Dissecting autophagosome formation: The missing pieces

The formation of autophagosomes is the central part of the macroautophagy pathway. Little is known, however, about how the participants in this process affect the membrane dynamics at the phagophore assembly site (PAS). Recently, we demonstrated that Atg8, a lipid-conjugated ubiquitin-like protein, controls the expansion of the phagophore. In addition, we showed that the autophagosome formation process can be traced and dissected by time-lapse fluorescence microscopy observation of GFP-Atg8. These findings constitute one step further in our understanding of autophagosome formation. Key questions remain open, however, on how the actions of other proteins at the PAS are coordinated with that of Atg8 and on the precise role of Atg8.

Addendum to: Xie Z, Nair U, Klionsky DJ. Atg8 controls phagophore expansion during autophagosome formation. Mol Biol Cell 2008; 19:3290-8.     

Localized de novo phospholipid synthesis drives autophagosome biogenesis

ABSTRACT

During (macro)autophagy, cells form transient organelles, termed autophagosomes, to target a broad spectrum of substrates for degradation critical to cellular and organismal health. Driven by rapid membrane assembly, an initially small vesicle (phagophore) elongates into a large cup-shaped structure to engulf substrates within a few minutes in a double-membrane autophagosome. In particular, how autophagic membranes expand has been a longstanding question. Here, we summarize our recent work that delineates a pathway that drives phagophore expansion by localized de novo phospholipid synthesis. Specifically, we found that the conserved acyl-CoA synthetase Faa1 localizes to nucleated phagophores to locally activate fatty acids for de novo phospholipid synthesis in the neighboring ER. These newly synthesized phospholipids are then preferentially incorporated into autophagic membranes and drive the expansion of the phagophore into a functional autophagosome. In summary, our work uncovers molecular principles of how cells coordinate phospholipid synthesis and flux with autophagic membrane formation during autophagy.

Abbreviations: ACS: acyl-CoA synthestases; CoA: coenzyme A; ER: endoplasmic reticulum     

Double duty of Atg9 self-association in autophagosome biogenesis

The understanding of the membrane flow process during autophagosome formation is essential to illuminate the role of autophagy under various disease-causing conditions. Atg9 is the only identified integral membrane protein required for autophagosome formation, and it is thought to cycle between the membrane sources and the phagophore assembly site (PAS). Thus, Atg9 may play an important role as a membrane carrier. We report the self-interaction of Atg9 and generate an Atg9 mutant that is defective in this interaction. This mutation results in abnormal autophagy, due to altered phagophore formation as well as inefficient membrane delivery to the PAS. Based on our analyses, we discuss a model suggesting dual functions for the Atg9 complex: by reversibly binding to another Atg9 molecule, Atg9 can both promote lipid transport from the membrane origins to the PAS, and also help assemble an intact phagophore membrane.     

Folding into an autophagosome

Autophagosomes arise in yeast and animals from the sealing of a cup-shaped double-membrane precursor, the phagophore. The concerted action of about 30 evolutionarily conserved autophagy related (ATG) proteins lies at the core of this process. However, the mechanisms allowing phagophore generation and its differentiation into a sealed autophagosome are still not clear in detail, and very little is known in plants. This is due in part to the scarcity of structurally informative, real-time imaging data of ATG proteins at the phagophore site. Among these, the ATG5 complex directs anchoring of ATG8 to the phagophore, an event required for membrane expansion. Detailed real-time and 3D imaging of ATG5, ATG8, and an ER marker at the expanding phagophore allowed us to propose a model for autophagosome formation in plants. This model implies tight connections of the growing phagophore with the outer face of the cortical endoplasmic reticulum and prompts new questions on the mechanism of autophagosome biogenesis.     

3D tomography reveals connections between the phagophore and endoplasmic reticulum

Autophagosomes have been reported to form in the vicinity of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). In many cases, the phagophore membrane is observed between two cisternae of rough ER, but it is not known whether these two membranes are directly connected. To investigate the relationship of the phagophore membrane and the ER, we used electron microscopic tomography of serum and amino acid starved normal rat kidney cells. The cells were fixed in glutaraldehyde and reduced osmium tetroxide and embedded in Epon. Dual axis tilt image series were acquired from two successive 250-nm sections. To analyze the three-dimensional (3D) morphology of phagophores and the associated rough ER, 3D tomograms were used to model the ER and phagophore membranes. The tomographic reconstructions revealed connections between the phagophore/autophagosome membrane and the closely located ER cisternae, especially with the ER located inside the autophagosome. The connections were typically formed by narrow extensions from the phagophore/autophagosome to the ER. This finding has potential implications on the origin of autophagosome membranes, and on the mechanism of phagophore membrane extension. In addition, we observed lipid droplets in very close contact with the phagophores/autophagosomes.     

Folding into an autophagosome: ATG5 sheds light on how plants do it

Autophagosomes arise in yeast and animals from the sealing of a cup-shaped double-membrane precursor, the phagophore. The concerted action of about 30 evolutionarily conserved autophagy related (ATG) proteins lies at the core of this process. However, the mechanisms allowing phagophore generation and its differentiation into a sealed autophagosome are still not clear in detail, and very little is known in plants. This is due in part to the scarcity of structurally informative, real-time imaging data of ATG proteins at the phagophore site. Among these, the ATG5 complex directs anchoring of ATG8 to the phagophore, an event required for membrane expansion. Detailed real-time and 3D imaging of ATG5, ATG8, and an ER marker at the expanding phagophore allowed us to propose a model for autophagosome formation in plants. This model implies tight connections of the growing phagophore with the outer face of the cortical endoplasmic reticulum and prompts new questions on the mechanism of autophagosome biogenesis.     

Dissecting autophagosome formation: the missing pieces

The formation of autophagosomes is the central part of the macroautophagy pathway. Little is known, however, about how the participants in this process affect the membrane dynamics at the phagophore assembly site (PAS). Recently, we demonstrated that Atg8, a lipid-conjugated ubiquitin-like protein, controls the expansion of the phagophore. In addition, we showed that the autophagosome formation process can be traced and dissected by time-lapse fluorescence microscopy observation of GFP-Atg8. These findings constitute one step further in our understanding of autophagosome formation. Key questions remain open, however, on how the actions of other proteins at the PAS are coordinated with that of Atg8 and on the precise role of Atg8.     

Endocytosis and autophagy: Shared machinery for degradation

Two key questions in the autophagy field are the mechanisms that underlie the signals for autophagy initiation and the source of membrane for expansion of the nascent membrane, the phagophore. In this review, we discuss recent findings highlighting the role of the classical endosomal pathway, from plasma membrane to lysosome, in the formation and expansion of the phagophore and subsequent degradation of the autophagosome contents. We also highlight the striking conservation of regulatory factors between the two pathways, including those regulating membrane budding and fusion, and the role of the lysosome in sensing the nutrient status of the cell, regulating mTORC1 activity, and ultimately the initiation of autophagy. Editor's suggested further reading in BioEssays The evolution of dynamin to regulate clathrin‐mediated endocytosis Abstract     

The Golgi complex as a source for yeast autophagosomal membranes

Today, more than 50 years after the discovery of autophagy, the origin of the autophagosomal membranes remains for the most part elusive. Many sources for the lipid bilayers have been proposed, but no conclusive evidence has been found to support one particular origin. The lipids do not appear to be generated at the site of autophagosome formation, the phagophore assembly site (PAS), since so far no lipid synthesizing enzyme has been found at this location. The current consensus is also that the autophagosomes do not directly bud off from a pre-existing compartment, and recent evidence in mammalian cells has revealed that the nascent autophagosome could expand through a lipid transfer mechanism from an adjacent organelle. In yeast, such an event has never been observed and data from our and other laboratories suggest that the Golgi complex could be a key player in mediating the expansion of the phagophore.     

Control of GABARAP‐mediated autophagy by the Golgi complex,centrosome and centriolar satellites

Within minutes of induction of autophagy by amino‐acid starvation in mammalian cells, multiple autophagosomes form throughout the cell cytoplasm. During their formation, the autophagosomes sequester cytoplasmic material and deliver it to lysosomes for degradation. How these organelles can be so rapidly formed and how their formation is acutely regulated are major questions in the autophagy field. Protein and lipid trafficking from diverse cell compartments contribute membrane to, or regulate the formation of the autophagosome. In addition, recruitment of Atg8 (in yeast), and the ATG8‐family members (in mammalian cells) to autophagosomes is required for efficient autophagy. Recently, it was discovered that the centrosome and centriolar satellites regulate autophagosome formation by delivery of an ATG8‐family member, GABARAP, to the forming autophagosome membrane, the phagophore. We propose that GABARAP regulates phagophore expansion by activating the ULK complex, the amino‐acid controlled initiator complex. This finding reveals a previously unknown link between the centrosome, centriolar satellites and autophagy.     

Autophagosome closure requires membrane scission

During the intracellular process of macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy), a membrane-bound organelle, the autophagosome, is generated de novo. The remodeling of the autophagic membrane during the life cycle of the organelle is a complex multistep process and involves several changes in the topology of the autophagic membrane. Here, we focus on the final step of autophagosome formation, the closure of the phagophore, during which the inner and outer autophagic membranes become separate entities. We argue that this topological membrane transformation is a membrane scission event. Surprisingly, not a single recent review describes this substep as membrane scission (or membrane fission). In contrast, a number of publications imply that membrane fusion is involved. We discuss the potential sources for misinterpretation and recommend to consistent use of the unambiguous term “membrane scission.”     

Self-interaction is critical for Atg9 transport and function at the phagophore assembly site during autophagy

Autophagy is the degradation of a cell's own components within lysosomes (or the analogous yeast vacuole), and its malfunction contributes to a variety of human diseases. Atg9 is the sole integral membrane protein required in formation of the initial sequestering compartment, the phagophore, and is proposed to play a key role in membrane transport; the phagophore presumably expands by vesicular addition to form a complete autophagosome. It is not clear through what mechanism Atg9 functions at the phagophore assembly site (PAS). Here we report that Atg9 molecules self-associate independently of other known autophagy proteins in both nutrient-rich and starvation conditions. Mutational analyses reveal that self-interaction is critical for anterograde transport of Atg9 to the PAS. The ability of Atg9 to self-interact is required for both selective and nonselective autophagy at the step of phagophore expansion at the PAS. Our results support a model in which Atg9 multimerization facilitates membrane flow to the PAS for phagophore formation.     

Indirect estimation of the area density of Atg8 on the phagophore

Atg8 is a ubiquitin-like protein that controls the expansion of the phagophore during autophagosome formation. It is recruited to the phagophore during the expansion stage and released upon the completion of the autophagosome. One possible model explaining the function of Atg8 is that it acts as an adaptor of a coat complex. Here, we tested the coat-adaptor model by estimating the area density of Atg8 molecules on the phagophore. We developed a computational process to simulate the random sectioning of vesicles heterogeneous in size. This method can be applied to estimate the original sizes of intracellular vesicles from sizes of their random sections obtained through transmission electron microscopy. Using this method, we found that the estimated area density of Atg8 is comparable with that of proteins that form the COPII coat.     

Physiological functions of Atg6/Beclin 1： a unique autophagy-related protein

The most striking morphological feature of eukaryotic cells is the presence of various membrane-enclosed compartments. These compartments, including organelles and transient transport intermediates, are not static. Rather, dynamic exchange of proteins and membrane is needed to maintain cellular homeostasis. One of the most dramatic examples of membrane mobilization is seen during the process ofmacroautophagy. Macroautophagy is the primary cellular pathway for degradation of long-lived proteins and organelles. In response to environmental cues, such as starvation or other types of stress, the cell produces a unique membrane structure, the phagophore. The phagophore sequesters cytoplasm as it forms a double-membrane cytosolic vesicle, an autophagosome. Upon completion, the autophagosome fuses with a lysosome or a vacuole in yeast, which delivers hydrolases that break down the inner autophagosome membrane along with its cargo, and the resulting macromolecules are released back into the cytosol for reuse. Autophagy is therefore a recycling process, allowing cells to survive periods of nutrient limitation; however, it has a wider physiological role, participating in development and aging, and also in protection against pathogen invasion, cancer and certain neurodegenerative diseases. In many cases, the role ofautophagy is identified through studies of an autophagy-related protein, Atg6/Beclin 1. This protein is part of a lipid kinase complex, and recent studies suggest that it plays a central role in coordinating the cytoprotective function ofautophagy and in opposing the cellular death process of apoptosis. Here, we summarize our current knowledge ofAtg6/Beclin 1 in different model organisms and its unique function in the cell.     

The Golgi as a potential membrane source for autophagy

In macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy), a morphological hallmark is the formation of double-membrane vesicles called autophagosomes that sequester and deliver cytoplasmic components to the lysosome/vacuole for degradation. This process begins with an initial sequestering compartment, the phagophore, which expands into the mature autophagosome. A tremendous amount of work has been carried out to elucidate the mechanism of how the autophagosome is formed. However, an important missing piece in this puzzle is where the membrane comes from. Independent lines of evidence have shown that pre-existing organelles may continuously supply lipids to support autophagosome formation. In our analysis, we identified several components of the late stage secretory pathway that may redirect Golgi-derived membrane to autophagosome formation in response to starvation conditions.     

The Golgi as a potential membrane source for autophagy

In macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy), a morphological hallmark is the formation of double-membrane vesicles called autophagosomes that sequester and deliver cytoplasmic components to the lysosome/vacuole for degradation. This process begins with an initial sequestering compartment, the phagophore, which expands into the mature autophagosome. A tremendous amount of work has been carried out to elucidate the mechanism of how the autophagosome is formed. However, an important missing piece in this puzzle is where the membrane comes from. Independent lines of evidence have shown that preexisting organelles may continuously supply lipids to support autophagosome formation. In our analysis, we identified several components of the late stage secretory pathway that may redirect Golgi-derived membrane to autophagosome formation in response to starvation conditions.Key words: lysosome, membrane biogenesis, protein targeting, secretory pathway, stress, vacuole, yeast     

The phagophore in four dimensions—a study in wood

One of the key features of macroautophagy/autophagy is the dynamic nature of the membrane rearrangements that take place during expansion of the phagophore, the sequestering compartment that matures into an autophagosome. There are various ways to depict this process, but in most cases the method ultimately relies on a two-dimensional medium. Most people working in the field of autophagy realize that the typical ‘C’-shaped drawing of a phagophore is meant to represent a cup- or bowl-like structure that exists in the cell in 3 dimensions. However, explaining this concept to a lay person often leads to confusion and misinterpretation. Accordingly, we decided to generate a four-dimensional version of the expanding phagophore as a wood sculpture, that depicts this transient compartment in 3 dimensions over time.

Abbreviations: ER: endoplasmic reticulum     

A BAR-Domain Protein SH3P2, Which Binds to Phosphatidylinositol 3-Phosphate and ATG8, Regulates Autophagosome Formation in Arabidopsis

Autophagy is a well-defined catabolic mechanism whereby cytoplasmic materials are engulfed into a structure termed the autophagosome. In plants, little is known about the underlying mechanism of autophagosome formation. In this study, we report that SH3 DOMAIN-CONTAINING PROTEIN2 (SH3P2), a Bin-Amphiphysin-Rvs domain–containing protein, translocates to the phagophore assembly site/preautophagosome structure (PAS) upon autophagy induction and actively participates in the membrane deformation process. Using the SH3P2–green fluorescent protein fusion as a reporter, we found that the PAS develops from a cup-shaped isolation membranes or endoplasmic reticulum–derived omegasome-like structures. Using an inducible RNA interference (RNAi) approach, we show that RNAi knockdown of SH3P2 is developmentally lethal and significantly suppresses autophagosome formation. An in vitro membrane/lipid binding assay demonstrates that SH3P2 is a membrane-associated protein that binds to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate. SH3P2 may facilitate membrane expansion or maturation in coordination with the phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) complex during autophagy, as SH3P2 promotes PI3K foci formation, while PI3K inhibitor treatment inhibits SH3P2 from translocating to autophagosomes. Further interaction analysis shows that SH3P2 associates with the PI3K complex and interacts with ATG8s in Arabidopsis thaliana, whereby SH3P2 may mediate autophagy. Thus, our study has identified SH3P2 as a novel regulator of autophagy and provided a conserved model for autophagosome biogenesis in Arabidopsis.     

Getting ready for building: signaling and autophagosome biogenesis

Autophagy is the main cellular catabolic process responsible for degrading organelles and large protein aggregates. It is initiated by the formation of a unique membrane structure, the phagophore, which engulfs part of the cytoplasm and forms a double‐membrane vesicle termed the autophagosome. Fusion of the outer autophagosomal membrane with the lysosome and degradation of the inner membrane contents complete the process. The extent of autophagy must be tightly regulated to avoid destruction of proteins and organelles essential for cell survival. Autophagic activity is thus regulated by external and internal cues, which initiate the formation of well‐defined autophagy‐related protein complexes that mediate autophagosome formation and selective cargo recruitment into these organelles. Autophagosome formation and the signaling pathways that regulate it have recently attracted substantial attention. In this review, we analyze the different signaling pathways that regulate autophagy and discuss recent progress in our understanding of autophagosome biogenesis.