Mixed culture of killer and sensitive Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains in batch and continuous fermentations

This paper presents a kinetic study of the dynamics of the population of two Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains (designated K1 and 522D) in mixed culture. These two strains are commonly used in wine making. The K1 strain (killer yeast) secretes a glycoprotein (killer toxin) which causes the death of the 522D strain (sensitive yeast). Initially, the mixed cultures were realized in batch fermentations. Initial concentrations of killer yeast were 5 and 10% of the total population. The influence of the killer strain on the sensitive cultures was measured in comparison with a reference fermentation. The reference fermentation was inoculated only with the sensitive strain. Results show that an initial concentration of 10% of killer strain affects the microbial population balance and the rate of ethanol production. However the fermentation was only slightly disturbed when the proportion of killer to sensitive yeast at the beginning of mixed culture was 5%. To achieve total displacement by the killer yeast at low concentrations, the mixed cultures were carried out in a continuous system. The results obtained in continuous fermentations with the same strains have shown that a level of contamination as low as 0.8% of killer strain was sufficient to completely displace the original sensitive population after 150 h incubation.     

Kinetic study and mathematical modelling of killer and sensitive S. Cerevisiae strains growing in mixed culture

This paper presents a kinetic study of two yeasts growing in pure and mixed batch cultures. Two winemaking strains were used: S. cerevisiae K1 possessing the K2 killer character and S. cerevisiae 522D sensitive to the K2 killer toxin. Initially the kinetics of growth of the two strains were analysed in pure culture. In this case, the kinetic profiles of biomass production have shown that the growth rate of the K1 strain is slightly superior to the 522D strain. During the fermentation, the viability for both populations was higher than 90%. Fermentations in mixed culture with an initial percentage in killer strain of 5 and 10% with respect to the total population were carried out. The results showed a more important decrease in the percentage of total viable yeasts when the initial concentration of killer yeast increased. However, the kinetic profiles of total biomass (killer plus sensitive yeasts) were very similar for both fermentations. A mathematical model was proposed to simulate the microbial growth of the killer and sensitive strain developing in pure and mixed cultures. This mathematical model consists in three main reactions: the evolution of the killer toxin in the culture medium, the duplication and the mortality rates for each microbial population. The results of the simulation appeared in agreement with the experimental data.     

Nitrogen availability of grape juice limits killer yeast growth and fermentation activity during mixed-culture fermentation with sensitive commercial yeast strains.

The competition between selected or commercial killer strains of type K2 and sensitive commercial strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae was studied under various conditions in sterile grape juice fermentations. The focus of this study was the effect of yeast inoculation levels and the role of assimilable nitrogen nutrition on killer activity. A study of the consumption of free amino nitrogen (FAN) by pure and mixed cultures of killer and sensitive cells showed no differences between the profiles of nitrogen assimilation in all cases, and FAN was practically depleted in the first 2 days of fermentation. The effect of the addition of assimilable nitrogen and the size of inoculum was examined in mixed killer and sensitive strain competitions. Stuck and sluggish wine fermentations were observed to depend on nitrogen availability when the ratio of killer to sensitive cells was low (1:10 to 1:100). A relationship between the initial assimilable nitrogen content of must and the proportion of killer cells during fermentation was shown. An indirect relationship was found between inoculum size and the percentage of killer cells: a smaller inoculum resulted in a higher proportion of killer cells in grape juice fermentations. In all cases, wines obtained with pure-culture fermentations were preferred to mixed-culture fermentations by sensory analysis. The reasons why killer cells do not finish fermentation under competitive conditions with sensitive cells are discussed.     

接种发酵和自然发酵中酿酒酵母菌株多样性比较

[目的]探究自然发酵和接种发酵两种发酵方式,对霞多丽葡萄发酵中酵母菌种多样性和酿酒酵母菌株遗传多样性的影响.[方法]以霞多丽葡萄为原料,分别进行自然发酵和接种不同酿酒酵母菌株(NXU 17-26、UCD522和UCD2610)的发酵,利用26S rDNA D1/D2区序列分析和Interdelta指纹图谱技术分别进行酵...     

Occurrence of Killer Yeasts in Spontaneous Wine Fermentations from the Tuscany Region of Italy

The occurrence of killer yeasts in an area of Tuscany (central Italy) was studied. Killer yeasts were found in 88% of spontaneous wine fermentations from 18 wineries. The incidence of killers varied with respect to fermentation stage and vintage period, increasing from the first vintage to successive ones and from the commencement to the end of fermentation. At the end of fermentation, the proportion of killer strains relative to total yeast population was below 25% in 15 cases, above 75% in 6 cases, from 25 to 50% in 5 cases, and from 50 to 75% in 3 cases. Karyotype analysis also showed a mixed killer population in the fermentations in which the killers dominated.     

Characterization, ecological distribution, and population dynamics of Saccharomyces sensu stricto killer yeasts in the spontaneous grape must fermentations of southwestern Spain

Killer yeasts secrete protein toxins that are lethal to sensitive strains of the same or related yeast species. Among the four types of Saccharomyces killer yeasts already described (K1, K2, K28, and Klus), we found K2 and Klus killer yeasts in spontaneous wine fermentations from southwestern Spain. Both phenotypes were encoded by medium-size double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) viruses, Saccharomyces cerevisiae virus (ScV)-M2 and ScV-Mlus, whose genome sizes ranged from 1.3 to 1.75 kb and from 2.1 to 2.3 kb, respectively. The K2 yeasts were found in all the wine-producing subareas for all the vintages analyzed, while the Klus yeasts were found in the warmer subareas and mostly in the warmer ripening/harvest seasons. The middle-size isotypes of the M2 dsRNA were the most frequent among K2 yeasts, probably because they encoded the most intense K2 killer phenotype. However, the smallest isotype of the Mlus dsRNA was the most frequent for Klus yeasts, although it encoded the least intense Klus killer phenotype. The killer yeasts were present in most (59.5%) spontaneous fermentations. Most were K2, with Klus being the minority. The proportion of killer yeasts increased during fermentation, while the proportion of sensitive yeasts decreased. The fermentation speed, malic acid, and wine organoleptic quality decreased in those fermentations where the killer yeasts replaced at least 15% of a dominant population of sensitive yeasts, while volatile acidity and lactic acid increased, and the amount of bacteria in the tumultuous and the end fermentation stages also increased in an unusual way.     

Changes of diversity and population of yeasts during the fermentations by pure and mixed inoculation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains

Mixed inoculation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains is used in winemaking for achieving high sensory quality of the wine. However, information on the diversity and population of yeasts during inoculated fermentation is very limited. In this study, we evaluated the effect of mixed inocula with different inoculation timing on the yeast community during fermentations of Cabernet Sauvignon. Grape must was inoculated with pure cultures of S. cerevisiae RC212 or S. cerevisiae R312, and simultaneous and sequential inoculation of both strains. Wallersterin Laboratory Nutrient (WLN) medium and sequence of the 26S rDNA D1/D2 domain were used to compare the diversity of yeast species. Five species, including Candida diversa, Hanseniaspora opuntiae, H. uvarum, Issatchenkia orientalis and I. terricola, were identified in the grape must, with Issatchenkia sp. being predominant (67.5 %). Three to four species were involved in each fermentation treatment. The fermentations by mixed inocula presented more yeast species than by pure inocula. Interdelta sequence typing was used to identify S. cerevisiae strains. Ten genotypes were identified among 322 isolated S. cerevisiae strains. Their distribution varied among different stages of fermentations and different inoculation treatments. The inoculated strains were not predominant, while indigenous genotypes I, III, and V showed strong competitiveness during fermentation. In general, this study provided information on the change of population structure and genetic diversity of yeasts in fermentations inoculated with pure and mixed S. cerevisiae strains.     

Metabolic profiling as a tool for revealing Saccharomyces interactions during wine fermentation

The multi-yeast strain composition of wine fermentations has been well established. However, the effect of multiple strains of Saccharomyces spp. on wine flavour is unknown. Here, we demonstrate that multiple strains of Saccharomyces grown together in grape juice can affect the profile of aroma compounds that accumulate during fermentation. A metabolic footprint of each yeast in monoculture, mixed cultures or blended wines was derived by gas chromatography - mass spectrometry measurement of volatiles accumulated during fermentation. The resultant ion spectrograms were transformed and compared by principal-component analysis. The principal-component analysis showed that the profiles of compounds present in wines made by mixed-culture fermentation were different from those where yeasts were grown in monoculture fermentation, and these differences could not be produced by blending wines. Blending of monoculture wines to mimic the population composition of mixed-culture wines showed that yeast metabolic interactions could account for these differences. Additionally, the yeast strain contribution of volatiles to a mixed fermentation cannot be predicted by the population of that yeast. This study provides a novel way to measure the population status of wine fermentations by metabolic footprinting.     

Studies on strong and weak killer phenotypes of wine yeasts: production, activity of toxin in must, and its effect in mixed culture fermentation

R.A. MUSMANNO, T. DI MAGGIO and G. CORATZA.1999.Two different killer phenotypes were detected among K⁺ (killer) yeasts isolated from spontaneous wine fermentations using a plate bioassay. The two phenotypes differed in their degree of killer activity, and were designated as SK⁺(strong killer) and WK⁺(weak killer). Strains showing either phenotype were assayed for expression of killer activity under different growth conditions. Growth in must negatively affected expression of the killer activity of both phenotypes. The supernatant fluids from must cultures showed a lower killing effect than those from yeast phosphate dextrose broth (YPDB) cultures. The ability of the two K⁺ phenotypes to prevail on K-sensitive yeasts was studied in mixed-culture fermentation experiments. Under these conditions, only strains showing SK⁺ phenotype were able to prevail on the K-sensitive yeasts. These results suggest that the K⁺ phenotype could play a relevant role in spontaneous fermentations provided that the strain exhibits an SK⁺ phenotype, and that the latter phenotype should be preferred when selected K + strains are to be used as fermentation starters.     

Isolation, purification, and characterization of a killer protein from Schwanniomyces occidentalis

The yeast Schwanniomyces occidentalis produces a killer toxin lethal to sensitive strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Killer activity is lost after pepsin and papain treatment, suggesting that the toxin is a protein. We purified the killer protein and found that it was composed of two subunits with molecular masses of approximately 7.4 and 4.9 kDa, respectively, but was not detectable with periodic acid-Schiff staining. A BLAST search revealed that residues 3 to 14 of the 4.9-kDa subunit had 75% identity and 83% similarity with killer toxin K2 from S. cerevisiae at positions 271 to 283. Maximum killer activity was between pH 4.2 and 4.8. The protein was stable between pH 2.0 and 5.0 and inactivated at temperatures above 40 degrees C. The killer protein was chromosomally encoded. Mannan, but not beta-glucan or laminarin, prevented sensitive yeast cells from being killed by the killer protein, suggesting that mannan may bind to the killer protein. Identification and characterization of a killer strain of S. occidentalis may help reduce the risk of contamination by undesirable yeast strains during commercial fermentations.     

Role of killer effect in fermentations conducted by mixed cultures of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Abstract The present work reports on population dynamics in musts (pH 3.2) inoculated with pairs of Saccharomyces cerevisiae wild strains. Two assays determined the growth of both killer and sensitive strains; the latter were not totally eliminated from the must and non-proliferating populations were detected. Another two were carried out with two killer or two sensitive strains, respectively; the exponential growth of the two populations was observed in both cases. The succession of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains was seen to be common in the four assays; only one strain proved to have the ability to complete fermentation, whereas the other disappeared after 28 days of fermentation. The most important fermentation compounds were estimated at the end of fermentations.     

Mutual antagonism among killer yeasts: competition between K1 and K2 killers and a novel cDNA-based K1-K2 killer strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mutually antagonistic K1 and K2 killer strains compete when mixed and serially subcultured. At pH 4.6, where the K1 killer toxin is more stable in vitro, the K1 strain outcompeted the K2 strains at both 18 and 30 degrees C. At pH 4.0, closer to the in vitro pH optimum of the K2 killer toxin, the K1 strain again predominated at 18 degrees C, but at 30 degrees C the K2 strains became the sole cell type on subculture. To show more clearly that these results were dependent upon the respective killer toxins, control experiments were conducted with isogenic, nonkiller strains cured of the dsRNA-based killer virions. Such nonkiller strains were unable to compete with antagonistic killers under conditions where their isogenic killer parents could, strongly suggesting that the killer phenotype was important in these competitions. Double K1-K2 killer strains cannot stably exist, as their dsRNA genomes compete at a replicative level. Using recombinant DNA methodology, a stable K1-K2 killer strain was constructed. This strain outcompeted both K1 and K2 killers when serially subcultured under conditions where either the K1 or the K2 strains would normally predominate in mixed cultures. Such a double killer may be useful in commercial fermentations, where there is a risk of contamination by killer yeasts.     

Stability and expression of a plasmid-containing killer toxin cDNA in batch and chemostat cultures of saccharomyces cerevisiae

A chimeric plasmid (pYT760-ADH1) containing the yeast killer toxin-immunity cDNA was transformed into a leucine-histidine mutant (AH22) and into four industrial toxin-sensitive yeasts. The chimeric plasmid was very stable and expressed toxin production (89.5 +/- 4.8% killer cells) in two of the transformed yeasts that contained the 2mu plasmid, but was lost within 10 generations from two other transformed pickle yeasts that did not contain the 2mu plasmid. It suggested that plasmid stability was dependent on the presence of the 2mu plasmid which is naturally present in some yeasts. The plasmid was extremely stable (100% killer cells) and expressed more toxin in the mutant strain AH22. The effects of dilution rate, D(h(-1)) on plasmid stability and toxin expression were studied in transformed AH22 (AH22/T3) and Montrachet 522 (522/T1) wine yeast grown in glucose-limited chemostat cultures. The results show that killer toxin production by AH22/T3 cells increased as a function of D(h(-1)) and that plasmid stability reached 100% at D >/= 0.09 +/- 0.01 h(-1). However, with Montrachet 522/T1 transformed cells, 100% plasmid stability was seen at D >/= 0.18 +/- 0.02. h(-1). We also challenged the AH22/T3 in chemostat culture (D = 0.25 h(-1)) with an equal number of untransformed cells (AH22). Transformed cells dominated the population (100%) within 8-10 h of growth, a time equivalent to two mean residence time.     

The Production of a Yeast Killer Factor in the Chemostat and the Effects of Killer Yeasts in Mixed Continuous Culture with a Sensitive Strain

In batch culture in a complex medium the killer yeasts NCYC 738 and NCYC 235 gave maximal killer activity when grown in the pH ranges 4·2–4·4 and 4·6–4·8 respectively. Incubation of culture filtrates of NCYC 738 for 10 h at 25 °C or 2 h at 29 °C resulted in a 50% reduction in activity. The addition of bovine serum albumin or gelatine to a complex medium stabilized killer activity. In a defined medium the addition of yeast extract stimulated the production of killer activity. When killer yeast NCYC 738 was grown in a chemostat, killer activity was influenced by temperature, pH and the rate at which the culture was stirred. The production of killer activity was growth-linked and increased as dilution rate was raised to a maximum of 0·15 h"1. Steady state continuous cultures of the sensitive strain, NCYC 1006, were contaminated deliberately with either killer or killer-cured strains. During the first 30 h cultivation, the cell concentration of both strains increased. Subsequently the sensitive strain was displaced from the culture. When killer-cured NCYC 738 was added, the rate of displacement was proportional to the culture temperature. However, with killer NCYC 738 increase of temperature reduced the rate of displacement. When killer NCYC 235 was employed, a lowering of pH decreased the rate of displacement but had no effect when killer-cured NCYC 235 was used.     

Redox interactions between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces uvarum in mixed culture under enological conditions

Wine yeast starters that contain a mixture of different industrial yeasts with various properties may soon be introduced to the market. The mechanisms underlying the interactions between the different strains in the starter during alcoholic fermentation have never been investigated. We identified and investigated some of these interactions in a mixed culture containing two yeast strains grown under enological conditions. The inoculum contained the same amount (each) of a strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and a natural hybrid strain of S. cerevisiae and Saccharomyces uvarum. We identified interactions that affected biomass, by-product formation, and fermentation kinetics, and compared the redox ratios of monocultures of each strain with that of the mixed culture. The redox status of the mixed culture differed from that of the two monocultures, showing that the interactions between the yeast strains involved the diffusion of metabolite(s) within the mixed culture. Since acetaldehyde is a potential effector of fermentation, we investigated the kinetics of acetaldehyde production by the different cultures. The S. cerevisiae-S. uvarum hybrid strain produced large amounts of acetaldehyde for which the S. cerevisiae strain acted as a receiving strain in the mixed culture. Since yeast response to acetaldehyde involves the same mechanisms that participate in the response to other forms of stress, the acetaldehyde exchange between the two strains could play an important role in inhibiting some yeast strains and allowing the growth of others. Such interactions could be of particular importance in understanding the ecology of the colonization of complex fermentation media by S. cerevisiae.     

Continuous mixed strain mesophilic lactic starter production in supplemented whey permeate medium using immobilized cell technology

The aim of this work was to study a new process for the continuous production of mixed-strain lactic acid bacteria starters using immobilized cells. Three strains of Lactococcus (two Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis: KB and KBP, and one Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis biovar diacetylactis: MD) were immobilized separately in kappa-carrageenan-locust bean gum gel beads. Continuous fermentations were carried out in a 1 L pH-controlled stirred tank reactor with a 30% (v/v) bead inoculum (strain ratio 1:1:1), continuously fed with a whey UF permeate medium, supplemented with 1.5% yeast extract and 0.1M KCl. The effects of three parameters-pH, temperature (T), dilution rate (D), and their interactions on the composition and activity of the culture in the effluent at pseudosteady state were studied according to a rotatable central composite design, during a 53-day fermentation. The process showed a high biological stability and no strain became dominant, or was eliminated from the bioreactor. The statistical analysis showed that the three strains were differently affected by the studied parameters, and that a large range of effluent starter composition can be achieved by varying D, pH, and T. However, the acidifying characteristics were not affected by the culture conditions. A cross-contamination from other strains of the mixed culture was observed in gel beads entrapping a pure culture at the fermentation onset, and led to a biomass redistribution within the beads. However, the strain ratio (KB:KBP:MD) observed after the 53-day experiment (1:2:2) was close to the initial bead ratio (1:1:1). The beads demonstrated a high mechanical stability throughout the 53-day continuous fermentation. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 56: 502-516, 1997.     

Genetic and fermentation properties of the K2 killer yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae T206

Saccharomyces cerevisiae T206 K⁺R⁺, a K₂ killer yeast, was differentiated from other NCYC killer strains of S. cerevisiae on the basis of CHEF-karyotyping and mycoviral RNA separations. Genomic DNA of strain T206 was resolved into 13 chromosome bands, ranging from approximately 0.2 to 2.2 Mb. The resident virus in strain T206 yielded L and M RNA species of approximately 5.1 kb and 2.0 kb, respectively. In micro-scale vinifications, strain T206 showed a lethal effect on a K^-R^- mesophilic wine yeast. Metabolite accumulation and toxin activity were measured over a narrow pH range of 3.2 to 3.5. Contrary to known fermentation trends, the challenged fermentations were neither stuck nor protracted although over 70% of the cell population was killed. Toxin-sensitive cells showed cytosolic efflux.     

Lactic acid production by mixed cultures of Kluyveromyces marxianus, Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus and Lactobacillus helveticus

Lactic acid production using Kluyveromyces marxianus (IFO 288), Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus (ATCC 11842) and Lactobacillus helveticus (ATCC 15009) individually or as mixed culture on cheese whey in stirred or static fermentation conditions was evaluated. Lactic acid production, residual sugar and cell biomass were the main features examined. Increased lactic acid production was observed, when mixed cultures were used in comparison to individual ones. The highest lactic acid concentrations were achieved when K. marxianus yeast was combined with L. delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus, and when all the strains were used revealing possible synergistic effects between the yeast and the two lactic acid bacteria. The same synergistic effects were further observed and verified when the mixed cultures were applied in sourdough fermentations, proving that the above microbiological system could be applied in the food fermentations where high lactic acid production is sought.     

Occurrence and Growth of Killer Yeasts during Wine Fermentation

Sixteen wine fermentations were examined for the presence of killer yeasts. Killer property and sensitivity to killer action were found in isolates of Saccharomyces cerevisiae but not in isolates of Kloeckera, Candida, Hansenula, and Torulaspora spp. Several killer and killer-sensitive strains of S. cerevisiae were differentiated by colony morphology, and this property was used to monitor their growth kinetics in mixed cultures in grape juice. Killer-sensitive strains died off within 24 to 48 h during mixed-strain fermentation. Killer action was demonstrated at pH 3.0 and pH 3.5 and over the range of 15 to 25°C but depended on the proportion of killer to killer-sensitive cells at the commencement of fermentation. The dominance of killer strains in mixed-strain fermentations was reflected in the production of ethanol, acetic acid, and glycerol.     

Influence of killer strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae on wine fermentation

The effect of killer strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae on the growth of sensitive strains during must fermentation was studied by using a new method to monitor yeast populations. The capability of killer yeast strains to eliminate sensitive strains depends on the initial proportion of killer yeasts, the susceptibility of sensitive strains, and the treatment of the must. In sterile filtered must, an initial proportion of 2-6% of killer yeasts was responsible for protracted fermentation and suppression of isogenic sensitive strains. A more variable initial proportion was needed to get the same effect with non-isogenic strains. The suspended solids that remain in the must after cold-settling decreased killer toxin effect. The addition of bentonite to the must avoided protracted fermentation and the suppression of sensitive strains; however, the addition of yeast dietary nutrients with yeast cell walls did not, although it decreased fermentation lag.