Serologic analysis of human tumor antigens

Summary The immune adherence (IA) assay was used to measure serum reactivity of patients with melanoma and osteosarcoma against paired cell lines (tumor cells and normal skin fibroblasts obtained from the same individuals) grown in tissue culture. Sera from 224 patients with various stages of melanoma were compared with sera from 100 normal age- and sex-matched donors. None of the 18 stage I sera (0%), 23 of 166 (14%) stage II sera, 3 of 40 (7%) stage III sera, and 3 of 100 (3%) normal sera were highly reactive to a standard allogeneic melanoma-fibroblast pair. None of the sera exhibited unique activity against melanoma. There was no correlation between stage of melanoma and high serum reactivity, nor was this reactivity predictive of recurrence. Sera from 39 tumor-bearing osteosarcoma patients prior to amputation were compared with sera from 50 normal age-and sex-matched donors. Eight of 39 (21%) patient sera and 1 of 50 (2%) normal sera were highly reactive to an osteosarcoma-fibroblast pair. No sera had reactivity uniquely directed against osteosarcoma. Eight osteosarcoma and two melanoma patients were tested simultaneously against their autologous cultured tumor and skin cells. Only one of these patients exhibited high reactivity towards autologous cells, and this reactivity was equal against both osteosarcoma and normal cells. None of seven highly reactive osteosarcoma or six highly reactive melanoma sera had residual tumor-specific reactivity against allogeneic osteosarcoma or melanoma after absorption with cultured fibroblasts, cultured fetal fibroblasts, or fetal calf serum.     

Demonstration of the specificity of a monkey antiserum against human melanoma

Summary The reactivity spectrum of a monkey antiserum raised against in vitro-cultured human melanoma cells was compared by means of three different assays: complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC), antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) and mixed hemadsorption (MHA). After absorption with a pool of cells from T- and B-lymphoid cell lines the antiserum was specifically cytotoxic in CDC for cultured melanoma cells. The melanoma specificity of the antiserum was confirmed by quantitative absorption experiments with cultured melanoma and nonmelanoma cells. When the lymphoid cell-absorbed antiserum was assayed by MHA, however, a high reactivity against both melanoma and nonmelanoma cells was observed. Further absorption with nonmelanoma tumor cells removed the reactivity of the antiserum with different nonmelanoma cell lines, but did not abolish its reactivity with melanoma cells. After this second absorption, the antiserum remained cytolytic against melanoma cells in CDC. In ADCC experiments this antiserum was not able to induce any cytotoxicity even before absorption.Analysis of Sephadex G 200 fractions of the antiserum revealed that the melanoma-specific antibodies cytotoxic in CDC were localized exclusively in the IgM peak. This finding was confirmed in similar studies with four other nonhuman primate melanoma antisera. Abbreviations used in this paper: CDC, complement dependent cytotoxicity: ADCC, antibody dependent cell mediated cytotoxicity; MHA, mixed hemadsorption; FCS, fetal calf serum.     

Effect of the H-2 gene complex rates of fibroblast intercellular adhesion

The rate of collection of embryo fibroblast single cells by an embryo fibroblast monlayer was realted to the H-2 haplotype of the fibroblast monolayer. The rate was highest for the H-2s strains and lowest for the H-2k strains with all other strains examined being intermediate. As opposed to monolayers prepared from the A and C3H background animals, monolayers from B10 background mice only demonstrated an H-2 haplotype dependent rate differential after treatment with fetal calf serum or neuraminidase. The relationship that was seen between monolayer H-2 haplotype and rate of adhesion with embryonic monolayers was not observed with either congenic 3T3 cell lines or fibroblasts derived from adult tissues. It was further shown that the rate of single cell pick-up could be substantially reduced by incubating the monolayers with the appropriate polyspecific anti-H-2 antisera. The inhibition observed appeared to be directly related to anti-H-2 antibody binding and was not merely a function of ligand binding to the cell surface, as antisera directed against other fibroblast cell surface antigens did not significantly inhibit the adhesive rate. These results indicate a role for the H-2 gene complex in modulating fibroblast-fibroblast intercellular adhesion.     

Membrane-associated antigens of human malignant melanoma IV: Changes in expression of antigens on cultured melanoma cells

Summary Established melanoma cell lines were cultured for one passage (approximately 1 week) in different lots of fetal calf and new born calf sera and then tested against a panel of previously positively reacting sera from melanoma patients and polyspecific HL-A alloantisera. Using indirect immunofluorescence the cells showed varying degrees of reactivity ranging from positive to negative reactions depending on the supplementing serum in the culture medium. When standardized culture conditions were used and the cells were tested by immune adherence at several weeks intervals against panels of sera from melanoma patients, from tumor patients other than melanoma, from pregnant women, and from normal donors, most of the sera reacted identical, but some sera not only had changed quantitatively but also qualitatively from a negative to a positive reaction and vice versa indicating a shift in the spectrum of expressed antigens. When single cell clones from a cell line were isolated and tested against a panel of antisera, striking differences in reactivity were observed suggesting that the shift in the spectrum of expressed antigens was due to the outgrowth of dominating subclones with antigen patterns different from the previously dominating subclones. This conclusion was further supported by experiments in which a weakly positive reacting serum was employed to separate a cell line into positively and negatively reacting sublines. Unit gravity sedimentation and density gradient sedimentation were used in order to separate rosetted from non-rosetted tumor cells which had been prepared by immune adherence. It is concluded that cultured cell lines are in a dynamic state and that differentiation is one of the major mechanisms accounting for a change in antigen expression.     

Expression of fetal antigens by normal human skin cells grown in tissue culture.

Normal human sera are capable of causing complement-mediated lysis of normal human skin cells grown in tissue culture. This lytic reactivity can be completely removed by absorption with first trimester fetal tissue. Absorption with a variety of normal adult human tissues including lymphocytes, decidua, skin, and muscle are incapable of absorbing reactivity. Absorption of reactivity by fetal tissue is specific and not due to the introduction of anti-complementary or other nonspecific factors, as evidenced by the inability of simultaneous fetal absorption to remove reactivity from antisera with specificity for HLA antigens. Similarly, absorption of lytic sera with fetal calf serum proteins was incapable of removing reactivity against normal cells in tissue culture. It thus appears that normal human cells in tissue culture express antigens shared by the first trimester human fetus, but not present on a variety of adult human tissues. This "neoantigen" present on normal human cells when grown in tissue culture is a potential source of confusion and must be accounted for in searching for human tumor-specific antigens utilizing tissue culture cells.     

Serial studies of autologous antibody reactivity to squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck

Summary In previous studies we evaluated the incidence and specificity of autologous antibody reactivity against squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck (SCCHN). We were able to demonstrate that autologous antibody reactivity is present in native sera but was usually of too low a titer to allow further analysis. Dissociation of immune complexes by acidification and ultrafiltration of serum augmented autologous antibody reactivity in nine out of nine autologous systems tested. Native antibody and antibody derived from immune complexes produced by the host and reactive with autologous tumor cells may be directed against physiologically relevant antigens. Therefore, correlations of antibody titers with clinical course may provide insight into the nature of the host response to cancer. In the present analysis, serological studies of six patients with SCCHN were performed with serum samples obtained over many months. Results of serial serological assays were correlated to tumor progression and clinical course. Fluctuations in autologous antibody reactivity were noted over time. In four cases, rises in autologous antibody titers preceded the clinical diagnosis of recurrence by several months. Drops in autologous antibody reactivity were noted in two cases following surgery or radiation therapy. In two cases of long-term survivors, no correlation between antibody reactivity and clinical course was noted. Specificity analysis of the six autologous systems demonstrated reactivity against autologous and allogeneic SCCHN as well as melanoma cell lines. These sera did not react with glioma, neuroblastoma, renal cell, breast, bladder and colon carcinoma cell lines nor with fetal calf serum, pooled lymphocytes, red blood cells and platelets. Autologous serial serological studies may provide a means by which to evaluate the host/tumor relationship in patients with SCCHN.     

Effect of glutaraldehyde treatment of human melanoma cells on the expression of melanoma-associated antigens

Summary Human melanoma cells were treated with different concentrations of glutaraldehyde, and retention of serological reactivity with antisera against melanoma-associated antigens, HLA antigen, and 2-microglobulin was assessed by quantitative absorption analysis in mixed hemadsorption microassays. Glutaraldehyde concentrations of 0.025% or greater significantly impaired binding to melanoma cells of antibody against melanoma-associated antigens. At a concentration of 0.0025% antibody binding was not decreased although plating efficiency was reduced to less than 1%. Glutaraldehyde concentrations of 0.25% or greater significantly reduced binding to the same melanoma cells of antisera against HLA antigen and 2-microglobulin. Glutaraldehyde treatment (up to 2.5%) of HT-29 colon carcinoma cells failed to reduce reactivity of antisera against CEA and blood group A isoantigen, which are present on these cells. These studies indicate that the effect of glutaraldehyde treatment of cells on retention of surface antigens is critically dependent on the concentration of glutaraldehyde used and the type of antigens involved. Abbreviations used in this paper: MAA, melanoma-associated antigens; GA, glutaraldehyde; FCS, fetal calf serum; RPMI, Roswell Park Memorial Institute; 2M, 2-microglobulin; CEA, carcinoembryonic antigen; PBS, phosphate-buffered saline; NGP, normal glycoprotein cross-reacting with CEA; SRBC, sheep red blood cells     

Immunological studies of the embryonic muscle cell surface. Antiserum to the prefusion myoblast

Xenogeneic antisera raised in rabbits have been used to detect compositional changes at the cell surfaces of differentiating embryonic chick skeletal muscle. In this report, we present the serological characterization of antiserum (Anti-M-24) against muscle tissue and developmental stage-specific cell surface antigens of the prefusion myoblast. Cells from primary cultures of 12-d-old embryonic chick hindlimb muscle were injected into rabbits, and the resulting antisera were selectively absorbed to obtain immunological specificity. Cytotoxicity and immunohistochemical assays were used to test this antiserum. Absorption with embryonic or adult chick heart, brain, retina, liver, erythrocytes, or skeletal muscle fibroblasts failed to remove all reactivity of Anti-M-24 for myogenic cells at all stages of development. After absorption with embryonic myotubes, however, Anti-M-24 no longer reacted with differentiated myofibers, but did react with prefusion myoblasts. The myoblast surface antigens detected with Anti-M-24 are components of the muscle cell membrane: (a) these macromolecules are free to diffuse laterally within the myoblast membrane; (b) Anti-M-24, in the presence of complement, induced lysis of the muscle cell membrane; and (c) intact monolayers of viable myoblasts completely absorbed reactivity of Anti-M-24 for myoblasts. These antigens are not loosely adsorbed culture medium components or an artifact of tissue culture because: (a) absorption of Anti-M-24 with homogenized embryonic muscle removed all antibodies to cultured myoblasts; (b) Anti-M-24 reacted with myoblast surfaces in vivo; and (c) absorption of Anti-M-24 with culture media did not affect the titer of this antiserum for myoblasts. We conclude that myogenic cells at all stages of development possess externally exposed antigens which are undetected on other embryonic and adult chick tissues. In addition, myoblasts exhibit surface antigenic determinants that are either masked, absent, or present in very low concentrations on skeletal muscle fibroblasts, embryonic myotubes, or adult myofibers. These antigens are free to diffuse laterally within the myoblast membrane and may be modulated in response to appropriate environmental cues during myodifferentiation.     

Parvalbumin, a Neuronal Protein in Brain Cell Cultures

Dissociated brain cell cultures were derived from 14-day-old embryonic as well as from newborn mice. The cells were grown in a medium containing 10% fetal calf serum. Indirect immunofluorescence was performed using antisera directed against the Ca2+-binding protein parvalbumin (Mr 12,000). In embryonic cultures a large proportion of cells was intensely stained by antiparvalbumin . In double-labelling experiments involving the simultaneous application of antisera against parvalbumin and the neuron-specific enolase, the enolase-containing cells were also parvalbumin-positive and both antisera revealed identical intracellular staining patterns. Conversely, almost no parvalbumin- and enolase-positive cells were present in cultures derived from newborn mice. However, in these cultures many cells were immunoreactive toward the myelin basic protein, an accepted marker for oligodendrocytes. The presence of parvalbumin within the embryonic brain cell cultures was confirmed by analyses of the culture extracts (4 mM EDTA, pH 7.5) by HPLC on reverse-phase supports, two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and immunoblotting. The present study suggests that in mouse brain cell cultures, parvalbumin is localized in neurons.     

Detection of phenotypic differences on human malignant melanoma lines and their variant sublines with monoclonal antibodies

The hybridoma technique was used to generate monoclonal antibodies against a wide spectrum of melanoma-associated surface antigens. Mice were immunized against the human melanoma lines Mel A-375, SK Mel-25, and Mel S-5 (subclone of SK Mel-25), which differ with respect to a number of biological and biochemical properties. Spleen cells were fused with P3 X 63-AG8.653 myeloma cells. Twenty hybridomas producing antibodies that were negative on platelets, leukocytes, and monocytes but positive on melanoma cells were isolated and recloned. The specificity of antibodies was investigated on 30 human melanoma and nonmelanoma lines. Five groups of antibodies could be distinguished by their reactivity (1) with few melanoma lines and embryonic fibroblasts; (2) with melanoma, neuroblastoma, and teratoma; (3) with melanoma, neuroblastoma, glioblastoma, teratoma, and carcinoma; (4) with melanoma, teratoma, and carcinoma; and (5) with melanoma, neuroblastoma, teratoma, glioblastoma, carcinoma, embryonic fibroblasts, and B-lymphoblastoid cells. The antigen expression was qualitatively and quantitatively different from cell line to cell line. No evidence for melanoma-specific antigens was found. Eight antibodies were isolated detecting phenotypic differences on sublines of SK Mel-25.     

Phase II study of vaccinia melanoma cell lysates (VMCL) as adjuvant to surgical treatment of stage II melanoma

Summary Patients with stage II melanoma were vaccinated with vaccinia virus-induced melanoma cell lysates (VMCL). The vaccine contained viable vaccinia virus, membranous fragments and no intact nuclei. A number of antigens defined by monoclonal antibodies were detected in the vaccine including the ganglioside GD3 and DR antigens. Administration of the vaccine was associated with depression of natural killer cell activity against melanoma and K562 target cells in the first 3–6 months of treatment. Leucocyte dependent antibody (LDA) activity against melanoma cells was induced or increased in titre in approximately half of the patients studied. Continued vaccination was associated in a number of patients with a decrease in LDA titres. Studies on a small sample of patients revealed that this was associated with the development of serum factors which inhibited LDA activity. LDA activity appeared directed to non-MHC antigens on melanoma cells which were of at least two specificities. One specificity which was shared with antigens on a number of non-melanoma carcinoma cells was removed by absorption on fetal brain and may be similar to oncofetal antigens described by other workers. Reactivity against melanocytes was induced in some patients and may underlie the development of vitiligo in several patients. These results suggest that vaccines prepared from VMCL may be a favourable method for increasing immune responses against melanoma.     

Rabbit antiserum against Daudi-cell membrane fractions detects cell surface antigens present on subpopulations of human lymphocytes.

An antiserum was produced by immunization of rabbits with membrane preparations of a human lymphoblastoid B cell line, Daudi. After absorption with a human endometrial carcinoma cell line, this antiserum appeared to be specific for antigen(s) present on adult and fetal thymocytes as well as on tonsillar lymphocytes but absent, or present in very small amounts, on normal or phytohemagglutinin- (PHA) stimulated peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). When T and B cell-enriched fractions from tonsillar lymphocytes were tested with the anti-Daudi serum, the reactivity was equally distributed in each population. Among 13 human lymphoblastoid cell lines tested, reactivity was demonstrated on three out of four T cell lines, and on four out of nine B cell lines. The positive reacting B cell lines were derived from two African and two American Burkitt lymphomas. The antigen(s) described does not seem to be related either to human Ia-type antigens or to Epstein-Barr virus-associated antigens because these antigens are not present on fetal or adult thymocytes. Reciprocal absorption experiments indicate that this anti-Daudi serum detects the same antigenic structures present on certain subpopulations of T and B lymphocytes.     

Specificities of heterologous antisera against human leukaemia cells. 2. Reactions against fetal liver cells and absorption studies with fetal tissue.

Rabbit or goat antisera directed to ALL and AML cells were investigated in cytotoxicity tests with fetal liver cells as targets. After absorption with erythrocytes and spleen cells from allogenic donors the antisera killed fetal liver cells. There was no reaction with remission leukocytes or blood leukocytes from normal donors. Treatment with fetal tissue removed the activity of the AML and ALL antisera against ALL cells but not of the AML antisera against AML cells. This indicates the existence of at least two antigens on the surface of AML cells, one antigen is common with ALL cells and of fetal origin and another one seems to be characteristic of AML cells and not of fetal origin. Because treatment with fetal tissue removed all activity of the ALL antisera it can be assumed that leukaemia-associated antigens on ALL cells are of fetal origin.     

In vitro sensitization of human lymphoid cells to antigens on cultured melanoma cells: II. Sensitization against melanoma-associated antigens

Peripheral blood lymphoid cells from patients with malignant melanoma can be sensitized on allogeneic or autochthonous melanoma monolayers. Peak cytotoxicity occurred after 5 days of sensitization. Sensitization appeared to be directed against melanoma-associated antigens, as judged by the pattern of cytotoxic reactivity. Sensitized cells were cytotoxic against autochthonous or allogeneic melanoma cells, but not against autochthonous fibroblasts or allogeneic tumor cells of different histologic types. Sensitization of responder lymphoid cells from melanoma patients on allogeneic melanoma cells usually resulted in more pronounced cytotoxicity against autochthonous melanoma target cells than did sensitization on autochthonous melanoma monolayers. These results indicate that cell cultures of human malignant melanoma contain tumor-associated antigens which can sensitize human peripheral blood lymphoid cells in vitro. These results also support the concept that there are cross-reactive tumor-associated antigens in human malignant melanomas.     

Heterogeneity of primary and metastatic human malignant melanoma as detected with monoclonal mntibodies in cryostat sections of biopsies

Summary Monoclonal antibodies were generated against established melanoma cell lines and characterized by their reactivity with various sublines. The antibodies selected for their reaction with melanoma-associated antigens were tested on cryostat sections of melanoma tissue from various stages and on other tumors. The reactivity with normal tissues was also determined. Of 30 antibodies reacting with melanoma cell lines 11 did not react with melanoma biopsies. Of the remaining 19 antibodies nine displayed broad cross-reactivity with normal cells and structures and other benign or malignant tumor cells. Among the remaining antibodies five types were defined that detected antigens (nevocellular I, nevocellular II, neural, endothelial, basal cell) found on certain normal tissues and structures and on certain tumor phenotypes. Even though there seems to be a tendency for some antigens to be preferentially associated with certain stages of melanoma, it has not yet been possible to establish any clear-cut correlation between the expression of one of the differentiation antigens and a particular stage or malignancy potential of melanoma.     

Tissue-specific cell-surface antigens in embryonic cells

With the use of antisera prepared in rabbits against suspensions of live embryonic chick tissue cells, qualitative differences in cell surface antigens were demonstrated on cells from different embryonic chick tissues by immune agglutination and immunofluorescence. Unabsorbed antisera reacted with both homologous and nonhomologous cells; thorough absorption of the antisera with heterologous tissues removed cross-reacting antibodies, and the antisera acquired a high degree of tissue specificity. Thus, antiretina cell serum absorbed with nonretina cells or tissues, agglutinated only neural retina cells, and was shown by immunofluorescence tests to react specifically with the surface of retina cells, both in cell suspensions and in frozen tissue sections. Comparable results with antisera against cells from embryonic liver and other tissues demonstrated the existence of tissue-specific, phenotypic disparities in the antigenicities of embryonic cell surfaces, in addition to the presence of cell-surface antigens shared by certain classes of cells, and of antigens common to all cells in the embryo. The results are discussed in terms of the possible involvement of such phenotypic determinants in the specification of cell surfaces, in relation to cell recognition and developmental interactions.     

Derivation of 30 human embryonic stem cell lines—improving the quality

We have derived 30 human embryonic stem cell lines from supernumerary blastocysts in our laboratory. During the derivation process, we have studied new and safe method to establish good quality lines. All our human embryonic stem cell lines have been derived using human foreskin fibroblasts as feeder cells. The 26 more recent lines were derived in a medium containing serum replacement instead of fetal calf serum. Mechanical isolation of the inner cell mass using flexible metal needles was used in deriving the 10 latest lines. The lines are karyotypically normal, but culture adaptation in two lines has been observed. Our human embryonic stem cell lines are banked, and they are available for researchers.     

Serological analysis of xenogeneic anti-lymphoblastoid cell-line sera with specificity against HLA-B12

In view of the importance of potent anti-HLA sera with narrow reaction patterns against defined HLA antigens, two xenogeneic antisera were raised in rabbits following immunization with human lymphoblastoid cell lines fromHLA-nonidentical donors homozygous for HLA-B12. After absorption with lymphoblastoid cell lines of an appropriate HLA phenotype, the antisera were purified over DEAE-cellulose ion exchange chromatography and reconcentrated. Both antisera recognized HLA-B12-positive peripheral blood cells of unrelated donors tested in the microcytotoxicity assay. The two rabbit antisera revealed a high degree of similarity in their anti-HLA-B12 antibody specificity. One antiserum showed some cross reactivity with HLA-B13 as has been reported in allo-anti-HLA-B12 sera. The other antiserum revealed some activity against HLA-DRw7-positive donors. Antibody activity could be removed completely from two further rabbit anti-HLA antisera by absorption with lymphoblastoid cell lines from related and unrelatedHLA-identical donors. The advantages of using lymphoblastoid cell lines as immunogens and absorption material for the production of heterologous anti-HLA typing sera are discussed.     

Expression of surface antigens and its relation to parameters of malignancy in human malignant melanoma

Summary Human malignant melanoma cell lines were assayed for secretion of plasminogen activator (PA) and for growth in the nude mouse. It was observed that cell lines that were high producers of PA also grew in the nude mouse. In order to detect differences in membrane constituents of cells related to these parameters of malignancy, antisera were raised in non-human primates against the high producer (Mel A-375) and the non-producer cell of PA (SK-Mel 25). After extensive absorption the two antisera showed little or no cross-reactivity with the other cell line. Several subclones were isolated from SK-Mel 25 and assayed for PA production and growth in the nude mouse. Two sublines (S 5 and S 13) were found that produced moderate amounts of PA and grew in the nude mouse, whereas five other sublines were negative in both respects. By means of antisera against sublines it could be shown that patterns of surface antigens were distinct from that of the parental line.     

Serological analysis of xenogeneic anti-lymphoblastoid cell-line sera with specificity against HLA-B12

In view of the importance of potent anti-HLA sera with narrow reaction patterns against defined HLA antigens, two xenogeneic antisera were raised in rabbits following immunization with human lymphoblastoid cell lines from HLA-nonidentical donors homozygous for HLA-B12. After absorption with lymphoblastoid cell lines of an appropriate HLA phenotype, the antisera were purified over DEAE-cellulose ion exchange chromatography and reconcentrated. Both antisera recognized HLA-B12-positive peripheral blood cells of unrelated donors tested in the microcytotoxicity assay. The two rabbit antisera revealed a high degree of similarity in their anti-HLA-B12 antibody specificity. One antiserum showed some cross reactivity with HLA-B13 as has been reported in allo-anti-HLA-B12 sera. The other antiserum revealed some activity against HLA-DRw7-positive donors. Antibody activity could be removed completely from two further rabbit anti-HLA antisera by absorption with lymphoblastoid cell lines from related and unrelated HLA-identical donors. The advantages of using lymphoblastoid cell lines as immunogens and absorption material for the production of heterologous anti-HLA typing sera are discussed.