Inhibition of chloroplast electron transport reactions by trifluralin and diallate

The herbicides trifluralin (alpha,alpha,alpha-trifluoro-2,6-dinitro-N, N-dipropyl-p-toluidine) and diallate (S-[2,3-dichloroallyl] diisopropylthiocarbamate) inhibit electron transport, ATP synthesis, and cytochrome f reduction by isolated spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) chloroplasts. Both compounds inhibit noncyclic electron transport from H(2)O to ferricyanide more than 90% in coupled chloroplasts at concentrations less than 50 mum. Neither herbicide inhibits electron transport in assays utilizing only photosystem I activity, and the photosystem II reaction elicited by addition of oxidized p-phenylenediamine or 2,5-dimethylquinone is only partially inhibited by herbicide concentrations which block electron flow from H(2)O to ferricyanide. Inhibition of ATP synthesis parallels inhibition of electron flow in all noncyclic assay systems, and cyclic ATP synthesis catalyzed by either diaminodurene or phenazine metho-sulfate is susceptible to inhibition by both herbicides. These results indicate that trifluralin and diallate both inhibit electron flow in isolated chloroplasts at a point in the electron transport chain between the two photosystems.     

Inhibition and uncoupling of photophosphorylation in isolated chloroplasts by organotin, organomercury and diphenyleneiodonium compounds

1. Trialkyltin, triphenyltin and diphenyleneiodonium compounds inhibited ADP-stimulated O(2) evolution by isolated pea chloroplasts in the presence of phosphate or arsenate. Tributyltin and triphenyltin were the most effective inhibitors, which suggests a highly hydrophobic site of action. Phenylmercuric acetate was a poor inhibitor of photophosphorylation, which suggests that thiol groups are not involved. 2. Triethyltin was a potent uncoupler of photophosphorylation by isolated chloroplasts in media containing Cl(-), but had little uncoupling activity when Cl(-) was replaced by NO(3) (-) or SO(4) (2-), which are inactive in the anion-hydroxide exchange. It is suggested that uncoupling by triethyltin is a result of the Cl(-)-OH(-) exchange together with a natural uniport of Cl(-). Tributyltin, triphenyltin and phenylmercuric acetate had low uncoupling activity, probably because in these compounds the uncoupling activity is partially masked by inhibitory effects. 3. At high concentrations the organotin compounds caused inhibition of electron transport uncoupled by carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone or NH(4)Cl. At these high concentrations the organotin compounds may be producing a detergent-like disorganization of the membrane structure. In contrast, diphenyleneiodonium sulphate inhibited uncoupled electron transport at low concentrations; however, this inhibition is less than the inhibition of photophosphorylation, which suggests that the compound also inhibits the phosphorylation reactions as well as electron transport. 4. The effects of these compounds on basal electron transport were complex and depended on the pH of the reaction media. However, they can be explained on the basis of three actions: inhibition of the phosphorylation reactions, uncoupling and direct inhibition of electron transport. 5. The inhibition of cyclic photophosphorylation in the presence of phenazine methosulphate by diphenyleneiodonium sulphate shows that it inhibits in the region of photosystem 1.     

Evidence for two sites of inhibition of photosynthetic electron transport by dibromothymoquinone

Two sites in the photosynthetic electron transport chain of spinach chloroplasts are sensitive to inhibition by the plastoquinone antagonist dibromothymoquinone (2,5-dibromo-3-methyl-6-isopropyl-p-benzoquinone). This compound imposes maximal inhibition on reactions involving electron transport from water to a terminal acceptor such as ferricyanide at concentrations of about 1 μm. At concentrations of about 10 μm, dibromothymoquinone also inhibits electron transport reactions catalyzed by photosystem II in the presence of p-phenylenediimines or p-benzoquinones. This inhibition is observed in both untreated and $\text{KCN}\text{Hg}$-inhibited chloroplast preparations. Thiol incubation of chloroplasts exposed to dibromothymoquinone relieves inhibition at both sites. This reversal of inhibition is, however, different for the two sites. Restoration of ferricyanide reduction, which is blocked by 1 μm dibromothymoquinone, required high thiol/inhibitor ratios and incubation times with thiol of up to 3 min. The reversal of inhibition of p-phenylenediimine reduction by photosystem II, on the other hand, requires a thiol/inhibitor ratio of 1, and incubation times as short as 5 s. Addition of bovine serum albumin to absorb dibromothymoquinone results in a partial restoration of photosystem II reactions, but ferricyanide reduction, which requires photosystem II and photosystem I, cannot be restored by this procedure.     

Comparison of the effects of some perminductors on mitochondria and chloroplasts

The effects of valinomycin, gramicidins A and S, melittin and the protonophore 3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxybenzylidenmalononitrile on rat liver mitochondria and pea chloroplasts during active electron transport were studied. The canalogenes melittin and gramicidin S as well as gramicidin A and the protonophore increase the proton conductance of the inner mitochondrial membrane and chloroplast tylakoid membrane. The curve for the dependence of the canalogene effects on their concentration is S-shaped for both types of the organelles. Valinomycin reveals no protonophore activity and at high concentrations inhibits electron transport in both types of the coupling membranes. The uncoupling activity of gramicidin A and canalogenes and the inhibiting activity of valinomycin do not depend on the type of organelles when the concentration of these compounds is expressed as concentration in the membrane lipid matrix. At the same time the activity of the protonophore in chloroplasts is 6 times less than that in mitochondria. It is assumed that this difference in the protonophore activity is due to the differences in the mechanism of coupling of electron transport rather than to the peculiarities of lipid composition of mitochondria and chloroplasts. The lack of dependence of activity of peptide perminductors on the membrane lipid composition can probably be due to the fact that their effects is localized in the carbohydrate moiety of the lipid bilayer and does not involve the polar "heads" of the lipids.     

Development of photosynthetic electron transport in Pinus silvestris

Photosynthetic electron transport activity has been measured in chloroplasts isolated from dark-grown seedlings of Pinus silvestris L. and in chloroplasts isolated from seedlings subjected to illumination for periods of up to 48 h. Activities of photosystem 2, photosystem 1 and photosystem 2 plus 1 have been measured. Chloroplasts isolated from dark-grown seedlings showed significant electron transport activity through both photosystems and through the entire electron transport chain from water to NADP. Illumination of the seedlings for only 5 min markedly promoted photosystem 2 activity. The artificial electron donor, diphenylcarbazide. promoted activity in chloroplasts from dark-grown seedlings and in chloroplasts from seedlings illuminated for up to 30 min. In comparison to photosystem 2 and overall electron transport from water to NADP, photosystem 1 activity increased only slightly during illumination. Measurements of electron transport and fluorescence kinetics have confirmed that photosynthetic electron transport capacity is limited on the water splitting side of photosystem 2 in dark-grown seedlings, whereas the primary and secondary electron acceptors of photosystem 2 are fully synthesized and functioning in darkness. Polyethylene glycol must be used as a protective agent when isolating photoactive chloroplasts from secondary needles of conifers. However, the presence of polyethylene glycol, when isolating chloroplasts from dark-grown pine cotyledons, caused a total inhibition of the activity of photosystem 2. The failure of others to show a substantial electron transport activity in chloroplasts from dark-grown Pinus silvestris might depend on their use of polyethylene glycol in the preparation medium and/or on their use of suboptimal reaction conditions for the electron transport measurements.     

Effect of dibromothymoquinone on photosynthetic electron transport]

The effect of dibromothymoquinone on photosynthetic electron transport in pea dependent on concentration was studied. Dibromothymoquinone inhibited general electron transport from water to NADP+ in isolated chloroplasts and ethiochloroplasts and the electron transfer via plastoquinone and cytochrome f in the leaves and isolated plastids. At all concentrations studied dibromothymoquinone significantly affected the absorption changes at 590 nm in the ethiochloroplasts associated with plastocyanine photoreactions. Possible location of electron carriers in the photosynthetic electron transport chain is discussed.     

Delayed chloroplast luminescence. Activation and suppression

Effect of diethyl ether, detergent triton X-100, glycerine, sucrose and preliminary heating on delayed luminescence (DL) of chloroplasts has been studied. Ether and triton X-100 in concentrations activating electron transport inhibit DL acting similarly to photophosphorylation uncouplers. Preliminary heating to 42-42C, glycerine and sucrose activate both the electron transport and DL of chloroplasts. Activation of electron transport under these agents is suggested to result not from photophosphorylation uncoupling, but from the changes in the conformation of chloroplast memebranes.     

Regulation of photosynthetic electron transport and photophosphorylation in intact chloroplasts and leaves of Spinacia oleracea L.

Oxygen ist reduced by the electron transport chain of chloroplasts during CO₂ reduction. The rate of electron flow to oxygen is low. Since antimycin A inhibited CO₂-dependent oxygen evolution, it is concluded that cyclic photophosphorylation contributes ATP to photosynthesis in chloroplasts which cannot satisfy the ATP requirement of CO₂ reduction by electron flow to NADP and to oxygen. Inhibition of photosynthesis by antimycin A was more significant at high than at low light intensities suggesting that cyclic photophosphorylation contributes to photosynthesis particularly at high intensities. Cyclic electron flow in intact chloroplasts is under the control of electron acceptors. At low light intensities or under far-red illumination it is decreased by substrates which accept electrons from photosystem I such as oxaloacetate, nitrite or oxygen. Obviously, the cyclic electron transport pathway is sensitive to electron drainage. In the absence of electron acceptors, cyclic electron flow is supported by far-red illumination and inhibited by red light. The inhibition by light exciting photosystem II demonstrated that the cyclic electron transport pathway is accessible to electrons from photosystem II. Inhibition can be relieved by oxygen which appears to prevent over-reduction of electron carriers of the cyclic pathway and thus has an important regulatory function. The data show that cyclic electron transport is under delicate redox control. Inhibition is caused both by excessive oxidation and by over-reduction of electron carriers of the pathway.     

Effects of long-chained aliphatic amines on photosynthetic reactions in isolated spinach chloroplasts

The effect of six long-chained aliphatic amines on ¹⁴CO₂-reduction, electron transport and the 515 nm absorbance change and shrinkage in isolated intact and broken chloroplasts from spinach ( Spinacia oleracea L. cv. Weibulls Medania) was investigated. Five of the six investigated amines affected photosynthesis in intact chloroplasts by inhibiting ¹⁴CO₂-reduction. In broken chloroplasts the same amines uncoupled electron transport. When added to intact chloroplasts the five amines induced a light-dependent oxygen uptake leading to (he formation of hydrogen peroxide. The oxygen uptake was not due to the amines acting as Mehler reactants. The mode of action, different from that of simple aliphatic amines, was an effect on membrane integrity, first affecting the membrane potential. At higher amine concentrations a more general effect on the ion conditions in the thylakoids was evident.     

Catechols stimulate ferricyanide reduction in chloroplast photosystem II.

In isolated chloroplasts (Spinacia olearacea), where electron transport to Photosystem I is blocked by the plastoquinone antagonist, dibromothymoquinone, lipophilic catechols in concentrations of 50--150 microM stimulate ferricyanide reduction in Photosystem II and associated O2 evolution. Non-permeating catechols, such as Tiron, are unable to stimulate this reaction. Those quinones, such as 2,5-dimethylbenzoquinone, which act as class III electron acceptors, do not lead to stimulation of ferricyanide reduction in Photosystem II or stimulation fo associatied O2 evolution, when electron transport to Photosystem I is blocked by dibromoquinone. Stimulation of ferricyanide reduction is not observed in Tris-treated chloroplasts, implying that electron donation to Photosystem II by catechols is not responsible for the stimulation. Various mechanisms for this stimulation in class II chloroplasts are discussed.     

The effect of dimethyl sulphoxide on electron transport in chloroplasts

The effect of DMSO (dimethyl sulphoxide) on electron transport in chloroplast membranes has been studied. It has been found that concentrations of DMSO up to 20% (v/v) do not inhibit electron transport in freshly isolated chloroplasts, but that higher concentrations start to cause inhibition. However, in chloroplasts that have been aged for 8 to 24 hours by storage at 4 degrees C, the addition of DMSO at concentrations up to 20% causes stimulation of electron transport. Possible mechanisms for this effect are discussed.     

Alkaloids as inhibitors of photophosphorylation in spinach chloroplasts

A group of 12 alkaloids were tested as inhibitors of photophosphorylation in spinach chloroplasts. Ajmaline, a dihydroindole alkaloid, was found to be the strongest inhibitor of both cyclic and non-cyclic photophosphorylation. Low concentrations of ajmaline also inhibited the dark and light ATPases, and the coupled electron flow from water to ferricyanide, measured either as ferrocyanide formed or as oxygen evolved, but not the uncoupled electron transport or the pH rise of illuminated unbuffered suspensions of chloroplasts. Higher concentrations of ajmaline stimulated, instead of inhibiting, photosynthetic electron transport or oxygen evolution and decreased the pH rise, thus behaving as an uncoupler, such as ammonia.Photophosphorylation was partially inhibited by 100 μM dihydrosanguinarine, 100 μM dihydrochelerythrine (benzophenanthridine alkaloids); 500 μM O,O'-dimethylmagnoflorine, 500 μM N-methylcorydine (aporphine alkaloids) and 1 mM julocrotine. They also inhibited coupled oxygen evolution and only partially (dihydrosanguinarine and dihydrochelerythrine) or not at all (the other alkaloids) uncoupled oxygen evolution.Spegazzinine (dihydroindole alkaloid), magnoflorine, N-methylisocorydine, coryneine (aporphine alkaloids), candicine and ribalinium chloride were without effect on photophosphorylation at 500 μM.     

Structural and functional stability of isolated intact chloroplasts

The effect of in vitro ageing on the ultrastructure, electron transport, thermoluminescence and flash-induced 515 nm absorbance change of isolated intact (type A) chloroplasts compared with non-intact (types B and C) chloroplasts was studied.When stored in the dark for 18 h at 5°C, the structural characteristics of intact and non-intact chloroplasts were only slightly altered. The most conspicuous difference between the two was in the coupling of the electron transport which was tighter and more stable in intact chloroplasts. Under dark-storage the activity of PS 2* decreased and the -20°C peak of thermoluminescence increased at the expense of the emission at +25°C. These changes were less pronounced in the intact chloroplasts. PS 1 activity and the flash-induced 515 nm absorbance change were not affected by dark-storage.When kept in the light (80 W m^-2 (400–700 nm) for 1 h at 5°C), the thylakoid system of chloroplasts rapidly became disorganized. Although the initial activity of electron transport was much higher in intact chloroplasts, after a short period of light-storage the linear electron transport and the electron transport around PS 2 decreased in both types of preparations to the same low level. These changes were accompanied by an overall decrease of the intensity of thermoluminescence. PS 1 was not inhibited by light-storage, while the flash-induced 515 nm absorbance change was virtually abolished both in preparations of intact and non-intact chloroplasts.The data show that in stored chloroplast preparations intactness cannot be estimated reliably either by the FeCy test or by inspection under the electron microscope. These tests should be cross-checked on the level and coupling of the electron transport.     

Effect of salts and electron transport on the conformation of isolated chloroplasts. I. Light-scattering and volume changes

Whole chloroplasts isolated from the leaves of spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) exhibit 2 types of conformational change during electron transport. Amine-uncoupled chloroplasts swell and atebrin-uncoupled chloroplasts shrink. Chloroplasts uncoupled by carbonylcyanide phenylhydrazones and by treatment with ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid do not change their volumes or light-scattering properties during electron transport. Phosphorylating chloroplasts shrink only slightly.The rate and extent of the conformational change parallel the rate of electron transport; both the decrease in turbidity with methylamine and the increase in turbidity with atebrin are rougly proportional to the Hill reaction rate. Consequently the great volume and light-scattering changes which occur in the presence of these uncouplers can be attributed, in part, to the very high rates of uncoupled electron transport. However, for a given rate of electron transport the atebrin-induced scattering increase is very much greater than the increase observed during photophosphorylation.When uncouplers are combined, the carbonylcyanide phenylhydrazone effect (no change) supercedes both the methylamine effect (swelling) and the atebrin effect (shrinking). The methylamine effect supercedes the atebrin (shrinking) and ethylenediamine tetracetic acid (no change) effects. The atebrin effect supercedes the ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid effect. A similar hierarchy of effects is observed with regard to the rate of the uncoupled electron transport.These light-scattering changes of whole chloroplasts reflect similar changes which occur in very small digitonin particles of chloroplasts. Therefore one must look among chloroplast substructures for the basic mechanism of swelling and shrinking.Many salts (including methylamine hydrochloride) cause the chloroplasts to shrink. This phenomenon is not osmotic since comparable osmolarities of sucrose are without effect. Magnesium chloride and calcium chloride are most effective but all salts tested gave major volume decrease when less than 0.05 m. The salt-shrunken chloroplasts show greater light-scattering changes during electron transport than do low-salt chloroplasts.     

Vanadium in photosynthesis of Chlorella fusca and higher plants

The influence of vanadium compounds (vanadate, vanadyl citrate) on photosynthesis in Chlorella fusca and in algal and spinach chloroplasts has been investigated. It was found that: 1. At moderately high concentrations (at least 0.1 mM) both vanadate and vanadyl citrate enhance photosynthetic O₂ production in intact C. fusca cells. At lower V concentration (about 2 μM) only vanadate stimulates photosynthesis. The increase is dependent on culture conditions and on light intensity. 2. Up to 1 mM V, neither vanadium compound influences PS II activity, either in intact cells or in algal or spinach chloroplasts. 3. The PS I reaction in algal and spinach chloroplasts is maximally enhanced (3-fold) in presence of vanadium (20 μM). The increase is independent of light intensity. 4. Cr(VI), Mo(VI), and W(VI) (1 mM) stimulate photosynthesis in intact C. fusca cells, but do not influence the photosystems of isolated chloroplasts. Vanadium is suggested to act as a redox catalyst in the electron transport from PS II to PS I.     

Inhibition by triphenyltin chloride of a tightly-bound membrane component involved in photophosphorylation.

At very low concentrations (less than 1 muM) triphenyltin chloride inhibits ATP formation and coupled electron transport in isolated spinach chloroplasts. Basal (-Pi) and uncoupled electron transport are not affected by triphenyltin. The membrane-bount ATP in equilibrium Pi exchange and Mg2+-dependent ATPase activities of chloroplasts are also completely sensitive to triphenyltin, although the Ca2+-dependent and Mg2+-dependent ATPase activities of the isolated coupling factor protein are insensitive to triphenyltin. The light-driven proton pump in chloroplasts is stimulated (up to 60%) by low levels of triphenyltin. Indeed, the amount of triphenyltin necessary to inhibit ATP formation or stimulate proton uptake is dependent upon the amount of chloroplasts present in the reaction mixture, with an apparent stoichiometry of 2-2.5 triphenyltin molecules/100 chlorophyll molecules at 50% inhibition of ATP formation and half-maximal stimulation of proton uptake. Chloroplasts partially stripped of coupling factor by an EDTA was are no longer able to accumulate protons in the light. However, low levels of triphenyltin can effectively restore this ability. The amount of triphenyltin required for the restoration of net proton uptake is also dependent upon the amount of chloroplasts, with a stoichiometry of 4-5 triphenyltin molecules/100 chlorophyll molecules at 50% reconstitution. On the basis of this and other evidence it is concluded that triphenyltin chloride inhibits phosphorylation.Atp in equilibrium Pi exchange and membrane-bound ATPase activities in chloroplasts by specifically blocking the transport of protons through a membrane-bound carrier or channel located in a hydrophobic region of the membrane at or near the functional binding site for the coupling factor.     

The effects of high concentrations of salts on photosynthetic electron transport in spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts.

1. Photosynthetic electron transport from water to lipophilic Photosystem II acceptors was stimulated 3--5-fold by high concentrations (greater than or equal to 1 M) of salts containing anions such as citrate, succinate and phosphate that are high in the Hofmeister series. 2. In trypsin-treated chloroplasts, K3Fe(CN)6 reduction insensitive to 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea was strongly stimulated by high concentrations of potassium citrate, but there was much less stimulation of 2,6-dichloroindophenol reduction in Tris-treated chloroplasts supplied with 1,5-diphenylcarbazide as artificial donor. The results suggest that the main site of action of citrate was the O2-evolving complex of Photosystem II. 3. Photosystem I partial reactions were also stimulated by intermediate concentrations of citrate (up to 2-fold stimulation by 0.6--0.8 M-citrate), but were inhibited at the highest concentrations. The observed stimulation may have been caused by stabilizaton of plastocyanin that was complexed with the Photosystem I reaction centre, 4. At 1 M, potassium citrate protected O2 evolution against denaturation by heat or by the chaotropic agent NaNO3. 5. It is suggested that anions high in the Hofmeister series stimulated and stabilized electron transport by enhancing water structure around the protein complexes in the thylakoid membrane.     

Rates of vectorial proton transport supported by cyclic electron flow during oxygen reduction by illuminated intact chloroplasts

The light-dependent quenching of 9-aminoacridine fluorescence was used to monitor the state of the transthylakoid proton gradient in illuminated intact chloroplasts in the presence or absence of external electron acceptors. The absence of appreciable light-dependent fluorescence quenching under anaerobic conditions indicated inhibition of coupled electron transport in the absence of external electron acceptors. Oxygen relieved this inhibition. However, when DCMU inhibited excessive reduction of the plastoquinone pool in the absence of oxygen, coupled cyclic electron transport supported the formation of a transthylakoid proton gradient even under anaerobiosis. This proton gradient collapsed in the presence of oxygen. Under aerobic conditions, and when KCN inhibited ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase and ascorbate peroxidase, fluorescence quenching indicated the formation of a transthylakoid proton gradient which was larger with oxygen in the Mehler reaction as electron acceptor than with methylviologen at similar rates of linear electron transport. Apparently, cyclic electron transport occured simultaneously with linear electron transport, when oxygen was available as electron acceptor, but not when methylviologen accepted electrons from Photosystem I. The ratio of cyclic to linear electron transport could be increased by low concentrations of DCMU. This shows that even under aerobic conditions cyclic electron transport is limited in isolated intact chloroplasts by excessive reduction of electron carriers. In fact, P₇₀₀ in the reaction center of Photosystem I remained reduced in illuminated isolated chloroplasts under conditions which resulted in extensive oxidation of P₇₀₀ in leaves. This shows that regulation of Photosystem II activity is less effective in isolated chloroplasts than in leaves. Assuming that a Q-cycle supports a H⁺/e ratio of 3 during slow linear electron transport, vectorial proton transport coupled to Photosystem I-dependent cyclic electron flow could be calculated. The highest calculated rate of Photosystem I-dependent proton transport, which was not yet light-saturated, was 330 mol protons (mg chlorophyll h)^–1 in intact chloroplasts. If H⁺/e is not three but two proton transfer is not 330 but 220 mol (mg Chl H)^–1. Differences in the regulation of cyclic electron transport in isolated chloroplasts and in leaves are discussed.     

Differential changes in the electron transport properties of thylakoid membranes during aging of attached and detached leaves, and of isolated chloroplasts

Abstract. Aging of chloroplasts both in vivo and in vitro causes a considerable loss in the 2,6-dichlorophenol indophenol (DCPIP)-Hill reaction with water as electron donor. The loss can be reduced by exogenous electron donors like diphenyl carbazide (DPC). suggestive of aging-induced damage of the oxygen evolving system. Aging also brings about a considerable loss in methylviologen (MV) reduction mediated by Photosystem I (PS I) of chloroplasts with an ascorbate-DCPIP couple as the electron donating system.
The loss in the electron transport ability of the plastids is faster during in vitro compared to in vivo aging of the chloroplasts.
Light protects the photo-electron transport ability of chloroplasts during aging of intact leaves in contrast to its action during aging of the isolated organelles.     

Nano-Anatase Relieves the Inhibition of Electron Transport Caused by Linolenic Acid in Chloroplasts of Spinach

Linolenic acid is an inhibitor of electron transport in chloroplasts of higher plants. It has obvious effects on the structure and function of chloroplasts. In the present paper, we investigated the nano-anatase relieving the inhibition of photoreduction activity and oxygen evolution caused by linolenic acid in spinach chloroplasts. The results showed that linolenic acid in various concentrations could obviously reduce the whole chain electron transport and the photoreduction activity of two photosystems, especially on the oxidative reside and reduce reside of photosystem II (PS II). After adding nano-anatase to chloroplasts treated by linolenic acid, the whole chain electron transport rate, the photoreduction activity of two photosystems, and the oxygen evolution rate were increased significantly, indicating that nano-anatase could obviously decrease the inhibition of linolenic acid on the electron transport, photoreduction activity, and oxygen evolution of spinach chloroplasts.