Accuracy of proofreading with zero energy cost

Accuracy of biological discrimination at the molecular level is known in some systems to involve kinetic proofreading mechanisms. Hopfield and Ninio were the first to propose simple specific kinetic mechanisms for such proofreading and to demonstrate that an energy cost accompanies their improvement in accuracy. Savageau and Freter subsequently derived the explicit cost-accuracy relationship for a broad class of proofreading mechanisms, including the conventional Hopfield-Ninio mechanism just referred to. In other systems, the presence of proofreading mechanisms is in question because the diagnostic features of conventional kinetic proofreading are absent. However, Hopfield has recently proposed an alternative “energy-relay” mechanism, which lacks the characteristic features of conventional proofreading and yet is capable of improving accuracy. In this paper, I use the general cost-accuracy relationship that we have previously derived to examine the energy cost and accuracy of proofreading mechanisms involving an energy relay. The principal findings are the following. First, such mechanisms improve accuracy with a zero cost of proofreading, when “proofreading cost,” defined as the cost due specifically to proofreading, is separated from the costs of putting material through the system. Second, the basic energy-relay mechanism discussed by Hopfield has only a modest improvement in accuracy, but a comparable improvement by a conventional proofreading mechanism would have a cost of about 0·0352 (moles ATP per mole of total product output). Third, accuracy can be increased somewhat if multiple stages of conventional kinetic proofreading precede the energy-relay mechanism. The cost for this improvement is zero while a comparable increase in accuracy achieved by conventional proofreading alone has a cost of about 0·0385. Finally, I propose an alternative arrangement of energy-relay mechanisms that is capable of increasing accuracy still further. The maximum accuracy achieved by this scheme at zero energy cost is comparable to that achieved by an infinite expenditure of energy in a single stage of conventional proofreading.     

Kinetic proofreading of ligand-FcepsilonRI interactions may persist beyond LAT phosphorylation

Cells may discriminate among ligands with different dwell times for receptor binding through a mechanism called kinetic proofreading in which the formation of an activated receptor complex requires a progression of events that is aborted if the ligand dissociates before completion. This mechanism explains how, at equivalent levels of receptor occupancy, a rapidly dissociating ligand can be less effective than a more slowly dissociating analog at generating distal cellular responses. Simple mathematical models predict that kinetic proofreading is limited to the initial complex; once the signal passes to second messengers, the dwell time no longer regulates the signal. This suggests that an assay for kinetic proofreading might be used to determine which activation events occur within the initial signaling complex. In signaling through the high affinity IgE receptor FcepsilonRI, the transmembrane adaptor called linker for activation of T cells (LAT) is thought to nucleate a distinct secondary complex. Experiments in which the concentrations of two ligands with different dwell times are adjusted to equalize the level of LAT phosphorylation in rat basophilic leukemia 2H3 cells show that Erk2 phosphorylation, intracellular Ca(2+), and degranulation exhibit kinetic proofreading downstream of LAT phosphorylation. These results suggest that ligand-bound FcepsilonRI and LAT form a complex that is required for effective signal transmission.     

A coproofreading Zn(2+)-dependent exonuclease within a bacterial replicase

The proofreading exonucleases of all DNA replicases contain acidic residues that chelate two Mg(2+) ions that participate in catalysis. DNA polymerase III holoenzymes contain their proofreading activity in a separate subunit, epsilon, which binds the polymerase subunit, alpha, through alpha's N-terminal php domain. Here we demonstrate that the alpha php domain contains a novel Zn(2+)-dependent 3' --> 5' exonuclease that preferentially removes mispaired nucleotides, providing the first example of a coediting nuclease.     

Proofreading systems of multiple stages for improved accuracy of biological discrimination

The phenomenal accuracy of biological discrimination is due in many cases to specific proofreading mechanisms. We have previously developed a macroscopic theory of such mechanisms and applied it to the case of single-stage proofreading. In this article we apply the theory to systems with multiple stages of proofreading. A specific relationship between improved accuracy due to proofreading and the associated energy cost is given. This is a macroscopic relationship that must be satisfied regardless of the details of the underlying mechanisms. Five factors in the design of such systems are shown to influence their overall accuracy: (1) initial discrimination, (2) number of proofreading stages, (3) proofreading discrimination of each stage, (4) distribution of proofreading effort among the stages, and (5) total energy expended for proofreading. We show that there is an optimal distribution of proofreading effort that, for a given degree of accuracy, minimizes the energy cost of proofreading. We also provide a simple physical interpretation of this minimum condition. These results are used to examine proofreading in two experimental systems for which there is appropriate data available in the literature: the valyl-tRNA synthetase catalyzed misacylation of tRNA^Val with threonine and the isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase catalyzed misacylation of tRNA^Ile with valine. The correlation between the magnitude of a discrimination factor and the size of the corresponding enzymatic cavity is discussed.     

Genetic factors affecting the impact of DNA polymerase delta proofreading activity on mutation avoidance in yeast

Base selectivity, proofreading, and postreplication mismatch repair are important for replication fidelity. Because proofreading plays an important role in error correction, we have investigated factors that influence its impact in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We have utilized a sensitive mutation detection system based on homonucleotide runs of 4 to 14 bases to examine the impact of DNA polymerase delta proofreading on mutation avoidance. The contribution of DNA polymerase delta proofreading on error avoidance was found to be similar to that of DNA polymerase epsilon proofreading in short homonucleotide runs (A4 and A5) but much greater than the contribution of DNA polymerase epsilon proofreading in longer runs. We have identified an intraprotein interaction affecting mutation prevention that results from mutations in the replication and the proofreading regions, resulting in an antimutator phenotype relative to a proofreading defect. Finally, a diploid strain with a defect in DNA polymerase delta proofreading exhibits a higher mutation rate than a haploid strain. We suggest that in the diploid population of proofreading defective cells there exists a transiently hypermutable fraction that would be inviable if cells were haploids.     

Proofreading, NTPases and translation: successful increase in specificity.

The discussion of proofreading started in the April issue of TIBS is completed by treating the two branched Michaelis-Menten enzymes that can proofread. The conditions required for proofreading can be seen to determine the expression of proofreading in its biological settings. There are surely instances of proofreading as yet unrecognized.     

A GTPase reaction accompanying the rejection of Leu-tRNA2 by UUU-programmed ribosomes. Proofreading of the codon-anticodon interaction by ribosomes

The characteristics of a GTPase reaction between poly(U)-programmed ribosomes, EFTu . GTP, and the near-cognate aminoacyl (aa)-tRNA, Leu-tRNA Leu 2, have been studied to assess the role of this reaction in proofreading of the codon-anticodon interaction. The reaction resembles the GTPase reaction with cognate aa-tRNAs and EFTu . GTP in its substrate requirements, in its involving EFTu . GTP . aa-tRNA ternary complexes, and in its requiring a free ribosomal A-site. The noncognate reaction differs from the cognate one in that aa-tRNA becomes stably bound to the ribosomes only 5% of the time; it therefore seems best characterized as an abortive enzymatic binding reaction. The rate of reaction is a significant fraction (4%) of that of the cognate aa-tRNA, indicating that recognition of ternary complexes by ribosomes involves a level of error greater than that of translation as a whole. The rejection of the noncognate aa-tRNA following GTP hydrolysis is therefore a vital step in the translation process and fulfills the criteria set for a proofreading reaction. Leu-tRNA Leu 2 which escapes rejection through proofreading, forms a stable complex with the ribosomal A-site, so it appears that the Leu-tRNA2 which was rejected never reached the A-site and that proofreading precedes full A-site binding.     

DNA polymerase proofreading: Multiple roles maintain genome stability

DNA polymerase proofreading is a spell-checking activity that enables DNA polymerases to remove newly made nucleotide incorporation errors from the primer terminus before further primer extension and also prevents translesion synthesis. DNA polymerase proofreading improves replication fidelity ∼ 100-fold, which is required by many organisms to prevent unacceptably high, life threatening mutation loads. DNA polymerase proofreading has been studied by geneticists and biochemists for > 35 years. A historical perspective and the basic features of DNA polymerase proofreading are described here, but the goal of this review is to present recent advances in the elucidation of the proofreading pathway and to describe roles of DNA polymerase proofreading beyond mismatch correction that are also important for maintaining genome stability.     

Contribution of 3' leads to 5' exonuclease activity of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme from Escherichia coli to specificity

The effects of deoxynucleoside monophosphates on the 3' leads to 5' exonuclease activity of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme have been correlated with their effects on the fidelity of DNA replication. In particular, dGMP inhibits the proofreading activity of the enzyme and decreases the fidelity in those cases where a "following nucleotide effect" is also noted. This is strong evidence for proofreading. However, the absence of the effects of proofreading inhibitors or following nucleotides need not be evidence against the occurrence of proofreading: a theoretical analysis shows that these effects may not be observed even though there is active proofreading. This is suggested to be the case with the phage T4 enzyme system. The proofreading activity of Pol III appears to be directed primarily towards removing purine x pyrimidine-mediated rather than purine x purine-mediated misincorporations. recA protein inhibits the proofreading activity of Pol III on synthetic templates containing mismatched 3' termini. This is paralleled by a decrease in the fidelity of DNA replication in vitro. The inhibition is increased in the presence of dGMP or dAMP but there is no further increase in the infidelity of replication. The presence of both dNMPs and recA protein does not enable Pol III to copy past pyrimidine photodimers.     

Proofreading, NTPases and translation: constraints on accurate biochemistry.

Two accurate individual reactions can work together as a more accurate overall mechanism. This is straightforward for a transient reaction, but the same accuracy in the steady state (termed proofreading) requires many preconditions. The preconditions for proofreading can be summarized as four statements, which allow experimental identification and subsequent confirmation of proofreading mechanisms.     

The proofreading of hydroxy analogues of leucine and isoleucine by leucyl-tRNA synthetases from E. coli and yeast.

Three analogues each of leucine and isoleucine carrying hydroxy groups in gamma- or delta- or gamma- and delta-position have been synthesized, and tested in the aminoacylation by leucyl-tRNA synthetases from E. coli and yeast. Hydrolytic proofreading, as proposed in the chemical proofreading model, of these analogues and of homocysteine should result in a lactonisation of these compounds and therefore provide information regarding the proofreading mechanism of the two leucyl-tRNA synthetases. Leucyl-tRNA synthetase from E. coli shows a high initial substrate discrimination. Only two analogues, gamma-hydroxyleucine and homocysteine are activated and transferred to tRNALeu where a post-transfer proofreading occurs. Lactonisation of gamma-hydroxyleucine and homocysteine could be detected. Leucyl-tRNA synthetase from yeast has a relatively poor initial discrimination of these substrates, which is compensated by a very effective pre-transfer proofreading on the aminoacyl-adenylate level. No lactonisation nor mischarged tRNALeu is detectable.     

Dissipation-error tradeoff in proofreading.

Chemical proofreading systems, of the kind believed responsible for the extremely high fidelity of DNA replication, achieve minimum error probability (equal to the product of the error probabilities of the writing and proofreading stages) only in the limit of infinite energy dissipation. However, a considerable degree of proofreading can be obtained in less strongly driven systems, dissipation only 0.1-1 kT/step.     

On the fidelity of DNA synthesis. Pyrophosphate-induced misincorporation allows detection of two proofreading mechanisms

The effect of pyrophosphate on the fidelity of in vitro DNA synthesis has been examined. Pyrophosphate enhances misincorporation by Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I in copying phi X174 DNA. The increased misincorporation is directly proportional to the extent of inhibition of the rate of polymerization. In contrast, pyrophosphate is not detectably mutagenic with avian myeloblastosis virus DNA polymerase or DNA polymerases alpha and beta from animal cells, which lack associated proofreading activities. This suggests that increased misincorporation by pyrophosphate is not due to an increase in misinsertions by DNA polymerase, but rather due to inhibition of proofreading by pyrophosphate. However, the pyrophosphate-induced infidelity has a different specificity from, and is not competitive with, two experimental markers of 3'----5' exonuclease proofreading; i.e. the effects of the next nucleotide or the addition of deoxynucleoside monophosphates. These distinctive features suggest a second mode of proofreading susceptible to inhibition by pyrophosphate. This concept is discussed in relation to models for proofreading described in the literature.     

Proofreading dynamics of a processive DNA polymerase

Replicative DNA polymerases present an intrinsic proofreading activity during which the DNA primer chain is transferred between the polymerization and exonuclease sites of the protein. The dynamics of this primer transfer reaction during active polymerization remain poorly understood. Here we describe a single‐molecule mechanical method to investigate the conformational dynamics of the intramolecular DNA primer transfer during the processive replicative activity of the Φ29 DNA polymerase and two of its mutants. We find that mechanical tension applied to a single polymerase–DNA complex promotes the intramolecular transfer of the primer in a similar way to the incorporation of a mismatched nucleotide. The primer transfer is achieved through two novel intermediates, one a tension‐sensitive and functional polymerization conformation and a second non‐active state that may work as a fidelity check point for the proofreading reaction.     

Effects of coordination of diammineplatinum(II) with DNA on the activities of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I

The effects of the reaction of cis- and trans-diamminedichloroplatinum(II) with DNA have been measured with regard to DNA synthesis, 3'-5' exonuclease (proofreading), and 5'-3' exonuclease (repair) activities of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I. Both isomers inhibit DNA synthetic activity of the polymerase through an increase in Km values and a decrease in Vmax values for platinated DNA but not for the nucleoside 5'-triphosphates as the varied substrates. The inhibition is a consequence of lowered binding affinity between platinated DNA and DNA polymerase, and of a platination-induced separation of template and primer strands. Strand separation enhances initial rates of 3'-5' excision of [3H]dCMP from platinated DNA (proofreading), while total excision levels of nucleotides are decreased. In contrast to proofreading activity, the 5'-3' exonuclease activity (repair) discriminates between DNA which had reacted with cis- and with trans-diamminedichloroplatinum(II). While both initial rates and total excision are inhibited for the cis isomer, they are almost not affected for the trans isomer. This differential effect could explain why bacterial growth inhibition requires much higher concentrations of trans- than cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II).     

DNA合成的忠实性机制

DNA的忠实性合成对于基因组稳定和物种延续至关重要,否则可能会产生严重的后果。DNA合成具有极高的忠实性,这主要基于3个步骤:(1)基于氢键、碱基对构象或其他因素的核苷酸选择;(2)基于3′→5′外切酶活性的校对,方式有顺式校对和反式校对,可以去除错误掺入的核苷酸;(3)基于错配修复、切除修复、同源重组修复和跨损伤DNA合成的修复过程,可以纠正逃过校对的错误核苷酸。由于DNA聚合酶不仅可以作为抗病毒或抗癌药物的靶标,而且其忠实性还与抗药性或药物副作用有关,所以深入研究DNA合成的忠实性具有非常重要的意义。文章主要论述了DNA合成的忠实性机制,并对DNA聚合酶的应用前景做了展望。     

Single-base discrimination mediated by proofreading 3' phosphorothioate-modified primers

It has been well known for decades that deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) polymerases with proofreading function have a higher fidelity in primer extension as compared to those without 3' exonuclease activities. However, polymerases with proofreading function have not been used in single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) assays. Here, we describe a new method for single-base discrimination by proofreading the 3' phosphorothioate-modified primers using a polymerase with proofreading function. Our data show that the combination of a polymerase with 3' exonuclease activity and the 3' phosphorothioate-modified primers work efficiently as a single-base mismatch-operated on/off switch. DNA polymerization only occurred from matched primers, whereas mismatched primers were not extended at the broad range of annealing temperature tested in our study. This novel single-base discrimination method has potential in SNP assays.     

Evidence for Extrinsic Exonucleolytic Proofreading

Exonucleolytic proofreading of DNA synthesis errors is one of the major determinants ofgenome stability. However, many DNA transactions that contribute to genome stability requiresynthesis by polymerases that naturally lack intrinsic 3´ exonuclease activity and some of whichare highly inaccurate. Here we discuss evidence that errors made by these polymerases may beedited by a separate 3´ exonuclease, and we consider how such extrinsic proofreading may differfrom proofreading by exonucleases that are intrinsic to replicative DNA polymerases.     

Single-base discrimination mediated by proofreading inert allele specific Primers

The role of 3' exonuclease excision in DNA polymerization was evaluated for primer extension using inert allele specific primers with exonuclease-digestible ddNMP at their 3' termini. Efficient primer extension was observed in amplicons where the inert allele specific primers and their corresponding templates were mismatched. However, no primer-extended products were yielded by matched amplicons with inert primers. As a control, polymerase without proofreading activity failed to yield primer-extended products from inert primers regardless of whether the primers and templates were matched or mismatched. These data indicated that activation was undertaken for the inert allele specific primers through mismatch proofreading. Complementary to our previously developed SNP-operated on/off switch, in which DNA polymerization only occurs in matched amplicon, this new mutation detection assay mediated by exo(+) DNA polymerases has immediate applications in SNP analysis independently or in combination of the two assays.     

Single-base discrimination mediated by proofreading 3′ phosphorothioate-modified primers

It has been well known for decades that deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) polymerases with proofreading function have a higher fidelity in primer extension as compared to those without 3′ exonuclease activities. However, polymerases with proofreading function have not been used in single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) assays. Here, we describe a new method for single-base discrimination by proofreading the 3′ phosphorothioate-modified primers using a polymerase with proofreading function. Our data show that the combination of a polymerase with 3′ exonuclease activity and the 3′ phosphorothioate-modified primers work efficiently as a single-base mismatch-operated on/off switch. DNA polymerization only occurred from matched primers, whereas mismatched primers were not extended at the broad range of annealing temperature tested in our study. This novel single-base discrimination method has potential in SNP assays.