Beta-adrenergic receptors: evidence for negative cooperativity.

The specific binding of [³H] (?)alprenolol to sites in frog erythrocyte membranes provides a tool for directly assessing ligand binding to adenylatecyclase coupled β-adrenergic receptors. Hill Plots of such binding data yield slopes (n_H=“Hill Coefficients”) less than 1.0, suggesting that negatively cooperative interactions among the β-adrenergic receptors may occur. The existence of such negative cooperativity was confirmed by a direct kinetic method. The dissociation of receptor bound [³H] (?)alprenolol was studied under two conditions: 1) with dilution of the ligand-receptor complex sufficient to prevent rebinding of the dissociated tracer and 2) with this same dilution in the presence of excess unlabeled (?)alprenolol. If the sites are independent, the dissociation rates must be the same in both cases. However, the presence of (?)alprenolol increases the rate of [³H] (?)alprenolol dissociation, indicating that negatively cooperative interactions among the β-adrenergic receptor binding sites do occur.     

An assay for beta-adrenergic receptors in isolated human fat cells

The beta-adrenergic receptors have been characterized in isolated human adipocytes using a potent beta-adrenergic antagonist (-)-[3H]dihydroalprenolol. Binding of (-)-[3H]dihydroalprenolol to isolated fat cells was stereospecific and saturable, the maximum number of binding sites calculated being 7.8 +/- 2.2 pmol of bound ligand/10(7) cells, corresponding to 450,000 binding sites/cell. The dissociation constant was estimated to be 2.7 +/- 1.1 nM. The results with competition-inhibition experiments using beta-adrenergic agonists and antagonists indicated that the binding sites in isolated adipocytes were predominantly of the beta1-subtype; about 80% of the receptors were of this type. With the present method, specific beta-adrenergic receptor number and affinity in isolated human adipocytes could be determined in about 1 g of human adipose tissue.     

Human fat cell beta-adrenergic receptors: beta-agonist-dependent lipolytic responses and characterization of beta-adrenergic binding sites on human fat cell membranes with highly selective beta 1-antagonists

Beta-adrenergic receptors were characterized in human fat cell membranes using 125I-labeled cyanopindolol (125I-labeled CYP) and highly selective beta 1-antagonists. The iodinated radioligand bound saturably and specifically to a single class of high affinity binding sites. The number of binding sites determined with 125I-labeled CYP closely agreed with that determined with two other tritiated radioligands: [3H]dihydroalprenolol and [3H]CGP-12,177. Since 125I-labeled CYP does not discriminate between beta 1- and beta 2-adrenoceptors, the densities of the two receptor subtypes were determined from the competition curves of 125I-labeled CYP by highly selective beta 1-antagonists (bisoprolol, ICI-89,406, CGP-20,712A, and LK-204,545). Moreover, in order to enable correlation with binding data, the regulation of adenylate cyclase activity and of lipolysis was tested with various beta-agonist and antagonist compounds. The results obtained on fat cell membranes from abdominal subcutaneous adipose tissue demonstrated the following. 1) 125I-labeled CYP represents a valuable tool for the quantification and the delineation of beta-receptor subtypes. 2) The presence of sodium ions in binding buffers causes a modification of the affinity of beta-sites for some beta-antagonists. 3) The human fat cell beta adrenergic receptor population defined by nonselective radioligands is composed of two subtypes that can be interpreted in terms of classic beta 1- and beta 2-adrenergic receptor subtypes as assessed by competition studies with highly selective antagonists; beta 2-sites are predominant (60-70% of 125I-labeled CYP sites) in the adipocytes of slightly overweight women. 4) Results support the idea that beta 1- as well as beta 2-adrenergic receptors are coupled with adenylate cyclase and involved in the induction of lipolysis. 5) The results focus on the interest in some beta 2-agonist drugs (zinterol, clenbuterol) as partial inductors of lipolysis, with the lipolytic efficacies of these compounds being well correlated with their efficacies at 125I-labeled CYP sites.     

The structural basis of negative cooperativity: receptors and enzymes

Crystal structures of the negatively cooperative aspartate receptor caught at intermediate stages in the binding process help to elucidate structural factors involved in ligand binding. The frequency of occurrence of negatively cooperative proteins suggests that sequential changes in binding patterns will be extensive in positively cooperative as well as in negatively cooperative and no cooperativity proteins.     

Site-site interactions among insulin receptors. Characterization of the negative cooperativity.

By studying the dissociation of 125I-instulin from its receptors in the absence and phe negatively cooperative type for the insulin receptors. In the present study we extend oy purified mouse and rat liver membranes as well as in human circulating monocytes and human cultured lymphocytes demonstrated negative cooperativity that was extraordinarily simn membranes more slowly than it does from its receptors on whole cells. The dissociaty a small percentage of the receptor sites (1 to 5%), are sufficient to accelerate dissociation of hormone from receptor. At these insulin concentrations insulin is entirely monomeric, and in fact at higher concentrations of insulin (greater than 10(-7) M) where insulin dimers predominate, the cooperativity effect is progressively lost. The dissociation rate of 125I-insulin alone (that is at very low fractional saturation of receptors) was markedly accelerated by dripping the pH from 8.0 to 5.0, whereas the dissociation of 125I-insulin at high receptor occupancy was only slightly accelerated by the fall in pH. The dissociation rate was directly related to temperature, but the dissociation rate of 125I-insulin at low receptor occupancy was much more affected by reduction in temperature and showed a sharp transition at 21 degrees. Urea at concentrations as low as 1 M produced a marked acceleration of 125I-insulin dissociation. Divalent cations (calcium and magnesium) appear to stabilize the insulin-receptor interaction, since higher degrees of receptor occupancy were required to achieve a given rate of dissociation of 125I-insulin. These data make it likely that the insulin receptors exist as oligomeric structures or clusters in the plasma membrane. Insulin receptor sites appear to switch from a "slow dissociating" state to a "fast dissociating" state when their occupancy increases; the proportion of sites in each state is a function of occupancy of the receptor sites by the insulin monomer as well as of the physiochemical environment. Other models which could explain apparent negative cooperativity besides site-site interactions, i.e. polymerization of the hormone, steric or electrostatic hindrance due to ligand-ligand interactions, or unstirred (Noyes-Whitney) layers are considered unlikely in the case of insulin receptors on both experimental and theoretical grounds.     

Formyl peptide chemotaxis receptors on the rat neutrophil: experimental evidence for negative cooperativity

To examine the existence of negative cooperativity among formyl peptide chemotaxis receptors, steady-state binding of f Met-Leu-[3H]Phe to viable rat neutrophils and their purified plasma membranes was measured and the data were subjected to statistical analysis and to computer curve fitting using the NONLIN computer program. Curvilinear, concave upward Scatchard plots were obtained. NONLIN and statistical analysis of the binding data indicated that a two-saturable-sites model was preferable to a one-saturable-site model and statistically valid by the F-test (P less than .010). In addition, Hill coefficients of 0.80 +/- 0.02 were obtained. Kinetic dissociation experiments using purified plasma membranes showed evidence of site-site interactions of the destabilizing type (negative cooperativity). Thus, unlabeled f Met-Leu-Phe accelerated the dissociation of f Met-Leu-[3H]Phe under conditions where no rebinding of radioligand occurred. The rate of dissociation of f Met-Leu-[3H]Phe from the plasma membranes was dependent on the fold excess of unlabeled f Met-Leu-Phe used in the dilution medium; at the highest concentration tested (10,000-fold excess), the dissociation rate was more than double the dissociation rate seen with dilution alone. In addition, occupancy-dependent affinity was ascertained directly by studying the effect of increasing fractional receptor saturation with labeled ligand on the dissociation rate of the receptor-bound labeled ligand. These data showed that the f Met-Leu-[3H]Phe dissociation rate was dependent on the degree of binding site occupancy over the entire biologically relevant range of formyl peptide concentrations. Furthermore, monitoring of the time course of dissociation of the receptor/f Met-Leu-[3H]Phe receptor/f Met-Leu-[3H]Phe complex as a function of receptor occupancy revealed that receptor affinity for f Met-Leu-Phe remained occupancy-dependent during the entire time of dissociation examined (up to 10 min). Finally, the average affinity profile of the equilibrium binding data demonstrated a 60% decrease in receptor affinity in changing from the high affinity to the low affinity conformation.     

Thyrotropin receptors in normal human thyroid. Nonclassical binding kinetics not explained by the negative cooperativity model

Saturation analysis of equilibrium binding of iodinated thyrotropin (125I-TSH) to normal human thyroid preparations yielded linear Scatchard plots under non-physiological conditions of pH 6.0 or 20 mM Tris/acetate buffer, pH 7.4. The apparent equilibrium dissociation constant of this binding was approximately 10(-8) M. By contrast, nonlinear plots were obtained under standard conditions of pH 7.4 and 40 mM Tris/acetate buffer. Resolution of the components of these curves by computer analysis revealed the presence of at least two classes of binding sites, one of which is of a low capacity and high affinity (approximately 10(-10) M) consistent with receptor binding. The other component is of a high capacity and lower affinity. Binding to non-target tissues of muscle, parathyroid, mammary carcinoma, and placenta was only demonstrable at pH 6.0 or in 20 mM Tris/acetate buffer, pH 7.4, yielding linear Scatchard plots with similar binding affinity (approximately 10(-8)M) to normal thyroid but much reduced capacity. Preincubation of thyroid tissue at 50 degrees C resulted in an apparent selective loss of the high affinity component of binding measured under standard conditions. Kinetic experiments on the dissociation of bound 125I-TSH were undertaken to determine whether the non-linearity of Scatchard plots was due to two or more classes of binding sites or negative cooperativity. It was found that the experimental determinant that is presently ascribed to a negative cooperativity phenomenon regulating receptor affinity (i.e. an enhanced dilution-induced dissociation rate in the presence of excess native hormone), although apparently hormone-specific, was demonstrated under nonphysiological binding conditions and in non-target tissue. Significantly, the phenomenon was found under conditions of pH 6.0 or 20 mM Tris where a linear Scatchard plot was obtained. The evidence thus suggests that 125I-TSH binds to heterogeneous binding sites (of which the high affinity is probably the receptor for TSH) and that the enhanced dilution-induced dissociation of bound hormone by native hormone for this system, is only a characteristic of the low affinity binding site (maybe gangliosides).     

Temperature-dependent negative cooperativity among angiotensin II receptors of isolated rat glomeruli

The binding characteristics of angiotensin II to isolated rat glomeruli were studied at various temperatures from 15 to 37 degrees C using 125I-labeled angiotensin II. The remarkable features of the binding at 37 degrees C, compared with those at lower temperatures, were (1) decreased maximal binding due to increased dissociation rate, (2) short duration of the steady state, which was, however, sufficient for performing steady-state binding assays, and (3) marked curvilinear Scatchard plots with upward concavity. The difference between the dissociation rates caused by dilution only and by dilution plus cold angiotensin II increased with increase in temperature. From these results, we conclude that the site-site interactions of a negatively cooperative type, which are negligible at lower temperatures, exist among rat glomerular angiotensin II receptors at the physiological temperature, and that the binding study may as well be performed at 37 degrees C for the purpose of investigating quantitative correlation between the hormone binding and its biological effect.     

Glycoprotein hormone receptors: link between receptor homodimerization and negative cooperativity

The monomeric model of rhodopsin-like G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) has progressively yielded the floor to the concept of GPCRs being oligo(di)mers, but the functional correlates of dimerization remain unclear. In this report, dimers of glycoprotein hormone receptors were demonstrated in living cells, with a combination of biophysical (bioluminescence resonance energy transfer and homogenous time resolved fluorescence/fluorescence resonance energy transfer), functional and biochemical approaches. Thyrotropin (TSHr) and lutropin (LH/CGr) receptors form homo- and heterodimers, via interactions involving primarily their heptahelical domains. The large hormone-binding ectodomains were dispensable for dimerization but modulated protomer interaction. Dimerization was not affected by agonist binding. Observed functional complementation indicates that TSHr dimers may function as a single functional unit. Finally, heterologous binding-competition studies, performed with heterodimers between TSHr and LH/CG-TSHr chimeras, demonstrated the unsuspected existence of strong negative cooperativity of hormone binding. Tracer desorption experiments indicated an allosteric behavior in TSHr and, to a lesser extent, in LH/CGr and FSHr homodimers. This study is the first report of homodimerization associated with negative cooperativity in rhodopsin-like GPCRs. As such, it may warrant revisitation of allosterism in the whole GPCR family.     

Analysis of negative cooperativity for glutamate dehydrogenase

The empirical equation, which describes negative cooperativity in the enzyme kinetics, has been proposed. The equation is obtained from the Michaelis-Menten equation where the Michaelis constant is replaced by the effective Michaelis constant, which is a linear function of the v/Vmax ratio (v is the rate of the enzymatic reaction and Vmax is the limiting value of v at saturating concentrations of substrate). The equation allows the limiting values of the Michaelis constant at v/Vmax --> 0 and V/Vmax --> 1 to be estimated, K0 and Klim, respectively. The Klim/K0 ratio is considered as a quantitative characteristic of negative cooperativity. The applicability of the equation has been demonstrated for the kinetic data obtained for glutamate dehydrogenases from various sources (negative kinetic cooperativity for coenzyme). The negative cooperativity for the functions of saturation of protein by ligand is also analyzed. The data on binding of spin-labeled NAD, NADH, and NADPH by beef liver glutamate dehydrogenase are used as examples.     

Cross-linking of cell surface receptors enhances cooperativity of molecular adhesion

Cooperativity of molecular adhesion has been proposed as a mechanism for enhanced binding strength of adhesion molecules on the cell surface. Direct evidence for its mechanism, however, has been lacking until now. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to measure the adhesive strength between concanavalin A (Con A) coupled to an AFM tip and Con A receptors on the surface of NIH3T3 fibroblast cells. Cross-linking of receptors with either glutaraldehyde or 3, 3'-dithio-bis(sulfosuccinimidylproprionate) (DTSSP) led to an increase in adhesion that could be attributed to enhanced cooperativity among adhesion complexes. An increase in loading rate due to greater stiffness of fixed cells also contributed to the twofold increase in binding strength. These results show that receptor cross-linking can greatly contribute to a total increase in cell adhesion by creating a shift toward cooperative binding of receptors.     

An investigation of the ligand binding properties and negative cooperativity of soluble insulin-like growth factor receptors

To investigate the interaction of the insulin-like growth factor (IGF) ligands with the insulin-like growth factor type 1 receptor (IGF-1R), we have generated two soluble variants of the IGF-1R. We have recombinantly expressed the ectodomain of IGF-1R or fused this domain to the constant domain from the Fc fragment of mouse immunoglobulin. The ligand binding properties of these soluble IGF-1Rs for IGF-I and IGF-II were investigated using conventional ligand competition assays and BIAcore biosensor technology. In ligand competition assays, the soluble IGF-1Rs both bound IGF-I with similar affinities and a 5-fold lower affinity than that seen for the wild type receptor. In addition, both soluble receptors bound IGF-II with similar affinities to the wild type receptor. BIAcore analyses showed that both soluble IGF-1Rs exhibited similar ligand-specific association and dissociation rates for IGF-I and for IGF-II. The soluble IGF-1R proteins both exhibited negative cooperativity for IGF-I, IGF-II, and the 24-60 antibody, which binds to the IGF-1R cysteine-rich domain. We conclude that the addition of the self-associating Fc domain to the IGF-1R ectodomain does not affect ligand binding affinity, which is in contrast to the soluble ectodomain of the IR. This study highlights some significant differences in ligand binding modes between the IGF-1R and the insulin receptor, which may ultimately contribute to the different biological activities conferred by the two receptors.     

Rapid and reversible disappearance of beta-adrenergic cell surface receptors

The water soluble beta-adrenergic ligand [3H]CGP-12177 was used to measure the cell surface receptors in intact cells. In two cell lines, C6 glioma and WEHI 7 lymphoma cells, -50% of the cell surface receptors disappear within minutes of incubation of the cells with isoproterenol. The receptors can still be detected in homogenates and reappear on the cell surface when cells are washed and reincubated at 37 degrees C. The data agree with a disappearance of the receptors from the cell surface by an agonist-mediated endocytosis.     

Nested MWC model describes hydrolysis of GroEL without assuming negative cooperativity in binding

Folding assistance and ATPase activity of GroEL are based on the existence of different conformations. In order to characterise these conformations, published data on steady state ATPase activity in the absence of GroES were reanalysed simultaneously in terms of the Nested MWC model. This model is a hierarchical extension of the symmetry-model of Monod et al. [J. Mol. Biol. 12 (1965) 88]. An unique set of GroEL specific parameters was obtained. This set was supported by comparison of predictions arising from this set of values with experimental data for hydrolysis of ATP in the presence of ADP and ATPgammaS, binding of ATPgammaS and ADP to GroEL in the absence of ATP, and binding of ATP as monitored by fluorescence labelling. Thus, for the first time, multiple data sets for the interaction of nucleotides with GroEL are described quantitatively by an allosteric model. A noteworthy feature of our model is that no negative cooperativity in ATP binding occurs in accordance to experimental observations. Furthermore, the model also includes the existence of a conformation with very high ATPase activity. Such a conformation might be of importance at a certain stage in the folding cycle.     

Evidence for negative cooperativity in human erythrocyte sugar transport

1. When d-glucose exchange influx is measure over a wide range of concentrations then two affinity constants (2.27 and 26.0 mM) are evident. This is consistent with a transport model (the allosteric pore model) in which there is negative cooperativity between subunits of the transport protein. 2. The equations for the allosteric pore model interacting with two substrates (or a substrate and an inhibitor) have been derived and have been used to analyse data from exchange inhibition and for mixed infinite-trans uptake experiments. 3. The exchange inhibition of tracer 3-O-methyl-d-glucose, d-xylose and d-fructose uptake by d-glucose also shows evidence for negative cooperativity and for two inhibition constants which are approximately equal to the d-glucose equilibrium exchange affinity constants. 4. The uptake of d-glucose into infinite-transd-glucose or 3-O-methyl-d-glucose gives K_m values of 2.6 and 2.33 mM, respectively. The uptake of 3-O-methyl-d-glucose into infinite-transd-glucose or 3-O-methyl-d-glucose gives K_m values of 6.0 and 4.6 mM, respectively. V values are slightly higher when the internal sugar is 3-O-methyl-d-glucose. 5. In cells that are treated with fluorodinitrobenzene the apparent K_i value for d-glucose inhibition of tracer d-fructose uptake is lowered. It is proposed that this is due to a partially selective effect of FDNB on the internal subunit interface stability constant (the internal pore gate).     

Structural basis of negative cooperativity in transthyretin

A comparison of the AC and BD binding sites of transthyretin (TTR) was made in terms of the interatomic distances between the Ca atoms of equivalent amino acids, measured across the tetramer channel in each binding site. The comparison of the channel diameter for apo TTR from different sources revealed that in the unliganded transthyretin tetramers the distances between the A, D and H beta-strands are consistently larger, while the distances between the G beta-strands are smaller in one site than in the other. These differences might be described to have a 'wave' character. An analogous analysis performed for transthyretin complexes reveals that the shape of the plot is similar, although the amplitudes of the changes are smaller. The analysis leads us to a model of the changes in the binding sites caused by ligand binding. The sequence of events includes ligand binding in the first site, followed by a slight collapse of this site and concomitant opening of the second site, binding of the second molecule and collapse of the second site. The following opening of the first, already occupied site upon ligand binding in the second site is smaller because of the bridging interactions already formed by the first ligand. This explains the negative cooperativity (NC) effect observed for many ligands in transthyretin.