Regulation of nuclear transport and degradation of the Xenopus cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor, p27Xic1

The regulation of the vertebrate cell cycle is controlled by the function of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs), cyclins, and CDK inhibitors. The Xenopus laevis kinase inhibitor, p27(Xic1) (Xic1) is a member of the p21(Cip1)/p27(Kip1)/p57(Kip2) CDK inhibitor family and inhibits CDK2-cyclin E in vitro as well as DNA replication in Xenopus egg extracts. Xic1 is targeted for degradation in interphase extracts in a manner dependent on both the ubiquitin conjugating enzyme, Cdc34, and nuclei. Here we show that ubiquitination of Xic1 occurs exclusively in the nucleus and that nuclear localization of Xic1 is necessary for its degradation. We find that Xic1 nuclear localization is independently mediated by binding to CDK2-cyclin E and by nuclear localization sequences within the C terminus of Xic1. Our results also indicate that binding of Xic1 to CDK2-cyclin E is dispensable for Xic1 ubiquitination and degradation. Moreover, we show that amino acids 180-183 of Xic1 are critical determinants of Xic1 degradation. This region of Xic1 may define a motif of Xic1 essential for recognition by the ubiquitin conjugation machinery or for binding an alternate protein required for degradation.     

Ubiquitination of Cyclin-Dependent Kinase Inhibitor,Xic1, is Mediated by the Xenopus F-box Protein xSkp2

In the frog, Xenopus laevis, the Cip/Kip-type cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) inhibitor, Xic1, inhibits DNA replication in interphase egg extracts through the binding of CDK2-cyclins and Proliferating Cell Nuclear Antigen (PCNA). During DNA polymerase switching in the replicating Xenopus egg extract, Xic1 is targeted for ubiquitination and degradation when localized to chromatin through its binding to PCNA. To date, the machinery responsible for Xic1 ubiquitination is unknown and although it is predicted that the E3 called SCF may mediate Xic1 ubiquitination, characterization of the SCF in Xenopus is lacking. In this study, we describe the identification and characterization of Xenopus Skp2 (xSkp2) and the role of xSkp2 in the ubiquitination of Xic1. Our results indicate that the expression of xSkp2 appears to be developmentally regulated with low protein levels found in the egg and increased levels found in the developing embryo. We also demonstrate that when ectopically expressed, a xSkp2 F-box deletion mutant inhibits the initiation of DNA replication suggesting a role for the SCF in the onset of S phase in Xenopus egg extracts. We further show that xSkp2 binds to C-terminal residues of Xic1 and when co-expressed with Skp1, promotes the proteolysis of Xic1 in the egg extract. Moreover, the xSkp2 F-box deletion mutant inhibits the DNA-dependent ubiquitination and proteolysis of Xic1 when added to the interphase egg extract. Importantly, our studies demonstrate that SCFxSkp2 supports the ubiquitination of Xic1 in a reconstituted in vitro ubiquitination assay and that this Xic1 ubiquitination does not require either CDK2-cyclins or Cks1. These studies provide the first characterization of the SCF in Xenopus and its role in the ubiquitination of CDK inhibitor, Xic1, during DNA replication initiation.     

Proliferating cell nuclear antigen recruits cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor Xic1 to DNA and couples its proteolysis to DNA polymerase switching

The Xenopus cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) inhibitor, p27(Xic1) (Xic1), binds to CDK2-cyclins and proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), inhibits DNA synthesis in Xenopus extracts, and is targeted for ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis. Previous studies suggest that Xic1 ubiquitination and degradation are coupled to the initiation of DNA replication, but the precise timing and molecular mechanism of Xic1 proteolysis has not been determined. Here we demonstrate that Xic1 proteolysis is temporally restricted to late replication initiation following the requirements for DNA polymerase alpha-primase, replication factor C, and PCNA. Our studies also indicate that Xic1 degradation is absolutely dependent upon the binding of Xic1 to PCNA in both Xenopus egg and gastrulation stage extracts. Additionally, extracts depleted of PCNA do not support Xic1 proteolysis. Importantly, while the addition of recombinant wild-type PCNA alone restores Xic1 degradation, the addition of a PCNA mutant defective for trimer formation does not restore Xic1 proteolysis in PCNA-depleted extracts, suggesting Xic1 proteolysis requires both PCNA binding to Xic1 and the ability of PCNA to be loaded onto primed DNA by replication factor C. Taken together, our studies suggest that Xic1 is targeted for ubiquitination and degradation during DNA polymerase switching through its interaction with PCNA at a site of initiation.     

Proteolysis of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Xenopus</Emphasis> Cip-type CDK inhibitor,p16<Superscript>Xic2</Superscript>, is regulated by PCNA binding and CDK2 phosphorylation

Background

Cell division is positively regulated by cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) partnered with cyclins and negatively regulated by CDK inhibitors. In the frog, Xenopus laevis, three types of CDK inhibitors have been described: p27^Xic1 (Xic1) which shares sequence homology with both p21^Cip1 and p27^Kip1 from mammals, p16^Xic2 (Xic2) which shares sequence homology with p21^Cip1, and p17^Xic3 (Xic3) which shares sequence homology with p27^Kip1. While past studies have demonstrated that during DNA polymerase switching, Xic1 is targeted for protein turnover dependent upon DNA, Proliferating Cell Nuclear Antigen (PCNA), and the ubiquitin ligase CRL4^Cdt2, little is known about the processes that regulate Xic2 or Xic3.

Methods

We used the Xenopus interphase egg extract as a model system to examine the regulation of Xic2 by proteolysis and phosphorylation.

Results

Our studies indicated that following primer synthesis during the initiation of DNA replication, Xic2 is targeted for DNA- and PCNA-dependent ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis and that Cdt2 can promote Xic2 turnover. Additionally, during interphase, Xic2 is phosphorylated by CDK2 at Ser-98 and Ser-131 in a DNA-independent manner, inhibiting Xic2 turnover. In the presence of double-stranded DNA ends, Xic2 is also phosphorylated at Ser-78 and Ser-81 by a caffeine-sensitive kinase, but this phosphorylation does not alter Xic2 turnover. Conversely, in the presence or absence of DNA, Xic3 was stable in the Xenopus interphase egg extract and did not exhibit a shift indicative of phosphorylation.

Conclusions

During interphase, Xic2 is targeted for DNA- and PCNA-dependent proteolysis that is negatively regulated by CDK2 phosphorylation. During a response to DNA damage, Xic2 may be alternatively regulated by phosphorylation by a caffeine-sensitive kinase. Our studies suggest that the three types of Xenopus CDK inhibitors, Xic1, Xic2, and Xic3 appear to be uniquely regulated which may reflect their specialized roles during cell division or early development in the frog.

     

The CRL4Cdt2 Ubiquitin Ligase Mediates the Proteolysis of Cyclin-Dependent Kinase Inhibitor Xic1 through a Direct Association with PCNA

During DNA polymerase switching, the Xenopus laevis Cip/Kip-type cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor Xic1 associates with trimeric proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and is recruited to chromatin, where it is ubiquitinated and degraded. In this study, we show that the predominant E3 for Xic1 in the egg is the Cul4-DDB1-XCdt2 (Xenopus Cdt2) (CRL4^Cdt2) ubiquitin ligase. The addition of full-length XCdt2 to the Xenopus extract promotes Xic1 turnover, while the N-terminal domain of XCdt2 (residues 1 to 400) cannot promote Xic1 turnover, despite its ability to bind both Xic1 and DDB1. Further analysis demonstrated that XCdt2 binds directly to PCNA through its C-terminal domain (residues 401 to 710), indicating that this interaction is important for promoting Xic1 turnover. We also identify the cis-acting sequences required for Xic1 binding to Cdt2. Xic1 binds to Cdt2 through two domains (residues 161 to 170 and 179 to 190) directly flanking the Xic1 PCNA binding domain (PIP box) but does not require PIP box sequences (residues 171 to 178). Similarly, human p21 binds to human Cdt2 through residues 156 to 161, adjacent to the p21 PIP box. In addition, we identify five lysine residues (K180, K182, K183, K188, and K193) immediately downstream of the Xic1 PIP box and within the second Cdt2 binding domain as critical sites for Xic1 ubiquitination. Our studies suggest a model in which both the CRL4^Cdt2 E3- and PIP box-containing substrates, like Xic1, are recruited to chromatin through independent direct associations with PCNA.The eukaryotic cell cycle is positively regulated by cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) and negatively regulated by CDK inhibitors (CKIs) (22, 25, 27, 28). A complete knockout of all CDK inhibitor function, although as yet not attained in mammalian cells, has been accomplished in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and is shown to result in genomic instability due to premature entry into S phase (19). Conversely, the overexpression of cyclin E in mammalian cells has also been observed to induce chromosome instability (31). These studies suggest that CDK inhibitor function can play a critical role in maintaining genomic stability through the proper regulation of DNA replication initiation. Mammalian Cip/Kip-type CDK inhibitors p27 and p21 are stoichiometric inhibitors of CDK2-cyclins that regulate the entry into S phase and are targeted by ubiquitin- and proteasome-dependent proteolysis during the G₁-to-S-phase transition (4, 5, 33, 35). In the frog, Xenopus laevis, three types of CDK inhibitors have been identified that share sequence and functional similarities with mammalian p27 and p21. The first type of CDK inhibitor includes the Xenopus inhibitor of CDK (p27^Xic1 or Xic1) and kinase inhibitor from Xenopus (p28^Kix1 or Kix1), which share ∼90% amino acid sequence identity with each other, preferentially inhibit the activity of CDK2-cyclin E or A and bind all CDK-cyclins and proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNAs) (30, 32). The second and third types of Xenopus CDK inhibitors are p16^Xic2 and p17^Xic3, which share sequence homology with p21 and p27, respectively, and exhibit restricted developmental expression but have not been extensively characterized biochemically (9).In an effort to study the molecular mechanism of Cip/Kip-type CDK inhibitor proteolysis in the context of the temporal events of DNA replication initiation, we utilize the biochemically tractable Xenopus egg extract system. This extract can recapitulate all of the events of semiconservative DNA replication and fully support protein ubiquitination and degradation in the context of DNA replication initiation (3, 36). Using this system, we have shown that during DNA polymerase switching, Xic1 is recruited to sites of DNA replication initiation through its association with proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and is targeted for ubiquitination and degradation (6). Using a strategy of PCNA reconstitution to PCNA-depleted extracts, our studies showed that Xic1 ubiquitination and turnover required not only PCNA binding but also the ability of PCNA to be loaded at a site of DNA replication initiation by replication factor C (RFC) (6). Our previous study indicated that like mammalian p27 and p21, Xic1 could be ubiquitinated in vitro by SCF^XSkp2 (21), but our subsequent studies suggested that Xenopus Skp2 (XSkp2) levels were very low in the early embryo, and XSkp2 immunodepletion did not stabilize Xic1 in the Xenopus egg extract (our unpublished observations). Therefore, we postulated that in the interphase egg extract, Xic1 was targeted for ubiquitination by an alternate ubiquitin ligase.In this study, we identify Cul4-DDB1-XCdt2 (CRL4^Cdt2) as the ubiquitin ligase for Xic1 in the egg. We also identify both the critical residues of Xic1 required for association to Cdt2 and the critical lysine residues of Xic1 ubiquitinated by CRL4^Cdt2. Importantly, we report a direct interaction between the C-terminal domain of Cdt2 and PCNA and show that the C-terminal domain of Cdt2 is required to promote the proteolysis of Xic1. Our studies suggest a model for Xic1 ubiquitination and proteolysis which requires the Xic1 PIP box for association with PCNA and Xic1 chromatin recruitment, the Xic1 sequences flanking the PIP box for association with Cdt2, specific lysine residues within the Cdt2 binding domain of Xic1 for efficient Xic1 ubiquitination, and a direct association between the Cdt2 C terminus and PCNA.     

Triggering ubiquitination of a CDK inhibitor at origins of DNA replication

To ensure proper timing of the G1-S transition in the cell cycle, the cyclin E-Cdk2 complex, which is responsible for the initiation of DNA replication, is restrained by the p21(Cip1)/p27(Kip1)/p57(Kip2) family of CDK (cyclin-dependent kinase) inhibitors in humans and by the related p27(Xic1) protein in Xenopus. Activation of cyclin E-Cdk2 is linked to the ubiquitination of human p27(Kip1) or Xenopus p27(Xic1) by SCF (for Skp1-Cullin-F-box protein) ubiquitin ligases. For human p27(Kip1), ubiquitination requires direct phosphorylation by cyclin E-Cdk2. We show here that Xic1 ubiquitination does not require phosphorylation by cyclin E-Cdk2, but it does require nuclear accumulation of the Xic1-cyclin E-Cdk2 complex and recruitment of this complex to chromatin by the origin-recognition complex together with Cdc6 replication preinitiation factors; it also requires an activation step necessitating cyclin E-Cdk2-kinase and SCF ubiquitin-ligase activity, and additional factors associated with mini-chromosome maintenance proteins, including the inactivation of geminin. Components of the SCF ubiquitin-ligase complex, including Skp1 and Cul1, are also recruited to chromatin through cyclin E-Cdk2 and the preinitiation complex. Thus, activation of the cyclin E-Cdk2 kinase and ubiquitin-dependent destruction of its inhibitor are spatially constrained to the site of a properly assembled preinitiation complex.     

Sequence and length recognition of the C-terminal turnover element of LpxC, a soluble substrate of the membrane-bound FtsH protease

The membrane-anchored FtsH protease is essential in Escherichia coli as it adjusts the cellular amount of LpxC, the key enzyme in lipopolysaccharide (LPS) biosynthesis. Both accumulation and depletion of LpxC are toxic to E. coli. By continuous proteolysis of LpxC, FtsH maintains a low concentration of LpxC and, hence, the proper equilibrium between LPS and phospholipids. The C terminus of LpxC is required for turnover. By adding this tail to glutathione-S-transferase (GST) we show that it is necessary but not sufficient for FtsH-mediated degradation. A detailed mutational analysis revealed six non-polar residues in the C terminus of LpxC that are critical for degradation. Alteration of the C-terminal AVLA motif towards the SsrA-like sequence ALAA directed LpxC to other cellular proteases reinforcing the importance of the C-terminal tail for targeting to FtsH. Short C-terminal truncations stabilized LpxC. Most mutations in the C terminus of LpxC left its enzymatic activity intact as was shown by growth assays, microscopy and 2-keto-3-deoxyoctonate (KDO) determination. The critical length of the turnover element was defined by internal deletions. A C-terminal tail of about 20 amino acids length is required for proteolysis of LpxC by FtsH.     

Identification of the Degradation Determinants of Insulin Receptor Substrate 1 for Signaling Cullin-RING E3 Ubiquitin Ligase 7-mediated Ubiquitination

Hyperactivation of mechanistic target of rapamycin complex 1 (mTORC1) and its effector kinase S6 kinase 1 (S6K1) is known to trigger multisite seryl phosphorylation of insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS1), leading to its ubiquitination and degradation. This negative feedback inhibition functions to restrain PI3K activity and plays critical roles in the pathogenesis of cancer and type II diabetes. Recent work has implicated a role for cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligase 7 (CRL7) in targeting IRS1 for mTORC1/S6K1-dependent degradation. In the present study we have employed both cell-based degradation and reconstituted ubiquitination approaches to define molecular features associated with IRS1 critical for CRL7-mediated ubiquitination and degradation. We have mapped IRS1 degradation signal sequence to its N-terminal 574 amino acid residues, of which the integrity of Ser-307/Ser-312 and Ser-527, each constituting a S6K1 phosphorylation consensus site, was indispensible for supporting CRL7-forced degradation. In vitro, S6K1 was able to support the ubiquitination of bacterially expressed IRS1 N-terminal fragment by CRL7 but at low levels. In contrast, CRL7 supported efficient ubiquitination of IRS1 N-terminal fragment in hyperphosphorylated form, which was isolated from infected insect cells, suggesting requirement of additional phosphorylation by kinases yet to be identified. Finally, removal of IRS1 amino acids 1–260 led to substantial reduction of ubiquitination efficiency, suggesting a role for this region in mediating productive interactions with CRL7. The requirement of multisite phosphorylation and the N terminus of IRS1 for its turnover may ensure that complete IRS1 degradation occurs only when mTORC1 and S6K1 reach exceedingly high levels.     

SET-related cell division autoantigen-1 (CDA1) arrests cell growth

We used an autoimmune serum from a patient with discoid lupus erythematosus to clone a cDNA of 2808 base pairs. Its open reading frame of 2079 base pairs encodes a predicted polypeptide of 693 amino acids named CDA1 (cell division autoantigen-1). CDA1 has a predicted molecular mass of 79,430 Daltons and a pI of 4.26. The size of the cDNA is consistent with its estimated mRNA size. CDA1 comprises an N-terminal proline-rich domain, a central basic domain, and a C-terminal bipartite acidic domain. It has four putative nuclear localization signals and potential sites for phosphorylation by cAMP and cGMP-dependent kinases, protein kinase C, thymidine kinase, casein kinase II, and cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs). CDA1 is phosphorylated in HeLa cells and by cyclin D1/CDK4, cyclin A/CDK2, and cyclin B/CDK1 in vitro. Its basic and acidic domains contain regions homologous to almost the entire human leukemia-associated SET protein. The same basic region is also homologous to nucleosome assembly proteins, testis TSPY protein, and an uncharacterized brain protein. CDA1 is present in the nuclear fraction of HeLa cells and localizes to the nucleus and nucleolus in HeLa cells transfected with CDA1 or its N terminus containing all four nuclear localization signals. Its acidic C terminus localizes mainly to the cytoplasm. CDA1 levels are low in serum-starved cells, increasing dramatically with serum stimulation. Expression of the CDA1 transgene, but not its N terminus, arrests HeLa cell growth, colony numbers, cell density, and bromodeoxyuridine uptake in a dose-dependent manner. The ability of CDA1 to arrest cell growth is abolished by mutation of the two CDK consensus phosphorylation sites. We propose that CDA1 is a negative regulator of cell growth and that its activity is regulated by its expression level and phosphorylation.     

Deletion analysis of the 51-kilodalton protein of the Bacillus sphaericus 2362 binary mosquitocidal toxin: construction of derivatives equivalent to the larva-processed toxin.

Bacillus sphaericus 2362 produces a binary toxin consisting of 51- and 42-kDa proteins, both of which are required for toxicity to mosquito larvae. Upon ingestion by larvae, these proteins are processed to 43 and 39 kDa, respectively. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we have obtained N- and C-terminal deletions of the 51-kDa protein and expressed them in B. subtilis by using the subtilisin promoter. Removal of 21 amino acids from the N terminus and 53 amino acids from the C terminus resulted in a protein with the same electrophoretic properties as the 43-kDa degradation product which accumulates in the guts of mosquito larvae. This protein was toxic only in the presence of the 42-kDa protein. A deletion of 32 amino acids at the N terminus combined with a 53-amino-acid deletion at the C terminus resulted in a protein which retained toxicity. Toxicity was lost upon a further deletion of amino acids at potential chymotrypsin sites (41 at the N terminus, 61 at the C terminus). Comparison of the processing of the 51- and the 42-kDa proteins indicated that in spite of their sequence similarity proteolysis occurred at different sites.     

The effects of changing the site of activating phosphorylation in CDK2 from threonine to serine

Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) that control cell cycle progression are regulated in many ways, including activating phosphorylation of a conserved threonine residue. This essential phosphorylation is carried out by the CDK-activating kinase (CAK). Here we examine the effects of replacing this threonine residue in human CDK2 by serine. We found that cyclin A bound equally well to wild-type CDK2 (CDK2(Thr-160)) or to the mutant CDK2 (CDK2(Ser-160)). In the absence of activating phosphorylation, CDK2(Ser-160)-cyclin A complexes were more active than wild-type CDK2(Thr-160)-cyclin A complexes. In contrast, following activating phosphorylation, CDK2(Ser-160)-cyclin A complexes were less active than phosphorylated CDK2(Thr-160)-cyclin A complexes, reflecting a much smaller effect of activating phosphorylation on CDK2(Ser-160). The kinetic parameters for phosphorylating histone H1 were similar for mutant and wild-type CDK2, ruling out a general defect in catalytic activity. Interestingly, the CDK2(Ser-160) mutant was selectively defective in phosphorylating a peptide derived from the C-terminal domain of RNA polymerase II. CDK2(Ser-160) was efficiently phosphorylated by CAKs, both human p40(MO15)(CDK7)-cyclin H and budding yeast Cak1p. In fact, the k(cat) values for phosphorylation of CDK2(Ser-160) were significantly higher than for phosphorylation of CDK2(Thr-160), indicating that CDK2(Ser-160) is actually phosphorylated more efficiently than wild-type CDK2. In contrast, dephosphorylation proceeded more slowly with CDK2(Ser-160) than with wild-type CDK2, either in HeLa cell extract or by purified PP2Cbeta. Combined with the more efficient phosphorylation of CDK2(Ser-160) by CAK, we suggest that one reason for the conservation of threonine as the site of activating phosphorylation may be to favor unphosphorylated CDKs following the degradation of cyclins.     

Identification of the protease and the turnover signal responsible for cell cycle-dependent degradation of the Caulobacter FliF motor protein

Flagellar ejection is tightly coupled to the cell cycle in Caulobacter crescentus. The MS ring protein FliF, which anchors the flagellar structure in the inner membrane, is degraded coincident with flagellar release. Previous work showed that removal of 26 amino acids from the C terminus of FliF prevents degradation of the protein and interferes with flagellar assembly. To understand FliF degradation in more detail, we identified the protease responsible for FliF degradation and performed a high-resolution mutational analysis of the C-terminal degradation signal of FliF. Cell cycle-dependent turnover of FliF requires an intact clpA gene, suggesting that the ClpAP protease is required for removal of the MS ring protein. Deletion analysis of the entire C-terminal cytoplasmic portion of FliF C confirmed that the degradation signal was contained in the last 26 amino acids that were identified previously. However, only deletions longer than 20 amino acids led to a stable FliF protein, while shorter deletions dispersed over the entire 26 amino acids critical for turnover had little effect on stability. This indicated that the nature of the degradation signal is not based on a distinct primary amino acid sequence. The addition of charged amino acids to the C-terminal end abolished cell cycle-dependent FliF degradation, implying that a hydrophobic tail feature is important for the degradation of FliF. Consistent with this, ClpA-dependent degradation was restored when a short stretch of hydrophobic amino acids was added to the C terminus of stable FliF mutant forms.     

Regulation of PTEN phosphorylation and stability by a tumor suppressor candidate protein

The tumor suppressor PTEN plays an essential role in regulating signaling pathways involved in cell growth and apoptosis and is inactivated in a wide variety of tumors. In this study, we have identified a protein, referred to as PICT-1 (protein interacting with carboxyl terminus 1), that binds to the C terminus of PTEN and regulates its phosphorylation and turnover. Down-regulation of PICT-1 in MCF7 cells by RNA interference enhances the degradation of PTEN with a concomitant decrease in its phosphorylation. PTEN C-terminal tumor-associated mutants, which are highly susceptible to protein degradation, have lost the ability to bind to PICT-1 along with their reduced phosphorylation, suggesting that their rapid turnover results from impaired binding to PICT-1. Our results identify PICT-1 as a PTEN-interacting protein that promotes the phosphorylation and stability of PTEN. These findings suggest a novel molecular mechanism underlying the turnover of PTEN, which also provides an explanation for the loss of PTEN function due to C-terminal mutations.     

Recognition, targeting, and hydrolysis of the lambda O replication protein by the ClpP/ClpX protease.

It has previously been established that sequences at the C termini of polypeptide substrates are critical for efficient hydrolysis by the ClpP/ClpX ATP-dependent protease. We report for the bacteriophage lambda O replication protein, however, that N-terminal sequences play the most critical role in facilitating proteolysis by ClpP/ClpX. The N-terminal portion of lambda O is degraded at a rate comparable with that of wild type O protein, whereas the C-terminal domain of O is hydrolyzed at least 10-fold more slowly. Consistent with these results, deletion of the first 18 amino acids of lambda O blocks degradation of the N-terminal domain, whereas proteolysis of the O C-terminal domain is only slightly diminished as a result of deletion of the C-terminal 15 amino acids. We demonstrate that ClpX retains its capacity to bind to the N-terminal domain following removal of the first 18 amino acids of O. However, ClpX cannot efficiently promote the ATP-dependent binding of this truncated O polypeptide to ClpP, the catalytic subunit of the ClpP/ClpX protease. Based on our results with lambda O protein, we suggest that two distinct structural elements may be required in substrate polypeptides to enable efficient hydrolysis by the ClpP/ClpX protease: (i) a ClpX-binding site, which may be located remotely from substrate termini, and (ii) a proper N- or C-terminal sequence, whose exposure on the substrate surface may be induced by the binding of ClpX.     

Substrate specificity of CDK2-cyclin A. What is optimal?

The optimal amino acid sequence of substrates for recognition by the cyclin-dependent kinases is well established as -Ser/Thr0-Pro+1-Lys+2-Lys+3-. The catalytic efficiency of CDK2-cyclin A is impaired 2000-, 10-, and 150-fold, when Pro+1, Lys+2, or Lys+3, respectively, is substituted with Ala in a short synthetic peptide substrate. Yet, in physiological substrates of both CDK2-cyclin A and CDK2-cyclin E, it is found that Lys+2, and, occasionally, both Lys+2 and Lys+3 together are replaced with suboptimal determinants. Such suboptimal phosphorylation site motifs are invariably associated with a distinct cyclin-binding (Cy) motif, which has been shown to compensate for otherwise poor catalysis. Here we have investigated the kinetic basis for substrate recognition by CDK2-cyclin A. In the optimal motif, Pro+1 serves to dramatically enhance both substrate binding affinity as well as the rate of chemical phosphotransfer, whereas Lys+2 and Lys+3 both serve to enhance mainly substrate binding. When linked to a suboptimal phosphorylation site sequence (Lys+2 --> Pro) the Cy motif increases catalytic efficiency (kcat/Km) by increasing affinity without affecting turnover (kcat). When fused to the optimal sequence, however, catalytic efficiency is only minimally enhanced, because the resulting high substrate affinity impedes the rate of the phosphoryl transfer reaction. Our results provide kinetic insight into the basis for selecting suboptimal specificity determinants for the phosphorylation of cellular substrates.