The Ncd tail domain promotes microtubule assembly and stability

Non-claret disjunctional (Ncd) is a Drosophila kinesin-like motor required for spindle assembly and maintenance in oocytes and early embryos. Ncd has an ATP-independent microtubule binding site in the N-terminal tail domain as well as an ATP-dependent microtubule binding site in the C-terminal motor domain. The Ncd tail domain shares many properties with the microtubule-associated proteins that regulate microtubule assembly, including microtubule binding and bundling activity and an abundance of basic and proline residues. Given these similarities, we examined the ability of Ncd tail domain proteins to promote MT assembly and stability. The results indicate that the Ncd tail domain can promote MT assembly and stabilize MTs against conditions that induce MT disassembly, and suggest that Ncd may influence MT dynamics within the spindle.     

Reversing a ‘backwards’ motor

Ncd, a kinesin-related microtubule motor protein that moves the ‘wrong’ way on microtubules, towards the minus ends, has now been made to move like kinesin, towards plus ends, by fusing regions from outside the kinesin motor domain to the Ncd motor.^1,2 Since it is the kinesin motor domain that binds to and moves on the microtubule, the finding that regions outside the motor domain can confer directionality of Ncd movement is remarkable—it implies a structural basis for motor polarity. Here we consider this finding from a structural point of view and discuss the implications for motor function and evolution. BioEssays 20:108–112, 1998. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

The ATPase cross-bridge cycle of the Kar3 motor domain. Implications for single head motility

Kar3 is a minus-end directed microtubule motor involved in meiosis and mitosis in Saccharomyces cerevisae. Unlike Drosophila Ncd, the other well characterized minus-end directed motor that is a homodimer, Kar3 is a heterodimer with a single motor domain and either the associated polypeptides Cik1 or Vik1. Our mechanistic studies with Ncd showed that both motor domains were required for ATP-dependent motor domain detachment from the microtubule. We have initiated a series of experiments to compare the mechanistic requirements for Kar3 motility in direct comparison to Ncd. The results presented here show that the single motor domain of Kar3 (Met(383)-Lys(729)) exhibits characteristics similar to monomeric Ncd. The microtubule-activated steady-state ATPase cycle of Kar3 (k(cat) = 0.5 s(-1)) is limited by ADP release (0.4 s(-1)). Like monomeric Ncd, Kar3 does not readily detach from the microtubule with the addition of MgATP. These results show that the single motor domain of Kar3 is not sufficient for ATP-dependent microtubule dissociation, suggesting that structural elements outside of the catalytic core are required for the cyclic interactions with the microtubule for force generation.     

A point mutation in the microtubule binding region of the Ncd motor protein reduces motor velocity.

Non-claret disjunctional (Ncd) is a kinesin-related microtubule motor protein in Drosophila that functions in meiotic spindle assembly in oocytes and spindle pole maintenance in early embryos. The partial loss-of-function mutant ncdD retains mitotic, but not meiotic, function. The predicted NcdD mutant protein contains a V556-->F mutation in the putative microtubule binding region of the Ncd motor domain. Here we report an analysis of the properties of recombinant Ncd and NcdD proteins. A GST-NcdD fusion protein translocated microtubules approximately 10-fold more slowly than the corresponding wild-type protein in gliding assays. The maximum microtubule-stimulated ATPase activity of an NcdD motor domain protein was reduced approximately 3-fold and an approximately 3-fold greater concentration of microtubules was required for half-maximal stimulation of ATPase activity, compared with the corresponding wild-type protein. The Km for ATP and basal rate of ATP turnover were, in contrast, similar for the NcdD mutant and wild-type Ncd motor domain proteins. Pelleting assays demonstrated that the binding of the mutant NcdD motor protein to microtubules was reduced in the absence of nucleotide, relative to wild-type. The reduced velocity of NcdD translocation on microtubules is therefore correlated with reductions in microtubule-stimulated ATPase activity and affinity of the mutant motor for microtubules. The characteristics of the NcdD motor explain its meiotic loss of function, and are consistent with partial motor activity of Ncd being sufficient for its mitotic, but not its meiotic, role.     

Two-state displacement by the kinesin-14 Ncd stalk

The nonprocessive kinesin-14 Ncd motor binds to microtubules and hydrolyzes ATP, undergoing a single displacement before releasing the microtubule. A lever-like rotation of the coiled-coil stalk is thought to drive Ncd displacements or steps along microtubules. Crystal structures and cryoelectron microscopy reconstructions imply that stalk rotation is correlated with ADP release and microtubule binding by the motor. Here we report FRET assays showing that the end of the stalk is more than ~9nm from the microtubule when wild-type Ncd binds microtubules without added nucleotide, but the stalk is within ~6nm of the microtubule surface when the microtubule-bound motor binds an ATP analogue, matching the rotated state observed in crystal structures. We propose that the stalk rotation is initiated when the motor binds to microtubules and releases ADP, and is completed when ATP binds.     

A mechanistic model for Ncd directionality

Ncd is a kinesin-related protein that drives movement to the minus-end of microtubules. Pre-steady-state kinetic experiments have been employed to investigate the cooperative interactions between the motor domains of the MC1 dimer and to establish the ATPase mechanism. Our results indicate that the active sites of dimeric Ncd free in solution are not equivalent; ADP is held more tightly at one site than at the other. Upon microtubule binding, fast release of ADP from the first motor domain is stimulated at 18 s(-1), yet rate-limiting ADP release from the second motor domain occurs at 1.4 s(-1). We propose that the head with the low affinity for ADP binds the microtubule first to establish the directional bias of the microtubule.Ncd intermediate where one motor domain is bound to the microtubule with the second head detached and directed toward the minus-end of the microtubule. The force generating cycle is initiated as ATP binds to the empty site of the microtubule-bound head. ATP hydrolysis at head 1 is required for head 2 to bind to the microtubule. The kinetics indicate that two ATP molecules are required for a single step and force generation for minus-end directed movement generated by this non-processive dimeric motor.     

Determinants of molecular motor directionality

Work over the past two years has led to a breakthrough in our understanding of the molecular basis of the directionality of the kinesin motor proteins. This breakthrough has come first from the reversal of directionality of the kinesin-related motor Ncd, followed closely by the reversal of kinesin's directionality and the finding that the Ncd 'neck' can convert Ncd or kinesin, which are intrinsically plus-end-directed microtubule motors, into a minus-end motor. These findings raise several outstanding questions, foremost, how does the neck function in motor directionality?     

Moving a microtubule may require two heads: a kinetic investigation of monomeric Ncd

Ncd is a minus-end-directed microtubule motor and a member of the kinesin superfamily. The Ncd dimer contains two motor domains, and cooperative interactions between the heads influence the interactions of each respective motor domain with the microtubule. The approach we have taken to understand the cooperativity between the two motor domains is to analyze the ATPase cycle of dimeric MC1 and monomeric MC6. The steps in the ATPase cycle where cooperativity occurs can be identified by comparing the two mechanisms. The rate-limiting step in the MC6 mechanism is ADP release at 3.4 s(-)(1). The observed rate constant for ATP-induced dissociation from the microtubule is 14 s(-)(1). However, the relative amplitude associated with MC6 dissociation is extremely small in comparison to the amplitude associated with dimeric MC1 dissociation kinetics. The amplitude data indicate that monomeric MC6 does not detach from the microtubule during the initial turnovers of ATP, and ATP hydrolysis is uncoupled from movement. The results show that cooperative interactions between the motor domains of the dimer are required for ATP-dependent dissociation; therefore, one function of the partner motor domain may be to weaken the interaction of the adjacent head with the microtubule.     

Mud binds the kinesin-14 Ncd in Drosophila

Maintenance of proper mitotic spindle structure is necessary for error-free chromosome segregation and cell division. Spindle assembly is controlled by force-generating kinesin motors that contribute to its geometry and bipolarity, and balancing motor-dependent forces between opposing kinesins is critical to the integrity of this process. Non-claret dysjunctional (Ncd), a Drosophila kinesin-14 member, crosslinks and slides microtubule minus-ends to focus spindle poles and sustain bipolarity. However, mechanisms that regulate Ncd activity during mitosis are underappreciated. Here, we identify Mushroom body defect (Mud), the fly ortholog of human NuMA, as a direct Ncd binding partner. We demonstrate this interaction involves a short coiled-coil domain within Mud (Mud^CC) binding the N-terminal, non-motor microtubule-binding domain of Ncd (Ncd^nMBD). We further show that the C-terminal ATPase motor domain of Ncd (Ncd^CTm) directly interacts with Ncd^nMBD as well. Mud binding competes against this self-association and also increases Ncd^nMBD microtubule binding in vitro. Our results describe an interaction between two spindle-associated proteins and suggest a potentially new mode of minus-end motor protein regulation at mitotic spindle poles.     

Antagonistic microtubule-sliding motors position mitotic centrosomes in Drosophila early embryos

The positioning of centrosomes, or microtubule-organizing centres, within cells plays a critical part in animal development. Here we show that, in Drosophila embryos undergoing mitosis, the positioning of centrosomes within bipolar spindles and between daughter nuclei is determined by a balance of opposing forces generated by a bipolar kinesin motor, KLP61F, that is directed to microtubule plus ends, and a carboxy-terminal kinesin motor, Ncd, that is directed towards microtubule minus ends. This activity maintains the spacing between separated centrosomes during prometaphase and metaphase, and repositions centrosomes and daughter nuclei during late anaphase and telophase. Surprisingly, we do not observe a function for KLP61F in the initial separation of centrosomes during prophase. Our data indicate that KLP61F and Ncd may function by crosslinking and sliding antiparallel spindle microtubules in relation to one another, allowing KLP61F to push centrosomes apart and Ncd to pull them together.     

Minus-end-directed motor Ncd exhibits processive movement that is enhanced by microtubule bundling in vitro

Drosophila Ncd, a kinesin-14A family member, is essential for meiosis and mitosis. Ncd is a minus-end-directed motor protein that has an ATP-independent microtubule binding site in the tail region, which enables it to act as a dynamic crosslinker of microtubules to assemble and maintain the spindle. Although a tailless Ncd has been shown to be nonprocessive, the role of the Ncd tail in single-molecule motility is unknown. Here, we show that individual Ncd dimers containing the tail region can move processively along microtubules at very low ionic strength, which provides the first evidence of processivity for minus-end-directed kinesins. The movement of GFP-Ncd consists of both a unidirectional and a diffusive element, and it was sensitive to ionic strength. Motility of a truncation series of Ncd and removal of the tubulin tail suggested that the Ncd tail serves as an electrostatic tether to microtubules. Under higher ionic conditions, Ncd showed only a small bias in diffusion along "single" microtubules, whereas it exhibited processive movement along "bundled" microtubules. This property may allow Ncd to accumulate preferentially in the vicinity of focused microtubules and then to crosslink and slide microtubules, possibly contributing to dynamic spindle self-organization.     

Are Coiled-Coils of Dimeric Kinesins Unwound during Their Walking on Microtubule?

Dimeric kinesin motor proteins such as homodimeric kinesin-1, homodimeric Ncd and heterodimeric Kar3/Vik1are composed of two head domains which are connected together by a rod-shaped, coiled-coil stalk. Despite the extensive and intensive studies on structures, kinetics, dynamics and walking mechanism of the dimers, whether their coiled-coils are unwound or not during their walking on the microtubule is still an unclear issue. Here, we try to clarify this issue by using molecular dynamics simulations. Our simulation results showed that, for Ncd, a large change in potential of mean force is required to unwind the coiled-coil by only several pairs of residues. For both Ncd and kinesin-1, the force required to initiate the coiled-coil unwinding is larger than that required for unfolding of the single [Formula: see text]-helix that forms the coiled-coil or is larger than that required to unwind the DNA duplex, which is higher than the unbinding force of the kinesin head from the microtubule in strong microtubule-binding states. Based on these results and the comparison of the sequence between the coiled-coil of Kar3/Vik1 and those of Ncd and kinesin-1, it was deduced that the coiled-coil of the Kar3/Vik1 should also be very stable. Thus, we concluded that the coiled-coils of kinesin-1, Ncd and Kar3/Vik1 are almost impossible to unwind during their walking on the microtubule.     

Interactions between Subunits in Heterodimeric Ncd Molecules

The nonprocessive minus-end-directed kinesin-14 Ncd is involved in the organization of the microtubule (MT) network during mitosis. Only one of the two motor domains is involved in the interaction with the MT. The other head is tethered to the bound one. Here we prepared, purified, and characterized mutated Ncd molecules carrying point mutations in one of the heads, thus producing heterodimeric motors. The mutations tested included substitutions in Switch I and II: R552A, E585A, and E585D; the decoupling mutant N600K; and a deletion in the motor domain in one of the subunits resulting in a single-headed molecule (NcN). These proteins were isolated by two sequential affinity chromatography steps, followed by measurements of their affinities to MT, enzymatic properties, and the velocity of the microtubule gliding test in vitro. A striking observation is a low affinity of the single-headed NcN for MT both without nucleotides and in the presence of 5′-adenylyl-β,γ-imidodiphosphate, implying that the tethered head has a profound effect on the structure of the Ncd-MT complex. Mutated homodimers had no MT-activated ATPase and no motility, whereas NcN had motility comparable with that of the wild type Ncd. Although the heterodimers had one fully active and one inactive head, the ATPase and motility of Ncd heterodimers varied dramatically, clearly demonstrating that interactions between motor domains exist in Ncd. We also show that the bulk property of dimeric proteins that interact with the filament with only one of its heads depends also on the distribution of the filament-interacting subunits.     

Visualizing a new binding site of ncd-motor domain on tubulin

Ncd is a microtubule minus-end directed motor of the kinesin superfamily. Previously it has been shown that ncd and kinesin motor domains share the same major binding site on microtubules. Here we report a three-dimensional EM reconstruction of negatively stained two-dimensional Zn-induced tubulin crystal sheets (Zn-sheets) decorated with the ncd motor domain at a resolution of 16 A. This work has revealed a second specific binding site for the ncd motor domain. The motor binding site on the tubulin Zn-sheets spans both alpha and beta tubulin subunits. This binding site is located at a position different from the previously identified ncd binding site on microtubules and may play a role in motor function.     

Kinetic studies of dimeric Ncd: evidence that Ncd is not processive

Ncd is a kinesin-related motor protein which drives movement to the minus-end of microtubules. The kinetics of Ncd were investigated using the dimeric construct MC1 (Leu(209)-Lys(700)) expressed in Escherichia coli strain BL21(DE) as a nonfusion protein [Chandra, R., Salmon, E. D., Erickson, H. P., Lockhart, A., and Endow, S. A. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 9005-9013]. Acid chemical quench flow methods were used to measure directly the rate of ATP hydrolysis, and stopped-flow kinetic methods were used to determine the kinetics of mantATP binding, mantADP release, dissociation of MC1 from the microtubule, and binding of MC1 to the microtubule. The results define a minimal kinetic mechanism, M.N + ATP M.N.ATP M.N.ADP.P N. ADP.P N.ADP + P M.N.ADP M.N + ADP, where N, M, and P represent Ncd, microtubules, and inorganic phosphate respectively, with k(+1) = 2.3 microM(-1) s(-1), k(+2) =23 s(-1), k(+3) =13 s(-1), k(+5)= 0.7 microM(-)(1) s(-)(1), and k(+6) = 3.7 s(-)(1). Phosphate release (k(+4)) was not measured directly although it is assumed to be fast relative to ADP release because Ncd is purified with ADP tightly bound at the active site. ATP hydrolysis occurs at 23 s(-)(1) prior to Ncd dissociation at 13 s(-)(1). The pathway for ATP-promoted detachment (steps 1-3) of Ncd from the microtubule is comparable to kinesin's. However, there are two major differences between the mechanisms of Ncd and kinesin. In contrast to kinesin, mantADP release for Ncd at 3.7 s(-)(1) is the slowest step in the pathway and is believed to limit steady-state turnover. Additionally, the burst amplitude observed in the pre-steady-state acid quench experiments is stoichiometric, indicating that Ncd, in contrast to kinesin, is not processive for ATP hydrolysis.     

Identification of microtubule binding sites in the Ncd tail domain

Nonclaret disjunctional (Ncd) is a minus end-directed, C-terminal motor protein that is required for spindle assembly and maintenance during meiosis and early mitosis in Drosophila oocytes and early embryos. Ncd has an ATP-independent MT binding site in the N-terminal tail domain, and an ATP-dependent MT binding site in the C-terminal motor domain. The ability of Ncd to cross-link MTs through the action of these binding sites may be important for Ncd function in vivo. To identify the region(s) responsible for ATP-independent MT interactions of Ncd, 12 cDNAs coding various regions of Ncd tail domain were expressed in E. coli as C-terminal fusions to thioredoxin (Trx). Ncd tail fusion proteins (TrxNT) were purified by ion exchange (S-Sepharose) and/or Talon metal affinity chromatography. Purified TrxNT and NT proteins were analyzed in microtubule (MT) cosedimentation and bundling assays to identify which tail proteins were able to bind and bundle MTs. Based on the results of these experiments, all TrxNT and NT proteins that showed MT binding activity also bundled MTs, and there are two ATP-independent MT interaction sites in the tail region: one within amino acids 83-100 that exhibits conformation-independent, high-affinity MT binding activity; and another within amino acids 115-187 that exhibits conformation-dependent, lower affinity MT binding activity. It is possible that both of these MT interacting sites combine in the native protein to form a single MT binding site that allows the Ncd tail to bind cargo MTs in vivo.     

Mechanisms for focusing mitotic spindle poles by minus end-directed motor proteins

During the formation of the metaphase spindle in animal somatic cells, kinetochore microtubule bundles (K fibers) are often disconnected from centrosomes, because they are released from centrosomes or directly generated from chromosomes. To create the tightly focused, diamond-shaped appearance of the bipolar spindle, K fibers need to be interconnected with centrosomal microtubules (C-MTs) by minus end-directed motor proteins. Here, we have characterized the roles of two minus end-directed motors, dynein and Ncd, in such processes in Drosophila S2 cells using RNA interference and high resolution microscopy. Even though these two motors have overlapping functions, we show that Ncd is primarily responsible for focusing K fibers, whereas dynein has a dominant function in transporting K fibers to the centrosomes. We also report a novel localization of Ncd to the growing tips of C-MTs, which we show is mediated by the plus end-tracking protein, EB1. Computer modeling of the K fiber focusing process suggests that the plus end localization of Ncd could facilitate the capture and transport of K fibers along C-MTs. From these results and simulations, we propose a model on how two minus end-directed motors cooperate to ensure spindle pole coalescence during mitosis.     

Identification of Ncd tail domain-binding sites on the tubulin dimer

The Drosophila non-claret disjunctional (Ncd) kinesin-like protein is required for spindle assembly in oocytes and spindle maintenance in early embryos. Through the action of ATP-dependent microtubule (MT)-binding sites in the head and ATP-independent MT-binding sites in the tail, Ncd may bundle and, perhaps, slide MTs relative to each other. Our previous work on the MT-binding site of the Ncd tail domain demonstrated that this site, like the MT-binding sites of tau, contains basic residues flanked by proline residues and can promote MT assembly and stability. Here, we characterize the interactions of a monomeric Ncd tail protein with subtilisin-digested MTs in order to identify sites on the tubulin dimer that interact with the Ncd tail. The results provide evidence for four such binding sites per tubulin dimer and support the hypothesis that each binding site consists of a cluster of acidic residues in the C-terminal regions of alpha- and beta-tubulin.     

Kinetics processivity and the direction of motion of Ncd.

The kinetic mechanism of the nonclaret disjunctional protein (Ncd) motor was investigated using the dimer termed MC1 (residues 209-700), which has been shown to exhibit negative-end directed motility (Chandra et al., 1993). The kinetic properties are similar to those of the monomeric Ncd motor domain (Pechatnikova and Taylor, 1997). The maximum steady-state ATPase activity of 1.5 s(-1) is half as large as for the monomeric motor. Dissociation constants in the presence of nucleotides showed the same trend but with approximately a two-fold decrease in the values: K(d) values are 1.0 microM for ADP-AlF(4), 1.1 microM for ATPgammaS, 1.5 microM for ATP, 3 microM for ADP, and 10 microM for ADP-vanadate (in 25 mM NaCl, 22 degrees C). The apparent second-order rate constants for the binding of ATP and ADP to the microtubule-motor complex (MtMC1) are 2 microM(-1) s(-1). Based on measurements at high microtubule concentrations the kinetic steps were fitted to the scheme,[see text] where N refers to one head of the dimer and T, D, and P stand for ATP, ADP, and inorganic phosphate. k(1) and k(-4) are the first-order rate constants of the transition induced by the binding of mant ATP and mant ADP respectively. ADP release is the main rate-limiting step in the MtMC1 mechanism. The binding of the MC1-mant ADP complex to microtubules released less than half of the mant ADP (alternating site reactivity). The second mant ADP is only released by the binding of nucleotides that dissociate the MtMC1 complex (ATP and ADP but not AMPPNP). The apparent rate constant for dissociation of the second mant ADP is four times smaller than the first and much smaller than the rate of dissociation of MtMC1 by ATP or ADP. These results are explained by a model in which MC1.ADP is first dissociated from the microtubule by ATP, followed by rebinding to the microtubule by the ADP-containing head. Ncd may follow a different reaction pathway than does kinesin, but the differences in rate constants do not explain the opposite direction of motion. The kinetic evidence and the high ratio of motile velocity to ATPase support a nonprocessive, low duty cycle mechanism for the Ncd motor.     

Microcephaly protein Asp focuses the minus ends of spindle microtubules at the pole and within the spindle

Depletion of Drosophila melanogaster Asp, an orthologue of microcephaly protein ASPM, causes spindle pole unfocusing during mitosis. However, it remains unclear how Asp contributes to pole focusing, a process that also requires the kinesin-14 motor Ncd. We show that Asp localizes to the minus ends of spindle microtubule (MT) bundles and focuses them to make the pole independent of Ncd. We identified a critical domain in Asp exhibiting MT cross-linking activity in vitro. Asp was also localized to, and focuses the minus ends of, intraspindle MTs that were nucleated in an augmin-dependent manner and translocated toward the poles by spindle MT flux. Ncd, in contrast, functioned as a global spindle coalescence factor not limited to MT ends. We propose a revised molecular model for spindle pole focusing in which Asp at the minus ends cross-links MTs at the pole and within the spindle. Additionally, this study provides new insight into the dynamics of intraspindle MTs by using Asp as a minus end marker.