Structure of the complex of the colicin E2 R-domain and its BtuB receptor. The outer membrane colicin translocon

The crystal structure of the complex of the BtuB receptor and the 135-residue coiled-coil receptor-binding R-domain of colicin E3 (E3R135) suggested a novel mechanism for import of colicin proteins across the outer membrane. It was proposed that one function of the R-domain, which extends along the outer membrane surface, is to recruit an additional outer membrane protein(s) to form a translocon for passage colicin activity domain. A 3.5-A crystal structure of the complex of E2R135 and BtuB (E2R135-BtuB) was obtained, which revealed E2R135 bound to BtuB in an oblique orientation identical to that previously found for E3R135. The only significant difference between the two structures was that the bound coiled-coil R-domain of colicin E2, compared with that of colicin E3, was extended by two and five residues at the N and C termini, respectively. There was no detectable displacement of the BtuB plug domain in either structure, implying that colicin is not imported through the outer membrane by BtuB alone. It was concluded that the oblique orientation of the R-domain of the nuclease E colicins has a function in the recruitment of another member(s) of an outer membrane translocon. Screening of porin knock-out mutants showed that either OmpF or OmpC can function in such a translocon. Arg(452) at the R/C-domain interface in colicin E2 was found have an essential role at a putative site of protease cleavage, which would liberate the C-terminal activity domain for passage through the outer membrane translocon.     

The structure of BtuB with bound colicin E3 R-domain implies a translocon

Cellular import of colicin E3 is initiated by the Escherichia coli outer membrane cobalamin transporter, BtuB. The 135-residue 100-A coiled-coil receptor-binding domain (R135) of colicin E3 forms a 1:1 complex with BtuB whose structure at a resolution of 2.75 A is reported. Binding of R135 to the BtuB extracellular surface (DeltaG(o) = -12 kcal mol(-1)) is mediated by 27 residues of R135 near the coiled-coil apex. Formation of the R135-BtuB complex results in unfolding of R135 N- and C-terminal ends, inferred to be important for unfolding of the colicin T-domain. Small conformational changes occur in the BtuB cork and barrel domains but are insufficient to form a translocation channel. The absence of a channel and the peripheral binding of R135 imply that BtuB serves to bind the colicin, and that the coiled-coil delivers the colicin to a neighboring outer membrane protein for translocation, thus forming a colicin translocon. The translocator was concluded to be OmpF from the occlusion of OmpF channels by colicin E3.     

The colicin E3 outer membrane translocon: immunity protein release allows interaction of the cytotoxic domain with OmpF porin

The crystal structure previously obtained for the complex of BtuB and the receptor binding domain of colicin E3 forms a basis for further analysis of the mechanism of colicin import through the bacterial outer membrane. Together with genetic analysis and studies on colicin occlusion of OmpF channels, this implied a colicin translocon consisting of BtuB and OmpF that would transfer the C-terminal cytotoxic domain (C96) of colicin E3 through the Escherichia coli outer membrane. This model does not, however, explain how the colicin attains the unfolded conformation necessary for transfer. Such a conformation change would require removal of the immunity (Imm) protein, which is bound tightly in a complex with the folded colicin E3. In the present study, it was possible to obtain reversible removal of Imm in vitro in a single column chromatography step without colicin denaturation. This resulted in a mostly unordered secondary structure of the cytotoxic domain and a large decrease in stability, which was also found in the receptor binding domain. These structure changes were documented by near- and far-UV circular dichroism and intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. Reconstitution of Imm in a complex with C96 or colicin E3 restored the native structure. C96 depleted of Imm, in contrast to the native complex with Imm, efficiently occluded OmpF channels, implying that the presence of tightly bound Imm prevents its unfolding and utilization of the OmpF porin for subsequent import of the cytotoxic domain.     

Colicin occlusion of OmpF and TolC channels: outer membrane translocons for colicin import

The interaction of colicins with target cells is a paradigm for protein import. To enter cells, bactericidal colicins parasitize Escherichia coli outer membrane receptors whose physiological purpose is the import of essential metabolites. Colicins E1 and E3 initially bind to the BtuB receptor, whose beta-barrel pore is occluded by an N-terminal globular "plug". The x-ray structure of a complex of BtuB with the coiled-coil BtuB-binding domain of colicin E3 did not reveal displacement of the BtuB plug that would allow passage of the colicin (Kurisu, G., S. D. Zakharov, M. V. Zhalnina, S. Bano, V. Y. Eroukova, T. I. Rokitskaya, Y. N. Antonenko, M. C. Wiener, and W. A. Cramer. 2003. Nat. Struct. Biol. 10:948-954). This correlates with the inability of BtuB to form ion channels in planar bilayers, shown in this work, suggesting that an additional outer membrane protein(s) is required for colicin import across the outer membrane. The identity and interaction properties of this OMP were analyzed in planar bilayer experiments.OmpF and TolC channels in planar bilayers were occluded by colicins E3 and E1, respectively, from the trans-side of the membrane. Occlusion was dependent upon a cis-negative transmembrane potential. A positive potential reversibly opened OmpF and TolC channels. Colicin N, which uses only OmpF for entry, occludes OmpF in planar bilayers with the same orientation constraints as colicins E1 and E3. The OmpF recognition sites of colicins E3 and N, and the TolC recognition site of colicin E1, were found to reside in the N-terminal translocation domains. These data are considered in the context of a two-receptor translocon model for colicin entry into cells.     

Investigating early events in receptor binding and translocation of colicin E9 using synchronized cell killing and proteolytic cleavage

Enzymatic colicins such as colicin E9 (ColE9) bind to BtuB on the cell surface of Escherichia coli and rapidly recruit a second coreceptor, either OmpF or OmpC, through which the N-terminal natively disordered region (NDR) of their translocation domain gains entry into the cell periplasm and interacts with TolB. Previously, we constructed an inactive disulfide-locked mutant ColE9 (ColE9(s-s)) that binds to BtuB and can be reduced with dithiothreitol (DTT) to synchronize cell killing. By introducing unique enterokinase (EK) cleavage sites in ColE9(s-s), we showed that the first 61 residues of the NDR were inaccessible to cleavage when bound to BtuB, whereas an EK cleavage site inserted at residue 82 of the NDR remained accessible. This suggests that most of the NDR is occluded by OmpF shortly after binding to BtuB, whereas the extreme distal region of the NDR is surface exposed before unfolding of the receptor-binding domain occurs. EK cleavage of unique cleavage sites located in the ordered region of the translocation domain or in the distal region of the receptor-binding domain confirmed that these regions of ColE9 remained accessible at the E. coli cell surface. Lack of EK cleavage of the DNase domain of the cell-bound, oxidized ColE9/Im9 complex, and the rapid detection of Alexa Fluor 594-labeled Im9 (Im9(AF)) in the cell supernatant following treatment of cells with DTT, suggested that immunity release occurred immediately after unfolding of the colicin and was not driven by binding to BtuB.     

Crystal structures of the OmpF porin: function in a colicin translocon

The OmpF porin in the Escherichia coli outer membrane (OM) is required for the cytotoxic action of group A colicins, which are proposed to insert their translocation and active domains through OmpF pores. A crystal structure was sought of OmpF with an inserted colicin segment. A 1.6 A OmpF structure, obtained from crystals formed in 1 M Mg2+, has one Mg2+ bound in the selectivity filter between Asp113 and Glu117 of loop 3. Co-crystallization of OmpF with the unfolded 83 residue glycine-rich N-terminal segment of colicin E3 (T83) that occludes OmpF ion channels yielded a 3.0 A structure with inserted T83, which was obtained without Mg2+ as was T83 binding to OmpF. The incremental electron density could be modelled as an extended poly-glycine peptide of at least seven residues. It overlapped the Mg2+ binding site obtained without T83, explaining the absence of peptide binding in the presence of Mg2+. Involvement of OmpF in colicin passage through the OM was further documented by immuno-extraction of an OM complex, the colicin translocon, consisting of colicin E3, BtuB and OmpF.     

Release of immunity protein requires functional endonuclease colicin import machinery

Bacteria producing endonuclease colicins are protected against the cytotoxic activity by a small immunity protein that binds with high affinity and specificity to inactivate the endonuclease. This complex is released into the extracellular medium, and the immunity protein is jettisoned upon binding of the complex to susceptible cells. However, it is not known how and at what stage during infection the immunity protein release occurs. Here, we constructed a hybrid immunity protein composed of the enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) fused to the colicin E2 immunity protein (Im2) to enhance its detection. The EGFP-Im2 protein binds the free colicin E2 with a 1:1 stoichiometry and specifically inhibits its DNase activity. The addition of this hybrid complex to susceptible cells reveals that the release of the hybrid immunity protein is a time-dependent process. This process is achieved 20 min after the addition of the complex to the cells. We showed that complex dissociation requires a functional translocon formed by the BtuB protein and one porin (either OmpF or OmpC) and a functional import machinery formed by the Tol proteins. Cell fractionation and protease susceptibility experiments indicate that the immunity protein does not cross the cell envelope during colicin import. These observations suggest that dissociation of the immunity protein occurs at the outer membrane surface and requires full translocation of the colicin E2 N-terminal domain.     

Structural stability and domain organization of colicin E1

Thermodynamic properties, stability, and structure of the toxin-like molecule colicin E1 were analyzed by differential scanning calorimetry and circular dichroism to determine the number of structurally independent domains, and the interdomain interactions necessary for colicin import into the Escherichia coli cell. Analysis of denaturation profiles of the 522 residue colicin E1, together with fragments of 342 and 178 residues that contain subsets of the domains, showed three stable cooperative blocks that differ in thermal stability and correspond to three major functional domains of the colicin: (i) the COOH-terminal channel-forming (C) domain with the highest thermal stability; (ii) the BtuB receptor binding (R) domain; and (iii) the N-terminal translocation (T) domain that has the smallest stabilization enthalpy and thermal stability. Interdomain interactions were described in which T-R interactions stabilize R, and T-C and R-C interactions stabilize R and T, but destabilize C. The R and T domains behaved in a similar way as a function of pH and ionic strength. Interacting extended helices of the R domain, possibly a coiled-coil, were implied by: (i) the very high (>90%) alpha-helical content of the R domain, (ii) cooperative decreases in alpha-helical content near the T(tr) of thermal denaturation of the R domain; (iii) a large denaturation enthalpy, implying extensive H-bond and van der Waals interactions. The R domain was inferred, from the extended network of interacting helices, large DeltaH, and steep temperature dependence of its stabilization energy to have a dominant role in determining the conformation of other domains. It is proposed that cellular import starts with the R domain binding to the BtuB receptor, followed by unfolding of the R domain coiled-coil and thereby of the T domain, which then interacts with the TolC receptor-translocator.     

Colicin crystal structures: pathways and mechanisms for colicin insertion into membranes

The X-ray structures of the channel-forming colicins Ia and N, and endoribonucleolytic colicin E3, as well as of the channel domains of colicins A and E1, and spectroscopic and calorimetric data for intact colicin E1, are discussed in the context of the mechanisms and pathways by which colicins are imported into cells. The extensive helical coiled-coil in the R domain and internal hydrophobic hairpin in the C domain are important features relevant to colicin import and channel formation. The concept of outer membrane translocation mediated by two receptors, one mainly used for initial binding and second for translocation, such as BtuB and TolC, respectively, is discussed. Helix elongation and conformational flexibility are prerequisites for import of soluble toxin-like proteins into membranes. Helix elongation contradicts suggestions that the colicin import involves a molten globule intermediate. The nature of the open-channel structure is discussed.     

Colicin crystal structures: pathways and mechanisms for colicin insertion into membranes

The X-ray structures of the channel-forming colicins Ia and N, and endoribonucleolytic colicin E3, as well as of the channel domains of colicins A and E1, and spectroscopic and calorimetric data for intact colicin E1, are discussed in the context of the mechanisms and pathways by which colicins are imported into cells. The extensive helical coiled-coil in the R domain and internal hydrophobic hairpin in the C domain are important features relevant to colicin import and channel formation. The concept of outer membrane translocation mediated by two receptors, one mainly used for initial binding and second for translocation, such as BtuB and TolC, respectively, is discussed. Helix elongation and conformational flexibility are prerequisites for import of soluble toxin-like proteins into membranes. Helix elongation contradicts suggestions that the colicin import involves a molten globule intermediate. The nature of the open-channel structure is discussed.     

A 76-residue polypeptide of colicin E9 confers receptor specificity and inhibits the growth of vitamin B12-dependent Escherichia coli 113/3 cells

The mechanism by which E colicins recognize and then bind to BtuB receptors in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli cells is a poorly understood first step in the process that results in cell killing. Using N- and C-terminal deletions of the N-terminal 448 residues of colicin E9, we demonstrated that the smallest polypeptide encoded by one of these constructs that retained receptor-binding activity consisted of residues 343-418. The results of the in vivo receptor-binding assay were supported by an alternative competition assay that we developed using a fusion protein consisting of residues 1-497 of colicin E9 fused to the green fluorescent protein as a fluorescent probe of binding to BtuB in E. coli cells. Using this improved assay, we demonstrated competitive inhibition of the binding of the fluorescent fusion protein by the minimal receptor-binding domain of colicin E9 and by vitamin B12. Mutations located in the minimum R domain that abolished or reduced the biological activity of colicin E9 similarly affected the competitive binding of the mutant colicin protein to BtuB. The sequence of the 76-residue R domain in colicin E9 is identical to that found in colicin E3, an RNase type E colicin. Comparative sequence analysis of colicin E3 and cloacin DF13, which is also an RNase-type colicin but uses the IutA receptor to bind to E. coli cells, revealed significant sequence homology throughout the two proteins, with the exception of a region of 92 residues that included the minimum R domain. We constructed two chimeras between cloacin DF13 and colicin E9 in which (i) the DNase domain of colicin E9 was fused onto the T+R domains of cloacin DF13; and (ii) the R domain and DNase domain of colicin E9 were fused onto the T domain of cloacin DF13. The killing activities of these two chimeric colicins against indicator strains expressing BtuB or IutA receptors support the conclusion that the 76 residues of colicin E9 confer receptor specificity. The minimum receptor-binding domain polypeptide inhibited the growth of the vitamin B12-dependent E. coli 113/3 mutant cells, demonstrating that vitamin B12 and colicin E9 binding is mutually exclusive.     

Mobility of BtuB and OmpF in the Escherichia coli outer membrane: implications for dynamic formation of a translocon complex

Diffusion of two Escherichia coli outer membrane proteins—the cobalamin (vitamin B12) receptor (BtuB) and the OmpF porin, which are implicated in the cellular import pathways of colicins and phages—was measured in vivo. The lateral mobility of these proteins is relevant to the mechanism of formation of the translocon for cellular import of colicins such as the rRNase colicin E3. The diffusion coefficient (D) of BtuB, the primary colicin receptor, complexed to fluorescent antibody or colicin, is 0.05 ± 0.01 μm²/s and 0.10 ± 0.02 μm²/s, respectively, over a timescale of 25-150 ms. Mutagenesis of the BtuB TonB box, which eliminates or significantly weakens the interaction between BtuB and the TonB energy-transducing protein that is anchored in the cytoplasmic membrane, resulted in a fivefold larger value of D, 0.27 ± 0.06 μm²/s for antibody-labeled BtuB, indicating a cytoskeletal-like interaction of TonB with BtuB. OmpF has a diffusion coefficient of 0.006 ± 0.002 μm²/s, ∼10-fold smaller than that of BtuB, and is restricted within a domain of diameter 100 nm, showing it to be relatively immobile compared to BtuB. Thus, formation of the outer membrane translocon for cellular import of the nuclease colicins is a demonstrably dynamic process, because it depends on lateral diffusion of BtuB and collisional interaction with relatively immobile OmpF.     

Comparison of the uptake systems for the entry of various BtuB group colicins into Escherichia coli

Colicins A, E1, E2 and E3 belong to the BtuB group of colicins. The NH2-terminal region of colicin A is required for translocation, and defects in this region cannot be overcome by osmotic shock of sensitive cells. In addition to BtuB, colicin A requires OmpF for efficient uptake by sensitive cells. The roles of BtuB and OmpF in translocation and binding to the receptor of the colicins A, E1, E2 and E3 were compared. The results suggest that for colicin A OmpF is used both as a receptor and for translocation across the outer membrane. In contrast, for colicin E1, OmpF is used neither as a receptor nor for translocation. For colicins E2 and E3, the situation is intermediate: only BtuB is used as a receptor but both BtuB and OmpF are involved in the translocation step.     

OmpF enhances the ability of BtuB to protect susceptible Escherichia coli cells from colicin E9 cytotoxicity

The outer membrane (OM) vitamin B(12) receptor, BtuB, is the primary receptor for E group colicin adsorption to Escherichia coli. Cell death by this family of toxins requires the OM porin OmpF but its role remains elusive. We show that OmpF enhances the ability of purified BtuB to protect bacteria against the endonuclease colicin E9, demonstrating either that the two OM proteins form the functional receptor or that OmpF is recruited for subsequent translocation of the bacteriocin. While stable binary colicin E9-BtuB complexes could be readily shown in vitro, OmpF-containing complexes could not be detected, implying that OmpF association with the BtuB-colicin complex, while necessary, must be weak and/or transient in nature.     

The colicin Ia receptor,Cir, is also the translocator for colicin Ia

Colicin Ia, a channel‐forming bactericidal protein, uses the outer membrane protein, Cir, as its primary receptor. To kill Escherichia coli, it must cross this membrane. The crystal structure of Ia receptor‐binding domain bound to Cir, a 22‐stranded plugged β‐barrel protein, suggests that the plug does not move. Therefore, another pathway is needed for the colicin to cross the outer membrane, but no ‘second receptor’ has ever been identified for TonB‐dependent colicins, such as Ia. We show that if the receptor‐binding domain of colicin Ia is replaced by that of colicin E3, this chimera effectively kills cells, provided they have the E3 receptor (BtuB), Cir, and TonB. This is consistent with wild‐type Ia using one Cir as its primary receptor (BtuB in the chimera) and a second Cir as the translocation pathway for its N‐terminal translocation (T) domain and its channel‐forming C‐terminal domain. Deletion of colicin Ia's receptor‐binding domain results in a protein that kills E. coli, albeit less effectively, provided they have Cir and TonB. We show that purified T domain competes with Ia and protects E. coli from being killed by it. Thus, in addition to binding to colicin Ia's receptor‐binding domain, Cir also binds weakly to its translocation domain.     

Porin threading drives receptor disengagement and establishes active colicin transport through Escherichia coli OmpF

Bacteria deploy weapons to kill their neighbours during competition for resources and to aid survival within microbiomes. Colicins were the first such antibacterial system identified, yet how these bacteriocins cross the outer membrane (OM) of Escherichia coli is unknown. Here, by solving the structures of translocation intermediates via cryo‐EM and by imaging toxin import, we uncover the mechanism by which the Tol‐dependent nuclease colicin E9 (ColE9) crosses the bacterial OM. We show that threading of ColE9’s disordered N‐terminal domain through two pores of the trimeric porin OmpF causes the colicin to disengage from its primary receptor, BtuB, and reorganises the translocon either side of the membrane. Subsequent import of ColE9 through the lumen of a single OmpF subunit is driven by the proton‐motive force, which is delivered by the TolQ‐TolR‐TolA‐TolB assembly. Our study answers longstanding questions, such as why OmpF is a better translocator than OmpC, and reconciles the mechanisms by which both Tol‐ and Ton‐dependent bacteriocins cross the bacterial outer membrane.     

Flexibility in the receptor-binding domain of the enzymatic colicin E9 is required for toxicity against Escherichia coli cells

The events that occur after the binding of the enzymatic E colicins to Escherichia coli BtuB receptors that lead to translocation of the cytotoxic domain into the periplasmic space and, ultimately, cell killing are poorly understood. It has been suggested that unfolding of the coiled-coil BtuB receptor binding domain of the E colicins may be an essential step that leads to the loss of immunity protein from the colicin and immunity protein complex and then triggers the events of translocation. We introduced pairs of cysteine mutations into the receptor binding domain of colicin E9 (ColE9) that resulted in the formation of a disulfide bond located near the middle or the top of the R domain. After dithiothreitol reduction, the ColE9 protein with the mutations L359C and F412C (ColE9 L359C-F412C) and the ColE9 protein with the mutations Y324C and L447C (ColE9 Y324C-L447C) were slightly less active than equivalent concentrations of ColE9. On oxidation with diamide, no significant biological activity was seen with the ColE9 L359C-F412C and the ColE9 Y324C-L447C mutant proteins; however diamide had no effect on the activity of ColE9. The presence of a disulfide bond was confirmed in both of the oxidized, mutant proteins by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry. The loss of biological activity of the disulfide-containing mutant proteins was not due to an indirect effect on the properties of the translocation or DNase domains of the mutant colicins. The data are consistent with a requirement for the flexibility of the coiled-coil R domain after binding to BtuB.     

Individual domains of colicins confer specificity in colicin uptake, in pore-properties and in immunity requirement.

Six different hybrid colicins were constructed by recombining various domains of the two pore-forming colicins A and E1. These hybrid colicins were purified and their properties were studied. All of them were active against sensitive cells, although to varying degrees. From the results, one can conclude that: (1) the binding site of OmpF is located in the N-terminal domain of colicin A; (2) the OmpF, TolB and TolR dependence for translocation is also located in this domain; (3) the TolC dependence for colicin E1 is located in the N-terminal domain of colicin E1; (4) the 183 N-terminal amino acid residues of colicin E1 are sufficient to promote E1AA uptake and thus probably colicin E1 uptake; (5) there is an interaction between the central domain and C-terminal domain of colicin A; (6) the individual functioning of different domains in various hybrids suggests that domain interactions can be reconstituted in hybrids that are fully active, whereas in others that are much less active, non-proper domain interactions may interfere with translocation; (7) there is a specific recognition of the C-terminal domains of colicin A and colicin E1 by their respective immunity proteins.     

Initial steps of colicin E1 import across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

Data suggest a two-receptor model for colicin E1 (ColE1) translocation across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. ColE1 initially binds to the vitamin B(12) receptor BtuB and then translocates through the TolC channel-tunnel, presumably in a mostly unfolded state. Here, we studied the early events in the import of ColE1. Using in vivo approaches, we show that ColE1 is cleaved when added to whole cells. This cleavage requires the presence of the receptor BtuB and the protease OmpT, but not that of TolC. Strains expressing OmpT cleaved ColE1 at K84 and K95 in the N-terminal translocation domain, leading to the removal of the TolQA box, which is essential for ColE1's cytotoxicity. Supported by additional in vivo data, this suggests that a function of OmpT is to degrade colicin at the cell surface and thus protect sensitive E. coli cells from infection by E colicins. A genetic strategy for isolating tolC mutations that confer resistance to ColE1, without affecting other TolC functions, is also described. We provide further in vivo evidence of the multistep interaction between TolC and ColE1 by using cross-linking followed by copurification via histidine-tagged TolC. First, secondary binding of ColE1 to TolC is dependent on primary binding to BtuB. Second, alterations to a residue in the TolC channel interfere with the translocation of ColE1 across the TolC pore rather than with the binding of ColE1 to TolC. In contrast, a substitution at a residue exposed on the cell surface abolishes both binding and translocation of ColE1.     

Immunity protein protects colicin E2 from OmpT protease

The endonuclease colicin E2 (ColE2), a bacteriocidal protein, and the associated cognate immunity protein (Im2) are released from producing Escherichia coli cells. ColE2 interaction with the target cell outer membrane BtuB protein and Tol import machinery allows the dissociation of Im2 from its colicin at the outer membrane surface. Here, we use in vivo approaches to show that a small amount of ColE2-Im2 protein complex bound to sensitive cells is susceptible to proteolytic cleavage by the outer membrane protease, OmpT. The presence of BtuB is required for ColE-Im2 cleavage by OmpT. The amount of colicin cleaved by OmpT is greatly enhanced when ColE2 is dissociated from Im2. We further demonstrate that OmpT cleaves the C-terminal DNase domain of the toxin. As expected, strains that over-produce OmpT are less susceptible to infection by ColE2 than by ColE2-Im2. Our findings reveal an additional function for the immunity protein beside protection of producing cells against their own colicin in the cytoplasm. Im2 protects ColE2 against OmpT-mediated proteolytic attack.