The ploidy of plants obtained from anther culture of cauliflowers (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis)

Anther culture of four cultivars of autumn cauliflower gave embryo yields of 100 embryos (per 100 anthers cultured) for one cultivar, eight embryos for a second cultivar, and almost zero for the two other cultivars. From 986 embryos which were grown on, 418 plants were regenerated. The ploidy of the regenerants was assessed by measuring guard cell lengths, pollen size, and by chromosome counts at meiosis. Only 1% of the regenerants were haploid, 41% diploid, 5% triploid and 53% tetraploid. One octoploid plant was also found. The results are discussed in relation to equivalent results for Brussels sprouts, and the use of anther culture in the breediing of cauliflowers.     

Genetic and non-genetic factors affecting anther culture of Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera)

Summary Eight inbred lines of Brussels sprouts and ten F₁ hybrids derived from them were tested for their response to anther culture. From 5–19 plants per genotype were tested, and each plant was tested on 3–6 separate occasions. Results from the inbred lines were broadly similar to those from the F₁ hybrids, despite the inbreds producing fewer buds and having a higher frequency of anther deformities. The maximum embryo yield from an inbred line was 215 embryos per 100 anthers, and from a hybrid was 275. From estimation of the variance components it was calculated that, for both inbreds and hybrids, about half the total variation was genetic whereas variation due to plants within genotypes and to occasions within plants were each about 13% of the total. The narrow sense heritability of responsiveness to anther culture (estimated by the proportion of variation between inbred lines which was genetic) was 0.48, and there was partial dominance for this character. In three cases the hybrid outyielded the better inbred, and this heterosis may well be due to dispersed dominant genes.     

ABA promotion of ethylene production in anther culture of Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera) and its relevance to embryogenesis

Abscisic acid (ABA) inhibited embryogenesis in anther culture of Brussels sprouts. This was accompanied by enhanced ethylene production during the first half of the anther culture period followed by a reduction in ethylene during the latter half, when compared to anthers not treated with ABA. The enhancement of ethylene production by ABA 6 h and 48 h after the start of the culture period was counteracted by the ethylene biosynthesis inhibitor aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG). Both AVG and the ethylene antagonist AgNO₃ removed much of the ABA inhibition of embryogenesis, suggesting that at least part of the ABA effect on embryo production is mediated through increased ethylene biosynthesis.
ABA promotion of ethylene production was reduced by high temperature: less ethylene evolved from ABA-treated anthers following a 24 h treatment at 35°C than from ABA-treated anthers incubated continuously at 25°C. A high temperature treatment such as this is invariably necessary for embryogenesis in Brussels sprouts anther culture.     

Effect of genotype,induction medium,carbohydrate source,and polyethylene glycol on embryogenesis in maize (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Zea mays</Emphasis> L.) anther culture

This study conducted two experiments involving in vitro anther culture of Zea mays L. The first experiment tested 46 maize genotypes, including inbred lines, single and three-way cross hybrids, and line A188 as control, in three different induction basal media (IMSS, N6 and YPm) for their androgenic responses. The results showed that the embryos were established 2–3 weeks after the anthers of the few responsive genotypes were cultured. Most responsive genotypes produced embryos in at least one of the three basal media; therefore, genotype is more important than the type of medium for androgenesis in maize. The mean number of anthers that developed to embryo ranged from 19 embryos per Petri dish in YPm medium for the cross (DH5 × DH7) genotype to 0 for some maize genotypes. In the second experiment, this research reports for the first time the effect of carbohydrates and polyethylene glycol (PEG) as a non-metabolized osmoticum on the embryogenesis anther culture of maize. The genotype DH5 × DH7 was used for this experiment, and the media were varied by altering sucrose, maltose, and PEG concentrations. Results showed that the maximum embryogenesis (32 embryos per Petri dish) was obtained by YPm basal medium supplemented with 60 gl^?1 sucrose + 0.0125 M PEG and 30 gl^?1 sucrose + 30 gl^?1 maltose + 0.0125 M PEG. The lowest rate of embryogenesis was observed in YPm basal medium with 60 gl^?1 maltose and 0.0125 or 0.025 M PEG. Sucrose or a high concentration of maltose was found to be necessary for embryogenesis in anther culture of maize. Therefore, the addition of low levels of PEG and/or different sugars in the experimental design appeared to improve the protocol currently available in the world, especially for anther embryo yield and haploid plant regeneration in maize.     

Anther culture in Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera)

In Brussels sprouts, yields of up to 357 embryos per 100 anthers cultured were obtained using a thermal shock treatment of 16 h at 35°C at the start of the culture period. Treatments of 48 h at 35°C and 14 days at 30°C gave no embryos. The F₁ hybrid cv. Gower consistently gave higher embryo yields than the F₁ hybrid cv. Nym, the differences being 3 to 10-fold. Differences in embryo yield of 3-fold or less were usually not statistically significant because of great variation within a treatment. This variation was less with donor plants raised in a growth room than with those raised in a glasshouse, where temperature and light intensity could not be so accurately controlled. From 842 embryos cultured, 270 plants were regenerated, mostly via hypocotyl explants, which developed from the anther-derived embryos. Most of the regenerants were haploid or diploid, with a few of higher ploidy.     

Ethylene production during anther culture of Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var gemmifera) and its relationship with factors that affect embryo production

The ethylene inhibitor silver nitrate (AgNO₃) is known to overcome the poor response of the Brussels sprouts cultivar Hal to anther culture. Ethylene production by Hal anthers after 6 h of culture at 35°C was on average 10- and 20-fold greater than from anthers of the highly responsive cultivars Gower and GA1 x RDF2. The initial 24 h period at 35°C necessary for embryogenesis in anther culture of Brussels sprouts generally reduced ethylene production by the anthers after 6, 24, 48 and 72 h of culture, although the effect was not seen in 2 out of 3 Hal experiments until 24 h, and after 6 h was only found with 1 of 3 GA1 x RDF2 experiments. Embryo production was inhibited by the inclusion of the ethylene precursor, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) or the ethylene-releasing compound, ethephon in the media. Silver nitrate (AgNO₃) and the ethylene biosynthesis inhibitor aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) promoted embryogenesis but did not substitute for the high temperature treatment. The relevance of ethylene production during anther culture to the effects of genotype and high temperature on anther culture embryogenesis is discussed.Abbreviations ACC 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid - AVG aminoethoxyvinylglycine     

Genotype,plant, bud size and media factors affecting anther culture of cauliflowers (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis)

Summary Eleven F₁ hybrid cultivars of cauliflower, representing a range of maturity types, were examined for their responsiveness to anther culture. Embryos were produced from each of the cultivars tested, and the mean embryo yield varied from 82.2 embryos per 100 anthers cultured for cv Dova to 0.6 embryos for cv Serrano. Variation between genotypes and between plants within a genotype was significant, both in terms of embryo yield and percentage responsive anthers. Autumn and winter maturing cauliflowers were generally more responsive than summer types. Embryo yields were enhanced by culturing anthers on solid rather than on liquid media. An increase in concentration of 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) from 0.1 to 0.3 mg/l also increased embryo yield. Embryo yield was doubled when anthers were cultured on solid media containing 0.3 mg/l 2,4-D compared to liquid media containing 0.1 mg/l 2,4-D. Although bud size alone did not have a significant effect on embryo production, genotype x bud size and plant x bud size (within genotype) interactions were significant. Estimation of the variance components demonstrated that, apart from the residual plate-to-plate variation, variation between plants was the largest source of variation, accounting for approximately 30% of total variance. Plant x bud size (within genotype) interaction accounted for 18% of total variance and genotypic differences for approximately 8%.     

Variations in response to high temperature treatments in anther culture of Brussels sprouts

The level, time of application and duration of the high temperature treatment necessary for embryo production from Brussels sprouts anther culture were examined. The effects of 29, 32, 35, and 38°C given for 24 h immediately following removal of the anthers from the bud, were tested on different cultivars, on different plants within the cultivars and on different occasions for each plant. Most embryos were produced following 32 and 35°C, very few following 30°C and none following 38°C. Although there was a tendency for some cultivars to respond better to one or other of the two more favourable temperatures, this varied considerably between individual plants. Plant to plant variation was also seen in the overall level of the response, although responsiveness tended to decline with successive samplings of the same plant. Experiments with cultivars Hal and Gower suggested that high temperature was required for at least 12 h after anther removal, but beyond that time the optimum period varied from plant to plant. If the excised anthers were held at 25°C for 16 h or more with Hal or 24 h or more with Gower before being exposed to the high temperature treatment, embrogenesis tended to be reduced. It is suggested that apparent non-responsiveness in anther culture may result to a large extent from the specific conditions that are used during the anther culture process.     

Anther culture of kale (Brassica oleracea L. convar.acephala (DC.) Alef.)

The pollen development and androgenic ability of 18 kale (Brassica oleracea convar.acephala) genotypes was observed during an anther culture study. Anther culture was successful in 6 of the genotypes and the highest yield obtained was 17 embryos per 100 anthers plated. Two stages of anther development were identified as being responsive to anther culture. The first and most responsive was that corresponding to the late uninucleated stage and the second to the late binucleated stage. These stages correspond with the onset of mitotic events in the microspores. Pollen viability was studied and low viability was noted which declined to zero after 9 days of anther culture. The initial viability level however was not clearly related to androgenic ability. The significance of the production of haploid and dihaploid kale genotypes in the study and breeding of resistance to clubroot is discussed.     

A study of factors affecting embryo yields from anther culture of cabbage

In cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata), a thermal shock treatment of 24 h at 35 °C at the start of the culture period resulted in higher embryos per 100 anthers (30.0) compared to a treatment of 48 h. Similarly , a chilling treatment of 24 h at 4 °C resulted in a higher embryo yield (6.0) per 100 anthers compared to a treatment of 48 h. However, the embryo yields were significantly higher (p> 0.01) in thermal shock than chilling treatments in all experiments. Treatments of 6 days at either 35 °C or 4 °C gave no embryos. The most responsive cultivar was the F₁ hybrid , Hercules, in all experiments. Although anther culture was successful in the other genotypes, the open pollinated ones, the highest number of embryo yields per 100 anthers was obtained in the hybrid. High temperature treatment before culture had a beneficial effect on the embryo yields. The responsiveness of anthers to addition of increasing concentration of silver nitrate (AgN0₃) (the ethylene inhibitor) to the culture medium, showed a progressive increase in the embryo yields in all the genotypes. Since embryos were also formed in the absence of silver nitrate, probably, due to a greater genotype × medium interaction, it is noted that the presence of silver nitrate in the medium may not be essential for cabbage anther culture as reported earlier. The findings of this study may be recommended for large production of cabbage embryos in culture.     

A simple wheat haploid and doubled haploid production system using anther culture

Summary Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) haploids and doubled haploids have been used in breeding programs and genetic studies. Wheat haploids and doubled haploids via anther culture are usually produced by a multiple step culture procedure. We improved a wheat haploid and doubled haploid production system via anther culture in which plants are produced from microspore-derived embryos using one medium and one culture environment. In the improved protocol, tillers of donor plants were pretreated at 4°C for 1–2 wk before anthers were plated on a modified 85D12 basal medium with phenylacetic acid (PAA) and zeatin and cultured at 30°C with a 12-h daylength (43 μEs⁻¹m⁻²) in an incubator. Microspore-derived embryos developed in 2–3 wk and the plants were produced 3–4 wk after anther plating. In the improved system, as much as 53% of the anthers of Pavon 76 were responsive with multiple embryos. For plant regeneration, as many as 22 green and 25 albino plants were produced from 100 anthers. Sixty-five green plants were grown to maturity and 32 (49%) plants were fertile and produced seeds (indicating spontaneous chromosome doubling) while 33 plants did not produce seed. Of five Nebraska breeding lines tested using the protocol, NE96675 was very responsive and the other lines less so, indicating that the protocol is genotype-dependent.     

Comparison of media for their aptitude in wheat anther culture

Different media were evaluated with anthers of five spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) genotypes for their ability to produce embryos and green plants in anther culture. Our first experiment showed that the addition of a combination of 19 amino acids significantly increased the number of embryos and green plants obtained. The mean number of green plants per 100 anthers for the two genotypes in this experiment, HY320 and B723, went from 28.2 without amino acids in the medium, to 46.7 with addition of amino acids. Our second experiment with the genotypes HY320, Wim and Laval-19 showed that liquid medium with Ficoll is more efficient for anther culture (9.9 green plants/100 anthers) than solid (0 green plants), gelationous media (2.5 green plants/100 anthers) or liquid medium with Membrane Rafts (0 green plants; Hoechst Celanese Corp.). Our third experiment revealed that the effect of replacement of sucrose by maltose varied with the genotype of the donor plant. Maltose partially inhibited the androgenesis of three responsive genotypes, HY320, Wim and Reliance (40.3 green plants/100 anthers instead of 43.9 with sucrose), while maltose significantly increased the androgenesis of the recalcitrant genotype Laval-19 (10.8 green plants/100 anthers instead of 5.4 with sucrose). An amino acid x maltose interaction was also observed. Amino acids without maltose increased androgenesis, but the addition of maltose to the amino acid-enriched medium eliminated this positive effect of the amino acids.     

Diversity of diploid androgenic Brussels sprout plants of R0 and R1 generations

Androgenic Brussels sprout plants were produced by the use of anther culture from the donor cultivar 'Philemon F1'. A total of 96 plants obtained from 20 androgenic R0 genotypes assigned as diploids were evaluated both in the generative and vegetative stage, in respect of their morphological characters: mean plant height; leaf size, colour and waxiness; leaf blade shape, blistering and attitude; number of sprouts; as well as their self-incompatibility and fertility. Androgenic R0 plants derived from each of the 20 embryos were highly diversified and differed from the donor in one or more morphological traits in the vegetative stage. Evaluated populations also varied in fertility and self-incompatibility. Six androgenic genotypes that set a sufficient amount of seeds of the R1 generation and 'Philemon F1' were evaluated in the field in respect of plant height, total and marketable yield per plot, shape of stem with sprouts, shape and density of sprouts, and spacing between sprouts. Only four diploid R0 and R1 populations may have some value for further breeding, as they are characterised by good vigour, high or medium ability for sprout generation, and sufficient fertility.     

Effect of silver nitrate and 2,4-D on anther culture of Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera)

The response to anther culture, of six genotypes of Brussels sprouts was tested on six media which included two levels of 2,4-D and the presence or absence of silver nitrate. The presence of silver was usually beneficial, and with some genotypes had a very large effect. Increasing 2,4-D could be beneficial in the absence of silver nitrate, but was sometimes detrimental in the presence of silver. Replacing agar with highly purified agarose was not particularly beneficial. Genotype, medium and genotype × medium interactions were all significant factors, with genotype being the most important.     

Microspore embryogenesis induced through in vitro anther culture of almond (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus dulcis</Emphasis> Mill.)

Anther culture is one of the most widely used methods to induce gametic embryogenesis. The aim of this investigation was to induce microspore embryogenesis in almond (Prunus dulcis Mill.), through this technique. Anthers were cultured at the vacuolated developmental stage, and seven cultivars, two culture media and two temperature treatments were assessed. Although evidence of the microspore induction was observed in all the genotypes and treatments tested (symmetrical nucleus division and multinucleated structures), calli were produced merely by anthers cultured in the medium P and the regeneration of embryos was detected only in anthers of the cultivars Filippo Ceo, Lauranne and Genco, placed on medium P and subjected to the Control treatment (direct culture at 25?±?1?°C, without the hot thermal shock at 35?±?1?°C for 7 days). Characterization by SSR marker analysis of the embryo genotypes revealed that the regenerants had a single allele for each locus whereas the parent cultivar was heterozygous, indicating their development from haploid microspores. This study reports the evidence of gametic embryogenesis and, particularly, of microspore embryogenesis through in vitro anther culture, in almond, and, for the first time to our knowledge, the production of homozygous embryos.     

Screening South African wheat germplasm for androgenic competence

Microspore and anther cultures provide an opportunity to create haploid and doubled haploid plants within a single season, thereby reducing the time and cost of cultivar development. Microspore and anther culture has been widely used and incorporated into wheat breeding programs in many countries, but little is known about the effectiveness of these techniques on South African germplasm. By using two responsive genotypes, isolated microspore culture was shown as more effective at revealing androgenic competence, and was used to evaluate the response of four South African inbred lines and two hybrids. Inbred lines A and B were highly responsive (336 and 207 embryo-like structures [ELS] per 100 anthers, respectively), line D was slightly responsive (5.1 ELS per 100 anthers) while line C was recalcitrant. The hybrid A × C was highly responsive (274 ELS per 100 anthers), and B × D did not respond at all. Green plant regeneration in a local genotype was very low (1% for line B) compared to that of foreign genotype (17% for Pavon 76). Similarly to other wheat genotypes grown around the world, the responsiveness of the South African varieties is also very variable. Thus, more efforts are needed so that isolated microspore culture can become a general tool in breeding programs.     

The frequency of embryogenic pollen grains is not increased by in vitro anther culture in Nicotiana tabacum L.

The numbers of embryogenic (S) grains present in in-situ mature anthers of Nicotiana tabacum L. were compared to the numbers of embryos and plantlets produced in cultured anthers excised at the optimal mitotic stage of development for anther culture. The Feulgen technique of staining embryos caused a considerable loss of grains from cultured anthers but this did not seriously affect the determination of the percentage of embryos present. In no instance did the numbers of embryos produced exceed the maximum number of S grains found, and the distributions of S grain and embryo frequencies in anthers were similar. In rare instances S grains which had undergone the first embryogenic division were observed in situ. The results indicate that all grains capable of embryogenesis are determined during early flower formation and that their number is not increased by in vitro culture.     

Improvement of green plant regeneration by manipulation of anther culture induction medium of hexaploid wheat

Anthers of three hexaploid wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) genotypes with high frequencies of albino regenerants in anther culture were compared to DH after inoculation on medium supplemented with ficoll, colchicine or maltose separately, pair-wise or combined, in an attempt to increase green plant regeneration. Maltose treatment produced more green regenerated plants than sucrose for all of the genotypes. The three chemicals combined in anther medium either reduced green plant regeneration or did not yield significantly different numbers of green regenerated plants compared to the maltose treatment. With DH fewer embryo-like structures (ELS) were obtained per 100 cultured anthers on all medium containing colchicine but greater frequencies of green plants per 100 ELS were obtained. It appeared that the increase in green regenerated plants per 100 ELS was due to a better quality of embryos that were capable of regenerating into green rather than albino plantlets. Smaller increases in green plants per 100 ELS were observed in ICR 4 and V-15 on colchicine containing medium compared to DH. Genotypic differences in anther culture response were observed for ELS per 100 cultured anthers (increased for V-37, decreased for DH and approx. the same for ICR 4 and V-15 in medium with all three chemicals compared to the sucrose control).     

Anther Factor(s) in Barley Anther Culture

The effects of anther tissues were studied systematically on microspores forming multicellular units and furthermore on pollen callus formation in the anther culture of Hordeum vulgare (cv. Sabarlis). Anther productivity was found to be greatly enhanced by use of medium previously conditioned by anthers. In 15 experiments observed, anthers produced 26 times on average more calli in the conditioned medium than in control, in a few cases, even more than 80 times more calli formed. According to this, the authors supposed that cultured anthers released some components, anther factor (s) (AF), which is important to androgenesis in the culture. To achieve high yields of callus, culture was restricted to anthers which had been subpected to cold pretreatment. The temperature stress could not be replaced by the AF. However, for conditioning medium, anthers at binuclear stage were found to be more effective than the test anthers either with or without the pretreatment. Anthers from other 8 barley varieties were also effective for conditioning, as the difference of anther productivity still existed in the culture with conditioned medium between various genotypes tested. Anther response and callus yield were increased in both the culture of anthers at mid and late-uninuclear stage by use of conditioned medium. AF interacted synergistically with m-inositol. Cytological observation showed that AF increased apparently the formation of MPGs, while m-inositol mainly stimulated callus formation from MPGs. To some extent, the effect of exogenous hormone(s) could be replaced by AF. The anther response and pollen callus yield could be much enhanced by increasing anther inoculation density, which also raised the AF level in the culture. Thus, by use of the temperature stress prior to anther culture and culture of test anthers in conditioned medium with m-inositol, or at higher inoculation density, a very high production of pollen callus could be obtained in barley anther culture. For meeting the more specialized requirements of less responsive species or genopypes, the principles given here may be provide some basic information.     

Anther culture with different genotypes of opium poppy (Papaver somniferum L.): effect of cold treatment

This study concerns anther culture and the production of microspore-derived calluses and plants of the opium poppy (Papaver somniferum L.). It was confirmed that growth regulators were necessary for microspore callus production. Cold treatment (7 d at 7°C) of the buds prior to culture lead to a twofold increase in the frequency of responsive anthers and in the number of calluses per 100 anthers plated. Callus was produced from cultured anthers of several genotypes, covering a wide genetic background. Step by step removal of growth regulators from the culture medium promoted organogenesis and plant regeneration. Most regenerated plants were diploid. The overall process of microspore embryogenesis closely resembled that described in previous reports on somatic callus production and plant regeneration from poppy hypocotyls in vitro.