Metal binding to Pseudomonas aeruginosa azurin: a kinetic investigation

The interaction between azurin from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Ag(I), Cu(II), Hg(II), was investigated as a function of protein state, i.e. apo-, reduced and oxidised azurin. Two different metal binding sites, characterized by two different spectroscopic absorbancies, were detected: one is accessible to Ag(I) and Cu(II) but not to Hg(II); the other one binds Ag(I) and Hg(II) but not copper. When added in stoichiometric amount, Ag(I) shows high affinity for the redox center of apo-azurin, to which it probably binds by the -SH group of Cys112; it can displace Cu(I) from reducedazurin, while it does not bind to the redox center of oxidizedazurin. Kinetic experiments show that Ag(I) binding to the reduced form is four times faster than binding to the apo-form. This result suggests that metal binding requires a conformational rearrangement of the active site of the azurin. Interaction of Ag(I) or Hg(II) ions to the second metal binding site, induces typical changes of UV spectrum and quenching of fluorescence emission.     

Metal-binding properties of an engineered purple CuA center in azurin

A CUA center engineered into Pseudomonas aeruginosa azurin was studied by metal substitution. Metal-binding properties were determined by electronic absorption (UV-vis) and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The metal-binding site readily binds thiophilic metal ions, such as Hg(II), Ag(I), Cu(I), Cd(II), and Au(I). Harder metal ions, like Co(II), bind to apo-CuA-azurin only under basic conditions (pH 9.1-9.2). The results obtained from these studies indicate that two factors influence metal binding in CuA azurin: (1) the site favors metal combinations which produce an overall +3 charge, and (2) the site binds soft, thiophilic metal ions. The results demonstrate the remarkable ability of the CuA center to maintain valence delocalization of its native metal ions and to ensure redox accessibility of only one of the two redox couples (i.e., [Cu(1.5)...Cu(1.5)]<==> [Cu(I)...Cu(I)]) under physiological conditions. These findings may lead to the preparation of new metal ion derivatives and can serve as a basis for understanding this efficient electron transfer center.     

Studies of thermally induced denaturation of azurin and azurin derivatives by differential scanning calorimetry: evidence for copper selectivity

Azurin, a blue copper protein from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and several derivatives of azurin have been studied by differential scanning calorimetry. Two well-separated, irreversible transitions are observed in a scan of apoazurin under a variety of conditions, and they are assigned to distinct steps in the denaturation process. No specific structural component can be assigned to the lower temperature transition, but a "flap" structure which is found near the metal binding site may be involved. Circular dichroic spectra suggest that melting of the beta-sheet structure, the main structural motif in the native protein, occurs during the second transition. With the exceptions of the Ni(II) and p-(hydroxymercuri)benzoate derivatives, the transitions are superposed in the metalated forms, and the enthalpies of denaturation are more endothermic. By comparison with other first-row divalent transition ions and especially Zn(II), the Cu(II) derivative exhibits the most endothermic denaturation process. Along with other data, this suggests that the binding energy is greater for Cu(II). It is postulated that the selectivity for copper over zinc arises because of the irregular binding geometry offered by the folded protein. Denaturation of the Hg(II) derivative is even more endothermic, confirming that the type 1 binding site has a very great affinity for Hg(II). Finally, when substoichiometric amounts of Hg(II) are added to the apoprotein, there is evidence that a novel mercury-bridged dimer of azurin forms.     

Thermodynamic and spectroscopic study of Cu(II) and Ni(II) binding to bovine serum albumin

The thermodynamics of Cu(II) and Ni(II) binding to bovine serum albumin (BSA) have been studied by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). The Cu(II) binding affinity of the N-terminal protein site is quantitatively higher when the single free thiol, Cys-34, is reduced (mercaptalbumin), compared to when it is oxidized or derivatized with N-ethylmaleimide. This increased affinity is due predominantly to entropic factors. At higher pH (approximately 9), when the protein is in the basic (B) form, a second Cu(II) binds with high affinity to albumin with reduced Cys-34. The Cu(II) coordination has been characterized by UV-vis absorption, CD, and EPR spectroscopy, and the spectral data are consistent with thiolate coordination to a tetragonal Cu(II), indicating this is a type 2 copper site with thiolate ligation. Nickel(II) binding to the N-terminal site of BSA is also modulated by the redox/ligation state of Cys-34, with higher Ni(II) affinity for mercaptalbumin, the predominant circulating form of the protein.     

Photophysics of metalloazurins

The fluorescence lifetimes of Cu(II), Cu(I), Ag(I), Hg(II), Co(II), and Ni(II) azurin Pae from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Cu(II), Cu(I), and Hg(II) azurin Afe from Alcaligenes faecalis were measured at 295 K by time-correlated single-photon counting. In addition, fluorescence lifetimes of Cu(II) azurin Pae were measured between 30 and 160 K and showed little change in value. Ultraviolet absorption difference spectra between metalloazurin Pae and apoazurin Pae were measured, as were the fluorescence spectra of metalloazurins. These spectra were used to determine the spectral overlap integral required for dipole-dipole resonance calculations. All metalloazurins exhibit a reduced fluorescence lifetime compared to their respective apoazurins. Forster electronic energy transfer rates were calculated for both metalloazurin Pae and metalloazurin Afe derivatives; both enzymes contain a single tryptophyl residue which is located in a different position in the two azurins. These azurins have markedly different fluorescence spectra, and electronic energy transfers occur from these two tryptophyl sites with different distances and orientations and spectral overlap integral values. Intramolecular distances and orientations were derived from an X-ray crystallographic structure and a molecular dynamic simulation of the homologous azurin Ade from Alcaligenes denitrificans, which contains both tryptophyl sites. Assignments were made of metal-ligand-field electronic transitions and of transition dipole moments and directions for tryptophyl residues, which accounted for the observed fluorescence quenching of Hg(II), Co(II), and Ni(II) azurin Pae and Cu(II) and Hg(II) azurin Afe. The fluorescence of azurin Pae is assigned as a 1Lb electronic transition, while that of azurin Afe is 1La. The marked fluorescence quenching of Cu(II) azurin Pae and Cu(I) azurin Pae and Afe is less well reproduced by our calculations, and long-range oxidative and reductive electron transfer, respectively, are proposed as additional quenching mechanisms. This study illustrates the application of Forster electronic energy transfer calculations to intramolecular transfers in structurally well characterized molecular systems and demonstrates its ability to predict observed fluorescence quenching rates when the necessary extensive structural, electronic transition assignment, and spectroscopic data are available. The agreement between Forster calculations and quenching rates derived from fluorescence lifetime measurements suggests there are limited changes in conformation between crystal structure and solution structures, with the exception of the tryptophyl residue of azurin Afe, where a conformation derived from a molecular simulation in water was necessary rather than that found in the crystal structure.     

The effect of redox state on the folding free energy of azurin

 The unfolding of oxidized and reduced azurin by guanidine hydrochloride has been monitored by circular dichroism. Dilution experiments showed the unfolding to be reversible, and the equilibrium data have been interpreted in terms of a two-state model. The protein is stabilized by the strong metal binding in the native state, so that the folding free energy is as high as –52.2 kJ mol^–1 for the oxidized protein. The reduced protein is less stable, with a folding free energy of –40.0 kJ mol^–1. A thermodynamic cycle shows, as a consequence, that unfolded azurin has a reduction potential 0.13 V above that of the folded protein. This is explained by the bipyramidal site in the native fold stabilizing Cu(II) by a rack mechanism, with the same geometry being maintained in the Cu(I) form. In the unfolded protein, on the other hand, the coordination geometries are expected to differ for the two oxidation states, Cu(I) being stabilized by the cysteine thiol group in a linear or trigonal symmetry, whereas Cu(II) prefers oxygen ligands in a tetragonal geometry. Received: 15 January 1997 / Accepted: 3 April 1997     

Periplasmic metal-resistance protein CusF exhibits high affinity and specificity for both CuI and AgI

The periplasmic protein CusF, as a part of the CusCFBA efflux complex, plays a role in resistance to elevated levels of copper and silver in Escherichia coli. Although homologues have been identified in other Gram-negative bacteria, the substrate of CusF and its precise role in metal resistance have not been described. Here, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was used to demonstrate that CusF binds with high affinity to both Cu(I) and Ag(I) but not Cu(II). The affinity of CusF for Ag(I) was higher than that for Cu(I), which could reflect more efficient detoxification of Ag(I) given the lack of a cellular need for Ag(I). The chemical shifts in the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra of CusF-Ag(I) as compared to apo-CusF show that the region of CusF most affected by Ag(I) binding encompasses three absolutely conserved residues: H36, M47, and M49. This suggests that these residues may play a role in Ag(I) coordination. The NMR spectra of CusF in the presence of Cu(II) do not indicate specific binding, which is in agreement with the ITC data. We conclude that Cu(I) and Ag(I) are the likely physiological substrates.     

The Methylococcus capsulatus (Bath) Secreted Protein, MopE*, Binds Both Reduced and Oxidized Copper

Under copper limiting growth conditions the methanotrophic bacterium Methylococcus capsulatus (Bath) secrets essentially only one protein, MopE*, to the medium. MopE* is a copper-binding protein whose structure has been determined by X-ray crystallography. The structure of MopE* revealed a unique high affinity copper binding site consisting of two histidine imidazoles and one kynurenine, the latter an oxidation product of Trp130. In this study, we demonstrate that the copper ion coordinated by this strong binding site is in the Cu(I) state when MopE* is isolated from the growth medium of M. capsulatus. The conclusion is based on X-ray Near Edge Absorption spectroscopy (XANES), and Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) studies. EPR analyses demonstrated that MopE*, in addition to the strong copper-binding site, also binds Cu(II) at two weaker binding sites. Both Cu(II) binding sites have properties typical of non-blue type II Cu (II) centres, and the strongest of the two Cu(II) sites is characterised by a relative high hyperfine coupling of copper (A_|| = 20 mT). Immobilized metal affinity chromatography binding studies suggests that residues in the N-terminal part of MopE* are involved in forming binding site(s) for Cu(II) ions. Our results support the hypothesis that MopE plays an important role in copper uptake, possibly making use of both its high (Cu(I) and low Cu(II) affinity properties.     

Complexometric titrations of protein-bound metal ions: a method for determining binding constants

A method for quantifying the affinity of proteins for specific metal ions has been developed. Both the stoichiometry and the binding constants of the protein-bound metal ion can be determined by titrating protein-bound metal ions with complexometric reagents and observing electrochemically the change in free metal ion concentration. The technique is limited to cases where the affinity of the macromolecule for the metal ion is less than or similar to the affinity of the complexometric reagent for the metal ion. The method has been employed successfully in the study of both Cu(II) and Ag(I) binding to the apoprotein of bovine cuprozinc superoxide dismutase.     

Solution structures of the reduced and Cu(I) bound forms of the first metal binding sequence of ATP7A associated with Menkes disease

The coding sequence for the first N-terminal copper binding motif of the human Menkes disease protein (MNK1; residues 2-79) was synthesized, cloned, and expressed in bacteria for biochemical and structural studies. MNK1 adopts the betaalphabetabetaalphabeta fold common to all the metal binding sequences (MBS) found in other metal transport systems (e.g., the yeast copper chaperone for superoxide dismutase CCS, the yeast copper chaperone ATX1 bound to Hg(II), and most recently Cu(I), the bacterial copper binding protein, CopZ, and the bacterial Hg(II) binding protein MerP), although substantial differences were found in the metal binding loop. Similar to ATX1, MNK1 binds Cu(I) in a distorted linear bicoordinate geometry. As with MerP, MNK1 has a high affinity for both Hg(II) and Cu(I), although it displays a marked preference for Cu(I). In addition, we found that F71 is a key residue in the compact folding of MNK1, and its mutation to alanine results in an unfolded structure. The homologous residue in MerP has also been mutated with similar results. Finally, to understand the relationship between protein folding and metal affinity and specificity, we expressed a chimeric MBS with the MNK1 protein carrying the binding motif of MerP (CAAC-MNK1); this chimeric protein showed differences in structure and the dynamics of the binding site that may account for metal specificity.     

Distinct metal-binding configurations in metallothionein

In a study of the binding stoichiometry of various metals to rat liver metallothionein, the protein appears to coordinate metals in 2 distinct configurations. Ions of at least 18 different metals were shown to associate with the protein suggesting that there is little specificity in binding. Most metals exhibited saturation binding at 7 mol eq forming M7-metallothionein. These included Bi(III), Cd(II), Co(II), Hg(II), In(III), Ni(II), Pb(II), Sb(III), and Zn(II). Others metals including Os(III), Pd(II), Pt(IV), Re(V), Rh(III), and Tl(III) give a positive indication of binding, but stoichiometries were unclear. Ag(I) and Cu(I) bound in clusters as M12-metallothionein. This binding stoichiometry was determined in 3 ways: (a) by determining the equivalence point in Cu- and Ag-titrated samples where resistance to proteolysis is maximal; (b) by determining the point where Zn ions are completely displaced from Zn7-metallothionein; and (c) by direct binding studies. Ag-reconstituted protein, recovered from gel filtration, had an average Ag content of 11.5 g atoms/mol of protein. A similar stoichiometry for the Cu-protein resulted from displacement of Zn from Zn7-metallothionein by Cu(I). The M12-protein was converted to the M7-protein by displacement of Ag(I) or Cu(I) with 7 mol eq of Hg(II). Whereas the distribution of metals in the 2 domains of M7-metallothionein is M4 alpha and M3 beta, the arrangement in the M12-molecule is probably M6 alpha and M6 beta. We propose that metallothionein ligates Ag(I) and Cu(I) in a trigonal geometry by bridging thiolates. This is in contradistinction to a tetrahedral binding geometry in the M7-protein. Distinct binding configurations may result in different tertiary structures for M7- and M12-proteins which may relate to metabolic specificity of Zn-metallothionein and Cu-metallothionein, respectively.     

Unusual Cu(I)/Ag(I) coordination of Escherichia coli CusF as revealed by atomic resolution crystallography and X-ray absorption spectroscopy

Elevated levels of copper or silver ions in the environment are an immediate threat to many organisms. Escherichia coli is able to resist the toxic effects of these ions through strictly limiting intracellular levels of Cu(I) and Ag(I). The CusCFBA system is one system in E. coli responsible for copper/silver tolerance. A key component of this system is the periplasmic copper/silver-binding protein, CusF. Here the X-ray structure and XAS data on the CusF-Ag(I) and CusF-Cu(I) complexes, respectively, are reported. In the CusF-Ag(I) structure, Ag(I) is coordinated by two methionines and a histidine, with a nearby tryptophan capping the metal site. EXAFS measurements on the CusF-Cu(I) complex show a similar environment for Cu(I). The arrangement of ligands effectively sequesters the metal from its periplasmic environment and thus may play a role in protecting the cell from the toxic ion.     

Cu(I) analysis of blue copper proteins.

A simple colorimetric test for the Cu(I) content in blue copper proteins is described. The procedure is based on the formation of a complex between Cu(I) and 2,2'-biquinoline in an acetic acid medium. Analyses of spinach plastocyanin, Pseudomonas aeruginosa azurin and Rhus vernicifera stellacyanin show that the cysteine residue in the type 1 site does not induce Cu(II) reduction under our conditions. There is evidence in laccase samples for the presence of an endogenous reductant that can reduce 0.14 +/- 0.04 mol of Cu(II)/mol of protein; however, the addition of EDTA eliminates the interference. The analysis shows that 25 +/- 2% of the type 3 copper ions are in the reduced form in the resting enzyme and that 80 +/- 15% of the type 3 copper ions are reduced in preparations of type-2-depleted laccase. There is growing interest in the development of chemically modified forms of laccase, and our method should be very useful for establishing the valence state of the metal centres in the various derivatives.     

Characteristics of azurin from Pseudomonas aeruginosa via 270-MHz 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.

Assignments of resonances in the 1H nmr spectra of Cu(I) azurin to proton groups in the protein are discussed in detail. Comparisons are drawn between Cu(I), Cu(II), apo, Hg(II), and Co(II) azurin samples. Redox titration of Cu(I) azurin with K3Fe(CN)6, is used to correlate Cu(I) and Cu(II) 1H nmr spectral features, and observed line broadenings deriving from Cu(II) paramagnetic effects are used to deduce the distances of assigned proton groups from the copper center. Histidine residues are characterized in terms of pK values, rates of acid-base exchange near the the pK, and rates of C2H exchange with solvent deuterium. The possibility of histidine involvement in the azurincytochrome 551 electron exchange mechanism is discussed. A small number of NH protons observed to be distinctively inert to 2H exchange with solvent 2H2O, in the Cu(I) protein, are found to show increased lability on removal of the metal.     

Copper and the oxidation of hemoglobin: a comparison of horse and human hemoglobins.

Oxidation studies of hemoglobin by Cu(II) indicate that for horse hemoglobin, up to a Cu(II)/heme molar ratio of 0.5, all of the Cu(II) added is used to rapidly oxidize the heme. On the other hand, most of the Cu(II) added to human hemoglobin at low Cu(II)/heme molar ratios is unable to oxidize the heme. Only at Cu(II)/heme molar ratios greater than 0.5 does the amount of oxidation per added Cu(II) approach that of horse hemoglobin. At the same time, binding studies indicate that human hemoglobin has an additional binding site involving one copper for every two hemes, which has a higher copper affinity than the single horse hemoglobin binding site. The Cu(II) oxidation of human hemoglobin is explained utilizing this additional binding site by a mechanism where a transfer of electrons cannot occur between the heme and the Cu(II) bound to the high affinity human binding site. The electron transfer must involve the Cu(II) bound to the lower affinity human hemoglobin binding site, which is similar to the only horse hemoglobin site. The involvement of beta-2 histidine in the binding of this additional copper is indicated by a comparison of the amino acid sequences of various hemoglobins which possess the additional site, with the amino acid sequences of hemoglobins which do not possess the additional site. Zn(II), Hg(II), and N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) are found to decrease the Cu(II) oxidation of hemoglobin. The sulfhydryl reagents, Hg(II) and NEM, produce a very dramatic decrease in the rate of oxidation, which can only be explained by an effect on the rate for the actual transfer of electrons between the Cu(II) and the Fe(II). The effect of Zn(II) is much smaller and can, for the most part, be explained by the increased oxygen affinity, which affects the ligand dissociation process that must precede the electron transfer process.     

Stellacyanin. Studies of the metal-binding site using x-ray absorption spectroscopy.

Stellacyanin is a mucoprotein of molecular weight approximately 20,000 containing one copper atom in a blue or type I site. The metal ion can exist in both the Cu(II) and Cu(I) redox states. The metal binding site in plastocyanin, another blue copper protein, contains one cysteinyl, one methionyl, and two imidazoyl residues (Colman et al. 1978. Nature [Lond.]. 272:319-324.), but an exactly analogous site cannot exist in stellacyanin as it lacks methionine. The copper coordination in stellacyanin has been studied by x-ray edge absorption and extended x-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) analysis. A new, very conservative data analysis procedure has been introduced, which suggests that the there are two nitrogen atoms in the first coordination shell of the oxidized [Cu(II)] protein and one in the reduced [Cu(I)] protein; these N atoms have normal Cu--N distances: 1.95-2.05 A. In both redox states there are either one or two sulfur atoms coordinating the copper, the exact number being indeterminable from the present data. In the oxidized state the Cu--S distance is intermediate between the short bond found in plastocyanin and those found in near tetragonal copper model compounds. Above -140 degree C, radiation damage of the protein occurs. At room temperature the oxidized proteins is modified in the x-ray beam at a rate of 0.25%/s.     

Independence of the domains of metallothionein in metal binding

Mammalian metallothionein is a low molecular weight protein with two metal-binding domains. To determine if metal binding in one domain affects binding in the other, we prepared peptides corresponding to the regions that enfold the two metal-thiolate clusters. Metal reconstitution studies of these peptides revealed stoichiometries of metal binding similar to those observed within the intact molecule. Thus, the alpha domain coordinates 4 Cd(II), 6 Cu(I), or 6 Ag(I) ions regardless of whether the domain is part of the total protein or is studied as a separate peptide. Likewise, the beta domain binds 3 Cd(II), 6 Cu(I), or 6 Ag(I) ions in both the intact protein and as a separate peptide. If cluster B in intact metallothionein is preformed with Cu(I) or Ag(I), cluster A saturates with either 4 mol eq of Cd(II) or 6 mol eq of Ag(I). Similarly, preformation of the A cluster with Cd(II) does not affect the binding of 6 Cu(I) ions in the B cluster. Therefore, the metal-dependent folding of the protein to create one cluster occurs independent of constraints or influences from the other domain. Formation of the protein with a tetrahedrally coordinated metal in one cluster and a trigonally coordinated metal in the other center is possible.     

Copper binding traps the folded state of the SCO protein from Bacillus subtilis

The SCO protein from the aerobic bacterium Bacillus subtilis (BsSCO) is involved in the assembly of the cytochrome c oxidase complex, and specifically with the Cu(A) center. BsSCO has been proposed to play various roles in Cu(A) assembly including, the direct delivery of copper ions to the Cu(A) site, and/or maintaining the appropriate redox state of the cysteine ligands during formation of Cu(A). BsSCO binds copper in both Cu(II) and Cu(I) redox states, but has a million-fold higher affinity for Cu(II). As a prerequisite to kinetic studies, we measured equilibrium stability of oxidized, reduced and Cu(II)-bound BsSCO by chemical and thermal induced denaturation. Oxidized and reduced apo-BsSCO exhibit two-state behavior in both chemical- and thermal-induced unfolding. However, the Cu(II) complex of BsSCO is stable in up to nine molar urea. Thermal or guanidinium-induced unfolding of BsSCO-Cu(II) ensues only as the Cu(II) species is lost. The effect of copper (II) on the folding of BsSCO is complicated by a rapid redox reaction between copper and reduced, denatured BsSCO. When denatured apo-BsSCO is refolded in the presence of copper (II) some of the population is recovered as the BsSCO-Cu(II) complex and some is oxidized indicating that refolding and oxidation are competing processes. The proposed functional roles for BsSCO in vivo require that its cysteine residues are reduced and the presence of copper during folding may be detrimental to BsSCO attaining its functional state.     

A pH dependence study on the unfolding and refolding of apoazurin

Azurin, a small blue copper protein from the bacterial species Pseudomonas aeruginosa, is mostly a β-sheet protein arranged into a single domain. Previous folding studies have shown that the equilibrium denaturation of the holoprotein follows a two-state process; however, upon removal of the copper, the denaturation had been reported to follow a three-state process. The two unfolding transitions measured for apoazurin had been thought to arise from two different folding domains. However, in the present work, we found that the denaturation of apoazurin occurs over a single transition and we determined the folding free energy to be −27.8±2.4 kJ mol⁻¹. From this measurement along with measurements previously reported for the unfolding of the holoazurin, we were able to determine that Cu(II) and Cu(I) stabilize the native structure by 25.1±6.9 kJ/mol and 12.9±8.1 kJ/mol, respectively. It is our contention that the second transition displayed in the denaturation curves previously reported for apoazurin arise from protein heterogeneity—in particular, from the presence of Zn(II) azurin. We extended our investigation into the denaturation of Zn(II) azurin at pH 6.0 and 7.5. The equilibrium denaturation studies show that the zinc ion significantly stabilizes the native-state structure at pH 7.5 and very little at the lower pH. We attribute the decrease in the stabilizing effect of the zinc ion with decreasing pH to the protonation of two histidinyl side chains. When protonated the ligands, His 46 and His 117, are incapable of binding a metal ion. Further, comparing the denaturation curves of Zn(II) azurin measured by circular dichroism with those measured by fluorescence indicates that the denaturation of Zn(II) azurin is far less simple than the denaturation of apoazurin.