Interaction of Era with the 30S ribosomal subunit implications for 30S subunit assembly

Era (E. coliRas-like protein) is a highly conserved and essential GTPase in bacteria. It binds to the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) of the small (30S) ribosomal subunit, and its depletion leads to accumulation of an unprocessed precursor of the 16S rRNA. We have obtained a three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopic map of the Thermus thermophilus 30S-Era complex. Era binds in the cleft between the head and platform of the 30S subunit and locks the subunit in a conformation that is not favorable for association with the large (50S) ribosomal subunit. The RNA binding KH motif present within the C-terminal domain of Era interacts with the conserved nucleotides in the 3' region of the 16S rRNA. Furthermore, Era makes contact with several assembly elements of the 30S subunit. These observations suggest a direct involvement of Era in the assembly and maturation of the 30S subunit.     

Effects of the ribosomal subunit association on the chemical modification of the 16S and 23S RNAs from Escherichia coli

70S ribosomes and 30S and 50S ribosomal subunits from Escherichia coli were modified under non-denaturing conditions with the chemical reagent dimethylsulfate. The ribosomal 23S and 16S RNAs were isolated after the reaction and the last 200 nucleotides from the 3' ends were analyzed for differences in the chemical modification. A number of accessibility changes could be detected for 23S and 16S RNA when 70S ribosomes as opposed to the isolated subunits were modified. In addition to a number of sites which were protected from modification several guanosines showed enhanced reactivities, indicating conformational changes in the ribosomal RNA structures when 30S and 50S subunits associate to a 70S particle. Most of the accessibility changes can be localized in double-helical regions within the secondary structures of the two RNAs. The results confirm the importance of the ribosomal RNAs for ribosomal functions and help to define the RNA domains which constitute the subunit interface of E. coli ribosomes.     

A ribonucleoprotein fragment of the 30 S ribosome of E. coli: evidence for long range RNA-RNA interactions.

A stable homogeneous ribonucleoprotein fragment of the 30 S ribosomal subunit of E. coli has been prepared by mild nuclease digestion and heating in a constant ionic environment. The fragment contains about half of the 16 S ribosomal RNa and six proteins: S4, S7, S9, S13, S16 and S19. The RNA moiety contains the reported binding sites of all six proteins. After deproteinization, 80% of the RNA migrated as two major electrophoretic bands, which were isolated and sequenced. Each band contained sequences from the 5' and 3' thirds of the 16 S RNA but none from the central third. That these two noncontiguous RNA domains migrated together electrophoretically in Mg++-containing gels after deproteinization constitutes direct evidence that the 16 S RNA is folded in the intact ribosome so as to bring the two domains close together and that there are RNA-RNA interactions between them in the presence of Mg++.     

Study of the binding of the S7 protein with 16S rRNA fragment 926-986/1219-1393 as a key step in the assembly of the small subunit of prokaryotic ribosomes

Both structural and thermodynamic studies are necessary to understand the ribosome assembly. An initial step was made in studying the interaction between a 16S rRNA fragment and S7, a key protein in assembling the prokaryotic ribosome small subunit. The apparent dissociation constant was obtained for complexes of recombinant Escherichia coli and Thermus thermophilus S7 with a fragment of the 3' domain of the E. coli 16S rRNA. Both proteins showed a high rRNA-binding activity, which was not observed earlier. Since RNA and proteins are conformationally labile, their folding must be considered to correctly describe the RNA-protein interactions.     

The topography of ribosomal proteins on the surface of the 30S subunit of Escherichia coli

Eight ribosomal proteins, S6, S10, S11, S15, S16, S18, S19 and S21 have been localized on the surface of the 30S subunit from Escherichia coli by immuno electron microscopy. The specificity of the antibody binding sites was demonstrated by stringent absorption experiments. In addition we have reinvestigated and refined the locations of proteins S5, S13 and S14 on the ribosomal surface which had previously been localized in our laboratory (Tischendorf et al., Mol. Gen. Genet. 134, 209-223, 1974). Thus altogether 16 out of the 21 ribosomal proteins of the small subunit from E. coli have been mapped in our laboratory.     

Ribosomal protein-dependent orientation of the 16 S rRNA environment of S15

Ribosomal protein S15 binds specifically to the central domain of 16 S ribosomal RNA (16 S rRNA) and directs the assembly of four additional proteins to this domain. The central domain of 16 S rRNA along with these five proteins form the platform of the 30 S subunit. Previously, directed hydroxyl radical probing from Fe(II)-S15 in small ribonucleoprotein complexes was used to study assembly of the central domain of 16 S rRNA. Here, this same approach was used to understand the 16 S rRNA environment of Fe(II)-S15 in 30 S subunits and to determine the ribosomal proteins that are involved in forming the mature S15-16 S rRNA environment. We have identified additional sites of Fe(II)-S15-directed cleavage in 30S subunits compared to the binary complex of Fe(II)-S15/16 S rRNA. Along with novel targets in the central domain, sites within the 5' and 3' minor domains are also cleaved. This suggests that during the course of 30S subunit assembly these elements are positioned in the vicinity of S15. Besides the previously determined role for S8, roles for S5, S6+S18, and S16 in altering the 16 S rRNA environment of S15 were established. These studies reveal that ribosomal proteins can alter the assembly of regions of the 30 S subunit from a considerable distance and influence the overall conformation of this ribonucleoprotein particle.     

Hydroxyl radical footprinting of ribosomal proteins on 16S rRNA.

Complexes between 16S rRNA and purified ribosomal proteins, either singly or in combination, were assembled in vitro and probed with hydroxyl radicals generated from free Fe(II)-EDTA. The broad specificity of hydroxyl radicals for attack at the ribose moiety in both single- and double-stranded contexts permitted probing of nearly all of the nucleotides in the 16S rRNA chain. Specific protection of localized regions of the RNA was observed in response to assembly of most of the ribosomal proteins. The locations of the protected regions were in good general agreement with the footprints previously reported for base-specific chemical probes, and with sites of RNA-protein crosslinking. New information was obtained about interaction of ribosomal proteins with 16S rRNA, especially with helical elements of the RNA. In some cases, 5' or 3' stagger in the protection pattern on complementary strands suggests interaction of proteins with the major or minor groove, respectively, of the RNA. These results reinforce and extend previous data on the localization of ribosomal proteins with respect to structural features of 16S rRNA, and offer many new constraints for three-dimensional modeling of the 30S ribosomal subunit.     

Assembly of the 30S ribosomal subunit: positioning ribosomal protein S13 in the S7 assembly branch

Studies of Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit assembly have revealed a hierarchical and cooperative association of ribosomal proteins with 16S ribosomal RNA; these results have been used to compile an in vitro 30S subunit assembly map. In single protein addition and omission studies, ribosomal protein S13 was shown to be dependent on the prior association of ribosomal protein S20 for binding to the ribonucleoprotein particle. While the overwhelming majority of interactions revealed in the assembly map are consistent with additional data, the dependency of S13 on S20 is not. Structural studies position S13 in the head of the 30S subunit > 100 A away from S20, which resides near the bottom of the body of the 30S subunit. All of the proteins that reside in the head of the 30S subunit, except S13, have been shown to be part of the S7 assembly branch, that is, they all depend on S7 for association with the assembling 30S subunit. Given these observations, the assembly requirements for S13 were investigated using base-specific chemical footprinting and primer extension analysis. These studies reveal that S13 can bind to 16S rRNA in the presence of S7, but not S20. Additionally, interaction between S13 and other members of the S7 assembly branch have been observed. These results link S13 to the 3' major domain family of proteins, and the S7 assembly branch, placing S13 in a new location in the 30S subunit assembly map where its position is in accordance with much biochemical and structural data.     

Interaction of tetracycline with RNA: photoincorporation into ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli.

Photolysis of [3H]tetracycline in the presence of Escherichia coli ribosomes results in an approximately 1:1 ratio of labelling ribosomal proteins and RNAs. In this work we characterize crosslinks to both 16S and 23S RNAs. Previously, the main target of photoincorporation of [3H]tetracycline into ribosomal proteins was shown to be S7, which is also part of the one strong binding site of tetracycline on the 30S subunit. The crosslinks on 23S RNA map exclusively to the central loop of domain V (G2505, G2576 and G2608) which is part of the peptidyl transferase region. However, experiments performed with chimeric ribosomal subunits demonstrate that peptidyltransferase activity is not affected by tetracycline crosslinked solely to the 50S subunits. Three different positions are labelled on the 16S RNA, G693, G1300 and G1338. The positions of these crosslinked nucleotides correlate well with footprints on the 16S RNA produced either by tRNA or the protein S7. This suggests that the nucleotides are labelled by tetracycline bound to the strong binding site on the 30S subunit. In addition, our results demonstrate that the well known inhibition of tRNA binding to the A-site is solely due to tetracycline crosslinked to 30S subunits and furthermore suggest that interactions of the antibiotic with 16S RNA might be involved in its mode of action.     

RNA-protein interactions in the ribosome. II. Binding of ribosomal proteins to isolated fragments of the 16 S RNA

Specific fragments of the 16 S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli have been isolated and tested for their ability to interact with proteins of the 30 S ribosomal subunit. The 12 S RNA, a 900-nucleotide fragment derived from the 5′-terminal portion of the 16 S RNA, was shown to form specific complexes with proteins S4, S8, S15, and S20. The stoichiometry of binding at saturation was determined in each case. Interaction between the 12 S RNA and protein fraction $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$ was detected in the presence of S4, S8, S15 and S20; only these proteins were able to bind to this fragment, even when all 21 proteins of the 30 S subunit were added to the reaction mixture. Protein S4 also interacted specifically with the 9 S RNA, a fragment of 500 nucleotides that corresponds to the 5′-terminal third of the 16 S RNA, and protein S15 bound independently to the 4 S RNA, a fragment containing 140 nucleotides situated toward the middle of the RNA molecule. None of the proteins interacted with the 600-nucleotide 8 S fragment that arose from the 3′-end of the 16 S RNA.When the 16 S RNA was incubated with an unfractionated mixture of 30 S subunit proteins at 0 °C, 10 to 12 of the proteins interacted with the ribosomal RNA to form the reconstitution intermediate (RI) particle. Limited hydrolysis of this particle with T₁ ribonuclease yielded 14 S and 8 S subparticles whose RNA components were indistinguishable from the 12 S and 8 S RNAs isolated from digests of free 16 S RNA. The 14 S subparticle contained proteins S6 and S18 in addition to the RNA-binding proteins S4, S8, S15, S20 and $\text{S}\text{16}\text{S}\text{17}$. The 8 S subparticle contained proteins S7, S9, S13 and S19. These findings serve to localize the sites at which proteins incapable of independent interaction with 16 S RNA are fixed during the early stages of 30 S subunit assembly.     

Protein binding sites on Escherichia coli 16S RNA; RNA regions that are protected by proteins S7, S14 and S19 in the presence or absence of protein S9.

14C-labelled proteins from E. coli 30S ribosomal subunits were isolated by HPLC, and selected groups of these proteins were reconstituted with 32P-labelled 16S RNA. The isolated reconstituted particles were partially digested with ribonuclease A, and the RNA fragments protected by the proteins were separated by gel electrophoresis and subjected to sequence analysis. Protein S7 alone gave no protected fragments, but S7 together with S14 and S19 protected an RNA region comprising the sequences 936-965, 972-1030, 1208-1262 and 1285-1379 of the 16S RNA. Addition of increasing amounts of protein S9 to the S7/S14/S19 particle resulted in a parallel increase in the protection of the hairpin loop between bases 1262 and 1285. The results are discussed in terms of the three-dimensional folding of 16S RNA in the 30S subunit.     

Characterisation of RNA fragments obtained by mild nuclease digestion of 30-S ribosomal subunits from Escherichia coli.

When Escherichia coli 30-S ribosomal subunits are hydrolysed under mild conditions, two ribonucleoprotein fragments of unequal size are produced. Knowledge of the RNA sequences contained in these hydrolysis products was required for the experiments described in the preceding paper, and the RNA sub-fragments have therefore been examined by oligonucleotide analysis. Two well-defined small fragments of free RNA, produced concomitantly with the ribonucleoprotein fragments, were also analysed. The larger ribonucleoprotein fragment, containing predominantly proteins S4, S5, S8, S15, S16 (17) and S20, contains a complex mixture of RNA sub-fragments varying from about 100 to 800 nucleotides in length. All these fragments arose from the 5'-terminal 900 nucleotides of 16-S RNA, corresponding to the well-known 12-S fragment. No long-range interactions could be detected within this RNA region in these experiments. The RNA from the smaller ribonucleoprotein fragment (containing proteins S7, S9 S10, S14 and S19) has been described in detail previously, and consists of about 450 nucleotides near the 3' end of the 16-S RNA, but lacking the 3'-terminal 150 nucleotides. The two small free RNA fragments (above) partly account for these missing 150 nucleotides; both fragments arose from section A of the 16-S RNA, but section J (the 3'-terminal 50 nucleotides) was not found. This result suggests that the 3' region of 16-S RNA is not involved in stable interactions with protein.     

A detailed model of the three-dimensional structure of Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA in situ in the 30 S subunit

A large body of intra-RNA and RNA-protein crosslinking data, obtained in this laboratory, was used to fold the phylogenetically and experimentally established secondary structure of Escherichia coli 16 S RNA into a three-dimensional model. All the crosslinks were induced in intact 30 S subunits (or in some cases in growing E. coli cells), and the sites of crosslinking were precisely localized on the RNA by oligonucleotide analysis. The RNA-protein crosslinking data (including 28 sites, and involving 13 of the 21 30S ribosomal were used to relate the RNA structure to the distribution of the proteins as determined by neutron scattering. The three-dimensional model of the 16 S RNA has overall dimensions of 220 A x 140 A x 90 A, in good agreement with electron microscopic estimates for the 30 S subunit. The shape of the model is also recognizably the same as that seen in electron micrographs, and the positions in the model of bases localized on the 30 S subunit by immunoelectron microscopy (the 5' and 3' termini, the m7G and m6(2)A residues, and C-1400) correspond closely to their experimentally observed positions. The distances between the RNA-protein crosslink sites in the model correlate well with the distances between protein centres of mass obtained by neutron scattering, only two out of 66 distances falling outside the expected tolerance limits. These two distances both involve protein S13, a protein noted for its anomalous behaviour. A comparison with other experimental information not specifically used in deriving the model shows that it fits well with published data on RNA-protein binding sites, mutation sites on the RNA causing resistance to antibiotics, tertiary interactions in the RNA, and a potential secondary structural "switch". Of the sites on 16 S RNA that have been found to be accessible to chemical modification in the 30 S subunit, 87% are at obviously exposed positions in the model. In contrast, 70% of the sites corresponding to positions that have ribose 2'-O-methylations in the eukaryotic 18 S RNA from Xenopus laevis are at non-exposed (i.e. internal) positions in the model. All nine of the modified bases in the E. coli 16 S RNA itself show a remarkable distribution, in that they form a "necklace" in one plane around the "throat" of the subunit. Insertions in eukaryotic 18 S RNA, and corresponding deletions in chloroplast or mammalian mitochondrial ribosomal RNA relative to E. coli 16 S RNA represent distinct sub-domains in the structure.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Use of lead(II) to probe the structure of large RNA's. Conformation of the 3' terminal domain of E. coli 16S rRNA and its involvement in building the tRNA binding sites

The present work shows that lead(II) can be used as a convenient structure probe to map the conformation of large RNA's and to follow discrete conformational changes at different functional states. We have investigated the conformation of the 3' domain of the E. coli 16S rRNA (nucleotides 1295-1542) in its naked form, in the 30S subunit and in the 70S ribosome. Our study clearly shows a preferential affinity of Pb(II) for interhelical and loop regions and suggests a high sensitivity for dynamic and flexible regions. Within 30S subunits, some cleavages are strongly decreased as the result of protein-induced protection, while others are enhanced suggesting local conformational adjustments. These rearrangements occur at functionally strategic regions of the RNA centered around nucleotides 1337, 1400, 1500 and near the 3' end of the RNA. The association of 30S and 50S subunits causes further protections at several nucleotides and some enhanced reactivities that can be interpreted in terms of subunits interface and allosteric transitions. The binding of E. coli tRNA-Phe to the 70S ribosome results in message-independent (positions 1337 and 1397) and message-dependent (1399-1400, 1491-1492 and 1505) protections. A third class of protection (1344-1345, 1393-1395, 1403-1409, 1412-1414, 1504, 1506-1507 and 1517-1519) is observed in message-directed 30S subunits, which are induced by both tRNA binding and 50S subunit association. This extensive reduction of reactivity most probably reflects an allosteric transition rather than a direct shielding.     

Comparative Surface Structure of 16S Ribosomal Ribonucleic Acid of 30S Ribosomes of Procaryotic Cells

Ribonuclease T(1) treatment of 30S ribosomes of Escherichia coli converts a large region at the 3' OH end of 16S ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) to low-molecular-weight RNA. The final 25 nucleotides at the 3' terminus of the molecule emerge relatively intact, whereas most of the region "upstream," for about 150 nucleotides, is converted to oligonucleotides. Identical enzyme treatment generates a fragment of about 60 nucleotides from the middle of 16S rRNA (section D'). To determine whether there are similar sequences in other bacteria, which occupy similar accessible surface locations, we treated 30S ribosomes from Azotobacter vinelandii and Bacillus stearothermophilus with RNase T(1). In each case, a fragment of RNA about 25 nucleotides in length containing the 3' OH end of 16S rRNA and a fragment of about 60 nucleotides in length similar, but not identical, in oligonucleotide composition to section D' of E. coli 16S rRNA were obtained from nuclease-treated 30S ribosomes. These data indicate that, although the primary structure at the 3' end and the middle (section D') of the various 16S rRNA's is not completely conserved, their respective conformations are conserved. A number of identical oligonucleotides were found in the low-molecular-weight fraction obtained from RNase T(1)-treated E. coli, A. vinelandii, and B. stearothermophilus 30S ribosomes. These results show that identical RNase T(1)-sensitive sequences are present in all three bacteria. Hydrolysis of these regions leads to the production of the fragments 25 and 60 nucleotides in length.     

Directed hydroxyl radical probing of the rRNA neighborhood of ribosomal protein S13 using tethered Fe(II).

Directed hydroxyl radical probing was used to probe the rRNA neighborhood around protein S13 in the 30S ribosomal subunit. The unique cysteine at position 84 of S13 served as a tethering site for attachment of Fe(II)-1-(p-bromoacetamidobenzyl)-EDTA. Derivatized S13 (Fe-C84-S13) was then assembled into 30S ribosomal subunits by in vitro reconstitution with 16S rRNA and a mixture of the remaining 30S subunit proteins. Hydroxyl radicals generated from the tethered Fe(II) resulted in cleavage of the RNA backbone in two localized regions of the 3' major domain of 16S rRNA. One region spans nt 1308-1333 and is close to a site previously crosslinked to S13. A second set of cleavages is found in the 950/1230 helix. Both regions have been implicated in binding of S13 by previous chemical footprinting studies using base-specific chemical probes and solution-based hydroxyl radical probing. These results place both regions of 16S rRNA in proximity to position C84 of S13 in the three-dimensional structure of the 30S ribosomal subunit.     

RNA-protein cross-linking in Escherichia coli ribosomal subunits: localization of sites on 16S RNA which are cross-linked to proteins S17 and S21 by treatment with 2-iminothiolane.

Treatment of E. coli ribosomal subunits with 2-iminothiolane coupled with mild ultraviolet irradiation leads to the formation of a large number of RNA-protein cross-links. In the case of the 30S subunit, a number of sites on 16S RNA that are cross-linked to proteins S7 and S8 by this procedure have already been identified (see ref. 6). Here, by using new or modified techniques for the partial digestion of the RNA and the subsequent isolation of the cross-linked RNA-protein complexes, three new iminothiolane cross-links have been localized: Protein S17 is cross-linked to the 16S RNA within an oligonucleotide encompassing positions 629-633, and protein S21 is cross-linked to two sites within oligonucleotides encompassing positions 723-724 and positions 1531-1542 (the 3'-end of the 16S RNA).     

A three-dimensional model of domain III of the Escherichia coli small ribosomal subunit

A three-dimensional model of domain III (nucleotides 920 to 1395) of the 30S ribosomal subunit of E. coli is proposed. The data used as a guide in folding the secondary structure of the RNA into a tertiary structure are four long range RNA-RNA interactions proposed by us on the basis of experiments performed in this laboratory plus two sets of data from other laboratories: protein-RNA cross-linking sites for proteins S1, S3, S7, S10 and S12, and the interprotein distances determined by neutron scattering. The model is consistent with nearly all of the published experimental findings on the structure of domain III.