monolayer remained constant. This “contact regulation of cell division” resulted in a steadily decreasing frequency of mitosis per cell as the culture became crowded. With the decrease was associated a gradual change in cell shape, from maximally flattened to maximally compact, due to contact inhibition of the movement of cells across one another. When cells were removed along a line scraped on a dense culture, the cells at the edge of the scrape flattened, migrated into the vacant area, and subsequently increased their frequency of mitosis to that characteristic of non-confluent cells. Inhibition of mitosis caused by a limitation on the nutrient supply was also reversed at a line-scrape. These observations suggest that cell flattening promoted mitosis by causing the cell membrane to expand, thereby facilitating the uptake of nutrients. The cell membrane would thus function in the mechanism of contact regulation as a transducer, for converting the pressure of the surrounding cell population into a restraining force upon the metabolism of cell division.