Nature of the turtle shell: Morphogenetic causes of bone variability and its evolutionary implication

The turtle shell is characterized by a high degree of conservatism of the fundamental model and, at the same time, a high variability at the individual level. The components of the bony shell vary in origin. The costal and neural plates of the carapace are modified elements of the axial skeleton (ribs and neural arches) and the plastral plates are transformed dermal ossifications of the shoulder girdle and gastralia, peripheral, pygal, and suprapygal plates are similar to osteoderms of other reptiles. The variability of the structure of particular parts of the turtle shell is manifested differently. Most anomalies have been recorded in the caudal part of the carapace. The plastron is relatively stable in morphology. Variations in the bony shell structure are observed in (1) unusual shape and size of plates combined with normal number of plates, (2) presence of additional plates, and (3) absence of regular plates. Based on the morphogenetic characteris-tics, anomalies are subdivided into (1) variations caused by changes in the number of elements of the axial skeleton or their contacts with the dermis (neurals and costals); (2) variations due to changes in the number of horny scutes (peripherals); (3) variations connected with irregular osteogeny or disturbed growth of bones     

Description and genetic mapping of Polypodia: an X-linked dominant mouse mutant with ectopic caudal limbs and other malformations

In this report we present a spontaneous mouse mutant, named Polypodia (Ppd), that primarily exhibits ectopic, ventral/caudal limbs and associated pelvic girdle malformation or duplication. Less penetrant features include diphallia, microphthalmia, small kidney, curled or kinked tail, forelimb anomaly, and skin papillae. Ppd mice have a normal karyotype and no large-scale genomic deletions or insertions by BAC-based array comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). Ppd is X-linked dominant with approximately 20% penetrance on the C3H background and maps to X:61.6 Mb-X:71.24 Mb. The limb and a subset of the nonlimb anomalies are similar to those in offspring from retinoic acid-treated dams at E4.5-5.5 and feature overlap with the Disorganization mouse mutant and human patients with ectopic legs. We hypothesize that Ppd affects very early steps in the formation of caudal structures including limb and appendage number. The existence of noncaudal anomalies implies the involvement of Ppd in a broad array of cell fate decisions.     

Signals from trunk paraxial mesoderm induce pronephros formation in chick intermediate mesoderm

We used Pax-2 mRNA expression and Lim 1/2 antibody staining as markers for the conversion of chick intermediate mesoderm (IM) to pronephric tissue and Lmx-1 mRNA expression as a marker for mesonephros. Pronephric markers were strongly expressed caudal to the fifth somite by stage 9. To determine whether the pronephros was induced by adjacent tissues and, if so, to identify the inducing tissues and the timing of induction, we microsurgically dissected one side of chick embryos developing in culture and then incubated them for up to 3 days. The undisturbed contralateral side served as a control. Most embryos cut parallel to the rostrocaudal axis between the trunk paraxial mesoderm and IM before stage 8 developed a pronephros on the control side only. Embryos manipulated after stage 9 developed pronephric structures on both sides, but the caudal pronephric extension was attenuated on the cut side. These results suggest that a medial signal is required for pronephric development and show that the signal is propagated in a rostral to caudal sequence. In manipulated embryos cultured for 3 days in ovo, the mesonephros as well as the pronephros failed to develop on the experimental side. In contrast, embryos cut between the notochord and the trunk paraxial mesoderm formed pronephric structures on both sides, regardless of the stage at which the operation was performed, indicating that the signal arises from the paraxial mesoderm (PM) and not from axial mesoderm. This cut also served as a control for cuts between the PM and the IM and showed that signaling itself was blocked in the former experiments, not the migration of pronephric or mesonephric precursor cells from the primitive streak. Additional control experiments ruled out the need for signals from lateral plate mesoderm, ectoderm, or endoderm. To determine whether the trunk paraxial mesoderm caudal to the fifth somite maintains its inductive capacity in the absence of contact with more rostral tissue, embryos were transected. Those transected below the prospective level of the fifth somite expressed Pax-2 in both the rostral and the caudal isolates, whereas embryos transected rostral to this level expressed Pax-2 in the caudal isolate only. Thus, a rostral signal is not required to establish the normal pattern of Pax-2 expression and pronephros formation. To determine whether paraxial mesoderm is sufficient for pronephros induction, stage 7 or earlier chick lateral plate mesoderm was cocultured with caudal stage 8 or 9 quail somites in collagen gels. Pax-2 was expressed in chick tissues in 21 of 25 embryos. Isochronic transplantation of stage 4 or 5 quail node into caudal chick primitive streak resulted in the generation of ectopic somites. These somites induced ectopic pronephroi in lateral plate mesoderm, and the IM that received signals from both native and ectopic somites formed enlarged pronephroi with increased Pax-2 expression. We conclude that signals from a localized region of the trunk paraxial mesoderm are both required and sufficient for the induction of the pronephros from the chick IM. Studies to identify the molecular nature of the induction are in progress.     

Local signals in the chick limb bud can override myoblast lineage commitment: induction of slow myosin heavy chain in fast myoblasts.

Patterning of fast and slow muscle fibres in limbs is regulated by signals from non-muscle cells. Myoblast lineage has, however, also been implicated in fibre type patterning. Here we test a founder cell hypothesis for the role of myoblast lineage, by implanting characterized fast and slow mouse myoblast clones into chick limb buds. In culture, late foetal mouse myoblast clones are committed to a probability (range 0-0.92) of slow myosin heavy chain (MyHC) expression. In contrast, when implanted into chick limbs, fast mouse myoblast clones express myosin characteristic of their new environment, without fusion to chick muscle cells and in the absence of innervation. Therefore, local signals exist within the chick limb bud during primary myogenesis that can override intrinsic commitment of at least some myoblasts, and induce slow MyHC.     

Adenovirus-mediated gene transfer as a tool to study angiogenesis in the chick embryo

Abstract. An adenoviral construct encoding a nuclear-localized beta-galactosidase marker protein was injected into the heart of chick embryos at Hamburger-Hamilton (HH) stage 14-15 (approximately 52-56 h of incubation). Reporter gene expression was determined 48-54 h after injection. Efficient gene transfer into endothelial cells (ECs) of intraembryonic and yolk sac vessels was observed. ECs of vessels in the head region, which undergo massive expansion around the time of injection, were efficiently labeled. However, limb bud vasculature, which starts to develop around stage 16 (HH), carried scarce (wing bud) or no (leg bud) lacZ marker. In contrast, ECs of the allantois, a structure that develops even later (around stage HH 18), expressed lacZ reporter. This observation suggests that EC precursors infected at an earlier time migrated into the allantois. A few non-endothelial cell types were also labeled by the reporter. These results suggest that adenovirus-mediated gene transfer provides a powerful tool to study angiogenesis in the developing chick embryo.     

Development of the axial skeleton in wolffish, Anarhichas lupus (Pisces, Anarhichadidae), at different temperatures

The ontogeny of the axial skeleton, in particular the caudal skeleton, is described from embryos to adult specimens in common wolffish, Anarhichas lupus. The eggs were incubated at constant temperatures of 7.0, 11.0 and 13.0 °C. High egg mortality and structural changes in skeletal development (fusion of parts, absence of distal radials and most of dorsal and anal fin rays, abnormal neural arches and dorsal fin rays) were observed at 13 °C. The frequencies of some anomalies were lower at 11 °C than at 13 °C. The main reason of structural changes of the skeleton at high temperature is the breaking of normal correlations between developmental rates of some cartilaginous structures and other tissues and organs of the embryo. These data suggest an epigenetic mechanism of skeletal evolution.     

Tail gut endoderm and gut/genitourinary/tail development: a new tissue-specific role for Hoxa13

Hoxa13 is expressed early in the caudal mesoderm and endoderm of the developing hindgut. The tissue-specific roles of Hoxa13 function have not been described. Hand-foot-genital syndrome, a rare dominantly inherited human malformation syndrome characterized by distal extremity and genitourinary anomalies, is caused by mutations in the HOXA13 gene. We show evidence that one specific HOXA13 mutation likely acts as a dominant negative in vivo. When chick HFGa13 is overexpressed in the chick caudal endoderm early in development, caudal structural malformations occur. The phenotype is specific to HFGa13 expression in the posterior endoderm, and includes taillessness and severe gut/genitourinary (GGU) malformations. Finally, we show that chick HFGa13 negatively regulates expression of Hoxd13 and antagonizes functions of both endogenous Hoxa13 and Hoxd13 proteins. We suggest a fundamental role for epithelial specific expression of Hoxa13 in the epithelial-mesenchymal interaction necessary for tail growth and posterior GGU patterning.     

Cardiovascular malformations induced by bromodeoxyuridine in the chick embryo

For the study of morphogenesis and early embryonic development, 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR), a halogenated analogue of thymidine, is incorporated into replicating DNA and serves as a valuable tool. To study the teratogenicity of BUdR on the developing chick cardiovascular system, we topically administered graded doses of BUdR (32.6-325.6 nmol) in ovo during Hamburger-Hamilton stages 15 to 16. We also administered to a parallel group of embryos corresponding nanomole doses of thymidine during identical stages of development. In the thymidine-treated group, survival rates and cardiovascular anomaly rates did not differ statistically from those in the chick Ringer's control group. Both survival rates and cardiovascular anomaly rates in the BudR-treated group were dose-responsive. Among 78 embryos with cardiovascular anomalies induced by BUdR, vascular malformations were found in 96%. These anomalies included interruption of the right fourth aortic arch, absence or hypoplasia of the right and/or left sixth aortic arch, and persistence of the left fourth aortic arch. Interruption of the right fourth aortic arch was always associated with intracardiac anomalies. Intracardiac anomalies were found in 54% of the embryos; these included ventricular septal defect, double outlet right ventricle, and persistent truncus arteriosus. Subclavian artery malformations were noted in 95% of the embryos. Possible mechanisms for BUdR-induced malformations in the cardiovascular system of the chick are discussed.     

Vascular abnormalities due to hyperthermia in chick embryos

Intraembryonic vascular abnormalities were studied in chick embryos exposed to temperatures 3 degrees C and 4 degrees C above normal temperature (38 degrees C) from the beginning of incubation. The average duration of hyperthermia was 54 and 53 hours, respectively. Immediately after exposure, the embryos were examined with FITC-Dextran microangiography in vivo. Following hyperthermia various abnormalities in the heart, ventral aortae, aortic arches, omphalomesenteric arteries, and the distal dorsal aortae frequently occurred. There were also significant microvascular changes in the head, in the lateral and caudal parts of the embryos, and in the pellucid area of the yolk sac. In another series incubation at 41 degrees C, hyperthermia of 3 degrees C during the first 3 days of development produced several extraembryonic vascular abnormalities. These included duplication and abnormal branching of the cranial vitelline vein, absence or abnormal course of the omphalomesenteric vessels, aneurysmatic dilatation or abnormal course of the caudal vitelline vein, and aneurysmatic dilatation or occlusion of the abdominal venous sinus. Most frequent findings were blind, congested, and dilated microvascular segments in the pellucid area, commonly associated with an irregular microvascular pattern and perivascular swelling. The abnormalities described are assumed to be caused by the direct effects of hyperthermia upon the developing vessels resulting in microvascular insufficiencies, pathological leakage, and perivascular oedema. Such disturbances may have serious consequences for embryonic vascular development and microcirculation, which in turn may have adverse effects on further embryonic growth and development.     

Interpretation of some median anomalies as illustrated by cyclopia and symmelia

Anomalies that involve the median plane are heterogeneous, and their embryological basis varies widely. Cyclopia and symmelia present a number of similarities: 1) They would appear to arise by neither fusion nor merging but mainly through a failure in lateralization. 2) Mesenchymal deficiency is important in both: possibly disturbance of the prechordal plate in cyclopia and failure of the caudal eminence in symmelia. The caudal eminence is an important developmental feature that is only recently becoming clearer in the human embryo. 3) Disturbance of axial material seems to be essential in both. 4) The results of experimental teratogenesis and an analysis of normal human development confirm that these conditions arise early. The teratogenetic termination-periods in the human are probably 2 1/2 weeks for cyclopia sensu stricto (a median eye in a single orbit) and 3 weeks for cyclopia sensu lato, i.e., synophthalmia (paired ocular structures in a single orbit); 2 1/2 weeks for symmelia of the upper limbs (e.g., in cephalothoracopagus) and 3 1/2 weeks for symmelia of the lower limbs in a single individual. It is pointed out that in symmelia the limb buds, upper or lower, have failed to separate at their postaxial margins. This is in contrast to dimelia, in which the preaxial borders are missing and the postaxial margins are duplicated (postaxial dominance).     

The effect of vitamin A on limb regeneration in Rana temporaria

Previous experiments in which vitamin A has been administered to developing or regenerating limbs have shown that different limb axes are affected. In regenerating axolotl limbs, serial reduplications in the proximodistal axis are produced. In the developing chick limb bud, mirror-imaged reduplications in the anteroposterior axis are produced. Results reported here on Rana temporaria limb buds reveal that vitamin A causes both effects to occur. That is, limbs are both serially reduplicated in the proximodistal axis and mirror imaged in the anteroposterior axis. Time and concentration effects are explored and the significance of these results for our current understanding of axial organisation in limbs is discussed.     

Prenatal ossification in rabbits as indicative of fetal maturity.

During the prenatal period of development of the rabbit skeleton (days 21-30) the successive phases of fetal maturity can be distinguished by reference to the progress of ossification, particularly in the distal limbs and sternum. In the present study absent or incomplete ossification of sternebra 5 occurred in 8% of term fetuses. The incidence of anomalies of prenatal ossification of the axial skeleton was 1.9%. The relevance of delayed and disturbed ossification with regard to teratological tests is discussed.     

The developmental fate of the rostral/caudal half of a somite for vertebra and rib formation: experimental confirmation of the resegmentation theory using chick-quail chimeras

To determine whether resegmentation of somites forms the axial skeleton, we traced the development of the rostral and the caudal half of a somite during skeletogenesis in chick-quail chimeras by replacing the rostral or caudal half of a newly formed chick somite with that of a quail somite. The rostral half-somite transplant formed the caudal half of the vertebral body, the entire spinous process and the distal rib, while the caudal half-somite transplant formed the rostral half of vertebral body, the rostral half of spinous process, the vertebral arch, the transverse process and the entire rib. These findings confirm the resegmentation theory except the spinous process and the distal rib.     

Congenital malformations in rats with the semilethal mutation fused pulmonary lobes

It has been demonstrated that an autosomal recessive gene, fused pulmonary lobes (fpl), causes fusion of the right pulmonary lobes with several associated malformations and a high incidence of death in homozygous newborns (Aoyama et al. Teratology 1988; 37:159-166). The aim of the present study was to investigate whether the deaths of fpl/fpl newborns were caused by functional abnormalities of the malformed lung or other associated malformations. Day-20 fpl/fpl and fpl/+ fetuses were weighed and examined for gross abnormalities. The lungs of selected fetuses were further examined for histological abnormalities. A wide variety of associated external, visceral, and skeletal anomalies as well as relatively lower body weights than those of phenotypically normal fpl/+ littermates were observed in the fpl/fpl fetuses. The associated anomalies consisted of hematomas and/or subcutaneous hemorrhages in the head, truncus and limbs, eyelid anomalies, CNS defects, lobation anomalies of the liver, hypoplasia of the spleen, partial absence of the skull bones, and dorsi- or ventriflexion of the phalanges of the limbs. Among them, CNS defects and partial absence of the skull bones were considered to be possible causes of newborn deaths. However, the incidence of these malformations was approximately 10% and was lower than the neonatal mortality, which had been estimated to be approximately 50% in the previous study (Aoyama et al. Teratology 1988; 37:159-166). The lungs of fpl/fpl fetuses consistently had hypoplasia of the intermediate lobe and fusion of the right pulmonary lobes. No histological changes suggesting postnatal respiratory insufficiency were found in the lungs of day-20 fpl/fpl fetuses, and the cause of newborn death remains unclear.     

Sonic hedgehog signaling from the urethral epithelium controls external genital development

External genital development begins with formation of paired genital swellings, which develop into the genital tubercle. Proximodistal outgrowth and axial patterning of the genital tubercle are coordinated to give rise to the penis or clitoris. The genital tubercle consists of lateral plate mesoderm, surface ectoderm, and endodermal urethral epithelium derived from the urogenital sinus. We have investigated the molecular control of external genital development in the mouse embryo. Previous work has shown that the genital tubercle has polarizing activity, but the precise location of this activity within the tubercle is unknown. We reasoned that if the tubercle itself is patterned by a specialized signaling region, then polarizing activity may be restricted to a subset of cells. Transplantation of urethral epithelium, but not genital mesenchyme, to chick limbs results in mirror-image duplication of the digits. Moreover, when grafted to chick limbs, the urethral plate orchestrates morphogenetic movements normally associated with external genital development. Signaling activity is therefore restricted to urethral plate cells. Before and during normal genital tubercle outgrowth, urethral plate epithelium expresses Sonic hedgehog (Shh). In mice with a targeted deletion of Shh, external genitalia are absent. Genital swellings are initiated, but outgrowth is not maintained. In the absence of Shh signaling, Fgf8, Bmp2, Bmp4, Fgf10, and Wnt5a are downregulated, and apoptosis is enhanced in the genitalia. These results identify the urethral epithelium as a signaling center of the genital tubercle, and demonstrate that Shh from the urethral epithelium is required for outgrowth, patterning, and cell survival in the developing external genitalia.     

Role of Runx genes in chondrocyte differentiation

Runx2/Cbfa1 plays a central role in skeletal development as demonstrated by the absence of osteoblasts/bone in mice with inactivated Runx2/Cbfa1 alleles. To further investigate the role of Runx2 in cartilage differentiation and to assess the potential of Runx2 to induce bone formation, we cloned chicken Runx2 and overexpressed it in chick embryos using a retroviral system. Infected chick wings showed multiple phenotypes consisting of (1) joint fusions, (2) expansion of carpal elements, and (3) shortening of skeletal elements. In contrast, bone formation was not affected. To investigate the function of Runx2/Cbfa1 during cartilage development, we have generated transgenic mice that express a dominant negative form of Runx2 in cartilage. The selective inactivation of Runx2 in chondrocytes results in a severe shortening of the limbs due to a disturbance in chondrocyte differentiation, vascular invasion, osteoclast differentiation, and periosteal bone formation. Analysis of the growth plates in transgenic mice and in chick limbs shows that Runx2 is a positive regulator of chondrocyte differentiation and vascular invasion. The results further indicate that Runx2 promotes chondrogenesis either by maintaining or by initiating early chondrocyte differentiation. Furthermore, Runx2 is essential but not sufficient to induce osteoblast differentiation. To analyze the role of runx genes in skeletal development, we performed in situ hybridization with Runx2- and Runx3-specific probes. Both genes were coexpressed in cartilaginous condensations, indicating a cooperative role in the regulation of early chondrocyte differentiation and thus explaining the expansion/maintenance of cartilage in the carpus and joints of infected chick limbs.     

Fate maps of the primitive streak in chick and quail embryo: ingression timing of progenitor cells of each rostro-caudal axial level of somites

Developmental fates of cells emigrating from the primitive streak were traced by a fluorescent dye Dil both in chick and in quail embryos from the fully grown streak stage to 12-somite stage, focusing on the development of mesoderm and especially on the timing of ingression of each level of somitic mesoderm. The fate maps of the chick and quail streak were alike, although the chick streak was longer at all stages examined. The anterior part of the primitive streak predominantly produced somites. The thoracic and the lumbar somites were shown to begin to ingress at the 5 somite-stage and 10 somite-stage in a chick embryo, and 6 somite-stage and 9 somite-stage in a quail embryo, respectively. The posterior part of the streak served mainly as the origin of more lateral or extra embryonic mesoderm. As development proceeded, the fate of the posterior part of the streak changed from the lateral plate mesoderm to the tail bud mesoderm and then to extra embryonic, allantois mesoderm. The fate map of the primitive streak in chick and quail embryo presented here will serve as basic data for studies on mesoderm development with embryo manipulation, especially for transplantation experiments between chick and quail embryos.